r/hiphopheads • • Sep 26 '18

Young Thug's 'On the Rvn' Is the Rapper Near His Best, but Is That Enough? Despite mounting pressures, the rush of a ticking clock is mostly imagined by fans and critics alike. Thug is home, and he has plenty of time.

https://noisey.vice.com/en_us/article/438axm/young-thugs-on-the-rvn-is-the-rapper-at-his-best-but-is-that-enough
4.5k Upvotes

691 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Kire_L Sep 26 '18

I don’t get it. Why do people think Thug wants to be extremely large? Dude looks like he’s enjoying his life and isn’t out here starving or begging to headline some festivals. Maybe he wants to go the route of Big Krit and Currensy. Commercially Havana is probably as close to a billboard number 1 hit, but it’ll be played in the same vein as artists that are featured or on a remix like Luis Fonsi and Daddy Yankee, Gucci Mane, or Ty Dolla Sign.

471

u/AmericanHerstoryX Sep 26 '18

yeah his fans definitely care more about his billboard success than he does, but i think every artist would like higher sales numbers in general. For how big and dedicated and vocal his fanbase is it's just surprising to see him do such low numbers. His name recognition and sales numbers just don't really match up i feel like

33

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

There's this overall trend here where if any artist isn't selling 80K or whatever they're failing.

When Jay Rock or Denzel Curry or Vince Staples sell 20K people act like it's a huge failing.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

its so weird lol. do people not realize that people pirate music 3x as much as they did in 2005. streaming helps but looking at album sales is wild these days. only superstars truly sell.

150

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

I think, in general, the type of fans to stan Thug aren’t the same type of people who actually buy hiphop records. People like KRIT and Currensy, as mentioned earlier, appeal to more traditional fans, the type who are more likely to cop an album or still see value in having physical formats of music

90

u/AmericanHerstoryX Sep 26 '18

i don't think this is really true, most big time thugger fans i know and follow are pretty serious heads and/or DJs. The thing is while his fanbase is pretty large and dedicated, I think he's also popular just as a personality and he sometimes gets memed, so that makes it seem like his fanbase is muchhh bigger. Still though with someone whose name and face you see a lot on the internet you'd probably expect loosely corresponding sales numbers

42

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Still, I’d be willing to bet that fans of people like KRIT are more likely to buy music than fans of people like Young Thug. Just thinking about demographics and the quality of their complete projects, its not surprising as you say it is, why Thug doesn’t do numbers like some expect him to

58

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Just to add to the convo. If I tell someone who isn't a fan of KRIT, that he put out a new album and it's dope. There's a 50/50 shot they'll try it out

Tell someone who doesn't like young thugs old stuff that he put out a new album and it's dope. They're gonna say "fuck that I'm not listening to anything where I can't understand the words" or some shit. People figure out they don't like young thug and just put him away forever. Whereas other rappers get a new chance every album.

Just my two cents

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

2

u/shroomysam Sep 26 '18

Tru, recently been cop’n all the new curren$y vinyl releases.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/icyprod Sep 26 '18

Watch the vid of Lyor Cohen scolding thugger, Thug said he wants 10 number 1 billboard hits

2

u/AmericanHerstoryX Sep 26 '18

seems like an unreasonable goal but shoot for the stars tugga behbeh

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

I know it’s so weird, if you go to the thugger and even here subreddit you see people upset that he doesn’t market more. Like if he wanted to he would, but he is content where he is.

→ More replies (39)

36

u/lyuch Sep 26 '18

Wasn’t thug the dude who said he wanted 10 #1 singles?

26

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

there was an interview with him I saw once where he said he wanted to do Michael Jackson numbers

3

u/Androidgenus Sep 27 '18

He told Lyor Cohen he wanted to release ten #1 singles in a year

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Wasn’t he just busted for trying to sell meth lmao

1

u/meechy_dev Sep 26 '18

because he is, he said it himself?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

It's speculated thug is super broke, solely from outliving his wallets budget, so I would imagine he wants to be big.

1

u/mcoppmann Sep 27 '18

He is in debt hugely

1

u/4_Better_Or_Worse Sep 27 '18

He may be starving tho he never eats lol

1

u/old__pyrex Sep 27 '18

I just want Thug to be successful and be able to continue to produce great work - this is why I would hope he put up numbers. Now obviously I realize he has a good niche for himself, but back in 2014-2016 it did seem like he was struggling to get what he needed commercially. He's one of my favorite artists of his era and having good numbers is going to help him get on more features, get more promotion, work with more producers, basically do more of what he wants to do. That's all - it's not like Thug fans are being numbers whores for no reason, we just wanted our dude to succeed.

