Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
It looks like she’s kissing it; in the book, she kissed the one she wrote to Roger just before she discovered the letter from Frank in the desk. But I could see it being Roger’s since she’s likely not going to get it through mail after the desk has been disassembled with only two episodes left.
I’ve been wondering if she really needs the letter from Roger since she’s already decided she and the kids need to go to him and the show has pretty much already established that focusing on a certain person can help you steer, so wouldn’t the stones take her to the right year anyway, without her even knowing he’s in 1739?
I’m also thinking there’s not enough time to include both Roger’s letter and Frank’s and I’m not even sure if we need Frank’s (Brianna already knows he knew about her mother going back in time being true and all that). Although the show version of the prophecy actually makes more sense in that it is immediate danger for Brianna but we’ve already been over that once before with Geillis. I don’t know.
I think it’s hard on them too, or at least beginning to be. Roger thinks he is dead and has a splitting headache when he goes back with Buck. Brianna’s atrial fibrillation in Bees is probably caused by time travel, similar to Buck’s heart issues. So I think that is consistent with Claire who, in the books, thinks that going through the stones once again (which would be her fourth time) would kill her. Roger is on 3 now, Brianna on 2. They’ll both be on 4 by the time they reunite with Claire and Jamie, and in the book they admit it was an incredibly difficult passage that only succeeded because the kids (who will be on 3) were able to steer them.
i know john tried to disguise his accent to sound less Fancy English when he was captured by americans the second time in the books... props to david berry for not adjusting his accent not just from australian to english, but the degree of englishness to suit the situation lol
I can't unhear how much John's accent sounds like Peter Dinklage in Game of Thrones. Did they have the same voice coach?
The groom comment was definitely too on the nose
Letter from Roger should be next week
How is William an idiot? He's been so upstanding with Jane and her sister. He can't have known that Richardson is a spy from the future who wants to hurt his family through him
Lafayette’s speech/ cadence reminded me a little of the King of France , he immediately came to mind when I heard him speak 2 different actors but maybe that’s why he seemed so familiar to you .
At first I thought he kinda looked like Fergus. I knew it wasn't him, but he hasn't been in an episode in quite a while so I don't have a super clear picture in my mind of how he looks. But it could be the French thing more than their appearances.
Here we have a display of Hal's opinion about Revolutionary War - I guess it will somehow be connected to Richardson. We also hear that John used his middle names in previous episodes.
I really like that John has his own view of the war and he is not blindly agreeing to what Hal says, despite Hal being in the house of Lords and all.
Pennsylvania, 1778
John swearing an oath 😅 I am laughing but I know John doesn’t take any oath easily, no matter how fake or forced it is.
Title Cards - Betsy Rose stitching a star on the flag - there will be talk about it during an episode.
Jamie puting the chandelier, like the house is his 🤣
Omg, I can only imagine John's reaction to the knowledge of the dinner in his house.
La Fayette! He is so sweet! There is Lee as well! I already dislike him.
Omg Claire eating the eels, I laughed aloud!
Percy is there! And I loved they distinguished that there is no family connection between Claire and him there! Let it stay so!
Roquefort cheese, remember that name!😊
Aww Fanny, and William's change in posture when he meets her. Such a gentleman!
Jane speaks Latin. Interesting! I like Frances already!
Bree is such a brave woman. She actually got back to kick some asses!!
Callahan is Richardson ?!?!?! Is that the same actor?!
I really like the actress playing Jane!
Jamie inspecting his troops. Bixby is there. Claire seeing John 😂
Omg, John's eye is horrible!
If what I see with my good eye is real, you needn't bother with the state of this one🤣🤣 John, the king of humour!
John Jamie Claire , the 3 of them are such a mess !!
I like the dove reference!
Fanny 💛 , I started to cry when she came and thanked William.
Richardson, the snake. So, William is going to Hessians, but not to Knyphausen as I assumed.
Percy and John background info plus new info about Richardson - OMG, so tense! John revealed Percy's real name (Perseverance) to Jamie and Claire !! I am sure there is a good reason for it! Since in the books he doesn't reveal that to anyone.
Ye dinna get used to it, believe me. Save our son - Great lines!
I was nodding my head as I read your comment. Agree on all points.
Yeah. I’m pretty sure that Callahan is Richardson. Definitely looks like the same actor and they made a big deal out of showing his face when Rob called out to him. Callahan wasn’t listed in the credits, though. So, we don’t have definitive confirmation yet. Are we still supposed to be guessing if it’s him??
Actors usually don’t get credits in this show if they don’t have any (substantial) lines; if they get more screen time, they’re usually featured extras, which someone playing Callahan would’ve been if they hadn’t intended for him to be Richardson as well.
