r/listentothis • • Dec 18 '15

Electronic Lemon -- Smells like teen spirit [cover electronic] (2014)

https://soundcloud.com/musicbylemon/smells-like-teen-spirit
272 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

13

u/PabloCandybar Dec 19 '15

I don't know how to say "I didn't like it" constructively... :(

6

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15 edited Dec 20 '15

"I'm afraid that this attempt at bringing an original flair to such a classic song, while admirable, falls far too short. Converting a song that is known for its energetic and somewhat angry tone into something so slow with such quiet, underwhelming, autotuned vocals misses the point of what Nirvana were trying convey. This unintentionally undermines and undervalues what is regarded as a classic song. I know this may be a bit harsh, especially since you are indeed talented, but know that I'm only telling you this because I want you to succeed. Let's face it: covers obviously are not your forte, because any cover you'd do in your style would come off as half-hearted and bland regardless of how passionate you are about it.

One of my favorite lines from a webtoon called 4-Y records perfectly sums this up:

"I listen to bands like Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Nine Inch Nails, and Smashing Pumpkins to hear angry, if not self-reflective music. Not some god-awful 12 minute instrumental of pseudo self-awareness and/or inane political views spoken from the perspective of a hackney twit."

Okay, maybe not that second half. But you get the idea.

Instead, what you should do is fine-tune what you already have and try making something that honestly expresses who you are. Believe me, it'll come off as a thousand times more genuine and people will love you for being you. That is, as opposed to how you did now, which comes off as someone who tries too hard to be unique by making lackluster covers that miss the point entirely.

It isn't that the effort isn't appreciated. It took some serious balls to do, and I greatly admire that. The problem is that other genres don't convert to your style well, and Smells Like Teen Spirit is considered and untouchable classic for a reason. Your energy is better spent on being more original, which means writing your own music and lyrics."


Sometimes, you just gotta be real.

18

u/JB1549 Dec 18 '15

Hmm... not sure why they made this into a cover, sounds like it would have been good as an original song, just use your own lyrics.

6

u/FriscoBay Dec 19 '15

Cobain is turning in his grave...

11

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

Tori Amos cover 1992 for anyone who hasn't heard.

5

u/quantic56d Dec 19 '15

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTWKbfoikeg

Original for anyone who hasn't heard it.

I make electronic music myself. IMHO these kinds of covers are terrible. Make something new instead of trying to ride the success of a massive hit song. It smacks of all those shitty wedding bands playing jazz versions of classic songs.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

I haven't been the same since I read the comment "Stop being so damn affected!" on her "losing my religion" cover.

Love some of her originals though.

1

u/pandemonium91 Dec 19 '15

I'm quite partial to Patti Smith's cover as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_ciiCyxOJA
The only thing I hate about it is the way she says "dangerous".

17

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

Wow this sucks really bad

8

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

Agree'd, expected something spectacular with all the upvotes. As a die hard Nirvana fan I really didn't enjoy it at all.

7

u/PuppyFlavorRamen Dec 19 '15

That's because you're a die hard Nirvana fan, IMO. It's not my taste either, but how could it live up to the original that you surely cherish?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

Well, I do enjoy for example Seether's covers so it can be done.

4

u/MCmevin Dec 18 '15

she should have covered Weird Al

4

u/Nullkid Dec 19 '15

This reminds me of when they were told they would be using a recording during a live set and kurt sounded like an opera singer 10 hits into an acid trip. They all played their instruments robotic-like, to show they weren't playing at all.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

Blech. Made on a Casio ten dollar keyboard with a boat rock easy listening beat.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

It sounds nice but I'm allergic to autotune :( I think it shouldn't be necessary for this tune either, there's nothing special going on - a proper singer should be able to sing this in key without autotune, and it's not being used as effect either.

3

u/tPRoC soundcloud Dec 18 '15

I'd say it is definitely being used as an effect, just subtly.

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

"Subtle autotune" as in "you can hear autotune is applied a little bit" is really annoying to me.
I don't like the warble garble autotune sound.
I can accept miniscule pitch- or timing-correction, IF it's done to improve the sound of a track, in a way that's not noticeable.
I can also understand using autotune as an effect, when it's done in an obvious way - eventhough I might not appreciate it very much.
But applying "subtle autotune" in a way that doesn't add anything but just warbles the sound a bit annoys me very much.
I might have just become a grumpy old man at 39... :)

1

u/WrongLetters Dec 19 '15

That's not even subtle, it's just not EXTREME.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

Alright, so please tell me what you think autotune is. I'm always open for education.