For example someone like KRIT who didnt catch the numbers he really needed, and had a long drought where he wasn't quite making music up to his caliber and it wasn't getting good promotion, etc, that took him out the game for a while.

Or take someone like ilovemakkonnen who's not putting up numbers. He's done. Numbers do matter a lot when they aren't enough for an artist to eat.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

[deleted]

56

u/wishihadfriends1 Sep 26 '18

Mans selling roughly 30k first week on albums and you're saying he's extremely large lmao

31

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Young Thug has abnormally low album sales for his popularity because he releases several albums a year with little promo rather than one every year or two with physicals and a lot of promo.

Pretending to not understand this isn't a good argument.

→ More replies (26)

56

u/SCzergrush Sep 26 '18

30k in streams is 45,000,000 songs streamed from the album. Having your work listened to 45 million times in a week sounds pretty big. The nature of album sales has dwarfed sales numbers a lot.

14

u/TheSpanishKarmada Sep 26 '18

Compared to the numbers other artists do who don't have anywhere close to the name recognition thug does, it's pretty low

→ More replies (2)

40

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

He's in the Top 200 artists in the world on Spotify that's pretty big tbh

52

u/taquito-burrito Sep 26 '18

Lol, that sounds a lot better than saying he’s the 188th most listened to artist on Spotify.

40

u/sleepingfactory . Sep 26 '18

He’s one of the top 188 artists in Spotify

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

So probably not even top 25 among hip hop artists

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

136

u/aggaggang . Sep 26 '18

I think this author is forgetting That thug has court in a couple weeks for 8 felonies! He is potentially facing serious time, that’s why the fans are scared of “the clock ticking”

→ More replies (11)

249

u/Dig-Duglett . Sep 26 '18

I didn't think On the Rvn was underwhelming at all. I actually felt it was some nice, clean, return to form Thugger I was craving following Slime Language (which seemed more like a YSL showcase).

45

u/northernnighttts Sep 26 '18

THE FIRST COMMENT I’VE AGREED WITH

26

u/OGforGoldenBoot Sep 26 '18

Yeah this comment needs to be higher. I feel like if you don't like this album then you probably don't actually like thug.

That article talked about the highlights of his career and just left out Jefferey entirely so all of it's opinions are basically entirely invalid.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/masemasemase Sep 27 '18

Same. Sometimes I feel like people just refuse to like any “new shit” because then they can’t say “oh he’ll never be as good as ____.”

I think this project is fantastic: short and sweet, and even the features are good. I love it.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

It seemed like that cause that’s what it was

→ More replies (5)

580

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

Thugger is only 27. For reference, Rick Ross was 30 when “Hustlin” dropped. Lil’ Wayne was 25 when he dropped Tha Carter III. Future was 28 when Pluto came out. Thugger has plenty of time, and already has an established cult fan base. If he doesn’t do any extended stints in prison, or die of anything drug related (not to be morbid, just realistic),the prime of his career could still be ahead of him.

Edit: Wayne was 25 when C3 dropped. Makes me feel even older.

305

u/LiveLoveLaughASAP Sep 26 '18

Lil Wayne is not really the best example, mans been hot since he was 16 I think?

237

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

Lil’ Wayne is actually a perfect example because they’ve had similar career arcs. Lil’ Wayne’s debut album came out in 1999, but he didn’t come close to the level he’s at now until 2006-2008

71

u/LiveLoveLaughASAP Sep 26 '18

Fair point! That's also a great way to look at it.

43

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Wasn’t Tha Carter II like the second beet selling rap album of 2005? Young Thug wasn’t dropping albums ten years ago afaik

28

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

It was the sixth best selling album of that year. And AGAIN, I was making a timeline comparison. Weezy debuted in 1999. Carter II came out in 2005. That’s six years. Thugger had four years between his first mixtape and Barter 6.

