r/AnthemTheGame • • Mar 10 '19

Other Constructive Criticism: My Biggest Issue with Anthem Is That I Don't Feel the Game Respects My Time or Investment

So.

I reached level 30 about a week and a half ago, and I enjoyed the leveling process. I managed to avoid many of the technical issues that plagued so many players, and I have a lot of good things to say about the campaign. I think the story is actually quite interesting, particularly when put up against what other looter-shooters have to offer. I enjoyed the writing and how real the characters felt. The music is amazing, and so is the gameplay - both flying and shooting feel very good. I didn't think a game could 'feel' better to play than Destiny 2 in the looter-shooter genre, but for me Anthem is just as satisfying to play, which is saying something. I also love how different all the javelins feel from one another.

But.

Since reaching level 30 and grinding for a few days, I've had almost no desire to play for at least the past five days, maybe longer. Why? It's simple. I just don't feel that Anthem respects the time that I put into it.

I have no issues with playing games for hundreds of hours. I've easily poured that much time and more into Destiny 2: Forsaken (NOT launch version D2, which I avoided after getting burned by D1 on launch), The Witcher 3, Warframe, World of Warcraft (WotLK era), and more. Why? Because I felt that those games respected the time and effort I, as a player, put into them.

In Anthem, the end-game is the loot grind. And I actually happen to think that the grind in this game could be very satisfying. I'm a min-maxer, so I would happily spend dozens of hours working out neat builds for every javelin and grinding for gear. But I'm only willing to go to that kind of effort if it feels like the game is willing to meet me halfway and give me as much as I'm giving it.

The way I see it, Anthem's issue is this: inscriptions are bad, but drop rates aren't high to compensate. Honestly, I would rather guns just have fixed inscriptions if they were going to have low drop rates (getting a +15% weap damage when I could potentially get +200% just feels ridiculous), but it seems as if Bioware is attached to inscriptions.

Given the fact that Bioware seems to be 100% sure that they want inscriptions, the drop rates need to be higher. Astronomically higher. At least as high as they were during the two 'bugged' periods we've had.

I don't feel the game respects me as a player when I spend 2.5 hours doing all 3 legendary contracts and a tyrant mine run on GM1, just to get only the 4 guaranteed masterwork items that in all likelihood will either be sidegrades or downgrades. It makes me feel like I'm just wasting my valuable time, which I do cherish, slaving away at a game - REMEMBER, GAMES ARE SUPPOSED TO BE FUN, BY THE WAY - and have nothing to show for it.

I play games to have fun. That's what games are for. And I've never played a game that felt more like it wanted me to dislike the game in spite of myself than Anthem.

When I stop playing Anthem and start playing The Division 2 on Tuesday, I don't know if I'll ever come back. And as somebody who was incredibly excited for this game, that actually makes me sad. But I'm not leaving because of the loot. The loot is only a symptom of a greater problem. I'm leaving because I don't feel that this game has indicated to me in any way that it appreciates me as a player. Instead, I feel like the current iteration of the game has been developed to waste my time in the hopes that doing so will keep me around until there's more content. But it won't. I have more respect for my time than that.

All 10 of my friends that got the game with me have already stopped playing. I was the only one left.

The worst part about it is that I don't know whether or not I'll come back to the game to see how it's doing in a few months. If I enjoy a game but ultimately shelve it for a bit because it was just light on content, I'm more than willing to revisit it. But if I feel like a game just burns me and wastes my time? Not so much. Why would I give a second shot to a game that has consistently failed to indicate that it will value my time on a fundamental level?

I hope Bioware understands that this game won't have a Rainbow Six: Siege-like resurrection later down the line (which I think is what they're hoping for) if all the people who could revive it stopped playing not because they felt that the game was unfinished and had potential, but because they were pissed off at a game that they felt was just wasting their time.

Ah well.

1.7k Upvotes

161 comments sorted by

114

u/Zeebie_ Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

the problem is the fixes are simple

  1. increase the drop rate

  2. allow all ember to upgraded to MW via and upgrade function 5 white = 1 green, 5 green = 1 blue etc

  3. use these embers to reroll inscriptions either all 4 or just one

  4. allow us to craft replacement inscriptions using rare drops like "leg of a giant spider", "Heart of Anthem created creature" or stuff from freeplay

this way no matter what we do , we are working towards and end game

2

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I agree. The endgame just feels completely aimless right now, which is killing it for me. Having some sort of progression system so that I could at least use my common/uncommon/rare/epic embers and guarantee that I would eventually have a good set of masterworks/legendaries would make such a difference.

18

u/FishermanYellow Mar 10 '19

I’ve said it before as so many others have, just take a look at Diablo 3 loot. Although we’d probably require a stats page to work it out fully but in addition to those things you mentioned why not even have a Kiani’s cube, one for guns, one for abilities and one for components. (For those who don’t know what Kiani’s cube is you just use materials to salvage the item and gain it’s special ability, you can have 3 abilities active in addition to your equipped gear)

But yes, anything we do has to be working towards the end game. Doing anything in Diablo 3 has a purpose (picking up low rarity items for crafting materials, picking up lower tiered gems to upgrade them, getting xp for paragon levels etc.

10

u/TheStaIker Mar 10 '19

I literally made a post about this. Anthem's Kanai's Cube

11

u/Necroval Mar 10 '19

Judging by their in game challenge system and time gating, I honestly don't think they give a fuck. I look at the situation as a whole and I see them scrambling to extend the game life and considering login numbers with other games and think that the decrease in players is a normal surge post release. I dont think they realize that the whole base is about to leave. This games player base is about 1 week from mass exodus. They super duper fucked up.

4

u/Kaylavi Mar 10 '19

I was alot more excited for anthem than div2 (though I did really want div2 to be good, I had a great time with #1 like 8months ago. The idea of anthem was just more up my alley) but I havnt had interest to touch anthem in a few days unless all my buddies are on but then when I hop on and get no upgrades after like 4 hours and only seeing gaurenteed drops I just sigh and find a reason to hop off or say I'm tired and go watch letterkenny

1

u/Shoehornz Mar 11 '19

It’s fucking embarrassing!

1

u/Kaylavi Mar 11 '19

Figure it out

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Kaylavi Mar 10 '19

Division

7

u/PlagueOfGripes Mar 10 '19

While I applaud the effort, having the majority of your reward functions happening in menus is a really bad idea. Combat should yield immediate rewards, not the resources to use in a UI somewhere.

Inscriptions should be editable, though, if they're going to obsess over them, as opposed to simply letting people sort through treasure. At least then you could slowly build towards a good weapon, rather than being given landfill material once every hour.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

PoE steps in and disagrees with you.

you can make upgrade interesting and sustainable, and the way to get end game. The important part is to make end game interesting, and also make sure that playing has a chance of dropping end game gears. Even in that game people are not happy that most super end game gears come from crafting, but that is an issue Anthem doesn't have the luxury of thinking about.

1

u/Kaylavi Mar 11 '19

I'd like to see grandmaster work like torment in diablo and run them similar to nephi rifts. That'd be slick as hell

3

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Dragon Age Inquisition drops schematics or (more importantly) you earn them through in game activities. In Inquisition you have a number of stats on each item that you can dictate by changing the crafting material (Primary, Utility, Offense and Defense Slots). Higher level gear has a fifth slot called Masterwork that provides higher variance interesting design. You therefore get materials then build the design you want, from drops of schematics. It values your time in that if you want something specific, you can damn well go gathering and get what you want. I get that RNG is a good dopamine hit when you get that godroll, but as a gamer I want to be able to actually work towards something I want specifically. Guild Wars 2 Legendaries are similar. I'd rather build a legendary called "Heart of a Titan" and have to kill 10 titans to get their hearts, 50 dominion to get there tech and then look at building the inscriptions too. Because ultimately even if it takes a week / 2 weeks / 3 weeks, I know what I get, and it's awesome!

