r/AtomicPorn • • Aug 13 '17

Desert Rock I - Buster-Jangle Dog - November 1, 1951 [600×738]

Post image
93 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/Adamaaa123 Aug 13 '17

Anyone know how far away these men would have been from the blast out of curiosity?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '17

I believe 10 miles was standard. They then had the soldiers March Into the aftermath. How far into it, I don't know, but the fallout raining down on them was a sure death sentence.

10

u/jumpinjezz Aug 14 '17

This was an airburst. There would have been very little local fallout.

It looks like the dose was around 3 Röntgens which isn't too much. It's an old unit that is hard to convert without knowing what type of radiation they were exposed too.

Nukes are amazing weapons, but the stigma of radiation means they are often misunderstood.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '17

The fallout has to go somewhere, it's not all going to be scattered by the wind.

1

u/jumpinjezz Aug 15 '17

True, but it depends on a number of factors. Type of nuke, detonation height, wind, weather (Rain etc) and other things all affect how much fallout is local and how much is carried away. An air-burst on a clear but windy day is going to have a lot less local fallout than a cratering shot on a still day.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '17

Agreed, I just don't think it's accurate to say the effects will be minimal. They will be if that fallout doesn't rain down upon them. But I've heard of plenty of instances of these soldiers getting cancer.

1

u/jumpinjezz Aug 15 '17

You originally said a "death sentence". I'm saying that the radiation exposure these soldiers had is not a death sentence. There may be an increase in cancers compared to other soldiers that served at a similar time, but its only a few %.

The people who were most affected by these tests were the "Downwinders" the people living well to the east of the Nevada test site, where the fallout actually came down.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '17

The reason I say that was because of Castle Bravo and the sorry of sailers being trapped in their ships for days due to the unexpected fallout. I remember reading their conclusion being the same as mine, that it would have been a death sentence.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '17

I also just found a source, saying that the a survey of the servicemen, who marched towards the detonation, a large portion were found to have leukemia. So while maybe not an immediate death sentence, it certainly had horrible Heath effects.

1

u/jumpinjezz Aug 24 '17

The survey talks about Operation Plumbbob and Desert Rock VII and VIII. This photo is for Desert Rock I, after Dog shot of Operation Buster Jangle.

In this case, the troops in this photo had minimal radiation exposure. It was an airburst with no local fallout.

The survey talks about a different nuke test, which was a ground burst. I would expect there to be significant exposure to the troops. There were 10 cases of leukemia, instead of the expected 4, given the sample size. That's .003% of the troops exposed. It's not a death sentence for all of them.

You're not wrong, radiation is deadly & nukes produce radiation, it's just not as scary or deadly as people think.

1

u/Adamaaa123 Aug 13 '17

I'm only starting to learn of the destruction these bombs can cause lately. I obviously knew they were bad but maan still can't comprehend

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '17

I'm not sure anyone can really comprehend without seeing first hand, and I'm not sure anyone else wants that. YouTube videos don't do it justice.

2

u/Ambae Aug 14 '17

It's sorta odd when you recognize a nuclear explosion