→ More replies (3)

86

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

future different bro, he remind me of steve nash late bloomer, his old stuff good but the new shit put made him a 2x MVP, dudes like 34 now still making hits

45

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

How is Future much different? Both from ATL, started releasing mixtapes around the beginning of the decade, both autotuned trap rap, same lyrical content, actually did an album together, took a few years to get any mainstream exposure. I know they don’t sound the same, but they are very comparable as far as their careers go.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/MrSamster911 Sep 26 '18

Eminem was 26 or 27 when he dropped the slim shady lp

19

u/heyguysitslogan Sep 26 '18

lol Wayne is the absolute worst example you could have picked

At the age Wayne was rapping I was playing sonic on game cube

10

u/lynit Sep 26 '18

wayne is a great example because he took forever to grow into the commercial and critical juggernaut he is/was.

5

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

Which is why you don’t have a much of a clue about Wayne’s career. Yes, he began rapping when he was VERY young. But he didn’t have the crossover, greatest-rapper-alive type of reputation until at least 2006. Lil’ Wayne’s debut album came out in 1999. I was playing Sonic on the Dreamcast before Wayne’s debut released, and on the Genesis long before that. Trust me, his career arc is similar to Thug’s.

5

u/heyguysitslogan Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

More 10 year old white kids pirated tha carter 3 leak than young thug has fans total

→ More replies (6)

2

u/gtclutch Sep 26 '18

but Lil wayne was 25 when Carter 3 dropped.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

JID just started recently and he's 27.

Danny Brown only blew up when he was 30

1

u/superdankleo16 Sep 27 '18

Lol okay when thug sells a milli first week we’ll all see how similar their career arcs were.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/jiggawara Sep 26 '18

Said this in the album thread but CLIMAX is really an amazing song

17

u/heritagenovus Sep 26 '18

I've honestly played it like 30 times already, couldn't agree more

13

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Climax and High are on loop for me. Just really great songs

5

u/jiggawara Sep 26 '18

that’s the thing with thug... when he gets it right he takes it to another level

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Climax makes me climax

2

u/TheKwardian Sep 27 '18

Thug and London can do no wrong

2

u/Rndomguytf . Sep 27 '18

Such a fucking vibe yea

1

u/RobotsDevil Sep 27 '18

Sin was definitely the highlight of the album for me. But climax is a close second, 6lack is killing it.

→ More replies (1)

276

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Thug cares about his fashion, his family, his brothers, etc. He doesnt give a fuck about competing with other rappers for being the best. He’s living his best life and is unbothered

75

u/Ezekiiel . Sep 26 '18

He's got a dedicated fanbase too. As long as Thug is happy in life and continues to put out good music I don't care, I'll be there to support him

→ More replies (5)

327

u/ststone4614 Sep 26 '18

Na, this album isn't his best. It's good to hear a short clean project from him though.

Idk what Thug needs to do to stay relevant. His sound is as great as it ever was, but maybe the wow-factor is slipping away with the market saturated by his copycats.

81

u/cuse23 Sep 26 '18

Im a huge Thugger fan and think this album was pretty good but not his best, but let's not forget that when he came everyone called him a Lil Wayne copycat and he even basically admitted as such. There's space for him and his copycats he's just gotta keep releasing things that push his sound forwards like Beautiful Thugger Girls. I think this was a good baby step but he's gotta keep evolving. I don't think he's ever gonna break out into household superstar status like everyone hopes but he should at least have a long solid career as an underrated artist with a sizable fan base thats extremely dedicated

23

u/kickthefavelas Sep 26 '18

Tbf his older stuff sounded way more like Wayne than his later projects. I think he definitely morphed it into a sound that he can call his own.

5

u/cuse23 Sep 26 '18

Yeah that's what I was tryin to say he's been adapting and fine tuning his sound hes gotta keep creating beautiful thugger music without worrying about becoming a pop star and he'll fly right away from these up and coming wannabe Thuggers

51

u/radicalexponents Sep 26 '18

He helped create a sort of copycat that has blown up in the last few months which is Gunna. You listen to Oh Okay with Thug, Gunna, and Lil baby it is difficult to distinguish between any of them lol.

31

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Personally I think Gunna is reasonably distinguishable, but Lil Baby sounds extremely similar.

40

u/bigpenisdragonslayer Sep 26 '18

I don't think any of them sound similar but I also listen to them constantly so maybe my ears are different now

10

u/twerkallknight Sep 26 '18

lil baby reminds me more of rich homie quan than thugger.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/ssonti Sep 26 '18

everyone needs to listen to cop me a foreign top5 thug verses I love when he does shit like that it’s similar to his verse on Meek Mill - We Ball

3

u/PhillyFreezer_ . Sep 26 '18

He helped create a sort of copycat that has blown up in the last few months which is Gunna

Gunna to me took his whole style from Rich Homie Quan

→ More replies (2)

29

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Idk what Thug needs to do to stay relevant

Drop Hy!£UN35.

