r/swtor • u/Jedipedia Database site: swtor.jedipedia.net • Sep 09 '16
Datamining Comprehensive list of 5.0 Class Changes
https://swtor.jedipedia.net/en/news/5-0-class-changes71
Sep 09 '16
Force Lightning removed from Sith Assassin
...
→ More replies (6)10
u/vale93kotor Sep 09 '16
Really makes me sad, hope the replacement will be decent... Don't have much hope knowing BW though
15
Sep 09 '16
I don't think there's going to be a replacement. If you watched the video, the guys who were going through the changes said that with these changes, BW is -probably- aiming to further distinguish advanced classes between each other (Sorc from Sin, for example, or Jugg from Mara).
That's why melee classes lose their ranged abilities, and vice versa.
20
Sep 09 '16
then they better change our stupid ass looking abilities that mimic sorcs like creeping terror. Hatred assassins look like a sorc who didn't study well in school, so dropped out to join assassin school, but sucked at that to.
→ More replies (5)6
u/bstr413 Star Forge Sep 09 '16
I don't think there's going to be a replacement.
There is a replacement for Deprecating Volts, which was the version of Force Lightning that Sins used. Using Force Lightning on a DPS Sins was mostly useless past a certain level.
→ More replies (1)9
u/chiruochiba Sep 10 '16
I'd hate losing Depredating Volts. That's the main iconic ability for 'Sin tanks, and timing it correctly to build stacks is a large portion of the Darkness skill cap. This just looks like we are being reduced to the level of Jug tanks who spam their rotational abilities on cooldown.
→ More replies (2)
22
Sep 09 '16
That UI is one of the most beautiful things that I've ever seen, very clean and organized, very easy to read and user friendly. Nice site and well done!
Sucks to see that this expac Assassins will be taking a backseat competitively, but we shall prevail.
→ More replies (6)
19
45
u/Nitia Progenitor Sep 09 '16
It's pretty insane how much effort you guys put into this. The mining, formatting all that info into a very concise and readable list, organizing the podcast.
You're doing such a big job for this community, thank you!
10
u/FlavivsAetivs Eudoxia ~ Revert Back to 6.X Sep 09 '16
Seconded.^
Can't say the same for Bioware. Especially with some of these changes...
~ Eudoxia
→ More replies (1)
31
15
Sep 09 '16
60-second droid mezes have been removed from Agents/Smugglers and Marauders/Sentinels. Droids (and other NPCs) can still be mezed with the mezes from Sorcerers/Sages and Mercenaries/Commandos.
This makes me so unhappy :(
8
1
u/TheAtomicOption Sep 11 '16
I'm just weirded out by the whole droid/not-droid mez thing to begin with. In all content that's not operations, you rarely have one of each class in either your group or the pack of mobs, so the difficulty of mob packs varies wildly because sometimes you can mez stuff, and other times you can't.
→ More replies (2)1
u/ricojes Sep 11 '16
Now Slingers get to shoot droids in their dicks... mecha dicks... whatever those are.
70
u/ghouldrool Sep 09 '16
There's class balancing... and then there's going 'BWAAARRRGGH' once a year.
17
Sep 10 '16
3
u/Otylo Sep 10 '16
I have not much faith in bioware tbh, I was very patient, but I saw them do so many screwups this year. It is like they do not understand us players at all, and neither how their game works with classes and what we like. Lets not begin about all the bugs that still exists in this game for years.....
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)4
u/Kadmeia Sep 10 '16
I've never had much faith in Bioware's ability to balance their classes. Now that little bit of faith has just been completely obliterated. Absolutely incompetent. I can only hope many of these changes won't make it to the final 5.0.
12
u/VuffyPulva Harbinger Sep 09 '16
Blackout has been merged into stealth.
Well then, that completely changes how Deception plays.
→ More replies (2)
21
u/lyranSE Sep 09 '16
60-second droid mezes have been removed from Agents/Smugglers
WTF the whole point of this skill is because sleep dart doesn't work on droids. Is sleep dart going to be buffed to work on droids to compensate?
0
Sep 09 '16
[deleted]
10
u/Thybro Sep 09 '16
But their intimidating roar ability got the portion where is say it doesn't work on droids removed. So I'm thinking all stuns/mezzes work on droids now. Which is why slice wasn't needed.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/masonicone Sep 09 '16
So my Sniper can throw knives, my Gunslinger shoots people in the dick, and now Calaculated/Hot Pursuit lets me use Snipe/Charged Burst a few times when moving?
I can live with this.
5
u/Murrlan Star Forge Sep 09 '16
my Gunslinger shoots people in the dick
This literally made me lol...at work...
16
u/this_swtor_guy Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Honest question: how does it make sense for Phase Walk to be removed from Shadows/Assassins but kept on Sages/Sorcerers?
The ability being added on the latter was always strange to begin with, given that they aren't a stealth class. Phase Walk was very useful for tanking and sometimes for DPS as well in PVE for Shadows and Assassins. It's more generally a PVP ability, but even then Sages/Sorcerers certainly don't need it any more than Shadows/Assassins, and arguably less.
Also: why remove droid CCing from the game? As I glance over the changes globally, I can't help but think many changes are being made for the dumbest possible player. Yes, it's not good when you come across a level 65 with a healing cell activated on their DPS Merc, but it also helps that player learn a thing or two about reading over their abilities after it's pointed out and, hopefully, makes them a better player afterwards. If the player can't actually read or understand a tool-tip, I'm not sure BW is doing them any favors with these changes.
