r/AnthemTheGame • u/RealSeltheus • Mar 09 '19
Discussion To all the people defending the low droprates and convoluted inscription system, saying "we just want free amazing loot ASAP", let's teach you some math.
Okay, so let's get the most important thing out of the way first.
I LIKE Anthem, I like the gameplay, I even thought the story was decent enough and so were most characters.
BUT you can like something and point out it's flaws with good intentions, for the sake of the game becoming a more well rounded and enjoyable experience. There aren't just haters and white knights out there, there is a whole big spectrum in between and they make up the majority, so put down your pitchforks and try to see the bigger picture.
So now to the topic at hand. The loot and inscription situation. People being angry about the reverted increase in droprates aren't just lazy bums that want everything handed to them, it's more complex then that and it all boils down to psychological manipulation of the mind through perception, not neccesarrily facts. But the fact is an increased droprate doesn't affect the whole "you will just get all ultimate god rolls within a week and be done with the game"...that's not how things work.
And this is where the math comes in. So let me break it down to the essentials first.
X = 100/Y(Z4)
Y stands for the amount of possible MW items in the loot pool
Z stands for the amount of possible inscriptions in each slot, to the power of four for the slot amounts.
Y = 27(MW weapons) + 10(class specific components) + 10(MW Gear) = 47
Z = for the sake of simplicity let's go with 15 possible different inscriptions per slot, which seems modest, it's most likely more.
So 15 to the power of four = 50 625 different combinations of inscriptions(and this isn't even accounting for the different percentage rolls, just the inscription type itself, otherwise this number would be multiple times as high)
So this gets us to:
X = 100/47(50625)
X = 100/2.379.375
X = 0.0000420278
THESE ARE THE ODDS FOR ANY GIVEN COMBINATION OF INSCRIPTIONS ON ANY GIVEN MW DROP!!!
Now to clarify, it's a hypothetical number since it streamlines 15 possible inscriptions per slot(which should be in the right ball park though), DOESN'T account for different percentage rolls for each of them AND doesn't take into account the actual droprate of MW items(since this variable is unknown), just the odds for when a MW item DOES drop.
Needless to say, accounting for the missing variables you can safely add several zeros behind the decimal.
So here is where the psychological manipulation of the mind comes in.
You'd have to win the lottery to beat the odds of EVER getting that so called "god roll". Impossible? No. Mathematically extremely unlikely? Yeah.
So what is an increased droprate actually gonna do for you? In the greater scheme of things? Almost nothing. What does it do for your mind? Everything you need to keep you going.
It manipulates you into perceiving the odds as higher as they factually are and therefore tricks you into thinking you got "a chance" at your god roll, despite the possibility being next to none.
I'd like to bring up an example I used in a different topic, where people defended the low droprates. Think of getting your god roll as equally as possible as winning the actual lottery. Buying a ticket(aka MW drop) gives you the chance, of course, but how likely is it?
Now assume you are buying ten thousand tickets(10 000 MW drops)...does it increase your odds of winning the lottery? No, it doesn't. That's not how math and probability works. The odds are always the same, it never changes, because getting ten thousand tickets doesn't add the odds up accumulatively...it's the SAME odds per ticket. Your chances increase, based on the amount of tickets, the odds however are always the same...next to none. But "in your head" this is processed differently...it makes you believe your odds are better on a superficial level.
It works the same way with the increased droprate of items. THIS IS WHY an increased droprate has nothing to do with getting the ultimate gear, it's about tricking your mind into perceiving the odds as more favourable than they factually are. It makes you feel like "shooting for that god roll" is a possibility and therefore keeps you engaged and keep on trying.
THAT IS WHAT PEOPLE ASKING FOR INCREASED DROPRATES REALLY WANT. Not free handouts...
So yeah...if you read up to this point, thanks for taking the time. If you still disagree that the droprate should stay as it is, then at least accept the notion of "our" demands as a valid reasoning.
38
u/Kegheimer Mar 10 '19
This is bad math, but has the right idea.
I don't own anthem, but I'm lurking. So if the inscription slots are UNIQUE then you are correct.
Z4 is the total number of sequences (with replacement!). AAAA is an option. ABCD and DCBA are distinct options
The math you're looking for is "15 choose 4", which is 15! / 11! 4!
"15 choose 4" is 1365. Substantially lower than 50625.
That makes the odd of your god roll ~37 times more than what you stated.
4
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
Inscription slots are unique, each are categorized into minor/major primary and minor/major secondary, each have their own pool of inscriptions and distinct percentage ranges.
I'm no math genius, so I appreciate the input.
5
u/Kegheimer Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
Combinatorics was one of my favorite classes I took for my math / stats degree!
EDIT - looks like these are permutations since a primary major presumably cannot also be a primary minor or a secondary.
Then the math is 15! / 11! which is 32,760. Still smaller than 154 but not as much.
4
u/zarjaa PS4 - Mar 10 '19
Appreciate the efforts, but still believe this to be incorrect.
Each pool is distinct: A can have 1 of 15 (from Pool 1 major), B can have 1 of 15 (from pool 1 minor), C can have 1 of 15 (from pool 2 minor), D can have 1 of 15 (from pool 2 major).
So Z4 would still be accurate since you are technically only "15 choose 1" for each inscription.
However, I will add that the rolls can also have a range of values. So this actually becomes a significantly large problem even assuming a uniform distribution of value ranges.
12
u/Kitsunekinder Mar 10 '19
There are two distinct pools of primary and secondary, but two inscription pools (with different spreads but we can ignore that for now) for primary and secondary.
So it's
Pool 1 | Pool 2
Pool 2 | Pool 1 <--- Lower line has higher values
Each pool has at least 15 options, if not considerably more, and they're not mutually exclusive in any way. You can roll like
Damage | Luck
Luck | Damage
6
u/Kegheimer Mar 10 '19
So if AB and BA are equivalent outcomes, then it the model is "N choose K combinations". N! / (N-K)! K!
IF AB and BA are distinct outcomes, then it is "N choose K permutations", which is 15! / 11! which is 32,760. This method excludes AA and BB. In Anthem, it would exclude AABD as well.
5
u/xeri-star Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
I don't think it's as simple as a single nCr. Pools 1 and 2 have distinct contents, so I'd say it's an nPr for each pool (perms because the results for each pool can be AA, BB etc). Assuming
n = 15for each pool, and we have two slots for each pool,15 P 2 = 210.For each pair of slots we have 210 perms, so total perms is
210 * 210 = 44,100.I want to stress, though, that
n = 15is a big assumption here and the true sizes of the two pools could greatly affect the result. I might go and count up the actual pool sizes...Edit:
Actually I don't think it's either nPr or nCr! You can roll the same attribute from a pool for both slots, so it is just simply
n * nfor each pair of slots.Looking at the spreadsheet from this comment, there are varying pool sizes depending on the item, and of course some item types only have two slots (one for each pool).
If we take the case of a weapon, it looks like the primary & secondary pool sizes are around
n = 8andm = 20respectively, and we have 4 slots with the above pattern (2 slots per pool). Totalpermspossible outcomes are thus:n^2 * m^2 = 64 * 400 = 25,600However, the secondary pool is much less essential to weapon quality. The popular goal seems to be for +Dmg in both primary slots, which has a probability of 1/64, which isn't too bad. Unfortunately, this is just rolling for the attributes and not their values. If both primary slots get +25% Dmg, it's probably trash.
17
→ More replies (6)14
u/ChrischinLoois Mar 10 '19
Yeah but listen, if carol goes to the store with $5 and watermelons are $2.50, then how many bowling balls does she take to the arcade?
→ More replies (2)2
u/Draconax Mar 10 '19
Each inscription slot has its own pool of stats it can roll. They are not dependent on the other slots, and you can get duplicates of the same stat.
25
u/Hypnoticrain PC - Mar 10 '19
Finally a legendary loot post, I was getting only commons in the NEW feed.
9
6
u/Pleanio Mar 10 '19
They are prob. just afraid of giving out more embers and people not spending enough coins on them (since they want to drain and push them to spend real money on skins).
Thanks for taking your time to provide some math. nice read ;)
8
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
They shot themselves in the foot in that department anyway 😑 If there were more customizable options to get through Coins/Shards, people might actually spend them.
I'm sitting on 140k Coins right now after already spending around 80k...there is just not much worth getting :/
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Eternio Mar 10 '19
wonder if the devs will respond to this well thought out post, which is exactly what they said they wanted.
6
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
I honestly don't expect them to respond to any of these kind of posts, I just want them to realize that "doing incremental adjustments" over the span of a few months is gonna break this games neck. They need a solution and they need a sense of direction to follow through and they need it now. The current loot and inscription system and droprate is something they can't leave as is for much longer...even one week is stretching it at this point with Division 2 right around the corner.
57
u/riddleme Mar 10 '19
BioWare right now:
"We hear your feedback and will continue to monitor the situation."
Translated:
"Despite the multitude of lessons learned from similar genre games and pleading from our current playerbase, we will continue to be stubborn and do what WE think is right."
14
u/D_Banner Mar 10 '19
Its Ben Irvo dude, look up his history on SWOTR
3
u/behemon PC - (~°o°)~ Here's an ember ~(°o°~) Mar 10 '19
Is he the one responsible for that "awesome" F2P transition?