Or at least a proper album with hit singles/videos and promotion.

→ More replies (4)

99

u/TTSOLOQPLS Sep 26 '18

I disagree about his sound being as great as it ever was. I think Slime Season 3 was his best sound and I feel like he’s gotten really far from that with a sound that’s, in my opinion, pretty boring and repetitive.

72

u/Ring_The_Bell Sep 26 '18

Barter 6 is easily his most solid project imo. You cant find a track on that album that wasnt amazing.

12

u/ssonti Sep 26 '18

i rather play ss3 over b6 any day because of the bird man verses alone

but that aside i feel like barter 6 cohesiveness gets overrated hard

12

u/Wh_ton Sep 26 '18

It’s extremely cohesive, the whole album fits an elegant, luxurious vibe throughout. Also birdmans menacing laid back flow is a perfect contrast to thug and imo sounds refreshing. The album is a perfect introduction and showcase to everything thug excels at. Ss3 is definitely a stellar album but I wouldn’t say it’s any more cohesive than B6

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

200

u/AsclepiusofHealing Sep 26 '18

JEFFERY was peak thug for me.

130

u/maplesoftwizard Sep 26 '18

When JEFFERY came out I was convinced it was gonna be a breakout success for Thug.

25

u/AsclepiusofHealing Sep 26 '18

For sure, Wyclef Jean is one of the best sounding hip hop songs in recent memory. The beat and the cadence is phenomenal. Harambe is experimental as fuck and just bangs even though it really shouldn’t

→ More replies (1)

36

u/SirWynBach Sep 26 '18

See, I thought everyone would feel this way. I’m a little surprised by the die hard thugger fans who say that ss3 and barter 6 are his best projects. I’ve only listened through those projects once each, but they seemed pretty easy to dismiss as generic trap albums that run too long. I guess maybe I’m just sick of the trap sound as a whole, but I always thought thug’s whole appeal was his zany voice over more beautiful/experimental production. But even on Jeffery, it seemed like was just scratching the surface of his potential.

16

u/maplesoftwizard Sep 26 '18

Well I'm gonna have to disagree with that. If you thought there wasn't some crazy vocals and excellent production on ss3 then idk what you were listening to. Go give it another spin because other than JEFFREY, idk if anything else he does has touched that sound

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

barter 6 is so much better. his verses are way more intricate. he doesn't care about sounding "cleaner". Halftime and Check are much much better than anything on Jeffery

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

12

u/TTSOLOQPLS Sep 26 '18

Although not as much as SS3, I loved JEFFERY. I think they’re similar in the sense of unpredictability and versatility which are Thug’s strengths and best traits imo, I just think that these strengths are more exaggerated on SS3. Compare this to On The Rvn, tracks 1,2, and 5 all sound the same and are super predictable.

8

u/Wh_ton Sep 26 '18

Wait are you saying on the run, icey, and real in my veins all the sound the same and are super predictable? Cause i don’t think so at all

→ More replies (2)

3

u/blosweed Sep 26 '18

Big facts

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

barter 6 rapping is so much better. he sounded cleaner on jeffery. idk i think that was a clear step down and kinda set him on a downward path until On the Rvn

2

u/yungQuantum Sep 26 '18

Anybody fucked with Thug since the 1017 Thug days? Thats what really put me on to him. Such a dope mixtape imo, it was so different than anything out there at the time, I feel like this tape went so under the radar.

→ More replies (18)

18

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Also remember that SS3 came out 2 years ago, which for Thugger is like 2 centuries, but for most artists is usually less than the time between albums.

Even Barter 6 was only 3 years ago. It's not like he's 20 years past his prime. His prime was practically yesterday so it's possible we can get new Thugger music on that level.

I think the fear for his fans, and myself included, is that he's rich and comfortable now, so he's not as hungry as he was 2 years ago, but that fear is there for a lot of artists who go on to release dope projects, and I still think Thugger has it in him.

8

u/bowtie25 Sep 26 '18

SS3 I agree was the best mix of melody and rapping followed by barter 6 or SS2

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

he is relevant? People just dont buy his music

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Yeah I’m actually becoming a fan of Gunna. I’m surprised Young Thug is cool with Gunna. If young thug is Coca Cola then gunna is Kroger brand cola.

