r/hiphopheads • u/ltrob . • Dec 08 '18
XXXTENTACION - SKINS ALBUM REVIEW (Fantano)
https://youtu.be/A38GRCfbJkw996
Dec 08 '18
Not exactly related but as far as posthumous albums go, as much as I want to hear more Mac miller I hope the people in control of his music don’t release a bunch of unfinished songs as an album. I think swimming was a really great culmination of him as an artist even if it shouldn’t have been his last album.
416
u/sunburntredneck Dec 08 '18
Swimming is a perfect last album. I'd be fine with a demo tape or something of the sort but not another album. Peep and X both didn't have that perfect, complete, victorious-feeling last album. X still has another posthumous "album" to come so maybe it's better
242
Dec 08 '18
absolutely agree. Swimming is perfect.
not an ounce of filler.
→ More replies (1)37
u/aRawPancake Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
I personally felt that there were just a couple filler songs as with most of Macs albums. Not nearly as bloated as some other rappers but something he struggled with a bit as well
Edit: I do appreciate that all responses to this are different songs. It just goes to show how universally liked he was 😊
19
u/Elhak . Dec 09 '18
I’m curious, what would you cut? Nothing comes to my mind right away
→ More replies (11)20
Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Yes it’s called bad vibes forever which was in process since like 2016. Apparently the best songs are suppose to be on that album. And it’s incomplete and it was suppose to have more underground features in it. Underground at the time, denzel, suicide boyz, doja cat etc, there was a tracklist
Honestly if they want to make a quality x album without putting trash out just remaster his angry soundcloud shit.
Rip roach, take a step back, sippin tea in yo hood, i am, caution, gnarly bastard.
Boom good album right there with sounds that work well together
→ More replies (2)31
Dec 08 '18
I don't really want anything else to be released unless it is 100% finished by Mac, and even then. SWIMMING is too perfect.
15
u/magkruppe . Dec 09 '18
Well I remember Syd and others mentioning he had an album called Circles that was pretty much finished. Hoping we get to hear that
→ More replies (1)7
u/DEFINITELYnotA_PEDO Dec 09 '18
Yeah I agree, I thought it was rumored he had another album completely finished, if that's the case, release it. But if it was even 1% not finished by Mac I'm not interested
→ More replies (2)24
99
Dec 08 '18
I think we can have confidence in the Mac Miller estate. Everything thus far has been handled with decency and respect.
He deserves that.
16
u/chiefsfan_713_08 Dec 08 '18
I wouldn't mind. It's not like they'll ever be able to finish them now so it's as good as they'll get ya know? I'd rather have half finished songs than nothing at all I guess
12
u/Dr_Drank Dec 09 '18
I can absolutely live with a release of loose singles, but nothing labeled as an album by Mac. I hate that we cant watch him progress even further
19
u/King-Salamander Dec 09 '18
Earlier in the morning on the day he died, I was at work and was talking to a co-worker about how one of the most exciting things, for me, about growing older is seeing how my favorite artists progress and evolve. I specifically talked about Mac, saying that he had hands down the most amazing trajectory of any artist I follow, and how I couldn't wait to hear what 45-year old Mac was putting out after reflecting back on his life and career. I mean we went from Kids to Swimming in less than a decade, I can't even imagine what he would've been putting out ten or twenty years from now. I'm still feeling pretty heartbroken that he's gone, but I really do feel like Swimming was the perfect last album. It's nothing but pure catharsis, start to finish.
That being said, I would love if his parents released some of his unfinished work, but I don't want it to happen unless they feel it's completely appropriate.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Neander7hal Dec 08 '18
It’s really interesting to be in this thread and see a bunch of comments like this. Like y’all must not remember (or be aware of) what they did to Pac after he died. We’re gonna be seeing posthumous Mac and XXX albums and features for at least another couple years.
28
u/SheenEstevezzz Tell em play Metro Boomin at my Funeral Dec 08 '18
Feel like Macs label/family situation is better than pacs and xxxs so i have more faith
11
u/CAI3O0SE Dec 08 '18
He apparently had plenty of finished albums that he just hadn’t released. Im sure there are a ton of unfinished songs too, but I think in that remember mac show hosted by (ebro?) someone mentioned that he was sitting on albums that he said he’d release someday
6
u/onamor_tap Dec 09 '18
Yeah I remember this too, I think it was open late with Rosenberg when they did a mac tribute show, I think ty$ said he had an album with mac that was almost done. They also talked about a completely finished Mac and pharell album that was unreleased, it was called pink slime iirc
→ More replies (4)2
Dec 09 '18
He had a folk type album on the way called “Circles”
The Internet talked about it on their Beats 1 show
→ More replies (3)2
Dec 08 '18
Peep’s album was good because they took a whole year to finish it up but this album felt real rushed
1.5k
u/notorious_kjk . Dec 08 '18
Can’t argue with him at all. Only 10-20% of it feels COMPLETELY finished. However, you have to take one of his last points into account, that the blame doesn’t fall on XXX, but rather the producers and his label that decided to take over the project posthumously.
