r/btc • u/increaseblocks • Jan 30 '19
Just 18 more months to go!
https://i.imgur.com/2TEQyWX.jpg11
u/lizardflix Jan 31 '19
Ok, I'm out. I joined btc years ago and stayed after it was taken over by bch people and became a place to push bch. Now it's just a place to bash btc. There's nothing productive about this sub at all. So long losers.
3
u/yaharoo Jan 31 '19
lol 100% true. Good for you. Move on to something more productive. I'm here just for the lolz tbh
18
u/Ardinias Jan 31 '19
Yo at least negative comments aren't being deleted here. Fuck /r/Bitcoin mods.
8
u/veritas103108 Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 31 '19
The thing i find the most interesting is BCH's own forum for their propaganda is becoming less and less effective. Posts like this get more upvotes supporting BTC than BCH. As if we didn't already know it - it's another clear sign of BCH's complete failure. It's community is crumbling underneath them.
BTC isn't in competition with BCH but it's sure entertaining to see another attack on bitcoin fail yet again.
3
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19
This comment section is getting brigaded to hell, though. All those years in the echo chamber made their emotions raw, they can't even handle jokes anymore.
It's tough seeing the "king" fail though, I guess.
3
u/CatatonicMan Jan 31 '19
Eh, not really a joke. Jokes are supposed to be funny.
1
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19
I agree it's depressing, but it's something we need to move past if we want cryptocurrency to succeed. I had a lot of trouble getting over BTC after mining it for so long, but everything dies eventually.
1
u/kattbilder Feb 01 '19
1
u/cryptochecker Feb 01 '19
Of u/Dixnorkel's last 62 posts and 1000 comments, I found 13 posts and 459 comments in cryptocurrency-related subreddits. Average sentiment (in the interval -1 to +1, with -1 most negative and +1 most positive) and karma counts are shown for each subreddit:
Subreddit No. of comments Avg. comment sentiment Total comment karma No. of posts Avg. post sentiment Total post karma r/CryptoCurrency 130 0.14 222 1 0.8 (very positive) 57 r/decred 1 0.0 16 0 0.0 0 r/factom 1 0.1 5 0 0.0 0 r/litecoin 0 0.0 0 1 0.14 4 r/CryptoMarkets 20 0.08 28 0 0.0 0 r/CryptoCurrencies 7 0.14 14 0 0.0 0 r/BitcoinMining 35 0.12 56 0 0.0 0 r/Bitcoincash 11 0.16 26 0 0.0 0 r/Digibyte 6 0.19 17 1 -0.2 3 r/ethtrader 18 0.1 263 0 0.0 0 r/BitcoinBeginners 2 -0.1 4 0 0.0 0 r/btc 203 0.1 1203 9 -0.07 261 r/Crypto_Currency_News 4 0.27 (quite positive) 6 0 0.0 0 r/Monero 19 0.05 -6 0 0.0 0 r/vertcoin 2 0.22 5 0 0.0 0 r/siacoin 0 0.0 0 1 0.0 1 Bleep, bloop, I'm a bot trying to help inform cryptocurrency discussion on Reddit. | ^About | ^Feedback
0
47
u/Karma9000 Jan 31 '19
It went live in early 2018 with real money, just a few months after segwit fixed tx malleability, and it’s been growing in size and scale steadily since then.
Fun meme i guess, but, like, what are you talking about? It’s wildly disingenuous to suggest there hasn’t been any progress on that front since 2015 and that people are just waiting around for “lightning network” to appear.
16
u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 31 '19
went live
More like an alpha version was released only. Right now it’s a toy for developers and enthusiasts. Until LN devs solve the path routing problem in a decentralized way (not using watchtowers for example) then it’s not “live” as a decentralized payment network. Good luck!
8
u/kristoffernolgren Jan 31 '19
What are you talking about? Watchtowers are for keeping track of channels when you are not online, not routing and are also not at all centralised.
16
u/mongkeboy Jan 31 '19
Regardless of what it's being used for or not used for, saying it's not a live network is just dishonest.