5

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

This changes almost nothing because masterwork embers only create masterwork items and not legendary items. While it's nice to think that masterwork embers are amazing, the simple truth is that they don't matter for the highest geared players. I already look at every masterwork drop as yet another item to be scrapped.

Now, if we had slots where masterwork was the 'highest' available item, then the embers would have 'real' value. As it stands the best use of crafting materials for me is to craft support items which are still currently capped at epic quality afaik.

2

u/Zeebie_ Mar 10 '19

the idea was to use the MW ember to reroll inscriptions on legendary or MW items so as to not make them useless

4

u/Necroval Mar 10 '19

I spent over 100 hours unlocking gear blueprints for this exact purpose. Now I am sitting on 800 embers and scared to use them because ive gotten like 3 masterwork embers in the last 24 hours.

6

u/Zeebie_ Mar 10 '19

I don't understand why they nerfed masterwork embers in freeplay it's not like they can be used on legendary. I don't understand why they are making it so hard to improve our characters

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Sorry, you don't mention legendary items int that post at all.

1

u/NabeelSteel Mar 10 '19

Its almost like they had to make this up as they went because there were no existing references within the looter genre they could pull from. /s

43

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

Honestly, I would rather guns just have fixed inscriptions if they are going to have low drop rates.

This is the absolute most pre-launch Destiny 2 hopeful I’ve ever seen.

Reddit, Bungie forums, social media... all EXPLODED negatively the more annoyed players got with random rolls on drops.

Actually it was so much for so long that the second game didn’t have them on release. They listened to an enraged community and didn’t put them in the second game.

It took till Forsaken dropped to get them back. They listened to an even more enraged community and had to put them in the second game after a year.

You don’t want to get rid of random rolls, because you don’t know what you have until it’s gone.

That gun you like using that’s working for you on GM2? It now has inscriptions that don’t help your build... forever, and no amount of grinding will give you one.

Fixed... fixed “BioWare Curated” rolls are one thing ALONG SIDE random rolls. But this ship will sink if they removed random inscriptions all together.

I wouldn’t even plant that seed in Biowares head unless you’re expecting disappointment from a choice you wanted.

Nothing good can come from one type of loot drop only dropping one way forever.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

I completely understand what you're saying!

I was just throwing ideas out because obviously having low drop-rates and the chance for inscriptions to be incredibly variable is not good game design.

I think my ideal solution would be that Masterworks couldn't have an inscription lower/higher than +100-150%, and legendaries couldn't have one lower/higher than +150-200%.

The range is just too much right now imo. I don't think I should ever run into a situation where a legendary weapon - the highest tier of loot - is worse than a masterwork weapon because it has inscriptions that are worse. It completely removes the prestige of legendary weapons if they can be useless. Legendary weapons, if they're going to be the pinnacle of the loot, should ALWAYS be more useful than masterworks, at least in my opinion.

I'm completely fine with not having fixed inscriptions so that people can chase that +sniper damage +elemental damage weapon for their storm or whatever, but I'm NOT fine with getting legendaries that are potentially worse than masterworks if legendaries are supposed to be the pinnacle loot weapons in the game.

2

u/Sequazu Mar 10 '19

I like the idea of Bioware curated inscriptions like if the gun that boosts elemental damage only rolled with elemental boosts, gear damage, and gear speed.

3

u/Groenket PC - Mar 10 '19

They should consider reducing the possible inscription pool tho. Lots of inscriptions, tho functional, are just bad. They really ought to take all the flight/heat stuff off of the components and add a few equippable slots for "Flight mods." These mods could take all those inscriptions out of the pool for components, and they could even get nifty with it and have things like "Extra air dodge" onto masterwork level flight mods. having flight modifiers scattered into the inscriptions on everything else nearly guarantees most builds will consider those inscriptions to be trash.

6

u/RadClark Mar 10 '19

That and the +1-15% damage honestly feels like a kick to the groin when i know it can go as high as 200. Totally find with grinding it but the return rate for a min maxer isnt there

2

u/Groenket PC - Mar 10 '19

Also true

3

u/SecretBiscuits PC - Mar 10 '19

They need to keep the huge loot pool exactly how it is, just increase the loot drops. The inscriptions are supposed to make the grind, but we can’t grind inscriptions if we can’t even get the weapons or gear

1

u/Groenket PC - Mar 10 '19

Reducing the amount of inscriptions on components and weapons would reduce the grind theoretically, but the number of inscriptions, coupled with the ranges possible makes for an exceedingly large amount of grind. There was a post today or yesterday doing the math on getting a specific component with 4 specific inscriptions and the odds were akin to winning the lottery. Taking the four or so inscriptions for flight out of the generic pool and sticking them on flight specific mods would leave plenty of grind but improve how rewarding it is, imo. Even if they increase the drop rate, that's going to improve your psychological enjoyment of the game, but actual javelin improvements will remain fairly scarce. And that is with taking into account the wide range of percentage bonuses associated with each inscription.

Don't get me wrong, the drop rate needs to go up, but generic loot quality needs to be improved as well.

1

u/SecretBiscuits PC - Mar 10 '19

I saw that same post and commented on it, it was a good one and more people should see it. And I could maybe budge on a few changes to inscriptions, like how if it’s legendary it should have a damage increase less than 50% if it has the damage increase inscription. Things like that alone would drastically decrease the lottery-like chances on the god roll weapon as our mutual friend had described, but I do feel that the vast amount of different inscriptions need to remain in play because at the end of the day this is supposed to be a game that you spend hours grinding on.

1

u/elfaia Mar 10 '19

Yeah I know the limitation of having fixed rolls but seriously, with the state of mw/legendary items in anthem, I'd rather take fixed rolls and move on to the next item than trying to farm for the god roll. Not with this drop rate.

1

u/Karuzo-Sama PC - Mar 11 '19

What Bungie did with Forsaken is not comparable to this inscription crap Anthem has...

Bungie has a pretty low amount of "perks" on their equipment and there are some you want on a gun and some which are just crappy. But Perk A is the same as Perk A on every other equipment! If you got that DMG Perk on your gun, you got it. You don't have to roll a 250%. You don't have to disessamble it, when it only gets 1% DMG. That is a huge difference!

Another sidenote: Bungie had only 2 perks, which most of the time counted. And you had some guns with like 3 perks per slot out of which you could choose 1. This means, if you had those 2 important perks right and now you want that godroll with those minor stuff, you had 3 (!) chances to get it right. And even if you didn't get the really really good stuff, those other perks weren't necessarily useless like getting Melee DMG on your storm.

And last but not least: The Perks in Forsaken didn't matter as much as they do here in Anthem. You can't do GM3 with a crappy inscription gun. I did the raids with non ideal gear on every character in Forsaken. And I managed to get a really really good gear on every one of those before the Light cap was raised.

Now, in Anthem, I have not a single okay drop, let good or godlike aside. I can't really play any of the other chars (even tho they are fully masterworked) since their gear is even worse than my Interceptors.

