r/Fantasy • Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Aug 27 '17

The r/Fantasy Top Novels Poll: 2017! Now With Star Wars -- Results thread

Hey, look what I found!

Our original voting thread was here.

I want to give y'all a sincere apology that this is so late. Unfortunately, moderators really are only human, and sometimes life gets in the way. I dug this up and finished it up this week, and hopefully it's all good.

Thanks go out to u/Potterhead42, u/LittlePlasticCastle, u/Megan_Dawn, and u/The_Real_JS, who have all worked hard on this list. I'm only the last one to have my sticky fingers on it.

This list had 5758 valid votes on it! Seriously, holy cow! Also, we have consolidated as many books into series as possible. Hopefully that's okay. There are almost certainly errors, not least of which are typos. I hope you forgive me for them -- this was massive.

So, with no further ado -- this is the full list, available in a Google Sheet for you to mess with.

And here are the top votes!

RankingNum of VotesTitle
1251A Song of Ice and Fire by George R. R. Martin
2241The Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson
3226Middle-Earth Universe by J. R. R. Tolkien
4218The Kingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss
5196Harry Potter by J. K. Rowling
6175Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson
7166Gentleman Bastard by Scott Lynch
8165The Wheel of Time by Robert Jordan
9143The First Law by Joe Abercrombie
10139Discworld by Terry Pratchett
11133The Malazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson
12126Realms of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb
13101The Dresden Files by Jim Butcher
1484Worm by Wildbow
1574Dune by Frank Herbert
1673Red Rising by Pierce Brown
1771Riyria by Michael J. Sullivan
1866The Broken Empire by Mark Lawrence
1956Lightbringer by Brent Weeks
2053The Chronicles of the Black Company by Glen Cook
2053The Dark Tower by Stephen King
2150Enderverse by Orson Scott Card
2246Hyperion Cantos by Dan Simmons
2344The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams
2442His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
2541American Gods by Neil Gaiman
2640The Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis
2739The Broken Earth by N. K. Jemisin
2838Powder Mage by Brian McClellan
2838Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay
2937The Lions of Al-Rassan by Guy Gavriel Kay
3033Good Omens by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett
3033The Witcher by Andrzej Sapkowski
3132Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke
3132The Earthsea Cycle by Ursula K. Le Guin
3231The Magicians by Lev Grossman
3330Kushiel's Universe by Jacqueline Carey
3330The Books of Babel by Josiah Bancroft
3427Abhorsen by Garth Nix
3427Sandman by Neil Gaiman
3526The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison
3625The Book of the New Sun by Gene Wolfe
3724World by the Five Gods by Lois McMaster Bujold
3724Uprooted by Naomi Novik
3823New Crobuzon by China Mieville
3823Ready Player One by Ernest Cline
3823Culture by Iain M. Banks
3922The Bartimaeus Sequence by Jonathan Stroud
3922Tortall by Tamora Pierce
4020Redwall by Brian Jacques
4119The Shadow Campaigns by Django Wexler
4218The Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini
4218The Expanse by James S. A. Corey
4218The Second Apocalypse by R. Scott Bakker
4218The Chronicles of Amber by Roger Zelazny
4218Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn by Tad Williams
4218Thrawn Trilogy by Timothy Zahn
4317The Belgariad by David Eddings
4317Foundation Universe by Isaac Asimov
4317The Empire Trilogy by Janny Wurts and Raymond Feist
4317Vorkosiga Saga by Lois McMaster Bujold
4317The Riftwar Cycle by Raymond Feist
4317Twig by Wildbow
4416Night Angel Trilogy by Brent Weeks
4416Raven's Shadow by Anthony Ryan
4416The Acts of Caine by Matthew Woodring Stover
4515The Drenai Saga by David Gemmell
4515Codex Alera by Jim Butcher
4515The Divine Cities by Robert Jackson Bennett
4515The Traitor Baru Cormorant by Seth Dickinson
4515The Princess Bride by William Goldman
4614Elantris by Brandon Sanderson
4614Warbreaker by Brandon Sanderson
4614The Sarantine Mosaic by Guy Gavriel Kay
4614The Demon Cycle by Peter V. Brett
4713Watership Down by Richard Adams
4713Percy Jackson & the Olympians by Rick Riordan
4812Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman
4812The Emperor's Soul by Brandon Sandson
4812Wars of Light and Shadow by Janny Wurts
4911The Dagger and the Coin by Daniel Abraham
4911The Traitor Son Cycle by Miles Cameron
4911Inheritance Trilogy by N.K. Jemisin
4911The Last Unicorn by Peter S. Beagle
4911The Stand by Stephen King
4911Pact by Wildbow
5010The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant by Stephen R. Donaldson
5010The Chronicle of the Unhewn Throne by Brian Staveley
5010The Deed of Paksenarrion by Elizabeth Moon
5010The Dandelion Dynasty by Ken Liu
5010Book of the Ancestor by Mark Lawrence
5010The Elric Saga by Michael Moorcock
5010Greatcoats by Sebastian de Castell
5010Wayfarers by Becky Chambers
266 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

24

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

moderators really are only human

Nice try.

