r/TrueFilm • u/[deleted] • Oct 04 '15
Jonathan Rosenbaum on List-o-mania and an alternative to the AFI's mediocre top 100 list
http://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/list-o-mania/Content?oid=89661921
u/Splagodiablo Oct 04 '15
Wait what about AFI's list makes it mediocre? I'm genuinely curious?
30
Oct 05 '15
It's not diverse enough and mostly focuses on stuff that was a hit at the time, won major Oscars, or at least a very major cult movie like Blade Runner. Apart from Clockwork Orange there's very little that's challenging to the audience. Also, even within the realm of mainstream Hollywood movies they managed to leave out a lot of major contributors to its history. Snow White and Toy Story stand in for all of American animation history in what looks like unimaginative choices and documentaries are left out completely.
Basically, it just looks like the winners of a popularity contest, instead of a true snapshot of American film history...which is more diverse and interesting than many realize. So it's lists like that that contribute to the perception that old movies are boring or unsophisticated compared to today's.
23
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
Nailed it. If you're only given a hundred movies, you've got to mostly fill up every slot with stand-ins. "XYZ will be animation, this will be noir, western, silent..." Which they didn't do. The only value i could see in it would be to get kids into older movies... But it doesn't really do that well, either. It wastes too much time agreeing that the canon is still the canon. The fault is its inception: that a company can list, in order, the greatest pieces of art from a particular medium. That's too personal of a subject for a committee to handle. Let Sight & Sound keep doing its thing, let imdb keep aggregating. They're just mile markers on the journey.
These lists provide two possible functions: giving me titles to watch, and allowing me to (dis)agree with the titles you've chosen. Simply comparing Rosenbaum's list to AFI's is enough to see which offers more. You can't really say anything to AFI's list, other then, "Eh, I guess so." Rosenbaum's on the other hand, is interesting. It's personal, I agree and disagree with a lot, I've got titles to watch...It's a conversation.
13
Oct 05 '15 edited Oct 05 '15
And you want a list to feel like it's having a conversation with you, too, not just filling those slots with the most obvious choice.
A list like this carries significant weight; like how at Barnes & Noble they have a prominent display of all of them. What's really the point of treating movies people have already heard of and seen as the most significant, at least, cultural monuments in film history? A lot of them really are that good, yes, but we don't really need to affirm the greatness of movies that are already widely available all the time when so many other great ones need to be 'discovered' by modern people and aren't always available in nice releases. One of my favorite things about commercial-friendly lists like this is that they never pay the lip-service to Birth of a Nation that critics and directors do, but always include Gone with the Wind instead, which is equally problematic but still profitable.
9
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
Haha, exactly. They do that accidental faux pas, where they're caught in a position of either having to admit that they like a flawed (racist) thing, and need to defend it (which they'd never do); or, they have to disengenously backtrack and curse Gone With the Wind, thus opening up a slot for, say, Pleasentville. That's yet another reason why the committee will never make a good best-of art list. They'll never be able to defend "dead nigger storage." And they shouldn't. It doesn't matter what Coca Cola thinks about King Kong's racist ass. I care about what lordhadri thinks about it, or Rosenbaum, Roger Deakins, or whoever.
22
u/Forfeit32 Oct 05 '15
Honestly, nothing. It's the equivalent of having Sergeant Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band, Pet Sounds, and Led Zeppelin IV on a best albums list. Those are the albums that defined their times, but some think that lesser known stuff is actually better music, just not as widely known to the average person.
18
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
That's a great point, but i think the counter argument is not that lesser known titles are better. It's that they desserve more airtime. It's about disparity. If Zoso and Pet Sounds are widely regarded as 10/10 and get 90% of the airtime, shouldn't widely regarded 9's get more than 10% of the airtime? The list makes it way more black and white than it is. Most people think Citizen Kane is really good. Does thast mean it has to be #1 every time, at the expense of ever mentioning Kansas City Confidential?
11
u/laughterwithans Oct 05 '15
but isn't the point of the list to lay out the "Greatest American Films of all time?"
If so, then a list called, "Some Other Interesting Films You May Not Have Heard Of" would be more along the lines of what you're demanding.
For instance, if you put The White Album on the greatest albums list, instead of Sgt. Peppers, you have to justify why one is greater than the other.
Sgt. Peppers defined an era of music, The White Album did not, therefore, although the White Album is spectacular, and even more daring and challenging, it's a rough stretch to say that it deserves Sgt. Peppers spot on the list, just because you're tired of seeing it there.
