r/whowouldwin • u/DarthFartus • Jun 13 '19
Battle Andre the giant at his peak health vs hafthor bjornson(the mountain)
Scenario-A max overhead press Scenario-B shoot style pro wrestling match Who take the win the mountain has a year to train
27
13
u/JablesRadio Jun 13 '19
Sadly, Andre was never "healthy". His back and hips always have him problems. While he was athletic, he was never anywhere close to the level of The Mountain.
Mountain takes both 10/10, 9/10.
10
u/Rando_Thoughtful Jun 13 '19
I think this fight is unfair unless it allows Andre to utilize his greatest ability: drinking. Like in one round they should each have to drink 2 cases of beer and then wrestle.
16
u/thecorporatebanana Jun 13 '19
As much as I love Andre, I don't think he can take either round.
Andre was strong, but Bjorn is on a whole other level. Bjorn is insanely strong and muscular, while Andre always struggled with health problems. He was strong, but never Bjorn strong.
Bjorn absolutely dominates in R1. Whatever he can lift would really hurt Andre to even try, even in his prime.
In R2, Andre has a slim chance because he does have a significant weight advantage (which can mean a lot when it comes to grappling) and a much larger reach, but Bjorn wins 8/10 just with raw strength. And again, Andre probably hurts himself trying.
If 22-year-old Andre started training for this match for like three or four years, he might have a better chance, but he'd have to do a lot of strength training and learn a lot about fighting. Again, as much as I love Andre, he was always a performer, not an actual professional fighter. If he had time to learn real, serious fighting, that might be enough to close the gap. But neither of your scenarios specify any training for Andre, so with the prompt as it is, Andre goes down hard in both matches.
6
Jun 13 '19
I love Andre but he Would get slaughtered, we was never healthy and was Big because his Condition, whereas Thor is Naturally big, this is a big difference, Making Thor much more healthier.
Thor is also very nimble, look at his strongman competitions and with One year of training will be able to beat Andre easily
Round 1 - Thor Stomps, he has been doing this his whole life
Round 2 - Thor Stomps Again, one Double leg takedown and Andre folds as his knees give out due to his condition and thats just one way the fight can go
1
Jun 13 '19
Hafthor stomps, Andre was never healthy because of his giantism, even in his prime he had back and hip problems.
Like, it's barely a competition at all.
-7
u/lejefferson Jun 13 '19
A fake wrestler versus the strongest man who's ever lived?
6
u/dmcd0415 Jun 13 '19
1
u/Biggerboi981 Jun 13 '19
Care to elaborate on your claim that Louis Cyr was anything other than fabricated myths?
2
u/dmcd0415 Jun 13 '19
No I'll go ahead and agree with you on Cyr. Now can you elaborate on why you might think he's stronger than these 10 guys? You can go one by one if you want, I have time to read.
https://www.mensjournal.com/health-fitness/10-strongest-men-all-time/
1
26
u/GekidoTC Jun 13 '19
Even at peak health Andre’s gigantism really effected him. Can’t really compare him to a world class athlete who is naturally huge. Hafthor would stomp A. But, obviously Hafthor would be the heel in the match so he would lose B.