r/btc • Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom • Jan 11 '19

Alert The creator of the now famous HODL meme says that the HODL term has been corrupted and doesn’t mean what he intended; also mentions that the purpose of Bitcoin is to spend it and that BTC has lost its value proposition.

402 Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

53

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

31

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

Yup, that's him.

15

u/CommunistAndy Jan 11 '19

One of the comments “ok I am hodling too, waiting for cash on gox to buy more” oof

2

u/SoundSalad Jan 12 '19

Why oof? That was the only reasonable way to buy for awhile.

8

u/yagami_lite Jan 11 '19

Ye that's the guy!

7

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

One day subs like /r/bitcoin and /r/cryptocurrency will have thousands of people that will feel bamboozled.

1

u/FabioEnchalada Jan 12 '19

One day? Lol

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Where do you think the entire space would have been if microsoft and steam would still accept Bitcoin for payments?

0

u/Adrian-X Jan 12 '19

You'd needs to remove the transaction limit to imagine that reality.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

[deleted]

13

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Microsoft and steam using Bitcoin in commerce was the beginning of a network effect of money coming in to play for Bitcoin. Not allowing the chain to grow naturally killed that network effect. THen everything splintered and lost focus. Now people that want to use Bitcoin in commerce have to make a choice, support Bitcoin ... but it does not work like money anymore because of replace by fee and a mempool that on a regular basis does not get emptied out by the next fond block.

Or support something else that does not have the Bitcoin name.

1

u/Ithinkstrangely Jan 12 '19

Bitcoin is now Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin is now Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin...

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Bitcoin is Bitcoin

Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin Cash

Bitcoin = digital gold

Bitcoin Cash = P2P money.

It's only a matter of time before they rename Bitcoin to Bitgold.

4

u/hapticpilot Jan 12 '19

Bitcoin = digital gold

Bitcoin = p2p electronic cash system.

The push to frame it as purely digital gold came from the Bitcoin Core cult. The originators of the cult clearly want to destroy the progress of the Bitcoin but they couldn't just say "Bitcoin should really be small and shit" so instead they came up with "reasons" that Bitcoin should be small and shit like:

  • it's actually digital gold! (note how gold is not used as cash. it's used by a tiny fragment of Earths population. IE it doesn't hurt the fiat bankers operation. They want Bitcoin to be like that.)

  • bigger blocks are dangerous (their arguments were bad and irrelevant. Bitcoin was already designed from its inception to have big blocks and that's the plan that drew millions of people towards adopting and promoting it and giving it its initial value)

  • The LN will be better for cash purposes (it isn't and it wont)

2

u/CEERNunnos Redditor for less than 30 days Jan 13 '19

Smart man

2

u/Ithinkstrangely Jan 12 '19

The elites unfairly usurped the name with their "hostile takeover". I refuse to change and believe me this is important: I'm an entity of change.

This is my perspective on the truth. Bitcoin got corrupted. Bitcoin Cash IS Bitcoin now. I'll argue from this standpoint forever. They should rename it to Bitcoin Fiat...

Agree to disagree?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

liar

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Bitcoin is NOT sound money. Sound money does not have a daily hard cap on tx.

2

u/ZeroWithEverything Jan 12 '19

TIL HODL was a drunken typo, not intended as an acronym for Hold On for Dear Life.

-6

u/moleccc Jan 11 '19

hmm, the way I remember it was as a typo in wall observer. Not sure how to go about finding that post.

15

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

39

u/Cobra-Bitcoin Jan 11 '19

This guy epitomizes early adopters pretty well. A bit of an eccentric but also extremely intelligent. I miss seeing these types of people in the Bitcoin community. I think Amir Taaki was the last of these still active, but even he's been chased out and ostracised. A shame.

20

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

Yup, so many have come out against Core knowing they fucked up full and well. They will never admit to it though. I'm still not sure why you don't make use of Bitcoin.org to help spread the original message more. Maybe 2019 will be a good year to start. Doesn't have to be a dramatic change, slow and steady wins the race. :)

2

u/Cobra-Bitcoin Jan 11 '19

I'm still not sure why you don't make use of Bitcoin.org to help spread the original message more.

The site is spreading the original message. The homepage alone has three occurrences of the word "payment" and promotes low fees.