5
Jan 31 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/CatatonicMan Jan 31 '19
Saying it's ready for mass consumer adoption would be dishonest. Saying it's live is simply stating a fact.
2
Jan 31 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/CatatonicMan Jan 31 '19
That's not what "live" means, though. You need to be more precise in your language.
1
Jan 31 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/CatatonicMan Jan 31 '19
Don't be accurate, you mean. Nah, I'll keep doing what I'm doing.
The prototype/alpha/beta/RC/whatever status of a product indicates it's relative level of features and completeness, not it's "gone live" status. They're separate concerns. Same goes for utility/usability/capacity.
So, I'll reiterate: you need to be more precise in your language.
4
u/SatoshisVisionTM Jan 31 '19
It must be pretty hard to score around here, with you moving all those goalposts. You claim it isn't live because *in your opinion* it is alpha.
r/btc downvote brigade rate limiter censorship: you are doing that too much. try again in 5 minutes.
19
u/Touchmyhandle Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 31 '19
LN has more adoption than BCHABC. Just a couple of weeks ago the spam bots must have malfunctioned and we got a brief glimpse of how many people really use BCHABC. I can't find the data but it was less than 20 tx a block for about 2 hours or something.
This sub is lead by some people that were initially well meaning, but as they realised they had it all wrong they were too deep and too committed and their egos couldn't allow them to be honest. So instead we get posts like this that divert from reality. Oh, and 50% of posts salty about Bitcoins success. Such a dumpster fire.
-8
u/segregatemywitness Jan 31 '19
You are a professional liar. Your mom must be proud.
15
u/Touchmyhandle Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 31 '19
You epitomize why nobody takes you lot seriously.
3
u/GrilledCheezzy Jan 31 '19
This same thing happens as soon as I say anything realistic here. Wait until they have Ethereal come and say the same thing about you as everyone else they dislike while pretending to be a bot.
-5
u/segregatemywitness Jan 31 '19
Wow are you using vpn vote bots. +7 for you and -7 for me, eh?
Why does reddit let you scumbags moderate /r/bitcoin? Will they not be able to "find" financing on Wall Street if they don't look the other way?
7
u/Touchmyhandle Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 31 '19
Haha. Makes a change, my shot normally gets down voted to hell in here. Maybe you just need to reassess the nonsense you keep spewing?
6
u/SuperSmash01 Jan 31 '19
It's the market valuing the things you're saying that is giving you downvotes, not bots.
-4
-7
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
LN has more adoption than BCHABC
No it does not have more merchant adoption. BCH has 100k merchants that accept it. The LN only has a couple thousand NODES total, not even merchants.
15
u/Touchmyhandle Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 31 '19
Where are all the transactions then? Why has the number of transactions been flat since launch. Check blockchair right now. It says 0.12 tx per second.... Nobody is using BCHABC buddy.
-6
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
Did you even read my post? I stated that BCH has over 100k merchants that accept it. This is because bitpay alone has 100k merchants, and bitpay accepts BCH.
Do you somehow think that this statement is false?
The LN on the other hand, has very few merchants that accept it.
0
Jan 31 '19
[deleted]
0
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
Pretty much every merchant that accepts BCH vis Bitpay accepts BTC. So your point is moot.
Yes it does. I never stated otherwise. (BTC took 10 years to get to that point, and BCH only took 1 year, though, so this isn't surprisinf)
Instead, I stated the the Lighting Network has a horrible adoption rate, and that very few merchants accept it.
I was comparing the great adoption rate of BCH, to the horrible adoption rate of the lighting network, that basically nobody uses.
4
Jan 31 '19
It's delusion at a very high level to talk about the "great adoption rate of BCH" when a single centralized payments processor (Bitpay) enables BCH payments solely because they're identical to Bitcoin in terms of implementation. This "great adoption rate" you talk about is a side-effect of Bitpay being a successful Bitcoin payment processor. Merchants don't get paid in BCH, they probably don't even know it's accepted, and they most certainly don't care.
Bch transaction count is continuously low and doesn't improve, it's slowly but surely losing it's value, becoming less and less relevant.
