r/hiphopheads • u/ltrob . • Jan 10 '19
21 Savage - I Am Greater Than I Was ALBUM REVIEW (Fantano)
https://youtu.be/cY27XD0ZRho1.0k
u/tk_writes Jan 10 '19
Why the hate for the song monster? It’s a typical CG verse and it was cool to see 21 match his energy. Also interesting cause from the way it sounds CG had a crazy amount of influence on it and that type of track is something that the XXL freshman version of 21 would have never even been able to keep up with.
97
Jan 10 '19
Fantano doesn't like Childish Gambino very much if you look at his reviews of him. Only project he rated decently is Awaken My Love and that's kinda far from Gambino's typical style he's used most of his career
32
u/DeadStopped Jan 10 '19
He loved This Is America
36
Jan 10 '19
I'm just generally speaking. There are some exceptions with certain songs
2
u/Terencebreurken Jan 10 '19
This is America is also vastly different from any studio material CG made, i relate what Fantano says about at least Camp and BTI’s flow sounding stale and without real character; compare that to This Is America, wich is rich in personality and urgence.
3
Jan 10 '19
I completely agree when talking about Camp sounding kinda stale but I'm a BTI fanboy so no comment on that one lmao
→ More replies (1)2
u/Unkept_Mind Jan 10 '19
I’m not a big fan of CG aside from his radio hits and bumped TIA for a while. Song goes hard. You don’t have to like everything an artist does to like one of their pieces.
58
u/YizWasHere Jan 10 '19
Yeah I don't think Monster is amazing or anything but I enjoyed it. Thought CG's verse was pretty cool. Instrumental was pretty interesting and he flowed well on it.
1
u/justinfingerlakes Jan 10 '19
this prob the 5th review in the past 5 months of a album/song i really really liked and he singles out as being bad or that he didnt like it. usually he says he likes another song or 2, and ill try to check it out again and just have no idea what hes talking about and have to realize we're 2 diff ppl with diff tastes
91
u/Champagnesoda Jan 10 '19
I’m personally disappointed because gambino rarely does features and I expected him to come really hard, especially considering it’s a 21 album. I wanted you see me bino or sweatpants bino but it just felt very very regular.
56
u/tk_writes Jan 10 '19
I think at first I was expecting that too but those tracks are outliers and not typical for him. CG never does anything typical or expected though. That’s why Awaken, My Love was a funk album no one saw coming. Gambino does whatever he feels at the time and tbh this verse is more in his lane. It feels more in the vain of the Royalty stuff or even I Am Not A Rapper 2
41
u/mikeest . Jan 10 '19
Why the hate for the song monster? It’s a typical CG verse
You answered your own question.
→ More replies (1)12
u/KDawG888 Jan 10 '19
For me (don't know about him) the song was overhyped. I don't think it is a bad song but for the things I heard about it I was pretty underwhelmed after listening.
4
5
2
u/rhgolf44 Jan 10 '19
I think it’s a solid song. Bino flows really well on the song and 21’s verse brings it all together. This album is definitely in with the good ones from 2018
1
u/Awhile2 . Jan 10 '19
I think it’s a good song but easily one of if not the worst hooks on the album (and usually I like hooks with children singing) and Bono’s verse where he bites drakes yes indeed flow felt kinda wack
1
0
u/interwebbed Jan 10 '19
Anyone who hates this track can go eat a huge cock.
Its one of the best ones in the album, if not, THE best0
u/John_m33 Jan 10 '19
I had to agree with fantano on this one as I mentioned on this previous thread. Such a subpar verse, not memorable at all
0
Jan 10 '19
[deleted]
113
u/thisismyusernam Jan 10 '19
Didn't he make This is America his single of the year
409
u/FoamingAtTheMouthGuy Jan 10 '19
That wasn’t typical gambino though
→ More replies (5)76
u/rhgolf44 Jan 10 '19
But Childish has changed his music style so drastically over the years. What is “typical gambino”?
25
4
2
0
Jan 10 '19
[deleted]
133
→ More replies (1)8
1
52
u/stanley_twobrick Jan 10 '19
I don't blame him.