15

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

It's spreading the original message but using tools and resources that don't actually do that. For example, Choose Your Wallet should focus on wallets that support BCH since BTC is not reliably fast with low fees as the site says it is. The logical step would of course be to support BCH even if it was on a secondary page, to give the world the choice to choose which is the best option for them.

-4

u/Cobra-Bitcoin Jan 11 '19

It's Bitcoin.org, not BitcoinCash.org or Altcoins.org. The site exists to promote Bitcoin, and promotes it essentially how it's always been promoted -- as a payment system. Altcoins like Bitcoin Cash/SV/Ethereum have nothing to do with Bitcoin and it makes no sense to "support" them. You're suffering from the misguided delusion that Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin or one variant thereof. It's not, and never will be.

17

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

as a payment system.

The problem is that Bitcoin (BTC) is no longer a payments system as so clearly demonstrated over the years by Bitcoin Core developers. The clear route is toward a settlement system (layer 1) for Lighting (layer 2).

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

bitcoin does 2500000 tx pr day. you cant with a straight face claim bcash is more of a payment sytstem when it does less than one tenth if those tx.

6

u/bacondev Jan 12 '19

Because people like you are mindlessly promoting Bitcoin Core over Bitcoin Cash. Have you actually used Bitcoin Cash? From a technical perspective, BCH is superior to BTC. There exists no good reason to use Bitcoin Core over Bitcoin Cash as a payment system.

20

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

You're promoting a revolutionary payment system that is deliberately rate-limited. That's not very honest. And it's certainly not bitcoin.

When you move transactions to a private ledger where they can be censored, and there is no transparency, that's no improvement over what we have currently.

10

u/donkeyDPpuncher Jan 11 '19

Bitcoin as described in the white paper does not resemble BTC. Is BTC not Bitcoin any longer? Is it a variant of Bitcoin? Did segwit kill BTC's shot at remaining Bitcoin? Maybe the ridiculous 1 mb block size limit preventing its' use as cheap peer to peer cash makes it no longer Bitcoin?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Do you even understand how segregated witness works and why it was brought about? I mean it's become a talking point but do you actually get the benefit of it? You have perfect backwards compatibility. 2mb blocks and if I remember right the potential for a 4mb block. Most importantly this was done while maintaining complete backwards compatibility as to not compromise trust for people who might be in third world nations or on a limited development budget. Think about how amazing that was for trust.

7

u/BitttBurger Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

You are confused as heck. Or you’re being dishonest. Pick one. Those are the only two options.

The ticker has absolutely nothing to do with the concept of bitcoin. Do you grasp that?

There is a literal bitcoin based on ticker, and then there’s the invention of bitcoin based on a social imperative, and a structure and function intended by the creator.

Bitcoin Cash will never be bitcoin. Based on what metric?

Neither the structure, function, operation, nor social imperative can be met with the current BTC implementation.

That’s a big fucking serious deal dude.

If Bitcoin is described by its founder as pink, round, and strawberry smelling, and BTC is green, square, and smells like chocolate, how does that make it Bitcoin?

Conversely if Bitcoin Cash meets all the descriptors why is it not bitcoin?

The problem is you don’t put any value on the intent behind the invention.

Neither on an operational, structural, or social imperative / humanitarian level.

That’s a big problem and it’s a disconnect that needs to be reconnected in your mind. I realize you are afraid of your colleagues, but that’s not as important as keeping bitcoin, bitcoin.

Put simply: bitcoin is supposed to help the 6 billion poorest in the world onboard to a financial system for free.

BTC can no longer do that. So not only has its original imperative been lost, but it structure and function is no longer in play.

BTC is not bitcoin. It quite literally has deviated so far off track that it’s now the alt coin.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

I strongly support this message.

However, the infighting needs to stop. It's toxic for the community

I think the people supporting Bitcoin cash probably have good intentions in their mind but they have lost sight of the bigger picture. Trust. Adoption. This constant war on bitcoin is one they will never win.

I have been watching development since Bitcoin cash was born and I still don't understand why it wasn't marketed as an alternative rather than a competitor

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

I have been watching development since Bitcoin cash was born and I still don't understand why it wasn't marketed as an alternative rather than a competitor

its simple. bcash was an attempt at gaining control of bitcoin

2

u/jerseyjayfro Jan 11 '19

ok, so let's promote a big block fork on bitcoin. let's do it!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

You're suffering from the misguided delusion that Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin or one variant thereof. It's not, and

never

will be.

