r/AnthemTheGame • • Mar 09 '19

BioWare Pls Bioware, can you please meet us in the middle with the loot?

I'm going to start this off with a thank you, I have had so much fun playing this game. I am over 140 hours already and I just can't get enough of the gameplay. You all have done an amazing job in that regard, the combat is very satisfying.

However, the loot is really starting to wear me down. I main interceptor, and from hour 80 to hour 140 I didn't receive a single upgrade on it. I have crafted over 200 MW items (No, this is not an exaggeration) and out of all of them, I received 1 singular upgrade to my Wyvern Blitz. None of my strike systems, assault systems, or other weapons were upgraded. In order to upgrade my components, I crafted about 500 epic universal components to get 140% armor. Now I don't mind crafting, I don't mind the grind, but in this paragraph I didn't even mention the loot I picked up. This is because not only is it scarce, I still never received any upgrades. I know, RNG can be absolutely brutal and I completely understand that. I have always just had poor luck when it's come to looter shooters, mmorpgs, etc. I have accepted this.

That being said, last night with the increased drop rates I felt for the first time in my gaming life that my luck finally turned around. I was beyond ecstatic. I actually got 2 legendary drops and one was finally better than my masterwork. It wasn't a god roll, but it was better than what I was using! After 60 hours I felt progression and I was loving it! Then I got a few dozen masterwork drops, and guess what? Another small upgrade to what I had! It wasn't a huge upgrade, but my lord I finally felt progression again and I was to the moon. I actually lost track of time and played until 4:00 AM because I was having so much fun. I wasn't going through the typical "Oh finally, a MW. I hope I don't have to salvage this again' but instead it was "Time to sift through this AWESOME ocean of drops and pray I have an upgrade!" and for the first time in 60 hours it felt like a 10/10 game again. I was having a blast and I was getting super excited to do events, strongholds, and not go harvest farm. The sense of actual progression had me hooked until 4:00 AM (while I was actually sick, but powered through it because I was having so much fun on the game) and I didn't want to stop.

Now to end the post. I completely understand you want to retain your playerbase. You all have so many plans for the future of the game and want to keep us for years. We want that too! We love this game and play through the bugs because you guys built something truly amazing. I haven't been this excited to play a game in several years, my girlfriend of 7 years can't even remember the last time I was this excited about a game. I know you all have been thinking about the loot situation, and you're probably worried that letting loot be like it was during the bugged period will let everyone get their builds maxed out and just move on, and you know what you're probably right. Which is why I suggest meeting us in the middle, or at least close to it. If you could give us even 25-50% of what we saw last night you would have several dozen less posts complaining about loot, and several dozen more posts about people being happy they got item X/Y/Z. We would have that sense of progression again, that awesome feeling seeing a MW drop just from random enemies. It's an awesome feeling seeing loot other than the guaranteed drops. We just need you to try and meet us in the middle here.

TL;DR Please meet us in the middle (or close to it) with loot. We all had a blast during the bugged loot (not knowing it was bugged) but I understand you want to retain your players for years. If you could give us 25-50% of the drop rates we had during the bug everyone as a whole would enjoy your game even more and have an actual sense of progression.

Thank you.

1.1k Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

96

u/gopuri Mar 09 '19

"Time to sift through this AWESOME ocean of drops and pray I have an upgrade!"

This is the embodiment of what the community wants loot to be like in this game.
i want to take time during my end of game salvage to look through my loot and determine if its good or not, rather than hold f for 20 minutess while i drink a cup of coffee and watch youtube...

9

u/Cyanide0k Mar 09 '19

Your comment is all too real. I will literally check my work email on my phone or reply to messages/check news while just pressing F over and over again.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Hell it doesn't even have to be an ocean. Even a river or lake of loot would be nice.

Right now we don't even get a puddle. We get a single raindrop that ends up being complete shit.

10

u/hidden-in-plainsight PC - Mar 10 '19

You get a single hard coded raindrop. No variance.

See how much worse that is? Drop rates don't count for a fucking hard coded drop.

3

u/Mesadeath Mar 10 '19

A fucking pond would be nice.

5

u/Xbob42 Mar 10 '19

This just made me think of Bioware as a kid with a new pet goldfish. He doesn't want the goldfish to have too much water. Obviously you can't fill the entire house with water, that'd be silly.

So he's starting out with a damp napkin to house his new buddy, and over the coming months he'll see where it goes from there.

2

u/Hallowed_Trousers Mar 10 '19

Lol this is pretty funny and accurate. Surely the parents would advise them it's ok to start with at least a bowl or tank (if they are generous enough)!

1

u/Mesadeath Mar 10 '19

Shit, we don't even have the fucking bowl :(

1

u/Xbob42 Mar 11 '19

Hey, they've got the bowl on their Amazon Wishlist. That's a good sign! A solid "we'll see."

3

u/Huggdoor Mar 09 '19

I had this exact thought after farming dungeons for an hour and a half on free play. End mission loot screen looked like barney the purple dinosuar.

-1

u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19

Except that if you just blindly increase the drop rates you would make the leveling experience way too fast. Bioware needs time to make a better way to make endgame loot more rewarding.

1

u/gopuri Mar 10 '19

increasing drop rates would not make leveling any quicker, your experience is gained from the badges and overall objectives you complete. More loot really isnt gonna help you do that any faster. And more masterwork/legendary drops arent going to effect anyone leveling since you dont even start dropping them until lvl 25, which is generally near the end, if not after you finish the main story.

3

u/RafTen86 Mar 09 '19

60 hours of playtime without any upgrades? Man, that’s brutal. I’m at hour 16 right now and I hope they will fix the loot problem by the time I reach endgame or the only legendaries I will have will be probably the ones I received from preordering the Legion of Dawn edition

6

u/Cyanide0k Mar 09 '19

I sincerely hope you experience the opposite of me. I wouldn't wish my bad luck on anyone. May your drops be bountiful and legendary.

33

u/wamblytomato Mar 09 '19

I can't believe how everyone is ready and willing to answer to this community's questions AS LONG AS they're not about loot. Like, they literally drop off the face of the Earth. There have been countless threads like this going to front page in the last few hours and there's still not a shadow of a response.

It makes me mad and disappointed that they have proved to be attentive to community criticism and suggestions AND YET have not expressed an opinion on this fundamental matter.

Being acknowledged would be nice. Not the solution, of course, but a start at least.

-6

u/PM_ME_YER_DOOKY_HOLE Mar 10 '19 edited Mar 10 '19

It's because loot is their content. If they start giving that away more easily, people will get the gear they want and realize there is actually no content worth using it on.

This is just a really pretty slot machine with a bad payout ratio.

6

u/merkwerk Mar 10 '19

Yeah no, everyone knows what there is to do in the game you're not some super intelligent being that's seeing things that we don't. We want more loot so we can make cool/interesting builds to keep doing the content we're currently doing, because believe it or not some of us just enjoy the gameplay. But being able to have fun/unique builds is part of that, and the current loot drop rate on top of the possible combinations of rolls you can get makes that difficult.

For me being able to gear up all 4 Javelins at a reasonable pace and experiment with cool builds for each would be plenty to do.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

[deleted]

6

u/wamblytomato Mar 09 '19

That's exactly what I meant. Do they agree it's an issue? Are they alright with keeping it as it is? Just make your intentions known, people!

And BW doesn't need knights to protect them from me. I love them to death. I bought the game and do not regret it one bit. I am literally wearing an N7 t-shirt right now. Leliana is my phone background.

But that's the exact reason why I am frustrated with this situation. I love them and feel unheard. I wish they would just talk to us.

2

u/Astuur Mar 10 '19

I'm pretty sure they came out and said they were ok with current loot drops and wanted to wait and see how taking greens and white out of level 30 loot tables would affect that and revisit loot drops at a later date.

Of course that may be too late by then.

1

u/usagizero Mar 09 '19

white nights

Can we fucking quit it with this shit? Calling people white knights/trolls if we have a different opinion?

5

u/CptC4ncer PC - Mar 09 '19

This is the most reasonable post I think, especially with that guy saying he got 49 masterworks in 50 hours and thought that was fair.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

We should NOT meet them in the middle. No compromises on this subject. We don't need to prove anything or use math or magic to prove them we're right, there's enough actual historical evidence to prove that. If they don't learn from the past decade of looters, they're gonna fall, period.

5

u/fubarbox Mar 09 '19

High chance of bad stat rolls and low loot rates does not work. Keep the high chance of bad rolls, but increase the loot OR keep the bad drop rates and make stat rolls much more likely to be better. The longer this continues the more people you push away that want to have a good time with what you created. I am just one casual player, but I am already moving on because of this. I hope things change in the future so I can come back.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

No bargaining

8

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Agreed, we don't negotiate with terrorists

4

u/Oeconomia Gimme The Loot Mar 09 '19

༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ

1

u/RayearthIX PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

Okay... I see this all the time on the Anthem boards... who/what is that supposed to be?

5

u/slice29 Mar 09 '19

As a lurker in this sub reading through all the hate posts this game gets, I just wanted to commend you on such a well thought and constructive post. I couldn’t agree more with what you had said. I, too, am thoroughly enjoying this game, bugs aside. It’s refreshing to see a down to earth post and not some hormone raging teenager screaming “GIVE ME WHAT I WANT NOW OR I’LL SHIT ALL OVER YOUR GAME.”

Best of luck out there Freelancer!

2

u/Wall2200 Mar 10 '19

A very well thought out post. I had a lot of fun last night during the 'bug' even if I only got one or two years. Would like to see more MW on GM2.

2

u/ItsYaBoiBones56 Mar 10 '19

BioWare needs to read this. I don't care if they don't make the loot drops ridiculous but meeting in the middle I actually never thought of that, it'd make the game so so much more enjoyable.

2

u/Easay9 PC - Mar 10 '19

NO NOT IN the middel the 11 hour bugs is how loot should feel its not overly dropped at all 2hours in free play for 10 masterworks and 1 legendary feels fair half of that even would feel like garbage compared to other looters

2

u/mmmikhailov Mar 10 '19

Blackout time people! Stop playing at least for 24 hours until the loot is back and BW confirms that officially!

1

u/bp3xlfit21 Mar 10 '19

Division 2 time people

5

u/vgskid PLAYSTATION - Mar 09 '19

Not the middle. Put it back to where it was last night.

2

u/KD_From_Downtown Mar 09 '19

We are also getting MW and Leg drops for javelins not in use. This makes the lack of drops even worse. Now if something good drops it might not even be for the Jav I'm trying to upgrade.

2

u/Shhmokee Mar 10 '19

This is the ONLY POST ABOUT LOOT I CAN AGREE ON.

I can get with “meet us in the middle”

Not “shower us with MW and legendaries with god rolls in abundance and I better not see one purple green or blue item.”

I think there could be a slight increase in higher tier loot but most importantly it’s the states that need help. Stat ranges and something like a change one inscription on an item for a random roll. Costing the rarity of the weapon, but THAT part has to be a grind. Meaning getting terrible MW means we can use those salvage materials for a stat reroll.

4

u/TPx01 Mar 10 '19

We aren't asking for god rolls.

In the current system we have rng (is it a mw+?) on top of (is it an mw that I need/use/want?) on top of a X4 (is that inscription good?)

Even at the bug rate, I got 2 MINOR upgrades to One Build, over a 4ish hour period.

I'm not asking for god rolls. I'm asking for progression. I'm asking for our time to be considered. I'm asking for loot 2.0. The best thing that ever happened to Diablo 3

1

u/Shhmokee Mar 10 '19

You aren’t. You’re the first person with an opposing opinion mine that’s actually sounds reasonable.

A lot of people are asking for handouts. I’m totally on board with progression. Although I am progressing now , I can totally understand what you mean. Yes diablo now is SOO much fun but before all that it was a grind like anthem is now. I really hope all this negativity and shit surrounding this game doesn’t burry it in the end because I’m willing to see this journey through.

1

u/kr0tchr0t XBOX - Mar 10 '19

Got masterworks coming out my ass.

