r/GlobalOffensive • u/mbCARMAC ESL Official • Mar 01 '17
IEM Katowice Live Thread
Hey! Leave comments here on things you like and want more of! Leave comments here on hiccups you think we don't see.
If I don't get it fixed, at the very least I'll explain what the issue is. Have a beautiful day everyone!
EDIT: The first matches were delayed due to our lights agency making changes to the lights setup that the tournament area crew did not know about. The lights cables were found to interfere with the sound on TeamSpeak + stole a bit of power from coach PCs. We should have caught that something was changed and re-tested things again - that bit's on us.
24
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
and midround ad potato. how the FUCK do you keep doing it
9
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Not sure what happened there, but I am making sure it's not happening again.
13
u/calibraka Mar 01 '17
You know you are making sure this doesn't happen again last few events. Not even once per event. How?
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Changing processes and communication internally. It's not a switch to flip, unfortunately.
5
8
Mar 01 '17
Nice, got twitch ads mid round when score 11-2. Fantastic
5
8
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
credit where credit is due, the slow-mo replays with sound are very nice.
5
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Thanks. Glad someone's noticing what we have improved.
2
u/boconnell3333 valeria Mar 01 '17
Ay. Keep up good work. Ik it's kinda tough when all u have to hear all day is how ESL fucked up, but problems aside, I have been to ur guys events, and they are still a ton of fun, and I really enjoy watching streams as well. Ty for all u guys do, even if it's not perfect.
2
6
6
5
Mar 01 '17
I like how the B stream says "We'll be back soon" even though they were never here to begin with
2
4
4
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
Carmac I envy you for your thick skin, elephants ain't got shit on you. 30 minutes in and one match was delayed 10 minutes and dropped caster audio, the other match hasn't even started - I don't know how your team does it, but it's hard to stomach as a spectator of a lot of your LoL and CS events. And I believe with teams' announcements to choose their events more carefully ESL will start losing out when better running tournaments are chosen over yours. I hope it happens and ESL picks up their game for the better of all players and spectators.
3
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
People are expecting good entertainment (cue sarcastic comment that they don't) and if they're frustrated, it's most of the time for correct reasons. They voice their frustrations in many ways. I don't take the tone personally and try to work with the underlying message.
Unfortunately you are right, our starts are not smooth enough. I have reason to believe this will be a very good show overall, though.
4
3
3
u/ThomDeniz dAT Team Fan Mar 01 '17
I thought you said your events would be better?
0
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
In many ways there already are, but whenever we make an error it sure doesn't seem like we've improved.
7
Mar 01 '17
How about an explanation for why there are so many more mistakes at ESL events than any other? Just in the first game there were delays, no caster audio, and ads playing mid round. It's crazy.
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
It's complex on an individual level, but comes down to one general thing. Probably not having a buffer for what we want to achieve, so when issues occur (and every event has problem-solving), they stretch the crew. Things are usually not major and get ironed out, but that's just not good enough of course.
3
u/KungFuPuff Mar 01 '17
With working with so many different crews around the world do you hold the company you are working with accountable? The only way to expect change is to affect change. Hitting someones bottom line is usually an effective way. I know these hiccups hit your bottom line.
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Yes, we hold partners accountable. This time the delay came from a lack of communication from a third party to us, but WE should have caught it.
2
u/always_salty valeria Mar 01 '17
Yet you do nothing useful about it, considering that many of these problems have been happening at ESL events more so than most other events for YEARS.
We constantly hear "we will work on it", "this is unacceptable" and "we didn't do good enough" from people like Ulrich on Twitter, yet literally NOTHING gets done about it. And if something gets done about it then it's worthless because it doesn't change one bit.
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
We are, but we're a large company and introducing new processes isn't immediate in a structure of this size. Are we quick enough in introducing those? Doesn't feel that way to me personally, so I can see how it seems like it's in a standstill.