Would you like to make a McAfee style offer where you chop off your own dick when BTCC becomes defacto Bitcoin? What endgame would you be comfortable with? When exchanges use it as the backbone to trade against? When it's taken at Starbucks and BTC Core isn't? The Flippening? Set the metric.

6

u/Cobra-Bitcoin Jan 12 '19

What makes you assume I have a dick?

1

u/bacondev Jan 12 '19

Calling Bitcoin Cash an alt coin is a bit disingenuous, don't you think?

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Drop dead.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

promotes low fees

What does promoting low fees mean? Do you tell people to pay low fees? What about the "fee market"?

Realistically, promoting low fees exactly corresponds to promoting network upgrades that scale up the throughput while still preserving decentralization. That is what Bitcoin Cash is. Limiting your focus to those who have not upgraded makes your above claim insincere, IMO.

3

u/horsebadlydrawn Jan 11 '19

"Fee market" is a complete bullshit term anyway: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_irzBK5P0U

It's like a "speeding ticket market" or something

43

u/moleccc Jan 11 '19

I'm still around. I never was very "public", but I think I might fit the description. I'm hanging by a thread, though. I think after the cash fork debacle I need a longer than usual break. Bitcoin just isn't fun any more and the community seems to have lost its ideals and has been splintered into unfriendly factions.

8

u/BitttBurger Jan 11 '19

Please start being more vocal.

4

u/SoundSalad Jan 12 '19

Hey 🙋‍♂️

I think I'm eccentric and smart too.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

So... what should we buy then... SpaceX Puts?

1

u/E7ernal Jan 12 '19

It's really unfortunate that you feel that way, but I understand it. I think part of the problem is that there are legitimate attacks backed by some real money. We knew it could happen, but nobody expected it would happen so quickly, and we weren't ready.

Maybe it's time us old school bitcoiners banded together again in a forum that isn't so easily astroturfed as Reddit.

1

u/moleccc Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

It's really unfortunate that you feel that way, but I understand it.

Sorry to sound/be so negative. It's just that seeing it all crumble after all these years and seeing my peers fight each other is just hard. Also the huge inflow of stupid, greedy idiots hasn't helped.

Now, I'm not saying this is the end of it. I'm not selling my crypto (mainly BCH these days), either. There's still a chance we can pull this off. It just got that much harder. How are we going to enact a revolution if we keep fighting over the color of our pitchforks and the build of our guillotine?

I must admit I underestimated our enemies. Those fuckers are smart, determined and resourceful. I also overestimated our resilience against "social" attacks.

Maybe it's all just growing pains?

2

u/E7ernal Jan 13 '19

No, I get it. It seems like everything is outside of our control. But eventually we'll win out if we persevere and keep growing our ecosystem. The technology development on BCH is the best in the industry. We care about end users, and that will show in the end. Because crypto will have a real "mainstream moment" where BCH is ready. Average people have mostly given up on BTC. People didn't know about BCH. But they will, and it will work, and they'll like it.

1

u/moleccc Jan 14 '19

thanks for your positive outlook!

1

u/theantnest Jan 12 '19

This is exactly my feelings now too.

After the last cash fork, there isn't a community I want to belong to anymore.

24

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

What makes you think we're no longer around? We didn't leave. The community left us.

7

u/drcode Jan 11 '19

Actually, OP was specifically referring to the "extremely intelligent" early adopters.

(kidding)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

What a save!

3

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 12 '19

I suppose we havn't met before...

Point being though, the pseudonymous and online nature of the community allows for other pseudonymous entities like Cobra to paint a picture that we're no longer around just because we're not all hanging out on BitcoinTalk or on r/Bitcoin.

7

u/BitttBurger Jan 11 '19

Please be more vocal.

3

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 12 '19

Dealing with all the infighting is exhausting and I already have my own health concerns. For some time I did post here though once I figured out the problems with the Core client. Lately the events leading up to and after the BSV / ABC split led to a lot of nastiness from both major sides and I decided to resume my hiatus.

Bitcoin and the various associated communities have been a major part of my life. I'll never leave completely.

11

u/CC_EF_JTF OpenBazaar Jan 11 '19

There's lots of people like this who still support Bitcoin but they just aren't as vocal about it.

4

u/BitttBurger Jan 11 '19

Be more vocal.

7

u/E7ernal Jan 11 '19

Yah that's your fault, you dingus.