My last point: Exotics (basically legendaries in Anthem) had no perks, which rolled randomly. You grinded stuff for 80 hours and got an Exotic? Gratulations, you got yourself some good stuff (most of the time). There was no need to say: Hmm, let's pray this thing is worth the effort. You never ended up dismantling the Exotic, because it rolled bad.

20

u/TheBartographer Mar 10 '19

I feel like you hit the nail on the head; very well written. I too have spent countless hours on similar titles and Anthem gives me the same feeling as you. I play games because they are fun, but also respect my time as a player. This game can be fun when it works but I don't feel that Bioware has a clue what makes this type of title rewarding for players like us. Let's hope Division 2 launches smoothly. It seems like studios don't feel the need to launch finished titles anymore, but they'll happily take our money. It makes me pretty sad honestly and I've lost a lot of trust in this industry.

3

u/TAEROS111 Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

I didn't pick up Division 1 on launch because I saw the writing on the wall for that one, but I did pick it up after patch 1.8 and loved it.

The developers have been very candid about how they screwed up with the launch of Division 1 and how their goal is to pick up where Division 1 left off and then continue improving on it for Division 2. I played the open beta on PS4 Pro, and even though there were one or two technical problems, it felt great. It had all the quality of life stuff that Anthem was missing and then some, and I felt that the gameplay had also improved from Division 1 quite a bite. I left that beta feeling fully justified in my pre-order.

Honestly, it's the whole "games as a live service" model that's screwed Anthem. Game development isn't cost-efficient anymore, so publishers need to figure out ways to get more and more money out of a game post-launch. The whole 'live service' game model was created to just allow publishers to milk an IP for as long as possible while keeping development costs low in order to impress investors and keep shareholders on board.

The thing is, a lot of the first 'live service' games - Rainbow Six: Siege, Destiny 1, etc., launched in bad states, but they had no competition, so they were able to be resurrected after more development time was put into them. I think that this gave EA the idea that they could just release Anthem half-finished and then improve it as it went along. EA needed to buff up its Q1 2019 sales because Q3 2018 was rough for the company, and Anthem was the chosen sacrificial lamb. But I don't think EA accounted for the fact that players are just going to leave and go back to Destiny 2 or The Division 2 without sticking around to revive Anthem. Or maybe they did and just don't care. Who knows.

If you want to get games that are of consistently high quality, stick to first-party titles made or sponsored by console-makers (Nintendo, Sony, etc) or games made by studios that are government funded (CD Projekt Red). Console makers can afford to be loss-leaders, but other publishers can't. That's why Sony is putting out amazing stuff like Horizon: Zero Dawn and God of War while other publishers are so obsessed with crapping out more and more of these 'live service' games. Of course, there are exceptions to the rule, but I think that's going to be the trend that we'll be seeing more and more of.

Thanks for the positive feedback! I'm right there with you when it comes to the industry etc.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

the most jarring part is that the division 2 made a lot of "taken for granted" designs feel like godsend because of how bad Anthem was.

div2' inventory design is actually horrible but it felt better than Anthem. Some bosses are bullet sponges, but still felt better than Anthem. the dx12 on PC random crashes, but it is so much smoother than Anthem.

Pick up an item, inspect it right there and equip it without going through 4 loading screens. My God. might just buy the game for this (I'm waiting for May and reviews. no pre-order).

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I'm with you on this. I didn't have as many performance issues because I was playing the Division 2 beta on a late-edition PS4 Pro (I heard that people with early-edition consoles had more technical issues) and I was mind-blown by just how much of a difference the little QoL things made.

Switching back to Anthem really made me realize how stilted and dated the design of Anthem is. It almost feels like the game is trying to fight me whenever I want to play it which isn't exactly the hallmark of a game with a good design philosophy.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

The problem is Division 2 is not breaking any ground on designs, nor is it spectacularly optimized (performance on dx11 is terrible on PC). Anthem on the other hand is dropping people's expectation so low: basically have a functional menu that isn't designed by some student interns, and don't crash every other session.

I hate how this game is normalizing things that really should have been taken for granted and making people praise Division 2.

17

u/Papa-D-MMXI Mar 10 '19

This post is 100% me. 27 year old dad of 3 working 72 hours a week I bought Anthem to sink my time into cause I don’t buy games much due to the cost. Wasn’t planning on buying Division 2 until Anthem was the complete failure it was sadly. Now I see all these videos and posts and wish I could get a refund cause now I’m stuck with Anthem and too broke to buy Division for a couple months. Hope the game turns out great and my friends/coworkers don’t abandon it by the time I get around to buying it in the summer.

7

u/Catbeard3120 Mar 10 '19

Father of 2 here, so I can relate. Currently going back to school to finish my degree in nursing so I have little time to spend with my kids and even less time to play video games. I've pretty much given up on anthem until the loot problem is fixed, but I'm pissed that I spent money on this game at launch when it seems obvious now that it will be half price within 6 months.

8

u/Papa-D-MMXI Mar 10 '19

Yeah same man I’m pissed and I can’t begin to explain to my wife how I could spent another $60 in a week after just buying Anthem. I know in 3-6 months the game will be great but I would have also liked to buy it then for $30 instead of sitting on it now

6

u/Tehsyr CHONK-lossus Mar 10 '19

Oi bruv, odd question for you. I'm willing to send you either psn/xbox cards or a steam preorder for The Division 2, but how do you think your wife would react to someone sending it to you free of charge? Honest to god I'm already doing this for another user, and I'm willing to help you out as well.

1

u/CrazyCandyx Mar 10 '19

I know exactly how that feels like. I bought the LOD Edition which is about 2/3 of the money I have available for spending on random stuff that I like per month and now I wish I wouldve just waited and bought Division 2 instead 😧 really sucks.. putting my hopes up and then the disappointment 😔

2

u/Yamadronis Mar 10 '19

I had to save up for three months for Anthem. >:

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

which platform are you on? On both xbox2 and PC you have people listing all the objective problems with the game one week before release, and you still went on with it despite all the red tapes.

I hope that you have learned a lesson here. for me it literally doesn't matter, but $60 is a lot to you and it's sad because you can't enjoy a game you might because of Anthem. Do not pre-order. Wait a week. If you financially are stable by all means but if you can't afford to lose that $60 don't pre-order.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

[deleted]

2

u/jericho189 Mar 10 '19

I dont think thats true about the games problem

I love flying the abilities the components are cool even most support abilities are cool for me the only problem with anthem is loot

3

u/_Dialectic_ PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

Congrats on the kiddos and going back to school bud. I've got 3

3

u/Groenket PC - Mar 10 '19

Division 1 was the progenitor of not respecting your time via drops. Even later in the game when it played smooth and things were good, 90% of my playtime was speed running Lex and dismantling everything I picked up. There's a sweet spot of loot drop rate, rarity, and bonuses in there somewhere, noone's gotten to it yet (at least not for me, I realize that this sweet spot is probably different for everyone). Maybe D1 rise of iron was the best. D2 would be pretty good, but you have to spend too much time just working on power, in my opinion, to make the actual grind for rolls appealing.

3

u/mrread55 Mar 10 '19

Feels like more and more games are going from "seems like you'd enjoy this" to "you don't know what you want, we do, and you'll take this whether you like it or not" which is resulting in a heavy "go f yourself" mentality slowly from the community in the form of failing market share.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

"Do you guys not have phones?!"

Game development isn't about gamers making games for other gamers anymore. It's about monolithic multi-million or billion dollar publishers in an inflated industry desperately trying to milk money out of their customers with microtransactions and loot boxes so that shareholders don't bail.