4
u/pursehook "Gossip is like hail..." Oct 19 '15
but isn't the point of the list to lay out the "Greatest American Films of all time?" If so, then a list called, "Some Other Interesting Films You May Not Have Heard Of" would be more along the lines of what you're demanding.
Your's was my favorite comment in this mess.
If Rosenbaum had simply included the AFI poll methodology in his too-long article, people could have had the relevant facts for engaging in discussion.
3
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
Okay, you lay out the greatest American movies of all time. You have a hundred slots, so be careful. And you need to be able to back them all up. Objectively. Is your list the same as the AFI's? How boring! Is it different? How treasonous! You're also entering into a much larger argument.
Why are you the one who gets to decide what is great art, much less what is art, and what isn't? You now have to justify centuries of careers' worth of contradiction, so again, be careful. The onus is not on me to defend; it's on you. Why should I give a shit about what the AFI tells me is a good movie? And why is Rosebaum's list, a personal favorites list, worth less than whatever you can come up with? Or the AFI?
Just because you say Sgt Pepper's gas more influence than The Beatles, why should I believe you? And even if you're right, why should I care? What if I don't like Sgt Pepper's? Should I still enjoy spending my time reading about how wrong my opinion is?
2
u/laughterwithans Oct 05 '15
Yes art is subjective.
2
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
Then what's your point?
3
u/laughterwithans Oct 11 '15
That the AFI list isn't a list of stuff you might not have heard of.
I have no opinion on wether they are correct or not, but their goal isn't to turn people on to new stuff which is what it seems you want.
1
u/pmcinern Oct 11 '15
Yeah, I do want that. But, so far, you've only said two things: art is subjective, and the AFI's intention was to make a greatest-of list (which is objective, but ill-defined). What do they mean by great, and did all the people they polled have the same defintion (most influential, most awards, personal favorite)? I doubt it. So the meaning of the list isn't even fully coherent.
So the intention was murky, their execution sucked, we all think it's super important (or valid, or correct, or objective), and we're left with a list of titles we've all seen or heard of before, adding nothing new to the table. The titles listed are individually fine movies, but you could just as easily generate a similar list by setting imdb parameters in the advanced search to many votes, above 8.0, made before 2000, made in the U.S. ... I really can't stress enough how useless it is, precisely because of how impersonal this subjective list is. It's trying to fit squares into circles, so why are we all supposed to agree it fits?
If I came up with the same list, what would you think of me? I'd be the most boring, agreeable person ever. I'd laugh at fucking Jeff Dunham jokes. You'd think it was a bad list. So maybe I do just want something more interesting. But maybe the AFI made a pointless, shitty list, and we deserve something to talk about that isn't that. Which is precisely what Rosenbaum did.
7
u/Forfeit32 Oct 05 '15
Very well put. Was hard to wordicize my thoughts while watching the Cowboys.
1
8
u/dgapa Oct 05 '15
It's a fairly solid list of the greatest American films that are well received by a large group of critics and voters. Understanding that it's like having an amazing intro to film program is a great help. I was introduced to many great films I may not have watched otherwise. You can quibble with some picks but there aren't many "duds" on it.
11
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
They regurgitated a list of Widely Regarded Masterpieces. It's mediocre for a lot of reasons.
The premise: one company makes a lit of what it says it thinks are the best movies from one country. A) Who cares what the AFI thinks? B) Do we really think that this list is genuinely what they think are the greatest American movies? Because, C) not all of the movies on the list are even American.
The function: movie lovers now have a list of movies they've either already seen, or have already heard enough about to decide if they want to see them. It's a little useless.
The result: It has suspiciously little value. These movies have all already been touted as great by everyone for decades. So why bother rehashing this unoriginal list at all? Much less, with such fanfare, like it's objective or something? If I told you to watch Citizen Kane, would you care?
It's not a bad list, but it's really safe. Reeeeaaally safe. And it offers nothing to the public except to say, "You liked Casablanca? Well guess what? You're right!" When Tarantino says Hi Diddle Diddle or The Mercenary is one of his ten favorite movies of all time, though, that's something to pay attention to. Because it starts a coversation. The AFI list doesn't really do that. If it accomplished what y set out to do, which I don't think it did, then what it set out to do was a bad idea in the first place.
3
1
u/pursehook "Gossip is like hail..." Oct 19 '15
I think it is hilarious that after 2 weeks, and with this being Rosenbaum month, that this is still the top comment here. It just shows how convoluted and self-absorbed Rosenbaum’s writing can be. Sooo many words, yet he didn’t manage to convince even this audience. If anyone is still looking at this thread, I tried to pull out the highlights from the article to spare you from reading it -- see below or a link.
