r/btc • Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com • Feb 08 '19

Bitcoin Cash is Lightning Fast! (No editing needed)

436 Upvotes

605 comments sorted by

83

u/Thanah85 Feb 08 '19

The people constantly complaining that these videos are edited or otherwise manipulated need to just try a BCH transaction themselves. It's freaking fast.

But let's be serious, they're not really concerned the video is manipulated; it's just the usual trolls.

50

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

The fact that this video has 50% down votes shows the manipulation is in full force.

19

u/WippleDippleDoo Feb 08 '19

Keep on fighting. They will never win.

BitcoinCash = Freedom

28

u/MikeLittorice Feb 08 '19

Nah, it just shows a lot of people don't like you.

15

u/LuxuriousThrowAway Feb 08 '19

.. which shows that manipulation is in full force.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/braitacc Feb 08 '19

Or perhaps just because this video shows nothing new. Also the fact that you can do that also with btc and LN (for less than a satoshi) and other coins with low fees (fees are in satoshi not $ btw). Except bch is not the real btc, only another inferior copy like bitcoin gold or bitcoin diamond: Everybody , his grandma and his dog can fork off and do the same as in the video so they can benefit from a pump /Boring

11

u/rdar1999 Feb 08 '19

Mke a video with the following:

1 - transaction to LN sending funds;

2 - LN wallet connected to some candy machine or whatever you want;

3 - measure the time between 1 and the candy coming out of the box;

4 - measure the cost of the whole operation.

If you come up with something better than this video, I pledge to give you 100 bch.

Time to complete the task: next two hours.

Best regards.

62

u/Fly115 Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

Lightning vending machine.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Fb6Xww2P7c

Reasons why this is better;

Payment is 100% received and irreversible unlike the example above where the transaction is not in a block and could be reversed.

Payment cost less than 5 satoshi (conservative) compared to the example above where it would have cost minimum 300 satoshi (BCH).

BTC candy vending machine.

https://twitter.com/davidknezic/status/1000781725369323530

Almost identical to the example above. This is nothing new or unique to BCH

8

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

Reasons why this is better;

Payment is 100% received and irreversible unlike the example above where the transaction is not in a block and could be reversed.

Payment cost less than 5 satoshi (conservative) compared to the example above where it would have cost minimum 300 satoshi (BCH).

Reasons why this is worse:

  1. For different types of LN transactions where it would be desirable, the payment cannot be sent if the receiver is offline and not using a centralized custodian.

  2. The lightning network payment may fail to route for reasons unknowable and unpredictable to the sender or receiver.

  3. The lightning network payment can be stalled by an attacker for up to an hour at no cost to the attacker.

  4. 10% of all lightning network funds are completely unusable to users (Required for reserve)

  5. Lightning network nodes must keep keys hot

  6. SPV clients are both more protected against attack and consume less resources while remaining trustless in nearly all practical cases. Lightning network nodes cannot be used with SPV except with a centralized custodian.

  7. Vending machines like this represent an accumulator of small payments, which is going to force more onchain transactions because of incomplete money cycles. See below for explanation.

  8. Lightning nodes must find and use watchtowers to protect against their own losses; If there is a loss, they will not be able to recover the full amount lost, and there is nothing they can do to prevent this except only open/accept channels with trustworthy parties.

All of these problems are fundamental design problems of lightning. They cannot be fixed, and only a few of them can be mitigated by software/network improvements. No other cryptocurrency has any of these problems.

Explanation for 7 above: When small-payment accumulators go to pay out the accumulated small payments (Like to vendors, i.e. a service that refills the machine each month or a supplier who sells candy by the pallet), the payment is likely to be too large to be routed on lightning successfully and will have to be moved onchain. This creates a non-cyclic pattern of funds flowing to accumulators and then leaving lightning, which will require many more onchain transactions (Because funds going through accumulators cannot form a complete cycle back to the sources without leaving LN).

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (53)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/iguanarchist Feb 08 '19

What use is lightning fast transactions for simply a store of value coin?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CryptoOnly Feb 08 '19

Did that transaction receive a confirm before it released the candy?

21

u/captaincryptoshow Feb 08 '19

Do you need a confirmation to dispense a little bit of candy?

7

u/CryptoOnly Feb 08 '19

No I don’t believe so.

Just wanted to clarify seeing as it wasn’t mentioned.

This video would look exactly the same with any leadings POW coin if it’s got no confirms so I just don’t see what’s interesting about it.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/guuuug Feb 12 '19

Added to memorypool != added to block

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19

Manipulation? You mean opinion? I downvoted this shit with clear concience.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Libertymark Feb 08 '19

Most people who complain are troll traders who have never interacted with their crypto or sent to someone

Sad as fuck as they then willfully spread lies

2

u/ChristianCarbide Feb 08 '19

They concerned that it's true

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

Fast until everybody uses it and mempool backs up, fees go up. It is Bitcoin... maybe just slightly more tps.

Dag coins like Nano make a better currency... and zero fee is nice. Send 1 Nano... user gets 1 Nano, not 0.9995.

15

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

Post the pubkey so we can start feeding y’all in the office candy! 🍬🍬

Edit: pub address for anyone that is mobile https://explorer.bitcoin.com/bch/address/bitcoincash:qqj97v29qwt8af4wqvlup8ytuf84wq3k35pya6jc8w

17

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

Scan the QR code in the video! It is still online in our office now

10

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

Get a livestream set up!

12

u/Lothspell Feb 08 '19

I think it was a strategic mistake to name this bitcoin cash and take the bitcoin.com domain. It hurt the whole crypto space to have this confusion. Do you want McDonalds or McDonalds Burgers? So dumb, so petty.