→ More replies (20)318
u/Aaron_Carter301 Dec 08 '18
Did he not finish it before he died? Pretty sure I heard that somewhere.
499
Dec 08 '18
His team claimed it was like 90% finished by x already but who knows if that’s the truth
87
u/Brainwash_TV Dec 08 '18
But unless you're a producer you don't realise how much of a massive gap there is between 90% finished and 100% finished. 90 and 100 is literally the difference between demo and professional album.
35
Dec 09 '18
Facts. And some of these could have been first takes that they intended to re-record, or perhaps just demos for writing.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)10
Dec 09 '18
This. Post-Production is an art form in of itself, and you can cut significantly different albums from the same raw demos.
102
u/Aaron_Carter301 Dec 08 '18
I believe that it was 90%. I can see why you would question that though.
→ More replies (4)186
Dec 08 '18
How can they know that it was 90% finished if they didn't know what the finished product would be? Like that's saying he was 90% of the way to a goal when they have no idea where the goal was. I think it's just a nice way of saying "this release is only 10% more refined than the demos he left"
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (3)11
u/j508 Dec 08 '18
Yeah i really doubt that lol
I mean if they have the chance to get that money i guess i’d do the same
2.3k
u/Nolar2015 . Dec 08 '18
Respectful of Anthony to not give the red flannel even tho he gave it a 2/10
Also respect for him for not giving it a false good review just because of his passing. I would say a 2/10 is fair for this
868
u/hodontsteponmyrafsim Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
Agreed but idk if a 2 is even fair... It's a gross money grab honestly train food was the only interesting song. The one with Kanye was okay but kinda silly Anthony hit the nail on the head, the guitar "sample" sounds like fucking old school DOOM, in a bad way lol
147
Dec 08 '18
I'm really surprised people fw the ye track
I mean I love it but also was a massive fan of nu metal and metalcore back in the day so it's got a nostalgic vibe to me
But... I didnt think hhh people are into that stuff at all lol
65
Dec 08 '18
lol i had to shut that shit off. Couldnt even listen through the whole thing. Doubt i ever will.
→ More replies (3)72
14
Dec 08 '18
I thought it was really good but like you were, I listen to lots of hardcore and metalcore too so it was like a really good genre blend for me personally.
13
u/letterword . Dec 08 '18
I like X's part in One Minute, don't really like the song or the album, but I can understand why people don't like the song.
→ More replies (1)27
→ More replies (7)13
Dec 08 '18
I mean, youre probably also a bit biased... XXX is your grandaddy after all
10
Dec 08 '18
Nah I'm not even a fan at all. I like maybe 3 to 5 of his songs if you include the ones that are ski masks
→ More replies (3)184
Dec 08 '18
I agree the album was ass, but it's not a money grab. X made almost all of it before he died. I'd give it a NOT GOOD myself, but it wasn't a cash grab at all. X just isn't a good or interesting artist imo
135
Dec 08 '18
Some of the songs on there were obviously edited by his team after his death. “Woah (mind in awe)” the hook on that track and “one minute”, which isn’t even how much time X spends screaming on this track. That being said, it’s far from the worst that this project has to offer.
84
Dec 08 '18
I was never a huge fan of x but I gotta agree it's pretty fucking stupid how they did him dirty on that one minute track
I don't think hed ever try for something like that, even if I do like the track a lot
→ More replies (5)136
6
u/RitzCracker13 Dec 08 '18
Yeah I liked one minute honestly, until X’s part. It felt like they just took an old recording of him screaming that stuff and looped it for a while
29
u/j508 Dec 08 '18
STRONGLY disagree with you on there dude. This album sounds so obviously unfinished to me because a: literally 10 2 minute songs b: just simple melodies all around, hardly any verses and c: everything just sounds like a rough draft all in general
This “album” is the most blatant cashgrabby shit ive seen in a while and it disgusts me. Not particularly a fan of his music but i dont think its fair criticizing this album as a bad one when he didnt even get to finish it the way he wanted to.
17
u/siamesedeluxe Dec 08 '18
Did you listen to ?? Like most of your complaints hold up for that album too. So I'm not sure if it was unfinished or if it just sounds like shit "on purpose"
0
→ More replies (77)9
u/xGothboiGuccix Dec 08 '18
Definitely a money grab but we don’t know whats going on behind the scenes. Really wish they would’ve saved these vocals for a members only vol. 4, if not that they should’ve at least made this an unmastered album, i swear X’s best music is unmastered, short and sweet
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (11)16
u/mellowtooth Dec 08 '18
lmao in what dimension does the guitar sample in One Minute sound even remotely like DOOM
18
54
u/BABYSLUMPJESUS . Dec 08 '18
DOOM the crust punk band, not MF
22
24
u/mellowtooth Dec 08 '18
if you’re for real, do they also specify “all caps when you spell the man’s name”?
i’m pretty sure referring to “DOOM” on HHH is going to result in most people thinking of... yknow... DOOM
→ More replies (3)20
u/PiplupTCG . Dec 08 '18
Yeah I saw the thumbnail and was like "oh wow so he gave it like a 5-6 and then he said 2 lol
74
u/tuurminator . Dec 08 '18
I feel like he has been slowly moving away from the red/yellow flannel. JID got an 8, but no yellow flannel.