3
6
u/SikorskyUH60 Mar 10 '19
Ah, the Just Cause method of "oh, y'all want multiplayer? Nah, we tried it and didn't like it, so enjoy singleplayer!"
→ More replies (1)1
u/BudgetChicken Mar 10 '19
Agreed. The answer is staring them in the face and they still don't seem to understand. I've already stopped playing because of this situation. I would play through all the crashes and nuisances if loot was actually fun. If they fix the end game loot hunt I might come back but I'm not holding my breath at this point.
43
u/x-Sage-x Colossus Mar 09 '19
Brace for the incoming “but masterworks won’t feel special anymore!” Or “but muh specials”
4
u/zykezero Mar 10 '19
BW really just messed up by having item power level more closely tied to item rarity.
Should have spent more time reflecting on MMO loot progression.
11
u/ogtitang Mar 10 '19
Don't forget Legendaries won't feel legendary anymore. They're prolly just reading through the comments downvoting every single one of us too, like it matters.
22
u/THUMB5UP ༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ *Summon a complete game overhaul* ༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ Mar 10 '19
As if they felt Legendary to begin with....
-__-
→ More replies (1)3
u/MrStealYoBeef Mar 10 '19
Those 0% legendary effects are really some amazing effects.
And the effects that do work just directly reduce cooldowns, increase damage, or increase damage reduction. Amazing. Truly the most creative legendary effects I've ever seen.
2
Mar 10 '19
These people need to realize they don't feel special now, I grind for an hour and it's one MW with inscriptions like +3% elemental resist and +7% pick-up radius then it's trash heap like every blue and purple I get.
0
Mar 10 '19
[deleted]
→ More replies (3)2
u/ieattime20 Mar 10 '19
What's a game with good loot mechanics?
→ More replies (2)8
u/Stinkis Mar 10 '19
Diablo 3 is infamous for its Loot 2.0 patch which is basically a masterclass in good loot mechanics and its effect on player satisfaction.
Here's a feedback post for loot in Anthem by one of the devs behind that infamous patch.
→ More replies (3)
10
u/Lucky_Number_Sleven Mar 10 '19
I like this, and I feel like it explains the core issue with Anthem's loot nicely. It also doesn't account for the fact that Anthem allows for multiple builds, so if you want multiple "god rolls" for different builds on different Javelins, you're completely out of luck.
The stubbornness on this issue is concerning, so thank you for explaining it in numbers instead of feelings. Hopefully, this convinces at least a few people that something needs to change.
4
12
u/Rumshot- Mar 10 '19
But i only need 100 000 MW items to get 4 items with the rolls i want, if i get 5MW items or the same item every hour i only need to play 2.2 years (playtime) to get it. To be fair you where very generoues with your numbers. If you took the roll range (25-300% damage etc) you would need to play this game 100s of years. so if you bump up the drop rate to get 500MW per hour you could do it in 1 year. So gear up in 1 week hmm 26 000 MW per hour you would be geared in 1 week
1
u/Jerronbao Mar 10 '19
I'm sure that this will be lost in the comments, but if the MW items have a guarantee not to have duplicate inscriptions than I think the formula would be
100/(YZ(Z-1)(Z-2)(Z-3))
→ More replies (1)1
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
My formula is missing quite a bunch of variables to be entirely accurate :) It's supposed to be more a broad brush stroke to get the point across, especially since going for a more accurate result would decrease the numerical odds for sure, so it would be even worse xD
The inscriptions slots each have their own pool to pick from though and there is overlap between them, but getting an inscription in one slot doesn't exclude it from rolling in the overlapping slot as well :/
1
u/XenoZervos Mar 10 '19
Well said. Even if the loot you get is trash the feeling of seeing more drops or seeing more orange and yellow makes you want to farm for more and more even though the rolls are going to be garbage. It doesnt cause people to have the thought "Well that was a fucking waste of time". The way things are, its just pushing people away from the game. I had uninstalled the game a week back when the game was crashing/crap loot and i was really frustrated. Reinstalled the game today seeing that there wont be any white or green drops and it felt the exact same way. 1 hour of playing and I was bored and just alt+f4'd the game since i didnt want to bother to go through the menu to quit. Just wanted to get out of the game asap. This is not a type of feeling a looter shooter where end game is the thing to keep you hooked should feel like. Sorry for the negative posts but I can't help it when its frustrating.
2
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
I feel you, my motivation to play took a nosedive in the recent days, even before the loot pinata bug. Investing time in the game just doesn't feel like time well spent right now for me. The fun for the gameplay alone wears thin for me as well, it's still fun, but it's not enough on its own to keep me going anymore, especially now when more and more of my friends start showing the same fatigue.
1
u/Telzen Mar 10 '19
Wait doesn't that math assume you only want 1 of the 47 different available items? Not to mention that once you get the item once you can get its blueprint and then craft it over and over.
1
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
Yes it only depicts the odds of aiming for one specific item with one specific set of inscriptions based on loot drops, not taking out all other possible item drops through targeted crafting.
The odds are nowhere near accurate, since several variables are missing, which in return would only drastically decrease the odds even more, but it's not supposed to be pinpoint accurate, just a simplified visualisation of the general odds design behind it and how increased lootdrops would nearly have no effect on attaining actual god rolls, just the positive psychological effect it would have on players and their engagement.
But despite reducing the lootpool to a specific item through targeted crafting, the odds of getting a god roll are virtually sub 0.1% nonetheless. Not accounting for the time it would take to amass the needed crafting materials.
1
u/Mephb0t Mar 10 '19
Extremely low drop rates on the very best items are precisely what gives looters a prolonged life. Case in point, Diablo 2. I've been playing that game on and off since it came out. Last month I found my first griffon's eye. Fucking AMAZING feeling. I will never forget it. It's one of those moments in gaming you remember forever because it has to be earned.
People here want 10 legendaries per minute so they can farm the ultimate build immediately and then quit the game because there is nothing left to get.
All this begging for insane drop rates.... You're just asking for the game to die. You're asking for it.
I do think they should increase drops, but not to the stupid levels people on here want. I say keep legendaries legendary, and copy the reforge system from Diablo 3. Also items in general need to be far more interesting.
But, just want to say this - I think they need to prioritize frame rate and especially load times before absolutely anything else. The loading in this game is completely retarded and unreasonable and it's stopping so many people from buying the game. Loading first, loot second. Just my 2 cents, downvote if you're mad.
1
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
Sorry to be blunt, but you're projecting things and compare things completely unrelated.
We're not talking about something like a single item like Griffon's Eye in terms of rarity, we're talking about EVERY SINGLE ITEM being a Griffon's Eye in Anthem in terms of rarity(based on inscription pools).
Imagine the Griffon's Eye with the rarity it has, except when you do get it to drop, there is a 99.9% chance the skills and traits on it are garbage. You can't compare these...if it drops it drops, that's the one version that exists and that's that.
That's not how it works in Anthem. Having a hand full of super rare, exclusive items is fine. Having 99.9% of items be trash AND a horrible droprate is not.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/Skovosity XBOX - Mar 10 '19
Perfect post. I have such a difficult time explaining this to my friends. Especially the ones who think they’re odds are so much better on GM2/3 while taking twice as long to clear which is another topic lol.
→ More replies (2)3
u/balloptions Mar 10 '19
the gm2/3 thing vs gm1 is such a struggle w/ my friends
I even recorded a ton of our runs, and we got 6.6% more drops on gm2, but it took 2-3x as long... they still insisted gm2 was better
→ More replies (1)
13
u/mr_funk Mar 10 '19
Yup. Now of course, the idiots will ignore it and still just say we want god roll legendaries in a day, but at least we can say we tried to explain it.
And of course, BioWare also seems completely oblivious to this, which for a game developer is pretty shocking, so I don't actually expect them to do anything about it.
5
u/FaceWithAName Mar 10 '19
The fact that you think they are oblivious is hilarious. They are not oblivious, they just DONT CARE. Everyone here knows they read reddit yet all these fellow gamers are still holding out hope. I too am holding out hope, but in the meantime I have monster hunter world and the div 2 to look forward to. I’m sure this game will be great in a year or two, that’s what everyone keeps telling me. I hope they are right.
17
u/iiSpook PC Mar 09 '19
It's sad this has to be explained.
2
u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19
It's sad that we have to keeps explaining that blindly increasing drop rates will make the leveling experience way too fast. Bioware needs time to find other ways to make endgame loot more rewarding.
→ More replies (3)6
u/mr_funk Mar 10 '19
I can get explaining it to laypeople but not developers.
4
u/iiSpook PC Mar 10 '19
Especially when an actual game developer already explained it to them on this very subreddit.
3
u/usernamechecksout696 Mar 10 '19
Everyone should be aware. It will be exactly a month until they do anything about this. They have nothing good to release to you in a month's time so will need something to try and make people resub or keep chasing that shitty carrot. Expect a half arsed loot buff april 12th.
3
u/Nestramutat- PC - Mar 10 '19
While your math is a bit off, this is why I'm setting the game aside for now.
Anthem stealth nerfed my build with the patch this morning. I had put several dozen hours into optimizing my masterworks for that build, because I found it exceptionally fun. Now it's just about 33% worse across the board.
