r/hiphopheads • • Dec 21 '18

"6 Months Off Meds I Can Feel Me Again": In tweets about abandoning psychiatric medication for his art, Kanye West promotes a dangerous myth about creativity.

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/12/kanye-west-and-dangers-quitting-psychiatric-medication/578647/
8.0k Upvotes

799 comments sorted by

814

u/ThatParanoidPenguin Dec 21 '18

I wish this article was more comprehensive because it barely has anything to do with what Kanye has tweeted/talked about in the last year. That said, I think Kanye is trying to express something but loses himself in translation along the way. I think it’s valid to say that Kanye is speaking about his own experiences, but he has a huge platform and is just continuously misguided.

On his recent rant he tweeted “I love that we are destigmitizing mental health Gucciman and Quavo have a song called Bipolar this is so good for culture” but honestly is it really? The song is literally as basic as you can get in terms of using outdated stereotypes of bipolar disorder for metaphor. I’m not saying it can’t be done tastefully but Gucci Mane and Quavo maybe aren’t the people to do it.

Look, I’m not saying Kanye West needs to take his meds, that’s a dangerous way to dismiss anything someone with mental illness says. However, I think it’s ridiculous to think that Kanye West is some chief expert on mental health. I think people are allowed to criticize him for the ill-informed things he’s been saying but I don’t think this article does a good job of it.

13

u/Guckalienblue Dec 21 '18

Gucci’s book was a much better way to show bipolar than that song.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

I've been meaning to getting around to reading the Gucci biography for a while but didn't realize he's been diagnosed with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.

I feel like he's at least been able to display addiction pretty well in his post-jail output.

489

u/SmokeCocks . Dec 21 '18

I think Kanye is trying to express something but loses himself in translation along the way.

Pretty much Kanye.

218

u/TheBobaFatt Dec 21 '18

“Words get in the way of what i really wanna say”

67

u/SmokeCocks . Dec 21 '18

"You're not listening to what I'm trying to say."

9

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

"I just don't know how to express myself sometimes when I need to be properly different".

→ More replies (1)

123

u/Spartacus3321 Dec 21 '18

"Lost in translation with a whole fucking nation"

56

u/DerpinTurtle Dec 21 '18

I SWEAR TO GOD EVERYTHING HE DOES CAN BE DESCRIBED WITH ANY LYRIC IN THE PAST

41

u/screaminginfidels Dec 21 '18

Stuck a feather in his cap and called it macaroni

→ More replies (1)

25

u/coopstar777 Dec 21 '18

Pretty much this. If you want to know what Kanye really has to say, you have to look at his music. That's how he expresses himself. Anyone that just looks at a bunch of tweets and decides that's who he is doesn't actually care, they are only looking for rap drama

→ More replies (4)

6

u/huancossof Dec 21 '18

Must make rapping harder.

→ More replies (5)

241

u/CinnamonSwisher Dec 21 '18

That song has fuck all to do with actual bipolar disorder, and in fact the use of bipolar in that song ranges from classic Migos esque use of a word randomly and meaninglessly (“went bipolar on Chanel, went bipolar on the scale”), to colloquial use (“I fucked her and get her out my face that’s bipolar”), to stuff the could be borderline offensive depending on the person such as the constant equating of bipolar and crazy.

The fact that Kanye used that song as an example of progress or distigmifying shows how ignorant he is on the subject at wide. What I wish would be clarified in society is that just because you have a mental health issue doesn’t mean you’re the best person to be an advocate or help destigma. You can have a mental health problem and still be ignorant to the ins and outs of the entire mental health plane. That’s why people go to school specifically for it, a lot of times post grad.

I see it so much, especially on twitter where people wear their mental health problems like a badge of honor accomplishment. I’ve read so much ignorant shit that is preceded by “as someone with a mental health problem...” or something similar. I’m gonna stop cause this comment is already long and I could easily keep ranting but this is the kind of dangerous mindset Kanye clearly holds and it’s only made worse by his large platform.

38

u/MOTORCITYC0BRA . Dec 21 '18

Exactly I fuck with Gucci but who thought that shit was positive lmao

23

u/emsowns Dec 21 '18

Krizz Kaliko's Bipolar track came out years before and actually talked about more relevant shit imo. Not as popular a track but still relevant when talking about bringing mental health issues to light in hip hop.

21

u/WisejacKFr0st Dec 21 '18

Eyedea's Even Shadows Have Shadows is the best representation of mental illness in hip-hop in my opinion

→ More replies (5)

10

u/qedesha_ Dec 22 '18

A lot of Aesop Rock's work is about his mental health, especially The Impossible Kid (and Skelethon a little).

→ More replies (2)

86

u/COSMOOOO . Dec 21 '18

100% was offended by that shit bro. I have family members who're bipolar. Its like making a song called PTSD and relating your racks going up to humvees blowing up. You just dont do it.

84

u/therealestyeti Dec 21 '18

PTSD, call the plug, gettin racks (MONEY)

PTSD, got yo gurl on her back (IFUCKEDYOBITCH)

PTSD, when the doors go up (SKIRT)

PTSD, bitch I'm high as fuck (FADED)

85

u/Maxuranium Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18

PTSD, like a marine (YAH)

PTSD, I'm sipping lean (YAH)

PTSD, run up on the scene (BLAOW)

PTSD, coke'd up, charlie sheen (WOW)

→ More replies (7)

20

u/COSMOOOO . Dec 21 '18

Nevermind man im a hypocrite 21 says "PTSD like i got back from iraq " in asmr i thought it was great. Feel like i should delete my comment now.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/yeezusisachristian Dec 21 '18

He probably didn't even listen to the song

11

u/ohyosario Dec 21 '18

From my own experiences, I know that medication can overwhelm someone until they're robotic. Through time spent working on myself I've realized that overcoming / surviving / living with mental illness is half finding a clinical / medical solution, and the other half is building coping mechanisms, looking for joy and gratefulness, and sacrificing certain pleasures for overall stability.

69

u/EvadTB Dec 21 '18

agreed. I love Kanye, if he wants to drop his meds then that's his choice. however, it's really quite irresponsible of him to actively promote (or at the very least condone) not taking your prescribed medication. I know some Ye fans are pretty young, and i'd bet many of them have mental health issues as well. Ye has always had a problem with communication outside of music, I think he has positive intentions which get lost in translation and general ignorance. this doesn't excuse his behavior but I don't think it makes him a worse person. he has no malice in his heart, but the media really just wants to spin him as some kind of brainless delusional.

it's real disappointing to see the top minds of Reddit in this thread calling doctors and medical experts stupid because they disagree with Ye. for people who have never dealt with serious mental health issues, please know that medication for mental disorders should never make you feel "not yourself." if that's the case, you need to switch medication or talk to your doctor about stopping. it's never smart to just stop cold turkey for ANY prescription.

25

u/grilskd Dec 21 '18

please know that medication for mental disorders should never make you feel "not yourself."

I think that's naive. Mental health is in its infancy right now and the medications we've developed are for the most part far from perfect. Besides almost always having a slew of nasty side effects, these medicines can effect someone's brain in such a way that they lose aspects of their personality, or other characteristics which they consider a part of their identity. Usually however, the pros outweigh the cons.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/iceColdCool Dec 21 '18

Very well articulated and I agree 100%. As someone who deals with BPD, MDD and PTSD, I can absolutely say Kanye is severely misguided.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

The Atlantic's articles have always read to me like the author starts with a conclusion, and then pieces together fragmented and culturally relevant "evidence" to reach that conclusion and draw in as many readers as possible. It is backwards.