5

u/dwyss9 Feb 08 '19

in deed very very sad... they should name it RogerSuckPupped coin with the ticker RSP

-1

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

I think it was a tragic mistake for some people to use censorship and propaganda to morph BTC into something other than a peer to peer electronic cash system while insisting on keeping the Bitcoin name.

124

u/ATHSE Feb 08 '19

0-conf...

56

u/DylanKid Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

Who's going to spend thousands of dollars just to double spend a 40 cent transaction? On btc the could use replace by fee, but bch doesn't have rbf and miners obey the first seen rule.

Edit: copy pasting a reply I made to a different user so no one else has to repeat themselves in this thread:

0-conf is not fool proof (yet), but its still more reasonable to accept than credit cards in terms of safety for the merchant.

If I was a shop owner and someone was making a 40cent transaction right infront of me 0-conf is perfectly fine.

If u own a shop and you want to make them wait 10 minutes just to be doubly sure they aren't gonna screw you over 40 cents that's your choice.

Most people have the power to ring up their bank and flag a transaction as invalid a full day after a tx has taken place. Double spending is beyond the technical abilities of most people compared to a credit card tx reversal. Yet very few actual do commit fraud on the merchant with credit cards.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Damn son too much logical sense. It's almost like you're a smart consumer?!

12

u/anothertimewaster Feb 08 '19

Or a smart merchant! BCH is win/win for both!

1

u/dominipater Feb 09 '19

This makes too much sense. Why hasn't it been adopted?

1

u/DylanKid Feb 10 '19

2 reasons

  1. crypto isnt ready for the real world yet

2)propaganda is slowing us down by years... Take a look at r/bitcoin posts of 4 years ago and they are similar to r/btc posts of today

1

u/edwilli222 Feb 10 '19

Here to ask a real question. Couldn’t I just create a wallet that sends 5 transactions to 5 miners every time I do a transaction? So there’s then a 4 in 5 chance that I will get my money back?

My understanding is that the mempool is not in consensus. If I’m paying my buddy for lunch, it’s fine, which is true for ANY of the Bitcoins. Any scenario where you’re not worried about the security of the transaction ANY 0-conf would work.

2

u/DylanKid Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19

The scenario you are suggesting is possible but alot more complicated than it seems. How do you know the merchants node isn't a peer of one of the nodes you are sending the double spend tx to? They would see the double spend before the purchase tx.

Merchant software could also implement double spend protection, monitoring the mempool with different node clients at different locations on the network, if two transactions appear spending the same output the merchant could force the customer to wait for a confirmation before the purchase is complete. This isnt optimal tho. 0-conf is being made even safer using other methods.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

24

u/DaSpawn Feb 08 '19

was intentionally made less secure on BTC and that intentional flaw was removed from BCH during the Bitcoin upgrade

0-conf was always good enough for in person transactions and significantly safer than credit cards as it is now

5

u/din_granne Feb 08 '19

How is it less secure on BTC? And don't say RBF, because that's optional on BTC.

5

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

How is it less secure on BTC? And don't say RBF, because that's optional on BTC.

The problem is that RBF is a setting that makes a critical difference to the RECEIVER but it is a setting that is only set by the SENDER.

And worse, most wallets either don't support switching between the two at all, or make it more difficult/complicated than nontechnical users can understand.

A good system should be simple, easy to use, reliable, and fast. The lightning+mempool backlogs design fails on 3 of those points; With significant work it MIGHT be able to satisfy two of the four. It will never be reliable; Some times when you go to send a payment on lightning, your payment won't be able to route to the destination. This is unavoidable, unpredictable, possibly uncontrollable, and by design. When this happens you'll be sitting there waiting 30 minutes and paying a shockingly high fee (by comparison) to send your payment to "fix" the issue, when you never caused nor understood nor predicted the issue. It only takes a few such incidents to turn not only users away from lightning but merchants and receivers as well.

Worse yet if the receiver you want to send to is offline and you have to try to coordinate with them to get online because you can't pay them offline. How many times would some busy non-technical person have to be bugged about an offline-online problem before they decide "screw this crypto thing, I'm not accepting crypto anymore"?

Fundamentally this is the problem with Core's entire approach to designing the ecosystem, and their choices to shove the decisions down everyone's throat by banning/attacking/ostracizing anyone who dared to disagree with them. Core completely ignores the human element, psychology, and how real-world decision making and real-world business constraints are met.

Lightning IS better and more efficient than any other blockchain in theory. But when the rubber meets the road, lightning has to rebuild adoption and network effects from scratch to make lightning USEFUL, and it has to do that before users get frustrated again with the BTC mempool backlogs and high fees that they've designed for. In order to build that adoption critical mass, Lightning has to not lose the merchants/businesses who do get converted due to the numerous design issues, AND it has to be resilient against both known attacks(Such as the ability for an attacker to stall payments routed through them for up to an hour for basically zero cost, OR the problems created by LN software requiring decrypted hot keys) AND not-yet-discovered attacks and vulnerabilities.

On BTC this is all going to be fine and good without problems for at least the next several months - Mempools aren't full, and wallets aren't trying to calculate how to bid against eachother in an unpredictable fee market. When that is no longer true there's going to be a lot of anger and frustration from users who are stunned by a $5+ fee on their $25 bitcoin balance - Just like the last 4 times it happened.

On BCH, 0-conf and a lower-backlog design "just works" because it doesn't require any thought or action by wallet providers or users. A merchant can be informed of the risks of 0-conf fairly easily - If their transactions are for less than $3,000 or if they won't suffer any actual losses within a 30 minute timeframe (I.e. person walking out the door with jewelry vs online downloads vs shipment of product a few hours after), it is perfectly safe for them to accept 0-conf transactions. This decision can be made individually by merchants, who are the best ones to understand their risk profile and their use-case.

