r/trees • u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com • Apr 22 '17
Act now! Goodbye /r/trees theme, goodbye subreddit individuality, goodbye promoting smaller subs with menus, goodbye weed leaves when upvoting, goodbye TreesRadio and Tree's chatroom links, goodbye custom flair, hello homogenous Reddit!
Here is a small list of just a small bit of the things you may find missing from Reddit after this change on some other subreddits as well. (thanks to /u/reseph for the list)
Functionality: /r/Overwatch has subreddit filters
Functionality: /r/Dota2 has a list of current livestreams and their # of viewers
UX: /r/videos has a list of rules where on hover it expands out to explain each rule
Functionality: /r/Minecraft has a list of server status (icons) on sidebar
UX: /r/Hearthstone has notices & links on the top banner
Personality: /r/ffxiv has various CSS Easter Eggs to give it a bit more personality
Functionality: /r/Starcraft has a "verified user" system
UX: /r/Guildwars2 increased the the size of "message the moderators" to make it stand out more
UX: /r/ffxi has a small tooltip if a user hasn't set a user flair yet
UX: /r/DarkSouls2 has related subreddits linked on the sidebar with images instead of text
Personality: /r/mildlyinfuriating's joke where it slightly rotates "random" comment threads
Functionality: /r/ClashOfClans not only has a list of livestreams, but thumbnail previews of each
UX: /r/DarkSouls3 has a reminder when hovering over the downvote button
Personality: /r/StarWars has quote popups when you upvote
UX: /r/pcmasterrace has changed the "report" link to red
UX: /r/explainlikeimfive has custom colored link flair icons
Personality: /r/mylittlepony has countless emotes
Personality: /r/onepiece has a scrolling banner (which can be paused)
UX: /r/FinalFantasy has green background stickies to make them stand out
Personality: /r/mildlyinteresting has a moving gauge on sidebar
Functionality: /r/IASIP has a top menu
UX: /r/DoctorWho has a light red box on sidebar for new users to read
UX: /r/gallifrey disables the PM link on "Created by" so users focus on modmail
The admins have made it clear that they don't care what the moderators or users of the site think however and they know best and will be pushing forward with this development. We hope there may be some of our users who care enough about the CSS here and their other subreddits that by being vocal and outspoken early we can maybe prevent Reddit from making this mistake.
I'm still waiting on Admin responses to my questioning here but I doubt they will respond as they commonly don't answer tough questions. Edit: Admin reply, My reply back
Without CSS subreddits will all look the same, maybe the ability to change to a different color and a custom image header. We figured we would give you a heads up to help ease the transition since some of you inevitably will be confused and miss the old stuff as we will.
you can also visit /r/proCSS for more info/organizing
If you want to keep CSS please let the admins know by messaging one of them or commenting in that thread above to one of them. You can also message /u/spez by clicking this link (please be polite)
23
u/Nightshade400 Apr 22 '17
Fuck, this looks like shit now.
What is the reasoning for removing CSS?
→ More replies (3)26
u/Nightshade400 Apr 22 '17
Nevermind I read the link chains and it is still pretty ignorant when the internet pretty much runs on CSS. Their complaint that it is difficult to learn is thin at best. Any level of coding takes time to learn and CSS of all things can be learned with a good week or two of playing around, some reading and simple Google searches.
18
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 22 '17
And there are subreddits that will help newbies out with their sub CSS. I have also helped prepare css for many cannabis themed subreddits that I'm not part of just to help them out. Even if you don't know CSS you have options. If anything they should build their themes and customize tools for CSS noobs but leave CSS in for us who know how to use it and need it.
9
u/Nightshade400 Apr 22 '17
To me it sounds like they are trying to nerf the playing field so that everyone can get a trophy. Coding and learning how to do it right takes time and involves a lot of failure. That is why those that can't either knuckle down and learn or hire someone who can. By making it more accesible for everyone right out the box they are removing any incentive to learn or share knowledge...which I always thought was a huge part of Reddit as a whole.