132
Dec 08 '18
Not quite, he likes wearing them for smaller releases so people see the yellow flannel and discover a smaller artist, but I think -as someone else here said- he stated in a video that he doesn’t want to spoil the score for the bigger releases because people will view them regardless.
67
u/luxtp Dec 08 '18
i really respect that. him wearing the yellow flannel for his sat 1 review is how i discovered brockhampton, so it definitely works.
→ More replies (1)56
u/PM-ME-UR-MOTIVATION . Dec 08 '18
I think I heard somewhere on here that he doesn’t wear flannels for bigger releases anymore so it won’t spoil the rating, could be wrong though
→ More replies (4)3
u/corndogs1001 . Dec 08 '18
When was the last time he gave a album a 2? Was it revival?
→ More replies (1)
634
Dec 08 '18
HHH on Friday: “Love this album” and “ Some of X’s best put together songs”
HHH on Saturday: “Definitely agree 2/10”, “Producers and label left X hanging” and “ makes sense because it was only 80% finished when he passed”
24
u/teh_hasay Dec 08 '18
Every fresh release thread gets filled up with fanboys too hyped to judge an album objectively. That goes for pretty much any artist.
143
u/EvoFume Dec 08 '18
Fuck it, I liked it. It's not some incredible piece of music, but...I liked it.
Pls don't downvote me
55
Dec 08 '18
The point of my comment is that a lot of people on here look to other people like Anthony or someone with all the upvotes to base their taste of music on. If you like something don’t let someone who you think is the voice of everyone change your mind.
→ More replies (2)20
u/pickled_anus_lard . Dec 09 '18
I think a more reasonable explanation is that release threads are full of fans of the artist, and will pretty much always be positive. Then the separate group of people who agree with Fantano comment here. I really don’t think it’s Fantano controlling opinions.
→ More replies (3)2
u/swain_ryan Dec 09 '18
I liked it too. Even the song with Ye...reminds me of Rage Against the Machine and I love it. The whole album is good and riddled with Travis Barker drum tracks
→ More replies (17)25
Dec 08 '18
It's almost like there are over a million people on the sub all with unique ideas and opinions. All the people who liked the album on commented on the original thread, so, it makes sense that everyone who disliked it would comment on a negative thread lol.
→ More replies (4)
567
u/Theingloriousak2 Dec 08 '18
Fucking bravo for calling out kanye here
Let’s see how this sub reacts to that
This is one of the only times I completely agree with melon head, except a 2 score is a bit low here.
Seems like a lot of unfinished songs, it seems xxx just laid out some ideas and didn’t get a chance to finish them.
Train food is amazing and the true standout of the album
66
u/Nolar2015 . Dec 08 '18
What did he say about Kanye?
263
u/DerpinTurtle Dec 08 '18
That his lines relate to him desperately wanting to fit in with a newer crowd of hip hop listeners
64
Dec 08 '18
So he was being honest? I didn't hear the song or watch the review, but wouldn't it be a positive thing for Kanye to admit that he's been a so called "clout chaser"
79
u/DerpinTurtle Dec 08 '18
It’s not him directly admitting it, more so his lines just add to him trying to appeal to a newer generation
→ More replies (36)259
u/Jg_Tensaii . Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
Clout chasing and kanye are an all-time iconic duo. He did this multiple times and his core fan base still like him so at this point I don't really think anything will bring him down. I personally don't really care as long as the new shit sounds fresh and has personality.
175
u/GregoryBennettMusic Dec 08 '18
He makes good music. I don’t think too many people look past that
→ More replies (20)71
Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
As long as he keeps making genius music which he has been doing his whole career. I could care less what he does. I don’t listen to his opinions
28
u/UchihaRaiden Dec 08 '18
Kanye can’t even bring Kanye down bro these stans are different.
→ More replies (1)0
Dec 08 '18
[deleted]
→ More replies (3)32
u/RamboNaqvi Dec 08 '18
You can’t blame them for leaving though, not everyone can look past the bs he’s put us through. And there’s also obviously new fans he gains that end up leaving as well.
→ More replies (35)37
u/elehay4aksega Dec 08 '18
Fucking bravo for calling out kanye here
Let’s see how this sub reacts to that
As if him shitting on Kanye is anything new
21
u/ItzzBlink . Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 07 '25
ancient airport stocking dam bag hobbies fade detail wide library
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
11
Dec 09 '18
Damn, he loves Kanye, I bet he’d never give two of the best albums this decade a 6 and a 5 respectively
→ More replies (6)45
u/expirable Dec 08 '18
i really don't agree with people like fantano saying ye is clout chasing on x for his fanbase/listeners since x really admired Kanye and you can see that throughout his old tweets on twitter https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&vertical=default&q=from%3Axxxtentacion%20kanye and even in tracks like R U N where he sampled him from a talk show and naming a track "I LUv My CLiQuE LiKe KaNyE WeSt" it's all there, x would appreciate the feature/homage since he was a fan of yeezus too https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&q=from%3Axxxtentacion%20yeezus it kind of goes full circle and he died on the anniversary of yeezus coincidently... I just realized that but I assume Kanye definitely did although it's just a odd coincidence though.