→ More replies (5)
22
Sep 09 '16
I really don't like that we can't stun/slice droids. It was something that brought variety to the classes.
It certainly was useful in HM SnV when your breaching the city. :)
→ More replies (2)10
u/chiruochiba Sep 10 '16
I don't even understand the rationale for removing it. The CC certainly wasn't hurting class balance, and if anything it made Sniper/Mara slightly less pigeon holed into tunnel vision dps.
3
u/DoubleCheddar Sep 11 '16
It's simple. They want people to fight trash mobs vs skipping. Look at KOTFE you literally had 10% story, 5% boss fight, 50% travel 40% trash mobs to kill. By making content with long drawn out walks and mobs to kill every 10 feet they manipulate you into thinking you got an hours worth of content in a new chapter. In reality you got like 15 minutes of story and boss fight and 45 minutes of bull crap filler. That's like a steak that's 75% fat 25% meat. As long as people buy their now monthly packs that use to be every 2-3 months they'll keep shoveling this crap down our throats.
37
u/Lagao Cipher Nine(Star Forge) Sep 09 '16
Ah yes. Fuck operatives. Fuck you bioware.
12
u/this_swtor_guy Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Isn't it a given with every single expansion and balance update?
And no (half way decent) AOE ability was added, which was the only thing I was hoping for, for Operatives and Scoundrels.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Lagao Cipher Nine(Star Forge) Sep 09 '16
I think they should revert operatives back to 1.0.
Who's with me?
→ More replies (1)5
5
→ More replies (1)1
u/Lundorff Sep 09 '16
What makes you say that? What nerf am I missing?
4
u/PrincessPoopiePants Ebon Hawk Sep 09 '16
No nerf, they got a buff. Not a significant one, but it's fun to hate on operatives.
23
u/Yamirou Proud Altoholic - now 400% more Sage Sep 09 '16
They removed phase walk from sins/shadows? Who the hell thought it was a good idea o.o
And interesting what will happen to the toons leveled without an advanced class...
23
u/_Apostrophe_ Punctuation Legacy <Fortitude> Star Forge Sep 09 '16
They removed phase walk from sins/shadows? Who the hell thought it was a good idea o.o
The shitty part is: Sage/Sorcs get to keep it.
SO.... it was introduced as a Shadow/Sin ability. Became fairly integral as defining to the class.
Then they give it to Sage/Sorcs too.... ok... they didn't really NEED it, but sure... why not.
THEN - Take it away from the original class that had it?
dafuq?
11
Sep 09 '16
Blizzard did shit like this giving DK abilities to paladins, you eventually become numb to it.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Yamirou Proud Altoholic - now 400% more Sage Sep 09 '16
Yeah exactly, they gave it as part of expansion to sins/shadows so why why why suddenly take it away after years? It doesn't even make sense - supposedly they want to take away ranged abilities from melee (and they took every single one from sins/shadows) but they gave NEW ones (30 meters range!) to juggs/maras and they kept the old ones... what. Just what. Doesn't. Make. Sense.
4
u/CinderSkye Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
I had recently gotten the hang of when to selectively use Telekinetic Throw, too. I don't think I have ever been so disappointed by the class changes for an expansion.
There's efficacy and there's feel and they're destroying all the feel of a caster/melee hybrid. They could be making Jedi Shadow super effective numerically and I wouldn't care because they're destroying the feel.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)2
u/AbnerDoonAMoC Sep 09 '16
Agreed that was a good pull ability and it was a sin/shad only ability originally.
13
u/SpectresCreed Sep 09 '16
Mmm, having mixed feelings on this. I don't like losing Phase Walk as Shadow, but the changes to melee and ranged abilities based on melee and ranged classes is probably sensible.
I don't like the idea of picking the discipline at creation. There is a certain appeal to hitting level 10 and picking it. I always loved the build up to going to fleet and getting the quest to pick one.
3
u/flameofmiztli Sunfall Legacy | Star Forge Sep 09 '16
I dislike losing Phase Walk because it's a thematically nice thing to see a sin/shadow disappear and pop out of nowhere. Maybe make the tether to within 10m to keep the melee/melee-ish, but it's useful to be able to get back behind bosses or to have a quick pop in/out.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/Murrlan Star Forge Sep 09 '16
Now my Gunslinger can't kick people in the nuts anymore :(
10
u/brainfreeze91 Sep 09 '16
I mean, now you can shoot them there. And mechanically, it's a straight upgrade since it's a ranged stun now.
19
u/CharpShooter <Downfall> Harbinger Sep 09 '16
Yeah but it's mentally more satisfying to kick people in the nuts.
0
3
6
u/Nihux Sep 09 '16
I think it should be noted that the updated Phase Walk tooltip still reads as ''does not break stealth''.
I'm not convinced they're really taking it away from sins.
4
u/CinderSkye Sep 09 '16
Flipside: Harnessed Shadows still says it prevents pushback on TK Throw, and channeled abilities lost pushback a while ago.
2
6
u/guraqt2t The Blowhard Legacy Sep 09 '16
Actually looking forward to the direction they are going with these changes.