Ben Lambert is listed as Captain Richardson and he likely would’ve had to be listed as Captain Richardson / Callahan if he had spoken (compare to the Hessian soldier who greets William at the end of the episode—he’s just listed as “Hessian soldier” but he did have a couple of words to say). Plus they probably don’t want to give it away in the credits if people don’t realize 😅 But yeah, it definitely looked like him… unfortunately.
Hey, at least it seems like they’ve decided he looks different but similar enough in the two time periods by making him wear a wig vs. his natural hair. Thats should mean no plastic surgery, right?
We also hear that John used his middle names in previous episodes.
I kind of chuckled at this. It's a good thing everyone in that time period had like half a dozen names so they always have an alias handy. :D (Alexander Malcolm being the other obvious one.)
I realize I'm a week behind and maybe nobody will see this, but sharing thoughts/questions anyway. (Baffled they chose to air Xmas week... I didn't have chance to watch til 1/2)
I flipped thru the show only thread first- I was curious if any viewers thought "Callahan" looked familiar. It's on nobody's radar at all, which is great! But it was such a quick glimpse of the face, it's not surprising. I had to pause and literally walk up right to the TV to see him more clearly - but I'm pretty sure it's the Richardson actor. I rewound on my viewing like 3 times to try to see :) I watched the credits - "Callahan" isn't listed, unless I missed him. That ommission I think confirms that at least in the show, they are in fact the same - otherwise they'd have listed John Doe as the actor - but this way they don't have to list Richardson's actor as Callahan too and spoil it.
In the books, doesn't Ernie know about time travelling as well? The show made it seem like he's out of the loop.
I thought the shootout scene was good. Sophie did really well with all that! I felt the 80s timeline was the best part of the episode overall.
I've just read MOBY once so far, and it was like 2 years ago so details are fuzzy - I purposefully didnt want to read 7 or 8 again too close to it airing so that I could experience the show's version fresh-ish. So I'm really debating what did or didn't happen in the books now and hoping to be straightened out.... Jamie and LJG never met/saw each other again after "we were both f*ng you"- right? As of his kidnapping in Bees, they've not spoken? The whole LJG surrendering to him, becoming his prisoner and paroling him - this is all BRAND new stuff, yes? And I don't recall this specific threat on William either where Richardson again sets him up. This quest to save him is also different?
The dinner scene --- just a few too many "wink wink" overt, obligatory War nods that made it kinda "meta" for the audience. A bit heavy handed at times for me. But watching her eat that jellied eel was amusing, so all is forgiven!!! Lol
Percy - the scene between he and John alone was a true highlight! I was glad to see several commenters who are clearly show-only people say that this exchange piqued their interest on the backstory of the two! "Allowed to touch me"....looking forward to more between those two in future episodes hopefully
Jamie and LJG never met/saw each other again after "we were both f*ng you"- right? As of his kidnapping in Bees, they've not spoken? The whole LJG surrendering to him, becoming his prisoner and paroling him - this is all BRAND new stuff, yes? And I don't recall this specific threat on William either where Richardson again sets him up. This quest to save him is also different?
No, it’s mostly from the book. I don’t think they speak per se, but Jamie is definitely made aware of John (and Germain) among his militiamen so John gives him his parole. Claire operates on John’s eye, but it’s Germain and Fergus who assist her, not Jamie. Then, Jamie basically leaves him to his own devices without revoking his parole and giving him an opportunity to escape, which means he’s still Jamie’s prisoner as the battle begins. Fergus and Germain watch John escape from the tent he was left at, quickly followed by Percy. They only come face to face after he leaves the Continental camp, somewhere in the woods (not in his own house in Philly). Percy tells him about Richardson’s being an American spy and his plans (the plot with the Hessians is show-only but the gist is the same—Richardson has tried to ruin the Greys’ reputation by making William appear associated with Rebels, and now he’s planning to capture him). At some point during the battle, John runs into Jamie and tells him he has reasons to believe William is in danger, which prompts Jamie to revoke his parole and send him on his way towards the British army.
They do speak again, though, after John and Hal come to wherever Claire is staying when she’s recovering from her gunshot. That’s only when John tells him specifically about Richardson and they believe that he’s taken William to Philadelphia. But then it turns out William’s been off searching for Jane and Fanny, he finds Rachel and injured Ian, and they make a deal: Rachel will take Jane and Fanny to some local Quakers to keep them safe from whoever’s after them for Harkness’ murder, and William will take Ian to Claire and Denny. John, Hal, and William finally reunite before the double Quaker wedding, which William doesn’t attend because he goes off looking for Ben. I can’t remember if Jamie and John speak at the wedding but I think that is the last time they see each other (John and Claire see each other again in Savannah, though).
