r/btc • • Feb 13 '19

It’s happening - BTC dev Luke jr writing code to Bitcoin BTC codebase to fork to lower the block size to 300kb!

https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/compare/v0.17.1...luke-jr:example_300k-0.17
204 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

76

u/MobTwo Feb 13 '19

I doubt it will be merged. If it does, then it is obvious most of the transactions will start going towards Lightning Network. Congratulations to them, they did what they set out to do. Push all onchain transactions to Lightning Network.

83

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Feb 13 '19

If merged it's obvious most transactions will leave the BTC chain. And not for LN.

6

u/ssvb1 Feb 13 '19

The move to the LN is already happening, the current BTC block size limits and on-chain fees are about right to encourage this gradual transition. There is just no need to fix something that is not broken.

If the block size limits reduction idea of u/luke-jr really materializes into a formal BIP or a pull request, then we can start talking about it. So far Luke has just pulled some numbers out of his ass without even bothering to provide proper explanations.

14

u/hapticpilot Feb 13 '19 edited Feb 13 '19

the current BTC block size limits and on-chain fees are about right to encourage this gradual transition

BTC isn't a closed system. If the cost of using the system goes up and user experience goes down, users will indeed look around for alternatives. However, the LN isn't the only other option. We also have the options (AKA "substitute products") BCH, Ethereum, Litecoin, Dash, Monero and countless others to choose from. BCH will likely be particularly attractive to users because many (most?) Bitpay merchants accept it and it has wide general acceptance in places that accept BTC.

All of the shenanigans that have gone on in attempt to damage BCH are just short term injuries that BCH will recover from. This is because the fundamentals of it remain strong:

  • original, proven Bitcoin design. Easy to use, fast & cheap.

  • large amount of software development in both the core (full node) software and external software that interacts with it.

  • massive community. It could well be even bigger than the BTC community. I know for a fact that the BTC community is largely illusionary. There's a massive, well organised propaganda campaign that targets, shapes and forms the BTC community.

  • wide acceptance (relative to other cryptos)

  • lots of passionate promoters

For the record: I am an ex-BTC user. I stopped using it entirely due to the cult-like take-over and destruction of the system. I now use alternative, superior systems.

Edit: fixed typos and slightly improved wording

5

u/au80022 Feb 13 '19

The BTC first mover advantage is now over. If Bitcoin core can't do the right thing, all these other coins are ready to go with better infrastructure.

6

u/hapticpilot Feb 13 '19

Yep. It's already happened to a large degree. BTC has lost a huge amount of market share and it's directly related to the lack of capacity in the system. I left BTC for precisely that reason and all the people I know in-person who are into crypto left BTC for the exact same reason as me.

I think the entities/individuals that use BTC fall into one of these groups:

  1. They are unaware of / ignorant of what has happened to BTC's market share and why. They probably don't even realize that if the market picks up again there's a good chance BTC will be gettng massive on-chain fees again.

  2. They know exactly what has happened and why and they're pleased about it. They want to destroy or at least slow down the adoption of Bitcoin and crypto in general.

  3. They can see that BTC has lost market share but they have alternative, incorrect reasons to explain it. One I hear bounced around a lot is that "it was always going to happen.".

  4. They're not real people. They're mass created artificial personas that are guided/operated by a human propagandist or team of propagandists who are paid to create the illusion of popular support for a given thing (AKA astroturfing).

I think it's a mix of all 4 with the majority of reddit & twitter personalities falling into category 3 and 4. Mostly 4 probably.

-4

u/kattbilder Feb 13 '19

Yeah everyone not agreeing with you is fake. Whatever makes you sleep at night my little dude.

1

u/hapticpilot Feb 13 '19

Yeah everyone not agreeing with you is fake.

I'm not sure how you got that idea.

Whatever makes you sleep at night my little dude.

... and a little underhanded insult/belittling attempt right there.

I imagine that you have the appearance of a gremlin. Not one of the cute fluffy ones. One of the aggressive angry ones that ate after midnight, has reptile skin, and slime dripping from its face.