With that said, not a fan of:
-Removing 60sec droid stun from melee classes, when already-advantaged ranged classes get to keep theirs.
-Giving guard to dps specs, especially considering how overpowered classes like dps jugg/guardian are in pvp currently. Healer sorc/jugg combos in pvp will be more unbeatable than they are already.
-The brutal assassin/shadow nerfs. Removing phase walk and giving it exclusively to sorc/sages is a cruel joke. The nerf to dot sorcs is expected, but they have the advantage of applying and spreading dots from far away. Shadows/sins don't have that advantage, so this is a strong nerf to them.
Making melee classes more melee and ranged classes more ranged is a good idea, but they'll need to find a way to make melee classes more mobile...considering the fact that pvp is based almost entirely on stuns/roots/snares. Maybe just something small like turning the utility where you can use the new 4.0 abilities as a root-breaker into a passive and reducing the cooldown on them.
10
u/Jalian174 Secatil Sep 09 '16
Is 'blade barrage' at least as flashy as blade dance was? I feel like that was a hugely iconic ability for sents
2
u/evilbob2200 Sep 10 '16
Did they like change master strikes name or something?
2
u/Jalian174 Secatil Sep 10 '16
Master Strike was changed to Blade Dance last year, and it looks like its being renamed again, but also turned into an instant ability
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Astthengach Close-shave - Buff Strikes 💪 Sep 09 '16
Here's an idea - maybe they'll restore the CD on force speed for shadows and sins.
I need something... No way I'm rerolling merc.
3
u/FlavivsAetivs Eudoxia ~ Revert Back to 6.X Sep 09 '16
That would be great. Hopefully they'll realize the stupidity of taking Phase Walk away from us and give it back before 5.0 actually rolls out though.
→ More replies (3)
5
u/f_no_ Sep 09 '16
HOLY SMOKES!!!
OK Inquisitors and Consulars..... BW would like you to bite the curb now......
19
u/AlbViana Wentworth (Star Forge) Sep 09 '16
Ok Bioware, I got the message. Maybe it's time to change my class. Been playing my Shadow since 1.1 non-stop. The changes to Serenity are a joke hahahaha. The spec is already incredibly squishy and they are decreasing the damage on some core abilities. The whole class in general is losing situation stuff like mind crush in openers, telekinetic throw when out of range in pvp...and, rip phase walk.
3
Sep 09 '16
I'm sad. I mained a Sage for ages and just started getting into Serenity and other Shadows. Now both have been nerfed into oblivion.
→ More replies (4)1
u/vale93kotor Sep 09 '16
Same. Pretty sad, I will still try to play it for a few days when it drops and see how it is, but it seems like I'll need to switch =.=
1
u/alkanechain Sep 09 '16
I admittedly haven't played in a long time, but my Shadow tank was my first character and has been a tank since level 10. She's still one of my favorite characters I've ever had in an MMO, my little stealthy-tank-in-a-dress who effortlessly wove throwing rocks around telekinetically into her lightsaber-fighting, and it's painful to think she'll play totally differently if I ever decide to go back to the game.
9
u/Nitia Progenitor Sep 09 '16
Guard is no longer tied to the tanking stance and can now be used by DPS players as well.
Okay that's a rather unexpected one.
Keeping skank tanking alive even though they got rid of stances?
5
u/IngloriousBlaster Star Forge Sep 09 '16
That pretty much completely negates the need for tanks in PvP.
2
u/chiruochiba Sep 10 '16
But just think of all the Jug, PT, and Sin DPS who can't even remember to use their taunts in PvP. Do you think they'll have an easier time remembering to use their guard?
→ More replies (4)8
Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
I thought it was tied to the Tank Spec instead according to other posts. Maybe a typo as this doesn't make much sense but maybe it is right? I don't know.
Edit: According to the other post by Swtor Mango
"• Guard (Ability Change) Must be spec¡¯d as a Tank to use. Can no longer skank tank."
https://www.reddit.com/r/swtor/comments/51v5pr/50_empire_ability_changes_and_additions/
So one of these is correct.
→ More replies (1)4
u/pythonic_dude Mostly, retired sintank, aspiring paladin Sep 09 '16
Earlier post by mango is just pure data, a lot of stuff on jedipedia is vague speculation.
2
u/DelegateTOFN Sep 09 '16
Yeah, I also don't like this change. But the passive stances are a step in the right direction.
→ More replies (1)
9
Sep 09 '16
Ravage/Blade Dance has been turned into an instant ability.
What does it mean? No chaneled dmg over 3 seconds? It will burst now?
12
u/this_swtor_guy Sep 09 '16
I really hope the animation hasn't changed, though it's hard to imagine it won't be replaced. That was one of the best Knight/Warrior animations, and I have little faith that low-budget SWTOR can replace it adequately.
4
u/Lundurro Sep 09 '16
They could speed it up to a 1.5 second animation. If you were using berserk in carnage it's cast time got close to that and looked fine, if a little hectic.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Joe2030 Sep 09 '16
Stealthed players are now fully invisible, you can no longer see them even when you are right next to them.
No more funny tricks with stealthers... Also a huge buff to them.
3
4
u/Tefia <Zorz> | Operative Healer Sep 09 '16
A lot of stuff is missing from this than from the other post last night?
1
u/bstr413 Star Forge Sep 09 '16
They did do a patch to the Closed Beta since the weekend. This is still very highly subject to change.