1
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
> Merchants don't get paid in BCH
Irrelevant. I don't care if the store I am buying coffee from immediately converts by USD into Euros. Why would I care what they do with my crypto, either?
> when a single centralized payments processor (Bitpay) enables BCH payments
Adoption rate is adoption rate.
And the BCH adoption rate is 1 thousand times larger than the adoption rate of the Lightning Network, which basically nobody uses.
> side-effect of Bitpay being a successful Bitcoin payment processor
But definitely *not* a lightning payment processor, right? Huh. I wonder why nobody uses lightning, even though both BCH and lightning have existed for around the same time period. It is almost as if 1 solution is significantly better than the other.
This whole thread is about how basically nobody uses the lightning network. Yes, people use BTC on chain, as on chain actually works (well... for the moment, as long as fees aren't high on BTC, lol!).
Yes, I agree, on chain payments are way better than a vaperware solution that basically nobody uses.
→ More replies (0)5
u/Karma9000 Jan 31 '19
I'm not disagreeing with the fact that it's small and retains a lot of UX challenges, my only point is that we can see them being worked on and improving, almost in real time. Anyone who claims LN proponents were suggesting that a full production release, easy to use by anyone and everyone with no further optimizations needed "within 18 months" in 2015 is being hugely dishonest.
1
Jan 31 '19
How are watchtowers in any way related to "the path routing problem"?
One can argue that Btc/Bch is also still a toy for devs and enthusiasts. At the very least, UX is still severely lacking. Ln development is moving quite fast, I wouldn't be surprised if it's going a lot faster than Bch dev. At what point do you guys stop it with the endless negative shitposting and just accept the fact that both sides are trying to build what they perceive to be the best way to scale bitcoin properly, the only difference being that one coin seems to be slowly fading into oblivion..14
Jan 31 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/BitttBurger Jan 31 '19
We are 10 years in. Saying it’s a toy for developers at this stage is lunacy. And since bitcoin is non functional and LN has replaced it for commerce, that’s precisely what you’re saying about Bitcoin. That is a seriously bad thing.
0
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
I can't buy anything with lightning coins. Very very few merchants accept it. Thats not live.
being live would be when 100k merchants accept payment in it. For example, BCH currently has over 100k merchants.
Right now it is a pre-alpha product that the lightning developers don't even suggest you use.
5
u/iupqmv Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
For example, BCH currently has over 100k merchants.
To be fair it is only thanks to few large payment processors that offer BCH next to other coins. There are very few places which are BCH only, or use BCH as main currency.
1
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
Adoption rate is adoption rate. "Exclusive" adoption rate isn't something I care about.
2
u/Karma9000 Jan 31 '19
I mean, if you want to torture the definition of “live” to mean “mature” then i’d agree with you, but again, you’re moving the goalposts from what the OP was suggesting and from what any lightning proponents were suggesting as a timeline for availability and growth of the technology.
Real use cases are here, now. They’re still small and still inconvenient, but both of those elements are improving, observably, every month. I see the argument that BCH looks ready and available today, and by all means, go for it! But LN growth and development has been roaring along just fine for something of it’s scale and complexity, and continuing to imply it’s non-existent as OP did is silly.
2
Jan 31 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
Yes that is true. That is my entire point. Basically nobody uses the lighting network. It is a horrible solution, that is extremely difficult to set up, and it will take years and years and years before it is in a usable state.
-6
u/CityBusDriverBitcoin Jan 31 '19
7
u/Karma9000 Jan 31 '19
You know that post talks about his experiment from 6 months earlier that year, yes? Several months after the lunch of LN? Fun anecdote, but for every one of him, there have clearly been many more joining/staying : /
29
u/ihackportals Jan 31 '19
LN has grown by > 10000%. This subreddit is total garbage.
13
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19
Lol so has everyone living, if you go back to the zygote. This statistic is meaningless.
5
u/BeardedCake Jan 31 '19
...Can't say the same thing about BCH adoption, price, hash rate, transaction count...I can keep going.
5
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19
Actually, if you go back to the creation of the BCH ticker, price has increased infinitely, similarly to LN growth in the original, bullshit statistic.