11

u/sirpsys Dec 18 '15

Ohhhh no :( This is truly offensive to the spirit of original song. What useless music.

3

u/CanucksFTW Dec 19 '15

Geez, I tried to keep an open mind but this has no soul or creativity

5

u/Bucklev Dec 19 '15

Hard to make a cover of a near perfect song. If you want to do it right, you have to make it like Johnny Cash do with Hurt from NIN.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

Or like Ghost did with If You Have Ghosts by Roky Erickson.

Roky's version.

Ghost's version.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

Glad to see i'm not the only one who doesn't like this. some songs just cant be covered, especially not like this.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

By chance I clicked on this, thanks for the share (Even though i'm subscribed, I have never clicked on these)! For the past week none of my music has been feeding that itch I couldn't place. This nailed it. :)

2

u/RainDancingChief Dec 19 '15

well... that's just awful.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

This isn't a cover. This is an awful song with smells like teen spirit's lyrics. It's plagiarism. You can change the rhythms and key of the instruments and song and it could remain a cover but literally changing the key, melodies and rhythms for every instrument while singing the lyrics is not a cover to me. If this is her interpretation of the song, she's (He's?) a fucking moron. I fail to hear how this bears any resemblance whatsoever to the original track, obviously neglecting the vocals.

-3

u/Raf99 Dec 18 '15

Why the F can't people make thear own music these days? Inspirational is one thing but taking an inspiring song and redoing it to make money is sad.

4

u/ikahjalmr Dec 18 '15

These days?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

She won't make money off of it, it's a terrible cover, and there is a ton of extremely inspiring original music out these days. Not sure what you are talking about.

1

u/PuppyFlavorRamen Dec 18 '15

I doubt they did it to make money, considering their Soundcloud has a fairly small following. It was probably an attempt to pay tribute to a song that's effected their life, and even if it wasn't your cup of tea that doesn't retract their right to add their own touch to something they enjoy.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

I'm kinda surprised this is getting so much hate in the comments. I really liked this, however I'm not personally a huge nirvana fan.

2

u/pandemonium91 Dec 19 '15

I liked it too. IMO many of the people here are treating it like OMG THE WORST THING EVER KILL YOURSELF IF YOU LIKE IT because they can't see it as a separate version (it's not like they took the original vocals and autotuned them, guys). Or it's legitimately not their style.

Either way, it's far, far from the worst thing I've ever heard.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

That's mostly because hipsters have this thing where Nirvana is godly because somebody else told them Nirvana was godly instead of having their own opinions so if anything isn't Nirvana but plays their songs it's bad and the only way to retain their thick rim glasses, neck beards and suspenders is to show how cool they are by acting like everybody else. It happens with the Beatles too.

2

u/pandemonium91 Dec 19 '15

Eh, I can get being a hardcore fan of something. But I think it's incredibly close-minded to dismiss any cover of a song just because it's not as good as the original (again, a matter of opinion) - or just different. Some of the best covers I've heard are vastly different from the original e.g. Boney M's "Rasputin" and the cover by Turisas are both fantastic IMO, and belong to vastly different genres.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

I love a good cover personally. I'm the Air Tonight by Non point or Land of Confusion by Disturbed are both awesome I think.

-1

u/___ok Dec 19 '15

Great breathing

-2

u/CaptainBayouBilly Dec 18 '15

So an Imogen Heap'ish cover of SLTS?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

1

u/DietElkse Dec 18 '15

You might be thinking of the Choir version of the song which was used to promote "Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck"

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

What the fuck?...

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

I...really fucking like that..

1

u/Sunfl00 Dec 19 '15

Oh man, thank you for linking that. It actually gave me some chills... I think it's the combined memories of "Hook" as well as the song. I should probably check out this movie.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

1

u/CaptainKirklv Dec 19 '15

That movie....woof

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/spongeycrumbs Dec 18 '15

no the op already posted that

22

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/HarbourCity Dec 18 '15

This Elevator music covers are listless. The original is an iconic burst of uncontrolled energy.

This is none of those things.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '15

When Kurt sung this he would be out of breath and exhausted by the end (to the point of singing his vocal chords raw and losing his voice). The context and spirit of the song is high energy and it's a damn hard song to cover any other way.