2

u/21Dawg Sep 26 '18

Young Thug is the reason we have Gunna. He got him big by featuring him over and over on his songs. So really Gunna would be like New Coke

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

this album is not barter 6 but its up there with anything else he as ever done

1

u/bigcrustyy Sep 26 '18

Anyone who thinks this album is his best hasn’t listened to his stuff that’s not on Spotify lol

→ More replies (36)

22

u/PotatoMonkee . Sep 26 '18

Thug’s music from 2013 through the end of ‘15 was, on its face and down to its core, engrossing, exhilarating, and relentlessly innovative. He was, during that stretch, probably the best rapper on the planet.

He had a great run but come on now, best rapper is a little bit of a stretch.

It’s why—not to over-read Twitter syntax—rappers like Gunna, who are plainly Thug’s children, are talked about as “replacing” him, when in reality Thug has just turned 27 and, by all indications, has at least a little more left in the tank.

Completely agree here. To me Gunna sounds like a very uninteresting Thugger clone. He doesn't seem to have the versatility that Thug does. But perhaps this is what it's going to take to make Thugger go pop. A dialed-down version of Thug.

I think On the Rvn is as solid as it gets from Thug. A couple bangers, some vocal flexing, a few funny quotables and an uplifting jam. If his next album is as focused and polished as this tape I'll be very happy.

→ More replies (1)

270

u/HappyHandel Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

It's just goofy, you know? Motherfuckers really think you're just gonna be hot forever. But there's only one Drake, and having a dedicated cult fanbase is more important in the longterm, just look at how dudes like Keef and SGP built careers on keeping the superfans around. And unlike those two, Thug maintains his relevancy in the mainstream through his high profile cosigns and flood of constant music.

227

u/Awhile2 . Sep 26 '18

Claiming SGP still has a career of some sorts is a little generous

10

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Bad example, but he does have somewhat of a cult following. Not enough to live comfortably obviously since he was recently homeless

60

u/UchihaRaiden Sep 26 '18

SGP is a big stretch. Dude is just idolized by edgy internet kids and he's a big homophobe. Miss me with that.

8

u/Skrong Sep 26 '18

I mean his production was spearheading the main wave of that early SC wave so his art deserves praise. Everything outside of that is weird shit. lmao

20

u/livintheshleem Sep 26 '18

Honestly what ever happened to him? Haven't heard of him doing anything in at least 5 years.

48

u/chr1syx Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

last time I heard from him was when he spoke an ancient curse on A boogie wit da hoodie and this other guy via twitter after they jumped Lil B at a festival

55

u/blazblue5 . Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

he shitposts on twitter and I think I saw him post nudes of azaelia banks once but dont quote me on that

Edit: sauce NSFWNSFWNSFWNSFW https://twitter.com/bskullldragon/status/1039553448264585216?s=21

26

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Tbf that's more of a career than I have

18

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

lmao can you imagine how unhealthy a relationship between sgp and azalea banks would be? two most psychotic people in the entertainment industry

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/east_is_Dead Sep 26 '18

He was homeless a year or two ago

8

u/JoinTheFightersGuild Sep 26 '18

lmao his Wikipedia article says "was" a rapper, "was" a producer all over the first paragraph. Someone's memeing him hard.

48

u/YoungZen Sep 26 '18

Yeah uhhh keef and sgp in the same category of 'superfans' is a stretch

29

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

keef definitely has an extreme cult following lol go check out r/ChiefKeef

27

u/YoungZen Sep 26 '18

that was my point... sgp has one too just nowhere near the same degree

9

u/Ezekiiel . Sep 26 '18

That sub literally had a guy "run up on" 69 and get stomped out just to be for reddit clout

15

u/DOPEITSDOM_ Sep 26 '18

I agree with this. And would just like to add that as long as he sticks to his script, I will (and people like me) will continue to be his fan.

I mean the dude is a clear influence on what is happening on that side of hiphop. I listen because of his versatility, his talent, and his overall dopeness. Numbers aint everything and Thug has proven to be a true artist, in almost every sense.

2

u/LittleBastard13 Sep 26 '18

Yeah thugger has by far become my favorite artist in the last few years. He just has so much different sounding songs. Kinda why i dont fuck w Travis as much as i used to.. his music is starting to all sound too similar

2

u/BryanBeast13 Sep 26 '18

Should have said Lil Ugly Mane instead of SGP

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Keef superfans and SGP superfans are totally different lol. I could see somebody still supporting Keef in 2018, but not SGP.