→ More replies (1)31
u/letterword . Dec 08 '18
Yeah but Kanye never showed any love for X until he died.
→ More replies (7)13
18
u/Unmesswittable Dec 08 '18
He’s wrong about Kanye though. Who doesn’t Kanye collab with? Maybe he just likes making music with a large assortment of artists?
31
u/Chunk_The_Hunk Dec 08 '18
I think it more how the verse is saying x did nothing wrong
→ More replies (5)11
u/letterword . Dec 08 '18
Also how Kanye never showed any love for X until he died.
18
Dec 08 '18
He openly admitted to it on Twitter after he died. He's more self aware than you think.
→ More replies (4)2
Dec 09 '18
I don't get the vibe Kanye exactly wants money, so I definitely see chasing new collabs as more of a "oh shit I dig this guy's work, I wanna work with him."
Kanye is all about collaboration. It makes total sense that he'd genuinely respect XXX as well, given he sees himself as having fought to change rap, and XXX is kinda the same.
4
u/iLuLWaT Dec 08 '18
Or Kanye actually believes that celebrities are judged on the worst things they have done, which is actually true in a lot of cases.
13
u/SitDown_BeHumble Dec 09 '18
Yeah I really hate it when people judge this guy for stabbing nine people and torturing his girlfriend.
→ More replies (1)2
u/YaboiCece Dec 09 '18
I'm a huge Kanye stan but i kinda agreed with him too. Him working with pump, tekashi and now xxx
4
-3
Dec 08 '18
Hes wrong bout ye tho
50
u/Missionize Dec 08 '18
i mean collabing with pump 6ix9ine & x within the span of 2 and a half months would suggest it might have some merit to it
20
Dec 08 '18
he did it with Chief Keef and kinda Travis too. it’s just the newer generations most popular artists are terrible people with massive cult like fans.
22
Dec 08 '18
What he did with Keef on HML was fucking amazing. Him dropping half ass bars on Pump, 69 and X tracks is a completely different thing.
→ More replies (13)16
u/707deathwish . Dec 08 '18
Notice how, when they asked him who his favourite new artists were, he picked all 3 of the most controversial ones: Lil Pump, 6ix9ine (oh btw he's done songs with both of them since then) and of course X, (who he suddenly said was an inspiration the second he died) and then he threw in Valee because of the whole "he's signed to GOOD Music, I wanna push him a lil harder" thing.
→ More replies (6)9
Dec 08 '18
are you implying the lil pump collaboration wasnt a brilliant piece of art
→ More replies (1)-3
u/Sebosauras Dec 08 '18
kanyes verse is reprehensible idk how people continue to cape for a man who's shown to be a complete piece of garbage in 2018
16
Dec 08 '18
Because he is still consistently making better music than almost anybody. You can get away with a lot when you have probably the best discography in hip hop
→ More replies (14)9
u/ChinaCatSunfIower Dec 08 '18
Damn, I never really considered that he actually does have one of the best discographies in hip hop. He really doesn't have a bad album. Even Cruel Summer had some slapperonies
→ More replies (6)6
→ More replies (1)1
u/NormanQuacks345 Dec 09 '18
I like the third verse of Train Food, but I feel the beat (and the other verses) could use some more substance, and I hate how they end the song. It just feels like I'm left hanging, like there should be something, anything following that line, but it just ends.
60
Dec 08 '18
I gotta get me some melon status
I said some of the same shit on the release thread and people brought out the pitchforks so I deleted it :(
19
u/pixelpancake Dec 08 '18
This sub forgets that music is subjective and that they can have their own opinion besides fantano’s. But I was saying the same shit too...
12
u/pickled_anus_lard . Dec 09 '18
Nah you both just posted in a thread populated mostly by XXX fans. Criticism in any artists release threads rarely goes well, and XXX’s fans are particularly rabid. This thread has less of that, especially because of the low score, less XXX fans willing to get clowned in here.
→ More replies (6)4
u/mothermaiden1066 . Dec 09 '18
Fantano has bugs on our phones and steals our opinions. He straight up stole my comments.
207
u/Cohtoh Dec 08 '18
I kind of disagree with his notion that if xxx was alive, this album would have magically sounded more complete and finished. Obviously it's all speculation as we don't really know what it would have sounded like if he was alive, but to me, most of these songs sound no more unfinished than a lot of songs on 17 and ?. His inability to make a complete song has been a huge issue throughout his whole career and I don't think it would have been fixed on this album. I'm not convinced that had xxx been alive, this album would have been much different. I'd give the album closer to a 4/10 though.