I wrote this on a different comment, but currently I only really trust games published by console-makers like Sony or Nintendo that can release stuff like Horizon: Zero Dawn, God of War, or Mario Odyssey because they can afford to be loss leaders, or studios with government funding like CD Projekt Red. Everyone else is too busy trying to figure out how to make more money to spend time figuring out how to make good games. There are exceptions (I actually think Ubisoft and Square Enix are doing a decent job of things), but ActivisionBlizzard or EA? oof.

3

u/bearLover23 Mar 10 '19

Amen to all of this. This is exactly what I was trying to highlight in this massive post I made. Players are losing a sense of agency and their internal locus of control is being smashed to pieces through the RNG shredder.

It's not good at all, it's really demoralizing and it's just painful.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AnthemTheGame/comments/aytu0z/constructive_feedback_with_chartsgraphs/

Btw I am also leaving for TD2. A game I NEVER would have told you I had ANY plans to play 5 months ago. No bloody way. It was a write off for me. It's sad this game is in SUCH a poor state right now that I refuse to waste anymore of my time for no sense of progression. I do not have the time or energy to waste for nothing.

2

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I read your post and thought it was great! It definitely had more time and effort put into it than mine - I hope that Bioware reads yours and considers everything you laid out.

I wasn't on board with TD2 either, but now... well, let's just say that I think Massive should give Bioware some kickback on their launch sales, because I have a feeling that TD2 got a lot of players due to Anthem's failures.

2

u/bearLover23 Mar 11 '19

Totally agreed again :D because tbqh Anthem's current performance just did exactly what you said. I did not expect this, like... at all.

Ah well! Live and learn! XD I am just gonna enjoy supporting and healing people in D.C. :3

3

u/Hanswurst0815123 Mar 10 '19

ouch be careful with "don´t respect my time as a player" stuff...this is what brought us the shitshow called Destiny 2 Vanilla where you get showered in loot and nothing in the game was special in any way

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I understand what you're saying. But in Anthem, I think that if they're going to allow inscriptions to remain the way that they are, then they have to increase the drop-rates by a dramatic percentage in order to make playing the endgame feel worthwhile. It's absurd that in this game you can get a legendary gun that's worse than a masterwork because the legendary has a +15% weap damage inscription while the masterwork has +200%. The fact that a legendary - supposedly the pinnacle of loot in this game - can just be useless indicates to me that there's something VERY wrong with how Bioware designed this game's loot and the reward philosophy behind Anthem in general.

There was a really good post that did the math and figured out that the odds of getting a god-roll legendary in Anthem are actually about the same as the odds of winning the lottery in real life due to the low drop rates and inscriptions. There's a reason I don't buy lottery tickets - it's because in all likelihood I'll never win, and it just feels pointless. Playing a videogame that I already dropped $60 for shouldn't feel the same way as buying scratch-offs at the local 7-11, but in Anthem it does, which is... just sad, really.

2

u/rrancid PC - Mar 10 '19

They had the time from early access, the feedback from the community and the experience from other developers to understand exactly why the game feels so unrewarding after 30-40 hours of playtime.

Somebody in charge at BW is shooting all these down because of some "other vision" and is killing Anthem, harming it much more than any other of its shortcomings.

I hope things change at BW, maybe even replace said people if necessary, but it'll be too late because it's not a "code" change but a "people" change, and those take time...

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

I mean this is pretty much exactly what happened when Ben Irving was the lead producer of SWTOR. The community would ask for common sense, quality of life changes for months only to essentially be told "we're doing internal testing to verify what you already know, but if you stick around it might get better," which is exactly what Chad said about the loot yesterday.

I'm not saying Ben is responsible for what's going on right now, but this isn't the only time BW has been obstinate about loot (hell, even in Dragon Age: Inquisition there were loot issues that took forever to get fixed). I just wish it felt like they understood that they don't have months to fix these design issues.

I understand not wanting to pull the trigger on something when you're not 100% sure it will work, but then again, they also released the game half-finished. This isn't the time for them to deliberate or do hundreds of hours of internal testing just so they can figure out what the playerbase already knows, this is the time for triage fixes so that the game actually maintains a playerbase. Unfortunately, it doesn't feel like they think things are that urgent.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Agree completely on your last point. Rainbow Six: Siege was able to have a resurrection because it was a unique game with no other real rivals.

Destiny and Destiny 2 did the same because with the exception of the Division, it had no real competitors -- and Division has its own issues.

But for Anthem, it has Destiny 2 in a decent spot, Division 2 about to launch (which is looking superb), Warframe in a much more developed position, and -- whisper it -- a possible Borderlands 3 launch later this year. In addition to people who can still jump back into Monster Hunt: World.

With that competition, Anthem had this window to shine. By summer/Fall this year, Anthem may be third or fourth in even the most committed looter player's lineup. There will be no resurrection.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

Yup. This game has design issues that need to be fixed within the next week, not within the next months, if it's going to succeed. Sadly, I don't think that will be happening...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

Gothalion on his stream the other day said that no game is more than a patch away from being fixed, so I don’t want to declare it dead — but I hope they fix it fast!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

I think the arguments from BioWare about the drop rate is that we'll get bored if we get everything we want right away. The simplest argument against this was in a math post yesterday pointing out the chances of receiving one God roll, let alone a fully kitted javelin is next to impossible. Right now, I think people are bored because they're not getting anything. I love the gameplay, but I'm not going to run more than one stronghold at a time unless the loot is worth it. One MW for that commitment is not worth it to me. I got two legendaries from that glitch the other day, and it was the first time since hitting 30 I was excited! I thought it had been fixed. The legendaries weren't even good, but they allowed me to change things up with my build and try new things. Now I'm stuck with that because I'm not going to get any better gear getting one MW every 20 mins or so.

I like the top comment on here. I think if we can't get loot that often, crafting and being able to re-roll one inscription would be nice to have. That way, we'd at least get to better our javelin until they decide that dropping a lot of loot is actually in their own interest as well.

I defended this game from the beginning. I just don't know what they're thinking anymore.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I also like that top comment.

It doesn't feel like that game has any sort of actual design to the endgame, which just makes it feel like everything is pointless. If there was at least a way for me to ensure that eventually I could make all those common/uncommon/rare/epic embers useful and use them to get a set of masterwork or legendary gear, I would be happy to grind away (providing the drop-rates were increased). But as it is now it just feels like Bioware has just designed the game around a grind that makes it almost impossible to get a truly min-maxed build no matter how many hundreds of hours you pour into the game.

The endgame design is just completely aimless right now, and it's killing the game.

2

u/Yamadronis Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

I like this post. It's well thought out and expresses current issues in a reasonable manner while relaying personal reasoning and experience. I wish it had some positive things to say as well, but I understand that's hard and secondary when all your friends have left and you feel the way you do.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

Thanks for the props! It's a rough one for sure. I wanted so desperately to love this game, but the design decisions are just driving me away.

13

u/Jay_Ell_Gee PLAYSTATION Mar 10 '19

I could not agree more.

I’m 30 now, not 20. I have a career, a family, responsibilities, as well as other hobbies that compete for my time.

I’ve been saying this since I hit endgame 9 days ago, that my time just doesn’t feel respected. I grouped up the weekend before this with some end game players and was fully MW geared in hours. Now, I’ve barely changed a single piece of gear since.

I never played The Division 1, so 2 is looking like a breath of fresh air to me.