→ More replies (1)

80

u/BonelikeDoctor Sep 26 '18

incredible how a song like "High" has just been sitting around in the studio for the better part of two years. I would love to see what else Thug has kept hidden away on his hard drives, he's created so much music but hasn't released a solo album that really satisfied my Thugger craving since Barter 6 imo

46

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

If Jeffery or On the Rvn didn’t satisfy your Thugger craving, I think he’s moved on a bit from the Barter 6 sound. But who knows, he may have several albums worth of material from that era.

16

u/BonelikeDoctor Sep 26 '18

don't get me wrong, i love Jeffrey and On the Rvn, but Jeffrey felt like more of an inventive collection of songs Thug had lying around, and on the rvn isn't really an album. Barter 6 was a true 13-song-long project which really had some purpose and concept behind it. SS3 has come the closest to hitting that standard but isn't nearly as cohesive as Barter

7

u/BonelikeDoctor Sep 26 '18

don't get me wrong, i love Jeffrey and On the Rvn, but Jeffrey felt like more of an inventive collection of songs Thug had lying around, and on the rvn isn't really an album. Barter 6 was a true 13-song-long project which really had some purpose and concept behind it. SS3 has come the closest to hitting that standard but isn't nearly as cohesive as Barter

5

u/randocalrissian17 Sep 26 '18

I don’t know that I would use the words boncept or bohesive to describe a Thugger project, but I understand Barter 6 being your favorite. It’s just not my favorite era of Thugger.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/nick182 Sep 26 '18

Is everyone listening to the same EP? The production on this project is incredible and Thugger's flow is innovative as always. Not as unique as something like SS2 but it's still a unique Thug project.

13

u/denimxdragon Sep 26 '18

There are so many artists out there that constantly put music out just because they want to. People that don’t get hyped up at all. But Young Thug is very much so in the light and regardless his fans will always want to listen to him. Like Roc Marciano or Ka, Thug will probably keep putting music out as long as he wants to.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Exhibit A: Gucci Mane

19

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Gucci had crossover hits throughout his career

8

u/TheRevMerril Sep 26 '18

Do people remember this dude was on “Havana”?

8

u/valoremz Sep 26 '18

I remember when people just thought he was a copy of Wayne.

8

u/HaHaWalaTada Sep 26 '18

Thug drops songs that i like on every project and some of his projects are solid from front to back. Even as an "old head" what more could i ask from an artist? Thugga is my guy..

65

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Jeffery was his best

62

u/The_Crownless_King Sep 26 '18

I prefer SS 1-3 and Barter but to each their own

27

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Barter 6 is up there too

→ More replies (7)

6

u/tpcrb Sep 26 '18

forreal man i feel like a bunch of people here haven't listened to all of SS1, no one mentions it when they're talking about peak thug. best beats and thugger flows out of all his projects imo.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Quarterback is peak thug and quavo for me, that albums had hits

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

draw down and again are two GOAT trap songs

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Superrandy Sep 26 '18

Me too. I find everything Jeffrey and newer to not be as good. It all sounds too samey for me, production, flows, etc.

21

u/AmericanHerstoryX Sep 26 '18

are you just completely forgetting about BTG

→ More replies (24)

14

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

How was it too samey? Future Swag sounds nothing like Kanye West. Wyclef Jean sounds nothing like Riri, etc.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

id put the tour and b6 over jeffrey

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Honestly I do not understand how b6 isn't undisputed best thug album. Nothing comes close

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Philipwangchang Sep 26 '18

Slime season 3 for me but I think on the run might be top 3. I just really like when London on da track and young thug work together

18

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Yes it is

Jeffrey > Barter 6 > I'm Up

I'm Up is so slept on it's crazy...

has Hercules, King Troup, For My People, Ridin.......all top tier Thug songs

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

fam how you gonna forget BTG? That was IMO right there with Jeffery as his best. Listen to it again that is peak Thug

4

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

was only doing top 3

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

listen to barter 6 again if you think this

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tree_dweller Sep 26 '18

wheres BTG?

3

u/ssonti Sep 26 '18

good project minus his family’s verses lmao

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

yes lmao those were terrible!