70
59
512
Jan 10 '19
Favorite Tracks: A&T
I've never needed Fantano's validation on anything, and so I haven't actively sought it.
But thank fucking christ he liked this track. I really thought I was alone on this.
259
u/tdubose91 Jan 10 '19
All doubts and opinions about 21 became indefinitely irrelevant when he said, “nutted on her cheek her new nickname is babyface”. If you couldn’t tell when you first heard it let me break it down, this is the top.
155
u/adamjm99 Phife Forever Jan 10 '19
Honestly you can go back even further, to when he said “Told the waitress I ain’t tippin, I like hot sauce on my chicken (on god). I pulled the rubber off and I put hot sauce on her titties.”
34
9
22
u/Swagkitchen Jan 10 '19
Joker says basically the same thing on the end of Juicy J's "Zip and a Double Cup" remix.
His line was "My college bitch whippin' eggs on a hot plate / Puttin' sperm on her cheek, baby face"
13
u/tdubose91 Jan 10 '19
Ahh shit. I fucking knew there was no fucking way this is the first time anyone was clever enough to catch and make the reference. I’m happy to hear of all people too joker but not surprised because homie is insane and raps his fucking ass off
8
u/old__pyrex Jan 10 '19
Not related to the previous discussion but that song has the GOAT Chainz verse "house full of a buncha sluts I'm bout to bust a buncha nuts"
22
u/shini_69 Jan 10 '19
Not only did he cancel Kim, and by that extension, ended any problems in North Korea but, any and all sins 21 could’ve done and ever did were immediately washed away when he said,
Yeah, Kim Jong, yeah, big bombs (21)
Wonderbread, man, make your bitch lick crumbs (Yeah)
44
u/HispanicAtTehDisco Jan 10 '19
GOAT bar tbh
→ More replies (2)45
u/tdubose91 Jan 10 '19
Factual, if I’m being honest I’m surprised it took us til 21 to get a variation of this bar and to me it actually sounds like it could be a 2015 2Chainz lyric.
31
u/Corosz Jan 10 '19
Akin to poetic lines such as "Her pussy so clean I can go to church in it."
26
u/tdubose91 Jan 10 '19
Damn didn’t expect to see someone quoting Aristotle here
12
u/Corosz Jan 10 '19
Not to mention "wood grain, chestnut / titty fuck, chest nut"
7
u/tdubose91 Jan 10 '19
Man fuck whoever I’m so glad we got a 2 Chainz in our generation and not some fucking Shakespeare lame. Chainz truly a cherub for this one
25
14
u/itshairball Jan 10 '19
The beat goes hard and if you can power through the chorus it's a pretty fun song in my opinion
5
u/ffs_fml Jan 10 '19
The chorus is even sampled and changed just a bit so it's not like the decided to make a trash chorus (the song is good nevertheless).
7
1
6
u/interwebbed Jan 10 '19
LMAO I can't take this track seriously but I do like it when I'm fucking lit.
24
u/Jddubman Jan 10 '19
I'm a DJ, this might not have been my favorite song to kick it and listen to, but this was the one song on the album I was excited to drop in my next set. I love this as a party track and I felt like it was slept on for a turn up song.
→ More replies (2)12
Jan 10 '19
Slept on? It was released two weeks ago.
17
u/Jddubman Jan 10 '19
" It was released two weeks ago." That's a long time in music in 2019 though tbh. Maybe I should have said it is currently being slept on instead of was slept on. I have not heard that song being played out and about, but then again where I live hip hop really isn't being played at the clubs like that. Is it a popular party song in cities in the US? I definitely feel like it could be.
→ More replies (2)2
u/hrshie Jan 10 '19
This is exactly how I felt when I saw that he like "ball w/o you" as well. Fucking love that track and thought I was the only one
1
Jan 10 '19
You not alone, love the kind of three 6 mafia aesthetic on the track and that final bar he drops
1
u/Hateitwhenbdbdsj Jan 10 '19
Dude that's literally two opposite things lmao. You clearly needed his validation on this. He's just another dude don't know why y'all care so much about his opinion when music is so objective.