4
u/Tefia <Zorz> | Operative Healer Sep 09 '16
There was actually no difference in patches from what other dataminers have been saying.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/SWTORHamster TORCommunity.com Sep 09 '16
So we forgot to include the Changed Talents in the post. Here's the raw data dump for anyone interested:
From 4.X PTS to 5.0 PTS #2: https://torcommunity.com/datamining/temp/ChangedTalents4to5.xml From 5.0 PTS #1 to 5.0 PTS #2: https://torcommunity.com/datamining/temp/ChangedTalents.xml
Corrects just a few small things here and there.
Cheers!
4
u/Sarguel Einherjar Sep 10 '16
They intend to nerf the Dps from Lightning sorcerer ?? Did I read that right ? Ha Ha Ha Ha
12
u/Kadmeia Sep 09 '16
So basically..nerf the shit out of Sorc and increase the damage of a skill you pretty much only use as a filler once in a while? Genius, Bioware. Chain Lightning damage nerfed by 6%? Holy shit..do you want us to be a DPS class or not? Just make up your fucking mind.
7
u/JaayRock <Nemesis> The Ebon Hawk Sep 09 '16
Goodbye Phase Walk, you will be missed.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/DomenicDenicola Draakas/Cece on Star Forge Sep 09 '16
So I heard sorcs got some utility/defense buffs, although I don't see them here... but it looks like they got a pretty uniform damage nerf, usually in the 4-10% range? That's pretty sad, given that lightning at least was already in the mid-bottom of the DPS charts.
2
u/HollowClown Sep 09 '16
I for one will be shelving my sorc completely now. Since Bioware doesn't seem to have any interest whatsoever in making them a viable DPS class, I'll just go mara again.
1
u/DerpineTOFN Sep 09 '16
the discipline changes for the sorcerer /sage for lightning/telekinetics are switched.
1
u/Jedipedia Database site: swtor.jedipedia.net Sep 09 '16
Thanks, we have fixed it. Operative section seems to be correct though.
1
u/DerpineTOFN Sep 09 '16
As well as with operative... If you head your section with imperial class/ republic class, make sure all changes to imperial classes are on the left side and vice versa.
1
Sep 10 '16
When do you plan to include sorc utilities? Thanks in advance.
2
u/Jedipedia Database site: swtor.jedipedia.net Sep 10 '16
We added them a few minutes ago. Republic-side equivalents will follow within the next hour!
1
u/Alortania The Tanky Tank Sep 10 '16
You guys are amazing! I do hope some of that doesn't make it past the test server though >_>
Thanks for this.
It's nice to see after hearing so much "game is on its last legs, no one even keeps the guides/mines updated anymore!" talk around the subreddit.
I know this might sound stupid, but any word if they'll be pushing Ops to cap or if they'll stay at 65 for a while (or the mechanics changed)?
Thanks again _^
1
u/Jedipedia Database site: swtor.jedipedia.net Sep 11 '16
Yes, ops will be at cap again. Similar to KotFE, SM will be for levels 50-70 and HM/NiM will be for 70 only. The loot is not in the files, so we don't know if it will use the same system as in KotFE (SM, HM and NiM/Priority HM) or a different one.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Senselesstaste Sep 09 '16
Im sad my sniper can no longer shiv. Perhaps not the best ability, but I always enjoyed finishing an enemy off with it if something in PvE survived to get that close.
4
7
u/QueenAlise Ebon Hawk Sep 09 '16
That's what is so wrong with these changes... too many of them affect the things that are FUN but not necessarily PRACTICAL.
It's also ridiculous to think that just because an agent is a sniper s/he doesn't know how to use a knife.
Sorry, really annoyed right now reading these changes. All I see is a bunch of things I enjoy about X class being yanked in order to cater to the lowest common denominators.
3
u/Senselesstaste Sep 10 '16
Yup, I agree. I can see 'why' they may have done it, but I don't agree with its removal. It was always a satisfying way to pick an enemy off and one of my favourite moves (visually) for my sniper.
3
u/AbnerDoonAMoC Sep 09 '16
So is blade dance/ravage just a 1 hit attack now?
8
u/SpectresCreed Sep 09 '16
Ugh that could suck if the animation is lame. Right now Ravage on a Mara is bad ass.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)1
Sep 09 '16
Still reads as 3 hits and you still have the 1.5s (or however long the GCD is) for the animation to play. i guess it'll look similar to the Mara's hasted ravage. Same animation but faster.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/MidasLoL Midas Legacy - Shadowlands Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Just want to point out that under sorc/sage, the Lighting and Teleknetics abilities are reversed.
Edit: Its apparently fixed as I read below.
3
3
Sep 09 '16
I wont even be so mad that they shit on hatred while giving deception a shiny new toy if they CHANGE THE GOD DAMN THRASH ANIMATION CAUSE IT'S ASS.
1
u/Huntozio Sep 10 '16
If reaping strike has a sick new animation i don't care about losing "2% dmg" on slow haha.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/The_Kwerty The Harbinger Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
I've done some work and have come to the conclusion that Pyro is going to have a new rotation come 5.0 thanks to the 1GCD Flamethrower allowing 9 sec Flaming Fists.