2

u/NeoBokononist Dec 21 '18

maybe kanye is just a manchild just like everyone else, except he has one very specific skill that people are so enamored with they'll give him a carte blanche platform for things he hasn't got a single fucking clue about.

i think people just need to realize that, other than hip hop production, kanye is just some random fucking dude who probably needs a lot of help he'll prob never get now that he's in the environment he's in.

3

u/RuffSamurai Dec 21 '18

If anyone in rap right now Is de stigmatizing mental health I would honestly have to say $uicideboy$ are doing it better than anyone.

→ More replies (2)

1.5k

u/DionysusThree Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18

It’s common to hear that psychiatric meds changed a persons way of thinking and feeling in a negative way, so I don’t think HIS personal choice is uncommon, and I don’t believe he is intentionally pushing a negative narrative.

106

u/mvc594250 Dec 21 '18

It isn't uncommon - that's the problem. Many people who are prescribed psychiatric medications do notice changes, sometimes these changes can include a perceived loss of creativity. However, going off their medication often makes them a danger to themselves or others. Why dont you understand that that is worse than just "having a different way if thinking?"

72

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Yeah the first treatment isn't always right and the solution rarely is to abandon medication all together.

It's a trial and error process for the most part and medication really isn't right for everybody but you can't know if you just feel bad effects from one treatment and go off your meds instead of adjusting w a doctor

28

u/mvc594250 Dec 21 '18

Exactly. I understand that dialing in the right medication can be difficult and that some prescriptions can make you feel like you've lost yourself. However, abandoning the process is a fast track back to the problems that forced you to find help in the first place.

→ More replies (23)

20

u/ConfessionsOverGin . Dec 21 '18

My problem with this title is that it refers to what Kanye said as a myth. It’s not a myth. At all. It’s a supremely common feeling. They know that, and they could’ve phrased the title along the lines of what you said: “is creativity worth the potential danger to oneself one can cause during a manic episode?” Of course the title is there for click bait, which I don’t vibe with. A feeling of being “foggy” is very common on antidepressants, and it’s kind of unfair to toss it up as a myth.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (27)

43

u/lamzydivey Dec 21 '18

Stephen Fry explored his decision not to medicate his bipolar disorder in a documentary called The Secret Life of the Manic Depressive. It was made over a decade ago, so not sure if he still stands by his decision but it really helped show how it’s not as clearcut a decision as it seems from the outside.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

Musician Adam Ant did something similar. It's important to not that he still works with a doctor.

Taken from his wikipedia-

"At 21 years of age, he was diagnosed as having bipolar disorder, and has spoken candidly about his experiences with the effects of the illness. In his 31 December 2010 interview for The Sun, Ant also discussed the side effects of medication for his bipolar condition: "In the past I've been a robot. It's been an out-of-body experience. Bipolar means up and down and that's me... Music has always been the best medication. I was on sodium valproate for seven years.... I couldn't get to sleep and I didn't make love for seven years. My hair fell out and I couldn't pick up a book as I couldn't concentrate. I didn't write a song or pick up a guitar in that time – and piled on the weight. I might as well have been dead. I work very closely with my GP and any decisions I make are made with him". During an interview with BBC Radio 6 Music, he declared that "mental health needs a great deal of attention. It's the final taboo and it needs to be faced and dealt with." Ant is involved in the Black Dog campaign, which promotes better understanding of mental illness."

21

u/Dragon_Fisting Dec 21 '18

On the other hand this is a well documented textbook case of going off mood stabilizers. Bipolar disorder is characterized by swings between mania and depression. Often, people will experience a period of mania after quitting, making it feel like you're more creative and happier than you were on meds. Then, the pendulum swings the other way and you're hit with crippling depression, eventually it gets bad enough that you resume medicating, rinse and repeat.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

As someone with Bipolar Disorder as well, this is INCREDIBLY negative and dangerous. He does not live with depression where some CBT can help manage the day, his brain is actively fighting against him on a regular basis. And will continue to until the day he is in the ground.

But anyway someone else has already pointed out that this isn't even what the article was actually saying.

17

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Yeah but you're supposed to take something different then lmao. You dont just stop taking them

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (39)

13

u/Back2november . Dec 21 '18

Sorry if this is an ignorant question, but are meds for depression etc always needed or can someone use them for 6 months/year quit, then be fine?

9

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

It's all about the person. I just do clinical therapy but I have some friends who can't function with their antidepressants and others who needed them initially for the therapy to be productive and have since stopped taking them or adjusted their dosage.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/LilSlurrreal Dec 21 '18

It entirely depends on the person. Ideally you want to be in therapy too, but good luck having the insurance that covers that

4

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Yeah when I was going to therapy it was 150 an hour but my church paid for it. So I got lucky.

3

u/chubbyurma Dec 22 '18

You have to have insurance to do therapy in America?

Can't you pay for each session or something? Or is it an absurd price without the insurance?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/zephyy Dec 21 '18

i've been clinically depressed for about 7 years now and if i don't have my meds, my mood is immediately worse and darker.

but people are different. some people are only depressed for a year and they're able to use therapy to change their way of thinking or as a form of catharsis while transitioning to a lower dose.

PSA: never quit SSRIs cold turkey, you'll get brain zaps.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

242

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Getting off meds was the best thing I could’ve done in my life. Actually got me motivated to do something with my life other than “yay I woke up today!”

212

u/VintageHamburger Dec 21 '18

yeah i hate articles like these so fucking much. mental illness is a spectrum and for many people going off meds can help more than the meds, and obviously it can be bad too.

103

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

fucking this. They act as if its black & white/clear cut. I've known people who have benefitted tremendously from the use of anti-depre. And others who it turned into fucking zombies (but didnt notice until further down the road), but felt as if they were alive again as soon as they were off

52

u/Sammlung Dec 21 '18

We aren’t talking about depression, we are talking about bipolar disorder. If a patient actually has bipolar disorder, it isn’t something you fuck around with. It’s very treatable but if left untreated it only gets worse.

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (13)

24

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Did you read the article though?

Simon Kyaga, a researcher at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, Sweden, echoed Muskin’s view of medication’s potential upsides for artists. “By reducing the risk for things like depression, medications may in fact increase the likelihood of being creative,” he says. He points to a 1979 study that found that lithium was a creative boon to people with West’s diagnosis. Any treatment that makes day-to-day life more livable and survivable for artists is good for their art, he reasons.

In 2012, Kyaga led a study of more than a million Swedes to investigate the connection between mental illness and creativity. His team found that creative people are more likely to have a psychiatric diagnosis of some sort, which means that the people treating them need to be sensitive to how treatment may interact with patients’ artistic processes. If treatment is mismanaged or medication isn’t prescribed appropriately, it can indeed cause problems for creativity. “I always stress the necessity to tailor treatment from an individual perspective,” he says. “This may sometimes mean adjusting the dose of medication or considering less well researched types of psychotherapy.”

Not all people with mood disorders need to or should be medicated, according to Muskin.

It's a lot easier to say it sucks when you don't read it and act like it says that a specific treatment with a specific medication plan is right for everybody, but that's not what it says.

Kanye isn't even doing clinical therapy. He's explicitly said he's using Twitter as his therapist. Do you really think this is the best treatment for him?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

85

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Sounds like the shit you were taking wasn’t helping in the first place. SSri’s legit helped my mental for the time I was on em

17

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

I tried so many and they all kinda did the same. I feel way more observant and clear minded and aware now

→ More replies (6)

6

u/LPNinja Dec 22 '18

It’s really interesting to see how everyone reacts differently tbh

When I tried SSRI‘s they gave me major panic attacks that went on for almost 2 hours and I broke down, I didn‘t feel like myself anymore, as if I was constantly dissocitating and out of body. I was shaking like it was cold but it was the hottest summer ever a few months ago.