Can I farm up another build that I'm sure will be just as fun? Yes. Do I want to invest those dozens of hours again, having lost the power level I farmed for, and knowing that anything I earn can be nerfed again? No.
3
u/_gravy_train_ Mar 10 '19
This is an excellent write up and a great perspective.
I don't defend the drop rate as much as I don't really care, but I understand why increasing it is a good idea.
It did feel good getting showered in MWs the other night and did sting getting few today, but whether or not that rate becomes permanent or happens periodically (during events?), doesn't really matter much to me.
I'll make do with what I get until I get something better.
3
u/mmmikhailov Mar 10 '19
Blackout time people! Stop playing at least for 24 hours until the loot is back and BW confirms that officially!
10
u/Sunskyriver Mar 09 '19
This post is very, very well thought out and a shining example of why we need an increased mw/legendary drop rate. Anyone defending the shitty drop rate currently in the game just has no concept of math, and how many hours it would take them to get every masterwork or even 1 with the inscriptions they want. Plus, you didn't factor in that you can get duplicates, and that there are 4 javelins, each with different and unique masterwork component slots.
1
u/TheRealEraser Mar 10 '19
Bioware have made a comment about the loot.
this is not gd news, they say in the next few months!!!!?
https://mobile.twitter.com/crobertson_atx/status/1104506215986548736
this is what i think they should do.
They already have somewhere to start from and thats how the loot was when it was bugged as they say.
Everyone was happy with the loot at that level so simply put it there and then adjust in small steps up or down.
The first thing they need to do is keep the player base happy otherwise by the time they have fixed the loot there will be no playerbase, Remember division 2 is next week and borderlands 3 could well be this year too as they are going to PAX west.
Also if the Dev's are worried about players getting too much good loot too quick there is an easy fix for that.
All they have to do is release a GM4 and a new level of loot called Legion, as in legion of dawn gear.
This will basically reset everyone on the loot grind at the level of loot drops the devs are happy with.
4
u/RealSeltheus Mar 10 '19
Oh jesus this doesn't bode well...for them to think they even got more than a couple weeks to make dramatic changes is somewhat delusional. Making babysteps over the course of a few months won't do nothing, because at that point people moved on and just don't care anymore...smh
1
Mar 10 '19
Guys don't believe this post. Peter Griffin bought thousands of lottery tickets and he was able to buy himself a suit of gold armour. This post is a lie
1
4
Mar 10 '19
I still play Diablo 3.
If you think being showered in loot, having rerolls, and easy farming content is bad for gaming, you have no idea how looters work.
Most people WANT to farm easy dungeons and be showered with loot, because endgame is all about building Godly armor sets, just because. I mean, pushing leaderboards is always fun, but I do it for the stat building, not for any real progression. It's fun to collect sets of Godly armor and power up my weapons to the max, just so I can go show those dumbass minions I've already been farming who's boss.
7
u/Inedditable Mar 10 '19
Out of all the loot posts, this is the one I’ll comment on. You’re cool headed, thinking mathematically, and that’s great. I have no idea if you’re right about any of the calculations, but even if you’re close, adding in the fact that rolls aren’t static, and roll in a range, god rolls will still be super rare even with the loot increase.
I LOVE loot games. I currently have no job, so since this game came out for Xbox, I’ve played it at least 6 hours every day, trying to be as efficient as possible, and looking in to every “loot theory” reddit post. I’ve done the harvest gear and crafting, I’ve done the 2 chest and quite strongholds, I’ve done the freeplay full clear with dungeons. I’ve played a lot, and whenever I stop, I think about playing some more (but I’m strong enough to not, I don’t have a problem, lol).
That all being said, I don’t have any god rolls, and have hardly any legendaries. I have some good rolls, and maybe one or two great rolls, but perfect? All usable inscriptions on one item with decent amounts? None.
I don’t know how sick the BioWare devs are of getting compared to diablo, but it’s the best example I have. I put way too many hours into diablo 3. And I come back to it every season and do it all over again. And the legendaries drop and drop and drop, and getting the perfect one is rare. Even with crafting, a lot of times, you can only get one item so good, unless like you say you win the lottery. And there are a lot of slots to try for.
And again, this is coming from someone who plays video games every day for hours. I can only imagine the weekend only players, or hour a night players. It must just be inconceivable to them. There needs to be a steady flow of items coming in that have potential, and then also can be broken down for crafting for more potential.
I wish that the anthem devs would post what their true concerns are for upping the drop rates. Because getting too good of loot too quickly can’t possibly be the only reason. I’m not going to be one of those people that says I’m gonna quit till it’s fixed, I still find the game fun. But I know, based on last night (where I got tons of loot but no upgrades) it’ll be way more fun if the drops were increased.
This post ended up rambling, sorry.
Tl;dr Based on my own many hours of experience in this game and other looters, I agree that with the current inscription system, the devs should not be concerned with people getting god rolls and getting bored. Up the drop rates please. :)
8
2
u/NOLAblueCat PC Mar 10 '19
And for people like me that want to gear out all four javs....however many zeros you add to the end of the equation you can X4 it.
2
u/CastoffRogue Mar 10 '19
I've never really thought about it that way. I know with RNG it's never increased the percentage odds. Just with more drops there are more chances to get that 1 god like item with that next to nil odd. I could beat the odds and get lucky and my next drop is that god tier item I've always wanted but the more loot that drops are more chances I can beat that odd. Knowing that it'll be whatever ungodly percentage for that roll and will always be that percentage. Even if we get something else that isn't that item but an upgrade to our stuff it gives you a sense of progression. A sense of winning something. Especially if it's better than what you've got. THAT is what really keeps you going in a RNG game, that hope of winning positively or the even greater hope of winning big. Garbage even makes the good better.
So for example lets say it's .1%. You have a pool of tickets that's 500 and another that's 10000. It'll always be .1% but with more drops at least you have more chances to roll for that .1%. Statistically speaking that item should drop 1 in every 1000 Drops. That .1% will always be .1% but that 10k pool you have right now will have more chances at that .1% than the 500. The more items that drop, the more chances you have at that roll so it does matter on drop count.
If we were to take the amount of inscriptions earlier you mentioned "50625" That means that 1 exact Item you wanted would be 1 in every 50625. If you had bad luck it'd take you 50000+ drops to get that item, the luckiest the 1st , and the worst anything beyond that 50625. That's RNG in a nutshell. You're gambling, rolling that die to beat the odds. That's why a lot of people get hooked on games like these.
So in conclusion, over all, an increased drop rate means more chances. The more chances you get at that roll the better. Plus it's just even more fun getting that loot to drop and if it's garbage it's more mats for masterwork item creation.
Even with drop rates increased I don't see anyone ever being completely maxed out any time soon. Even if they have maxed out 1 build of MANY, they are constantly updating, so new stuff and new changes may happen. With these 4 Javelins and possible new ones they will have to keep balancing each of them.
2
2
u/Omega8Trigun Mar 10 '19
Anyone arguing "but you'll have everything too quickly" really doesn't know what they're talking about.
This isn't Destiny where guns have like 3 perks that roll from a pool of a handful of perks, that each have a static effect with no rng in their effectiveness.
This is basically Diablo, where you have a lot of stats that can possibly roll AND there is a rng range of effectiveness of each of those stats. That DRASTICALLY increases the variation to an insane degree, where the realistic chances of getting a perfect roll are (as you have basically shown) incredibly rare. That's why in Diablo, as you get into the endgame difficulties it starts raining high level gear. Because at some point you're not just chasing an item. You're chasing an item with a certain set of stats with hopefully a high roll of those stats. You have to have loot ramp up super high in that scenario. Anthem has the same thing, but it's trying to pace loot like games with less rng, which doesn't work.
1
2
u/AJC146 Mar 10 '19
Amen. The increased drop rate got me a MW autocannon and flamethrower. Not amazing ones, but enough to power me up to the point where I don’t feel useless in GM, and enough to keep me wanting to find better versions.
2
u/McCaffeteria XBOX Mar 10 '19
I think your assessment of increasing lottery odds is wrong (buying more ticket DOES increase your likelihood of winning, mathematically speaking) but I don’t think you needed to mention it for your point to be valid in the first place.
That being said, I think that the lower drop rates would be fine if we had a way to increase or modify the inscriptions in a similar way to the division.
Either that or we need WAY more vault space.
2
u/socalstunna Mar 10 '19
I'm with you, I love (loved) anthem... But I realized they did this loot system like this because they have nothing else. They want you to grind forever cause they have no more content to give. Please grind our game and do the same 3 stupid dungeons over and over again thanks. All we could come up with is please go here collect this over and over go here and stay on the circle over and over. No thinking outside the box. So blatantly lazy. The entire time I played this game all I thought was, DID ANYONE ACTUALLY TEST AND/OR PLAY THIS GAME BEFORE RELEASE?! HOW DID THEY NOT NOTICE THIS.... Story is shit btw lol so boring.
My last legendary was a Tarsis sniper rifle with hip fire LOL, ammo amount (it only has one bullet), and fire rate (again one bullet), what a joke especially for a LEGENDARY! The devs don't give a shit, drops are shit, and lazy. This game is dead now GG!