Haha, fun to see Books of Babel both in the under-read and best list.

Thanks for the list!

9

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Aug 27 '17

This only human moderator isn't filling in 800 books worth of Goodreads links, haha. ;)

11

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17

The moderators were human once, but now they are mere spirits, noble specters who patrol the server kingdom, hunting trolls and slaying spam dragons. They are the Ghost Knights of r/Fantasy!

3

u/Charsatan Sep 03 '17

Reference to something?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17

Nope! Just general silliness!

7

u/Titan_Arum Reading Champion II Aug 27 '17

The Books of Babel are horribly underread outside of r/fantasy and within. Those who have read it seem to overwhelmingly love it. Thus, it makes both lists. I love this fact too!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

I can't wait to see the books in libraries and badger random people to read them!

4

u/Titan_Arum Reading Champion II Aug 27 '17

Oh! Me too! I've badgered enough of my friends and family to read the already. My mother loved them!

121

u/HiuGregg Stabby Winner, Worldbuilders Aug 27 '17

How is X above Y? How can Z be at Nth when it isn't even fantasy? Wtf, my favourite book isn't on this list. I didn't realize that one series had so many fans, I thought it was trash.


I'm all seriousness though, fun list! Nice to see Wayfarers on there.

40

u/BatBoss Hellhound Aug 27 '17

You bastard! X is the most revolutionary fantasy series in 100 years! Y is derivative garbage that is only on here because of nostalgia.

12

u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Aug 27 '17

There actually is an anime series called X.

17

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Aug 27 '17

And it is awesome.

16

u/NoNoNota1 Reading Champion Aug 27 '17

Some would say it's the most revolutionary fantasy series in 100 years.

30

u/TidalPawn Aug 27 '17

Oh sure, give XYZ all the love, just ignore all that ABC has done for the genre.

10

u/NoNoNota1 Reading Champion Aug 27 '17

We had to have them to get where we are, but they just don't hold up.

6

u/AmethystOrator Reading Champion Aug 27 '17

My guess is a demon conspiracy, we don't hear as much about them these days, and perhaps that's just how they want it?

Obviously an influx of sci-fi fans who are running rampant (as a reader I'm morally opposed to running, or any exercise really [That's a stereotype that's outdated? But, but, how else can I justify my unhealthy habits?]).

Sometimes peeps just can't appreciate greatness.

Obviously my elevated tastes (raises little finger while drinking wine) are so, um, elevated, that allowances have to be made. [Although it's 10:30 in the morning here, so if I'm drinking wine then that's maybe, possibly, perhaps not quite so sophisticated as I like to imagine. Darn the inconvenient speed of these solar rotations!]

Seriousness? You couldn't have mentioned that first?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

Nice to see Wayfarers on there.

Must...read...the sequel.

4

u/HumanSieve Aug 28 '17

I'd like to see a breakdown of this list about publishing dates, to see if there is a bias towards new/currently published work. I suspect there is. I would make it, but I'm off traveling.

9

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Aug 28 '17

Feel free to make a copy of the sheet and do the research; 800 is a bit too many for me to do. :/

5

u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X Aug 28 '17

Just four months later my vote would be significantly different.

4

u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Aug 30 '17

Funny how that works, isn't it? I had a similar reaction

5

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Aug 31 '17

I forgot to vote. o.o

1

u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Aug 31 '17

Lol, oh dear

2

u/Tioben Aug 28 '17

Having read 62% of these, I'm wondering if it is simply time to move on to another genre...

17

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Aug 28 '17

I think it's time for you to move on to the underread/underrated list. ;)

50

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

If Oathbringer doesn't disappoint, I wouldn't be surprised if Stormlight tops ASOIAF next year. 10 votes is already extremely close.

32

u/tkinsey3 Aug 27 '17

I enjoyed WoK and WoR, but I still feel like #2 is way too high for Stormlight (though I consider it Top 10-15 for SURE). Oathbringer has a lot to prove. I hope it's incredible.

32

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

I'm not sure it does either, with only 2 books out. I also think it's good to remember this is just a popularity contest, and Stormlight is much, much more mainstream than all but a few works on the list.