2
May 01 '17
CSS is easy as fuck what are they talking about ahahahah
That's pretty pathetic for a 'hip tech' company to say css is hard.
Like shit, if css is too hard for them, what is this site coded in then? Scratch? Fucking lol
7
u/flexus123 Apr 25 '17
Why trees radio ?
9
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 25 '17
TR will still exist we just won't be able to use CSS to add a link to it at the top of the page anymore.
6
u/PostGraduatePotUser Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Just to be clear, they are removing the ability to customize each page according to what moderators think their subbers might like?
How much actual reigning in of power is happening? Is the this a sign that not only is this site likely to be cleaned up but might be filtered to make it boring and placid?
I wonder what they plan to do to some of the other subs?
The ones listed look to be mostly video game oriented and thus subject to a bit more scrutiny as they are other companies' property. This sub has zero ties to anyone in particular, barring Reddit itself, and none of the little nuances hurt potential buyers/advertisers in any fashion.
If changes are being made here, have there been any reasons given as to why said changes are necessary? Generally advertisers like having brand recognition and this sub has it well established.
Is Reddit getting heat from the feds to slow down the freedom in which we share information? That would be a Constitutional breach if that is the case. To whom do I write and ask the pressing questions that matter?
This sub has a ton of great content: both comical and informative, that reaches a very diverse demographic on many counts. It is a hub of happiness and understanding that is rarely seen and must be preserved the way it was intended to be created. Give me some emails or some place in which I can reach those that make the decisions. Let me be an active member who can assist in keeping our sacred space a fun haven for all who love the herb!
6
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 23 '17
They are not targeting any individual sub they are removing it for everyone.
6
u/PostGraduatePotUser Apr 23 '17
It just speaks volumes about who they are as a company. Another Reddit will pop up in its place and give folks a reason to enjoy that space instead. Bad move, but it happens.
10
u/blueskin Apr 23 '17
It's happening to everyone.
Is the this a sign that not only is this site likely to be cleaned up but might be filtered to make it boring and placid?
Yes. This is primarily to get people on to their shitty mobile app, but it becomes a lot easier to control people in general when individuality has been curtailed; that's the modus operandi of every dictatorship in the world, as well as companies like Apple or Microsoft.
6
u/PostGraduatePotUser Apr 23 '17
Yes it is. All pure creativity is met with hostility and anger when confronted by a being that wishes to be omnipotent. The cessation of free anything is in jeopardy when knowledge and/or expression is suppressed.
I don't do apps so perhaps I will be migrating over to Snoop's site when all this is said and done.
2
u/BunnyOppai Apr 28 '17
I'm mostly concerned for r/ooer. They're going to lose what makes them special...
6
Apr 23 '17
When will the change happen?
6
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 23 '17
We don't know yet. Not immediately soon.
5
u/uptokesforall Apr 25 '17
Then please, the method appears lost to the ages
How do i put the number in the leaf?![5]
5
852
Apr 22 '17
I hate subreddits that look like the front page. :(
0
Apr 28 '17
[deleted]
12
2
2
May 09 '17
Yeah. but I rather Facebook vs myspace. remember trying to access a friend's profile who had every fucking thing on it? ten songs playing at once. curser changes. background is animated. 7 videos auto playing.
0
Apr 30 '17
[deleted]
112
u/anthodava Apr 30 '17
What hot garbage on this 90 degree day.
66
u/Daevir May 02 '17
Looks like reddit might lose its place as my favorite site. Fucking shame, but probably for the best so I don't spend so much time on here haha.
74
3
414
u/Geronimobius Apr 22 '17
"Oh hey, here have r/place and enjoy it, it will be the last time you can create something unique on reddit."
92
u/Sharia_leBluef Apr 24 '17
this is exactly what i was thinking, could you imagine /r/place if they did something like giving each sub one square area and 3 color choices? thats what this seems like to me. how fkn lame
174
u/ucantsimee Apr 22 '17
We are protesting this change! Head over to r/ProCSS to show your support
→ More replies (1)3
164
u/MikulkaCS Apr 22 '17
Why do companies always have some kind of update that is so counter-productive that it actually hurts their fans... what the fuck
1
1
u/Stardustchaser Apr 28 '17
This is why I left the Rotten Tomatoes forums. Had an account since early 2007. All sorts of upgrades to the site for whatever reason buried the forums from being seen on the front site page without a login, and then they tied new accounts to Facebook, and on the last "upgrade" almost three years ago I was kicked off my login and no amount of email requests to reset my old account were returned. It was a fantastic community, with fun and user drama and all sorts of great conversations. But ultimately I'm not going to give that site more business after their treatment of the people who were there from way back.
Geez I hope the admins here remember their roots.
0
Apr 22 '17
[deleted]
71
Apr 22 '17
I'm not supporting communism of any form but I gotta say, capitalism really fucks every nice thing up..
27
u/phoenix2448 Apr 23 '17
There's plenty between capitalism and communism. Its not so much that capitalism fucks things up, its that the system capitalism is currently operating in isn't good.
I'm not talking about the reddit CSS thing here, just sayin. But as an example of the reddit CSS thing, would you be inclined to pay reddit in order to keep CSS? If not, you don't care about it enough in an economical sense and there is no incentive for reddit to keep it except customer satisfaction. Which is extremely important, but on reddit its not like there are many substitutes that do what reddit does. I doubt they'll lose many members over it.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)8
u/Mechanus_Incarnate Apr 23 '17
30
Apr 23 '17
Everyone is maximum socialist there. I tried to have a conversation once and got banned instantly. Fuck that place.
→ More replies (1)12
u/snackies Apr 23 '17
Yeah there are a lot of things about capitalism that don't work right and things that should be kept socialist in nature or run without profit motives. But the people that are that far gone down their ideological rabbit hole develop an emotional attachment to their ideology. Then they cannot accept that any part of a unified ideology might be wrong.
3
1
65
u/SETM_Y_C Apr 22 '17
Reddit is becoming a bland vanilla shell of its former self in recent months. Jeez.
34
55
u/I_Fucked_With_WuTang Apr 23 '17
Part of the fun about Reddit is exploring different subreddits. A cookie cutter cut and paste "theme" for each subreddit will destroy the uniqueness of this site.
I'm not a mod but I'm willing to fight this till the end.
47
43
Apr 23 '17
Let's all find another forum website to gravitate too. If the admins don't want to listen to their community, why should we stick up with their bullshit?
27
u/potodev Apr 24 '17
Voat is basically backup reddit. Just not enough people using it right now to make it worthwhile for people to migrate. If reddit does enough crappy things, then maybe.
28
u/uptokesforall Apr 25 '17
Been there, noped out in 2 weeks cause its like only beimg subscribed to r/the_donald
Ben garrison comics are an instant karma farm btw
8
u/BunnyOppai Apr 28 '17
Honestly, it was the same for me. Voat is pretty obviously a very far-leaning Republican Reddit and they take "free speech" to the extreme.
16
u/theluckkyg Apr 27 '17
Voat is Reddit for subreddits that were banned. r/fatpeoplehate r/coontown r/european, etc. etc. Not really a desirable community.
3
u/potodev Apr 28 '17
Some people would say the same thing about /r/trees being undesirable. Us dirty pot smokers aren't the most "brand-friendly" group for reddit's
advertiserscorporate overlords. That's kinda the point of a backup reddit. To offer a place to go for communities that reddit deletes or otherwise craps on.8
u/theluckkyg Apr 28 '17
Even if reddit banned trees, which just doesn't fit with how they do things but whatever, I wouldn't wanna hang around with neo nazis, racists and bullies just because they've been excluded too.
Look at Voat's front page as of now. These are the default subs. I saw it described as Reddit but only being suscribed to The Donald, and it's fairly accurate.
3
May 02 '17
reddit users would have to flood voat with new users, and then fight all the same battles against users from fatpeoplehate/coontown and the like.