3

u/Fighter5150 Mar 10 '19

Division 1 is $10 bucks. It's legit fun for hours! Get on it bro

1

u/FreshTamale Mar 10 '19

Where? I've been trying to buy it. I really enjoyed the Div2 beta, and since I can't buy it right away due to cost, I wanted to grab Div1 and play it a while. Ubisoft had the gold version for $9, but I was waiting until the weekend to buy and play it. Despite the sale saying it goes until the 11th, they bumped the price back up to $90 a few days ago, and yesterday it was gone entirely.

If you know of anyone else selling it for $10 or less right now for PC, please let me know! I've checked all the stores I can think of.

2

u/Fighter5150 Mar 10 '19

Playstation store

2

u/FreshTamale Mar 10 '19

Damn, the one platform I don't own lol. Thanks though :D Shall keep hoping for a new sale sometime soon!

3

u/Yamadronis Mar 10 '19

Ubisoft store. Gold edition cheap.

1

u/FreshTamale Mar 10 '19

Nah they took it down before the sale ended. It went back up to $90. I saw it in the middle of the week and was going to buy it this weekend. The "Gold Games" sale is still active, but Div1 has been removed. :(

2

u/KypAstar Mar 10 '19

Gold edition was on sale for 10 on uplay. Also greenmangaming.com.

Also, if you like games based on atmosphere alone, Div 1 single player is great. The collectibles and various little non-main story content is really, really interesting, and coupled with the environment of snowy, silent NYC, it is one of the best video game atmospheres I've ever seen.

1

u/FreshTamale Mar 10 '19

They took it off sale despite the "Gold Games" sale still going on Uplay. My bad for thinking I could wait a few days. GMG also is $50 for the base.

Thank you though :D I'll just wait. It's no big deal, although certainly annoying they took it off sale early despite their advertising it until March 11th.

1

u/Fighter5150 Mar 10 '19

Basically the expansions to div1 are not worth the price, because it's so late in the game but the base game is super cool

6

u/TheBlueHat Mar 10 '19

What's an ever bigger insult is now after the patch you can get MW/leggo components that aren't for the javelin you're playing, nothing feels more insulting than finally seeing that yellow shine and it's a component for a javelin you never intend on playing.

2

u/ForceOmega Mar 10 '19

What's a yellow shine :'D

1

u/Zeebie_ Mar 10 '19

I wish this could be an option in the setting. Bias loot on/off. I play all 4 javs so dont mind it but if i didnt I would find it infuriating.

2

u/aw_coffee_no PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

We need more well-written posts like these. Thanks for bringing out your (and our) concern in a mature way. This is the kind of post that needs more traction to be seen by devs.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

Thanks! 'Preciate it

4

u/mmmikhailov Mar 10 '19

Blackout time people! Stop playing at least for 24 hours until the loot is back and BW confirms that officially!

1

u/nocith Mar 10 '19

Way ahead of you, RF Chieftan is a rough league starter.

2

u/SarcasticPedant Mar 11 '19

Playing Anthem feels like walking the Path of Exile.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Would anybody be upset, at this point, if they pulled Anthem and re-released it in a year?

I know that flying around like Iron Man and using powerful abilities to nuke braindead AI mobs is kinda fun, but to what end? Is farming purples in an empty world, running the same 3 legendary contracts and same 3 Strikes Strongholds on repeat really that thrilling an experience?

There isn't much incentive to get lost in customization, stat building, or crafting either. Any reason to enjoy a looter and invest in the world or your character is simply absent.

I feel like an Alpha tester tasked with providing feedback to a new Indie studio while enduring the growing pains of a brand new project that hasn't quite come together yet...

1

u/zlidiabetichar Mar 11 '19

I would respect the devs more if they did what Square Enix did with FFXIV (shut the game down for a year, come back with a game that was actually enjoyable and fun for a long period of time). Everything shows how shallow the game is, from the state of the game (bugs and performance) to the damage numbers (math behind everything), no raids, proper build options, stable loot progression... Even if we get anything new, we are still going to face the same frustrations because those systems and content aren't developed yet. For fck sake even the store / mtx doesn't have items that are worth buying that alone should show the state of the realm... So yea, this is a PTS (public test server) and we are the testers of a prequel of a game that is going to be fun to play and actually respect out time, brain and money.

10

u/aevitas1 XBOX - Mar 10 '19

As much as I agree, I don’t think Bioware gives a shit..

Note how they delayed the white/green drops fix to test ‘internally’ to see what drops feel like. You can’t tell me this feels good to them, then they mess it up and there’s a loot craze for an hour causing positive posts here and it’s insta nerfed.

As much as I love Anthem, it feels like Bioware is trying to kill it asap. These decisions are rediculous..

Edit: Bioware seems to threat loot like their way to keep this game alive, they think this is exciting and keeps players here.. Yeah, heh.

1

u/SerErris PC - 4k Mar 10 '19

Pretty much the same here. My time is too precious so I stopped playing Amnthem. Also I am not gonna invest anytime into any shop item. I still have all coins and of cause did not buy any shards ...

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

Yeah, I haven't invested anything in the shop either. It's insane to me that you can't just preview the emotes/armor/materials from the shop, you actually have to load into the forge and preview armor pieces one by one etc.

Having a limited shop with rotating items that nobody wants to buy... oof.

1

u/SerErris PC - 4k Mar 11 '19

That was not exactly my point. I more doubt that anyone is now even putting money at all in this game. But I agree they do not make it very easy to spend money :-)

That looks like the main design principle. Make it hard to love the game as much as possible on every level

1

u/Zickened Mar 10 '19

I feel this as well. It feels like this at every level of the game and it pushes me off. You wait for a long loading screen, to be greeted to a solo hub where you can only crawl to destinations and when you're done doing that, you get to a long load screen to get into a screen that makes you wait to join a queue while staring at a menu. Then, when you get into combat, you wait on cooldowns and fly between destinations to wait on more tacky cooldowns before you jetpack to the next destination, which surprise surprise, runs out of cooling, so you have to slow down and run to the next destination (getting the gist?). Then, to top it off, you get a mediocre supply of useless junk so you have to wait on more loot! It actually surprises me that in free play you don't have to run back to where you started to end the game!

Loot 2.0 did more for D3 than loot pinatas. It also gave characters the ability to have faster abilities, and new, awesome abilities.

I wanted this to be like Halo, but with jet packs and D3 loot. Why? Because these games exist. They are part of a multimillion franchise that seems to have worked on their games enough that they have a golden shine on them. They set expectations that people now have. The game play should be fun, do something similar but different than its predecessors and keep it engaging. What we have instead is a rushed botch job that feels under cooked that completely went into this blindfolded. Hell man, Diablo 2 and Duke Nukem 3d are like 20 years old and their gameplay is infinitely more satisfying than this hobbled together shit. I mean who honestly played this and thought it would be great to have a buggy group hub, a slow walk solo hub that you can't jump into your javelin from anywhere and thought that was even remotely functional? Why did it have to be a patch thing? It feels like Bioware is so high on their own shit that they have rose colored glasses that they just overlooked glaring issues.

The gameplay is lacking in a major way. I can't tell you how much I think cooldowns are the most immature and complacent way to do abilitity gameplay loops. Even global cooldowns are a shoddy stop gap, it's an unrewarding tool to make something feel powerful. If anything a charge up shot or cast is so much better, its anticipation, its focus, its situational awareness that has to happen and it's rewarding that you went through that time investment when it impacts. Cooldowns reward what? Patience of doing nothing and only simply timing properly so that you eliminate 3 year olds from the player pool?