5

u/DaSpawn Feb 08 '19

transaction processing times were made unreliable/unpredictable due to petrification of development to BTC itself in addition to RBF being possible and hence increases risks and transaction uncertainty

just because you don't want to hear the reality of the RBF problem will not somehow make it go away. Those risks only exist because RBF is possible

29

u/where-is-satoshi Feb 08 '19

Bitcoin BCH 0-conf is about 1000x safer than credit cards.

4

u/joeknowswhoiam Feb 08 '19

By which metric(s)?

20

u/where-is-satoshi Feb 08 '19
  1. A Credit Card payment authorizes the merchant to debit my account whereas Bitcoin BCH 0-conf is a cash payment requiring no such authorization. What stops a merchant from debiting a greater amount from my account or debiting another amount tomorrow.

  2. Credit Cards can be stolen and used. Requiring you to put a stop on them. I lose my phone or my phone gets stolen, I merely buy another phone and reload my wallet from a backup.

  3. Credit Cards expose my personal details like my name and account details whereas Bitcoin BCH 0-conf is just a cash payment with no such exposure.

  4. Credit Cards often have fees and charges whereas Bitcoin BCH 0-conf fees are negligible and I control them.

Credit Cards are old technology from a bygone era whereas Bitcoin BCH 0-conf is leading the retail revolution with its awesome speed, safety and convenience.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 08 '19

Yes, which is beside the point. People were pretending Coinbase editted their video, and yet it is easy enough to reproduce such an example.

1

u/mrjimmy77 Feb 09 '19

Still beating this dead horse eh?

1

u/aykcak Feb 08 '19

I was going to ask. thanks

-7

u/Trentw Feb 08 '19

That's right, undermining the inherent security model of PoW blockchains. Being reliant on this will lead to a large theft in the future, and this video won't age too well, just like the Mt Gox video.

7

u/xenyz Feb 08 '19

I don't think you'd use 0-conf for a large amount, so likely not a large theft.

The question then, is it worth the effort for a small theft, and the answer is it probably won't be.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/WippleDippleDoo Feb 08 '19

Bullshit FUD from a Core zealot.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (42)

13

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

Can someone explain technically why it is so fast? Is this due to a fundamentally different way that it works fron BTC?

10

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

I couldn't technically but it uses 0-conf meaning it has not been confirmed on the blockchain yet, but TX is in the mempool. Not sure if it's safe, but it's only 40c

3

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

0 conf could be done in BTC also. what i wonder is, how well things work once BCH gets a lot more users. (Assuming it does.)

11

u/kilrcola Feb 08 '19

We are no where near capacity, as it should have always been.
Each time it gets closer to capacity, you have two options.

  • Increase the block size

  • Increase the efficiency to fit more tx in each block

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SlingDNM Feb 08 '19

0 conf isnt working on BTC anymore because of RBF, You have a 100% Chance to Doppelspend Every Transaction on BTC Just by Using rbf a Minute later. Its 100% trivial to do, everyone Could Reverse every 40 Cent Tx they did for a fraction of a Cent more

BCH doesnt have rbf and while its theoretically possible to Double spend, it is practicly Impossible

5

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

why did BTC choose to do it this way?

6

u/SlingDNM Feb 08 '19

Well some say the Goverment threatend one of the devs to implement rbf, which is probably very highly unlikely lol

From the beginning core didnt like (and never encouraged) 0-conf, so it was No big loss that RBF broke it. RBF is Pretty useful too, especially with a coin that doesnt have stable TX Fees. You send someone BTC but the Fee is to Low? Just rebroadcast the TX with a Higher fee using RBF and voila! The tx gets accepted in the next block!

This isnt really needed with BCH tho because a) the TX Fee is pretty stable and Low and b) There is No need to quickly Upgrade the TX Fee since they all get into the next block anyway

I never really understood the Point of the LN for that reason, Sure it works, Sure its quite elegent code but its Just Not necassary imo since 0conf is Just as fast and safe (If you make it Safe Like BCH did) and even on-chain, without overcomplicated UIs and having to keep the Channel Open 24/7

TL;DR: RBF is Pretty neat by itself but completly breaks 0conf. BTC never cared about 0conf so they choose to implement RBF.

3

u/zimmah Feb 08 '19

To push lightning network,

3

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

FYI you've gotten a bunch of answers but I don't think many of them are realistic.

In my own opinion, it happened in part by accident and part was unavoidable. The blocksize conflict has been going on since at least 2013 and really got bad from 2015-on. By the time the conflict got bad:

  1. The main developers of Bitcoin happened to attract mostly open-source and cypherpunk developers. It had relatively few developers who had worked for large or successful companies. And as far as I can tell, no developer who ended up supporting small-blocks as the solution has a background in psychology or HCI design.

  2. Along with that, the forums, subreddit, and bitcoin wiki were all owned and controlled by the same person who decided to 100% back the small-block vision.

  3. The few big-block developers present were ostracized or quit quickly. Major personalities who disagreed were banned or threatened with banning from the discussion forums. Big-blockers had no other popular forums to discuss Bitcoin on until r/btc became popular in 2017.

The reason why small-blockers prefer their approach to scaling goes back to, I believe, paranoia and a disregard for HCI design and human psychology. They strongly believe that if your home computer, built yourself, on your home internet connection is not validating 100% of Bitcoin blocks & transactions starting from Genesis, you aren't using Bitcoin and/or you are vulnerable to government or corporate manipulation & takeovers. This is unrealistic and frankly a ridiculous belief, but they believe it.