Old Rotation:
Scorch -> Incendiary Missile -> Flaming Fist -> Flamethrower -> Rail Shot -> Filler -> Immolate -> Flame Burst -> Flaming Fist -> Filler -> Incendiary Missile -> Filler -> Flamethrower -> Rail Shot -> Flaming Fist -> Immolate -> Flame Burst -> Filler -> Repeat
The new rotation however is more like AP, in that it has conflicting cooldowns. For now, ill seperate the even GCDs from the odd ones.
The odd GCDs (1/3/5/ect...) run on a cycle of
Scorch -> Incendiary Missile -> Searing Wave -> Immolate -> Rail Shot -> Filler -> Incendiary Missile -> Searing Wave -> Immolate -> Rail Shot -> Repeat
While the even GCDs (2/4/6/ect...) are
Flaming Fist -> Filler -> Filler -> Repeat
Filler being a rapid shots about half the time, but the free Flame Burst should be used in the earliest filler possible.
1
u/Huntozio Sep 10 '16
Hope pyro's sustained is clearly better than AP's finally. Also i desperately hope the new flamethrower attacks animation is really nice.
3
u/meatsiren Sep 10 '16
I guess my Sorc can just hold his lightsaber as a security blanket. Would make more sense at this point if he didn't have one.
4
u/Otylo Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
There are a lot of changes that are good. But removing all the non essential fun abilities, like Trash for sorcerer!!!.. :( That is BS. :S I understand they want to make it more clear to new players what abilties you should use. But by removing these fun abilties things get way more boring. I have so much fun sometimes when I play relaxed in a chilling way, to just only use my lightsaber as sorcerer/sage and kill a mob with Trash. I mean I like to have the imagination that sometimes my Lightsaber is usefull! And I am like Sidious or Yoda lol. Just like you said Meatsiren, why do we otherwise have that Weapon. This ruins all the fun. :( There is another LS ability being added to our current standard LS attack, but I rather want to see that they just keep Trash and other abilties like dirty kick for gunslingers and force lightning for assassins, just for the sake of fun! And then add in a way a system or a colour to abilties (with a clear simple guide in 5-10 words like: purple is for your class+rotation and red is for fun) (just like you have boxing with your fists) so it clearly indicates to new players what is what. In this example I said here, players can keep the fun abilties what are not very usefull, so bioware can add with ease new or better powers too. Anyways there are more ways to "Rome" I always say, but imo this is not at all the best option. Its just an easy way to clear up things imo. And to not use trash and other fun things is like... Hearthbreaking. Dont do it Bioware! If you read this! X) I really mean it. :(
15
Sep 09 '16
Thank you for the reminder of why I'm playing a different MMO now.
5
3
u/Cut-the-red-wire Shadowlands| Not the wire you're looking for Sep 10 '16
And to think I was considering coming back... this dumbing down is partly why I quit to begin with.
→ More replies (3)1
11
u/4armmara Sep 09 '16
Soo, much of the effort is making the game noob proof witch actually makes sense to where BW is bringing the game, the casuals.
10
Sep 09 '16
Casuals appreciate complexity and skillfullness just as much as the hardcore players, they just plan their game time after their own schedule freely rather than allow the game dictate it through regular ops/guild events or otherwise.
What they are designing the game for is the same as Blizzard does with WoW, the inept 10%.
4
u/4armmara Sep 09 '16
10%? From what I've seen around in the game I honestly think you're a little bit optimistic there.
→ More replies (1)2
Sep 10 '16
Only casual in the sense of skill, not time. MMOs want mass market appeal (cuz more moneyz) but MMOs are notoriously complex to play. So invariably you see "simplification" changes to get and keep the crowd who doesn't want to learn calculus to do a rotation (I'm kidding about calculus, but if you're new to MMOs, there really is quite a learning curve... it took me a solid year or two of concentrated learning to become what would be considered a "highly skilled player").
Then there's the learning curve for each new game as well.
→ More replies (2)
14
u/SionCognus Sep 09 '16
I know I'm going to get downvoted for eternity for saying this, but I don't care. The apparent systematic neutering of Sorcs here is just ridiculous. I'm fine with nerfing the clear pvp problem areas. Phasewalk, Corrupted Barrier, etc were too powerful and needing retuning. However, nerfing all of that damage is just ludicrous. I know they don't care about raiding anymore looking at this. The main problem with Sorcs was never the damage, it was the utility and survivability. Best solution must be to nerf both? Like why is this necessary? Also, Lightning again gets screwed with a useless passive. Why are they trying to force shock into the rotation with a 4 gcd window of usage that will not even be able to be capitalized upon with every CD use. I mean every single rotational Lightning and Madness ability was nerfed by at least 3%. Clearly they didn't care to think about the repercussions for raiding, but I guess I shouldn't be surprised. Not that I had much faith in Bioware's ability to balance before, but this is just mind boggling how ill conceived these changes are. Yes I know this isn't final, but I doubt that they will tune these back or nerf other classes. Let's not delude ourselves
10
u/Jushyfruit Malocath - Shadowlands Sep 09 '16
This is pretty much exactly how I feel about these changes as a lightning main. The last thing I was expecting was to read these changes and see all my abilities nerfed. The utility on a lightning sorc is great but nerfing the already mediocre DPS just shows they are purely balancing around PvP. It's just disheartening at this point but still won't stop me from continuing to play it over other classes. Let's just hope they fix recklessness with TB and revert a few of these proposed changes, might be the best we can hope for.