2

u/Awhile2 . Sep 26 '18

its BTG > Tha tour > Barter 6 > SS1 > SS2 > 1017 Thug> Jeffery > On the rxn > SS3 > Im Up imo

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

jeffery is his most mainstream but barter is his peak so far

1

u/1Wallet0Pence Sep 27 '18

1017 Thug, Tha Tour and Barter 6 are Thug at his absolute best it’s only been downhill since

→ More replies (2)

12

u/bigpenisdragonslayer Sep 26 '18

I've been a thugger stan since SS1 and I really don't think On The Rvn is near his best. It was good, but nowhere near his best.

Can't deny he's in a bit of a lull right now though. Imo the best things for his career right now would be either:

  • Just take a break, dude's given us a lifetime's worth of work and he's only 27. burn out is real and I don't want that to happen to him

  • Rap more, we all know how versatile he is but when I heard his verse on Sacrifices (and that Bryson tiller track, to a lesser extent), I legitimately didn't know he could do that and want to hear more of it

  • Get more personal with his lyrics. I don't really care about lyrics usually, but that being said when he said "My last two years were the worst ones in my career" on that Lil Baby song, it was kinda refreshing to hear him open up even a little bit

But all that being said I'm not really too worried and I don't feel a ticking clock. Sure I'd like if he was more popular but whatever, I just hope he's doing ok.

12

u/57809 Sep 26 '18

Noisey is so fucking terrible I swear

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Surgawd8 Sep 26 '18

People thought thug was gonna huge and up there on the charts with Kendrick/drake/Cole after I’m up, barter 6, slime season 3 etc but he just kept it lowkey and never went mainstream

2

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

No, He released Jeffrey and disappointed all of his fans with his new bull shit sound

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/Superrandy Sep 26 '18

I love Thugger, but I feel like he is not as good post SS3. If "High" wasn't on On The Rvn then I don't think anyone would be talking about the tape. His production has just been so incredibly boring to me for awhile. It's either not hard enough to be a banger or not catchy enough to be a pop success. It's often the same sing songy flow over the same style of production thats super predictable.

46

u/The_Crownless_King Sep 26 '18

I've had Sin on repeat since I first heard it.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

its a banger

4

u/succ_my_dicc Sep 26 '18

Sin is soooo good. Easily my top song from the album. It’s catchy af + it bangs on my subs. Idk what the guy you replied to is talking about

37

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

High is certainly a selling point but On The Run, Sin, and Climax are imo some of his best work and the other two tracks are great as well

His projects pre SS3 and post Jefferey have been off to me but this is a return to form

24

u/yunginvesta Sep 26 '18

BTG is fucking epic yeeehawww

3

u/squabblez Sep 26 '18

I'm in love with this comment

20

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

His production has just been so incredibly boring to me for awhile. It's either not hard enough to be a banger or not catchy enough to be a pop success.

Holy cannoli is this ever accurate. It's all so middle of the road. Dude used to switch around from shit like Notice Me to something like Raw (Might Just) to something dark as fuck like Stunna or Freaky. I miss that so much. Everything now just sounds so fucking safe and sleek. Gimme some vintage unmastered Metro and Wheezy with Thugger doing 10 different flows over it.

2

u/concrete_manu . Sep 27 '18

At least Jeffery and BBTG were going for something interesting and different. On the rvn / slime language is thug returning to the pure trap sound and he's honestly been eclipsed by Uzi in this realm

1

u/Awhile2 . Sep 26 '18

id agree if it wasnt for BTG being my favorite thugger project.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/viewtiful_alan Sep 26 '18

I don't really care what Young Thug sells, but it does feel like a symptom of a larger problem. I want to hear at least one more project that feels thought through and cohesive the way Barter 6 did. His discography is extremely enjoyable, I just need that classic full-length album.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

This post is what happens when you let white kids congregate to talk about rap. The article. These comments. Y’all have no idea what the fuck you’re talking about

2

u/InanimateSensation Sep 26 '18

Yo I just want more solo Thugger

2

u/GabrilliusMordechai Sep 26 '18

How was On the Rvn his best? It's only 6 songs, And high was a leak anyways.

4

u/_Dil_ . Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

Before reading this article and scrolling through the comments, I had no idea that people/fans viewed Thug as a star who never reached his peak, or that his "clock is ticking" in some way. Albeit I'm a big Thug fan, these thoughts never crossed my mind.