1

u/FabioEnchalada Jan 12 '19

A bit of an eccentric but also extremely intelligent. I miss seeing these types of people in the Bitcoin community.

You're saying this about the modern-day equivalent of tulip mania.

1

u/SoundSalad Jan 12 '19

I think it was a mistake to split from Bitcoin. That's exactly what Blockstream wanted. Would be more effective to fight from the inside. I think we should reorganize and resume this fight from the inside to ensure that bitcoin adheres to the white paper, before it's too late.

6

u/Aviathor Jan 11 '19

I think user "Elux" (second reply) is the "creator" of the meme. "GameKyuubi" just realized that trading only leads to losses and then made a simple spelling error.

Without Elux's reply "HODL!" maybe there wouldn’t be this meme now.

2

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

ROFL trying to re-write history. Nice.

6

u/Aviathor Jan 11 '19

Nothing changes in history with my comment, it’s quite neutral. Paranoia much? So insecure of yourself and your sub?

2

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

Without Elux's reply "HODL!" maybe there wouldn’t be this meme now.

Trying to re-write history. RIP MUH HODL.

2

u/Aviathor Jan 11 '19

Don’t be so scared, all your narratives can be preserved, not matter who invented the meme! All good, calm down 😘

3

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

This guy started the chain reaction. Even if he didn't create the meme itself, the meme would have had no meaning without his post.

All credit to Elux, Piramida and others for giving it their own humorous spins of course.

5

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

So none of you HODL BCH? Really, not at all? You strictly spend it and don't save any BCH?

Wouldn't it make more sense to use stablecoins if you're a spend only user? Serious question here. Please don't get all butthurt.

13

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

7

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

Thanks for the response. That's what I do as well. Maybe it's my misunderstanding but I never took HODL as a never spend mantra. Just a silly saying to remind your average dumb money investor to hold through downturns.

What I do is spend when I'm sitting on a profit and HODL and accumulate when I'm sitting on a loss. I spend fiat when the market is down and crypto when the market is up.

I think encouraging people to spend during a loss is a noble idea to further adoption but in practice is a stupid financial move.

2

u/mcmuncaster Jan 11 '19

The idea to recycle is to gradually migrate fiat over to crypto....bear and bull cycles I spend and replace when i can, and continue to put more and more savings into crypto. I don't spend it because it's up and i feel rich, i spend because i want to encourage crypto as medium of exchange over fiat. I replace immediately because i want long term store of value as well.

Sad reality: no one accepts crypto where i live, limited to online

0

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

Yeah I understand the concept. I just prefer my method. I use crypto as a currency, an asset class and a store of value. And guess what? It's censorship resistant so I can use it anyway I choose.

People in this sub claim they're all about censorship resistance but they certainly like to tell you how you should be using your BCH!

2

u/mcmuncaster Jan 11 '19

I think you mean permissionless

Censorship resistance refers to the inability for it to be censored - like gov financial blockade of wikileaks, or credit card banning being used to purchase crypto

But i get your point

1

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

Yes, permissionless would be a better term.

4

u/BitcoinKicker Jan 11 '19

Can one hodl and spend?

When I want to buy something I spend BCH at every oppertunity.

I also use it to store value as the fiat currency of the nation I belong to suffers from inflation.

There for I hodl and spend.

3

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

I guess it depends on how you define HODL.

2

u/BitcoinKicker Jan 11 '19

I define hodl as not selling coins for fiat under any circumstances. Seeing as you asked the question, how do you define hodl?

3

u/saibog38 Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

I define hodl as not selling coins for fiat under any circumstances.

For me it's always been more of a rallying cry against panic selling in particular. I think some profit taking and rebalancing of your wealth on the way up is very prudent and reasonable, and I don't really consider that contrary to "hodling". Set some targets and if they're hit, take some profit. Selling because the price is crashing is usually just emotional trading and not a particularly good strategy imo. It's similar to FOMOing into a huge bull run, which is something I caution against as well.

3

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

I define HODL as holding until you reach your desired outcome, whatever that may be. Not selling for fiat under any circumstances is a bad idea for me (and for many others if they were being honest with themselves) but fine for others depending on what your goals are.

Edit: I can only post a comment once every 10 minutes in this sub (only sub I have a rate limit in). Mods don't like free thinkers like me:)

2

u/BitcoinKicker Jan 11 '19

I define HODL as holding until you reach your desired outcome

That's a cop out. You're defining something with arbitrary terms. It's like defining a term by saying "it means whatever I think it means at this particular instance"

Not selling for fiat under any circumstances is a bad idea

Absolutely, it shows blind commitment sans rationale.