0
Mar 01 '17
[deleted]
-1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
I understand what you feel. Most of the stuff we have (at least at IEM events) is about processes and how we communicate with each other, and the fact that we have a lot of people who are not normally in the core crew. We had to introduce processes to handle that, but with our size the change isn't immediate, which sucks. I will post what the issue was this morning in the other threads where reddit is having a field day, as well as the OP.
2
u/seimonator Mar 01 '17
Astralis game one hour delayed?
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
It's live now on the B stream.
2
u/seimonator Mar 01 '17
But why was it late?
3
u/Celestetc Liquid Mar 01 '17
Apparently mics between players and coaches weren't working.
-1
u/seimonator Mar 01 '17
And why is this not tested before the event?
5
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
You can bet it was tested, but tech failures happen. They shouldn't and they happen too often at ESL events atm. but that's how it is
1
u/aselwyn1 fnatic Mar 01 '17
ESL is the only event that tends to travel more then anyone turner's eleague is all done in house in studios not in arena's that they go to once a year
2
Mar 01 '17
I like the colours you have on the mainstream, makes it look very nice. But the B stream has quite significantly better quality. Any possibility to get the main stream upped?
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
I will flag this to production but I'm not nearly technical enough to tell you yes or no.
2
u/Ulmali Mar 01 '17
If you could refer your server admins for this article it would be good. This explains how you can limit player amount in the teams so cases like Olof & JW joining wrong server midgame wont happen again.
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Thanks, passed on. Not sure what happened and why since I know nothing about CS servers.
1
u/Ulmali Mar 01 '17
It seems just that some of admins gave the players wrong server to join and they joined mid round to the other game. But doing the limit that the site explains how to do it prevents this from happening, they can still connect to the server but cannot join to the teams as they are limited to 5 players if your admins follow the article. Coaches still can join to their teams etc normally.
1
34
u/PUGChamp- de_nuke Mar 01 '17
I just got an advertisement during a 1v1 in the last round of the first half on Nip vs FNC
11
10
u/polskanumberone Mar 01 '17
Are you guys able to stream at 1080p? I'm interested in the reasoning why not
-10
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
restriction from twitch's side except for very few special partner events
4
u/chemo-GER Mar 01 '17
Shouldn't a big company like esl be able to get one of those "very few special partners"?
-5
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
It's not about company size. Twitch just can't handle the bandwidth usually so I guess the cases where they enable it are hand picked and above the importance of a IEM. I would have to speculate on what the exact conditions are but fact of the matter is it's extremely rare.
5
0
Mar 01 '17
[deleted]
4
Mar 01 '17
1080p 60fps was also available on many many other streams, even for the Yogscast Christmas Charity streams... people telling me ESL can't get 1080p 60fps and a christmas charity stream can? Okay then.
0
Mar 01 '17
[deleted]
2
Mar 01 '17
Probably not, but if you're gonna offer this service why not have the ability to support it.
"oh you're a big company with lots of viewers and we have this awesome streaming ability to do 1080p 60fps but because you're so popular, you can't have it..." Either that or they're charging ESL to use it and they wont pay for it?
4
u/Kambhela de_train Mar 01 '17
There is no restriction for 1080p streaming from Twitch.
Bitrate is restricted for non partners but ESL is partnered so that is not an issue.
0
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
If bitrate weren't a limiting factor even for partners don't you think it would be offered?
2
u/Kambhela de_train Mar 01 '17
But that was not the question.
Also, the bitrate limit for non partners is 3500, partners by default are not limited. According to this discussion in reddit there has not been a case where stream was even taken down for fucking around with bitrates.
Also big events get special access, this was what the big fuss was about during the Eleague major because Twitch was not the limiting factor for 1080p 60 FPS but the equipment that Eleague used.
1
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
Yeah I just stumbled upon that link too. I honestly don't know the reason then but I think LCS e.g. don't offer 1080p either, at least not 60fps, so there seems to be some motivation to not go all out on the bitrates?
