r/Bitcoin • • Jul 20 '16

My Kraken account just got robbed! Beware.

My entire balance in BTC just got drained from Kraken and sent to an address that is not ours. Not sure how it happened because I've never even spoken my password out loud. Secure your accounts with two factor auth.

Withdrawal AGBQF7Z-WUT63Y-HKQZUJ« Back Type Bitcoin Date 07-20-16 05:50:09 -0500 Address 16m8BHbWVDgRSGRU3WVtqsay3JaEved12w Transaction ID 01cb694a2e5418318e26a9602dba8716bb700a2431b7a804cadac8035360fc5e Status Success Amount ฿0.43610 Fee ฿0.00050

10 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

8

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

Not sure how it happened because I've never even spoken my password out loud.

You type in your password every time you log in. If your computer is compromised then an attacker can get your password. This is what two factor authentication is supposed to prevent. I'm guessing you did not use it. It's not really your fault - people should be able to use an exchange without being security experts.

Do you know why exchanges allow any withdrawals at all without 2FA enabled? Because they do not give a shit about security or their customers' money.

If they really cared, they would force everyone to use 2FA. It's simply unsafe to NOT use it. What they'd have to do is disable withdrawals of any funds deposited without 2FA until a) you've enabled 2FA and b) waited 2 weeks. The waiting period is to ensure that if a hacker tries to enable 2FA on your account and withdraw, you have some time to catch it and stop it.

But no exchange will ever do this because they're lazy and it's easier to blame you when your funds are stolen right out from under their nose.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

2FA is a blessing and a curse. If its mandatory, prepare for customer support being overun with requests to disable and reset it, because they wipe their phone, or got a new one, or somehow lost their 2FA. On the flip side, you make it optional, but then queue the customer support "overrun" with people losing bitcoins because their account name and password fell into the wrong hands.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

Which is worse, having to wait to get your coins, or losing them completely?

And from the support standpoint, you don't even have to do anything manually to reset 2FA. Localbitcoins does it automatically just fine - you just have to wait two weeks. If no one logs into your account, in that time, 2FA is disabled. However LBC doesn't require 2FA either.

1

u/catsfive Jul 20 '16

Which is worse, having to wait to get your coins, or losing them completely?

From whose perspective? The exchanges, or the users? Two different things.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

The user's. The exchange doesn't care either way, except for if users start fleeing to another exchange. But that generally doesn't happen (people who lose their coins get blamed not only by the exchange, but also by other users).

2

u/catsfive Jul 20 '16

I cannot think of anything further than rocket science than 2FA. Proof: I use it, figured it out quickly.

You raise good points, however, about withdrawals on exchanges. My exchange allows me to set a delay for withdrawals.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

It's probably safe enough to allow withdrawals immediately if you require 2FA to withdraw. I think it's better to do the setup at the beginning and be secure all along, rather than try to deal with compromises later.

1

u/DarkMench Jul 20 '16

Kraken has two types of two factor. One uses an actual app that generates unique codes and the other is simply another password that doesn't change and is easily found with a keylogger. I'm curious if the OP used either.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

A 2nd password doesn't add much security, since if you can capture one, you can capture the other. What the unique codes give you is a secret that never leaves the device (unlike a password where you have to transmit the secret in a way it can be intercepted).

Unfortunately, all logins should just work like that from the beginning, passwords are a relic that needs to die already.

1

u/dooglus Jul 22 '16

Do you know why exchanges allow any withdrawals at all without 2FA enabled? Because they do not give a shit about security or their customers' money.

2FA is a pain to support. People lose their phone all the time. Or factory reset it. Or drop it in the toilet. Or the 2FA app updates itself and somehow loses all its secrets. And no matter how much you encourage them to keep a backup of the 2FA secret very few actually do it.

If an exchange forced its users to use 2FA they would both increase their support load and lose customers to an exchange that was easier to use. It's an unfortunate reality. So the best they can do is offer 2FA and encourage people to use it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

2FA is a pain to support.

No it isn't, and I already explained how to do it without involving support staff at all.

If an exchange forced its users to use 2FA

They don't have to force them to use 2FA to use the exchange, just to withdraw.

lose customers to an exchange that was easier to use

Nope, they wouldn't go anywhere. By the time the customer realized, "oh shit, I have to use 2FA", their money is already tied up in the exchange. They can't withdraw until they have 2FA, then once they do, why bother to withdraw and go elsewhere? They're already set.

It's really not that hard to understand: "If you can take all your funds out without your 2FA token, so can someone else. We have no way of knowing whether it was you or not, so we can't refund your money".