Edit: I can only post a comment once every 10 minutes in this sub.

That's generous go ahead and spend the next 595 seconds reviewing what you are about to post. Stupidity and free thinking are not the same thing.

2

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

I'm very sorry to offend your tribe but that's not arbitrary. Investing goals should vary from person to person depending on your situation.

Only letting someone talk once every 10 minutes because you think they're stupid is censorship plain and simple.

2

u/BitcoinKicker Jan 11 '19

I'm very sorry to offend your tribe but that's not arbitrary.

Loaded statement. I'm not offended.

Investing goals should vary from person to person depending on your situation.

Goal posting. We're not talking about investment goals. We're talking about the definition of hodl.

Only letting someone talk once every 10 minutes because you think they're stupid is censorship plain and simple.

because you say a lot of dumb things. This whole thread is evidence of your incompetence.

1

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

HODL = how you reach your investment goals by my definition. It's not the same as your definition. Are you able to understand that whether or not you agree with it?

1

u/nolo_me Jan 12 '19

It's nothing to do with the mods, it's a sitewide feature. Try it in any other sub where you have negative karma.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Bitcoin was meant to decentralize payments. You don't need block chain to HODL, you can do that with Magic the Gathering cards and frankly anything else.

18

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

Legendary thread. I have so many good memories from reading it back before people went completely crazy with muddled "store of value" propositions.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

yeah before the scaling debate there was only one and everything else could have been a scam for all I cared.. Now it's like bitcoin is being torn apart by every vector possible. Is BCH still the closest we have to a bitcoin? Out the few who define bitcoin the way those in this sub do even then the answer is yes no and maybe. Fuck.

-12

u/deltanine99 Jan 11 '19

No, BSV is.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Well.. you're half right to half of us, everyone else thinks you drank poison koolaid

13

u/Bitcoinawesome Jan 11 '19

HODL meme guy is the new "enemy of bitcoin" (tm)

33

u/money78 Jan 11 '19

"Value has to come from somewhere" even the guy who created the HODL meme he's saying that spending is what creates value lol and it seems from this interview he's a little upset about what Bitcoin has become. How do you like them apples, you core idiots with a fucking low IQ!

2

u/Extrakredit Jan 14 '19

I mean we know Hodl was a drunken rant. Nobody looks at this guy like he’s Antonopolous or anything.

-2

u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 11 '19

How do you like them apples, you core idiots with a fucking low IQ!

I don't think anyone cares about what "the guy who created the HODL meme" thinks.

Why do you think his opinion is so special? He's just a guy who made a typo once upon a time.

25

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

He's a guy who's post started an avalanche that eventually grew into a social movement rejecting many of the principles that for good reason used to be self-evident in the Bitcoin community.

Certain parts and I'm sure he himself is idolized plenty, which in turn makes his opinion relevant in todays crypto climate even if it perhaps really shouldn't have been.

1

u/kattbilder Jan 13 '19

A few really smart people already knew that bitcoin could increase in value and make you rich.

1

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 13 '19

Most everyone knew that it could, potentially. That doesn't mean you had the means to invest and stay invested, or that staying in until now would have been the most favorable option for you personally.

Especially, although this is a sidenote, if you knew the shortcomings of the software (not to be confused with the design itself) because you had worked intimately on it you might have seen reasons to convert a significant portion of your wealth at a strategic point. Many also lost their keys in early fat finger mistakes or because they didn't yet understand the system properly.

0

u/kattbilder Jan 13 '19

Of course it was obvious, Bitcoin blew up in 2013 and everyone wanted to get rich quick, all of my friends. Then they wanted to get rich quick again in 2017, they never hedl their BTC.

10

u/money78 Jan 11 '19

I don't think anyone cares about what "the guy who created the HODL meme" thinks.

Tell this to the core minions that made him a hero and famous due to his HODL error I never even saw his face until this moment.

Why do you think his opinion is so special? He's just a guy who made a typo once upon a time.

No one said his opinion is so special, the sheep in r/bitcoin made him special they took the hodl thing and make it a big thing because it fits their narrative. I heard about his meme in r/bitcoin. nevertheless, special or not he has the right to say whatever he wants just like you and me.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Did you know the creator of that Neo and Morpheus meme was also banned from /r/bitcoin?