1
u/Kambhela de_train Mar 01 '17
Certainly there is something, my best guess would be that they know that not enough viewers are able to consume at such high quality and that something like 720p60fps is good enough and does not require even remotely the level of resources that 1080p60fps does.
1
u/polskanumberone Mar 01 '17
Are you sure? IIRC, any streams which allow custom resolution selection are partnered and ESL_CSGO allows u to choose resolution/fps.
0
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
I'm 100% on this because it comes up very often. You can pick quality pretty much everywhere, that's what I meant by special partnered events (Only one I can think off of the top of my head is lol worlds). I believe the reason is that the datarate is capped, and usually people already complain about a too low bitrate for the 720p stream.
1
u/polskanumberone Mar 01 '17
The esl_csgob channel is partnered with twitch but you can't select custom resolution...
0
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
Like I said, very different levels of special. Don't hang yourself up on the terminology, All that matters is that a bitrate high enough for a 1080p stream is almost nonexistant on twitch
0
u/MrRoyce FaZe Mar 01 '17
You shouldn't spread misinformation like that, it's not right...
1
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
feel free to correct me, nobody came up with a more precise explanation yet
1
u/Eltitia Mar 01 '17
Hey guys, is there any stream with team coms?
6
2
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
Teams don't want their ingame communication heard so no.
1
u/Eltitia Mar 01 '17
I recall watching some matches with team comms on it, did they end it or is it for other tournaments?
2
u/Celestetc Liquid Mar 01 '17
They ended up around 1-2 years ago. Maybe smaller tournaments will have it but not the big ones with the top teams.
1
u/spotzel King NiKo Mar 01 '17
Teams were vocal since then that they don't want their comms heard so there haven't been any comm streams since, no matter what tournament.
1
Mar 01 '17
Do you have a YouTube stream? You DMCA'd the only one I found (fair enough) but YouTube works better on my shitty temporary connection since I can pause and let it buffer for a bit.
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Try Facebook / Twitter. There won't be YouTube for this event.
1
1
1
u/weirdoone NiP Mar 01 '17
Anyone know if entry into the arena is free just as previous years? (didnt get tickets in time). Can you just wait long queue and get inside even without tickets? If so, what are you allowed to enter then. Would appreciate if anyone could give me some info
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Yes, it's free. Yes, you can come in on a first come first serve basis.
1
u/weirdoone NiP Mar 01 '17
Thank you for the info. Are some areas restricted for the non-ticket guests ?
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Please note that the queue is pretty large!
1
u/weirdoone NiP Mar 01 '17
Counting with that. How long is it expected to wait (saturday/sunday). Any estimate ? Should we bring little folding chairs ? :D
1
1
1
1
u/Scortyx Mar 01 '17
The last many pistol rounds u cut into it at like 40 seconds late, its fucking annoying, stop it.
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
I will flag that to production, sorry.
1
u/Scortyx Mar 01 '17
It was the first couple matches today, havent happened since. But still
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Yeah, I get that it's annoying. I apologize.
2
u/2poundWheel Mar 01 '17
Thanks for being so professional and taking all this heat yourself, Carmac.
I've been scrolling through this thread of people calling you a shithead and a terrible TO, but you're handling it well, good on you. <3
1
u/EGSurvivor MOUZ Mar 01 '17
Why dont you start the Faze-Nip game instead of letting everyone wait for IMT-Optic to finish? Just brings more delays...
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
League Operations team handles that. I was in a 3 hour meeting, so I don't know the reasoning. Ordinarily what they do is very logical so I'm pretty sure there were good reasons.
2
u/EGSurvivor MOUZ Mar 01 '17
alright, thanks for the answer. hope your production are here tomorrow big
2
1
1
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 01 '17
Can we just make a new thread called fuck the ad guy? I almost feel bad for the man
4
1
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 01 '17
Would be very interested to know what Kjaebye was referancing when he mentioned that you can take a percentage of their prize money? Whats the rule here?
2
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Penalty points for breaking rules convert into a prize % deduction that gets put back into prize money split between the teams that had no penalty points iirc.
