r/BitcoinMarkets • • Jul 21 '16

[PSA] Kraken Accounts Compromised, Funds Stolen

Earlier today I submitted a post on behalf of my brother, /u/ds720, that his Kraken account was compromised, and asked if anyone else was experiencing similar issues. Since then, not only have I come across another redditor experiencing the same issue, a few of my friends and I have also received the following email from Kraken:

Hi caesar0901,

We detected a suspicious login attempt on your Kraken account this morning. The attempt provided your username but either did not provide the correct password or failed second factor authentication. The pattern of attempts we have observed is indicative of a potential data breach at another service where you may have used the same username. If you have reused your Kraken password with any other services, please immediately change your password.

It is strongly advised that passwords not be reused across services, that two-factor authentication be enabled on your Kraken account, and that you make use of the Global Settings Lock feature.

More information on securing your account in our help center: https://support.kraken.com/hc/en-us/articles/201396837-What-can-I-do-to-make-my-Kraken-account-secure-

Any information you are able to provide to our support team as to the potential source of the compromised credentials would be extremely helpful. For example, you might have recently provided your password to someone impersonating a Kraken employee, opened a suspicious email attachment or installed new software from an untrusted source. Or, you might know that you use the same password with another service (likely in the Bitcoin ecosystem) which has suffered a data breach.

If you are reusing your Kraken password at other services, please take a moment to secure those accounts with a new password and two-factor authentication. You might also do a Google search for ‘Password Manager’ and evaluate some options such as LastPass, KeePass and 1Password, which will help you create and manage strong, unique passwords for each service.

The Kraken Team

There are a few things troubling about this situation and email:

  • We only received these emails at 4:30pm EST, roughly 10 hours after the security issue.

  • Under my username on the top right corner of Kraken's home page, it says "1 BAD LOGINS SINCE LAST LOGIN ON 01-23-16 21:13:32 +0000.", however, no further details of the potential security breach are readily available. Bitfinex and Poloniex, on the other hand, readily provide an audit of your login history under the security settings of the account. Although Bitfinex and Poloniex do not provide a history of bad login attempts in the audit (as far as I can tell after trying a bad password a couple of times), it would have been another useful clue as to who the perpetrator is and how s/he might have gained access to my brother's account. Neither of us use the same password on more than one site and make sure that they are sufficiently strong. Without a log of previous legitimate and illegitimate login attempts, we can't tell whether the perpetrator is attempting to brute force our accounts or how security was otherwise compromised on Kraken's end. If the perpetrator is brute forcing logins, how many attempts does Kraken allow before freezing the account (or do they freeze accounts after x many bad log in attempts?). Fortunately, Kraken includes IP addresses in their emails when withdrawals are requested or other account preferences are changed (we know my brother's account was compromised from IP address 201.140.110.78 located in Mexico; we're from NE US and do not use VPNs, proxies, or anything other than our home Internet connections); however, instead of asking users to manually confirm actions requested on their site via email, the emails simply inform the users of such actions (and to catch unauthorized changes and withdrawals in time--see below).

  • At no point during the perpetrator's attack was my brother asked to confirm any action requested on the site via email. Admittedly, my brother did not have 2FA enabled on his account when his account was compromised. However, it seems that the perpetrator enabled 2FA on the account for funding (withdrawals) and for the Master key (to enable password recovery and two-factor authentication bypass). Both, Bitfinex and Poloniex ask their users to confirm enabling 2FA via email; on Poloniex, users can disable email confirmations for withdrawals only after the user enables 2FA. If Kraken also provided this basic layer of security, my brother's funds would likely have remained safe. However, since Kraken does not confirm enabling (or disabling) 2FA on their users' accounts via email, the perpetrator successfully enabled 2FA, changed the Master key, changed the withdrawal addresses, and requested withdrawals -- all in under 5 minutes. Here is the email my brother received from Kraken when the perpetrator gained access to his account and made the withdrawals (emphasis mine):

    Hi,

    A withdrawal request has been made for the withdrawal address named b. If you requested this action, great, it was successful.

    Thanks for choosing Kraken Bitcoin Exchange The Kraken Team

    Note: if you didn't request this action, your account may be compromised and you should do the following:

    1. log into https://www.kraken.com immediately and go to Account > Funding > Withdraw - you may be able to cancel the withdraw if you catch it soon enough.