Eventually I stopped and took my old medication (tianeptine) + valdoxan again and while I still have problems because it‘s 5 pills a day and sometimes I miss doses and feel exhausted, it does make me feel more at peace, less anxious and less chronically depressed. I feel nothing or like "today is neutral“ most of the time.

In the end this stuff is never supposed to heal us, just to make it bearable so we‘re in a headspace that allows us to tackle our deep rooted issues and break our thoughtcycles

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

66

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

So Kanye and many other artists are 100% sure that they lose their creativity when on meds and some doctor is saying that they’re wrong? Stupid ass article

67

u/ValiantAbyss Dec 21 '18

Yeah I have to say I disagree with all the backlash. Kanye isn't telling people to stop taking their meds. He's saying that his meds had a negative effect on him. And it's recognized side effect of taking medications where people feel like "zombies."

Pharmacology is a literal science but the human body is crazy and there is no one cure-all for many diseases and mental health issues.

But Kanye has always been the person to hate on so let them reach.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Nobody is suggesting there is a cure all, but Kanye doesn't do therapy and instead goes on public rants he calls therapy testimonials. The only reason that you'd defend this is because it's what he's currently doing. Have you consider that what he's currently doing might not be what's best for him? That just because he's doing it, doesn't mean it's best for him?

I've done things that were the best for me. You probably have to.

Kanye could be right that meds aren't best for him. But it could also be this:

Stigma against treatment is another big thing that keeps many people out of doctors’ offices. According to Muskin, the idea that medication’s aim is to obscure your truest self or make you a zombie can also encourage people who are on medication to quit altogether instead of seeking needed adjustments to their prescriptions. To them, he says, it can be easy to mistake the need for change for proof that their fears about psychiatric medication were correct: “The term is illusory correlation—it’s when you believe something, so you filter information to substantiate your belief and exclude everything else. We’re all vulnerable to it. We want to believe what we want to believe, and it truly prevents people from getting help.”

Maybe a change in dosage or medication would have been better? Like you said, there's no cure-all for many diseases and mental health issues. The solution when something doesn't work rarely is swearing off medication all together. Especially when you're also refusing clinical therapy.

14

u/ValiantAbyss Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18

You say that Kanye doesn't see a therapist, but I thought Kim had confirmed a few months ago that he was seeing one/trying to get help. Wouldn't he NEED to see one just to get his meds? IIRC even to get something as "simple" as Adderall you need to see a psychiatrist. Maybe this mistake on my part but I could've sworn he was seeing a psychiatrist at some point this past year.

I don't think Kanye always does what is best for his mental health, but I also don't think the media does a good job of dealing with it either by the way they cover it. Obviously he has issues, some we know about because they have been disclosed and others we may not even know about. We only know he was on medication because he told us but we don't know what else he might be doing.

For some, getting treatment may have negative connotations but I don't think that was Kanye's point. I think for Kanye, having a healthy way to express his emotions and clear creative outlet is a way to help battle his mental illness. His meds sound like they were interfering with his ability to do this and I think his main point is that medication shouldnt be the first thing people try because you might hate how you feel on them.

Edit: I can only find tabloids about Kanye being in therapy. Some seem more legit than others but it's all hearsay.

31

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

He told Charlamagne that he doesn't go to therapy because the world is his therapist and tweeted a couple days ago that his Twitter is "therapy testimonies"

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

I know you're just responding to the headline and I shouldn't seriously engage you, but if Kanye is right, then a lot of people who are "100% sure" are wrong such as:

  • Philip Muskin, a Columbia University psychiatry professor and the secretary of the American Psychiatric Association

  • Esmé Weijun Wang, a novelist who has written about living with schizoaffective disorder

  • Simon Kyaga, a researcher at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, who did a study on the relationship between mental illness and creativity that studied over a million people

  • a 1979 study that found that lithium was a creative boon to people with West’s diagnosis

Also Kanye has contradicted himself. He said at the White House that he doesn't have bipolar disorder and he was misdiagnosed. Is that Kanye who's 100% right, or is the one who went on Twitter talking about having bipolar disorder again 100% right? Is the Kanye who said he doesn't need therapy because "the world is his therapist" 100% right?

Not every treatment is right for everybody. The article specifically goes into this, but no medication or clinical therapy is just not treating bipolar disorder.

This whole year, Kanye has simultaneously insisted that he's totally fine and doing great while at the same time suggesting that he's currently going through shit. In the Twitter rant, he talked about how he was going through some mental shit and how the year has been really tough for him. Which of these Kanye should we believe? Which is 100% sure?

38

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Your source for lithium being a “creative boon” is incredibly weak. Seriously? A sample size of 24, and the subjects self report on their perceived levels of creativity. 50% (12/24) said it increased their creativity, and 25% (6/24) said it decreased their creativity. Are you sure you know what the word “boon” means?

7

u/Dopesick2099 Dec 22 '18

IKR? Like what even is u/TheRoyalGodfrey agenda here because he is bizarrely attached to the weak ass claims in this sus fucking article.

Dude either wrote the article, hates Kanye, or is that egomaniacal about not moving an inch away from his own first perspective.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

I was thinking the same thing. This is the only like I could find.

Seems a bit strange that the OP would be so dedicated to arguing with every detractor in such a meticulous way... almost like the OP was a coworker of the author and had a vested interest in how their work was perceived...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

Fair enough I'll concede on that, but if this clapback is supposed to prove that medication as a whole in any dosage negatively effects creativity for people with bipolar disorder, it doesn't.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/Axyend Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18

This whole year, Kanye has simultaneously insisted that he's totally fine and doing great while at the same time suggesting that he's currently going through shit. In the Twitter rant, he talked about how he was going through some mental shit and how the year has been really tough for him. Which of these Kanye should we believe? Which is 100% sure?

while i lean towards Ye contradicting himself, you do realise that it's totally possible that he has gone "through some mental shit" without that necessarily having bipolar disorder at the root of it? He says his breakdown in mental health was instead the result severe sleep deprivation that was initially misdiagnosed. that isn't impossible even if it sounds like bullshit to you.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Yeah but he explicitly alluded to having bipolar disorder three times in the Twitter rant

That’s why I say contradiction.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

4.4k

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 24 '18

How many here are on meds and still partying? Alcohol, weed, opiates everything non-medicinal (weed is gray area. I take 2 meds for Persistent Major Depressive Disorder, Bi-Polar type II, PTSD, but still smoke weed). Alcohol is the easiest way to prevent yourself from finding out how your meds are supposed to feel. Even a small amount can fuck up rhe chemistry hard. Other prescription drugs that you aren’t prescribed will numb the pain, obviously but won’t do you any favours when they wear off.

Meds for mental health... the best way I can sum it up, is that your mental health is a keyhole and being prescribed a certain medication is like being given a key to see if that will open the lock. Sometimes you get lucky and it opens right away, other times you need to keep trying keys. I had to go through some hellish moments because the keys didn’t work. I found ones that do and I’m still alive because they do. It doesn’t mean you’re broken or beyond help, it doesn’t mean the doc isn’t listening. It just means that there will be extra steps.

Also for you young ones if you’re reading. I have lived with depression for over 20 years (I’m 40) and while yes it’s hard. Yes I’ve tried to kill myself. Yes I’ve been tested with the worst life has to offer. It will get better if you work at it. It won’t always be tough. It won’t always be easy, but if you take care of yourself and know when you’re in a bad place, just remember you’re not alone, you’re not worthless, you’re not a piece of shit and its never too late to ask for help

Edit: man... I never expected this kind of response. Massive respect to all those who are grinding through some kind of pain. Each and every one of you are soldiers in a war with an invisible enemy.