2
u/the-obfuscated Mar 10 '19
Don't forget that as soon as they raise the level cap everything we've earned to that date will then become hard earned garbage.
BioWare, if you're listening, please give me enough loot that I can make multiple builds for each javelin over the course of a month. Or as a casual, one min/maxed build over the same period.
2
u/Dreamforger PC - Mar 10 '19
Sometimes I wish that these glowing orange and yellow gems weren’t items...
But tokens we could use to exchange 1:1 for gear or weapons of our choice, with the rolls we wanted. Then the grind was about getting a full build, and then afterwards side-builds.
2
2
u/mikeycantoon PC - Mar 10 '19
If you get everything in one day, what's the point? The point of a game is the escape, the experience. If you're just playing for loot, and get everything superfast and get the God builds, chances are you won't really want to play anymore because it's all too easy.
When Diablo 2 came out, my friends and I played that for a long time. Exploring and all that. I finally get Diablo 3 a couple years after it comes out. It's all about power leveling, getting the newest armor set. I barely remember the levels because you run through that at Mach 10. You want instant gratification, play a mobile game, that's what they're for. Yea everybody will take a break from this game, everybody does this to every game. This is nothing new. Warframe for example. I'll go 6months to a year without playing it. Get back to it and check out all the new content for months and then take another break. There is no game that will keep your attention everyday, no matter how good the graphics, devs, design, minimal bugs, nothing.
2
u/mordind Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
It’s frustrating to put so much time into a game.. to then have to just say no more. No masterworks no legendary’s dropping running grand master one and two strongholds for 12 hours. I did pre-ordered the division two but was really enjoying and had hope for anthem. I legit Lee wanted to get hooked into this game and started to… But I can’t get over all the anger the game brings up and frustration. It just kills the fun!But it seems one patch introduces the need for 100 more and I can see where this is going. It’s tough to play a game where every time you get off it’s because the game screwed you in someway and you’re frustrated. That is not what you want your gaming community to feel like.
And a 704 storm fully loaded with shield and armor consumables... breezes through grandmaster one strongholds and then gets killed by one spider in grandmaster 2 after I unloaded my poppa pump and threw all my elemental damage… And a spider killed me! When we finally finish the stronghold after 1 million dies… I got some purples. Now that really hits my reward center LOL
2
u/Hardcore1Gamer Mar 10 '19
lol, i actually was writing the same idea yesterday but saw so many posts about loot figured someone will use Math in some comments.
Well done mate
4
u/Thick_javelin Mar 10 '19
Dude you're doing math to explain something to people defending Bioware from making a shooter loorer having no loot. I'm not sure they will get you...
3
u/Darkhatred Mar 10 '19
The people defending bad loot must really love the color purple.
→ More replies (1)5
u/everyonestolemyname PC - Mar 10 '19
I got called a "whiny bitch who wanted a legendary build handed to them" on the Anthem Discord, before I was promptly banned for 48 hours for asking why my post was deleted, and /u/Musely still hasn't fully explained why it was deleted even though I sent a message via modmail as per their instructions.
2
u/Darkhatred Mar 10 '19
Well that sucks, that sounds like a toxic discord. Hopefully your stuff doesn't get deleted again.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/SalvajeCartel Mar 10 '19
Yup I said this a couple of days ago on a post that I made, progression in anthem is mathematically against you, and I was able to make that calculation even tho i failed my final math exam in hs 9 times. Its just common sense, drop rate & terrible inscriptions are ruining this game and if things dont change players will actually stop playing this game.
1
u/Bhargo Mar 10 '19
This actually kinda reminds me of the early days of The Division, where getting high level gear meant farming boxes in the dark zone hoping they dropped division tech (very low drop rates, low spawn and dear god the griefers) until you had enough to make a gun, then crafting the gun you had to hope it rolled good perks, then even if you did roll good perks you had to hope the perk stat range and damage range of the gun rolled well too. Someone did the math for it and even assuming the impossible like every box dropping div tech and playing nonstop 24/7 it would still take thousands of years to roll enough weapons to make a perfect set of weapons.
1
u/ScribeTheMad Mar 10 '19
Yeah, one of the other math posts back before the inscription change (was eyeballing rough math not as precise as that discussed here) estimated somewhere around 24 trillion possible rolls across a full set of gear for one Javelin.
But somehow increased drops is going to give us all full prefect legendary sets in a week.
(To be fair I recognize some people will play to full set of MW and maybe a legendary and consider the Javelin "complete" and quit playing "because there's nothing left to do". My argument is those players wouldn't stick around super long either way. I won't bash them, they just play to get to certain points and don't care about min/maxing or god rolls. But building the loot structure for the entire game to try to retain that small percentage of players is shooting themselves in the foot pretty bad.)
1
u/lickbrains PC - for loots & fashion Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
Everybody wants to see Anthem succeed. That's why these issues need to be addressed or, at the very least, acknowledged. We don't want to see a potentially good game get stale as soon as players realize their time isn't valued among its other issues (ex: poor CPU optimization). These odds are worse odds than the gacha games I play and those are meant to bleed their playerbase dry.
1
u/jcore294 Mar 10 '19
This would be better with a tldr, TBH, cuz I didn't read all that
1
u/StrangerDangerBeware Mar 10 '19
TLDR: Every new variable adds another number you need to add on top of the MW/Legendary drop rate to arrive at your chance of getting a good item. So for anthem that's Types of Items * Number of Items in that Category * All Inscriptions for Ability 1 * Numbers Range for Ability 1 * All Inscriptions (-1) for Ability 2 * Numbers Range for Ability 2........
Basically, if you do the math the chance of you getting a perfect item are astronomically small. The chance of getting an item with the 4 correct inscriptions are super small, even if you ignore that high variance between the percentage rolls. You could farm for months without seeing an item that has all 4 inscriptions you want. You need to farm until the heat death of the universe to get a single perfect item.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Jeggred86 Mar 10 '19
I play Storm most of the time and I don't even have one of the skills as MW I want to have, regardless of rolls. Yesterday I played Colossus for 2 strongholds and got both the MW skills I wanted with decent rolls.
It makes a huge difference when you play GM with purples or bad rolled MWs with the right perks. For Colossus I got the "Best Defense - Hitting an enemy with a rocket restores 35% armor" and "Voltaic Dome - Enemies are frozen once hit".
Give us better drop rates so we can get GMs of every kind relatively fast and let us play the game for the god rolls.
1
u/Alimond89 XBOX - Mar 10 '19
Just my tuppence worth.
I think the only way to to keep the drop rate as it currently stands is to be able to re-roll an inscription, but lock it to only being able to re-roll one inscription per peice of gear.
Maybe use epic components for this task, give them a half decent use in this game other than consumables.
Thoughts?
1
1
Mar 10 '19
My view is somewhere in the middle. Now is too low. But 10 masterworks all with good rolls is too much
1
Mar 10 '19
Exactly, it makes you feel rewarded for you time, instead of getting punched in the dick.
Not entirely correct math wise, but the message is very much correct.
1
u/swatop PC - Mar 10 '19
You are absolutely right with your calculation.
The players which want a specific drop of a MW with specific inscriptions for sure wont stop playing the game once they got a random MW with random inscriptions.
They would continue to grind... actually even being motivated again to grind since they know these MW and Legendaries drop frequently enough to have at least a chance to get a good roll.
It is the "carrot" the players need to continue playing for a longer period of time. It is a reward for invested playtime... a motivation... the incentive to play.
1
u/Ch1swill Mar 10 '19
Increasing the loot rate at least makes me feel my time rewarded. Or you make sure I get a good quality item in this shit rare loot rate.
1
u/artifex28 Mar 10 '19
The jinxed logic that someone at Bioware / EA might bring to the table:
By not giving enough loot, we ensure that players do not burn the game out for themselves. We essentially ration the best part of the game. This way they will want to play day after day, finding out if this might be the day they get a great MW or a legendary item. That keeps our retention high and as we know, the more players spend time in the game, the more they eventually spend money. This is what our analytics clearly show us.
...which is plain wrong. Or well, I mean the analytical part is technically correct, but it’s very short sighted and harmful for the game in the long run. That might keep your 7/14/30d retention high but not the 180/360d. The LTV of the players is a LOT higher when you have constant loot stream with complex enough itemization. This is exactly what can be found in the core of eg. Path of Exile's success and why Diablo implemented the "Loot 2.0" changes.
Instead the loot stream should be constant. It’s about making the good loot so complex in terms of the values (the rolls the items can have on them) that the players WANT to keep exploring and playing for even better and cooler items.
Now having these ”mind blown”-kind of moments where you notice that there aren’t just a single build you could go for by combining items X and Y and Z, but that there are numerous builds available at your fingertips, as you choose...that is what separates a great loot hunter from a not so great one. Waves to Path of Exile
The loot drops act as a gratification for playing. They’re the loot hoarders dopamine jolts. Like...drugs, the effect is the most efficient when the saturation is there.
Here’s how I would fix the loot.
I truly think that Anthem should implement follow things to items to increase the item complexity and amount of item permutations:
MWs should have a single random ”static effect buff” or from a limited pool, but pool neverthenless.
Currently they’re completely deterministic and linked to the item as it is. Every weapon X will have the MW/Legendary ”worded” effect of Y. This is shallow.