They have kicked out every creative person and/or independent thinker. All that is left is a handful of wolf, sheep and fake accounts run by companies that offer social media manipulation services.

6

u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

"you core idiots with a fucking low IQ"....."Tell this to the core minions"

You sound like you have a lot of hate inside you.

7

u/BitttBurger Jan 11 '19

He has every reason to be angry. Poor people around the world continue to suffer unnecessarily because a handful of arrogant developers decided they know what’s best for bitcoin, which includes crippling it and killing adoption and usage.

They’ve postponed financial sovereignty for billions around the world by years. Maybe dig a little deeper than the low-IQ cliche talking-points and figure that out sometime.

Do you think BCH forked because we like wasting our time and getting trolled for a year and a half by people like you? There’s a very serious social and humanitarian issue on the table here.

2

u/yellow_kid Jan 11 '19

If you're such a humanitarian why do you waste time on reddit instead of going out to help your fellow men and women in need?

2

u/BitttBurger Jan 12 '19

If you're such a humanitarian why do you waste time on reddit instead of going out to help your fellow men and women in need?

If you’re a good person why do you waste time on Reddit instead of doing good deeds for people?

Don’t ask stupid questions.

1

u/yellow_kid Jan 13 '19

I'm not a good person. Not like you anyway, the virtue signalling humanitarian.

2

u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Poor people around the world continue to suffer unnecessarily because a handful of arrogant developers

This is complete nonsense. Whatever decisions are taken by the core team - or any other open source project - do not cause the suffering of poor people.

Maintainers of open source projects are free to make whatever decisions they wish, we are all lucky people are willing to share code contributions so freely.

If you disagree, you can fork or follow another project. Such a project now exists in BCH, and you have no right to complain.

Stop being a salty bagholder.

1

u/BitttBurger Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

This is complete nonsense. Whatever decisions are taken by the core team - or any other open source project - do not cause the suffering of poor people.

If the devs directly and willfully block the project from being able to do the exact thing suffering people need it to do, then they absolutely are directly responsible for it.

A retarded five year old could connect these dots.

Maintainers of open source projects are free to make whatever decisions they wish, we are all lucky people are willing to share code contributions so freely.

Oh yessss! Thank you Gods of code, for blessing us with your kindness to even write code for our humble project. We are truly blessed!

No.

The fuck are you talking about? Do you actually believe that coders can never make bad choices? Or direct the project down the wrong path?

What kind of delusional cuck are you?

This project has a social and humanitarian imperative that the developers in charge have directly blocked due to social and economic illiteracy.

Stop worshipping fallible neckbeards who lack social skills and a connection with end users.

In the real world these people are told to follow specifications written up by product and end-user experts for a reason: coders typically don’t know shit about who they’re building for, and rarely care.

3

u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

The fuck are you talking about? Are you do you actually believe that coders can never make a bad choice? Or direct the project down a wrong path? What kind of delusional cuckold are you?

Of course a maintainer of an open source project can made mistakes or decisions I disagree with, but it's their project, not mine. I don't pay them anything and I'm lucky to get the code for free in the first place. The license explicitly allows anyone to take the code and do whatever they want with it, so why are you complaining?

You're just an entitled asshole with delusions of grandeur that you're changing the world.

1

u/janediscovers Jan 12 '19

Oh, but what a Special TYOP it is, isn't it?

15

u/Pipkin81 Jan 11 '19

Why would it matter what he says? He just made a typo that everyone liked. That doesn't make him any kind of Bitcoin expert.

5

u/bditmer Jan 11 '19

Holding through crashes is good, but holding them just to say you're holding with no plan for the future is bad

4

u/wmurray003 Jan 12 '19

Man he sucks at pool.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

He gets it. Smart man. Most people do actually get it if they can see past their own greed.

3

u/ISkiAtAlta Jan 12 '19

Did this video survive on the other side of the fence (r/bitcoin)?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

His speaking voice reminds me a lot of Edward Snowden.

9

u/jessquit Jan 11 '19

I remember when this stupid meme started. It was stupid then and it's still stupid now. "Derp I too am drunk and can't spell."

And yes isn't it fascinating how the ravings of some obviously drunk person (ranting about what a bad investor they are and how they can't make good decisions) have been turned into the entire strategy of Bitcoin? Great idea, let's all do what this drunk guy is doing since we also can't make good decisions.