Also: the expression is "Whatever helps you sleep at night".

1

u/kattbilder Feb 14 '19

I'm Gizmo!

7

u/shadowofashadow Feb 13 '19

So far Luke has just pulled some numbers out of his ass without even bothering to provide proper explanations.

You mean like they've done all along with the 1mb limit? There is no analysis that suggests 1mb is the right size, it's totally arbitrary.

4

u/r2d2_21 Feb 13 '19

Thing is, they're using the "it's arbitrary" fact as an excuse to reduce the block size.

2

u/whistlepig33 Feb 13 '19

Well... it was intended to be an arbitrary ceiling to be raised much much higher when needed.

4

u/jessquit Feb 13 '19

So far Luke has just pulled some numbers out of his ass without even bothering to provide proper explanations.

You mean like the 75% discount on Segwit transactions?

-1

u/ssvb1 Feb 13 '19

I mean 300kb, as mentioned in the topic of this discussion.

1

u/phro Feb 14 '19

LN breaks the incentive model that makes Bitcoin work. There must always be enough settlement fees on base layer to outbid any SHA256 rivals. LNs success reduces BTC security.

1

u/iwearahoodie Feb 13 '19

He’s explained very thoroughly his rationale for the numbers.

1

u/FlipDetector Feb 13 '19

it is obvious most of the transactions will start going towards Lightning Network

<3 BCK

<3 Flippening!

0

u/Adrian-X Feb 13 '19

I disagree. I think transactions will stay on the BTC chain. I'm not biased if BCH or BSV benefit as a result its clearly because they are better-managed networks with better incentives.

If for no other reason I think the drop in BTC fees should be a wake-up call. There is not enough fee pressure. If you can't get more users, you need to reduce transaction capacity.

48

u/obesepercent Feb 13 '19

No. Nobody is going to use the Lightning Network. They'll just switch to another cryptocurrency with faster and cheaper transactions. It's not like there's just BTC and paper checks and nothing else

8

u/Ithinkstrangely Feb 13 '19

One year ago:

https://www.coindesk.com/how-to-send-a-lightning-transaction-even-if-you-may-not-want-to

Man, time flies and we're in the fastest changing time ever. A time of constant change. How's the narrative on "the Lightning Network" going? Or, is it "Liquid"? Or, am I out of the loop again?

15

u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 13 '19

Yeah, you blink and 18 months have passed again...

300k blocks on BTC would be absolute suicide for the BTC chain. The BTC mempool was at 60MB just the other day, fees jumped and a bunch of transactions got delayed.

Unfortunately the resulting loss of confidence in BTC will infect all other coins. I suppose that will delay adoption another 18 months times 3.

4

u/tl121 Feb 13 '19

A smaller block size means cheaper spam attacks that DDOS the BTC blockchain. Perhaps a minor billionaire will take a gamble on demonstrating this point.

1

u/Adrian-X Feb 13 '19

Developers in BTC are actively resisting increasing the transaction limit to avoid these DDoS attacks.

Just moving the transaction limit to 2MB would make it almost impractical to execute.

1

u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 13 '19

I think a millionaire could easily do it. The cost is just the fees required to massively clog up the mempool, around $100k per day.

3

u/libertarian0x0 Feb 13 '19

Unfortunately the resulting loss of confidence in BTC will infect all other coins.

Will? That already happened in Dec 2017.

1

u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 13 '19

Agreed. But the next time it happens that will prove to the dummies that Lightning doesn't work and Segwit didn't help. And that's really the end of the road for BTC.

2

u/redog Feb 13 '19

It took like 30 years for them to get around to v2.0 of MIDI without any manufactured drama. Delays could be generational.

3

u/t9b Feb 13 '19

Smaller blocks mean higher transaction fees. I bet we reach a stalemate where the fees for moving BTC into a channel are so expensive that you can neither open a channel or send your coins to an exchange. I have no idea about price under those circumstances. I can speculate that (very limited) supply and demand will blow the price the through the roof, but you couldn’t pull your coins off the exchange even if you had some on there or the exact opposite where the liquidity issue causes nobody to want it at all, ever again. In which case BTC will effectively be unsellable.