Edit 2: For those who feel it’s too much, it’s too dark, there’s no hope; please just hold fast

Edit 3: never thought I’d get such a positive reaction. Thank you so much. I’m crying because I never thought my experience could help anyone.

Edit 4: it needs to be said. Keep your head up

980

u/WarHasSoManyFriends . Dec 21 '18

19 year old who has depression, thanks for your last paragraph. Trying to find all the positivity I can get.

254

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

it’s so hard. There’s no reasoning where it comes from and dealing with the boredom when you feel like you’re in the darkest place is the biggest struggle. Boredom has more than once fuelled a suicide attempt. Even when the thing that gives you meaning becomes meaningless. That’s the hardest thing. The sun will always rise lil bro

34

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 22 '18

If you are bored, go help those in need. There are multiple NGOs that can give you something to do. It brings you good karma and gets you out of bed too. Win win.

34

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

This so much. So so much. You don’t like people? Fine, volunteer wth an environmental group. Don’t care about that? Call the animal shelters. Don’t like animals? Help out st the community centre. Even getting out and walking around will help immensely

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

32

u/FufuGretzky Dec 21 '18

To be frank, depression is STRONG AF. I used to volunteer at camps/conferences helping out others around my age or even older, with life obstacles, mental health and what not. I don’t even take advice that I gave people I inspired. I try therapy, eating better, hanging out but it’s fucking tough and feels like you’re drowning. Whatever happens, I’m just glad I saved others, even if it isn’t myself

→ More replies (9)

9

u/YsiYsi Dec 22 '18

Im 22 a little older than you and even in the short time since i was 19 everything has started trending up. Every year choose something to get better at mentally is my big thing. Youre not asking for help but i know what youre feeling and someone on here told me the same shit when i was younger and it changed my life. This past year i worked on being present and really appreciating those long long days for what they are. Theyre long and theyre tough but at the end of the day you get to say you experienced it and you get to say you made it through and you get to say you are one day stronger. If you ever need someone to vent to youve got this random fucking stranger right here alright? Stay strong and dont miss a day of your meds if youre taking them. Much love.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Keep going. Push every day to the next one. You'll find that in the course of things there are more good days than bad days. Above all else just remember that you're more than you think you are.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/FREESTYLEkill3r Dec 21 '18

I’m 23 and have been struggling with it my whole life. Keep fighting man

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

95

u/jeremicci Dec 21 '18

Ty. I needed this.

Reading this helped me alot right now. I have a four day weekend, and will be spending Xmas eve and Xmas by myself without my daughters for the first time since they were born (9 years now).

I have a very similar mental health story as yourself, with depression, attempted suicide, and lots of self medicating.

People love and care about you man. I'm glad you and I have survived all we've been through. We just have to stay strong and persevere.

38

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

It’s so fucking hard man, the self medication is the hardest thing to cope with and figure out. Two years of really hard drinking was one drawn out suicide attempt...

I am not religious by any stretch but man if I am not praying for every young one out there who feel that suicide is the only answer. Especially knowing exactly what that feels like; standing on the edge looking into the darkness...

Today putting it into perspective. On the 18th I got a call from my doc—the biopsy/pathology results were in. Cancer free. Fuck if I’m letting some other shit try and kill me.

My man... I’m sorry you aren’t getting to see your kids. I’ve spent many a Christmas alone too. It’s not easy, but it doesn’t mean you’re worthless. It’s just nother thing to get through. Stay strong.

18

u/jeremicci Dec 21 '18

Ty.

I'm sorry if this is overstepping...

But on Xmas eve and Xmas I know I'm gonna be very depressed.

Would you mind if I messaged you If I'm feeling really down and thinking bad thoughts?

21

u/big_wener . Dec 22 '18

Yo man I know I'm not the OP, but if you want someone else to talk to as well hmu, my inbox is open

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (3)

33

u/Sir_Gunner . Dec 21 '18

Good tips man.

When you finally find the right meds its truly a blessing.

But def a lot of trial and error.

10

u/SteveMcWonder Dec 21 '18

I’m so glad you posted this. I needed to hear this but also most people don’t understand how hard it can be to find medication. I’ve been really avoiding a new psychiatrist because I’m tired of trying medication that doesn’t work, but I know I need to to get better.

But also I do know ye’s point because I WAS on lexapro and I know for a fact you don’t feel like yourself on that medication. You literally become like a robot, simply going through the motions, not happy or sad (or at least that’s how it was when I took it)

3

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

Oh truth. I hear you—some meds have notoriously low success rates. Too many chemical variables. Some just shouldn’t be on the market. Oh and going through a new meds every 4-6 months really takes a toll. I’m glad you’re still here!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/BakedSteak Dec 21 '18

I'm 22 and I've had depression for as long as I can remember. Your last paragraph hit me hard. Thank you

7

u/MrGanjaholic Dec 22 '18

I’m on bi-polar type 1 meds and I’ve figured out that being on psych meds is like being diabetic. You gotta take your fucking meds.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/LPNinja Dec 22 '18

I‘m 22 and have been dealing with a bunch of mentall illnesses (recurrent/major Depression with heavy depressive episodes, dysthemia, anxiety disorders, ADD, APD, impulse controll disorders and more) since 6 onwards (so for 16 years) and I can say following:

Even if I might stay disabled like this for the rest of my life, my medication and therapy made my life and character definitely better in the past 2 years. It‘s hard and there are times I want to die badly but it‘s finally not always terrible.

If someone as severe as me has their moments of peace and calm, I can guarantee you that you‘ll have your moments too and those moments are what we live for. Because they show that our pain is not constant, forever for 24/7 and I find that pretty comforting to know that pain and symptoms alike will pass and get more bearable especially with the right treatment.

Hang in there @ whoever reads this. I tried to off myself this year but I survived and I think you can survive this too, we‘re all in this together.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/iseeyourdata Dec 21 '18

Two things:

Alcohol is the easiest way to prevent yourself from finding out how your meds are supposed to feel.

I really appreciate that perspective and insight.

Yes I’ve tried to kill myself.

Can I ask how you tried? I don’t mean to be insensitive. Just genuinely curious around what you decided to do and why you chose that.

29

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

Not at all insensitive. I am loud and proud of my story. I am very open with my shit because maybe one day someone can learn how to live without as much of the trial and error i went through.

I have almost jumped from a 32nd floor balcony. I have taken opiates and alcohol. I have tried to drown myself (when the body doesn’t want to die, survival mode brought me back). Plus the two years of hard drinking and loads of other smaller impulses that probably would have just maimed me or crippled me or gave me irreparable brain damage.

I could have tried harder. I don’t live in the states so access to firearms is difficult—thank fuck

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Fr, I'm only 21 but i recently got out of the worst few years of my life thanks to some amazing people and really working on it and working on myself, "things get better" is completely platitudinal at this point but once it becomes true it's like a new day

4

u/aloha_mixed_nuts Dec 21 '18

Yes. Next time you find yourself struggling, like I have—at this point the peaks and valleys are expected. Whenever I have a good day i don’t despair if the next day is shit.—just remember those times it tried to take you and resist that shit like your life depends on it, because it does

6

u/Dopesick2099 Dec 21 '18

Lol I didn’t even read the article but what you just said speaks to a lot of people. We’re going to look back at this period in history and call it the age of narcotics or something crazy

I’ve struggled my whole life with just wanting to stay alive. I’ve given up on all the “supposed to be good for me drugs” like antidepressants and antipsychotics. I’m coming off a months long period of benzo abuse and I’ve had problems on and off with them for half a decade now. I’m having hypomania rn or I wouldn’t even be responding to you like this. I’m sure I’ll regret it in a couple of days on Christmas when I want to die again.