Some of them such as Andreas were around for the BGP routing disputes in the 90's and strongly dislike the choices made by internet engineers. Those choices were fundamentally made out of practical concerns and to make the internet work for business and commerce as well as for non-technical people; They didn't choose the most trustless, resilient route that the open-source geeks wanted.

So Bitcoin's scaling choice comes back to that. Small-blockers believe that anything that threatens their ability to do validation as they want is a threat to all of Bitcoin. Big-blockers believe that Bitcoin must be practical and usable for everyone who wants to use it, and that security is necessary but must be justifiable and reasonable in light of the risks and vulnerabilities.

You can see an example of Bitcoin Core's scaling philosophy meeting reality with segwit. Segwit was supposed to provide a 1.7-2.2x blocksize increase and was pushed and touted hard, even celebrated, to seek rapid adoption. Despite this, Segwit's adoption in the last 18 months has been bad, even worse than I expected. It's currently sitting around 33-37% and the highest was about 44%. The increase from it has only been about 1.25x. Why is the adoption so bad? Because people are lazy and do not do things the way Core developers want them to. Segwit requires that people take actual action and make a small change to their behavior to begin using it. Even as small as the change is, it's still only hitting that 33-44% usage mark even after all this time. High fees will increase adoption but it will be slow and the idea of Segwit ever hitting 100% adoption is laughable.

Now consider how it is going to be with lightning or Schnorr. Schnorr requires a substantial behavioral change to see the touted benefits. As it is now, only sweep transactions on exchanges will actually benefit, and people are unlikely to re-work how they transact in life just to get a 25% efficiency increase. Lightning introduces numerous tradeoffs, problems, and some advantages, but all told is likely to have much lower real adoption than segwit, which only required very minor changes with no actual disadvantages or tradeoffs.

Bigblockers on the other hand tend to be people in the business & industry of Bitcoin. Miners have real bills that must be paid and are only really profitable when the price is going up - Which means they need adoption and high fees+backlogs+requiring user behavior changes hurt adoption. Businesses and exchanges have the same problem; For some of them, high fees makes Bitcoin unusable for them.

Hope that answers the question. I don't buy into the conspiracy theories and don't think it is necessary to do so. Both groups are doing what they think is right. If not for the extreme censorship that started from Theymos and the frequent attacks(verbal, literal, and lies) against big blockers, I wouldn't think any less of them for their choice.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/hrones Feb 08 '19

it will work the same, as the blocksize will be kept above the transaction levels

1

u/pelasgian Feb 08 '19

Go take a look at the results from the stress tests in the fall of 2018.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/redpepper261 Feb 08 '19

During the Sept stress stress, the iozeta CryptoCandy was still this fast.

4

u/Onecoinbob Feb 08 '19

It's the same for all blockchains. The transaction is not final. (But reasonably safe).
The thing is, that Roger is misrepresenting the nature of these transactions for marketing reasons, but that's just how he is. Dishonest.

1

u/Anen-o-me Feb 09 '19

It was always this fast before for introduced an intentional 3 second delay into BTC-core in like 2014.

1

u/F0rtysxity Feb 11 '19

It is fundamentally different because no one is using its network.

1

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 11 '19

well, as long as that continues performance should be good. what is the problem?

1

u/Salmondish Feb 08 '19

BTC 0 conf onchain is just as fast and much more secure due to more hashpower

0

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[deleted]

10

u/censor-ship-sails-on Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

RBF is optional dumbfuck. Bitcoin can easily encode a transaction with RBF disabled.

Even without RBF, 0-confs are not safe -- and you know it -- which is why 0-conf is only suitable for a retarded gumball machine and nothing of greater value.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (10)

1

u/UnknownEssence Feb 08 '19

How does RBF make 0-conf unsafe?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gizram84 Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

RBF has absolutely nothing to do with it. RBF isn't done in secret. The tx is marked as replaceable. So non RBF txs are identical to BCH.

Merchants/payment processors can easily say "RBF enabled payments will require at least one confirmation before payment is accepted".

1

u/dashrandom Feb 08 '19

... isn't waiting for one confirmation a non-0 conf tx?

3

u/gizram84 Feb 08 '19

Yes. So non-RBF payments on Bitcoin work exactly like BCH.

Everyone here pretends that because RBF exists, all 0conf Bitcoin payments are less secure than BCH. That's a lie.

I was simply pointing out that RBF is optional and clearly marked, so merchants can still accept 0conf on Bitcoin, and just handle RBF differently.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

Merchants/payment processors can easily say "RBF enabled payments will require at least one confirmation before payment is accepted".

And, since almost no users are going to understand what that means or how to do it, assuming their wallet even supports it(which many do not), that means that most transactions that merchant wants to use will require confirmations.

Which means in the real, practical world, 0-conf is unreliable to the point of being unusable for merchants on BTC.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (40)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[deleted]

7

u/gimpycpu Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

I am not very educated on how Bitcoin Cash processes transactions but serious question. RBF does not exist but, could you for example create another transaction with a higher fee, that makes the previous UTXO invalid by making the balance insufficient on the previous transaction?

If not what controls the fee on the Bitcoin Cash chain?

Example Bob -> Alice 1000 sat 1 sat/byte

then I send another transaction

Bob -> Foo 1000 sat 20 sat/byte using the balance that was supposed to be sent to alice, therefor making the transaction invalid. is that possible?

3

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

Example Bob -> Alice 1000 sat 1 sat/byte

then I send another transaction

Bob -> Foo 1000 sat 20 sat/byte using the balance that was supposed to be sent to alice, therefor making the transaction invalid. is that possible?

In your example, the network would reject your Bob -> Foo transaction because it is a double-spend. It wouldn't be relayed past your own node and even if it was relayed to a miner, an honest miner would ignore it. In fact your own node might reject it if you didn't purge the pending Bob -> Alice transaction first (I haven't tested this so just a guess on that part).