I had never heard the phrase "god's blood" until John said "god's blood Claire!" a few episodes back. We've now heard it a total of 4 times in 6 episodes (and 2 in one ep). Is this the new, multi character "Jesus H Roosevelt Christ" ahaha.
Claire's face with the eels😂😂😂
I'm also absolutely loving the high level of LJG content. In previous seasons he would only really turn up for an episode or two at a time, and he's such a great character and David Berry is such a great actor. John is hilarious and the look on Jamie and John's face when Claire was describing the eyeball twist was great.
I noticed that too this ep when William said it and I thought about how often it’s been said lately. Although I do remember hearing “god’s tooth” from someone once or twice. Maybe from Murtagh in the early seasons.
It was Geordi in the print shop when Claire came back after 20 years and thought claire and jamie were in the middle of 'sexy time' when he walked in. He said "gods tooth, it's not even noon yet" LOL...one of my favourite lines in the series.
God, I really love the actress playing Jane! That casting was so damned good! The scenes with her and William are fantastic! I kind of wish they would Murtaugh her. I did notice that Fanny doesn't seem to have any kind of speech problems. I hope the casting for Aramanthus is equally as excellent.
You can always tell when DG writes a script because the dialogue is so on point. This episode really felt like early seasons of Outlander to me. I really enjoyed it!
And some of her dialogue is just...like when she was describing how she'd killed Harkness and said matter of factly, Fanny started screaming but they expected that, you know. Eww.
That said, the whore with a heart of gold trope is kind of overdone. She really doesn't look like someone who's been a prostitute since she was ten.
I agree about the writing. I was so looking forward to this episode because DG wrote it. The characters always feel most like themselves when when she is the main writer and I love how she manages to include tidbits for book readers.
In the opening sequence there is a shot of a lock of hair in a small hanker chief - I belive this to be Jane’s lock of hair being opened by Fanny I don’t belive the show will keep her around However I am enjoying her in scenes. I do think this actress and Sophie(Bri) look incredibly alike .
I truly hope its just a coincidence. I would HATE the trope of Faith being alive after all and had daughters. I hope that passage in the book is merely left at wishful thinking on the part of Claire as a mom contemplating and hoping for a different "what might have been"
Plus 1 - William being in love with/sex with his half-niece. Gross.
2 - the implication from DG he may be end-game with Fanny - gross for same reasons, but now doubly so thanks to the show visuals where you literally see William-Fanny being close to the equivalent of say Bri (William's what 8 years younger than her?) having a romantic relationship with someone between the ages of her two own kids Jem/Mandy. Gross
And forget Aramanthus, that is the most boring story line in the books, save Jane instead!
It's probably too much of a call back to Mary Hawkins in Season 2 to give her a speech impediment and maybe they thought it would distract from a storyline that was dramatic enough.
I really want Jane to live here! If she does go on trial, without Hal around, will it be John involved in her trial and sentencing?
I did notice that Fanny doesn't seem to have any kind of speech problems.
I can't say for certain WHY they chose not to give her any speech problems, but what I can say is that there is very little evidence showing that a tongue tie causes speech problems. Plus, if a tongue tie DID cause speech problems, it would not be an interdental lisp (/s/ --> /th/), it would most likely be a lateral lisp (slushy /s/).
That scene between John and Percy... I kind of feel bad for show only watchers, because I feel like that scene was way more powerful knowing the entire background between them. Heck, even those who have only read the big books but not the Lord John novellas/stories have missed out. What a great scene.
I had a rare chance to watch in-person with my sister since we were together for the holiday. She's never read the books and after their scene she said to me "I take it from your face that they've got a history together" hahahaha.
Oh gosh, there's just so much to that relationship, I don't think I could even summarize it very well, but if you really want to be spoiled, here's a decent wiki summary about Percy that covers the key aspects in the assorted books and stories: https://outlander.fandom.com/wiki/Percy_Wainwright
Yeah I had to pause it and explain the LJ/Percy relationship to my partner and he was like sorry what? Is this some cheesy porno 😂 LJ has a gay relationship with his step brother, who then cheats on LJ and then LJ helps him escape being arrested and sentenced because they were caught in the act of 'sodomy'. It's complicated okay! Like Lord John was deeply in love with Percy and what he did to him was so painful and awful. But in fairness you could tell from LJ's face it pained him to see Percy again.
-Jane & Fanny seeking William's help (funny, impactful, poignant) -Claire/Jamie and their little cuddling + soft scene with the cheese -Claire/Jamie reuniting with John and THAT eye scene (Germaine, you're missed lol) -"OUR SON" !!!!!!
Honestly, I am enjoying Season 7B so much. This is the first season I've watched "live" if you will, as I binge-watched the rest this summer for the first time (also read the book series for the first time this summer). The casting is excellent. David Berry, Sam Heughan, Caitriona Balfe, and Charles Vandervaart are killing it.