6

u/tkinsey3 Aug 27 '17

Totally agree. Same reason that Mistborn is so high.

Both are really, really good series, but if we're talking strictly quality I think I'd have Stormlight somewhere around 10-12 and Mistborn in the 20-25 range.

14

u/yahasgaruna Aug 27 '17

I think a large reason for Stormlight being as high as it is could be a legacy of the fact that Sanderson completed Wheel of Time - it was really smart of Doherty to force him to write tWoK around the same time he completed Books 13 and 14 - all the millions of folks completing Wheel of Time suddenly had an answer to the question "what do we read now?"

It helps that Stormlight is top-notch in terms of consistency, compared to Sanderson's other work.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17

Will have to see the results the year after TWOW as well. I expect ASOIAF gets another massive boost then.

23

u/TRRichardson Aug 28 '17 edited Aug 28 '17

Traitor Son Cycle

49

I see my work here on Earth is not yet done

7

u/vokkan Aug 27 '17

There's really a huge variation of styles in the top 10-15 placers, making a great showing of the diversity of the genre.

(and it makes me think that it wasn't made up of a hundred people with the exact same nominees just in slightly different orders)

6

u/DjangoWexler AMA Author Django Wexler Aug 28 '17

Someone should do diffs of each year's list, so we can see which series rise and fall, like on music charts.

9

u/DjangoWexler AMA Author Django Wexler Aug 28 '17

And by "someone" I mean "someone with more time than me".

4

u/ricree Aug 29 '17

One of the unofficial results threads had a diff on it, and so did the official 2015 list.

So far as I can tell, nobody has done one for every year, although it might be a bit tricky since they've changed the rules on series groupings more than once.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '17

[deleted]

3

u/DjangoWexler AMA Author Django Wexler Aug 30 '17

Interesting! I'm actually surprised there isn't more variation just via random sampling.

11

u/AmethystOrator Reading Champion Aug 27 '17

"When will the The r/Fantasy Top Novels Poll: 2017 poll results be posted..." Oh wait, it's here! Huzzah!!

Thanks very much to everyone who put in so much work.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

I can't believe it was that long ago. I had pretty much forgot about it.

Thanks for the list! It's always fun seeing these.

5

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Aug 27 '17

I see some new entries on the list, nice! Thanks for the work in putting this together!

5

u/pornokitsch Ifrit Aug 28 '17

Wow, well done!

4

u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Aug 27 '17

This is great! Thanks for all the hard work.

1

u/tolandruth Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

Read everything up to first law might have to start reading that. Have read 26 out of the top 50 list.

1

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 01 '17

There's 94 or 95 in the top 50 due to vote totals. :D

1

u/tolandruth Sep 01 '17

Yeah will definitely be looking into some of them thanks for putting together all of this.

1

u/catfishbilly_ Sep 02 '17

The Macht Travelers Gate The Crimson Empire The Twilight Reign

All should be on there above some, but I haven't voted on any so yeah.

Twilight Reign series was great, imo. The Crimson Empire hasten books out and is looking pretty good too.

2

u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 02 '17

Have you checked the extended list?

1

u/catfishbilly_ Sep 02 '17

Thanks, I actually overlooked that part lol. Late night laziness.

6

u/yahasgaruna Aug 27 '17

Are there any plans to ever merge all of Sanderson's Cosmere books into the same head, the way Hobb's Elderlings books have been?

19

u/TRAIANVS Aug 28 '17

I don't think those two are precisely comparable. The Realm of the Elderlings is far more interconnected while the Cosmere (at least at this stage) is more like several worlds in the same universe with the implication of a grander plot.

6

u/KristinnK Aug 28 '17

I wouldn't agree with this. Generally the policy has been to list together books in the same world, and the Sanderson series are set in different worlds, Cosmere notwithstanding. The magic systems are different, and there has only ever been one character that appears in different Cosmere worlds.

3

u/TheHighConnor Aug 29 '17 edited Aug 29 '17

There are multiple characters that appear in other Cosmere worlds. Also we have seen brief glimpses of magic systems crossing over worlds.

4

u/Armored_Caladbolg Aug 28 '17

I can't really see merging the Cosmere in a way that would be meaningful or not just for novelty. Could be that I'm not a very good writer, though.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

What do you mean by "merge into the same head"?

7

u/yahasgaruna Aug 27 '17

"The Realm of the Elderlings" describes at least 3 trilogies by Hobb, just like the term Cosmere includes both of Sanderson's big series, as well as several other books and short stories. All of Sanderson's titles have been kept separate while Hobb's have not - I was asking if that was a result of a decision not to merge Sanderson's series into one mega-series, or if it was a matter of time.

