r/listentothis • reddit • Mar 22 '17

Follows - Soulkeeper [Post-Rock/Dreampop/Shoegaze] (2015)

https://youtu.be/4xmfdkxXwlM
384 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

20

u/hiigaran Mar 22 '17

I've got to be honest, I love Post-Rock and shoegaze but this song came across as a caricature of those genres... like if somebody took Explosions in the Sky, Mum and Sigur Ros and decided to mash them all together, but with none of the pathos. I can't put my finger on why it rubbed me the wrong way but it just does not work.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Both genres can be extremely generic, this one just felt like a pairing up of all those generic aspects. It works, it's just not particularly interesting.

1

u/thanthenpatrol Mar 23 '17

It's not a good song. The lyrics are lousy.

3

u/dingle_dingle_dingle Mar 22 '17

Same, I feel like it would be better without the vocals but its still pretty generic sounding.

Other than the bands mentioned who are you digging right now?

2

u/Quetzal42 Mar 23 '17

If you want to hear a pretty good mixture of post rock and shoegaze, try Klimt 1918's album from last year:

https://youtu.be/zoSUiCPzDy4

https://youtu.be/h2GZkm6v0lQ

3

u/firakasha Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

I honestly thought the first 15 or seconds was just a sample of a [MONO](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mono_(Japanese_band)) song before the chords went a different way, and I kept hearing just pieces of other post-rock/shoegaze songs all throughout. They are definitely playing it safe within the boundaries of the genres.

EDIT: I don't know how to make wikipedia links that end in parentheses work? /u/feedthecollapse is a boss

3

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

I don't know how to make wikipedia links that end in parentheses work?

put a \ before the last parenthesis in the url:

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mono_(Japanese_band\)

[mono](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mono_(Japanese_band))

1

u/Kansoku Mar 22 '17

To me it sounds like a worse version of Back to my place by Tokyo Shoegazer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dw_lsHjH6X8

1

u/ThrivingDiabetic Mar 22 '17

It totally reminded me of Slowdive. Pretty much any song by Slowdive. But it was beautiful.

1

u/Grantonator Mar 22 '17

I would like to hear this artist do music for a TV show.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

[deleted]

21

u/gratinne moderator / spotify Mar 22 '17

This is the music version of "get off my lawn." From Wikipedia:

Post-rock

Dreampop

Shoegaze

18

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

You are doing nothing new. At best, you are mimicking stuff made in the 80s and 90s.

No one is claiming otherwise. All those genres date back to the 80s. They also aren't super obscure terms either.

The song in question is pretty generic, but yeah it is pretty much all of those genres.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Sounds like it adequately described what the it sounded like. I dont see the problem

6

u/JukeboxKid Mar 22 '17

A lot of music is hard to put in a single genre dude. It's not like every song comes slapped with a tag on it that says "this is dream pop" or whatever

15

u/ottervswolf Mar 22 '17

R/iamverysmart

11

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

more like /r/OutOfTheLoop if they think these are at all new terms.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

[deleted]

3

u/WhyJustOne Mar 22 '17

I know I'm late and I kind of get what you're feeling, so let me try and help make some sense of the situation.

Post-Rock: This is the term for a movement that sprung up in the late '80s and '90s where a large group of Experimental Rock artists tried playing around with Rock conventions like riffing, soloing and general song structure, and most importantly (IMHO), influenced each other. Some of these works are considered by a lot of people to be the greatest '90s Rock albums (merely opinions of course, but I feel the same). But sometime during the mid-'90s or so, they began streamlining their stuff so much that it was widely regarded as a genre of sorts. Eschewing riffs in favour of lines and solos taking on a more exploratory aspect with regard to sonic texture became the norm, and a convention was more or less established, with crescendos being the most popular dynamic. Some people say that this way, the music lost its way and grew less experimental. This is the reason why people speak of "waves" in Post-Rock, as in "First Wave", "Second Wave" and so on.

Shoegaze: This one also has to do with texture. Another group of bands embraced the whole "Wall of Sound" aesthetic that was used successfully in a lot of works before, and built a style around it and lots of effects on the instruments involved. The artists often performed live gazing introspectively at the processors at their feet, which gave rise to the term "Shoegazing".

Dream-Pop: Not really familiar with this one except for a few Cocteau Twins albums. But as it suggests, the term indicates the presence of ethereal melodies and a generally oneiric ambience.

Not really a fan of Post-Rock music these days, but at least technically, the artist in question mostly fits the part for all three "genres", but I can't say their stuff is in the same spirit as that of their predecessors.

Hope this helped.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

I'm like 99% sure the guy you're talking to isn't at all interested in how the terms are defined; same goes for anyone whining about genres names: it's nothing more than proud ignorance.

That said, it should be noted that Dream Pop was the original term for Shoegaze, with the latter taking over as it fell out of critical favor. Dream Pop being considered separate from shoegaze is a very recent thing.

1

u/ThrivingDiabetic Mar 22 '17

Dude you need a hug or something. Relax.

Shoegazer has been around since 1990. Just because you haven't heard of it and [insert random, grumpiness-inspired significant statistic here]% of people haven't either doesn't mean it doesn't exist and doesn't mean you're a dummy.

If you don't like it no sweat - move on. All my favorite bands are in this genre: Slowdive, Catherine Wheel, My Bloody Valentine, Ride, Swervedriver... some good stuff in there.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

I'm with you. I have never heard of dreampop or showgazing at all and I think I listen to a good mix of music.