On BCH, and Bitcoin prior to RBF being added in 2016, the network will only accept the first version of the transaction seen. A miner can manually bypass this and mine a double-spend into a block, but it comes at a risk to them and it can't be done easily, and the transaction must be sent to the miner off-network.

3

u/ModafOnly Feb 08 '19

Miners takes the first tx, not the highest fees one. Still there can be dishonnest miners that do so but the incentives are such that it's better for them to not break 0confs tx

5

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

Can you show me where BTC has been double-spent and why this is not a huge problem is possible?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[deleted]

4

u/TombStoneFaro Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

ah, thanks.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/marco89nish Feb 08 '19

... in BCH transactions are processed as they emerge (no preference based on their fee), therefore its not possible to doublespend just by paying higher fees than your previous tx, while this can happen in BTC.

What happens if someone sends two transactions (A and B) at the same time from different locations, meaning one part of BTC network with see TX A emerge first and other part with see TX B emerge first. If recipient of TX A sees A before B and recipient of TX B sees B before A, will they both give candy/product using 0-conf?

2

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

If recipient of TX A sees A before B and recipient of TX B sees B before A, will they both give candy/product using 0-conf?

Yes. This is called splitting the network.

For candy the risk is so small it isn't worth doing anything about. For a transaction of higher value like above $500, a merchant can mitigate this by running multiple fullnodes and verifying with each fullnode before crediting the amount. This approach can still be broken by a miner-supported double-spend, so a merchant should not accept a 0-conf transaction of value > $10k (in my opinion).

→ More replies (2)

24

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

So it didn't need to wait for a block to be found?

24

u/jessquit Feb 08 '19

Why would it. It's forty fucking cents. It doesn't need tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in proof of work to prove that it's not a double spend.

31

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

I'm aware of the irrelevance of verifying $.40, but this demo works the same on BTC, thus it doesn't show anything better (or worse).

BCH and BTC are the same speed, more or less, it's just that one can process more tps due to blocksize, though in practice it doesn't process more tps since there just aren't enough transactions.

8

u/jessquit Feb 08 '19

I'm aware of the irrelevance of verifying $.40, but this demo works the same on BTC

Why haven't I ever seen this demo on BTC? How did I miss that. You have a link to that?

BCH and BTC are the same speed, more or less, it's just that one can process more tps

¯_(ツ)_/¯

6

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

I'll make a video of it right now if you want. Send me $.40 on the BTC chain, and the second I see it broadcast I'll empty candy on my table.

I mean, that's all that's happening. There is no actual verification that the $.40 is securely mine yet in that BCH video.

When I said they are the same speed, I mean in block rates. The have difficult adjustments to find roughly the same amount of blocks per unit time. So long as the BCH blocks are not greater in size than the BTC blocks, then equal amounts of transactions will go through on both.

So in practice, they are the same speed for users.

5

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

Someone doesn't understand Bitcoin......

9

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

So you're saying I can't do this exact same video using the BTC network right now? I mean, I'll bet you $100 that I can do exactly the same thing.

You send me $.40 on the BTC network, and I will post the comment 'candy' the moment it gets broadcast.

I understand what you're trying to show and say about BCH with the video, but the reality is that right now and today, there is really nothing about BCH that works any better than BTC for a $.40 0-conf transaction. Both could in theory be double spent, both in reality would be irrelevant if it was because no one cares about $.40. It may be less likely to be double spent on BCH, but it's still possible.

You're not actually demonstrating a user experience that is unique to BCH.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

35

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Doublespending $.4 becomes possible as soon as the blocks are full again which is bound to happen on BTC if it keeps growing and won't ever happen on BCH. This means there is a dampner on BTC growth. It works, but if to many people start using it ... it stops working.

This is why you don't find videos of people doing it on BTC, also the people that care about using Bitcoin as money are with BCH and that another reason why you won't find videos like that for BTC.

6

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

I don't doubt it, I just don't think the reality of current adoptions fits the narrative of the video.

Both chains have low usage and right now both chains can handle 0-conf equally as well for the most part.

16

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

At this moment sure, but what about the next moment? BTC has already shown through past experience that its intended design will spontaneously result in very high on-chain fees.

Just because the fees are low right now doesn't make it look any better to me.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Both chains have low usage and right now both chains can handle 0-conf equally as well for the most part.

Does Bitpay accept 0 conf on BTC right now?

18

u/jessquit Feb 08 '19

Except one chain is being designed not to. So it would be stupid to use it like that. Like using a wrench to drive a nail. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (24)

19

u/MobTwo Feb 08 '19

This is a good time for newbies to learn about RBF and why RBF caused BTC 0-conf to be insecure. BCH 0-conf is much more secure than BTC so no, they are not the same. Please, go read more about RBF and doublespending and then you will understand why Bitcoin Cash is more secured than the outdated BTC.

4

u/TigerRaiders Feb 08 '19

What about Litecoin? Does it use RBF? Or any other coin? I’d like some honest criticism about BCH compared to other coins like XRP, NANO, stellar and Litecoin? Why choose BCH over any of those? Not trolling just an honest question.