Having read the books, there are SO MANY POV's to cram into this season and I think they're doing as good as can be expected pivoting between Roger, Bree, Ian/Rachel, William, John, Jamie/Claire. I am eating it up. Can't wait for the next episode.
There have been a lot of threads from people unhappy with 7B but I wonder if it's it's show- only people maybe? The huge gap between halves and the fast pace of stuff I know they're including when there's even more that's not... I am very much enjoying seeing the American revolution, it's actually what sucked me back in after the middle books felt so boring!
I feel like it might be a skewed representation though... People are more likely to complain about something that is "bad", rather than praise something that is "good" because the expectation is that it will be "good" so there's no point writing a post about fulfilling expectations.
And people just love to complain generally speaking: the sheer amount of different things that people have found to complain about, especially this season, is mind boggling to me. 90% of their complaints i haven't even noticed in the show, and the 10% that I do notice rarely bothers me, and never enough to make a whole post complaing about it. The complaints just irritate me so much:
The wigs are bad! (the only terrible wig I particularly noticed was Jenny's), the editing is weird, the acting quality generally is going downhill, Lord John is too pale, the transitions are clunky, Sophie is a terrible actress, (come onnnnnn, she's improved so much in recent seasons), the accents are bad, the wigs are not grey enough, Claire and Jamie are not wrinkled enough, "unpopular opinion, but I just hate Bree!", the camera angles are strange/the camera work is poor quality, the instrumental music is cheesy, Quaker speech annoys me, "[insert action here] is out of character" , Sophie doesn't look exactly like Bree (never mind all the other actors who also don't look like their characters), Claire and Jamie aren't as affectionate as they used to be, Sinead O'Connor's intro is terrible, "why do we have to focus so much on other characters??? I only care about Claire and Jamie!", the break between parts was too long, the makeup is terrible, the pacing is too fast, "why don't they go back to Scotland?", the story line doesn't make sense. "does anyone else just get so annoyed everytime they see Bree's face?" the plot doesn't make sense, the writing is terrible, "I miss season 1/2!"..... Feel free to add more!
I also feel like the book readers are more likely to like it because they have extra detail, and have already grown to love the storylines/characters, and are expecting the story.
Yet consistently each episode, the vast majority of people vote that they either loved it/mostly liked it.
So I think people overall do actually like this season.
I've legit seen every single one of those complaints, and I could probably come up with more... "Lord John is too pale" seriously?!?! If you hate it so much why bother watching lol
SAME! This season seems to be uniquely unpopular among the shownly people but man, I'm loving it. Might just be my favorite season of the show, period.
I would agree with this!!! I love S1, S3 (A. Malcom episode is all-time for me), and S5 but there is something about this current season that might trump them all for me. I love William and LJG’s storylines weaving into this season so much!!! I also feel like we see so much Bree and Roger growth.
I love it too. I can understand if you've never read the books, it might feel disjointed though. But as a book reader I see what they're doing and what they had to cut out. This episode felt very old Outlander too imo. Personally I just want loads more of Lord John 😂 I could watch him being a sassy bitch all day. Plus Brees fight for Lallybroch is the best part of the books. I'm sad they had to skip over a good chunk of it but I'm still loving it!
Starz said no to it. Writers etc were attached and David Berry signed a contract to do it - but Starz said no at the last minute apparently. If another network stepped in then Berry says he would love to do it still.
This and episode 10 have felt the most like Outlander in the whole season to me. Claire and Jamie's bedroom scene was sweet and felt genuine. William and Jane are incredible together, and there's a moment when Jane gives Fanny a look that looks EXACTLY how I pictured Jane from the books! AndCallaghan and Richardson appear to be the same actor!
It definitely looks like the same actor. Rob called the guy Callahan and then they did the close up of his face. They’re probably going to do some kind of flashback to it later. Show only people will be surprised.
This could've been like an hour of paint drying and then that scene and I'd still give it an A+ because PERCY!!!!!!
But for real this was great. I didn't know DG was writing an ep this season but you could tell (just like you could tell in S5) because it was funny! Was great especially getting to see John's classic wit after a rough few episodes for him.
And unsurprisingly for an ep written by DG, this was a real feast for readers. The appearance of book favs like Frances, the cheese, Mrs. Figg being the icon that she is, the scene with Ian's war paint. I just had a big grin on my face for the full hour. (Though I did roll my eyes a bit at the flag--this show loves its heavy handed symbolism hahahaha.)