1
Jan 10 '19
The term “validation” is dismissible here - look at it as a foil, not a plot device. My comment was a joke, I think that’s abundantly clear, but even if it isn’t, you should still put effort into dissecting it correctly
A&T is one of my favorite songs of 2018, and That’s not a popular opinion around here: not that it matters, but I’ll listen to that song in spite of the fact that I see hate for it all the time. The joke is that Fantano’s reviews are generally well received and we’re in a discussion thread for the review, so I said “thank Christ he liked it.” The point is that I don’t actually care who liked it, but it still feels good to see a reviewer rate it highly. The same way it would be nice if someone were to post a song thread for A&T right now, and most of the comments were positive.
I don’t actually understand why half of you missed the joke so hard, or even missed the point, but y’all look dumb when you do it, and it’s only bothering me because this happens on every Fantano thread
0
Jan 10 '19
[deleted]
82
u/NexusTR Jan 10 '19
"Fuck that guy, but jeez im so happy he likes the same song I like."
I dont really have an opinion on Melon but I hate how this sub weirdly idolizes him and try to pretend like they dont.
33
u/erytingIrie Jan 10 '19
it's so weird. they really take his opinion so seriously
16
u/BeerBellies Jan 10 '19
Hes a music critic that i respect, and tend to agree with. I dont always agree, but he tends to back his opinions up fairly well, but yeah, sometimes he'll straight up say he just isnt feeling a track/album, and thats fine too. Hes put me on to a lot of artists, so i certainly wont complain.
3
1
Jan 10 '19
I didn’t say fuck Fantano, I said opinions are opinions and nobody needs validation from opinions, because we should make our own.
Me saying “thank fucking Christ he likes this track” is just me acknowledging the fact that I’ve been in an echo chamber of people disrespecting the song for too long, and it feels good to have perspective from someone that understands why the song is so good
Read OP again.
2
u/NexusTR Jan 10 '19
lol i didn’t say you did, that was a general comment on how I think the sub views Melon.
So what your saying is, I took what you said, broke it down to piss off laymen, and then explained how I agreed with your sarcastic sentiment.
But I somehow missed the point...uhhh okay
2
Jan 10 '19
So you took a good-spirited comment that, in no way, represents the sub, and seeks to celebrate a truly amazing banger, and you flipped it every which way so you can damn "the laymen" of this board for an attitude they don't actively exhibit?
Well alright.
→ More replies (2)44
u/HispanicAtTehDisco Jan 10 '19
Nah yall weird for not recognizing bangers
0
Jan 10 '19
[deleted]
40
→ More replies (5)21
9
u/Bosilaify Jan 10 '19
How you gonna only quote a section of his comment and ignore the part where he says he doesn’t seek Fantaman’s validation.
0
3
2
1
u/cjdennis29 Jan 10 '19
It's not really a "thank god Fantano specifically liked it" and more "thank god someone else liked it"
1
u/Coliosis Jan 10 '19
New year's Eve party. Tripping balls on mushrooms. Lotta pretty bitches. Cue drool. Idea! Play A&T. Pretty bitches love. Shake they ass'. Yee.
114
u/Ghidoran Jan 10 '19
Fair review. I agree that there are some pretty forgettable tracks here, Padlock, Gunsmoke, the Lil Baby/Gunna one. I also agree that Gambino's feature was just alright, people are hyped cause its the first Gambino verse in a while but it wasn't anything special.
Still, there are some songs here that I thought would be forgettable, but I still have in rotation, specifically ASMR, Out for the night, and Ball w/o you. I guess those last two stand out mainly cause they're fairly different from the rest of the album.
Also, I really wish 21 had a longer verse on Good Day, he sounded demonic on that track.