2

u/a17c81a3 Feb 13 '19

Yeah I'm very technical and I wouldn't bother with LN. Does it even work? Watch tower server required wtf? Of course I already left BTC so I suppose the target demographic of hodlers confined exclusively to exchanges might use LN.. via the exchanges.

0

u/greenerthumbleXD Feb 13 '19

I use Lightning Network so your generalized statement was just proven incorrect.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

[deleted]

0

u/greenerthumbleXD Feb 13 '19

Sure.

Here is a graph showing the number of lightning nodes over time: https://bitcoinvisuals.com/ln-nodes

And here is visual displaying the overall capacity of those nodes over time: https://bitcoinvisuals.com/ln-capacity-per-node

The existence of alternative blockchains does not in itself prove those blockchains are or will be used for anything useful. Nor have those projects been stress-tested at scale.

1

u/greenerthumbleXD Feb 13 '19

Also, I'm not advocating for smaller blocks in this thread. Only like to point out that there is a non-trvial amount of people using Lightning right now.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19 edited Apr 05 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/hawks5999 Feb 13 '19

Probably even scores.

-2

u/Etovia Feb 13 '19

are there dozens of you?

yes, over 2000 nodes. I doubt all of them are greenerthumblerXD'ers

12

u/combatopera Feb 13 '19 edited Apr 05 '25

gpwwcc dandvyvhukcb psylslh ayeg

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

2000 nodes =/= actual use, and neither does them opening channels with each other so they can say "see! Look how much use there is!".

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/Etovia Feb 13 '19

How is amount of nodes relevant?

Well combatopera claimed "no one uses it".

But right, maybe no one uses it but just deployed 2000 nodes, yeap. /s

Btw bitrefill and others do publish stats on actual users, there are more then 1 user(s) - Q.E.D.

-1

u/greenerthumbleXD Feb 13 '19

Right now for the most part you have to run a node to use Lightning. Lightning nodes have more functionality than just a blockchain node for example.

5

u/rabbitlion Feb 13 '19

It won't be merged into the master branch or released into Bitcoin Core. Luke is planning to deploy it using a UASF (User Activated Soft Fork) similar to how they tried with Segwit.

Unfortunately, to some people the Segwit UASF appeared to be a success due to how the Segwit2x tried to gather as many people as possible and made their release in time to avoid UASF nodes getting forked off. This has deluded Luke and similar fanatics into thinking that UASF is a realistic way of deploying functionality that miners don't want.

4

u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 13 '19

How many BTC users do not know about LN? How many are willing to use it? I expect people to dump BTC more than move to LN.

2

u/KylanKylanasd Feb 13 '19

yup, lightning network is the future !

6

u/dexX7 Omni Core Maintainer and Dev Feb 13 '19

True. Don't believe the propaganda here. This will never be merged into Bitcoin Core, especially not to "push towards LN".

2

u/libertarian0x0 Feb 13 '19

If not merged, could it be enforced via UASF?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Where is shaolinfry when you need him?

2

u/FUBAR-BDHR Feb 13 '19

Is it really a push to LN? Could it be to get more Liquid adoption? Waiting to see a new tech based on Liquid announced any day now.

2

u/DylanKid Feb 13 '19

I feel like they are trolling

7

u/Jonathan_the_Nerd Feb 13 '19

Luke Jr. is serious about reducing the block size. He's been advocating it for years.

2

u/Salmondish Feb 13 '19

Luke coded many options that have never been accepted like all these block size increases:

https://github.com/luke-jr/bips/blob/bip-mmhf/bip-mmhf.mediawiki

https://github.com/luke-jr/bitcoin/compare/bc94b87%E2%80%A6luke-jr:hardfork2016

https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2017-January/013496.html

https://github.com/BitcoinHardfork/bitcoin

He also believes in not accepting a merge without consensus and in this case he would need to get 100% miner consensus so its not going to happen

1

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer Feb 19 '19

Miners have no special say in protocol changes. It would need support from the community in general, but not miners specifically.