I remember playing Sunset Overdrive and they had a gun that launched teddy bears with dynamite strapped to them and when you exploded certain monsters with it, the word "POP" would show up and the enemy would explode in a shower of orange goop all over the place. That was satisfying every single time. It was also ridiculous and broke the 4th wall but it was satisfying! You know what else is ridiculous and breaks the 4th wall? Causing a massive combination on a guy, resulting in an explosion and watching a whole guy fall over and disappear without any physical damage appearing. I want to see a dude's arm ragdoll across the map as my efforts of explosions result in a gory award. I get it, I may sound like a sadist or something by saying that, but why have humans if you're going to have explosive damage do nothing that happens in a realistic situation? If you have that much of an aversion to visual damage to people, why not have 3 armed hyena men instead? I mean I think Sniper Elite is a little overkill on that note, but it at least factors into the reward for the effort, which makes the gunplay loop rewarding! If the damage is meaningless, then killing enemies feels like a chore, just to get them out of the way so that you don't hit the pause button when you get downed.

I'm at level 18 right now and I just feel spent on it so far. Everything feels very samey and boring. The access to the in-game story is mediocre thus far, even in-mission when the voice over says the exact same audio clip after each checkpoint and actual story elements are buried in sub menus to read instead of being fleshed out through additional dialogue options, flash back sequences or something. I expect that because a little known company called Bioware actually set the precedent for this.

And all of this culminates into an experience that feels like they had 256 colors to choose from and chose black white and grey, its uninspired and feels like anything that could have added a little bit of ridiculousness for the sake of fun didn't fit in their mold and they aren't interested in listening to any criticism, positive or negative. It feels like they had 200 words for an essay that required 1000 and the assignment was due the next day... and when they got a D, they exclaimed that it was printed on pretty paper, so you should overlook the content issues and spelling mistakes, but if you gave them 6 months, it would be vaguely fixed better. It feels like I got shammed out of 60 bucks and that my instant money was worth more than my future money, and they don't have a structure in place to make my time or my future money worth it to them. It also feels like that's the gist of what other people are saying, too. It's like the game has cancer before anyone knew it, its parents know it has 2 weeks to live without immediate intervention and they're acting like it's totally healthy if they just keep believing it will. Meanwhile everyone that isn't in the family is begging to get the game some help.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

Thanks for taking the time to write up such a detailed response!

I agree with you on a lot of this stuff, and think that you bring up a lot of interesting points regarding how multiplayer games are typically developed and balanced versus how singleplayer games are handled.

Sadly, when Ben Irving was the lead producer on SWTOR a lot of the same stuff happened that's currently going with Anthem. Players would ask for common sense, obvious changes that needed to be made in order for the game to survive and he would always reply with stuff like "Oh we'll do internal testing and then in a few months we might fix it" which is pretty much what's happening with the loot situation now.

I was hoping that he would have learned something from his experience with SWTOR (the playerbase kind of rejoiced when he left) and I was really happy with how transparent the devs were pre-release, but now it seems like all that talk of really listening to the community and making quick changes based on community feedback was just that... talk.

I like Ben and the Bioware execs behind Anthem a lot as people, but as developers they need to realize that they don't have months to address the design issues with this game. They have like a week to get bandaid fixes out, or people will start leaving.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

I still think that shooting things in destiny is more fun. But the ability usage!!! That’s something they did right.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

I agree. As an old MMO addict, I really love the emphasis on abilities that this game has.

1

u/Klarkasaurus Mar 10 '19

When I finish playing anthem I have never had that feeling ever in my life of 25+ years of playing video games that I felt I just completely wasted my time in my life.

1

u/TAEROS111 Mar 11 '19

It just feels bad. Once you load into a mission and the music is playing, you're like 'this sounds awesome!'

Then you fly around and you're like 'This looks awesome!'

Then you blow something up with a grenade combo and you're like 'This feels awesome!'

And then you realize that you have to go through five loading screens just to get into the game, get into an activity, get loot, equip the loot, and continue playing with said loot.

Then you get disconnected multiple times in a single mission.

Then you don't get the loot at the end of the mission because it bugged out.

Then you spend hours on legendary contracts and strongholds just to get 4-5 useless masterworks with bad inscriptions.

And then, at a certain point, you just realize that the game is like 20% fun and 80% slogging through bad design to try and get to the fun stuff, and it just all feels pointless.

3

u/Stewie01 Mar 10 '19

Play a different game, you'll actually have fun with. Like you said, for now this is a waste of time.

3

u/_Dialectic_ PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

I never played diablo 3. I'll be buying it for my switch and playing it instead of this

4

u/SorainRavenshaw PC - Definitly not a Dominon Defector Mar 10 '19

funny thing about that: it was evidently doing the game for console that convenced much of the diablo 3 team to reevaluate their fundamental assumptions. Resulting in Reaper of Souls loot 2.0 that basically saved Diablo 3. I've seen one of the project leads from that talk about it.

3

u/stevenomes PLAYSTATION Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

to me its more about satisfaction. if i played a stronghold it takes 30 min and its really fun, at the end i get trash, i still would keep playing if the game is fun. but the problem is that the game is no longer fun. destiny had gunplay. no matter what the drops where and how many times you ran through crota or rinsed and repeated the nightfalls, it still was fun to get new guns, even if they werent that great, and shoot them and feel how they responded to your inputs. reloading, sound, responsiveness etc. all of it was on point. Anthem had that as well with the flying mechanics and combo system. it was really fun at first, but now with nothing new to try its just not as marvelous as it was at first. so then at that point you're right, they need to fix the loot system to make it more rewarding. if im going through a hard grind that isnt that fun i at least want to get something out of it. the game doesnt respect your time, and that is evident if you do the monitor stronghold. such a long slog for absolute horseshit drops. its not worth it. if the fight was cool and a rush i might keep trying but why?

3

u/oflowz Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

Sounds funny if you've never played it, but if Anthem had Starllink Battle for Atlas' open world upgrade/fortification/control system, missions, crafting, pilot skilll upgrading, creature scanning and loadout changing on the fly it would be the game everyone thought it would be.

3

u/JoshuaBadillo97 Mar 10 '19

There’s games you see yourself playing a year or two down the line. Other games you play for a month and forget about. This being one of them. I’m 21, school, internship, gym, I love this game, but if I’m not really being rewarded for my time what’s the point in playing? My homies left back to other games, I was the one telling them how great this game was and to give it another try. But it’s just complete a mission, salvage every item except for maybe 2, rinse and repeat. I’m all for grinding and shit, but there’s no excitement anymore. They could be new missions, but the loot would be the same. I’ve been sitting on 492, now 704 for about a week and half. Why continue with a game if you’re not progressing at all? Just yesterday I played for a bit, gotten 80+ purples, 2 Masterworks.. everything was salvaged. Imagine that...

9

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Me and my friends have been end-game (Power 490) for two weeks now. Yes! Two weeks waiting for a proper loot fix.

But nothing...

Two weeks, then a month, two months, a year...

Anthem? What's that? A game we shall never speak of again...

-5

u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19

So it's Bioware's fault that you went through a months worth of content in a week?

6

u/DefenestrateMyStyle Mar 10 '19

Saying there's a month of content is quite generous

-3

u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19

I haven't even gotten to level 30 yet, and I have a job and a life outside of video games.