→ More replies (6)2
u/CharpShooter <Downfall> Harbinger Sep 09 '16
Yeah they must be balancing around pvp since Phase Walk wasn't removed from sorcs.
2
Sep 09 '16
I expect them to adjust the other classes in future PTS patches. Remember when almost all classes got their surge (+critical multiplier) nerfed across multiple patches? Everytime there is a new level cap they adjust numbers down.
3
u/CommunistLibertarian The Harbinger Sep 09 '16
Don't get upset about DPS numbers yet - or anything - this is early, unfinished information. Maybe you're new to early, datamined info, but things will change between now and launch, especially specific numbers.
6
Sep 09 '16
I CANNOT understand the removal of Phase Walk from assassins... An original assassin exclusive ability....
This is fucking atrocious, I simply do not understand the logic.
2
1
u/Huntozio Sep 10 '16
+1, sorcs should never have had it. Being able to teleport around a corner with off heals + range is complete bull.
9
Sep 09 '16
First the took away end game and MMO content.. Now they went and fucked every class up.. I still believe this is on purpose. I'm thinking a new game must be in the works.. They are chasing people away on purpose now.. These changes make zero sense... Unless you look at it from the above perspective..
→ More replies (2)12
4
5
Sep 09 '16
Thanks for all the work you guys did. Boy BW really wants DPS Sins to be as undesirable as possible in PvE.
2
u/this_swtor_guy Sep 09 '16
Agreed - though we'll have to see what PVE actually means in KotET. I was hoping Infiltration/Deception might get some kind of differentiation from its uses in PVP to make it better for PVE. This has always been a problem with the DPS specs in the AC, and looks as though BW didn't even try to fix them to be effective in both environments.
The changes in general read as though many are made to be balanced around PVP, which perhaps makes sense if there isn't really any new PVE content that requires effort. It's not like you can't play any spec you want and do well in chapter content and heroic weeklies.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Tiro1000 EH - Zedrich Altair, Black Guantlet Sep 09 '16
Oh god, I hope blade dance turning into blade barrage won't screw up my rotation...
2
u/bstr413 Star Forge Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
You will have an extra GCD to fill, since it used to be a 3 second move. Carnage
and Vengeancewill fill it with their new ability: the other 4 Disciplines will fill it with something else.2
u/IngloriousBlaster Star Forge Sep 09 '16
What new ability is Vengeance getting? the only one I saw was Hew and that's a Vicious Throw replacement
→ More replies (1)
2
Sep 09 '16
what exactly is a cosmetic change? They just changed the description?
1
u/bstr413 Star Forge Sep 09 '16
In most cases, yes. Usually the description changed due to a different change like removing stances.
However, a few of them I wouldn't categorize as "Cosmetic Changes," since they change the effects of the skill.
2
Sep 09 '16
REALLY hope this is like, phase 1, and that Phase 2 is adding new abilities to replace the ones they took.
2
Sep 09 '16
The other thread had something about force leap getting another use within 7.5 sec of using it, or taking 7.5s off the CD if not used. Did that not happen?
2
2
u/Nekinej Sep 09 '16
Interesting move to ditch base classes.
Dare we dream of death knight/demon hunter or even monk style additions to the roster?
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Blueshiftrecall | Honoured Air Breather | Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
Fantastic, really appreciate you guys putting so much effort into this :)
"We are still months away from KotET releasing" Is that an indication you guys know the actual release date?
1
2
2
u/farlas816 Sep 09 '16
Those bastards, first they make explosive round and HIB have 10m range and now they're removing sticky grenade? Why are they obsessed with ruining the Vanguard class?
2
2
Sep 10 '16
It looks like the idea is to make hybridization even less of a thing and go all the way to making advanced classes (and specializations) their own special role. I don't think it's a terrible idea, as long as future content is supportive of trinity gameplay.
I kinda hope it'll come with an option to swap advanced classes though. I can't imagine a new player enjoying the prospect of choosing an advanced class from level 1 and being stuck with it for the life of that character.
2
u/Haplo12345 Sep 10 '16
Hallelujah Blade Dance becomes an instant
What's up with every class losing their 60-sec droid CC though? That's gonna make it an absolute bitch to go through KoTFE content with the forced combat w/ droids every 5 steps.
2
u/Skeith_ PoT5 Sep 10 '16
Once a-fucking-gain, they fuck my sin right up the ass. Its been a goddamn trend since 1.7. I kno this is all subject to change, but this is bullshit. Im fucking done with this game. Not even worth finishing the DvL event anymore.
2
Sep 10 '16
Here's an HONEST question, i hope someone can shed a little light here. What are they hoping to achieve by nerfing OUR dps skills, and OUR heal skills?? Increase game difficulty? But a lvl 10 affection companion can literally storm you through main story today. Sure, we don't yet know if comps. will be nerfed as well, but WHY nerf US???
Edit: And it's not just some abilities, on SOME classes. No, EVERYTHING has been nerfed down and/or removed.
→ More replies (2)7
u/wiseposterior Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
This is Bioware's way of mitigating the stat creep that comes with increased levels and new tiers of gear. They nerf across the board base ability damage/heals at the start of an expansion to slightly below where you are at the end of the previous expansion and let you progress through new tiers of gear and levels to slightly above the previous dps/heal levels. This will be the third expansion in a row that they do this.