Legendaries should have TWO. Combination of these would allow such depth to the game.
Sockets / ”a new layer” on top of the current and the above one. Item could roll 0-2 sockets. These sockets can be filled with components but once you do, it’s expensive to get them out. It’s elegant, since you already have both the components and the ”socketing” in the game as systems. No new currencies required.
Just add a tool to forge to ”forge” a component in to a socketable ”jewel” form.
These would act as sinks for the embers - both ways.
Increase drop amounts for MW/Legendary items by ...a lot.
Implement more difficulty settings
There’s a reason Diablo 3 has so many Torment levels - not to mention Greater Rift levels. Or Path of Exile having those map levels. Avoid difficulty granularity. Allow players to challenge themselves.
As there isn’t PvP in Anthem, I’m surprised they aren’t selling eg. harvesting boosts or ”premium status” for extra luck. Both would monetize well with above loot changes.
It wouldn't be absolutely hated by the players, as the feeling of getting more items constantly would be there anyways and mostly because people aren't playing against each other.
1
u/skurkip Mar 10 '19
I was thinking about what emotions I was feeling when they reverted it again and
I felt like I had a renewed energy playing the game. I have 190hours played already and been loving almost every second.
The revert felt like having the rug pulled from under you, or a heavy hit in the stomach, my motivation just plummeted (not saying what I felt was right or fair)
And last point - When playing the game and not playing the game nets me almost the same progress, something is wrong in the reward cycle. Sure playing the game is the only chance to get a good drop, but not likely even if I played another 190 hours.
Is this addiction like feelings that is displayed - most likely. But without those a looter game could never work. The good feeling of getting a better drop is what drives a game like this in the long run.
Now I'm only looking forward to Division 2, when before (a week ago or a little more) I was hesitant to even be able to not play Anthem. A feeling I had yesterday morning before the patch hit also. Atm I just feel a bit sad that I can't get what I'd like from Anthem atm. Maybe in the future when they sort the mess. Either make gearing different or increase loot or whatever they need to do. I think Anthem will be awesome closer to summer.
edit: forgot to thank you for your post, and sorry for the lengthy comment.
1
u/credicy Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
I still don't get it.I mean I do agree that the drop rates should be higher eventually, ESPECIALLY in GM2 and 3, but if they just shower you with loots right now what are you gonna do with them? Let's assume you get your godrolls and the perfect build, what are you gonna do then?
I think they're absolutely aware that the drop rates are not fine, but I do understand why they're hesitant to just increase them when there's nothing to do in the game besides the grind for loot.
Also I do think the main issue is how the inscriptions works. A masterwork item should always be an upgrade from an epic, but with these inscriptions that's not the case. Certain inscriptions or stat threshold should be only available at a certain tier
EDIT: to be clear, I'm not happy with the state of the loot right now, but I don't think just increasing it will make things better.
I have 5 legendaries and never use any of them, because they're worse than my masterwokrs, that's the main issue to me. I'me fine with them being this rare, but if that's the case they should always be better than the lower tier.
3
u/AJC146 Mar 10 '19
Because even with an increased drop rate the chances of you getting the gear/inscription combo you’re after is still astronomically high. A higher drop rate at least gives people the mindset that they have a chance of getting the loot/rolls they’re after. Take me for example:
I only usually get a couple of hours a day to play. I went from 3 days, level 30, GM1 and finding 5/6 pieces of MW loot that, aside from the 2 components being inherently better, were useless for my build, to 4 hours of the loot rain helping me find 2 pieces of gear that drastically improved my build and thus, my enjoyment of the game. They aren’t god rolls or even legendary, but they helped me get to a point in GM where I didn’t feel useless. I went from grinding until Division 2 comes out to considering just sticking with Anthem.
1
u/drgggg Mar 10 '19
Let's assume you get your godrolls and the perfect build, what are you gonna do then?
You still wont get the god rolls even if they increase the loot by a factor of 10.
With the numbers someone crunched above there are 25,600 weapon slot combinations.
At 6 MW an hour that would take over 177 days of game time to grind out the base for the weapon you want (not even accounting for the numerical rolls of the inscription) assuming everything dropped only weapons.
On top of that a basic way the devs like to extend the life of looters is to simply raise the level of items so you have to do the grind again. This would at least happen yearly and would probably happen once per update cycle.
1
u/Damatris Mar 10 '19
Totally agree.
Now, how long before there’s a petition to get to reroll inscriptions like the division?
1
u/DrakeWurrum PC - - Big Daddy Colossus Mar 10 '19
They did put out a post where they listed all the possible inscriptions you can get, so you could easily make your math more accurate if you wanted. But you still make an excellent point that doesn't need to be completely accurate.
1
u/ScribeTheMad Mar 10 '19
I think the problem there is we know the inscriptions but we don't necessarily know if there are different limitations between pools/slots (I mean I know we know Major and Minor have different caps on things like +dmg, but there could be some that only drop as Major or Minor and I don't recall seeing anything that specific)
1
u/opaPac Mar 10 '19
thank you for this great post! the white knights in the sub are out of hand at the moment but posts like this are super helpfull.
1
Mar 10 '19
Im not angry about the drop rate anywhere near as much as i am angry that now when i get a legendary, there is a 1 in 4 chance its for the javelin i am actually fucking playing.
1
u/BoomBOOMBerny Mar 10 '19
And all of this should be looked at through the lens of PvE only too. Which changes the tone of the loot conversation compared to almost any other looter shooter drastically.
1
u/Viron_22 Mar 10 '19
Can't it be noted that these aren't 'free' drops, you ostensibly have to be playing the game, and to increase the chances of a MW dropping playing on a harder difficulty. So the idea that increasing the drop rates as rewarding the undeserving is just stupid, yes some people will get things that didn't work for, that is how life works. Unless you want to push people off of the game by making it too stingy to tolerate, making you the loot God-Kings when it gets shutdown because only a handful of people who got struck by lighting are still playing.
1
u/Bosko47 Mar 10 '19
I don't think I saw many posts or comments defending Bioware right now, pretty sure the whole community is against them on this one
1
u/Trylander Mar 10 '19
Well your math isn'tfalse here but also not accurate cause not every item rolls with 4 inscriptions (components only drop with 2 if I remember correct) and i have no proof but also do think that every item has a pool of inscription to pick from and not all inscriptions at all (this turns the odds more into our favor). But thats not the point. From my observation, and this could be a false one too, it looks like that the "white Knights" are the ones not knowing realy how a looter game is operating. I see so many times, people bragging about there Item Level, or complaining about that Legendarys drop rate is good they want the chase for them.
All in all it boils down to the fact that they don't realize how builds are made out of all stats and inscriptions and not by simply just picking up an Item and say "done".
They don't see that the right combination of inscriptions and values refines a build and allows to push further than GM1. They think an arbitrary number in the upper right corner is all that matters in worse case and the more advanced white knight thinks that the Masterwork inscriptions in the right combination makes it possible alone.
They don't for what ever reason see or experience what the 2-4 affixes can do for your build and post like total garbage Legendary weapons on twitter.
Sure everyone should be happy to loot something exciting for the first time but at the same time they miss the point of realisation if this item is hot garbage or anything good, cause they only seee "LEGENDARY" and think MUST be good.
Not sure where this players come from, maybe from Destiny, maybe from Warframe or any other game that dosen't operate with an random affix pool item generation system. They see only Legendary and think they are done with that item and start complaining about duplicates.
I personally stoped reading there stuff they blow out into the internet cause they do the real harm to Anthem by not willing to understand it.
1
Mar 10 '19
Honestly the drop rates are just discouraging for how much effort it takes. I'll drop by anthem once in a while because the gameplay is great but without any incentive to gear up for any worthwhile end game content or satisfying drop rates, I'll be spending most of my time on destiny.
1
u/MrStealYoBeef Mar 10 '19
An hour or so of freeplay on GM1, traveling all over the map, I completed 7 world events, I came across one that glitched out and wouldn't finish, and three more that just disappeared before my very eyes. I was literally holding a piece of a relic and taking it to the main one when it disappeared, leaving me with the thing on my hip and nowhere to put it, fantastic work Bioware, it's truly amazing how fucking terrible that is. Between my world events, I took out every camp of enemies that I could find, making them summon more. I looted until my bag was entirely full
I found a total of two legendary enemies in all that time. I found zero masterworks and zero legendaries.
Holy fuck Bioware, I feel like I'm just wasting my time in this game, it's miserable. How the fuck can you manage to fuck up that bad? I was having some fun roaming around killing shit with a superpowered machine gun and firey explosions at first, and then little by little as I found nothing at all, my fun turned to frustration. I don't play games to frustrate myself, I play games to enjoy myself. This game isn't competing against other games that frustrate players, it's competing against other games that satisfy them and give them enjoyment in their free time. All the Iron Man simulator in the world will not bring me back if this shit isn't fixed.
"We wanted freeplay to be the endgame"
Fuck off Bioware, if you want us to roam around your giant ass map with maybe one other random person nearby because the others are fucking off on the other side of the map, give us a reason to. There's no objective, there's no goal, there's no reward, there's way too much travel time. You managed to make playing Iron Man into a frustrating experience. Wasting my god damn time. Release all the free DLC you want, you won't get money if you keep treating the players of the game with contempt and hatred.