Drugs are like that old saying about capitalism “the worst system of government except for all the others” It sucks that they work just right for so few of us but it’s still the tool we keep using

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

18 with bipolar II. thanks for the kind words and advice.

4

u/HisNameWasBoner411 Dec 22 '18

its so hard dude. how do you find the effort to actually try instead of just partying and getting fucked up to cope?

i lost my girlfriend this week because i party to cope. i want to get fucking better and i dont fucking know how.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/LeroyToThe Dec 21 '18

Thank you for that dog, i spent 5 days in a psychiatric hold this summer and it was the worst days of my life. Shit sucks seeing your mom sad because she couldn’t help you. I stopped taking my meds (Zoloft) because I hated the way it made me feel, but the analogy that you used was perfect. I’m gonna try going back to see a therapist and try different meds. I hope things are getting better for you big homie, I’ll keep you in my thoughts ❤️

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

This is the best mental health post I've seen on reddit

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Everyone need to go listen to the Joe Rogan podcast where he interviews Tyson Fury, a current Heavyweight Champ that had a long bout of depression after winning the fight of his life and feeling empty. The Concious is a dangerous thing if you let it control your reality. Set Goals, Work out and make friends. Its easy to say but it works. If you live a life with out any purpose and are just lounging around playing videogames everyday it will all catch up to you.

2

u/Cantbenoyuppy Dec 22 '18

Thank you. I needed to read this today.

2

u/DiceGames Dec 22 '18

man "know when you're in a bad place" resonated. You have to acknowledge, ask for help (or at least communicate to someone) then accept incremental, daily improvement.

2

u/BarryMecockener Dec 22 '18

Found this at the right time. Thank you

2

u/LeftyMcField Dec 22 '18

Thank you for sharing your story. I don’t know what else to say but thank you

2

u/reverse_sharkattack Dec 22 '18

Wow, imo this is the least likely sub to see so many people who are actually openly in touch with their emotions. Thank you.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dragonflyzmaximize Dec 22 '18

Hey I really appreciate this comment. 27 and have deal with major depressive disorder for the better part of a decade now. Thanks for being an inspiration.

Also, I have to say I loved the sentence "It will get better if you work at it" because I think a lot of people tend to stop before "if you work at it." Yes, it fucking sucks. Dragging yourself out of bed to exercise, take a shower, hell even brush your teeth can be hard as hell in the throws of depression. But yeah, you have to work at it and not allow depression to become an excuse for not working on yourself, which I've defffinitely fallen into many times throughout my life. So thanks, I rarely see people add that clause and I think it's much, much needed.

Much love, hope you stay well and same to everyone else on here dealing with any sort of mental health issue. Or hell, even if you're just going through a tough time this holiday season or whatever, stay strong. Go do something you love. Watch a movie you love. Listen to some great music. Try to do something you enjoy. Knock something off your to do list. Anyway sorry I'm rambling now.

Cheers all, and happy holidays.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/cpt_abe . Dec 22 '18

tbh weed helps me WAY more than when i used to take antidepressants, not saying that's the best option for everyone, but it works for me

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (69)

237

u/zweza Dec 21 '18

I’m a bipolar II creative myself and I can see where Kanye is coming from. I had meds that would level me out but make me pretty much a zombie who couldn’t get aroused, meds that gave me stability and happiness but frequent panic attacks, meds that didn’t work at all, etc. It’s hard to find what works for you when each medication takes weeks to start working then an additional couple weeks to ween off of if they don’t work to start something new.

Eventually I decided that this is something I’m going to be stuck with for the rest of my life and that I needed to change how I live to eliminate as many triggers as possible and take conscious measures to soften the blow when things do switch up.

The difference is that I don’t think Kanye is taking those measures. He’s giving into his mania (which admittedly feels pretty good) instead of trying to function as a reliable member of society, which he can get away with because he’s rich and can do basically anything and won’t feel much of an impact unless he dies or goes to jail. Those of us with bills and tenuous financial situations don’t have that luxury.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

Great post.

50

u/thrustinfreely Dec 21 '18

Was the oval office meeting 6 months ago?

20

u/skrrtrr Dec 22 '18

pretty recent, more like 2 months at the most.

53

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Jesus the Kanye defense force is going all out in this thread

26

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

People are delusional. Mental disorder needs to be forefronted with council and meds.

24

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

The man isn't even doing therapy, the world isnt a therapist. Bipolar disorder isnt something to conquer on your own, its something that needs professional treatment to treat.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

If he was doing therapy I'd trust him a lot more.

his aversion to it is definitely a big red flag

16

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Seriously. I’d love to hear what they have to say if he god forbid committed suicide while in a depressed episode.

16

u/BABYSLUMPJESUS . Dec 21 '18

Just wait till the dysphoric manic episode hits, that's when I tried to kill myself.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

[deleted]

8

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Logic Vs Trend ma frand

44

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

It’s proving the point of the article. Mental Illness is one of the toughest things to treat in the world, and the treatment process is often trial and error. If his meds are giving him issues, the solution is not to just suddenly stop taking them. There was a reason he was taking them in the first place.

Now, he’s making it sound like some heroic creative choice to not treat your mental illness which is fucking stupid. He’s got a ton of influence and I wish that he acted like he knew that sometimes.

→ More replies (9)

47

u/LilSlurrreal Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18

As a musician who is also bipolar, I can confirm that it is NOT a myth that meds take the music from your veins and the rhythm out of the beat of your soul. Wish it weren't true but it is. Some of us have only one choice: feel the magic of being alive or be stable as a walking corpse. My brother is on meds, and has been for 10 years. It's also been exactly 10 years since I've seen my brother's infamous sense of humor, his smile, his laugh

Edit: for the deranged mentally healthy people in this thread suggesting we need to try dozens of medications to find the right one in addition to weekly therapy sessions: that's great for people like Kanye, who I admit does seem to persistently resist legit help and has all the means in the world . But not everyone has the luxury of 1) the heath insurance that enables that level of care and 2) the ability to risk completely fucking up your system with a new med and risk not being able to work while your brain goes back to 'normal' and 3) sometimes even after you somehow get through that process , you're still a corpse. So you don't even know if Kanye has reached this stage Tldr fuck you

→ More replies (42)

24

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

I was recently diagnosed Bipolar II and I make music. I get it... it is super tempting to stop taking my meds, especially this soon into it. Being manic feels like the 'real me' and feels like creativity is flowing (for example, I just made a 30 song album in 6 days), but the destructive decisions outweigh the positive aspects. Then, of course, the depression comes and I hate myself and all of the music I made anyway, so I'm going to keep taking my meds. I'm sure once I get somewhat stable I'll thank myself.

If anyone needs support there's a caring community over at the bipolar subreddit. Feel free to DM me if anyone wants to talk.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

What does being manic feel like to you? Because I’ve been diagnosed bp2 and have disagreed with the diagnosis from jump. I’m always a reserved low energy type person with just really bad anxiety. Family friend with a bp2 son also told me that doesn’t sound right at all. This was after 6 months with my psych and therapist that they came to this conclusion and keep giving me mood stabilizers that just make me wanna sleep and eat. So even less energy than I already have. I don’t get it. I’ve stopped seeing that psych but it’s annoying

→ More replies (3)

170

u/MyNamesE Dec 21 '18

The amount of people who absolutely have not read the article but felt like commenting is super annoying bc there's actually a conversation to be had here with regards to different treatment methods, harnessing creativity when mentally ill vs actually acting on that creativity etc.

64

u/fl1po Dec 21 '18

Let me remind you, we're on /r/hhh.