1

u/unstoppable-cash Feb 13 '19

Push all onchain transactions to Lightning Network.

By central planning... FORCE all onchain tx's to LN...

1

u/cr0ft Feb 14 '19

Yes, pushed to all the... 5000 people/organizations who have nodes... of the pre-prel-alpha quality LN... where you have to be online 24/7 or you can lose money...

Total effing lunacy. These people aren't programmers, they're arsonists.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Why are we all surprised? He's done plenty of dumb shit in the past.

38

u/FreeFactoid Feb 13 '19

He's actually a double agent for BCH /$

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

I think he's a double agent for BTC, but who's keeping track?

6

u/f7ddfd505a Feb 13 '19

Cobra switched sides so many times, it's hard to know how he thinks about anything bitcoin related.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Either side would be a fool to support someone who is attempting to decisive them both. It doesn't matter where their loyalties lie if you can't trust them.

0

u/Dunedune Feb 13 '19

I like the idea of someone not belong to one "side". Bitcoin is too tribal :)

0

u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 13 '19

Switching sides, or keeping an open mind?

2

u/utrd Feb 13 '19

Maybe he IS Cobra.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Maybe the goal is to fit a block on a 360k 5.25" floppy, so you can send blocks by mail.

5

u/mossmoon Feb 13 '19

Why would BTC users reject this? If LN isn’t a solution at 300kb then how is it a solution at 1mb with more users but same the high fees and unreliability? Is this the moment BTC users realize they've bought tickets to the Fyre Festival?

28

u/tralxz Feb 13 '19

300kb blocks is an important upgrade to BTC. Anyone against this feature doesn't understand decentralisation or are trying to attack BTC. 300kb blocks must be implement as soon as possible.

3

u/BluntTruthGentleman Feb 13 '19

Then explain it

12

u/tralxz Feb 13 '19

It will take fee market to the next level.

4

u/SatoshisSidekick Feb 13 '19

because that is the quickest way to make bch the true bitcoin and finally kill btc.

2

u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 13 '19

You forgot the /s.

7

u/DylanKid Feb 13 '19

No need, we should be encouraging them to do this

9

u/DarkLord_GMS Feb 13 '19

Why just 5 months? It should be permanent. =/

12

u/Transactionstuckk Feb 13 '19

Let them. Everyone is realizing what bitcoin core is turning into, a big fat mess.

14

u/criptiano Feb 13 '19

The file you see is called example_300k and it shows an example on how to limit block size for a limited range of time. the bitcoin repo has been forked 22.000 times. I think this is just an additional example for other projects. why would they want to merge in main codebase a temporary change in block size from 1st of August to 31 Dec 2019?

3

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Feb 13 '19

I support luke in this. Let’s accelerate BTC’s death.

3

u/BitcoinCashForever1 Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 13 '19

I support Luke in his endeavors! Go for it...

6

u/Big_Bubbler Feb 13 '19

Taking the crazy up a notch, lol. If it keeps getting smaller it will eventually reach a point where it is truly safe from attacks and value changes.

2

u/Technologov Feb 13 '19

And from Spam !

2

u/Licho92 Feb 13 '19

ULTRAsmall blockers

2

u/Technologov Feb 13 '19 edited Feb 13 '19

How will it work in practice, if say, only 40% of miners adopt their new version? What if 60% ?

Will his code cause a hard fork, if large percentage (of users and miners) stay with an old version?

Bitcoin Miners have direct benefit enabling full 1MB blocks and collecting larger fees. (Rather than 300KB blocks)

3

u/SlingDNM Feb 13 '19

Do they? Cuz last time I checked smaller Blogs = full Blocks = bigger fees = increased mining profit

1

u/LarsPensjo Feb 13 '19

A softfork is needed for this. That means that a majority of the miners must accept it. Which means it is probably a good idea to use some signaling before the fork.