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/king_ja Mar 10 '19
Anyone who said the drops rates are fine are people who dont play looter shooters and apparently they prob have it right. Maybe Anthem isn't a looter shooter...?
1
1
u/JASTME Mar 10 '19
So i'm not a math guy at all. Give us a hand here -
So when you mention the whole gettting 10k tickets increases your chances but it doesn't increase your chances(?) Im a little lost. Surely there would be a difference that you'd get what you want, sure it would be borderline miniscule given the scale of things but wouldn't it still be a technically higher chance? I do understand that if you roll a dice 6 billion times, the odds a 6 comes up per dice roll stay the same, but if you do it 6 billion times, the chance you'll roll at least one 6 is better no?
4
u/jorgesalvador Mar 10 '19
If you toss a coin, the odds of head or tails are always 50/50. If you toss it multiple times, you have more tries at that 50/50 chance, but the odds of each toss do not change.
2
u/piratesgoyarrrr Mar 10 '19
It's a difference in terminology. You have more chances for the odds to be in your favor, if you will. The odds of it happening always stay the same because the number of possible combinations doesn't change (unless BW adds or removes something from the loot pool). Make a bit more sense?
1
u/Ahsta44 Mar 10 '19
My biggest problem with the gear is if big if you get a good roll, your locked in to a build.
1
u/cirilink94 Mar 10 '19
actually i was fine with droprate before,but after 'that crazy one day',i just can't go back
1
u/MCBalkanPS4 Mar 10 '19
So in that calculation where does luck apply
2
Mar 10 '19
Unless the devs drop the algorithm that luck modifies we really don't know. Also with the number of things they've pissed up who knows if it works completely right anyway.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/OnePintJohnny Mar 10 '19
This post is an eye opener for sure, a well written indication of the state the game is in.
I’m only level 17 and enjoy the gameplay but I’m finding that I have no motivation to get to level 30 knowing this and come back to anthem once all this is fixed, but maybe another game will have my attention when that happens..
Which brings me to the point that this game has been in development for 6 years you’d think a looter shooter backed by EA should be more refined than the state it launched in.
This is why I think I’m losing faith, or maybe I’m being too negative I don’t know.
2
Mar 10 '19
in development for 6 years
The lead dev died at one point. Huge numbers of things look completely different from 18 months ago. Something went terribly wrong at some point and lots of stuff got scrapped. This is not a game that has 6 years of dev. For example components were added around 3 to 4 months ago, and entire skill tree was ripped out.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/boom1000 Mar 10 '19
They need to add a system of some sort to let you effect or change inscriptions to a degree. I like farming and I like random rolls but I want to reliable at some point, get the inscriptions i want for my build. It shouldn't be easy and it should take time. Game is still young so I am optimistic that Bioware will get something figured out most people will be happy with.
1
u/BattleBattalion Mar 10 '19
The kind of people defending the rates either have never played a looter game before (no surprise since there are very few of them, and fewer good ones) or lucked out with a god roll and don’t want to “cheapen” it.
1
u/I_throw_hand_soap Mar 10 '19
I don’t get it. Do we want more drops to get legendary? Or do we want more drops to get MW and can you get god rolls on MW? I thought only legendary had god rolls.
1
u/LioKlingo Mar 10 '19
I totally agree wity your statement. One of the best post on Reddit in the last months! Thank you.
1
u/Thesiso Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
In essence if we skew the math enough so that people are winning the lottery more often it will bring them enhanced happiness. Interesting theory. I do hope they skyrocket the loot though so we can move on to complaining about how there isn't enough variation, the meta gets established, and we can all start playing like this is D3 and mindless drone through with a shot of endorphins every few minutes.
All in all I wish they would just up the difficulty and then up the reward for that because as it sets a masterwork Jav is all you need for GM3. Can't wait for the perfect build so I can get super bored using a hot knife through butter. Welcome to the land of instant gratification.
1
u/Esppx Mar 10 '19
BioWare have asked us to give feedback on bugs and / or issues with the game on the EA-forum as well as on Reddit. I have made a post on the drop rate of legendaries is here: https://answers.ea.com/t5/Bug-Reports/Way-to-low-droprate-for-yellows/m-p/7658062#M15240
For all of us, please hit «me too» on this post, and if you want – feel free to give your though on this issue. I think we’re a lot of people that think this is one of the biggeste issue with the game at the moment.
1
u/ghawkguy PC - Mar 10 '19
Loot is bad but what is worse for me is the lack of content. I even feel like vanilla Destiny had more content and that’s saying something. At least I could run a raid or even pvp when I got bored, but here there just isn’t much to do beyond the same stuff over and over.
1
u/i_win_u_know Mar 10 '19
I'm just glad there are literally only nerds here that have reached end game.
I've been playing nearly every day since launch and haven't reached end game.
Let these nerds sort it out so it works when I get there, you know, like at a normal pace that normal people with lives can realistically achieve.
1
u/TITANIUMS0LDIER Mar 10 '19
🎶 Do not play the loteryyy... It's not good for you it's not good for meeee🎶
1
u/mrcleanup14 PC - Mar 10 '19
Personally an ideal situation for loot drop would be similar to the rate of diablo with the optimization and rerolls capability of the division system. This would be an ideal world for Anthem I would believe!
1
Mar 10 '19
With respect, I ain't seeing a bunch of people SPECIFICALLY defending the droprates. In fact, not a single one personally. I'm sure they exist, but are they really in such quantities that it deserved a rebuttal of sorts?
I mean sure, I've seen a BUNCH of "They're doing their best!" and "Give Bioware a chance!" and whatnot. But "Calm down folks, the loot droprates are fine!!"?? Not so much...
1
u/dangerdan44 Mar 10 '19
Add in the percentage of said inscriptions and you’ll basically never get a decent item. What’s funny is MW isn’t even end game. True endgame build would be god roll legendary not god rolled MW. It’d really be a bummer to finally get a decent rolled MW just to replace it with a legendary. The loot in this game is miserable. I played for 8 hours yesterday. Nothing. I got 4 MW items, just 4, all junk.
1
u/Llorenne I'm a Jumpy Boi Mar 10 '19
I'd prefer getting normal drop rates BUT MEANINGFUL drop rates over unlimited drops any day.
People just like to end an expedition with 15 MW items. And honestly, I'm bored breaking them down one by one... (JUST ADD A DAMN MULTIPLE SELECTION OPTION).
But let's be honest. When those "bugs" or "mistakes" happen and people get a glimpse of happiness that they finally see items, even if they are trash.. they see items and not just some trash epics. MW and Leggos. They are happy. And then for a 2nd time BW takes the happiness away.. for whatever reason.
This is a thing that should be addressed asap. I'm not sure how hard it is to do it, maybe it's just 2-3 edits on the code.. maybe it's more complicated than that (hell I should know.. they said increasing the storage capacity from 250 to a bigger number is "more complicated" than we thought).
I just don't know man. This is chaos! All we needed is a damn normal game to have fun. Most of us complaining if not all.. are having fun with the game, as in gameplay. But we play for no reason.. like srsly.. we do over and over the same thing without progression.
1
1
u/Bayn12345678 Mar 10 '19
I'm just going to point out here, that this calculation is for an exact roll of the exact item and the exact inscriptions that you would like to basically choose, without rolling the % or whatever. This isn't anywhere near calculating the odds of a great or even good roll....
Sure there are problems with the loot system, like items that you can't even use as builds and other dumb shit. Imo there shouldn't be items that aren't either primers or detonators but that's a different topic.
Of your calculated exact roll, how much more does that reward you then lets say a good roll not exact roll you want but one with high percentages for its attributes (+%dmg or etc.) Then really how much better do you expect.
The law of diminishing returns applies here, everytime you get better item it is more difficult to get an even better one. You may roll 100000 times more for a better roll, but if it is only 2% better then you already got your great roll... you are just wasting your time. Perhaps there is a better way to get that improvement.
1
1
u/dreamz2realities Mar 10 '19
That only based on MW not Legendary? This is worse then the "Battlefront 2's 400h grind". They cmpletely ignored the importance of loot, getting tons of 1-20% along with ammo or sniper stats on a Rifle (max is 250 for some wich is a ridiculous difference based on RNG alone). Total waste of my time. 2 weeks in and already "burned-out". I am happy that some new single player games are coming out, I'm done with these multiplayer games with "bad game flow", waste of time and money.
I understand that the glitches have priority, but "it's a Lootershooter, loot should be the least of OUR worries" if we put the time in. People can overlook a lot if they get something in return, as is, I am just going to the next best the 15th. I'm not wasting more time for the hopes of loot that always has bad roles and no stability in combat either.
Plus: Exp should also act as an build up to legendary after 30 (reward for × amount of time played), but not even this has been thought of... 6years and didn't learn from other games that had this same issue and solved it way before this game came out.
1
u/dmsn7d The grabbits must be protected - PS4 - Mar 10 '19
This is true. But if they increased the MW/legendary drop rates, many people would continue to play to get the inscriptions that they want, but a lot of people would keep getting the same dozen or so items and then get bored because they keep getting the same items. They need to increase the drop rates, but they also need to create new items to add to the pool.