But like I said uptop the single most important thing here is Percy hahaha. And I'm extra excited not just because he's a great character and I love his and John's very, very complicated history, but because a) they're involving him in a big piece of PLOT which makes it seem like he'll be around for longer and makes me think we might get more Hal, and b) they introduced the Beauchamp stuff which could mean that we're getting Fergus stuff next season. Very exciting . . .
And are we doing the insane Richardson plot?!??! Cause it sure seems like it.
I wasn’t aware DG wrote this ep but it makes so sense! Each character felt very true to their book personalities and I was loving every second of it! Claire’s bit in the scene with the soldier with consumption was a highlight for me. It felt like the first time we’ve truly seen her comedic side since S1 or 2, and one of my biggest gripes with the show is how much the writers seem to struggle to incorporate each character’s humor, so this ep was a breath of fresh air
She wrote Journeycake. The whole Roger and Bree time travel fakeout thing is weird (but obviously the showrunners decided on that, not DG), but all the J&C scenes are just so great and book-like.
I guess they needed a way to a) confirm Jemmy can time travel, b) show the Mackenzies choose 'home', c) get them away from the Ridge for Claire's attack. But yes, it was a little weird.
I was sure they weren’t going to show his face until you reminded us that Diana wrote this episode. Her voice was all over this script. I could just hear her trying to clarify all the plot points she thought were clear when she wrote them all those years ago.
She never described Callahan and Richardson so clearly that they could have been the same person (and Bree’s ridiculous conclusion based on William’s sketch was … sketchy at best - pun intended), but if we make the same actor play both roles, well now it’s crystal clear, isn’t it?
I could not wait to see what everyone thought about this reveal! When Bree was grasping for his ski mask I was freaking out. I have been wondering if they were going to go there or not. Leave it to DG.
the thing is basically that Richardson is a TT and that he is that same guy in the future with Bree. When Bree goes back she sorts of recognizes him and in the books she says he had plastic surgery before going back in time. He has his own agenda in the past and I really don’t want to spoil you more, won’t help you figure out more and it’s all part of the later part of book 9. We just have no clue what the show will do with him, so this little screenshot seems to tell us they may follow that line Edit: We are all waiting for book 10 😂
You can always combine the book with audiobook (when you cannot be sitting down hours reading) and you will get at it faster! 😂 I listened to the whole series in like 4 months including LJ and novellas. Now I am back to the books, much slower, catching on all sorts of things I missed by just focusing on the main plot and feel much more relaxed! I would be totally confused if I was just watching the show without the book context.
Thank you! Was looking for this "comment". :D It looked like Bree wasn't looking at Callahan at that very moment, but I imagine she will later on make the connection anyway because we got this image (to play as a flashback). I wish it could have been just a bit more obvious so that show only people could have already now picked it up also and become intrigued as to what on earth is going on.
Ok thank you for the side by side ! I had to go back and pause on Callaghan’s face , then Richardson’s face and compare - I even watched the credits , there was no credit posted for Callaghan. I then had to explain to my husband what the heck I was trying to figure out 😂He is show only and totally lost .
I also rewound, paused and walked straight up to the TV - also watched the credits for the first time too!!! Callahan's omission from the credits signals confirmation for me. Otherwise they vould have just had Callahan - John Doe with no qualms. They didn't put it in credits because listing the Richardson actor again would spoil
The scene with Claire being handed the flag was so touching! I teared up!
Jane is perfection! I just love her and William. 😭
Making John's house the location of Washington's dinner and Rebel HQ, is interesting. (I understand it from a production standpoint).
I was a bit disappointed with the Percy character. I mean, the actor seemed skilled enough, but he didn't quite have the swarthy good looks I had in my head.
We seem to be going on some uncharted territory with the William plot, I wonder where it will take us. It's nice not to know exactly what's going on.
Brianna plot was excellent. Again, the changes were cleanly done.
I really like it when they reduce the timelines. Juggling 2 timelines is much better than 3. It feels less like viewing through a Viewmaster toy.
I suspect a lot of show only people will spying the book thread this week ;)
My husband, who's a Marine, criticized the dinner scene because there's no ways generals would have strategic discussions like that in front of wives and servants.
Not trying to disagree with your husband, but, is that only what would happen NOW? Cos back then women were not really viewed as threats (I assume) , mostly meek ornaments who don't do anything without their husbands permission.
phew! couldn't remember if rollo died after rachel + ian married or if it wasn't 'til after she got pregnant... glad he held on another episode lol.
can't decide if i like fanny + jane finding william when he was bathing in the creek... on the one hand, the scene is funny (& the "you find me at a disadvantage doesn't make as much sense in the show context), but on the other, jane is trying to be serious, and they're pretending that it wasn't swelteringly hot around the battle of monmouth.
a change i definitely like, though, is making richardson's motivations clearer from the start. wanting to hold william hostage was a clever way to adapt the "i'm in the wrong place?" part, although i wonder if ian & john going to save him will be changed from the books well.
last thought - john + jamie seem... not ready to kill each other now? that seems awfully fast, considering john seemed Pissed at the start of the episode. i wonder if they're putting aside their fight for good or for rescuing william's sake. definitely looking forward to john & william's reunion, since it'll be their first interaction post-jamie revelation. i wonder if they'll follow the books by having william go after jane without saying much to john because he's not ready to talk yet, or if they'll expand that scene.