In my opinion, he's easily one of the biggest stars in hip-hop and unquestionably has had been one of the most influential rappers of his generation. Regarding him as an artist and his music stalling out; his foundation as a rapper is creativity. His most unique skill is his ability to experiment with his voice, which allows him to constantly create new sounds and expand the boundaries of what he can do as a rapper. Unlike Pokemon, Thug has the ability to constantly evolve. Who knows what Thug is going to sound like it in 2020, but I bet its something unique.

Not hating on the article or anyone's opinion, I'm just legitimately shocked that this is even a conversation people are having.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PDaviss Sep 26 '18

This was one of his best? Its pretty forgettable music in general. I’ve listened to multiple projects of his and again I feel like I’m missing the moon. Here and there are a good song, but nothing feels complete or thought out or professional. Idk just dont get it

14

u/dz0id Sep 26 '18

I don’t think many of his fans would say it’s one of his best. I’m a huge fan of thug and have listened to all of his mixtapes and while I like this one he’s definitely been down hill since Barter 6. Try listening to the Slime Season tapes if you haven’t, thug in his prime. Drugged out flows over really ethereal beats. He’s gotten a lot more “generic sounding” since then and uses the same couple flows with overlong hooks. I also really love the 1017 thug era and his work with Gucci but it sounds very different from what he’s doing now

4

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

its one of his bests imo. No skippables and i think id put High and Climax in his top 15. Songs are crazy good

3

u/Fig_Newton_ Sep 26 '18

This is my favorite since SS3.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

thug's sales have actually been improving this whole time

2

u/hysro . Sep 26 '18

I respect that a lot of you guys love Thugger...But I think you guys need to realize that you're probably the vocal minority. You don't need to dig for some crazy reasoning for album sales...He just doesn't do it for a lot of people. You either like him or want nothing to do with him, and most people I know fall into the latter.

2

u/Brospective Sep 27 '18

Album sucked tbh.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

No offence but is there a sub with old school hiphop? I really dislike most of these new age rappers.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

Try r/aarp

1

u/thebbwbs . Sep 26 '18

Thug is good. I've been saying this for too long. Thug is more of an A&R and it shows in the people he works with.

1

u/ramatheson Sep 26 '18

He spelled "run" incorrectly.

1

u/InsaneAsylumDoctor Sep 27 '18

It's to make sure the FBI can't figure out his plans with their automatic search surveillance systems ofcourse

1

u/datf00l Sep 26 '18

I'm surprised people didn't turn on him after he started wearing dresses lol

1

u/RoachboyRNGesus Sep 27 '18

Um try again sweetie, he hasn't even dropped Hytunes yet (which is his debut album)... /s

1

u/culture_vulture811 Sep 27 '18

I’m just waiting till this guy releases an actual LP. My guy keeps releases mixtapes and EPS. The shit is good but I would like him to put his full effort into an actual studio debut

1

u/SillyHipster Sep 27 '18

So is Thugger on the KOD tour still or what? I saw he was at the 9/18 date which was after this all went down but I can't find a definitive answer anywhere.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

If you don’t know the difference between blonde hair thug and every other version of young thug you have no fucking business commenting on this thread, that accounts for 95% percent of this sub so of course all these responses I’m reading are bullshit

2

u/lssue Sep 27 '18

facts. nobody here has ever listened to OG thug, which is undoubtedly his best work. 1017 thug and ICFN1/2 are incredible, as are all the slime seasons.

1

u/kidkidnate5 Sep 27 '18

Buddy floated on this project good grief sheeesh 6/6 word to 6lack and especially Jado Smith for laying down a 16 as cold as the Rockies

1

u/Off-White_Pizza Sep 27 '18

Thugger bailed on me at the cole concert. Fuck em

1

u/BassFromThePast Sep 26 '18

Yo how is no one gonna fucking mention this goofy ass title, it sounds like a buzzfeed article lmao

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

"People think this. Is it true? In fact, it is not, and here's why"

what editor fucking ok'ed that lol

-2

u/snowavess Sep 26 '18

I don't like young thug

1

u/punk-assnerd Sep 26 '18

Lupe Fiasco is 36 (9 years older than thug) and just arguably released his best album yet. Age is just a number, and does not measure ability whatsoever.

-1

u/SFThirdStrike Sep 26 '18

Young Thug is possibly as big as he's going to get..a meme rapper.

0

u/throwaway19969 Sep 26 '18

He's a horrible rapper/singer or whatever just terrible