I'm guessing the big reason they are doing the across the board dps/heal nerfs again this time is to try to keep current PVE relevant for longer. They most likely will not have a great quantity of challenging PVE content at the start of 5.0, and they do not want to make HM/NiM ops faceroll easy through stat creep.
People who are upset over the inquisitor nerfs need to realize that it is not just them that are being nerfed. They are going to nerf everyone. This is just the 1st patch. Historically they balance inquisitors first then the other classes. Other base ability nerfs are coming.
2
u/issy_haatin Sep 10 '16
Reading that datamined stuff is like reading an april fools joke, heres to hoping they chabge stuff round a bit.
3
8
u/_Apostrophe_ Punctuation Legacy <Fortitude> Star Forge Sep 09 '16
I am fairly certain that a list of WORSE things they could have done.... doesn't exist.
→ More replies (8)
4
u/Beasthunt Too many to name Sep 09 '16
Jeesh. This reminds me of NGE derping.
3
u/ghouldrool Sep 10 '16
How do you even come up with launching an expansion with a level cap and instead of granting new, epic top tier abilities....you just take some old iconic abilities away! Buy our expansion for LESS abilities than you used to have! Happy levelling!! sigh
2
u/RaynSideways Sep 10 '16
Yeah, this post gave me fucking flashbacks. The last time a game got streamlined this hard, it died.
3
2
u/Low_On_Coffee Sep 09 '16
Thank you guys for this! As someone who always keybinds tank stance and guard on my DPS toons, I'm very excited about some of these changes. The idea of no more lowbies without advanced classes is also a true blessing. Lots to look forward to!
2
u/Lionflash Sep 09 '16
Hold the fuck up... they removed Take Cover and Crouch for Operatives and Scoundrels?
This actually really upsets me... :(
→ More replies (21)2
u/cheeseguy3412 Sep 09 '16
Yep, same here - I use that one out of every three encounters, sometimes more. Dropping into cover and sniping when things are too hot to go in is pretty much necessary, and the survivability boost potential is huge. Its pretty much required for my playstyle PVP... and the best / highest scoring PVP scoundrels I see make extreme use of this (Admittedly, I just recently got back to the game, but I have 3 gunslingers, 4 snipers, 3 agents and 3 scoundrels... all leveled through PVP.) - This will be a huge loss if it goes through.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/thebestaround999 Sep 09 '16
this is bullshit
they are taking three of the biggest professions with sorc, sin and ops and nerfing them. everyone loves those professions and they are weak already buff them!
→ More replies (5)
2
u/FlavivsAetivs Eudoxia ~ Revert Back to 6.X Sep 09 '16
15
u/sirkarrde Sep 09 '16
You really should just remove that signature macro. You're not Peter Mayhew and you already have your name in the flair.
~ sirkarrde
→ More replies (5)8
u/brainfreeze91 Sep 09 '16
I agree, it's not really necessary on Reddit, or at all nowadays. It's an old-internet thing.
~ Brainfreeze
--------------------------------------------"I don't like sand. It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere." -Annie Skywalker
7
u/4armmara Sep 09 '16
Indeed.
~4armmara
does so much damage in his marauder that people think it is a new class.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Marquess13 Traditional Jedi Robes Sep 09 '16
Any idea if they fixed Pooled Hatred being wasted on Shatter's dots?
1
1
Sep 09 '16 edited Sep 09 '16
sins lose an ability they use often, an ability they use sometimes, situationally, and sorcs lose...an ability they never use and likely dont have on their bar.
Seems fair.
edit* oh look, they even kept demolish. Glad they removed stuff that made us similar.
1
u/snk575 <Roughnecks, Ebon Hawk> Sep 10 '16
I'm really liking alot of the sniper changes. Don't really understand them getting rid of the droid CC though. And while i don't play my assassin alot, I really dislike the removal of force lightning from them. If they are aiming for melee classes only being melee then why give juggs a 30m force scream utility while taking away the 30m recklessness and force lightning itself? Also thank you for all your hard work guys. Its really appreciated!
2
Sep 10 '16
Yeah, the rest I mostly get (guard for dps aside), but removing the droid CC makes no damn sense, aren't agents supposed to be the bag of tricks class??
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/Tusnal Sep 10 '16
Why can't they make different abilities for sith and jedi!? As right now, it's the same thing, different sides.
1
u/Senselesstaste Sep 10 '16
Likely because that would be even harder to balance and take more time. All too likely BW Austin just wouldn't have the manpower to even do a half arsed job of balancing twice the amount of classes as they have now so the imp/pubs effectively mirror another instead and get renames.
1
1
1
u/Fanvarg Sep 10 '16
ITT: PVP FOTMs complaining they need to use effort next expac.
Never change mmo pvp community
1
1
1
u/IndifferentEmpathy TRE Sep 11 '16
So marauder changes... essentially obfuscate can become 6second 75% yellow damage reduction cooldown and by being in camo you can gain 48% melee ability buff to be used for something like furious strike. Damn, mara might be fun/obnoxious depending from perspective in the pvp now.
1
u/ProphetPX LEGENDARY since 2012 Sep 11 '16
Anyone else remember the "GOOD OLD DAYS" when Bioware just stuck to making D&D 2.0e games like Baldur's Gate, Icewind Dale; and KOTOR 1,2, etc... and USED to be WIDELY PRAISED for amazing games like that?