3

u/MobTwo Feb 08 '19

Sorry man, I wish I can help but I don't know enough about other coins to make the comparison. I happen to be in BCH because of the really awesome people here, and since the success of a coin is dependent on the community effort behind it, I stayed (not to mention I was banned in rbitcoin which accelerates all my efforts towards BCH)

In the end, I think it is also about aligned philosophy. Bitcoin folks want to be hodlers store of value while Bitcoin Cash wants to be p2p money for the world. I think the world is better off with p2p money. I really like to be able to walk into every shop and spend my BCH as money.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

I get it, I'm just saying that the whole "instant" candy thing will work on both chains given the low tx volumes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/curryandrice Feb 08 '19

Replace by Fee (RBF) compromises zero confirmation. This makes Bitcoin (BTC) susceptible to double spends in a way that Bitcoin (BCH) isn't. RBF destroys an economic use case for Bitcoin (BTC) and makes it inferior in all aspects. If people bought Bitcoin (BCH) like they do for Bitcoin (BTC) the hashpower would move over to a superior coin and we could have a Store of Value (SoV) and Mode of Exchange (MoE) simultaneously.

BCH is superior in every way.

3

u/marco89nish Feb 08 '19

Except that it takes ~3% of BTC hashrate to do 51% attack and make 0,1,2..∞-conf BCH transactions reversible.

2

u/0xHUEHUE Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

"rbf" exists in both, it's just a transaction selection policy. A miner can do it if they want to on bch, nobody can stop it, their blocks will still be valid. The rbf code just standardizes the policy. It is almost inevitable that miners will implement it on their own because it's the rational, greedy thing to do. Might as well make it a standard instead of having adhoc miner implementations.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

There’s no RBF in BCH, unlike BTC (inserted by secret agent in BTC by forcing Peter Todd to put it in core or else.. his life and family was threatened, just search this up its true)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Nobody would use BTC to send $0.40.

2

u/Nibodhika Feb 08 '19

Many people mentioned it, but you don't seem to know what RBF is about. In BTC it is possible to send the $0.40 to the machine, wait for the candies, then send all your funds to another address whith a higher fee, which will negate the previous transaction. Therefore in BTC until it's in a block it can be easily double-spend, while in BCH attempting to double-spend would probably require sending two transactions almost simultaneously and with the intent that one propagates to the machine and the other to the entire network without reaching the machine again, much, much harder to do.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/mjh808 Feb 08 '19

They added a 1-5 second delay to BTC which is enough to make this annoying in a queue.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

Nope. The cost of reversing this would be much higher than the value of the candy/transaction.

11

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

So it's unconfirmed?

14

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

Yes. That's how 0-conf works, it's right in the name.

12

u/gasfjhagskd Feb 08 '19

Why make a video showing how fast 0-conf is? 0-conf is that fast for every network...

13

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

On BTC network it is trivial to reverse any 0-conf transaction via replace-by-fee. While the transaction is broadcast nearly instantly, it cannot be trusted until at least 1 confirmation. ~100ms to ~10minutes, i.e. 6000 times slower.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (6)

1

u/justgimmieaname Feb 08 '19

If you spend 40 cents (or even $4.00) to buy something in a store does the patron bother to scrutinize the currency for possible counterfeit?

8

u/SwedishSalsa Feb 09 '19

530 comments, holy shit they sent the whole troll factory!

5

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

This was faster than my internet loading the video (4.5g on s7) 😂

8

u/frozen124 Feb 08 '19

Lol they are still so mad at coinbase for showing how quick BCH is.

7

u/LaurenK88 Redditor for less than 30 days Feb 08 '19

u/MemoryDealers where can I buy this candy machine?

7

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

You can buy it on Amazon.

1

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 09 '19

Here is the guy who makes them: https://www.iozeta.com/

4

u/freshlysquosed Feb 08 '19

The candy machine is just checking for mempool transactions to its address... It's equally as fast as any other crypto in that respect.

2

u/MrZep Feb 09 '19

why is he not in a jail

2

u/mysteelersrock82 Feb 10 '19

Bitcoin cash is equivalent to BitConnect

6

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

Great demo. I've been saying for a while that an ATM or vending machine is the best demo of 0-conf.

What we need is something like this that's more secure physically, like an ATM or a vending machine, and to set it up in public where people can attack it via double spend if they want.

Even this candy machine could probably be setup in a public place like a mall or somewhere else where vandalism/theft isn't possible. I think this would work almost anywhere in Japan, right?

As long as the size of the goods/transaction is small enough, 0-conf will work. I'd personally trust 0-conf up to $100 or $1000 if I owned a vending machine with some rate-limiting.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Onecoinbob Feb 08 '19

Zero confirmation transactions are equally fast on all blockchains.

But sure, yours are really special ;)

7

u/Satosashimi Feb 08 '19

This is cool tech, can't Litecoin or Dash also do this?

13

u/TheRealMotherOfOP Feb 08 '19

Pretty much any coin can

1

u/Anen-o-me Feb 09 '19

Those have other flaws.

1

u/SlingDNM Feb 08 '19

Every coin can do this, even Bitcoin core. But BCH tries to make 0conf actually Safe to use

4

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

Most coins can do this if they have a reliable reject-double-spend mempool policy.

Bitcoin Core does not have a reliable reject-double-spend mempool policy; Receivers cannot rely on BTC to do this.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

It is 0-conf, meaning it is not secured on the blockchain. Just published that you "wish to send this transaction".

That's not what 0-conf means.

0-conf on BCH means that the network will not relay a conflicting transaction. There are ways to bypass this, but the reliable one is expensive, difficult, and risky for those involved, and the non-reliable one is easy for a vulnerable party to mitigate.

3

u/sirviks Feb 08 '19

Paying fees for micro-transactions....

10

u/zynalk Feb 08 '19

The fact that this post is so downvoted is a testament to how scared core are of BCH and how effective it is as P2P cash

19

u/rombits Feb 08 '19

I doubt it. People just hate the jab at lightning and see the demonstration as glossing over the technicals of this working only as a 0-conf demo. Noobs will say ‘oh wow he sent money so fast, BCH must be amazing’ without understanding what just happened. It’s quite literally a parlor trick.