4

u/rum_burak Mar 10 '19

10-15 h since release is a lot?

1

u/DefenestrateMyStyle Mar 10 '19

You're not unique in that, there's just not much content

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

That's a months worth of content? Man... No wonder people want refunds.

Of course, that's not the true reason. 'Fun' is the true content, most important part of the game and real reason why people even care (check the sub).

Loot patch right now isn't fun. 99% of the sub agrees. It's been no fun for two weeks, even if we were max level, it was always about the loot.

1

u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19
  1. Im having plenty of fun just playing the game.

  2. what percentage of Anthem players are on this sub?

1

u/AbundantFailure Mar 10 '19

There's not a months worth of content here.

1

u/KypAstar Mar 10 '19

Lol months worth of content. The division w beta literally had more content. That's not even a joke. It's quantifiable.

2

u/Forgot10Hero Mar 10 '19

Very well said. I feel the same way. I so badly want this to be a great game to sink hundreds of hours into, but I just can't anymore. I haven't gotten an upgrade in days. Feels bad man :(

2

u/FestarUK Mar 10 '19

I’m very disappointed with the Game. Needs probably another 6 months of updates and more end game content. I’ll be playing the Division 2 for a few weeks then coming back to Anthem to see the state of the Game. Here’s hoping.

2

u/_Xebov_ PC - Mar 10 '19

I fully get that.

My weapons for example are all crafted. With all the items in the pool there is currently a 1/60 chance to get the desired weapon. I turned 30 within the pre release and i still dont have all weapons available. As soon as i got one i liked, i simply crafted it over and over until i got a decent roll. The chance to craft an update for me is practically zero.

For Abilities and Components the guaranteed drops are great to get the first ones. After that the chances for upgrades are nearly zero as well. For components i cant even craft MW ones.

Upgrading to Legendaries is hardly possible. I got a couple but all fall short in the damage compartment.

2

u/lonigus Mar 10 '19

First half of the game is a solid 7/10. The leveling process feels fluid and you feel the power going up to 30. Then the epics start to drop, you finish the somewhat decent story and get your frist MW in hard!

Then its like someone sacked the team responsible for the first half and subbed in the intern team responsible for endgame.

2

u/Stryker90210 Mar 11 '19

I've never played a game that felt more like it wanted me to dislike the game in spite of myself than Anthem.

I had to laugh at this line. I have said the same thing many times while playing Anthem. I really want to like this game. Especially since there really isn't anything else I want to play right now. But enough is enough. They have four days to significantly improve loot drops, after that I will be playing Division 2 and likely will not be back. I feel like I am putting in extreme effort to like this game and at every turn it is punching me in the face. It is a shame because I feel it had so much potential.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19

I completely agree. I was longing for this game forever and when it came out I was a bit underwhelmed. There were concerning aspects that had me and my group hesitant to keep playing. We shoved those fears aside and kept grinding.

Just last night the more optimistic friend just had enough and wanted to switch to a different game because in his words, “I’m tired of not being rewarded for playing this damn long.” I had to agree, we played 2 hours on freeplay without a single masterwork drop, and 3 days had gone by without any of us seeing a legendary! I’m all for a loot grind, hell I love that feeling, but in two days I had only received maybe 5 masterworks and only 2 of those weren’t duplicates.

I want this game to do well but seriously playing from 9:30pm till 1:00am and not getting anything useable for my javelins is a joke. If I’m going to see 160 epic drops atleast make those epics useable in some way.

2

u/ActionFlank Mar 10 '19

You're playing the same 3 dungeons repeatedly, just to do them again with a different gun. I don't think you respect your own time.

2

u/ContextualAnalysis Mar 10 '19

Got 4 masterworks from one GM1 quickplay after the drop rate nerf. That guy who says open world is better may be on to something

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Bro, thank you.

1

u/PM_ME_YER_DOOKY_HOLE Mar 10 '19

Well, they work for a company that doesn't respect their customers.

What the hell did we think was gonna hapoen?

1

u/Esppx Mar 10 '19

BioWare have asked us to give feedback on bugs and / or issues with the game on the EA-forum as well as on Reddit. I have made a post on the drop rate of legendaries is here: https://answers.ea.com/t5/Bug-Reports/Way-to-low-droprate-for-yellows/m-p/7658062#M15240

For all of us, please hit «me too» on this post, and if you want – feel free to give your though on this issue. I think we’re a lot of people that think this is one of the biggeste issue with the game at the moment.

1

u/chinmi PC Mar 10 '19

Very well written OP !

We need the increase in loot drop to min max our javelin setup. Somehow, someone that have the power to make decisions at bioware thinks if we get too much loot, we will stop playing in a month. They're wrong !! They're so stupid to think that way !! They don't realized that to min max and get the perfect rolled items will take more then a month or two or more !! And if we didnt get much loot to start min maxing, we will stop playing in less then a week caused of bored and frustration.

1

u/Skitt3r Mar 10 '19

I remember when games had items that were deliberately useless but were either extremely difficult to acquire or ridiculously expensive because it was a good laugh, now we get mad because games "dont respect us or our time".

2

u/midgetsnowman Mar 10 '19

pretty sure the differrence is if you get a joke weapon in a game thats explicitly designed to be a joke, thats a tad different than the first legendary gun youve seen in weeks having terrible stats

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Welcome to Elite Dangerous... oh wait.

1

u/Spellers569 Mar 10 '19

Well constructed post I 100% agree with everything you’ve said here

1

u/Anotherwan-kenobi Mar 10 '19

Laughs in destiny competitive

1

u/Kofipita Mar 10 '19

Also, I Love Capital Letters.

1

u/Bmac-Attack XBOX - Mar 10 '19

I wish I could get a full refund. I paid for a falsely advertised product

1

u/XorMalice PC - Mar 10 '19

All fair points.

The ember change is the one that is more annoying to me, actually. I've always been of the opinion that they will at some point increase the loot, and that will be somewhat soon. As such, my time building gear in game comes with the caveat that every hour I spend now on that could be done in half an hour at some point in the future- the obvious exceptions being the lootsplosion bugs, where every ten minutes is worth two hours later.

As such, I have mostly assumed that I'm playing at the stage of the game where the devs don't understand proper loot compensation over time. It wasn't long ago when I would roll up +175% modifiers, with the gear icon, to damage types that weren't present, and the devs changed that, raising the quality of loot per time by a smallish but still reasonable amount.

By contrast, the embers have always felt like a fair use of time, as they allow for rerolling actually relevant pieces. With an ember ninja nerf, especially one that feels like it will be reverted as soon as the weekend is over, it feels real bad to log in. It's as if the days I have off and could actually put into the game have had their value torpedoed- meanwhile, days when I'll be really busy with work will be appropriately valued (or at least closer to later progression).

Very frustrating, the loot, the embers, very confusing too. I'm not interested in The Division 2, but I'm looking forward to its launch, as I strongly suspect Bioware will be offering loot buffs at that time.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Don’t bother reading the text BioWare. The title is all you need to understand literally ALL of the angry posts on the front page. One simple switch flip and your game will stop bleeding itself out of life.

1

u/xeznut PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

Couldn't agree more. This is exactly what I feel. And if I leave now, I won't come back later.

1

u/Judeah Mar 10 '19

My problem with the game is crap loot and a shitty combat system. GM2 and 3 are not worth farming.

1

u/Tancrad Mar 10 '19

I really enjoyed the combat system. It's the only thing holding people in the game I think.