WHERE did ALL of THOSE SMART DEVS GO off to?
1
u/criches1984 Sep 12 '16
Damn PvP and the Sorc nerfs, my guild were discussing these changes Saturday and none of them thought outside of PvP that these nerfs were required in terms of PvE content.
1
u/Mirandel Sep 12 '16
I think that topic has to be pinned to the top - it's important and people has to know what ot expect from the future!
1
1
u/Ryssius20 Ylliarus Sep 15 '16
The fact they are removing base classes is insane... how will the original stories now unfold? What, will a Sith Assassin suddenly be able to play the Sith Warrior storyline? I really hope nothing of the sorts will happen.
Also, my apologies in advance, but thanks to whiny fucks from PVP Sorcs and Assassins get huge nerfs that, here it comes, NEVER WERE EVEN REMOTELY NECESSARY. They already did nothing in PVP and holding up against a Sith Juggernaut or Marauder is impossible. The whiny brats say Sorcs are OP? Hello have you seen Juggernauts and Marauders? What, will they keep on whining until Sorcs and Assassins do 1 damage? And I am sure even then the brats would whine because their precious stupid Juggernaut takes 1 damage.
It frustrates me so much that Bioware completely disregards the original player base and ONLY looks at the new players. What about the players that have been with you for years, Bioware you are literally throwing them away. They are dumbing down the game so much and I absolutely hate it. I used to love SWTOR and it was my favourite game of all time. Now they are completely ruining everything about it.
1
Sep 15 '16
More babying, more infantalisation, more simplification. Seriously, BioWare, what is wrong with you? Is this the kind of childishness we can expect from Andromeda as well? I tried to give this game a chance after 4.0 and remain disappointed with the huge hit gameplay took to make room for 'story' but now this?
This means it's time I find a new MMO and put the last EA product I was spending money on to bed. Hmmm.... a lot of my friends play Black Desert, I might have to invest my time and money in that instead.
1
u/BlastedInTheFace Sep 15 '16
That is not cool at all. Lets just nerf the shit out of my SI who is already weak as shit because of level sync.
1
1
u/aegisz Oct 23 '16
Also why is everyone surprised about them removing Phase Walk from SINS ? They ruined what was left of ranked arenas , since anyone who wanted to actually climb the rather rolled a sin..
Enuff is enuff
1
u/jedi_serenity Sep 09 '16
Thanks a lot for the work in mining this and writing it all up nicely!
Wonder how much of this will change.
If it's true that ACs are removed and you can't use base class abilities, I'll actually a little sad. Sometimes find utility in the base class abilities and like being able to build a bit of a hybrid toon for utility (not necessarily min-maxing performance). Hm. Ah well, we'll see how it actually plays.
So curious if there are more details on the Uprisings!
1
u/LethalTheCookie Sep 10 '16
I can't believe I say this, but I'm hyped for these changes. Too bad we don't get to ditch dinky pistol as PTs, but I guess it would have been awkward for the Vangs to lose their basic attack.
1
1
Sep 09 '16
PW removed from sin.. wtf? But no more Depredating Volts just breaks my heart.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/boredguy13 Sep 09 '16
WTF are they doing with tanks. They're adding/improving the dcd's of Jugs+Sins while nerfing PT's, this is the opposite of what should be happening.
1
u/Huntozio Sep 10 '16
PT's have been the best tanks for awhile, that is why. But overall the tanks are very well balanced.
2
u/boredguy13 Sep 10 '16
No, they were best tank in 3.0 because of hydraulic cheese on m+b and revan. m+b cheese went away with 4.0 and Revan is not the most relevant content anymore. Damage taken wise they're fine but too many fights where Sin or Jug can cheese a mechanic or survive better due to dcd's that taking a PT isn't optimal. They can easily clear every fight and all and the balance isn't bad now but widening the dcd gap makes 0 sense.
→ More replies (1)1
u/chiruochiba Sep 10 '16 edited Sep 10 '16
I had a double take when I saw the new utility options for Assassin. Used to be we had skills that were extremely useful in specific circumstances but were not general purpose (Deflection is for Melee/Ranged damage only, Force Shroud is for Force/Tech damage only.)
Deflection now, in addition to increasing Defense by 50%, also reflects 50% of all direct Force/Tech damage back at the attacker and reduces all Force/Tech damage done by all nearby targets by 12%. So Assassins basically stole an upgraded version of Jug's Saber Reflect and no longer need to understand damage types.
The new "Renewing Darkness" utility turns our in-combat stealth into a 20% HOT, essentially a bargain basement Kolto Overload.
The Shapeless Spirit utility now lets us take 30% less AoE damage! Remember the cheese of the Darkness/Deception hybrid on Brontes? I hope BioWare is prepared for NiM Brontes to be everyone's bitch now.
But! The most hilarious of all! Force Speed is now our best defensive cooldown, blowing all of our previous moves out of the water, because of a change to the Phasing Phantasm utility: "Force Speed grants Phasing Phantasm, causing you to absorb 60% of all incoming damage for the duration of Force Speed."
1
u/smiths22 Sep 10 '16
All these changes seem so pointless....why to bother when theres is 0 new endgame content (operations)....sigh
2
u/Haplo12345 Sep 10 '16
Awe already doesn't affect droids.