40
u/awkwardwildturtles Made a mod Laugh on 2/21/16-Awarded this Flair Apr 22 '17
my flair that everyone won't stop asking about? noooooooooo
its a love hate relationship
21
8
3
38
34
u/blueskin Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Total Harrison Bergeron shit.
As it is, it's based on a total lie too - phones do support CSS, in case anyone was wondering. They just want to cripple functionality that isn't available in their shitty app that they seem to be trying to push everyone towards.
As for saying that CSS 'isn't a standard', I don't even know where to begin. 95.7% of all websites use CSS. Even my personal site that is literally a single page with a few lines of text and a PGP key uses CSS.
16
u/SheMadeMeHerBitch Apr 24 '17
I'm on a phone right now and I see all the css. Looks great.
And fuck apps. Ill be damned if I install another app.
8
u/Parade0fChaos Apr 25 '17
Sing it, man. I got several weird looks at the office when they found out I don't have an app for every goddamn service under the sun. Facebook, Groupon, huge services like that have totally functional mobile websites that don't snoop through your entire phone and kill your battery. I must be near the cut-off in age where "there's an app for that" sounded more appealing than just typing in a web address.
→ More replies (1)2
u/OptimisticOctopi May 08 '17
I fucking hate apps. My phone has barely any memory left, and that's just not feasible. Tried to look at a resteraunts menu on yelp (I know they're shitty, but the menu wasn't anywhere else online) and they told me I'd have to download the app to look at more than like 5 pictures. What bullshit.
30
u/_ProgGuy_ Apr 23 '17
So... where's the next reddit alternative? I don't actually want to leave but if they keep making bad decisions I will. :(
20
9
u/uptokesforall Apr 25 '17
Theres are a half dozen of them, one even pays you for getring upvoted on content you produce but we're talking fractions of a penny here
8
u/low_key_like_thor Apr 25 '17
Seriously this angers me so much I'm tempted to just make my own better Reddit. Wish gathering users wasn't so hard though. Looking at Voat makes me wonder what it will really take to make the great migration. We've seen it happen in the past (Digg) but where do we draw the line with Reddit? We need a site that consistently puts users first over money or corporate decisions. Reddit's been pissing of off users for a while now; where the straw the breaks the camel's back??
→ More replies (1)4
u/Rtreesaccount420 Apr 28 '17
well if all the racist shitheads didnt rush over to voat it would have been a nice place.
→ More replies (1)6
u/BunnyOppai Apr 28 '17
Voat is very much like Reddit in terms of content, but most "verses", the Voat alternative to subreddits, are very much like T_D in terms of userbase and comments.
3
Apr 23 '17
Why? That's stupid. And that obnoxious ad at the top is stupid.
4
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 23 '17
What ad?
4
Apr 23 '17
I'm calling it an ad cuz it's at the top of the page and it's obnoxious. It really is an eye sore to look at and I feel like that alone ruins the sub. You guys are worried about losing weed leaf upvotes? What about the giant red letters that takes you a page and a half to read when it's one sentence. It's just stupid.
4
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 23 '17
It's temporary and to raise awareness since we will be losing functionality not just weed upvotes. A lot of people don't think it's stupid but ur entitled to ur opinion I guess.
→ More replies (1)
19
17
u/Tree_Nerd Apr 23 '17
taking this away is unthinkable to me. its like reddit stopped going to festivals and is growing up and putting on a suit and tie to go sell some shit(ads) and not smoke weed anymore.
16
15
14
Apr 23 '17
Visited r/mildlyinfuriating for the first time. Oh jesus why.
For other Redditors who may not have discovered the wonders of the subreddit, here are some of its quirks:
Dead pixel to the left of the screen
Windows activation notice to the right of the screen
Tilted comments. Gets scary when the threads are long.
You know the thing your mouse does when it's busy? That happens constantly. (That was the best thing of all, good job fellas!)
Fake ads at the bottom of the page
(I'm sure there are some others, these are just the ones that I've discovered so far)
Edit: fixed formatting
5
u/BunnyOppai Apr 28 '17
Dude, I turned off their CSS for these reasons. Fuck me if they didn't do the most amazing job at really infuriating me, even if it was intentional. Those mods are geniuses.