57

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Let me remind you, we’re on hhh Reddit

FTFY

25

u/harsh389 Dec 21 '18

Let me remind you, we’re on the internet

FTFY

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Want to know what happened to Ian gallager from shameless once he stopped taking his meds?

He became gay Jesus and then went to prison.

14

u/Talk-O-Boy Dec 21 '18

And that’s the GOOD ending to not taking meds. Look what happened to Monica...

→ More replies (1)

11

u/first_on_the_list Dec 21 '18

Who is this person to say that Kanye is pushing a myth? You can't tell him that he doesn't feel better than he did on meds. If that's what he feels, that's what he feels.

8

u/mfathrowawaya . Dec 21 '18

It's basically a big argument of data vs anecdote. People will stand on the side of scientific research and ignore any and all anecdotes. This is dangerous because of a.) People aren't numbers and shouldn't be treated like numbers and b.) Most people regurgitating science don't even understand it.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Yeah but there’s plenty of anecdotes that say the opposite

So you can’t just rely on anecdotes

Plus the correlation illusion mentioned in the piece is big. You can agree with someone’s anecdote that their medicine made them feel like shit, but there’s far more options than abandoning medication all together and you don’t know if other stuff doesn’t work for you unless you try it.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

You also shouldnt ignore scientific data just because of anecdotal evidence.

mental health issues are unique to the individual and should be treated as such; having said that, encouraging people to go off their meds in the name of creativity is very dangerous. most people do not have the stability and safety nets that a star like kanye has. a normal person stopping their medication out of nowhere could easily do extreme damage to their living situation in a very short amount of time.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/SocialJusticeYamcha Dec 21 '18

data is just a collection of anecdotes

34

u/fe1ixcu1pa Dec 21 '18

Not here to comment about creativity because I'm not in a creative industry and never will be. However, I do live with bipolar disorder and have dealt with it, luckily quite effectively, for quite some time. What I am here to say/comment on is that yes, Kanye is a person at the end of the day. However, Kanye is not a "normal person like you and me" in the aspect that he does not have normal person issues, problems, lifestyles like you and I. Kanye would never suffer the consequences of quitting meds and going into mania and ruining damn near every aspect of his life, every relationship, losing his livelihood, or his family. If Kanye quit his job (making music) guess what? He still has money to take meds when he wants to again. Not everyone is so lucky. Kanye says out of control shit? He has the entire Kardashian family behind him, money put away in trusts/accounts he can't touch, etc. A normal person, you and me, ol Joe Blow bipolar quits our meds - we lose our jobs, we alienate loved ones, we lose health insurance, we spiral into nothingness.

So while it's easy for Kanye to think that mental illness is a universal problem that can happen to him so it can happen to anyone - he needs to put his money where his mouth is, not where his feet are and speak responsibly to his fan base at large. It's simply irresponsible for him to tout being unmedicated works for him when he doesn't and couldn't have as much to lose as an average person.

3

u/TheGiediPrime . Dec 22 '18

This. He's forgetting he's in a very privileged position and that he's seen as a role model for a lot of people who risk ending up jobless and homeless because of their untreated mental disorders.

106

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 22 '18

From Hannah Gadsby’s Nanette:

Now, in the show, I'd spoken about taking antidepressant medication, and he had an opinion on that. Now, interestingly, I'd also spoken about how unhelpful unsolicited advice is in a... mental health plan, but he mustn't have heard that bit.

He came up to me after the show to give me his opinion. He said, "You shouldn't take medication because you're an artist. It's important that you feel." He said, "If Vincent van Gogh had have taken medication, we wouldn't have the sunflowers."

I never, ever, ever thought that my art history degree would ever come in handy. But, oh, my lord. I tore that man a college debt-sized new arsehole. I said, "Good opinion, mate. Except that he did medicate. A lot. He self-medicated a lot. He drank a lot. He even nibbled on his own paints. Problem.

And also, you know what else? He didn't just paint sunflowers, he did quite a few portraits of psychiatrists. Not even random ones. Psychiatrists who were treating him. And medicating him.

And there's one particular portrait of one particular psychiatrist, and he's holding a flower, and it isn't a sunflower. It’s a foxglove. And that foxglove forms part of a medication that Van Gogh... took for epilepsy. And that derivative of the foxglove plant medi-fucking-cation... "

I must have skipped a dose that day 'cause I was feeling it. "The derivative of the foxglove, if you overdose it a bit, you know what happens? You can experience the color yellow a little too intensely. So perhaps... we have the sunflowers precisely because... Van Gogh medicated.

What do you honestly think, mate?" I said. "That creativity means you must suffer? That is the burden of creativity? Just so you can enjoy it? Fuck you, mate. If you like sunflowers so much, buy a bunch and jerk off into a geranium.”

8

u/TheInfinityGauntlet Dec 21 '18

I can't believe here of all places I'm seeing Nanette mentioned, fucking amazing

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/Cressio Dec 21 '18

Or maybe those meds are extremely well documented to give the exact side effects he’s outlined and actually feels the way he claims he does getting off of them

15

u/yeezusbro Dec 21 '18

Reminds me of that show Homeland where Carrie always is better at her job off her meds but goes all manic

36

u/mfathrowawaya . Dec 21 '18

Most of us people with mental health issues go off meds once or more in our journey because we think the meds are hindering us or causing us not to feel alive.

I get that he has a large audience and influences people but it's his mental health.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/NickDerpkins . Dec 21 '18

Psychoactive drugs for mental problems are good and bad. They don’t always work for everyone. I hope Kanye is placing his true sanity above his creativity and actually doing well

5

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Dumb article. If he chooses to stop using psych meds because they impair him, that’s his choice.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

Nice, a white woman explaining how a black man is incorrect about his own feelings and correcting the record.

Love to see it. Fucking debased garbage.

14

u/silmaril12 Dec 21 '18

Didn't Kanye tell Trump that he was misdiagnosed and that he wasn't actually bipolar ? Now that he's beefing with Drake he wants to start saying he's bipolar again ? Yeah I think Kanye is doing a disservice to everyone trying to actually destigmatize mental health

11

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

The article talks about how treatment and the necessity of it differs per person and is difficult to get right, but Kanye is wrong for saying he feels better off his medication.

He's not promoting anything but if he was you have to be a special kind of retard to take medical advice from Kanye West.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OscarElite . Dec 22 '18

I don't hear people mention actual psychotherapy much in this thread, but It's more effective then meds and the fact that Kanye is actively pursuing something (pretty sure he does therapy) doesn't really get acknowledged. I'm just trying to say meds aren't the only solution, and it's not like Kanye has totally bad coping mechanisms. there's more to it.

3

u/Mad1ibben Dec 22 '18

Psychiatric meds hit so many people in so, so many ways. Kanye didnt handle his shit right, but calling his reasoning a "myth" is almost as ignorant as his actions. That shit isnt an exact science, what helps one person can straight sap the life out of another. That's why it's so important to pair meds with counseling of some sort, so you have a professional to help ID if the prescription is doing what it should. Attacking every report of a bad reaction to meds as paranoia is every fucking bit as harmful as what Ye was saying. We arent talking vaccinations here, there is relatively little proven understanding of the human brain and any treatment is going to be hit and miss with their own problems, painting it as just easy as popping a pill to fix yourself and that negative reactions a myth is fucking insane. Thats straight up propaganda shit.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

This article promotes a dangerous myth that pharmaceuticals are always the most safe and effective way to manage mental issues.

5

u/Calicrisp805 Dec 22 '18

From someone who struggled for a long time I stopped taking meds cold turkey. Started drinking lots of water, eating healthy and lightly working out. I feel better now than I ever had on meds. I've lost 80 lbs. Don't live to eat, eat to live. A lot of people don't do any of these things and hope a pill is going to solve all of their problems. This obviously won't work for everyone but I feel way better.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

you posted this article that you knew would be controversial to go ahead and start arguments with anyone who disagrees.