    2. change your password;

    3. create a new set of two-factor authentications;

    4. create a support ticket letting our support staff know about the incident: https://support.kraken.com.

    The IP recorded for this action was 201.140.110.78. --

Kraken has been investigating the breach of my brother's account and theft since this morning, and there have been a few updates and inquiries from Kraken on the support ticket about my brother's security practices. Although he should have been using 2FA from the moment he opened his account, we know that he does not use the same password or any variation of it on other websites, exchanges, or services. While my brother made a mistake not using 2FA, my concern is now with Kraken's seemingly cavalier security practices. By defaulting to email verification when 2FA is not enabled (rather than having the user "catch it soon enough"), thefts like that from my brother's account today, could easily be avoided. Furthermore, why don't they allow users to readily view an audit of their previous logins? Every now and then, I review my login history on other exchanges to make sure there are no anomalies; it's an additional layer of security for me since I can easily see the locations,times, and IP addresses of my logins--stuff that algorithms can easily miss (e.g., I was in Colombia recently and logged into an exchange from there and can see it in the login history on another exchange; if Kraken provided a similar log, I could have spotted the entry of the perpetrator logging in from Mexico immediately. If my brother's situation was simply a breach of the account (no theft), it's conceivable that the breach would have gone unnoticed without quick and easy access to these logs that I can review every so often.

Kraken: It's great that you detail what your user's can do to keep their accounts safe as you did in the suspicious login email, and it's all sound advice because users should absolutely do all they can to keep their accounts safe. As someone who knows a little something about computer security and production software (including web), I tend to implement security features that account for shoddy security practices of some of our lazier users. As one of the top crypto exchanges, you should also be doing all you can to protect your customers' accounts (even from themselves). The lack of manual email verification when enabling/disabling 2FA and when requesting withdrawals with or without 2FA is a serious dereliction of basic security practices. I hope you can address the issues I've raised and I urge you to elaborate on your approach to all things relating to the security of your clients' accounts.

11 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

2

u/krakenexchange Jul 21 '16

We’re very sorry your brother’s account was compromised. Thank you for voicing your concerns comprehensively. We appreciate the feedback. Moving forward, we’ll look for ways to better communicate to clients the importance of setting up 2FA for login and other security features, and to protect customers “even from themselves”, as you put it. Email withdrawal confirmations were never implemented as 2FA for login provides better protection (still protects you if both your password and email are compromised), but we're taking your advice to heart and will consider adding these.

2

u/caesar0901 Jul 21 '16 edited Jul 21 '16

/u/krakenexchange I appreciate your reply, and I'm glad you'll reconsider implementing the security features I mentioned in the post. I agree that 2FA is by far more secure; however, for customers that don't set it up, whatever their reason may be, defaulting to email verification for account changes and withdrawals should prove more secure than not having that failsafe. Without email verification (for customers without 2FA), perpetrators can make changes on the account and submit withdrawal requests. I understand the concern about possibly compromised email accounts; if the email account was also compromised, the perpetrator would be able inflict the same amount of damage on the exchange account as they can without the email verification. But if the email was not compromised, then it would succeed in thwarting the perpetrator's actions on the exchange.

1

u/C1aranMurray Jul 22 '16

I recommend an option where withdrawal addresses (at least for high volume traders) can only be added via a Skype call.

5

u/uboyzlikemexico Long-term Holder Jul 21 '16

I got that email too. There are a few sporadic posts about this in the other btc and the eth subs as well. I'm thinking Kraken is not being fully transparent on this. I bet it's site wide. Really big hack.

3

u/tookie_tookie Jul 21 '16

I got the same email. Logged in to kraken and it said 3 bad login attempts since last login on July 17. Problem is I never logged in on July 17. I have 2FA enabled.

Changed my password. Luckily I didn't have funds there.

1

u/DavideBaldini Jul 22 '16

What is weird for me is that I received the same email alert from Kraken, but I never registered an account with them.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

Did you register for an account with Cavirtex, Coinsetter, or Clevercoin?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '16

Has there been any bitcoin related sites hacked recently?

By the way, I am really impressed with CLEF which Bitfinex uses. Maybe Kraken should look into it.