→ More replies (5)2
u/nextbgates95 Apr 25 '17
The message icon in the top right is always "unread" even if you have no new messages.
1
Apr 26 '17
Oh. Some people mentioned the inbox thing, but it's all the same for me, as I do have a message that's been lying unread for over a month.
0
14
12
9
u/Anteatersarecute Apr 22 '17
Does this get rid of the side bar as well?
Also what's the point of deleting CSS? Like what does it accomplish or improve for the site?
10
u/smog_alado Apr 23 '17
I doubt Reddit would remove the sidebar. Its very important to have the community description and rules in a very visible place.
That said, if Reddit ever wanted to redisign the sidebar then it would problematic to do that while also allowing custom CSS because lots of the custom CSS out there was written with the assumption that the sidebar is organized and shaped exactly as it is right now.
8
7
Apr 23 '17
As a long time css mod this is almost heart breaking. So many subs will lose their uniqueness and individuality. I hope they take it seriously so we don't end up with just another boring vanilla site.
7
u/Scottcast Apr 23 '17
Seems like it's going to cause more harm than good for the reddit community no?
edit: I mean, wouldn't they make more money if more people are using it??
7
7
7
6
u/3D-Printing Apr 24 '17
Wait, I got a highdea! If this goes through, someone needs to make a reddit post-processing website/app that can take all of the data from a subreddit/reddit and allow it to go through custom CSS and stylizing the subreddit again!
6
6
6
u/TwitchlandRS Apr 24 '17
soon everyones profile will look like (for example) /u/Here_Comes_The_King .. and i don't like the new design, i love the retro look that reddit has.
5
5
u/chupwn Apr 24 '17
Can we email the admins threatening to blacklist reddit on our adblockers? That might work.
5
Apr 24 '17
Fagmin logic: "We aren't making enough ad money lets destroy one of the things that make our dwindling user based communities unique"
5
5
2
Apr 23 '17
i mean it seems like they're working on the actual underlying structure of the website... they even admitted this sort of customization is what they need and talked about creating tools to replace CSS in that very thread you linked first
i dont know lets see where this will lead us but don't take a bunch of assumptions away from this
7
u/GryphonEDM www.treesradio.com Apr 23 '17
They've already admitted their tools won't be able to do what CSS does. No ones assuming.
4
u/LoudpackJack Apr 23 '17
As a person who doesn't even know what CSS stands for but has an idea of what it is, this really doesn't effect me. I browse mobile (don't have a pc) but with that also being said doesn't make it right for them to take away customizability
0
4
3
3
u/Mechlai Apr 24 '17
if it means I won't have to worry about subreddits deleting entire posts of mine because I was missing "flair" then I'm fine with the change. seriously, that's the most frustrating part of reddit.
3
u/_RETLAW Apr 24 '17
Can someone ELI5?
5
u/BlazeReborn Apr 24 '17
Reddit is phasing out CSS. This means the nice little theme for this sub and others will cease to exist, along with functionalities unique to many subs.
3
3
3
u/kushlobster Apr 26 '17
Why wouldn't they want each sub reddit to be unique? That is part of the charm to Reddit, the individuality of each sub Reddit. Dumb choice on the admins part , trying to go main stream like this. Hope it bites them in the butt.
3
u/decideonanamelater Apr 26 '17
Functionality: /r/Dota2 has a list of current livestreams and their # of viewers
.... Fuck. I actually use that a ton.
3
u/DrizzlyEarth175 May 02 '17
Are we witnessing the downfall of Reddit? Could this be the coup de grace?
3
u/JAMALDAVIS May 03 '17
Couldn't RES add the CSS functionality back into Reddit? And then it's not Reddit's problem.
3
u/_Malara May 06 '17
Messaged with the below:
"Please don't take away css. As a member of the r/trees community, the flair and design of the page is part of our identity. I know one of our mods put forth some very solid reasoning for why the changes would affect many of the subreddits identities. Above all, I use Reddit on both mobile and through my laptop. I love the different subreddits designs. Look at r/cats! Paws for up and down votes!