11
Jan 10 '19
Yeah that’s my one slight query with that song. Literally everything else was really good imo. Although tbf he did just use Lord Infamous’s flow from Damn I’m Crazed so that’s probably why. Still would have been cool to hear a verse tho
8
4
45
Jan 10 '19 edited Jan 10 '19
For the most part I can agree with him on most songs. I disagree with him about a&t, all my friends, can't live without it, asmr, and monster. a&t was IMO the worst track in the album. After break da law, I was really hoping for a beat switch but it just kept going. all my friends is a good listen for me. Only song with Post in it where I actually like his singing. I don't know what I like about can't live without it, but it's enjoyable for me too. asmr did the whisper verses great in my opinion, both this song and Don't Come Out The House did it great. Production on the song really gave it a good lowkey vibe, that high pitched instrument that I cant think of the name of really did something for me, gave it the perfect cold lullaby feeling that still felt dark. monster was fuckin great, loved the Gambino verse and the production was straight up beautiful. Other than that though I can agree with him on everything else.
17
Jan 10 '19
I agree that a&t is the worst song on the album, and his worst song ever
15
u/Cressio Jan 10 '19
Young Miama singlehandedly ruins it, 21s verse is fire. I just listened with headphones for the first time and she sounds even worse lmfao. It sounds way better with car speakers
→ More replies (3)1
7
u/Super_guccure Jan 10 '19
This album was great showed growth for 21 and cant live without it is only the most forgettable song if werent listening to it with your ears
50
Jan 10 '19
I know it’s kind of an unpopular opinion on this sub, but that Gambino feature was weak and felt very mediocre like he said. Kinda sounds like he was there but wasn’t mentally.
12
u/Jwad35 Jan 10 '19
I thought it was pretty trash and extremely simple
11
Jan 10 '19
was just good to hear him again. BTI stuck in my rap repertoire
1
Jan 10 '19
Yeah I the verse isn't anything special but hearing his voice rapping again was nice. I think the songs pretty good overall. BTI is my favourite album ever
1
u/thisishorsepoop Jan 10 '19
Yeah I feel like people like that song more for the fact 21 and Don collaborated more than the actual verse. If it was just some random dude spitting that verse everyone would call it corny and ill-fitting
2
Jan 10 '19
honestly, if some random dude spit most albums we’d call them corny. You seriously underestimate how much names affect your enjoyment of music.
165
u/luckyducky636 Jan 10 '19
I enjoy this album overall but fr it just annoys me how the title of the album and the opening track make it seem like he’s a new changed person, then the 3rd fucking song he’s back to talking about titties and stuff, once I got used to the fact that he wouldn’t be changing I started to enjoy the album a lot more, anyone else feel that way or was that just me lol?
817
Jan 10 '19
is mr savage not allowed to mentions titties any more
459
u/DankBank419 . Jan 10 '19
imo even a changed man should be able to mention and enjoy titties
105
u/Battlemaster123 . Jan 10 '19
everyone should be able to enjoy them
26
u/DankBank419 . Jan 10 '19
what about terrorists and communists
109
Jan 10 '19
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Tittyfucking.”
It’s right there in the Declaration of Independence man
→ More replies (1)55
u/jmt2323 Jan 10 '19
Communism is actually just arguing that more people should be able to enjoy titties, instead of just the wealthy. After the workers seize the means of production, they'll have more money to make rain on stripper titties. Fighting for economic equality is the same as fighting for titty equality
→ More replies (4)32
118
u/Champagnesoda Jan 10 '19
He evolved he didn’t necessarily change. He’s smarter now and has a different view point on more serious things in life. Just because that’s the case doesn’t mean he doesn’t still love ass and tittles.
Maturing and still liking superficial things aren’t mutually exclusive
64
22
u/elitecookie119 Jan 10 '19
Well he didn’t change into a homosexual so let the man talk about ass and titties
4
u/jose_maria_morelos47 Jan 10 '19
I agree I was pretty excited with how it started. Even though A lot wasn’t that deep I was definitely expecting him to go into further detail about his past and how he has grown considering the title of the album. I didnt mind him going back to his older style but I did want more of that other more personal side of him.
1
1
u/EK22 Jan 10 '19
I had this issue with a lot of the reaction I saw on the internet too. Everyone was saying how he’s grown so much as an artist and all that. I mean, he has in a sense, I definitely think this is his best album, but I was expecting something more. His lyrics are subject matter aren’t really THAT different
→ More replies (1)1
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 10 '19
REMINDER: Review thread guidelines:
Parent comments in review threads must be over 140 characters.