3

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

and see the demonstration as glossing over the technicals of this working only as a 0-conf demo. Noobs will say ‘oh wow he sent money so fast, BCH must be amazing’ without understanding what just happened. It’s quite literally a parlor trick.

That's the thing though. The technical details of 0-conf CAN be glossed over for all users, and the risks for 0-conf can be easily explained for merchants to individually determine if they can accept 0-conf.

The "problems" frequently outlined by Core supporters are either misleading or flat-out wrong because they don't understand mempools or relaying policies.

Virtually every transaction that lightning is capable of can be safely done on 0-conf due to the small size and the difficulty/cost of double-spending 0-conf.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/CryptoOnly Feb 08 '19

In my humble opinion it’s more the fact that pretty much any POW coin with a decent amount of nodes for fast relay could do this considering it’s 0 conf, it’s nothing special and has been possible for years with pretty much any coin.

It was pretty much just an advertisement for Bitcoin.com, not that it bothers me but how often do crypto adverts get upvoted and like ok YouTube and Reddit..

3

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 08 '19

In my humble opinion it’s more the fact that pretty much any POW coin with a decent amount of nodes for fast relay could do this considering it’s 0 conf

BTC cannot do this unless the receiver can be guaranteed that the senders will all turn off RBF. Since many wallets do not even support that and even more users don't know how to set it, why they would, or what it does... Receivers cannot reasonably rely on this feature.

The comparison with lightning is very apt, as 0-conf can do nearly any transaction that lightning can currently do due to the small size limitations.

8

u/jessquit Feb 08 '19

"Must... Prevent... World... From... Seeing..."

downvoting intensifies

1

u/xav-- Feb 13 '19

Not scared. I’m just mad at myself for not having dumped it when it was $3k. I could have used the funds now to buy one BTC.

4

u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 08 '19

EHRMAGERD THAT'S EDITED! /s

3

u/Ineedmorebtc Feb 08 '19

Wow, a video where he doesn't spew vitriol and nonsense. I mush rather have these type of videos than the polarizing BS that I'm used to seeing.

4

u/Martin_Gormsen Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

Nice😎 I got an older version of the BCH candy dispenser from iozeta. My kids love it.

3

u/500239 Feb 08 '19

1st world problem. Too much candy comes out too fast. Awesome!

4

u/fipoch Feb 08 '19

You can drive fast on an empty highway

3

u/Romeo_the_Dog Feb 08 '19

Biggest cunt in crypto.

Bar none

3

u/throwmein555 Feb 08 '19

Maybe change the website name, something other than “bitcoin”

2

u/LashaHenks Feb 08 '19

I'm waiting for him to eat the chocolates. Please release the full video.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

BCash people are truly delusional. Instead of focusing on building their own project, they just keep complaining about Bitcoin. If you guys truly think you are better why don’t you work on improving your product? Go figure

8

u/xenyz Feb 08 '19

Bitcoin BTC people are truly delusional. Instead of focusing on building their own project, they just keep complaining about Bitcoin cash BCH. If you guys truly think you are better why don’t you work on improving your product? Go figure

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

[deleted]

3

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Yup exactly!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Many shitcoins are faster and safer then Bch network.

Bch low price because no one wants it, very low usage because their network is trusted by no one, low popularity because they offer nothing new just like shitcoins.

Bch missed the point completely again. First big roads, now fast transaction on a non trusted network like Bch.

There are fast service and big road in North Korea, aint nobody want to be there or have anything to do with it. Same thing as Bch.

Bch image is already tainted with Roger history/Bch dramas/Scam tricking new people

I think we seen some usage with Bch few months ago forcing people starving for food in 3rd world country, to hold BCH signs up for food. LOL

Next step is paying business to use Bch, oh wait Roger has already done it, one business even rejected Rogers $1 million a pop offer. Ouch. Guess who arent starving for food will reject Bch.

2

u/uri008 Redditor for less than 2 weeks Feb 08 '19

Bitcoin is complicated

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

If it is lightning fast, why does both Litecoin and Ethereum transfer from one exchange to another exchange so much faster than Bitcoin Cash?

That's really the only true way of measuring the speed of a coin.

How long does it take to get from binance to coinbase?

Yeah it sounds great being able to go to a cash register and paying with cryptocurrencies but in reality it's much smarter to buy a $100 gift card for $20 worth of crypto and saving $80 at the register.

4

u/DylanKid Feb 08 '19

That's really the only true way of measuring the speed of a coin.

Lol, so the only true way of measuring the speed of a crypto is how quick a centralised exchange processes it on both ends?

Please don't rely on that.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Exchanges pick their own confirmation levels, it has nothing to do with raw network speed, bullshitter

1

u/red1v1der Feb 08 '19

First read: "No edging needed".

True True.

1

u/wercrako Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

Yes, well, who is hungry?

1

u/Grahnite Feb 09 '19

No thanks. I only use real Bitcoin. Say NO to Btrash.

1

u/F0rtysxity Feb 10 '19

What happens to the fees if ppl actually start using BitcoinCash?

1

u/Pleasurepack Feb 12 '19

“Hi I’m a scam artist, do you like bitcoin? BOY DO I HAVE THE COIN FOR YOU!”

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

Does Roger still hodl BTC? If not, he is gonna get rekt.

1

u/MonsieurEskimo Feb 14 '19

Shit fucking coin

1

u/CaramelWithoutSugar Feb 21 '19

So it's good as lightning but riskier? me gusta mucho

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CaramelWithoutSugar Feb 21 '19 edited Feb 22 '19

So not really as good as lightning. Gotcha. This isn't the best time for me to reply since I am still playing, but I can't send you any bch. Thanks for the answer though.