81
u/redditor6845 Dec 08 '18
If X were alive today, maybe he’d at least finish the songs. It’s pretty clear that most of these seem almost like thoughts to come back to or just scrapped songs. Even in X’s weak/spotty discography, he’s always put out at least a few songs of note, and the songs mostly feel complete. The absolute shit songs off of ? and 17 at least were properly mixed and had some structure to it. Nobody puts this weak of a project out willingly
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (52)6
u/FijiTearz Dec 08 '18
As someone who was a fan of X during his rise to fame, his songs have always been very hit or miss. His albums have always had a couple good songs and a couple bad ones. Honestly this album is typical and expected of X, couple good tracks and a couple of bad ones. Plus this isn't X's fault it's not complete, he did his job he recorded his lines. This is the fault of the label and the producers. Yeah maybe he could have influenced that and changed it up more if he was alive but this album very much sounds like 17 and ?
36
u/catastrophicprophet . Dec 08 '18
X stans will defend it no matter what, but I completely agree with him here, one of my first thoughts was that the album doesn't 'flow' well and it felt like X was in the middle of experimenting with his sound when he made these tracks.
→ More replies (1)
108
u/coolmike28145 Dec 08 '18
Agree with the score completely. This album comes off as a compilation of really shit loosies, with STARING AT THE SKY and BAD! being exceptionally shit tracks.
34
u/ThnikkamanBubs Dec 08 '18
Lol I wonder why so many people decided to give the FRESH ALBUM thread multiple silver, gold and even platinum
3
u/TuhnuPeppu Dec 09 '18
Maybe just some people like the album? I know it has problems like being unfinished and all but i still enjoy it really much
→ More replies (2)52
u/bungle123 Dec 08 '18
Staring at The Sky actually makes me laugh because of how bad it is. He sounds so fucking goofy when he's singing in that song.
45
u/M1k35n4m3 Dec 08 '18
Do you listen to rock or even more specifically emo music? He really doesn't sound any different than any of those dudes in that song. It's just a style of singing. Y'all so weird
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (1)17
u/strange1738 Dec 08 '18
Hey, BAD! Is probably the only song on this album that feels like a real song.
12
45
u/coolmike28145 Dec 08 '18
It's like a minute and a half long, and 90% of the track is the hook.
→ More replies (4)5
→ More replies (2)4
u/dogenoob1 Dec 08 '18
yep, it really sounds like an X song but just incomplete when it comes to length, I really dig BAD! ez repeat for days, y'all trippin
12
u/acefern Dec 08 '18
I personally really enjoyed whoa, thought it was catchy lol.
I’m not going to argue melon’s opinion though because that’s exactly what his reviews are, opinions, we all have different opinions at the end of the day like when he gave MMLP2 a higher rating than Kamikaze or when he gave Yeezus such a low rating when it’s one of my favorite Kanye albums. Still dropped that like button to show him and his channel support though :).
127
u/Jg_Tensaii . Dec 08 '18
This shit is so bad Fantano invented a new flannel entirely for it. The white man in suite pulled a quicky on all of the angsty white girls. RIP X, not the biggest fan but I recognize the influence, pretty sure he wouldn't approve of this shit
272
u/nd20 :dimple: . Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
angsty white girls
Nah bruh. We're not gonna let xxx stans get away with pinning this on white girls. I know we like to blame every artist or album we don't like on white girls but I'm not letting the 20x more numerous angsty dudes get away with scapegoating the trash on this one
70
u/blazblue5 . Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
Completely agree, anecdotal obviously but from who I speak to at my college it’s the same type of dudes who fuck with X or white girls that like SAD! And Look at me! 95% of that is the dudes tho
20
u/CelalT Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
I dont think poeple who fuck with the emo X listen to look at me and his other relatively older stuff. I loved those but not really a fan of his newer stuff
13
Dec 08 '18
I find this to be the same. People who liked X's shit like Look At Me do not fuck with the softer emo stuff that he released before his death. I'm not a fan of either, but I know of very few people in real life whose fandom crosses over.
→ More replies (5)64
u/DogTheGayFish Dec 08 '18
Angsty white girls tilted me to read tbh, most of X's fanbase seems to be angsty younger male teens. People pinning that whole white-girl hip-hop tag to too many artists.
→ More replies (1)8
u/CadabraAbrogate . Dec 08 '18
Honestly, with my firsthand experience, I wouldn't pin it on angsty white girls, but more angsty girls of all ethnicities. I've definitely met more girls who claim to be fans of xxxtentacion than dudes, but these girls were mostly black or latina
37
u/Dictarium Dec 08 '18
literally never met a girl who was into xxx. it's a dude thing by the widest of all the margins.
16
u/domax9 Dec 08 '18
his older stuff yeah, but his more sad and depressing songs are loved by all the white girls i know
9
u/bzzrak Dec 08 '18
I know several girls who are into him, they mostly listen to the sadder calmer stuff.
→ More replies (1)10
u/nicefroyo . Dec 08 '18
Yeah there’s so much irrational hatred of white girls on this sub, like they’re the source of all the world’s ills.
10
u/Spez_dont Dec 08 '18
He used the same for Lil Xan – Total Xanarchy too
22
→ More replies (1)8
u/coolmike28145 Dec 08 '18
I recognize the influence
What influence?