If a miner produces a block that is too big after this softfork, there will be a chain split. Most probably (if signaling was used), the split will be a minority and ignored.

As it is temporary, no hardfork is needed to restore the old limit.

1

u/stale2000 Feb 13 '19

If 60% of miners adopt it, then the 40% of miners will be orphaned, and all nodes will follow the small blocks chain.

thats how soft forks work.

2

u/Adrian-X Feb 13 '19

The way to get consensus on this is to ban all the people who would disagree with the change. This "upgrade" could go smoothly. If the use what these learned.

3

u/kristoffernolgren Feb 13 '19

This is not something happening.

1

u/xGsGt Feb 13 '19

You guys either are really dumb or are just trying really hard to lie to ppl, Luke was just making a point on how easy it is to write a code for a temporary soft fork, that's the reason you see his choice from August to December, he even said it in his tweet, "DO NOT RUN THIS ON PROD"

I swear some of you bcash minions are really tards with your lying agenda

1

u/keo604 Feb 13 '19

It was similarly easy to raise the max block size. What’s the point of your post?

2

u/cumulus_nimbus Feb 13 '19

[ ] You understand the difference between a soft and a hardfork

3

u/keo604 Feb 13 '19

Yes. Both occurs in a chain split if it doesn’t have consensus. Do you understand that yourself?

2

u/xGsGt Feb 14 '19

No it does not split chains on soft forks :face-palm:

1

u/keo604 Mar 03 '19

No? Then mine a block that spends an ANYONECANSPEND segwit utxo and see what happens. Facepalm is the proper reaction to what you just said.

1

u/xGsGt Mar 04 '19

Right now btc is running both segwit and not segwit transactions, what are you talking about?

1

u/keo604 Mar 04 '19

Do you understand how the soft fork was techincally deployed?

Non-upgraded nodes see these as anyone-can-spend scripts. That means, old nodes are free to grab that money. Upgraded miners will not include these in a block, because they’ll fail to validate this transaction under SegWit’s new rules. However, if a non-upgraded miner would mine a block that spends these anyone-can-spend outputs it would cause the chain to split, as upgraded miners will orphan the block - even though it is backwards compatible (as it was produced by a non upgraded miner). So yes, a soft fork can result in a split, and yes, you’ve been lied to. Technical discussions that were against this hack were banned on all major forums, so you probably never heard of this (and many other things).

0

u/chainxor Feb 13 '19

Mah...we're just having fun ;-)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

There's no way he's not just having fun toying with people. He doesn't have to balls to actually follow through with it. He knows that it would prove his motives.

1

u/where-is-satoshi Feb 13 '19

It is a ruse. They intend to actually fork to a larger block.

1

u/Alexpander Feb 13 '19

Maybe btc devs secretly work for BCH

1

u/shadowofashadow Feb 13 '19

Good let's get this show on the road. This will only split the BTC camp.

1

u/loveforyouandme Feb 13 '19

Please succeed. I fully support this.

1

u/OrigamiMax Feb 13 '19

Ahahahahahahahaha

I think I’ll sell my last one soon

1

u/Dumbhandle Feb 13 '19

Bitcoin has been suicidal since Gavin left. So glad to see this accelerated progress. That capital must be liberated.

1

u/llamande Feb 13 '19

We have officially gone full retard.

1

u/stefann9 Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 14 '19

Whats wrong with them?

No more forks fucktards, go fuck yourself and leave block size as is. Stop destroying trust in btc.

1

u/HurlSly Feb 13 '19

I'm completely dumbfounded by this news. Are they completely nuts ?!

7

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Luke-jr did research where he found that to guarantee best decentralisation, 1mb blocks would not suffice. He found that 300k was the optimum block size.

2

u/steb2k Feb 13 '19

Proof of this 'research'?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

He tweeted claiming this sometime about a year ago. It's not my claim. I don't know if he made the reasearch available.