1
u/Malacarr PC - Mar 10 '19
I disagree with your assumption that people will be happy as long as they think they have a good chance of getting an upgrade for each playsession. After reading a lot of these "gief loot" posts and analyzing my own subjective experiences, I believe that it works like this: as long as the player gets an upgrade after every one or two games, they are happy. When they run 3 or more games in a row without getting useful loot and it starts happening more and more often, they go to Reddit and make "gief loot" posts.
So the problem is, no matter how generous the game is with the loot, each player will reach a point where they are very unlikely to find an upgrade in each given playsession. If BW greatly buffs MW and Legendary drop rates now, players who are now saturated with loot will start getting frequent upgrades again, and will keep getting them for a certain amount of hours (but this will last days or weeks, not months). Then they will become loot saturated again. If you don't believe me, look at what happened when Bioware buffed the loot for the first time by removing useless affixes. Loot saturated players started getting lots of upgrades again, the Reddit was happy, and it lasted less than 3 weeks.
So now we're back where we started. Only, the players are more powerful than they were, and the upgrades they can look forward to are marginal. And this makes a great difference. Like, right now I can potentially find upgrades that will greatly increase my power, for example a legendary weapon with +250% damage and +125% damage rolls. Now, lets say that in our hypothetical scenario I'm loot saturated and I already have a weapon with +225% and +100% damage. Would I be motivated by a possibility of finding such a small upgrade?
1
1
u/SecretBiscuits PC - Mar 10 '19
This is the constructive criticism that we need. And honestly I had to scroll through so many awful posts before I got to a gem like this who isn’t just complaining because that’s the popular thing to do. You’ve done the math, at least speculatively, you’ve put in time and you voice your opinion constructively. More posts like this need like and you should be much higher up on the thread.
Strong alone, Stronger together
1
Mar 10 '19
At this point I’m 477 gear lvl... I don’t care about god rolls. I want an increased drop rate so I can get a gun that I can use the best e.g. Truth of Tarsis... right now the MW guns I have received suck... my gear choices are limited as I have only gotten like 2 strike and 2 assault. The strike and assault I want to use have yet to be found. I WANT AN INCREASED DROP RATE SO I CAN ACTUALLY DO GM2+ my gear does not do too much for me at this moment in time plus I have the wrong guns for the playstyle I want... so your post is accurate about god rolls yes, but WE STILL WANT MORE DROPS
1
Mar 10 '19
If your math is right then the conclusion is obvious: it is much more likely to get a legendary drop than a masterwork with a good roll. Assuming legendaries have decent rolls by default and masterworks having pure random rolls, we can discount masterworks as a temporary means of getting by before the real deal.
1
u/Wellhellob PC - Mar 10 '19
Real problem is i feel like i'm wasting my time. Biggest problem of this game. I'm wasting a lot of time and effort and the drops are laughing at me. This game doesnt feel rewarding even if you able to find god roll. Every event chest(freeplay and stronghold) should give me at least 1 masterwork.
Legendaries can be rare i'm ok with that but we need masterworks for creating meaningful builds. Legendary is not necessary it's luxury but masterworks are necessary!
It's so pathetic putting 1 guaranteed drop to stronghold boss and hardcoding other drops to purples. You don't even have a chance to get 2 masterwork from boss.
They still didn't fixed the gm2 and gm3. Bioware disrespectful imo. This is my feelings when i play the game. I feel disrespect
1
Mar 10 '19
this is incorrect as the Z component would actually be a combination replacement where order does not matter but replacements are allowed, which is roughly 3060 combinations. which is .00069, still insane but much better than stated
1
Mar 11 '19
youre also taking away from the fact that the god roll of each item, that .00069*47 means i actually have a 3% chance of getting a combination of rolls i want out of the 47 items, where every item i get lowers my chance of getting a new item god rolled from 3% by .069% per item. where only the more god rolled items i have the less chance i have of getting a new god rolled item beneficial to my build. I have suggested a crafting method here that helps with this sense of stagnation. and only limits RNG to God rolled combinations and not the numbers attached to them.https://www.reddit.com/r/AnthemTheGame/comments/azlrtg/how_to_solve_the_lootdwindling_player_base/
if and only if im searching for one item does that make it .069% chance
1
1
u/BattleBattalion Mar 11 '19
There are ~84 inscriptions (I may have miscounted by one or two).
Taking into account that there won’t be useless inscriptions on an item. Without going back through and giving a proper guess, I’m assuming there would be 50ish different inscriptions possible on an item.
So that 0.00004% goes to a 0.00000034% assuming my 50 is around the available inscription number. And that’s not taking into account that it would be good inscription rolls.
1
Mar 11 '19
You're missing some parts of the system. A guy made a post about the previous droprates. He said he finished a stronghold with 10MW. He felt like that should be normal.
It only takes 1 150% Damage roll on a gun to trivialize GM1. I know this because I have several of them and they shared enemies effortlessly.
Now let's ignore that. Let's get into 10MW per Stronghold or Contract. We're looking at what roughly 10MW embers from trash rolls. If you're like me and you trash everything that fordnt have certain inscriptions you are guaranteed 10MW Ember everytime you go out, not counting any that you get by chance from a chest.
With that laid out, let's not forget we can craft Masterwork Gear & Guns. There's nothing stopping people from pushing to max in a week when there's so many ways to get Masterworks. Legendaries are an slight bump up. A 225% damage roll is cool, but if you end up with 2x 175% inscriptions on a gun it's just as good if not better.
I'm not sure if I'm the most lucky person in the world but I pretty much always get at least 1 Masterwork every time I go into free play GM1. Sometimes I get one within 10 minutes of starting the session. I just got my first Legendary last night. Most of the Masterworks I've gotten have had some pretty good inscriptions on them.
I honestly think people are grinding the wrong content. People who focus on strongholds & L contracts seem to have an overall worse time than people that literally just play the game. It's odd to me because they obviously don't find the loop they are choosing fun. But it's even more odd they find the base game itself unfunny unless they get the loot they want.
No matter what changes are made to this game. The people that want to walk away because the drop rates are to low clearly dont like the core gameplay. No amount of amazing loot is going to make them suddenly enjoy the gameplay more. A Yellow drop over a purple is not different gameplay. It's different gratification because it's the same gameplay.
1
u/DonkerSkadu Mar 11 '19
Wondering how many people remembers the fact that, except for components, you can craft every masterwork item....
And then you take in the fact that Strongholds and Legendary Contacts guarantees a MW drop and you can fa them for components and can therefore CRAFT your needed roll....
I do not see why people are complaining about the drop rate then....
Yes it is hard to get a legendary drop, but I believe that is how it should be. To make a comparison to something like Destiny 2, how often does one get an Exotic drop in game that you did not buy from Xur?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/YasookMadeek Mar 11 '19
Yeah but increased drop rate does allow me to get a weapon I don't have allowing me to 1. Enjoy the weapon (autocannon) and 2. Get the blueprints to craft it for inscriptions I want. I can't craft a weapon I don't have.
1
1
u/trashyratchet Mar 12 '19
That was a great post. Let me offer constructive criticism, please. When making and educated, scientific post, make sure that you don't mix up the word "than" with "then". As soon as you do it, somewhat educated folks will key in on it and deem you not credible. I will quote the section as follows, "...it's more complex then that and it all boils...". Mark me as a nitpick, that's ok. I foul up all of the time. But let's be frank. I noticed it. That means others noticed it. And here I am, taking the time to point it out. My internal skeptic turns on and I now question every single thing that you reported.
You obviously took a bit of time compiling this post. Kudos to you. Just wanted to point to a glaring weak point in your argument.
Cheers.
Edit: BTW. I absolutely upvoted. It's a great post.
1
Mar 09 '19
Yep, his math looks right to me. With that said I think it’s to late for anthem...
→ More replies (1)
1
u/az-anime-fan Mar 10 '19
The people defending low loot are the people who purples up with perfect inscriptions last time bioware was allowing loot to actually drop. Now they have there's they don't want you to have yours. You see this phenomenon in a LOT of other games (Elite Dangerous comes to mind).
1
u/Smokedcheeses Mar 10 '19
I cannot click upvote hard enough. More people, especially those at Bioware need to see this. Maybe if they see the impossible odds they will have a bit of sympathy on us players.
1
u/RangerDanger4tw Mar 10 '19
This is easily the best post on why loot drop rates need to change, the inscription system needs to be more refined, or some combination of the two. Thank you for stating your position with reason and without name calling and such. I wish that this was the top post with 6k upvotes instead of all the other angry loot posts (to be clear I am not saying this is an angry loot post, just that I wish posts like these would rise to the front page instead of what's currently on the front page).
I think that the people who are fine with the way things are just don't care about inscriptions that much. For them, the game will be essentially over once they get the set of legendaries they want and can beat grandmaster 3 strongholds. The inscriptions matter a lot if you want to perform at the absolute highest level, but how high do you need to stack inscriptions that you want for your build in order to beat grandmaster 3? If you don't need a perfect set like you have described but just a combination of few masterworks, many legendaries, good team work, and some "not terrible" (poorly defined, I know) inscriptions, then all of the sudden your odds of getting the gear you want become a lot higher. How you define the endgame (which is different for different kinds of players) really matters when discussing the current loot system and if it's good or not.