9

u/Scorch8482 Dec 21 '18

Fuck this headline. If you dont want to numb yourself on medication then you have the right to do that. Meds arent always the best option and fuck anyone who says otherwise. Good for Ye for finding inner happiness without the need of medication. Thats the ulttimate goal twking meds, isnt it?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Lol. I ain't creating shit off my antidepressants. I probably won't even leave my bed. Take Yo Meds!

5

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

I'll keep it real the problem with Kanye isn't that he's off his meds. It's that he's got some really shitty opinions AND he's off his meds. I have a few friends who have stopped taking their meds and they get erratic or lethargic but they still have the same opinions and are decent people at heart.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Kanye shouldnt censor what is true for him just to protect everyone else.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

To be totally honest, Kanye doesn't deserve to have his statements discussed in this much depth. I couldn't care less what this goof says or does anymore.

2

u/WillsBlackWilly Dec 21 '18

They say this is put is awful. I don’t think Kanye is promoting anything, I think he believes that shit. This is the type of shit that people with Bi-Polar disorder say and do all the time. It would be understandable to say “Kanye West promotes dangerous myth about creativity” if Kanye wasn’t a person with bi polar disorder. But he like clearly is and it just seems disingenuous.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

kanyes always gonna be demonized until 3 years after he does something when everyone says "oooh sorry we didn't mean it bank then" rinse and repeat

2

u/bx002 Dec 21 '18

I don't necessarily agree with the premise of this article. Within the last three years I have been on and off anti-depressants, and then was misdiagnosed bipolar type 2, then bipolar 1, than just depression and anxiety again.

During the whole last year I was taken off anti-depressants and put onto a bipolar med called Lamictal that's job is to literally slow down parts of your brain. It completely changed how I felt about myself, and as a creative (I'm a producer as well), it made it EXTREMELY difficult to create, and it really did feel like a core part of me was gone. I felt sluggish and slow, and it didn't help that they prescribed me a large dose.

It took 6 months to a year afterword to feel normal again. So I really do feel where Kanye is coming from, and I don't think he is saying this from any place other than his own personal journey. Now at the end of it all I am back on my anti-depressents that I started on, and am feeling great. This may be a different case since I may or may not actually have bipolar disorder (It was never fully resolved). But just thought I'd throw in my two cents. Am interested to hear opinions from other creatives who have been on these types of meds.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

He’s not pushing any myths. There are clear links between mania in bipolarity and creativity. Mood stabilizers dull the hell out of alot of people and there is a decent number of people who have had to choose their passion or their mental health.

2

u/latrishahope Dec 22 '18

I am bi polar and I tend to have a problem with going off my meds or skipping a day or two because I feel I don’t need them. Or I feel my problems are everyone else’s fault and I’ve been misdiagnosed. Then after the second day I’m high as a kite for hours, look and feel like I’m on drugs then crash into a depression that will last for days and I get suicidal. My doctors always scorn me and my last one was very blunt and told me if I go past two days of not taking lamectil (because I’m on 300 mg) it could be fatal. So I’m on it but the last two weeks I missed a day here and there and had my mood swings thoughts of suicide and all. The holidays are especially hard on those with mental illness. I’m not even enjoying them right now because I can’t handle stress. I relate to Kanye when you do art for living it can be scary relying on meds. I haven’t touched my piano for over two years, but I realize that’s because life changes along with my desires and what I want to do with my life. I’d rather be on meds and be around for my family and my own life than be a hot suicidal mess who’s crying and manic all the time.

6

u/ToTheNintieth Dec 21 '18

Man, I wish people weren't so reluctant to call out Kanye on his bullshit.

4

u/StanVanGundysStache Dec 21 '18

with all due respect, ya'll aint the creative genius 'Ye is.

4

u/SoundSalad Dec 22 '18

It's not a myth that some meds can dampen your creativity. This is true.

Oh and over 120,000 people die each year from adverse reactions to properly prescribed prescription drugs that were taken in accordance with a doctor's order, making it the 4th leading cause of death in the US, tied with strokes.

So there is a good reason to not take prescription drugs.

https://ethics.harvard.edu/blog/new-prescription-drugs-major-health-risk-few-offsetting-advantages

5

u/tarheel43 Dec 22 '18

In the US doctors are so quick to prescribe medication without getting to the root cause of the illness, and patients are quick to accept the temporary fix so they can avoid the hard work of fixing the causal behavior

4

u/SoundSalad Dec 22 '18

Yep... Most doctor's will prescribe you medicine before telling you to exercise and eat healthy.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/hysro . Dec 21 '18

It isnt a myth at all.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

Now, in apparently quitting his psychiatric medication for the sake of his creativity, West is promoting one of mental health’s most persistent and dangerous myths: that suffering is necessary for great art.

I wish this wasn't the strongest emphasis in the article, because it is really not the point. Medication changes you, sometimes in ways you may not like. You have to choose. Personally, I only very rarely take my ADHD medication because I find that it stunts my creativity, as much as it helps me get "stuff" done. And I can't live like that. Not because I want to suffer, but because I prefer how my brain functions without meds.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

Mushrooms , dmt, and lsd made me realize depression and anxiety meds are meant to mask symptoms while doing nothing to really help, much like pushing all your emotions deep down so you don’t have to deal with it. Fuck. That. Shit.

6

u/Moron_on_Oxy- Dec 21 '18

This man is a clown.

6

u/SharpyTarpy Dec 21 '18

This article is bad, this thread is bad, and OP’s comments are bad. Next

5

u/Nutriyents . Dec 21 '18

This article is garbage.

4

u/Dragonxoy . Dec 21 '18

Head ass article, head ass OP, Kanye is an idiot but his choice can neither be judged as right or wrong

3

u/seanrose123 Dec 21 '18

This some dumb shit.

4

u/Dopesick2099 Dec 22 '18

This some redcup all over the lawn shit

2

u/_reefermadness Dec 21 '18

2018 showed us that while creative- Kanye West isn’t the most intelligent guy.

2

u/TheFlameRemains . Dec 21 '18

It's nearly impossible to view Kanye as a positive promoter of mental health when he said that Bipolar song was rap respecting mental illness.

1

u/Teleports-Behind-U Dec 21 '18

I feel like a lot artists have some form of mental illness. A huge part of creativity is being unique. Having a mental issue makes someone see the world differently. It’s definitely not healthy, but it’s responsible for some of our greatest art.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18

As someone with a mental disorder who also creates for a career I know that I have a much stronger creative drive that is stifled somewhat by meds.

The part of my brain that pushes me to create the best prices of work I can also pushes me to follow compulsions, believe anxious thoughts and feel as a whole worse than when I am using meds. So it’s a bit of a trade off for my best mental stability or more creative drive.

I have no doubt that Kanye’s OCD, adhd or bipolar disorder has a high influence in his decisions to work on his craft non stop for his whole life, and to deny that he is probably more creative when he is off his lexapro lacks an understanding of how the mental conditions affecting him work. I think that it is very likely that his OCD literally forces him to create his most impressive work

1

u/ynotrhyme Dec 21 '18

TLDR anyone?

If it's Kanye saying the meds were curbing his creativity and stunting his personality etc I can confirm and totally agree as I have went through this. You feel like a fucking zombie on those pills but I understand certain simply just need them to function.

1

u/stillestwaters Dec 21 '18

Idk I think there’s a pretty standard and dangerous myth about being high or drunk all the time for creativity’s sake.