→ More replies (7)15
u/Jg_Tensaii . Dec 08 '18
He's a big part of the emo-rap sound of the past couple of years.. as a fan of the genre you sometimes have to take your personal taste out and observe the changes..
→ More replies (8)
10
u/sneekers0too1 Dec 09 '18
Tbh I thought the album was fire. Yeah it sounds unfinished but 90% of x’s shit sounds rough around the edges. I had really low expectations before I listened to it because I was really disappointed by cowys pt 2. So that could have something to do with it, but on the first listen I legit had goosebumps the whole time. Do i think this is exactly what X would have wanted? Obviously no, but its about 100 times better than what i was expecting.
47
u/CamusGrapes . Dec 08 '18
glad he called out kanye on this. Even if you do some mental gymnastics and think X saying he "fucked up" his girlfriend was just mentally, it's still a terrible thing and something fans should accept and move on from rather than defend.
i kinda liked X's ice hotel EP and a song here and there but have never really felt the love many others did and this album didn't change that. Either the record label fucked up the whole thing by scraping together whatever they could find or X managed to artistically regress pretty far. IMO this isn't the worst album of the year, but a 2/10 is pretty fair.
32
u/Wolfgang_Funkle Dec 08 '18
Honestly the people acting like X mentally abusing his girlfriend is completely fine are killing me. Like great he’s not guilty of a crime but he’s still doing some fucked up shit either way
79
u/souuur_d Dec 08 '18
Wow guess I’m in the minority for actually liking this project. I’d give it 7.5/10 at the lowest. Grew up on the whole emo, alternative rock, etc shit and I thoroughly enjoyed the album..
14
u/deathstrukk Dec 08 '18
Yeah a lot of people are looking at this as a bad rap album and I’d have to agree but it’s a great emo/grunge/alternative mash up sound, and it seems like a lot of emo rappers are moving to wards this sound. Look at coldhart his new song is completely pop punk
29
u/ChikinCSGO Dec 08 '18 edited Sep 24 '25
aware expansion governor humorous include worm automatic cooperative treatment aback
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/*polhold04045 Dec 09 '18
I listen to those genres and I very much dislike most of the album. Except train food, one minute and guardian angel.
9
19
Dec 08 '18
I hate how people on this sub who a lot of don’t listen to hardcore say x has bad scream vocals when even fantano says x is capable of doing so.
4
u/*polhold04045 Dec 09 '18
Exactly. X has great screams Imo. He could really belt them out especially since he was a singer he had good control. I would love to hear him do some Deathcore/metalcore type of shit. Or a joint with city mogue
6
u/ruacanobeef Dec 08 '18
So, I’ve honestly never listened to an XXX song before this because I didn’t really want to support such a piece of shit person. I went ahead and tried some of the “bad” songs off of this album and, well, I really didn’t hate them. I’m kind of in the same boat as you where I was really into emo, math rock, and other shit like that before I started branching out into hip hop and other genres. I will agree that some of it sounds hastily put together... but I almost like that for some reason?
3
u/imdeadseriousbro Dec 08 '18
I really didn’t hate them
check out his other studio albums. he does similair things but they feel more polished since at this point you arent supporting him directly. Pain = BESTFRIEND is another "bad song" that i enjoy
2
u/M1k35n4m3 Dec 09 '18
His style of short tracks is really great to me personally. X made his songs long enough for him to communicate what he wanted to express not for filler and whatever else. I really like that about him. It's just sort of pure emotion put into sound rather than every track trying to hit a particular minute marker of or fill a set number of bars.
2
Dec 09 '18
I was the same with his album before this. Checked out some of the songs, and just really dug what felt like an early 00's raw mid-west emo vibe.
2
2
→ More replies (15)0
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 08 '18
REMINDER: Review thread guidelines:
Parent comments in review threads must be over 140 characters.
Comments that solely name the score or describe the clothing the reviewer is wearing are not allowed
Meta comments solely about how the subreddit will react to the review are also not allowed.
Comments that only compare the review to other scores by the publication or by other publications are not allowed.
If this is a Fantano review, visit r/fantanoforever for all low-effort comments
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
26
u/Dr_MM Dec 08 '18
A 2/10 is fair. I liked the track featuring Kanye but the rest feel like demos just slapped together. This project is just a lazy cash grab to profit from a dead artist.
4
u/CalmTiger . Dec 08 '18
Didn't expect anything different, a 2 would be entirely fair here. It just felt unfinished, unstructured, an unmastered. not very good at all. I'm feeling a strong 1 to a light 2
4
u/Driscoll17 Dec 09 '18
I can’t seem to dislike X’s music. I know a lot of it is objectively bad but it just sits very well with me for some reason. He’s my most listened artist of the year on Spotify by far and honestly it did not surprise me in the slightest. A lot of his emotional shit is 100% forced and his lyrics are often pretty shallow but just his delivery and production apparently is made for my ear because I fucking love a lot of it. This album is obviously a cash grab, and the first time I listened to STARING AT THE SKY and One Minute I was laughing at how ridiculous they were but I still couldn’t help but love it and I don’t know why. A 2 is very reasonable for this album and I can 100% understand. I can’t even say I disagree but for me this album is like a light 7. I would never expect Anthony to give it that because it does not deserve it but XXXTENTACION just makes catchy, fun and enjoyable music for me. Am I the only one who feels this way? I feel like a lot of his fans either fucking live or die by him and defend him for his actions which I really dislike or only like his really popular music and aren’t really fans.