8

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

Not gambling their money with short term trades is a great idea for most people. If you're certain enough of a longer term investment in something that you really understand, you should absolutely ignore intraday and weekly fluctuations.

3

u/ferretinjapan Jan 11 '19

The "to the moon" meme was worse, but hodl was close behind. It just demonstrated to me how simple-minded, servile and greedy most people in Bitcoin were, and are even more these days.

As a joke, I apprecciated it, but it quickly turned into a tool to shame people into not selling.

7

u/horsebadlydrawn Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Aww cmon guys, HODL and 2theMoon were good fun. I thought of it as people having a laugh about the astronomical price growth. Humor was the best way to deal with missed opportunities and the entry of Wall St scumbags into the crypto space.

And +1 to this kid for spending his hodl-profits on guitars, pool tables, and pinball games.

2

u/ferretinjapan Jan 12 '19

I love memes as much as the next guy, but anything relating to the price quickly devolved into tribalism. It got to the point that these memes were spammed relentlessly as a covert form of shilling, and complaints about them caused people to be abused for daring to call them out.

Thats where they stopped being fun.

2

u/horsebadlydrawn Jan 12 '19

True.

For the record, I don't think the guy is that smart. He says "I bought BTC because of the whitepaper" but fails to connect the dots that BTC doesn't follow the whitepaper anymore. But anyone capable of independent thinking can figure out that "muh store of value, adoption/utility doesn't matter anymore" is utter nonsense.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

I agree

9

u/Fuyuki_Wataru Jan 11 '19

We used the Hodl meme to get new users not to sell their coins so the price would go up easier. It was a tactic, it worked. Because people used and believed a fucking meme as their investment strategy.

EU has become smart banning meme's, honestly didn't expect people to find out that meme's are powerful.

5

u/FluxSeer Jan 11 '19

Buy the looks of it he didnt hodl.

1

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 12 '19

HODL just meant not gambling by attempting to daytrade. Nothing else. Bitcoins were meant to be spent. The nature of any investment and of any money, is that you eventually part ways with it.

Many if not most early Bitcoin users and developers didn't keep substantial amounts, because that didn't make short term economic sense to them personally even if the design itself did for the longer term.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Bitcoin gets its value from its hashrate that protects its users against a 51% attack.

Right now it cost over $280,000 per hour to 51% attack the bitcoin network. There is no other coin that can match that level of protection.

https://www.crypto51.app/

3

u/jakesonwu Jan 11 '19

2

u/kingp43x Jan 12 '19

wow thats funny. i watched for a good five minutes and saw three BCH transactions

Give me the sweet downvotes because I believe Roger is playing you suckas

3

u/transisto Jan 11 '19

Ok now that the guy who made a fool of himself and sounded like a drunken idiot said so, Gonna spend my BTC on useless shit.

1

u/spiderjail Jan 12 '19

And he scratched

3

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Jan 11 '19

r/btc is thirsty as fuck since the hashwars.

2

u/mrreddit Jan 11 '19

Hodl means to me never sell for fiat

2

u/hlopez_22 Jan 12 '19

I agree with this completely. When I first got into Bitcoin, in 2013, the idea of Bitcoin was so good and had great ability to overturn paradigms, but now it’s becoming eh.

1

u/elpatron5 Jan 11 '19

To answer his question: The value is coming from some dark banksters pumping btc with their worthless billions and think they won bacause succesfullly corrupted some programmers.

1

u/mathaiser Jan 11 '19

Sooo, sing that BCH and BTC. are the same, just different fees per transaction, both a screwed!

1

u/OwnHelpCryptics Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 12 '19

Actually, btc was made originally by Satoshi in order to salve the financial crisis that a government has been facing but suddenly used in an opposite way. truth hurts. Someone should stand and contend on btc's main purpose.

1

u/FabioEnchalada Jan 12 '19

HODL GANG HODL GANG HODL GANG HODL GANG HODL GANG HODL GANG!

1

u/Lividwee New Redditor Jan 13 '19

If the BTC loses its value because the term has been destroyed, is it not that the BTC I invested in ZB will have nothing? That's not what I wanted to see.

1

u/bucketscometh Jan 11 '19

lmao what is this awkward conversation structure? And why does the opinion of this guy matter?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

wow who gives a fuck what this guy says

it's a fucking meme

1

u/loomenaughty Jan 11 '19

It’s pronounced GIF.