Comments that solely name the score or describe the clothing the reviewer is wearing are not allowed
Meta comments solely about how the subreddit will react to the review are also not allowed.
Comments that only compare the review to other scores by the publication or by other publications are not allowed.
If this is a Fantano review, visit r/fantanoforever for all low-effort comments
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
25
Jan 10 '19
This is about how I would rank it, maybe a 7.5.
Solid album just to toss on and bump while you work out or walk to work or whatever.
My one pointed I wanted to make: I like the album, but did anyone else think “letter to my momma” was atrocious? I’m a big 21 fan and I liked the album but damn that shit sucked. In the ranks of hip-hip maternal odes it has to be among the worst. I get that it’s heartfelt but it’s excruciatingly simple and boring, his flow is super basic, and the beat isn’t great either. Just a real weak spot on an otherwise consistent project, it gets an instant skip from me every time and I even sit through “a&t” and “1.5”, a song featuring the most unnecessary Offset verse of all time. Anyway, just wanted to point this out. Otherwise, like I said I’m a big fan of 21 and this album definitely delivered for the most part.
45
u/Luturtle Jan 10 '19
I think it just depends on what you want out of savage. Letter 2 my momma is beautiful in my opinion, it’s got a great vibe and it comes across really genuine, which I was not expecting. If you’re only listening to savage for bangers though I get how it can be underwhelming.
3
Jan 10 '19
It’s not that I only listen to bangers from him, I like all his music, but that song just didn’t hit for me. Different strokes I guess
1
28
Jan 10 '19
Didn’t get the hype thought it was pretty okay, 21 savage just has a really lazy flow that doesn’t do much. 6/10 for me honestly.
People were hyping this a lot but it’s honestly pretty forgettable.
There’s just better laid back lazy flows imo like Isaiah rashad’s etc.
139
31
u/BonafideSupastar Jan 10 '19
Shit is decent. Same as most trap records: great, catchy, occasionally off-the-wall production with an MC who isn't exactly the most charismatic or invigorating, although his deadpan monotone does makes him stand out from the other trappers. And also, I remember hearing people say that 21 was more introspective than he has been before, and then I hear the record and his surface-level introspection is relegated to like 2 or 3 tracks. Disappointing.
Still probably one of the better trap records from 2018 though, which only goes to show how much trap has been spinning its wheels as of late.
6
u/OrdinaryM Jan 10 '19
Feel like people appreciated it as it had a very different sound compared to his previous albums. Something a lot of people probably didn't know 21 was capable of.
3
4
u/CAI3O0SE Jan 10 '19
Still bumping The Sun’s Tirade. You could compare but that’ll just make 21 Savage look even worse.
1
6
u/BlackMoresRoy Jan 10 '19
God i'm so fucking sick of the needle drop. I know so many pretentious twats that talk about how music is their life and their entire personalities are defined around Music. Yet if i've seen a needle drop video i notice they jump repeat the same copypasta of whatever opinion was.
9
1
u/older-wave Jan 11 '19
I haven't listened to a single song from this album, or any song by 21 savage for that matter. But this is a good ass album title and for that it's gotta be at least OK.
-1
Jan 10 '19
This my least favourite 21 project. The only track i keep going back to is Out For the Night pt2, and that’s mainly cuz the travis scott part is hard af
-1
u/Deadlift4chips Jan 10 '19
I trust Fantano tastes when it comes to genres I would never partake in. Hip hip....no. But it’s always interesting to see his opinions on new works
-8
u/Super_guccure Jan 10 '19
This review solidifies that white folks never know what’s going on in rap music. The things that appeal to the culture, which is the target audience, etc. gimme my downvotes
→ More replies (2)
4.0k
u/winner_gagnant Jan 10 '19
Fantano Hatin cause Savage don’t make Soufflé music. He realized mid-soufflé that he can’t whip béchamel sauce to 21 Savage. The niggas wrist couldn’t get the flick right, so he blamed it on Savage the slob.