I’m not saying Ye shouldn’t be on his pills, he’s going wild, this whole thing points to a problem in diagnosing, prescribing meds, and more.

Doesn’t the idea of someone not taking their prescribed meds and feeling like themselves speak to a bigger problem? I’ve seen people’s personalities and such change 100% just from a doctors prescription that only added different problems on top of placating one. It’s like complete sedation and it’s scary as hell, one of the reasons I don’t ever see myself getting checked out for any anxieties or nervous tendencies. I’d rather have a tough time socializing and going out and such than not be myself.

I’m rambling but I think it’s easy to say Ye is being a bad role model here but a bigger problem this whole thing shows is a issue with prescriptions.

1

u/i4gotmyusrname Dec 22 '18

This reminds me of the time Devin Townsend took himself off of his medication to record the Strapping Young Lad album "Alien"

Even if the heavier side of music isn't your thing the making of that particular album is well documented and worth delving into for anyone interested in such subject matter.

The place where creativity meets wellbeing is always interesting to me.

1

u/Indetermination Dec 22 '18

I was on anti depressants for a long time, thinking I was having panic attacks and doctors thinking I had an anxiety problem. It turned out that I was having partial seizures and that I'm epileptic, now I'm on medication for that and everything has changed. When medication doesn't work, but you know something is wrong, it might just be the wrong meds. I love Mr West but I don't think he should give people this kind of advice, and also I don't want him to hurt himself.

1

u/notfirecrow Dec 22 '18

Y'all don't know shit about bipolar meds. They basically keep you one notch above depressive.

1

u/kkstoimenov Dec 22 '18

Honestly, don't speak on this unless you have taken medicine or do right now. It has upsides and downsides. Antipsychotics definitely make your emotions numbed and less intense, and made me less creative.

1

u/scarfox1 Dec 22 '18

Eh he said on mbdtf he was off to

1

u/LasagnaHentai Dec 22 '18

Not trying to detract from the important issue but I kinda understand Kanye in a way. I myself don’t know whether I feel better on or off my meds, I feel shitty both ways just a different kind of shitty.

1

u/BronzeCauseBadTeams Dec 22 '18

It's impressive that there are so many redditors who make music and actually have albums. Like damn.

1

u/sarxna Dec 22 '18

I think the most important point that has come out of all of the discussion that Kanye has caused is that people react to medication differently, and there is no right way to treat mental illness for everyone.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18

As long as he and his family feel he is fine that way. Nobody is gonna not take meds because Kanye says he makes better music off them

1

u/narwhalninja11 Dec 22 '18

An important thing people need to remember about this is that kanye is in a profession where bot taking his meds may make him more sucessful. In a job that relies so much on creativity, being off his meds might help him achieve that.

However, regular people are not musicians and aren't kanye west. Normal people need meds to live their lives and support themselves while being mentally healthy.

1

u/MeenaarDiemenZuid . Dec 22 '18

What is the article saying? I legit don't understand it. The quote seems positive about not using medicine. But how does that equal "that suffering is necessary for great art"? It's so fucking far fetched. Not using medicine = great suffering; is just not true. Completely taking out of context..

It also refers to an experience expert of schizoaffective disorder, which simply just isn't the case of kanye west.. It just seems to be trying to sound credible that a Novelist gave an opinion about their narrative.

This article just seems to promote the lack of med use (to solve mental problems). which obvious is a lesser problem than the opioid epidemic than it's actually going on in the USA.

1

u/OrphanDevour Dec 22 '18

I can see how some meds might make a person feel such a way, but I'm happy being "toned down" or whatever so long as I'm not bouncing off the fucking walls insane

1

u/heyoctavio Dec 22 '18

to be fairrrrrrrrr, i did not feel myself on antidepressants. and after stopping them for a few years, getting sever anxiety and depression earlier this year, my psychiatrist recommended me the smallest dosage possible of antidepressant because it helps w anxiety. it was mostly for the anxiety because she knows i have an addictive and abusive personality with drugs. but also the smallest amount possible because she understands that my work revolves around creativity. i didnt even have to explain how i felt no emotions when i took antidepressants in high school. she just knew

this isnt just like a thing he's saying that is super negative. i understand not everyone is the same. but he's not making a blanket statement about everyone that takes medications. just himself. and i myself totally resonate with that. because i would rather be crazy than numb just to fit in. i feel like the lowest lows are sometimes where im comfortable. i know them to well. but the lowest lows also give way to the highest highs. and those are only good in the moment. afterward they're scary. because it means the lows are inevitable and the highs wont last. but this is where i find my voice and my creativity. if everything is averaged out, i would not be me. my art would be suppressed. because its not who i am. even if it leads to my untimely demise. so be it.

i wouldnt have it any other way.

tl;dr: he is speaking for himself. not everyone on medication. and i personally feel the same way.

1

u/Cheapys_Pizza Dec 22 '18

He needs to get a better combination of meds, and eventually I think that will happen.

I guess you could argue he's influencing others, but people will always be going off their meds. The wrong meds can make you a zombie and it is a lot of trial and error. Doctors aren't perfect and all knowing.

We need to continue spreading the awareness of mental health issues, and support those in need.

1

u/TheBlerd1993 Dec 22 '18

Navy veteran checking in, have ptsd from being shot in Norfolk where I was stationed of all places by gang members during an imitation. They luckily just got my headrest and passenger door. It’s scary and hard and sometimes you need sometime to stabilize yourself so your not paranoid all the time. It’s can definetly dull the senses but it’s not something you should let ruin your creativity. Get the help you need.

1

u/PM_ME_XANAX Dec 22 '18

I'm an up and coming UK producer who had to go on sertraline start of this year and I'm doing just fine

1

u/wolfgang7261 Dec 22 '18

if its true for him its true for him

1

u/skyesdow Dec 22 '18 edited Dec 22 '18

Mental health meds can seriously fuck you up. And it takes MONTHS to know if that one specific solution is even working for you. And when it doesn't it again takes months before you can try a different one.

1

u/Ihateesports . Dec 22 '18

I love Ye. I really like him being contrarian because I feel like our society needs it, I think he's the greatest in hip-hop and I think he's a top 5 musician to date. But that being said this shit is not helping anyone, I have people in my life with bipolar and with borderline. They're not good people off meds.

1

u/SC3x3 Dec 22 '18

I disagree with Philip Muskin... some of the best creativity comes from struggle. He’s an ass and doesn’t even know it

1

u/BaelorsBalls Dec 22 '18

It’s all about what you make your reality. I spent years playing video games, partying, drinking smoking weed and sleeping. After going through a tough breakup(I didn’t try) , on a family vacation I got into an argument with my brother about the smallest thing, keeping my phone screen on at night cause I was watching Netflix. I just broke, I flipped shit, angry, then sad all at once and spent the next 30 min contemplating jumping out of the window of our hotel room. As I was at the window my mom came out and said “you’re scaring me please go to bed”. After that I went to bed. I’ve been doing great since. I go to therapy, go to the gym, and am about to graduate college. It’s all about people. People make you happy and sad, but people are what save you. Having people in your life, love, and interaction, is worth living for.

1

u/TheSuboxoneSusies Dec 22 '18

Cant say I disagree with him. I don’t think meds are a real long term solution. But short term I definitely needed to get grounded to reality at times. Nutrition/diet/exercise, sleep, meditation/spirituality, all the boring things are part of the real solution

(and sobriety for me)

Have you came across the Icarus Project? Don’t know how the site is today, but the story of Icarus is a good fit.

1

u/FIVE_DARRA_NO_HARRA . Dec 22 '18

Here’s Kanye talking about feeling again even though he’ll admit he uses serotonin antagonists like 2CB-FLY on SSRIs