1

u/TheHighConnor Aug 29 '17

There is a character who appears in every Cosmere Novel. Sanderson has said that he will eventually get his own series.

3

u/yahasgaruna Aug 29 '17

I know? Not sure why you got the impression I didn't.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

The Cosmere books are too different in quality, IMO. And the universe is bigger than The Realm of the Elderlings, so I'm not sure it can work here...

2

u/yahasgaruna Aug 27 '17

I guess, yeah.

3

u/iccylol Aug 27 '17

My to-read list was to long before this, now it's endless, i love it!

3

u/tracywc AMA Author William C. Tracy, Worldbuilders Aug 28 '17

Great list! There is a lot of Sanderson in there. I've read a lot of it, but certainly have some books to add to my reading list.

3

u/Kopratic Stabby Winner, Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Aug 29 '17

I always love seeing these lists.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17

Thanks for the work guys!

1

u/Kingdomdude Aug 28 '17

Amazing list! Thank You for your efforts.

1

u/IBNobody Worldbuilders Aug 29 '17

The Star Wars was interesting. I hit 5 stars, barely. I had most of the stuff on the first page, but hardly anything on the last.

Are those considered to be bottom of the barrel, or are they the worst of the best?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '17

I'm glad Codex Alera made the list, I loved that series. Such a fun read.

1

u/ichewyou Sep 01 '17

Is there an end of the year vote for only novels released this year?

2

u/keshanu Reading Champion V Sep 04 '17

There are the annual Stabby Awards

1

u/redditfetishist Sep 03 '17

can you post a full list? id like to see books on peoples top 10 that only had one vote?

1

u/keshanu Reading Champion V Sep 04 '17

1

u/theclaymore47 Oct 19 '17

Garth Nix and Tamora Pierce have taken me on some of my favorite adventures

1

u/hockeyjoker Jan 16 '18

I guess Terry Goodkind didn't make it out to give 'Sword of Truth' a vote. Oh well.

1

u/jonofan Jan 23 '18

As a Feist fan, I think "The Riftware Cycle" #43 should surely link to https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2041545.The_Riftwar_Saga - the Riftware series rather than the standalone book Honoured Enemy. I don't think Honoured Enemy would make any sense otherwise.

0

u/ronin0069 Jan 07 '18

Who the fuck rates Inheritance that high? Or rates it at all?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

[deleted]

17

u/Scyther99 Aug 27 '17

New books from Malazan universe are constantly being published. And even if you only consider main series, last book is only 6 years old, which is not much. Last Mistborn book is from 2008, same for First Law etc. Then we have Tolkien...

5

u/guyonthissite Aug 28 '17

Tolkien is always going to be a bit of an exception.

I only say this not to argue, but because I love Tolkien.

4

u/Tortankum Aug 30 '17

The last mistborn book was published in 2016...

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

[deleted]

2

u/pregnantchihuahua3 Aug 27 '17

ICE's first 6 book series is mediocre (some are good but mostly its meh) so I agree there, but a lot of people even consider Kharkanas to be better than the main series. In a different way obviously, it's much more poetic and Shakesperian, so I understand why people wouldn't like that, but in my and a lot of people's cases, it's perfect. Also ICE's new novel Dancer's Lament (although I have yet to read this one) is thought to be farrrrr superior to his first series.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

[deleted]

4

u/pregnantchihuahua3 Aug 27 '17

Yeah, and I can very much see why people would hate that type of book. It's my favorite style of literature to read so I'm obviously biased, but I do also see a lot of people who like the main series also like Kharkanas. It is a divided book though that is for sure!

4

u/TRAIANVS Aug 28 '17

I think Kharkanas is probably even more "hate it or love it" than Malazan. It's more philosophical, the prose is heavier, and it's even more thematically driven than the Book of the Fallen. Personally I'm really enjoying it, but I totally understand people who can't get into it despite loving the Book of the Fallen.

I also kinda like seeing this development in Erikson's writing. I think it's healthy for authors to try out new styles. Since this comment thread is about Malazan, I'd like to mention Esslemont's newest book (Dancer's Lament) as a prime example of that. His Malazan Empire series was... mediocre in my opinion. It had some great moments and left no doubt that Esslemont was a capable writer, but I think he suffered from trying to emulate Erikson's style. In Dancer's Lament I think he's over that and is writing on his own terms.

Tl;dr: Kharkanas is not everybody's cup of tea, but that being said go read Dancer's Lament.

3

u/lonedirewolf21 Aug 28 '17

Staying power? I think it is just starting to really grow. I expect it to continue to move up the list as more people get exposed to it.