1

u/pacman78 Jan 11 '19

One of us. One of us

1

u/spiderjail Jan 12 '19

Lmfao, what

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Kind of a douche

6

u/fruitsofknowledge Jan 11 '19

Kind of a human being making a good point or two though.

1

u/money78 Jan 11 '19

No, he's not a sheep he's smart enough to understand what's really going on with Bitcoin and the stupid HODL mentality!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Well as users there isn’t much else you can do until merchant adoption improves. The bull market was actually great for Bitcoin awareness

-3

u/codedaway Jan 11 '19

Another made up propaganda piece by Bcash bagholders.

There are people hodling, there are people spending, there are people creating.

The beautiful thing about BTC is that everyone can do with it as they wish and know they are on the most secure network in the world unlike BCH which at the flip of a switch can be attacked by minor pools on BTC.

You guys are laughably pathetic, it's unfortunate that so many people were tricked into BCH and are now holding bags full of nothing. I'll always be grateful to you twats for buying all of my coins at $3,100 a pop. But never grateful enough to stop calling you scamming retards out.

0

u/mrxsdcuqr7x284k6 Jan 11 '19

Someone should tell all the people filling up the BTC blockchain with transactions that their chosen coin has lost its value proposition and can only be used for store of value. Maybe a few hundred more Roger Ver interviews will do the trick.

0

u/forgoodnessshakes Jan 12 '19

HODL wasn't a campaign to lock up bitcoin, it was linked to the 300 Spartans 'Hold the line' and became a sort of 'Keep the Faith'. Hodlers didn't cash out because they believed in the upside potential (and were handsomely rewarded).

Hodling is a natural reaction to owning hard money (Gresham's Law) and a quick reminder not to cash out. This video looks as contrived AF.

-3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

He's clearly a scam

Slash s

0

u/saidthebells Jan 11 '19

Don’t shoot a scene with a pool table in Log and not grade it. It looks bloody awful. Just shoot Rec-709 if you don’t know how to grade your images. Jeeeeez....

0

u/Kiwit0m Jan 11 '19

Lol, basically saying he used it to buy drugs online. There weren't many other things to buy with btc back then. I think that's how many people found out about btc. We are the rebels, but born into the internet. Want to outsmart drug enforcement? Use a tech they are unfamiliar with

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Dr Craig Wright has been screaming this from the roof tops .

2

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jan 11 '19

I can't see his garbage tweets but I wouldn't be shocked to see a similarity in BTC and BSV hodl memes.

2

u/jeffreyrufino Jan 11 '19

That idiot is just power hungry. He doesn't care about Bitcoin.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Oh , so just name calling here bye

2

u/jeffreyrufino Jan 11 '19

Bye NPC

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Because I’m not name calling like the herd?

-8

u/BigSatanGuy Jan 11 '19

Tell him to stfu.

-6

u/ShrimpyKevin Redditor for less than 60 days Jan 11 '19

It's been proven several times that HODL is not an effective investment strategy. For those looking for the easiest and simplest way to invest in cryptocurrency, I would recommend trying Shrimpy.io.

With Shrimpy, you can essentially create and manage your crypto index fund. Instead of HODLing, Shrimpy helps rebalance your cryptocurrency assets to achieve your desired crypto portfolio or ratio. Best of all, it's free to sign up and use!

Read how rebalancing outperforms HODL: https://blog.shrimpy.io/blog/cryptocurrency-index-funds

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

[deleted]

3

u/dnick Jan 11 '19

So basically some random guy who meant to say ‘hold’ like hundreds of other people, but misspelled it, causing some random other person to pick up and make a cute meme should now be someone that has something more worthwhile to say than the other hundred people who didn’t misspell the same word.

“When I said hold, I meant x instead of what it’s being used for today, and you should listen to me because when I originally said it, I misspelled it”

1

u/willglynn123 Jan 11 '19

Long story short this guy’s opinion is less relevant than my left nut

1

u/curryandrice Jan 12 '19

No, if he said the exact opposite he would still be criticized for his luddite views.

The funny thing is that even the Hodl guy realizes that something is deeply wrong with the current perspective from Core. He's a trader and he gives off the sense that something was lost. Not money but the idea and ideals. The stark distinction between how he feels now and then should be taken as an intensifier effect. There's something really really wrong with the current scene.