16
u/montypython22 Archie? Oct 04 '15 edited Oct 04 '15
I think the thing to preface before attacking Rosenbaum's choices for the Alternative AFI is that the concept, the principle behind Rosenbaum's choices is the important thing, not necessarily the actual choices. Granted, most of these choices do coincide with some personal favorites of mine (including Do the Right Thing, Avanti!, Christmas in July, McCabe & Mrs. Miller, and Love Streams), but the point of this list is not to say "X film is better than Y film!", where "Y" represents a film on the AFI list and "X" its inverse. The point of Rosenbaum's list (and, indeed the point of many novel approaches to film history, such as Andrew Sarris's auteur theory) is to introduce people to different kinds of movies, to fresher and less-talked-of artworks that need the attention. It isn't a list that rotely regurgitates accepted (perhaps overrated?) classics like Casablanca, Gone With the Wind, Sunset Blvd., One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, etc. (Basically, most of the movies on the AFI list.) That's, of course, not to say those films are "bad"; that's not the point. What is the point is to shine a crucial light on those other movies that are in the similar vein of the overtalked classic and, more often than not, are more interesting than the overtalked classic.
That's the principle at work with TrueFilm's own Alternative AFI. It's not that we're saying F For Fake is a better or more important film than Citizen Kane, or that we pride Stagecoach over The Searchers or Make Way for Tomorrow over City Lights or A Woman Under the Influence over One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Like Rosenbaum's list, we're taking part in a conscious re-writing of the trajectory of populist film history, which prides talking about the greatness of really popular films while ignoring others.
6
u/pmcinern Oct 05 '15
I agree with you, to the point that I don't really understand the defending of his list. He pretty much covered all his bases in the preface, right? He was clear about it being perosnal, that his tastes were formed like anybody else's, that it's an answer to AFI and not necessarily his actual top 100 American.... He started out with a fine premise, defended it (maybe even a little too much), and still came out with a great list. I really don't see how someone could bash the list, other than to say how different their top 100 would be from his (which would be irrelevant). The essay before it, sure, but it's pretty clear he was just touting underloved movies, right?
6
u/Athenian_Dubstep Oct 04 '15
I've never been able to find Last Chants for a Slow Danc or Tom, Tom, the Piper's Son anywhere. Always wanted to watch them, though.
9
u/pursehook "Gossip is like hail..." Oct 04 '15
You can rent Tom, Tom, the Piper's Son for $275 on Amazon. It says for institutional use, but they are not checking. Not helpful? :)
5
u/Athenian_Dubstep Oct 05 '15
Oh boy, thanks! I'll get right on that.
1
u/pursehook "Gossip is like hail..." Oct 05 '15
Ooops, maybe you can buy the dvd for $30. Don't do the rental!!!
If you do buy it, be careful how you use it. Rosenbaum said it was for theaters only.
0
Oct 05 '15
[deleted]
3
Oct 05 '15
You can tell he deliberately included some movies that are hard to get, perhaps in the hopes that appearing on such lists will aid their preservation and help them become more available someday. Blu Ray was a big boon to cinephilia but even then a lot of us don't go further and seek out the films that still aren't available commercially, or are even only viewable in museums.
1
u/bkkwanderer Oct 09 '15
Thank you for this, just signed up for a pro account. How long do you have to wait to get recommendations?
0
Oct 04 '15
[deleted]
2
u/montypython22 Archie? Oct 04 '15
Please note the date of the article. It was written in 1998.
I know that Rosenbaum would most assuredly include A.I. Artifical Intelligence on an updated, post-1998 Alternative AFI.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15 edited Oct 04 '15
Another good introduction to Rosenbaum's writing, this essay shows how we coul expand our view of what counts as a great American movie beyond the usual industry-approved classics, and inspired this list that /r/Truefilm collaborated on a few months ago.