→ More replies (4)
7
Dec 08 '18
I genuinely really enjoyed this album and has been on repeat since it came out. I can understand melons opinions on the music because I had similar thoughts on it at first but the more I listen to it the album just has this feel to it that I can't describe. The only song that ill probably eventually stop listening to is maybe BAD it really is just to short.
3
u/Twisted_Lobster . Dec 09 '18
I can pull up the Fresh 17 & ? threads right now and literally all the comments there about how the songs felt unfinished, and you guys really think he was all of a sudden gonna drop an album that was gonna be a cohesive, completely finished sounding project? you people just want somehing to be mad at and it's ridiculous
12
u/berenjenaa Dec 08 '18
Man I be bumping Kanye albums all the time while driving. His music was so fucking good that is one of the few rappers I feel comfortable playing even if my family is in the car. Just some pure soulful shit. You would think he would get even wiser as he gets older right? Nope. He's making shit like "I'm a sick fuck, I like to quick fuck" for Clout... That's not the fucking Kanye I loved.
17
u/KyleActive . Dec 08 '18
Did u listen to Ye or KSG, no meme songs there
I honestly think he made that song partially to show he can still make mass appeal songs
3
27
u/SnakeSquad . Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
I don't see how anyone can disagree with this tbh, the album is absolute garbage and the only people who are saying otherwise are xxx fans who are in denial, think what you what but you can't deny how unfinished this piece of trash album is, as melon said you can't put this on xxx tho its his greedy ass camp that wanted to release this. They could've released it as a collection of left overs instead of trying to make this half assed album and no one would've cared.
Love how people here are actually saying earl gets a pass for it being short. xxx wish he could've had the song structure and quality that earl has put out. even when he was alive 17 and "?" are horribly put together albums, truly sad that people can't see that
11
u/TreyTreyStu . Dec 08 '18
I didn't think the album as a whole was a cohesive project but I'd say I liked 3-4 songs on the project that I'll probably listen to for a while. Its funny to see that people seem to agree that music is subjective only until certain artists that a majority hates get posted and then anyone with any sort of dissenting opinion is written off as a Stan or in denial. Ya'll feel so validated when Fantano backs up your opinion.
35
u/Hyperbole_Hater Dec 08 '18
It's pretty easy to see why someone could like Skins over SRS. If you honestly can't empathize with why someone's tastes would vary so wildly you ain't even trying to recognize differences in people.
→ More replies (9)21
u/Aaron_Carter301 Dec 08 '18
I disagree. It’s subjective, your comment sounds ignorant.
→ More replies (8)16
Dec 08 '18
im an xxx fan and im not "in denial" about liking the album, i genuinely enjoy a lot of the tracks on this thing
→ More replies (14)→ More replies (13)2
u/imdeadseriousbro Dec 08 '18
im a big X fan but this is just not as good as his other albums. ill take ski masks album over this anyday which i wouldnt say about his first 2 albums
3
u/SnakeSquad . Dec 09 '18
Definitely prefer skis album to this idk how you can be a fan of xxx and say this is a well thought out album, it barley has any songs
2
u/hezzyskeets123 Dec 08 '18
The album undeniably unfinished but the track difference just hits me weird....I just like the live sound....it sounds unfinished in a good way
2
Dec 08 '18
I agree with fantano on the 2/10. But I actually really liked Kanye’s verse and I think Kanye just does what he likes, doesn’t pander to anyone
→ More replies (1)
2
u/baconbytes Dec 09 '18
IDK, I don't really disagree with anything Fantano's saying here, but I still don't think it's a 2. I guess the shortness/incompleteness of the songs didn't bother me. I'd personally give it a 7 or 8, but that's clearly a very biased score.
8
Dec 08 '18
This was the biggest pile of garbage from a major artist that came out this year. You’re lying to yourself if you think is an enjoyable album.
0
7
Dec 08 '18
this review came too soon man, I get that it's short but this is literally a first reaction.
Also, I disagree with him. How can you say these tracks are unfinished when his best work is in this same format and length? One Minutes riff is annoying? The interlude is bad just because the track is called Interlude on a short album? For real?
22
u/bubmox22 Dec 08 '18
I think this album only makes sense to the people who were invested into X and his music. Everyone who doesn't share that investment is looking at it like they would any other rapper, except with the bias that X was a bad person (not debating that either way btw I have no room to speak on that)
it's not a bad thing. some people just don't understand and feel artists like other people do. but honestly this sub really feels like it's in attack mode for people who enjoyed it and I think that's really counterintuitive to what the sub is about - sharing and enjoying all different types of our favorite genre and picking and choosing what we want to listen to. there's no need to get the pitchforks out for this topic like I've been seeing. let the fans enjoy it and let's move on.