Another great episode! So much from the books and it’s making my reader heart so happy!
I’ve been WAITING for the Bree scene with the shot gun, I remember how intense it was from the books and just full of pure adrenaline while cheering her on.
John’s eye and the honey scene was another that had me going 😬🥴 his expression had me geeking though while Claire talks about the operation and Jamie just holds him down without hesitation.
Also shoutout to Claire, love the scene when she asks the coughing soldier, 3 days? 3 weeks? 3 months 🙄 the delivery just felt so Claire like in the books, also gave me some flashbacks to when she’s inspecting the villagers and soldiers during season 2 before culloden.
Love love love Jane and her sister, I’m here for them and William, and just eating up their interactions together.
Can’t believe how fast part 2 is going, I’m gonna miss this show SO MUCH
I can't see how they can do the Richardson plot because it's still unresolved in the books. Unless the author gives them a hint? Or they just make it up? Rescuing Lord John could be a dynamite action scene. Also, I can't see how they're going to pack all of this into a final season.
Well, you could really tell DG had written this episode. It flowed so well! And had more humour subtly injected to almost every scene, really liked that! Poor John thinking the honey will do the trick. 😂 I was glad they didn't show the "fingers around your eyeball" -maneuver and the several attempts at it... But I shuddered just remembering how it was described in writing...
I always pictured Percy as someone much more... michievous, flirtatious, light? Show Percy was so... poetic, stoic and serious. But I consider these as two different stories anyway so it is all fun, I don't mind!
Looking forward to see the condensation of the Rob/Callahan/Richardson plot. I wish they had made it more obvious that Callahan is Richardson, but at least we who knew what to look for saw it when that balaklava went off! My show only husband stayed clueless and I didn't even mention it. He was just on the edge of his seat with that scene, it was suspenseful and fast, really well done. I think Brianna's actress is great with scenes where she gets to act with her body, if it is just her talking it feels a bit forced.
It made sense to have LJG and Ian go after William this way, instead of everyone just wandering about their own messy businesses in the middle of the battle like in the book. :D And I always say this but I can't wait for next week's episode, drama intensifies with unexpected events!
I was specifically looking for Callahan's face to be the same actor as Richardson, and even still had trouble catching it. I am pleasantly surprised that they're going into the Richardson/ Percy plot lines as much as they are. I'm sad that they're apparently skipping the Sylvia Hardeman and her girls plot as they are the beginning of J&C "collecting" hard-luck young women to live on The Ridge.
Is it... the same actor? They look similar enough, but it's not an overly distinctive face.
Although I suppose if they weren't planning on doing the plot, they wouldn't have bothered putting emphasis on taking off the balaclava and having Rob yell "Callahan"!
But is this enough though, have we seen him enough? In the books, didn't Bree meet him properly doing excavation work? Is Bree (or the audience) likely to recognise him from a half-second, adrenalined fuelled, half-balaclaved glance in the dark? When they eventually do the reveal, all the show-only watchers are gonna go "huh??? Who???" cos we've barely seen him.
I feel like if they put him in a different wig, maybe gave him a beard, put on a different accent etc, and then introduced him properly, it would be enough so that people DON'T recognise him at first/make the connection (especially since they are not expecting it anyway), but when the reveal eventually comes, we will have actually met him enough so that people go "of course!!!" and actually make the connection.
"It's not an overly distinctive face" !!!!!! I know you probably mean the actor's, but it makes me smile how that's literally what the characters say about him as a character in the story too!! That's gonna lend itself to the plot to work so well!
I'm a week behind because I didn't watch last week with the holidays and all - so I just posted my initial reaction and stated that I'd rewound and paused to see if it was the same guy. I think it is. I also waited for the credits to try to confirm. Callahan wasn't credited. His ommission I feel is confirmation. Otherwise, they'd have had no qualms about listing Callahan - John Doe. Listing Richardson's actor again would be spoiler, so I think they purposefully left him off
He is in the books. I don't think we could connect the same actor otherwise.
We don't know his full story yet. So far, we know that Richardson wants to blackmail Greys - Hal particularly, so he would not make speech in the house of Lords. Richardson wants different outcomes of the war, especially to change history about slavery.