If a customer cannot understand this, as an exchange you do not want their business.

1

u/dooglus Jul 22 '16

No it isn't, and I already explained how to do it without involving support staff at all.

I find it annoying to support. I'm not willing to automatically reset 2FA after 2 weeks. If 2FA can be automatically reset then what's the point of having it?

It's really not that hard to understand

Lots of people just don't want to think about it. The "it won't happen to me" mentality.

If a customer cannot understand this, as an exchange you do not want their business.

I suspect exchanges want all the business they can get.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '16

If 2FA can be automatically reset then what's the point of having it?

Not anyone can reset it. The only way a hacker can take control this way is if a) he has control of your email and can prevent you from seeing the warning b) you don't access the account for two weeks.

I'm sure there are cases where a hacker could successfully take control of an account this way, but it's a lot harder than just stealing or guessing a password.

I suspect exchanges want all the business they can get.

I'm not so sure - take for example a user who's naive about security, deals in small amounts, gets hacked and badmouths the exchange on reddit. The amount that user generates in fees is much smaller than the reputational damage they cause.

1

u/dooglus Jul 23 '16

take for example a user who's naive about security, deals in small amounts, gets hacked and badmouths the exchange on reddit

Oh, there are certainly some users you would rather not have, but it's hard to identify them before they start trashing your reputation. Just dealing in small amounts isn't a reason to spurn them, because you never know when they might refer a whale to your exchange.

4

u/Freekjee Jul 20 '16

2fa enabled ?

3

u/slacknation Jul 20 '16

do u had 2fa?

8

u/Ds720 Jul 20 '16

Same thing happened to me this morning at around 6:30am EST!!
See below post my brother made for me on my behalf since I was unable to post due to lack of activity on my reddit account.

https://m.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/4tqvkl/kraken_trades_and_withdrawals_from_my_account_not/

1

u/Ds720 Jul 20 '16

Looks like other users as well. Email notifications with subject Suspicious Login on Kraken Account are being sent to multiple users.
Please check your accounts and change your passwords!

2

u/ThorvaldAagaard Jul 27 '16

Hi Mike

Are you registered on any other exchange ? Please contact me om [email protected] as I am investigation this case, and I would like to see if I can find any similarities in our cases Thorvald

1

u/tmornini Jul 20 '16

Wow, that's horrible.

Always keep bitcoin in your own wallet!

If you don't have the private keys, they're not your bitcoins... :-(

So sorry.

1

u/vamprism Jul 20 '16

sorry to hear that man, 1 more reason i cant rely on exchanges.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

"Debated answering here but... 33, combined worth of just under 2 mil(wife and I) so technically, I am not a millionaire, by myself. How'd we do it. Combined income of over 350k while living below our means (I drive a Jetta), working hard, making smart investment choices and not being afraid to try shit out. Started by flipping a house at 25 that netted 135k in profit, was able to afford down payment on another property along with a bigger house. We also skim 20 off the top of each cheque and invest in low cost index funds, started doing that in about 2007, so the bulk of my investments have gone swimmingly. Lastly after trying several business ideas out I finally made some dough with some algo trading on crypto currencies, this has really boosted net worth because I do it on the side. I don't think my situation is unique though, at best I would say I'm just slightly ahead of the curve, and most people that read this will likely be worth at least a million in their life. People have said it, biggest difference is the lack of financial stress. But no big difference in fulfillment / happiness actually comes from the money."

What a way to put a target on your back.

1

u/MIkeHBrown Jul 20 '16

You are right... shame...!

1

u/ZenNate Jul 20 '16

What a way to put a target on your back.

By what means would a hacker target someone on Reddit?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

crawling for keywords in comments or threads. A standard search however would probably get you a few targets in the matter of hours as well.

1

u/ZenNate Jul 20 '16

So, what do they do once they've identified a target?

1

u/TheYello Jul 20 '16

Nice try skid

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

Im not doing that kind of stuff so I can only guess but as head of the ECB Im definitely not posting advice on illegal behavior.

1

u/ZenNate Jul 20 '16

I'm just trying to protect myself.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '16

You seem to use paper wallets and have a healthy skepticism towards exchanges so if your wallets are created on machines that you use for nothing else and by code that can be considered to be safe then there is not that much to worry about apart from physical loss of course.

1

u/dooglus Jul 22 '16

It took me a while to understand that this was a quote from a post by OP from a month ago.

-1

u/aulnet Jul 20 '16

The problem is, you guys talk about 2FA like it's a feature EVERYBODY understand. Truth is people don't use it because they're intimidated by "2FA" like it's some complicated shit.