→ More replies (6)2
u/trailer_park_boys Dec 09 '18
Not at all true. I have two other X songs on my phone before this album came out. So I’m definitely not an X fan. But I absolutely found myself enjoying this album. You’re right though. This whole thread is everybody attacking each other for enjoying or not enjoying this album. Not very productive.
→ More replies (1)5
6
u/GrumpingIt Dec 08 '18
Hmm. I actually liked the project. Of course it was an amateur attempt from an artist early on in their career, but did I expect anything better than this? I would give it easily at least a 4/10. Train food and One Minute were good. I liked STARING AT THE SKY as well, but it sounds like a lot of people didn't.
4
u/Flexappeal Dec 08 '18
Man i'll admit im usually a fantano dickrider and my opinions end up being rly in line with his a lot of the time
but boy do i love One Minute and it sucks that he hates it. I love that riff that makes up the entire beat. Its some weird yeezus/suicideboys/beastieboys(???) thing that makes the whole song super cool
and i say that as someone who does not listen to XXX's music at all, but i saved this one track.
1
u/ThisisZoness Dec 08 '18
Same dude. Sounds like Kanye rapping over a riff from a THPS soundtrack in the best way.
→ More replies (4)2
2
Dec 08 '18
i don't think it's a 2/10 but it definitely isn't good maybe a 4 or 5, I realize this sub hates X but this just doesn't sound like an X album in any way it feels like people had these vocals and tried to mold them without trying to make it sound like him at all, there were maybe 2 or 3 songs that sounded good to me and the rest just feels... bad
→ More replies (1)
1
Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18
Hard to say. Honestly I’ve never really liked an X project before, but I think this would have been a really solid project had he finished it. There are a couple songs that are really exciting for the first verse or half-verse, but they are completely killed when the producer decides to just loop the same few lines again cause at the end of the day, these are some really unfinished demos, and they really don’t have much choice.
I don’t think he should have given this one a typical review. I think the song ideas were there, but the fact that it’s so unfinished really messes up the flow of most of the songs.
Maybe this should have been released as Skins: The Demos rather that an actual studio album.
1
u/25David Dec 08 '18
I love this and totally agree with the review. The album was unfinished and poorly mixed and a major cash grab for his label. Most of the songs just seemed pointless and carelessly thrown together. I totally agree with the final rating of a decent 2/10 and Fantano also described that this isn’t anyone’s fault but X’s label for milking off of a dead artist. I hope that we don’t see this with other dead artists like Fredo Santana or Mac Miller
1
Dec 09 '18
Serious question - I know a lot of artists probably don't self-produce (or self-record really, I have a separate producer) like I do since they have access to major studios, but if any of them do, do the labels take their personal computer to search for unfinished songs? Who is in control of a major artist's computer and hard drives once they die?
→ More replies (2)
1
u/TheMonsterIsAStar Dec 09 '18
Listened thru the album didn’t like it. If this was complete before his death damn that makes it even worse! It harsh sounded like rough cuts of what would become actual tracks. Never listen to this guy really before his death so maybe I just don’t get his sound and music but 10 tracks 20 minutes some tracks are literally a hook looped!? Crazy to think some ppl will spend money on this!
1
u/KorosSenseii Dec 09 '18
Imo skins was underwhelming. He said a total of 5 words in the album. I like xxx as an artist and i would love to see his creativity but skins was not what i wanted.
Edit: he was creative af. Skins does not reflect this.
1
u/Jeffman22 Dec 09 '18
Randomly, for whatever reason, this album had a decent amount of tracks on here I enjoyed. Really didn’t like 17, thought ? wasn’t very good either, but personally I’d give this a 5 maybe even a light 6
-2
u/Hollywood_WBS . Dec 08 '18
I didn't think he would make something worse than 17 or ?. I agree wholeheartedly with Melon except not putting the blame om Tentacion. His label already tweeted that it is 100% what he wanted. And I believe it. Its literally exactly like 17 with the same 1minute 2 minute songs that arent very good and are downright fucking trash except this one is much much worse. This was so boring outside a few moments where it becomes downright hilarious when hes tryna do a screamo song
He is also right on Kanye wanting more fans. As an actual huge fan, Kanye West has spent the 2nd half of 2018 just clout chasing and its insanely obvious. Why else would he hop on a track with Lil Pump. 6ix9ine. And the dead woman beater.
Id give it worse if I didnt like Ye's part just a little despite the dumbass shit he says.
-4
u/aoldotcomfag Dec 08 '18
I get how he says it sounds unfinished but that's been most of X's music why would this come as a surprise. Why would u listen to something and expect something different from the artists style?
24
u/Twitter_Beef . Dec 08 '18
Because its more unfinished than usual
8
u/UMANTHEGOD Dec 08 '18
You expect artists to develop.
If each album sounds the same, what's the point of even making another one?
→ More replies (1)
20
u/ltrob . Dec 08 '18
I mean thank you whoever gilded this but why would you spend money on this post? There are some better ones out there you could’ve chosen or something