On the other hand, he is in Rob's gang so he knows about gold. We still don't know what he wants from Bree and how that connection, besides gold, fits in the full story.
I was specifically looking for Callahan's face to be the same actor as Richardson, and even still had trouble catching it.
My shownly sister was like "am I supposed to know who that is?" and I was like "uhhhhhhh . . . I don't know" because you def couldn't recognize that quickly so I can't imagine they want people to know yet.
I had a feeling they will add the Callahan/Richardson plot in the show, I'm so curious if the show only people made the connection, because I'm also watching with my partner and I asked him if he realised who Callahan is, and he didn't, when I told him who he is, he was like, "huh, who's Richardson", lol, so I came here to talk to you guys.
There’s a fair number of us show-only or have only read some of the books fans that come to this thread because we don’t care about spoilers and/or want to steer clear of the drama in the show-only thread. They are not fans of this season.
Great episode!! I heard myself saying: ”omg… they’re going to try to do all of them..!” (meaning the storylines) just after seeing Percy, hearing Bens name, seeing Richardson in both time lines… That’s pretty ambitious!! And very cool!
Was laughing out loud when Jamie was inspecting his troops: ”his crooked hat is the least of his problems” or something like that. 😂 And then the snare: ”is this a weapon?”, ”yes, to the bunnies”. I love when Jamie gets more fun lines! Of course DG thinks to add them, it’s great when she writes the script! It was also really funny when the same soldier kind of lost the pace and his place in line when he was marching by Jamie later, just looking happy waving to his new friend.
I love Jane and Frances too. I hope they’ll be able to include Frances and Jamies friendship, and Rachels and Jamies too.
Brianna is so great this season. I love how she got rid of the guy hanging from the car, just punched him in the face. I also loved how she tried to fall apart totally silently, crying in the car while driving home with Mandy sleeping in the back seat, after leaving Roger at the stones. Heartbreaking! But a mom’s gotta keep going. Sophie is doing a great job!
In book 9, Ian goes to the brothel to know something about the sisters origins, they came by ship to America, and the captain (Velazquez, If I remember correctly) sold them to the brothel 'to cover' the unpaid tickets. It seems their parents died while at sea. It's an awful story. If Jane knew latin, maybe she was receiving a good education and they were not poor
Yes, that’s a piece of luck,” Jane agreed. “I couldn’t think how we were to find you in that moil, and when we saw you ride past like the fiend was after you—we’d got a ride on a baggage wagon—I didn’t think we’d ever catch you. But we took the chance, and … voilà! Fortuna favet audax, you know.” She wasn’t even trying to pretend she wasn’t laughing at him!
Yeah I reread it earlier. She knows that line but William doesn’t react to it and ask. So whether or not she’s bluffing about being fluent or knowledgeable I think is left unknown… I’m really liking how the show is adapting the books because I feel as though with her writing it gets confusing.
In the book, could it be just a phrase she would have picked up rather than a sign of her being educated?
Greek and Latin were big during the Age of Enlightenment when more people were literate and enamored of all the new discoveries being made that were changing their world.
In the book, could it be just a phrase she would have picked up rather than a sign of her being educated?
This is my guess.
I don't know if you remember the scene at Hardmans, and Jamie is reading the line written on a chamber pot. It is in Latin, but if read in English, it has some meaning as well. Anyway, I was thinking about wealthy educated customers telling her Latin lines.
Jane could just be showing her intelligence rather than education and she likely would have encountered Latin speakers among the whoremongers at the brothel.
It must have been nice to live during a time period when people were better read and valued knowledge more.
Whoever taught her this phrase in the brothel didn't get his latin right. If she got some classical education as a child (rather unusual for a girl in those times) she didn't pay attention.
It's "fortuna favet audaci" not "audax" (book) or "fortuna favet audacibus" not "audaces" (show). Fortune favours the bold.
Let me start off by saying that I really enjoyed this episode. It’s always a treat when Diana Gabaldon writes the script!
However, I don’t know how Mrs. Figg was able to cook and serve an extravagant meal in an afternoon with no help, especially in 18th century Colonial America. It seems like a bit of a stretch. I guess she’s a miracle worker. 🙄
Speaking of that dinner, I could not quit seeing Jamie and Claire ON that dining room table, while the dinner party scene was taking place. 👀 Maybe it’s just me.
Also, I will NEVER be okay with how at home Jamie is making himself in JOHN’s house. Not Letting This Go!!!!
This one bothered me less. I love Ian in general but I don't wanna be in on his sexy time. Probably bc his storyline started when he was a kid? Is that it?