I think about a player like my dad. He only plays video games when my brother and I play with him. He doesn't want to look at inscriptions, he just wants to see his guy going from blue to purple to orange to yellow, and ultimately beat difficult content. On the other hand, I want to develop cool powerful builds based around certain perks, damage types, combat styles, etc. I care A LOT about inscriptions and will keep a well rolled epic or masterwork over a poorly rolled legendary if it works towards my current build idea. For me to reach a great build, I need more masterworks and legendaries to drop. But in that world my dad gets bored with the game really quickly since his number gets about as high as it can get pretty quickly. This is especially true since there is no stats page to easily make comparisons between new and old loot and how it affects your total damage, health, etc. On the other hand, the current world makes sense for players like my dad, but for a player like me... like you said, the odds are low I will ever get the perfect build that I want to get.
How does Bioware balance the loot fantasy for the spectrum between (and inclusive of) these two types of players? I believe it's possible, but I'm not confident that Bioware has an answer for this yet. What should the expected value of drops required for a perfect build be? How many strongholds/contracts/hours in freeplay on average should a player be expected to complete to get a perfect build? How often should a player experience a power spike in order to feel engaged? These are all really hard, subjective questions to answer. It's obvious that Bioware has not yet found answers to these questions, and that's ultimately the takeaway from the current state of the sub IMO.
Long comment, thanks for reading if you got this far, lol.
1
u/kgold0 Mar 10 '19
It's even worse than you say because it can roll a 1 or a 250 or anywhere in between. You could have god inscriptions but if they're 1% each it doesn't help.
1
1
u/jroc25 Mar 10 '19
On top of a loot increase:
We need some sort of mechanism to reroll/upgrade stats. Make those shaper relics actually do something cool and put 1 in Tarsis. Improve or reroll atleast 1 minor stat and 1 major stat slot using crafting embers. Once you reroll a slot, you can continue to reroll it but not the other major/minor slots. Epic embers for minor stats, MW ebers for major stats.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Santiagodraco Mar 10 '19
Who knows what their logic is other than it's so wildly flawed that it's either complete incompetence or willful....on someones part.
Not only are the drop rates incredibly low and the chance of finding upgrade pieces astronomical.... they also essentially shut off MW ember drops from harvest nodes. I harvested about 40 nodes today in GM2 and received ZERO MW Embers. That's not "just bad RNG" that's intentional nerfing.
WTF are they thinking?
I've been calling this shit out for a week now and called out the posts by BI for what they are... spin doctoring... and received my expected downvotes because of it. Koolaid.
I simply cannot comprehend the mindset over there right now.
I have to believe that complete incompetence is the reason, at the top. Given what we know about the past 6 years of development and what we received as a product... once can look at various aspects of the product and see where things must have gone drastically wrong....consistently.
Graphics and audio assets, fantastic. Story, not too bad. Voice overs, great.
Coding and design...pretty horrendous. Combat is a blast... so I have to assume good leadership there. The rest... just boggles the mind.
If you take a look at the size of the map and the depth (really a lack thereof) of content... then look at a game like the Division and D2... and what I am sure will prove to be a significantly greater depth of content in almost every regard (but different gameplay to be sure) you can see the vast difference in competency and execution. Granted D2 has yet to launch so time will tell... and it has it's issues (UI team you hear me?) but the size of the map, the design of the world, combat (at least in beta).... just makes me wonder what's going on over at Bioware right now.
To not comprehend how the RNG system and the severely nerfed drop rates is absolutely KILLING this game and it's about to become a wasteland.... and to not do something about it. Bioware, what are you thinking? Seriously now.
You're killing me smalls!!
1
u/DexRCinHD Mar 10 '19
Holy shit what a lesson in maths. Very well done, I dare anyone to argue with this. Goes to show you can never argue with numbers !!
→ More replies (2)
1
u/umopUpside Mar 10 '19
I think the best thing Bioware could do is increase the roll chances for legendaries.
I’m fine with legendaries being stupid rare, it feels awesome when you find one, but make them have good rolls way more often. I don’t think they should increase drop rate though. Account for that with inscriptions and such.
1
u/celticsfan34 Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19
Now assume you are buying 10,000 tickets... does it increase your odds of winning the lottery? No it doesn’t.
Uh, yes it does. The odds per ticket are obviously the same as you say, but in the lottery example you are 10,000 times more likely to win if those 10,000 tickets could be guaranteed to be unique. It is absolutely cumulative. In the event duplicates can happen, you would end up with slightly lower odds than that but still improved, maybe 9,990x as likely.
I see where you’re coming from on your post, but that whole paragraph made no sense. Imagine there are 1 million possible lottery numbers, and you bought 1 million unique tickets. Your probability of winning is 100%. With 500,000 unique tickets your probability of winning is 50%. With 10,000 tickets it’s 1% and with 1 ticket it’s .0001%.
Edit: I realize after posting this you were probably referring to buying lottery tickets on different days, rather than 10,000 tickets on the same day. I feel like that’s a disingenuous way of looking at it, because it ignores the time factor. Your probability of getting a winning ticket is significantly higher with 10,000 chances than with 1, which is the important stat. The odds are irrelevant to what we’re talking about. If BioWare dropped 1 million items per stronghold, everyone would get an amazing item right away. That’s why I think the probability is a much more important stat than the odds.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Kortellus PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19
Amazing write up sir. If only there were more analytical and logical people out there
1
u/billy_merc_au Mar 10 '19
Your math is missing values for time and effort.
Factor these in and it really shines a light on how poorly this game was designed.
Great post though.
1
u/davemanhore Mar 10 '19
Not defending the loot. Its shit. However, once you have the blueprint unlocked you can take the weapon type out of the equation. Still f all chance of a good roll without being able to reroll one stat. Just need to break down 15 MW or harvest the stealth nerfed ember! When this game came out I thought I'd be delaying D2 purchase. Then I saw how shafted the end game was. D2 now has the hopes of a lot of miffed loot chasers firmly on its shoulders.
1
u/the_german7 PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19
Honestly this is what my buddies and I have been saying since launch. You need the higher drop rates to weed through the trash. I'd like to see people walking out with upwards of 10 MW and 3 or 4 legos after each expedition just because the odds are that only 2 or 3 of those will even be usable. I too love the gameplay but I haven't progressed in over a week now and that doesn't encourage me to keep playing.
Plus why are people defending the low drop rates anyways? Even if you got lucky and have all legos in every slot don't you want to go into your expedition with randoms who are just as geared as you? There's no PvP in this game so trying to keep other people from getting gear does nothing but hurt you.
Anyways, hears hoping we get a more permanent golden loot period. Otherwise, I don't see how they can keep a lot of the population.
1
u/BlaquKnite PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19
I understand your reasoning, the math checks out. But the logic doesn't.
First, I want to comment on your choice of words at the end ”our demands" how self entitled... Demands, really? A suggestion that you think would improve the game sure.
Actual comment, your entire wall of text is based on the assumption that everyone (or at least enough to sustain the game) want and will continue to play the game in the persuit of a perfect roll in every slot. Your math shows that won't happen so people will happily play forever... But in reality, the majority of people play to get gear just good enough to do the next challenge and once people are geared enough to just walk through GM3 they will get bored of walking through content that has gotten easy looking for something they won't ever find.
My opinion is Bioware made a huge mistake in making MW gear too easy to get and allowing all gear have a completely random roll.
I think they should have stuck us in epics longer. Hard has a very low chance of MW and if you do get one the inscription % chance is limited to like 5-15. Enough to get you started into GM1. Then GM1 should have MW be more common but have the % limits be something like 10-50. Enough so when you get decent rolls you can move to GM2 in in which would be almost entirely MW drops with % limits from 50-150 and a small chance of legendary drops, like very small (all legendary gear % increases are 100-max (300?)). Then GM3 would be all MW with %s in the 125-max range with a slightly higher chance of legendary but still small enough to make people freak out at getting one, not expect it.
That is MY ideal loot system to give a carrot on a stick and progression. But they can't do that system now, the cat is out of the bag. There are people running around with MW with +100% damage they found in hard... So yeah...
263
u/bearLover23 Mar 09 '19 edited Mar 09 '19
Well earned gold.
This is the more mathematical version of the loot drop cycle I was talking about in my massive post.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AnthemTheGame/comments/aytu0z/constructive_feedback_with_chartsgraphs/
It's simply unreasonable to have drop rates this low ontop of all of the rest. Upping drop rates alone won't be enough, it flat out won't be.
The RNG is stacked up so high. There is no way the VAST majority (like 98%) of players will ever get a single perfect build... in a game where build diversity and min-maxing is fundamental. Like... this is horrific.
Even if you DID get the inscriptions you want. There is no guarantee that they aren't just +3% damage or other similarily ridiculously low numbers
The RNG is stacked so freaking high.
I want to know who the heck can look at this calculation below and say this is fine, in a game with MULTIPLE javelins each having a huge diverse set of builds? Who?!
People will most likely quit well before they ever approach even a single optimal build. Because it's the calculated number in the opening post multiplied by 3 abilities, 6 components and 2 weapons.
That. Won't. Be. Happening. Anytime. Soon.