3
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 01 '17
Seems fair in general, is that not a pretty harsh ruling when ur asking someone to sit silently for 2 hours?
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
I wasn't there so I don't know if they were not allowed to talk, but yes, I would say it's harsh. Especially that the reason they wait isn't gameplay-related.
3
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 01 '17
Ive got to ask, why are u doing this. Feels like alot of ur answers are just 'I wasnt there' or 'Its nothing to do with me'.
I dont doubt that ur telling the thruth but you might not be the man to represent ESL.
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
The entire project is quite sprawled out both in terms of the things that get done and physical location. Impossible to know everything and be everywhere without doing everyone's job.
1
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 02 '17
Fair point, and dont get me wrong i think its great that you are here. Would be nice if there were more staff online to also help with questions.
1
u/dOnToN- Mar 01 '17
If you watched Dreamhack Las Vegas they had a moviemaker/editor that made a short highlight reel of the day before/same day. It gave a nice update and looked really professional. Do you have that in mind for the next upcoming events? p.s i love you
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Thanks for loving me. I am not sure what's planned by the content team, but for sure a moviemaker is coming. Just not sure what intervals we want to pump content out at.
1
1
u/aselwyn1 fnatic Mar 01 '17
Can we get a full list of music used in the event? other than just the theme for this year
1
3
u/MeatHook96 Natus Vincere Mar 01 '17
Can you guys please hire someone to do the camera work on the B stream Triple OT 2nd round out of the 8 kills we get to see only 1.
How is this even acceptable? You're running just a big event and no observers for B stream, not to mention its been 4 hours and only the 2 game is going on.
Delays are crushing the viewership experience.
Time and time again you guys know how to fuck it up every event.
12
u/Smurflll Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
Delayed matches
Mics not working
ad midround
Admins not knowing how to do their work
Overall bad production
Tec pauses all game long (Astralis-Optic) - One big failure
Cable failure in games
Wrong informations bottom line
Wrong pictures of teams
Seems like you haven't learned anything over the past 2 years. Just another fiasco for ESL, sadly.
2
u/engineno2 BIG Mar 01 '17
+1 sad to see they are just pretending to give a fuck and lie to the spetators after almost every event. never saw any real kind of improvement. they are so abdly organized as well i guess. just watched the immortals vs faze hltv and differnt teams kept joining and leaving, which kind of implies the players have no real clue what servers to play on. even on local lans with bigger brackets and 6 teams playing at the same time i didnt encounter such nonsense..
1
Mar 01 '17
From (one of) the biggest and best funded event organisers at a venue they frequent i expect emaculate production. This seems very disapointing.
1
u/Lacore 10 years coin Mar 01 '17
a youtube stream please... My internet is not really good but with youtube i can just delay with HD
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
Sorry, won't happen for this event. Twitter and Facebook should have streams.
7
u/shallza G2 Mar 01 '17
Classic ESL this far: Delay and casters muted Industry Leader 4HEAD
2
1
6
u/Kambhela de_train Mar 01 '17
I'd love for ESL to actually learn from their mistakes.
We are less than halfway into the first match and everything so far points to the direction of this being another ESL fiasco.
I doubt you guys are so much behind other events in terms of skill of staff or equipment that it can be explained that same stuff goes on from event to event.
2
0
0
1
u/viktorlogi Mar 01 '17
The caster's mics are muted on the main stream right now. There's just the game sounds.
2
1
1
1
u/General_Scipio FaZe Mar 01 '17
I really like running 2 streams at the same time, however the B stream is really low quality. I dont expect a full studio and an analysis desk but this is still a huge LAN, should be better than 2 guys sitting there using auto director.
1
-2
0
Mar 01 '17
[deleted]
1
u/mbCARMAC ESL Official Mar 01 '17
I will see what we can do here. I had little visibility on how that was arranged but I will talk to the right people.
2
34
u/machine- Caster, Desk Host - Machine Mar 01 '17
Can the green room please have a lifetime supply of this polish mayo?
THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE