r/HFY • u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse • Sep 15 '17
MOD Community PSA: Shared Universes, Author Permissions, and You
Greetings citizens of HFY. Lately your mod team has seen a rise in issues involving people not getting permissions to write in another author's universe, not getting the original author's permission to compose an ebook of their story/audio book of their story, and a general disregard of asking for permission to use another's work. We have also seen an unfortunate number of comments that incorrectly state content posted on reddit is public domain or that it is acceptable to copy content posted here because it is made available for free, when in fact users retain copyright of any submitted work.
As it has been a while since we have reminded the community to Read the Rules and Standards & Expectations, plus the fact that we have grown by several tens of thousands, your mod team has made this PSA to remind everyone about HFY’s policies regarding shared universes, authors permissions, and you.
Author Permission
Author permission beyond generally acceptable fair use is required for using another /r/HFY author's content in your own story or for reproducing their work. Make sure you include a clear scope for what permission you are trying to obtain, which may include universe, characters, or time frame. Once you have obtained permission, please indicate on your post that you obtained permission, to also make it clear that you read these rules. Include the following:
Statement that the story, narration, ebook, etc., was posted with permission of the original author (and link to that author);
Link to the original work;
Link to any other website the original author requires: patreon, personal website, subreddit, etc.;
Link to and compliance with any license agreement the work is restricted by, if it is not hosted on Reddit.
From our community's Standards and Expectations page, we have our community's outline regarding the need to get an author's permission if you wish to use their work. Fairly straight forward, if you want to use someone's work for anything, be it the setting for a story of your own, characters to appear in your series, some other instance of composing it in an ebook, narration, comic, or anything else that could be using another's work that is not yours, you must obtain author permission.
Message the author, tell them what you want to use their work for, see if they give your permission. When you do post, give them the proper credit, source their work and state that you have their permission and have read the sub's rules on the issue.
Authors: If you notice someone using your works without permission, contact the mods and we will help correct the situation.
7
u/Lvl25-human-nerd Robot Sep 15 '17
Awesome post! As a writer I'm glad to see this here. Also, just tossing an idea out there, what if on the author wiki's writers had a section where they could indicate whether or not they allow derivative works and any conditions attatched to such. The author could indicate "Please PM" "Open to any/all derivative works" "Open to derivative works within the setting but not using existing characters/ships" etc.
4
u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse Sep 18 '17
In a perfect world that would solve the issue for sure but sadly only a fraction of the community really checks out the wiki. Not to mention such a blanket statement could let things get out of control. Best bet is to just ask for the authors permission.
8
u/slice_of_pi The Ancient One Sep 16 '17
I think it would be easier, safer, and simpler to have prospective authors PM the universe/setting owner and ask permission as a default. Depending on every author to update their own wiki page is a bit like trying to keep the tide back with a broom.
3
u/Dragfie Sep 18 '17
Did something happen to trigger this?
(In other word; gimi all the gos!)
6
u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse Sep 18 '17
Specific big instance no, usually we have to deal with something along these lines once every so often (mostly ensuring author permission & accreditation for audio readings/ebooks by fans) but we have noticed an increasing trend, general inquiries in mod mail as well as the rise of more multiverse stories between several authors.
Along with the fact it has been a while since we have done any kind of PSA regarding our rules/standards and in that time our community has almost tripled in size.
So to answer your question you can say it's a lot of little things that we are taking care of all at once to ensure nothing big happens or as that bit of wisdom goes. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
5
u/YisouKou Xeno Sep 18 '17
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
Is this an English idiom? I haven't heard it before D:
3
u/mechakid Sep 18 '17
English or american. I use the phrase fairly often.
And it's true. It's easier to fix a problem by getting in front of it and controlling the issue.
1
2
u/CaCl2 Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17
Are blanket statements like ThisHasNotGoneWell's
"A Policy on Writing in my Universe: Go right ahead, though I do suggest getting on the Discord. It’s the easiest way to contact me, and I’ve posted some other notes and policy stuff there."
considered valid permission?
2
u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse Sep 22 '17
Yes but we still expect proper credit, links and mentions as stated in our rule to be followed. That way we can ensure the rules where read and are understood. Plus even if the author has given an open check to the community with their universe they still are the original creators of it and deserve credit, not to mention new readers need some point of reference to go to see in order to understand the verse it takes place it.
35
26
u/moofrog AI Sep 15 '17
I agree. Please be respectful of the authors of the works that we all get to enjoy here for free. When they put the effort that they have into the stories that they have made, it is only fitting that they retain the control of the creative direction and copyright of those works.
From a long time reader, thanks to each of you that have submitted your works for our enjoyment.
1
u/Louisthau AI Sep 22 '17
This should be a sticky. Like the sticky to end all sticky.
1
u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse Sep 22 '17
But it is stickied? At least for not till the next series of updates and posssible PSA's get posted.
1
u/Louisthau AI Sep 22 '17
I answered to the post on mobile, and it didn't seem like it was stickied. My fault I guess.
1
Oct 01 '17
I have seen some stories that "kinda" fit in another authors universe. Not exact, but then they will admit its "inspired by" or something and is extremely close.
What is your stance on this?
1
u/Hex_Arcanus Mod of the Verse Oct 01 '17
That is the gray area that we can not reasonably enforce and it would be pretty much up to the authors. Granted all aliens are inspired from a compound of sources over the years and there is nothing wrong with taking features so long as it is not a blaintent full rip and re color.
Though for such instances we have a number of English majors and doctors on contract to get their professional opinion on. They know every trick in the book when it comes to checking if something is plagerizrd or not. Thankfully I can come by the number of cases we have had of thatbhere on lessvthen half a hand.
3
u/squigglestorystudios Human Sep 19 '17
As someone who actively encourages fanworks, this is a wonderful reminder of etiquette. Thankyou wonderful mods!
24
u/StarfellWriter Alien Scum Sep 16 '17
I can't believe this is even a necessary post. Ugh. Then again...
In my experience, people are generally giant fleshbags - the flesh within the bags being comprised of sphincters.