Everything else is what's wrong.

1

u/Judeah Mar 10 '19

That's where I disagree, the while AI aimbot thing is extremely annoying.

1

u/BruhAgainWithThis Mar 10 '19

So many people are so dead set that division 2 is going to be great. It baffles me that after the issues people have seen with this, and many other games, that anyone would blindly jump behind another game.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Yeah. Just beat the game last night and already feel bored of it. I got a couple MW's and some more stuff with Luck but Freeplay feels empty unless you play with friends, Strongholds get boring (hate how Temple of Scar feels so cramped) after a couple runs, and once all the sidequests are done, the game won't hold my attention for too much longer.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

They should do one last world event where we see the game die in real time.

Server shutdown message pops up you see that plume of smoke way off in the distance before you see the blast wave hit you and wipe out your character for good....

Bam! GAME CRASHED FORCED SHUTDOWN!

Beautiful execution 💪🏻

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

No game exists today that "values your time/investment" Anthem is losing players based on variety of re-playable content. By content I mean strongholds The loot can come from anywhere in the world no matter how they implement it. Whenever Bioware adds a couple new strongholds and dungeons, people will come back.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

I couldn't have said this better. This is EXACTLY how I feel after my day today. I will at this point be only playing with friends while they take the slower more graceful journey to level 30.

1

u/Wellhellob PC - Mar 10 '19

Same feelings my dude.

1

u/srcsm83 PC Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19

I do very much agree... however I suppose I'll be keeping an eye out and popping in eventually when there is new content. But it discourages and baffles me that there hasn't been atleast armor sets that would keep me interested and that the loot's just not there, despite it having accidentally been in a good place twice already..

During the last few days I've felt like hopping on to play a bit more (as I genuinely enjoy the gameplay) but I haven't because of the feeling, that I'll be much better off hopping on later.. When things have been fixed, when the new content is here etc... but to hear that they will keep on working to make the loot better in the "next few MONTHS" is discouraging. What can be so difficult about it if, again, it has already been better by sheer accident? Atleast they could make the loot percentages halfway of what the "bugged loot" was... If I don't get 11 masterworks for 30 minutes, then I would certainly atleast appreciate around 5-6 masterworks per 30 minutes, instead of 0-1 masterworks we have now. That is if they still want to consider whether they want to make them that high, they could atleast for now improve them a nice compromise while they consider anything higher?

it just doesn't feel like I can consistently work towards anything at this moment. I have no armor sets I wanna save up for (insane that we have seen so little cosmetics), no reward that I would work towards or no incentive to play for loot when time and time again I come out of several hour sessions with handfuls of purples.

So while the gameplay is fun and I do play FOR fun, the lack of progress is working as a deterrent from hopping on. It's the worst damn feeling to accomplish a hard task, feel like you just triumphed over a challenge and then see a piece of trash as the reward. At that point it just annoys me and takes away from feeling good.

What feels even more demotivating, is how the entire sub is voicing this same thing across the board... and it's seemingly falling to deaf ears. Or - well - maybe not deaf, but nothing has been done to it and we only get "we'll look into it in the coming months". I'm sorry BioWare.. but I'm not sure how many more months you realistically have to fix something so essential before even the most patient of us start looking elsewhere :/ Not a threat, just trying to be honest.

1

u/Mardalf Mar 11 '19

Soo it's basically destiny is what I'm hearing

1

u/cypherhalo Mar 11 '19

You can’t play Warframe and talk about Anthem not respecting your time. Warframe is some of the worst grind that disrespects a players time I’ve ever seen. Not a bad game but the grind kills it for me.

1

u/ApollyonGuard Mar 20 '19

Wow! Thank you for saying, so eloquently, what I have been feeling. I want to chime in but I know it will only come out as frustration and anger. However I will say this, I feel this was NOT $120-ish dollars well spent and I (and hopefully many others) will not be pre-ordering your next game (unless it is Dragon Age AND there is a confirmed blood mage option) if I purchase it at all. I hope others in the game industry see this and realize that loosing my demographic's interest in your product is a poor financial decision.

1

u/pp_sven_BERG Mar 10 '19

how is the inscription in d2 works ? Is it better ?

6

u/lizhenghao1999 PC - Mar 10 '19

Each armor/weapon have two slots for random perk roll. Perks have fixed value so only the type/effect matters. Less variety but much more good rolls.

1

u/artfu1 PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

D2 is a 5 year old game including d1, d1 took a good while to get right, arguably the taken king a whole year later it started to fix then a while year again so two years, anthem is a new ip and has an excuse, shitty all the same but it ain't fair to compare

3

u/lizhenghao1999 PC - Mar 10 '19

Yep not saying D2 is better on that. Gear progression in D2 is becoming increasingly boring because better gear doesn’t give anything other than a linear damage increase. Just sad that I thought anthem would bring something fresh in the arena.

2

u/artfu1 PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

Me too mate,5k hours in d1 and just fried with d2 was soooo looking forward to anthem but solo play and all the issues makes it hard, especially after waiting since first announced, thinking about division2 Dident play beta as playing the anthem beta I think ruined my excitement for the game.

1

u/Nepharios Mar 10 '19

^ this and so much this! I need the feeling that i get something in return for invested time, and this game does not respect my time in any way... really sad!

1

u/lymsha Mar 10 '19

" I enjoyed the leveling process. "
It was a chore, really.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Sorry. But when i see thread like this with subject like that, all i can think of is that you are taking playing games waaaay toooo serious. You really dont have to do it if you dont enjoy it.

4

u/ePiMagnets Mar 10 '19

And that is his point. Some of us take our hobbies very seriously because they are what we use to keep our sanity. I have no problem dumping hundreds to thousands of hours into games I love and do so willingly when I feel my time is being respected and rewarded.

The moment that begins to wane I move on, sometimes I hold on for a little too long. In some cases I too feel sad or a little let down, especially when it was something I was excited for. I was very excited for anthem... was.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

If something that is your way of stress out costs you stress something is wrong.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

I think you went too emotional on this one.

1

u/Zickened Mar 10 '19

Apparently unlike you, I don't pay people 60 bucks to shit on me.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Apparently unlike me, 60 bucks for you is so much that you have to go on personal vendetta with developers. Get a job man.

1

u/Zickened Mar 11 '19

How much I make or anyone else in this thread for that matter doesn't excuse your crap attitude. I bought something that I'm not satisfied with and can't return it, otherwise this entire conversation would be moot. The only reason we're still talking is that the game isn't delivering on what was promised and until it is, I'll have a vendetta with the people who took that money.

1

u/Grundlage damage floaties Mar 10 '19

Hello, your post has been removed

for Rule [#1]:

Please remain civil. Personal attacks and insults, harassment, trolling, flaming, and baiting are not allowed. No harassing, vulgar, or sexual comments. No being creepy.

This includes responding with an insult to someone who insulted you. If you insult back, you may also get a removal/warning. Report any violations of Incivility using the report button instead.

This is not a warning, just a friendly reminder.

As part of release week we are enforcing harsher consequences. See more about this policy here.


If you would like to contest this removal, or want a better explanation as to why your submission violated this rule, please modmail us.

Do not reply to this message, or private message this moderator; it will be ignored.

We are not affiliated with BioWare, or EA. The views of the mod team do not reflect the views of BioWare, EA, or any of their subsidiaries.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

It’s fascinating to me how it takes someone dozens of hours of playing this game before they realize it doesn’t respect them.