Adoption is just blatantly false regardless of the timespan you're talking about though, there are way more vendors that accept BCH now. Can't say the same about BTC lol.
5
u/BeardedCake Jan 31 '19
What are you smoking: https://trade.kraken.com/markets/kraken/bch/btc/3d
The price crashed in relation to BTC. Maybe the price was lower when the ticker was created, but was the coin actually tradable? We both know the answer to that.
You say there is adoption...going from 0 vendors to 100 is not adoption. Nobody gives a shit that some sushi place in Australia is accepting BCH.
How about the other metrics (transaction counts, hashrate) , just gona ignore those?
4
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
You're really saying that other projects' hashrate has done better over the past year? Even BTC's?
Tx count means nothing, especially when spam and wash trading is so widely known about, and comparing it to BTC is even more meaningless when it's one of the most common cryptocurrencies in terms of trading pairs.
Maybe the price was lower when the ticker was created, but was the coin actually tradable?
Are you implying that there were places you could trade BTC for USD when it was first created?
You say there is adoption...going from 0 vendors to 100 is not adoption.
Lol there are way more than 100 vendors accepting BCH, there are 7 in my small city and 90 just in the nearest state capital, and I'm in the US. What are you smoking?
4
u/BeardedCake Jan 31 '19
Lol there are way more than 100 vendors accepting BCH, there are 7 in my small city and 90 just in the nearest state capital, and I'm in the US.
Again WHO gives a fuck? If it was being used, the transaction count which you say is bullshit metric would be higher, but It isn't. Fact of the matter is that nobody is using BCH just like Dogecoin, yet BCH has even a lower tx count.
"Are you implying that there were places you could trade BTC for USD when it was first created?"
I am not, just look at the chart and tell me how well BCH has done against BTC...
"Tx count means nothing, especially when spam and wash trading is so widely known about, and comparing it to BTC is even more meaningless when it's one of the most common cryptocurrencies in terms of trading pairs."
This is a self defeating point, you say its a meaningless metric then you state that its the most traded crypto...what if I told you trading/speculation constitutes use?
4
u/Dixnorkel Jan 31 '19
what if I told you trading/speculation constitutes use?
Lol I'm happy to admit that trading BTC is using it. Speculating isn't necessarily, but I get your point.
BTC is the most common crypto in terms of pairings because it's the oldest. Myspace is the oldest social media platform, but you don't see anyone really using it anymore, even though lots of people kept using it after Facebook was a thing. If you want to argue why BTC will continue to be used, feel free, but first mover advantage isn't really anything to brag about when it's so slow and expensive to use.
I am not, just look at the chart and tell me how well BCH has done against BTC...
It's done amazing during the times when BTC fees were insane and wait times made it borderline unusable, which will be constantly if mass adoption comes before LN is more decentralized/workable. BCH hashrate and price has almost dethroned BTC's at several points in the past, what time period are you talking about?
6
u/BeardedCake Jan 31 '19
"BCH hashrate and price has almost dethroned BTC's at several points in the past, what time period are you talking about?"
That has never happened, price has never even been close.
1
0
u/stale2000 Jan 31 '19
Yup, going from 0 people using it, to a hundred or so merchants is such a huge deal, man. Look at all the places that I am unable to pay with lightning coin at.
0
Jan 31 '19
[deleted]
-2
-5
2
7
4
u/Krytopotamus Jan 31 '19
I’m trying not to laugh because I own some BTC . Lucky we have Bitcoin Cash to save us from the frustration of unreliability
5
3
2
Jan 31 '19
You can buy stuff at bitrefill.com using lightning network.
It's just as functional as any other coin.
1
Jan 31 '19
So I heard this joke the other day. How would you describe Bitcoin cash as a number? Anyone?
Zero :)
5
0
-2
-1
u/sunnykeboy Redditor for less than 30 days Jan 31 '19
Hey, buddy, this picture is so vivid that I don't know how to express my mood when I see it. What I want to say is that we should have hope for virtual money. After all, we can't stop it from moving forward, just like the BTC I bought on ZB platform.
68
u/yaharoo Jan 31 '19
2017: BCH Tx count will go up any time now
Many years later...