1

u/ZpisceS Feb 13 '19

they are only good for nothing.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/Everluck8 Feb 13 '19

Theymos will ban all the miners

1

u/Adrian-X Feb 13 '19

I hope he does.

1

u/Pretagonist Feb 13 '19

Everyone will ignore this version and the idiots who support it will fork themselves right off the chain.

-1

u/coinstorage_guru Redditor for less than 90 days Feb 13 '19

Depends if they are Bitcoin SV maximalists or not

-1

u/0xHUEHUE Feb 13 '19

well it would probably increase fees for them sooo, might be nice for the halving

4

u/lubokkanev Feb 13 '19

They can already do that just by not accepting txs with less than 100sat/byte, for example.

5

u/greengenerosity Feb 13 '19

The only way that would work would be if nearly all the miners came together and decided that none of them would mine under 100 sat/byte.

But any miner(s) that did not agree to that would get all the fees up to the point where the mempool reached 100 sat/byte. It would be more profitable for miners to connect to a mining pool that took fees under 100 sat/byte as it would offer a better returns than the pools that chose not to. Those pools would over time get majority of hash if miners chased profit.

It would be possible to increase the lowest standard fee without needing any actions from the miners by increasing the default minimum relay setting on the most common full nodes. That is the reason why 100 sat/kilobyte transactions are generally not seen in the mempool, not because there are not miners who would accept it, but because the standard minimum relay fee is 1000 sat/kilobyte.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '19

Hmm, it’s almost as if the Bitcoin system incentivizes mining as many transactions as possible at as low a fee as possible...

This proposal seems like swimming up a river rather than down it.

1

u/greengenerosity Feb 13 '19

Every miner to every other miner:

Fee to low for you? Not for me!

Operational costs for mining to high for you? Not for me!

Profit margin to low for you? Not for me!

I agree with you. I am not suggesting a high minimum relay fee to increase fees.
Best is that senders offer their fees and miners offers what they are willing to mine, but that assumes that there is no artificially low cap and that the capacity of the network over time grows as fast or faster than user activity. As soon as there is some cap, and it is reached, there will be bidding rounds between senders, which is undesirable.

I think that the option between having 50kb blocks for BTC or a 100 sat/byte minimum for transactions for 6 months, and I had to put my money on what would be most detrimental, I would go for the 50kb block being the worst of the two, while also thinking that it could in fact collect the most amount of fees in total by having absurd fees.

1

u/lubokkanev Feb 13 '19

If many miners don't mine low fee TXs, then they will take a lot to be confirmed. Also, it can be a soft fork, like a block size decrease - then no miner will be allowed to mine low fee TXs, because it will be a consensus rule.

It would be possible to increase the lowest standard fee without needing any actions from the miners by increasing the default minimum relay setting on the most common full nodes.

That seems like BS. Everybody will just propagate directly to the miners then. "relay nodes" is a BS term.

2

u/greengenerosity Feb 13 '19

The extra steps that is needed to directly connect to miners to put a fee that is under the standard relay will translate to it representing a small fraction of low priority transactions. It also depends on what the standard relay fee is changed to. It will in any case not be possible to get transactions that is relayed directly to miners under the standard relay fee mined before the mempool is cleared out completely.

If I am not mistaken it is already possible to relay fees directly to miners that are under 1000 sat/kilobyte, it is not worth the effort for most people.

Having something like 10 sat/byte minimum relay fee will in practice translate to that being the new standard minimum fee that people will use with few exceptions. Anything hoping to get in the next block will have to be 10 or more sat/byte as long as the block cap is filled or close to being filled.

When Bitcoin Cash was around 4k(?) regular transactions often tipped over one cent, at that point it was discussed if the 1000 sat/byte relay fee should be lowered to set a lower pricefloor. Not because it was not possible for people to send it directly to miners, but because it would not be practically possible, not widespread at least.

0

u/CryptoOnly Feb 13 '19

Why would the miners ignore something that’s going to create fee pressure and greatly increase their earnings?