1

u/Aztro4 Mar 10 '19

I definitely won’t be around if they keep it as is. Both my friends already quit on me but Ea/BW doesn’t care? They got their money. I do my legendaries then get off, that’s all I can stand to do with how bad the loot is. I got online last night and I randomly did a stronghold, I got 5 master works and sent pictures to my friends! We were all excited to keep playing and then I come onto reddit the next day. Lol something needs to happen and fast. Division 2 is coming and even though I won’t be able to fly and use abilities like in Anthem, at least there will be loot and things to do. Please fix! Thanks :-)

1

u/FaceWithAName Mar 10 '19

This is what they want from what I can gather. Low ball the fuck out of people, show them the heavens, and then wait until “just give us a little” right where they wanted us the whole time. Sounds like plenty of people are all saying the same thing, games fun but loot! Well, we stop playing. You want a quick fix that’s it. Big enough numbers stop the game either dies it’s miserable self inflicted death or we get what we want.

1

u/Easay9 PC - Mar 10 '19

༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽

༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽

༼ つ ◕_ ◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ⊂༼ ◕_◕ ⊂ ༽

1

u/Dwilliams1177 Mar 10 '19

For real something needs to be done. They say if you play as a certain javlin the loot drop should be for that javlin or universal. So why the only legendary drop for a component comes out for a Colossus. I'm so mad 1 1/2 hours of free play for that mess.

1

u/mrcleanup14 PC - Mar 10 '19

http://chng.it/Ckx8hbwgHj

Petition to Raise the Loot Drop Rate

1

u/toomanyredbulls Mar 10 '19

Haha, that will show them!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

No middle ground. I just spent my day off to get 6 masterworks and a shitload of materials in freeplay just so that I can craft it all away into garbage loot rolls.

A full fucking day for rngesus to forsake me.

1

u/thatwriterguyva XBOX - Mar 10 '19

This is the middle, guaranteed 1 MW with increased loot quality rather than quantity. That's what they settled on from release

Now everyone is losing their mind and wants quantity

1

u/Xbob42 Mar 10 '19

Quality? Where the fuck is the quality? The loot quality is literally the worst in any game I've ever played. +1% damage on a Masterwork that's a ridiculously rare drop is not quality loot. Quality loot has high and reliable minimum stat pools. We should be focusing on which inscriptions we want and moving from there, not focusing on which inscriptions aren't between 1-15% of absolute trash.

1

u/TheBlueTunicLink Mar 10 '19

༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ Summon the Blackout ༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

5 stages of grief. #3 bargaining

1

u/stonedp1ngu Mar 10 '19

Play everyday since launch haven't seen anything new for over a week. 143 hours and I've seen 7 legendaries, 3 duplicates all have shit rolls. I literally booted up anthem today and just closed it as the realisation that theres just no fucking point sunk in.

1

u/romeo_fox PLAYSTATION - Mar 11 '19

I'm on-board to see the progression as well. We all know and accept that you have to grind somewhat to get anywhere in these types of games. What I am really not happy about is getting masterwork and my very 1st legendary drop to be for javelins I am not running. This past Saturday I finally got my 1st legendary drop and I was so excited, to the point where I felt almost childish, but it's taken so long to see one that I actually yelled when I saw it. Now keep in mind that I am a Colossus, and wouldn't you know it that the legendary drop was a Ranger component. I was furious. I literally quit Anthem and went to Destiny for several hours after that. Next day comes around and I am running HoR and come out with 2 masterwork items. One was for a Storm and the other for an Interceptor. I'm beside myself at this point as I am getting more components for javelins I don't use than for the one I do. ZERO progression made and that is beyond ridiculous to me.

1

u/MarnegieCellon Mar 09 '19

Where's my lootlancers at?

༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ Summon the loot ༼ つ ◕◕ ༽つ

1

u/bigfootswillie Mar 10 '19

Thank you man for the well-reasoned post. Everybody is frustrated with loot but people have to see things from the dev's perspective. You can't just get amazing loot all the time forever. The whole point of this game is to keep playing to keep chasing better loot. With the drop rate like it was yesterday, that would happen very quickly for even moderately hardcore players. Once you're "complete" there's really not much to do (which is admittedly another problem they will need to solve). The current drop rate is still shit though so meeting somewhere in the middle is much more reasonable.