1

u/davigimon Feb 08 '19

Obviously is fast, that highway is empty.

1

u/jgun83 Feb 08 '19

It took me over 3 hours to get 12 confirmations yesterday morning, so there's that.

1

u/RealColorman Feb 08 '19

Ya heard of MobilePay?

1

u/Napath2415 Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 08 '19

I need some money. The handsome bitcoin cash.

1

u/Cryptoguruboss Feb 08 '19

What if Roger asks his miners don’t process or reverse or double spend my transaction to steal my candies? Can he do that?

1

u/bcloud71 Feb 09 '19

No. He cannot.

1

u/SlingDNM Feb 08 '19

Roger should offer a huge Cash Award for someone that Manages to Double spend

1

u/BlTGROIN Feb 08 '19

I tried free.bitcoin.com and linked my Google account but I get this message: Your region has reached maximum amount of claims.

Pretty off putting to new users I would guess! Just a little FYI!

1

u/bcloud71 Feb 09 '19

it's just a cent anyway, why don't you post your BCH address, and I'll send you 5 cent.

2

u/BlTGROIN Feb 09 '19

Thanks for the offer, but I just wanted to try it out. I have a couple BCH stowed away :)

1

u/SuperNewk Feb 08 '19

So much better than my credit card

1

u/Actualcrypto Redditor for less than 2 weeks Feb 08 '19

The money button feature of Bitcoin cash is also a game changer. I think the project as a whole is not dead after all.

1

u/lingo_cash New Redditor Feb 08 '19

This is so cool! We will need to get one for our office!

1

u/zeptochain Feb 08 '19

Best advert for Bitcoin Cash I've ever seen. Awesome!!! Rock on!

1

u/dominipater Feb 09 '19

They're giving BCH away? Really? 'Cause that's seldom a great sign in an otherwise nice tech demo.

0

u/witu Feb 08 '19

Hehe, such hate.

-2

u/Insan-ET Feb 08 '19

Wow! Bitcoin Crash!

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Too bad you got sidetracked with all this other bullsh*t Roger.

14

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

Sidetracked with the exact same thing I've been focused on for 8 years. Peer to peer electronic cash for the world regardless of what it is called.

1

u/sunbro43va Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 09 '19

Also, you and Billy McFarland are like twins. Not just from your mannerisms and looks, but down to how to you do business lol. It's a bit wild. At least you are rich though right, Roger?

0

u/Hernzzzz Feb 08 '19

'Regardless of what it's called' yet you insist your shitcoin is bitcoin when clearly it isn't.

Peer to peer electronic cash for the world regardless of what it is called.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

Which bullshit? Public outreach? Marketing? Adoption?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Instead of evangelising Roger wanted to win so bad that he made a deal with the devil and ended up getting burnt. That is very clear to everyone. Then instead of acknowledging the bad call Roger and his friends doubled down on the fight. This left a major crypto equipment player crippled and has destroyed the reputation of all.

And to this day there has been no apology or even addressing the issue. Instead it’s everyone else’s fault. Just look upthread. Always some conspiracy holding you down.

Downvote all you want but this is the truth and the failure to even acknowledge is what turns off normies like myself.

4

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Feb 08 '19

I'm still waiting for an end to the censorship on /r/Bitcoin and an apology from the censors. The fact that you are allowed to post here while we aren't allowed to post on /r/Bitcoin shows who the good guys are.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19

Whataboutism.

P.S. You're not a good guy, Roger.

2

u/braclayrab Feb 08 '19

[citation needed]

2

u/curryandrice Feb 08 '19

The metrics that Roger plays by might not be the same metrics that you are using. If Roger wanted to merely spread the word of Bitcoin and the whitepaper then he is more successful than he probably ever dreamed. The entire world now knows and is trying to adjust to cryptocurrencies.

Price and hashpower might not be everything. It might be better to have a well informed populace. Knowledge is power.

1

u/lamarrotems Feb 25 '19

Who was crippled? I'm a noob and honestly don't know what you are referring to. Not trolling.

-1

u/flat_bitcoin Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

"The fee was a 30th of a penny", there's the problem. Lets say we are at scale, no block reward left, avg 1 tx per person on earth per day. Miners total revenue is therefore 2.3 million dollars.

Say 10% of transactions are low cost 0-conf, and 10% of that try to fraud the system, because it works, and free stuff. that's 1% of total transactions.

Those 1% would only need to broadcast a new transaction with a fee of 3.3 cent to double the total daily revenue of the miners.

People get free candy, coke, movie ticket whatever for 3 cents, miners double their revenue for including higher fee double spend transactions. Both parties are incentivized to break 0-conf.

0-conf is not secure, Avalanche needed.

-1

u/WetPuppykisses Feb 08 '19

daily reminder that exchanges are requiring for 30 or more confirmations on BCH making this coin one of the slowest coins out there

1

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 09 '19

Further proof that most of the BCH haters use cryptocurrency for literally nothing other than speculation/gambling on exchanges.

Some of us use it as money, bub.

-2

u/s1lverbox Feb 08 '19

So now ver is in vending business? Wow. Selling candy to kids? I think that's the only targeted part of society he didn't robbed yet.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/bitdoggy Feb 08 '19

I didn't watch the video but I don't see how "speed" will help BCH stay relevant i.e in top 5 or lately top 10.

-1

u/skisundays Redditor for less than 30 days Feb 08 '19

I do not believe that does exist any crypto currency faster than NANO

-3

u/zhell_ Feb 08 '19

Too sad that no one will be able to use this fastness because BCH is useless as money since like all crypto it's too volatile.

Hopefully BSV is just as fast and understood it and is making bitcoin useful before it can become money by building the METANET