Same except it’s only their sex scenes that compel me to fast forward lol. I can’t pinpoint what it is, I’m not sure that it’s just a chemistry thing bc outside of the those I really like them. I think you can tell John Bell isn’t attracted to women; whenever Ian and Rachel start kissing and touching it’s immediately more awkward
It annoyed me, the sort of reverence they give George Washington. I recently read about Ona Judge and the Mt. Vernon plantation. In the books I don’t think Claire meets him? From what I remember he’s just a guy that gives Jamie a command when he just wants to go home lol.
Not everyone is part of that kind of insane purity cancel culture though. And George Washington stepping down from power after two terms of service in the presidency is worth honoring him for forever.
George Washington was famous for having aides that were very much anti-slavery. Such as John Laurens and the Marquis de Lafayette. If it weren't for needing the southern states and that pact with the devil they made with them Washington could very easily have led an independence movement that ended slavery in the colonies forever.
Instead, they put the fight to end slavery off until finally dealing with it in the Civil War.
As for George Washington, it was his older, much wealthier wife who was big into owning slaves and was a dedicated plantation business woman. She and George had no children together and he could not force her or her stepchildren to end their practice of slavery.
Unlike Thomas Jefferson, who made excuses for not freeing slaves that were completely under his power, even when Lafayette offered to pay him to do so, George Washington freed all the enslaved people he could in his will of his own volition. This was made more complicated by how entangled families were.
While there is no justification for slavery then or NOW, because slavery is still very much alive and we all benefit from it today, acknowledgement must be made to those who fought in their own times to end it against intense pressure.
Ona Judge Staines escaped to the north away from Martha Washington's granddaughter which is a far better fate than so many others. George Washington wasn't out there chasing her down to get her back, that was his wife's business. Was George perfect in every way? No, he doesn't have to be, most people are not.
But, it's also worth reading about how much Quakers and others were going against accepted laws of the times when they protested or fought against the practice of slavery. You have to really be brave to stand up for what you know is right when everyone is telling you to just accept the status quo and natural order of things.
Claire does meet George Washington in the books. In MOBY, chapter 54, Jamie, Claire, and Ian dine with George Washington, Lafayette, Lee, Morgan, and other officers. They are NOT dining in Lord John’s house, however.
Yeah, I found the reverence to be cheesy and annoying. Treating him like a saint or something. I wish the show hadn't abandoned Claire's moral convictions about slavery and slave "owners.'
Surely any modern American would be a bit in awe at meeting George Washington! Father of our country! The guy on the dollar bill! An extraordinary historical figure even if not a saint.
I’m having the same feeling I had reading the books… I’m over all the revolutionary war stuff now 😅
Loving the Briana storyline! Wish we were getting a bit more of it.
Noticing the small changes is so interesting now! I think when reading the later books I started speed reading too much out of excitement, there’s details I have forgotten!
I’m reading echo in the bone right now and just read the first scenes with Percy in them, didn’t realise that happened so early on in the book! In the book I’m not even up to Jamie ‘dying’ or them going back to Scotland. Wondering if they’re going to still do the storyline with Fergus 🤔
I’m getting nervous now for how the endings are inevitably going to deviate!
Guys help me remember - what does the book say about William and the Hessians? I don’t remember this part at all… Friday seems so far away and I’m dying to know what happens (or at least what happening in book land.)
I mean yes, he did need Denzel because he didn’t know they were planning on hanging him. The point is everyone says Jamie is to blame - if he didn’t have the reactivated commission in his pocket, he wouldn’t be in such danger. Neither he or Jamie knew that he had it, but everyone is so quick to blame Jamie for this and turn around and say that he needs to get him out of it. Right now, he’s keeping him safe. he surrendered to Jamie, so he is (in a way) keeping him safe.
Did Jamie not think that something bad could happen to Lord John when he turned him over to those men? Even though he wasn’t actively in the military anymore but just the fact that he used to be. Jamie kind of seemed indifferent about it. Was it because he wasn’t worried he would be harmed or because he really didn’t care?
Jamie didn't expect anything bad to happen to John.
When Jamie heard what he heard, he is furious and desperate to get to Claire. He has no identifications - he can't afford to be taken captive for many days. It's obvious that John is an english aristocrat, so rebels must find out who he really is. But, as those men said - We don't need him if he is not a soldier- Jamie believes nothing drastic will happen to John.
Did anyone watch the intro cutscene at the end of the song? It showed what was presumably Betsy Ross sewing the flag. However there was one more symbolic detail. One arm was that of a white woman while the other was that of a black woman. Same sleeves/dress, so what are anyone’s thoughts of the symbolism of this?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Dec 27 '24 edited Jan 03 '25
Watch the S7E15 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
714 Extras:
Cast Commentary
BTS: The Pocock Sisters
Inside 714
714 Interviews:
Silvia Presents for TV Insider
Silvia for Decider
Silvia for TV Line
Izzy and John for Parade