Extra guaranteed drops for the higher GM difficulties would also be a good addition to this.

1

u/Asami97 Mar 10 '19

As much as I agree with you that drop rate should be buffed, we should not have to meet them in the middle. Neither should we have to put up with a lesser experience just because we want increased drops that damn badly.

Drops rates should be and need to be increased back to when they were 'bugged' the first time. And that's the bare minimum.

As consumers we don't get anything by being quiet and we don't get anything by meeting them in the middle.

Bioware need to buff drop rate considerably. No half measures.

1

u/bearLover23 Mar 10 '19

Meeting in the middle won't solve the actual issues is the problem. The chance of getting the rolls you want that can complete a build are EXTREMELY low.

Just showering us in drops won't help player agency.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

it’s unbelievable that people with 100+ hours already seriously expect a game to be catered to them. How many people do you actually think have hit that mark? I’d say maybe what- less than .01%? You’re playing the game a lot. Nothing wrong with that but just don’t act like you speak for everyone

1

u/JackKerras Mar 10 '19

Fuck the middle.

Loot needs to change, and not a little. They've screwed this up the same way, twice. They've 'fixed' it, to the vast detriment of their playerbase, the same way, twice.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

Finally a post about that I 100% agree with. Everyone just seemed to whine about not getting 100+ masterworks per mission just because they want it. I'm glad to see someone seeing BW's perspective and wanting a compromise without saying that BW is gonna shutdown and everything they do is terrible

I really appreciate this post. Thank you

0

u/MakinWarhere Mar 10 '19

The issue, as I see it, is the horrible inscriptions. Epic tried to push inscriptions like this in Fortnite: Save the World. The community was just as angry and vocal about their loot system and the awful inscriptions until they caved. If BioWare thinks they can keep this inscription system they are deluding themselves.

There need to be strict controls on which inscriptions can appear on which gear.

+10% sniper dmg on a MW shotgun? NO

+2% weapon dmg on any MW? NO

+3% clip size? Hell NO

Come on. Your player base will never find it acceptable to be expected to farm for a hundred or more of the same item hoping for a good roll. If you don’t believe me then just look into the history of Save the World loot

0

u/Iceykitsune2 PC - Mar 10 '19

+10% sniper dmg on a MW shotgun? NO

does it have a gear icon, or a javelin icon?

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

I agree with everyone, the loot drops need to go back. But we also came a bigger problem. GM's 2 and 3 are easy.. way to easy, even with full mw gear no legendaries. They need to balance the difficulties now that they have upped everyone's damage . We will all be face rolling gm3 and become bored or maybe bring the drop rate up on gm3. Everything in the game feels so out of tune

2

u/LithiumOhm PLAYSTATION - Mar 09 '19

Add gm4 lol

1

u/PM_ME_YER_DOOKY_HOLE Mar 10 '19

So...just add more health?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

I think it gm should have a structure.

Gm1: epic gear with Mw drops at the drop rate everyone wants. ("Glitched drop rate") no guarantees for a drop at the end. It will still provide grinding for amazing/god rolls.

Gm2: you should have some mw gear even full mw if you farm enough. Gm2 is where legendaries drop at the glitch rate. Obviously gm2 will be harder.

Gm3: super difficult, even with being full legendary. Still drops legendary gear ( so you can grind for God rolls) but has a chance to drop relics at a small drop rate but the stats on them are always amazing/god rolls. You can't craft relics but you can get legendary blue prints to drop. If you can gear up in relics then you will be semi ready for their "raids"

1

u/TrippyGummyBear Mar 09 '19

I completely agree about gm2. Like if loot was moved into there and gm3 I'd personally be fine with the progression of loot, but as it stands gm2/3 barely reward more than your casual gm1 stronghold. Its ridiculous that we can't even have that.

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

I'm down voting you, but only because you started with a thank you

2

u/Callyste Mar 09 '19

I'm downvoting you, but only because you downvoted him.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Well I'm up voting you for your honesty

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19

[deleted]

4

u/RayearthIX PLAYSTATION - Mar 10 '19

Compromise, negotiations, middle-ground, etc. a rare unicorn in this day of extremism.