Please keep this in mind. Respectfully, _Malara"
2
2
2
2
u/Bluesfire Apr 25 '17
One of the dumbest decisions I've ever heard of. We need to keep CSS. I can't believe that even with the outpoor of support for keeping it they still want to remove it.
2
2
2
u/Roboticsammy Apr 28 '17
When are we jumping ship to the next reddit site? It happened to Digg and now it's happening to Reddit. Voat sucks ass though, so not that.
0
2
2
u/cyrilio May 03 '17
The custome made wiki I've put hundreds of hours in at /r/ReagentTesting showing all known reagent test results in the world will also be gone /u/GryphonEDM
Its basically the largest public database of its kind.
2
u/Zen_Premium_Cannabis May 08 '17
why the fuck does this help them, its literally just making it less enjoyable
2
u/ohsool May 08 '17
What made Reddit such a fun and unique experience was the different CSS on each subreddit D:
2
4
3
2
u/Duhhhrew Apr 23 '17
From a CS nerd's perspective, I believe they would mainly do this to cut costs in their servers. Every CSS statement must be stored on their system and if there is currently no limit on CSS for subreddit admins they can essentially just store any data through CSS for their own benefit. This is highly unlikely, but there is a lot of expense in allowing a global, free, platform to practice CSS. In my opinion, if cost is the issue, they should compromise and simply set a limit, because the majority of subreddits do not use an excessive amount of CSS programming beyond what already threaded into reddit. Although it could just be AD politics as well. Who knows, but that is going to kill a lot of reddit's appeal for new users who don't understand the platform. The CSS "eye candy" certainly helps people come back for more. Otherwise its like 4 chan, dull.
11
u/ex1-7 Apr 23 '17
i am a little skeptical of this theory. the reason being that text content has a tiny footprint compared to images, and reddit even self-hosts images now. Besides, if people were really using CSS as a way to store secret data, the mods would be able to tell who because they have sysadmins and stuff.
6
u/blueskin Apr 23 '17
Yeah, they have no idea what they are talking about. CSS' overhead is absolutely trivial in the grand scale of things.
9
u/TheRealCopperfoil Apr 23 '17
For what it's worth, there apparently is a 100Kb limit to CSS designs. At least according to this.
There is a 100kb limit on your stylesheet. If you go over the limit, a css minifier as well as manual streamlining is recommended.
I feel like they even lowered it a few months back. I remember a bunch of designers complaining that they had to go through and cut out a bunch of stuff/doing complete rewrites. But maybe I'm miss-remembering something else.
6
u/blueskin Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
From a sysadmin who works on high availability sites/APIs at scale (admittedly not Reddit's scale, but probably more than most people's): Total and utter bullshit. I'm fucking terrible at writing CSS and willingly admit that, but I know how to efficiently get content out to endpoints, and CSS is not a problem.
CSS can be minified; reddit uses AWS so hosting and CDN costs are relatively low, and if they were really worried about them, they could just stick it behind Cloudflare and make it even lower with caching.
1
1
1
1
1
May 01 '17
I've been thinking about hanging up Reddit for a while but I think this would draw the line. Goes completely against the users of this site
1
u/little_l0relei May 01 '17
I want to help with this but I'm too high to know how. Can someone walk me through?
1
1
1
u/GoingRaid May 09 '17
It's not surpising this is happening to us. considering that microsoft thought it would be an awesome idea to overlay their operating system with that bright button cellphone widget "App" bullshit. say good bye to PC functionality as we know it.
1
1
u/AustinReiver May 10 '17
I don't understand the big deal this is such a funky post. Why are people so angry about losing CSS anyway? I honestly can't tell rn, I'm just so lit rn, I feel like I'm underwater but Im not sure, Why am I typing so slow right now or is it time really moving backwards as my fingers move forward I cant tell
694
u/KarniAsadah Apr 22 '17
Why would they do that..