Here's Rosenbaum's alternatives as a letterboxd list and in text form:
Ace in the Hole (The Big Carnival) (1951, Billy Wilder)
Affair to Remember, An (1957, Leo McCarey)
Anatomy of a Murder (1959, Otto Preminger)
Avanti! (1972, Billy Wilder)
Barefoot Contessa, The (1954, Joseph L. Mankiewicz)
Big Sky, The (1952, Howard Hawks)
Bigger Than Life (1956, Nicholas Ray)
Black Cat, The (1934, Edgar G. Ulmer)
Bride of Frankenstein (1935, James Whale)
Broken Blossoms (1919, D.W. Griffith)
Cat People (1942, Jacques Tourneur)
Christmas in July (1940, Preston Sturges)
Confessions of an Opium Eater (1962, Albert Zugsmith)
Crowd, The (1928, King Vidor)
Dead Man (1995, Jim Jarmusch)
Do the Right Thing (1989, Spike Lee)
Docks of New York, The (1928, Josef von Sternberg)
Eadweard Muybridge, Zoopraxographer (1974, Thom Andersen)
11 x 14 (1976, James Benning)
Eraserhead (1978, David Lynch)
Foolish Wives (1922, Erich von Stroheim)
Force of Evil (1948, Abraham Polonsky)
Freaks (1932, Tod Browning)
General, The (1927, Buster Keaton)
Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953, Howard Hawks)
Gilda (1946, Charles Vidor)
Great Garrick, The (1937, James Whale)
Greed (1925, Erich Von Stroheim)
Hallelujah, I'm a Bum (1933, Lewis Milestone)
Heartbreak Kid, The (1972, Elaine May)
Housekeeping (1987, Bill Forsyth)
Hustler, The (1961, Robert Rossen)
Intolerance (1916, D.W. Griffith)
Johnny Guitar (1954, Nicholas Ray)
Judge Priest (1934, John Ford)
Killer of Sheep (1978, Charles Burnett)
Killing of a Chinese Bookie, The (1976, John Cassavettes)
Killing, The (1956, Stanley Kubrick)
Kiss Me Deadly (1955, Robert Aldrich)
Ladies' Man, The (1961, Jerry Lewis)
Lady From Shanghai, The (1948, Orson Welles)
Last Chants for a Slow Dance (1977, Jon Jost)
Laughter (1930, Harry d'Abbadie d'Arrast)
Letter From an Unknown Woman (1948, Max Ophuls)
Lonesome (1929, Paul Fejos)
Love Me Tonight (1932, Rouben Mamoulian)
Love Streams (1984, John Cassavetes)
Magnificent Ambersons, The (1942, Orson Welles)
Make Way for Tomorrow (1937, Leo McCarey)
Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, The (1962, John Ford)
Man's Castle (1933, Frank Borzage)
McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971, Robert Altman)
Meet Me in St. Louis (1944, Vincente Minnelli)
Mikey and Nicky (1976, Elaine May)
Monsieur Verdoux (1947, Charles Chaplin)
My Son John (1952, Leo McCarey)
Naked Spur, The (1953, Anthony Mann)
Nanook of the North (1922, Robert J. Flaherty)
Night of the Hunter, The (1955, Charles Laughton)
Nutty Professor, The (1963, Jerry Lewis)
Palm Beach Story, The (1942, Preston Sturges)
Panic in the Streets (1950, Elia Kazan)
Park Row (1952, Samuel Fuller)
Phenix City Story, The (1955, Phil Karlson)
Point Blank (1967, John Boorman)
Real Life (1979, Albert Brooks)
Reminiscences of a Journey to Lithuania (1971, Jonas Mekas)
Rio Bravo (1959, Howard Hawks)
Scarface (1932, Howard Hawks)
Scarlet Empress, The (1934, Josef von Sternberg)
Scarlet Street (1945, Fritz Lang)
Scenes From Under Childhood (1970, Stan Brakhage)
Scenic Route, The (1978, Mark Rappaport)
Seventh Victim, The (1943, Mark Robson)
Shadows (1960, John Cassavettes)
Sherlock Jr. (1924, Buster Keaton)
Shooting, The (1967, Monte Hellman)
Shop Around the Corner, The (1940, Ernst Lubitsch)
Sound of Fury, The / Try and Get Me! (1950, Cy Endfield)
Stars in My Crown (1950, Jacques Tourneur)
Steel Helmet, The (1951, Samuel Fuller)
Stranger Than Paradise (1984, Jim Jarmusch)
Strawberry Blonde, The (1941, Raoul Walsh)
Sunrise (1927, F.W. Murnau)
Sylvia Scarlett (1935, George Cukor)
Tarnished Angels, The (1958, Douglas Sirk)
That's Entertainment! III (1994, Bud Friedgen & Michael J. Sheridan)
This Land Is Mine (1943, Jean Renoir)
Thunderbolt (1929, Josef von Sternberg)
To Sleep With Anger (1990, Charles Burnett)
Tom, Tom, the Piper's Son (1969, Ken Jacobs)
Track of the Cat (1954, William A. Wellman)
Trouble in Paradise (1932, Ernst Lubitsch)
Vinyl (1965, Andy Warhol)
Wanda (1971, Barbara Loden)
While the City Sleeps (1956, Fritz Lang)
Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter? (1957, Frank Tashlin)
Woodstock (1970, Michael Wadleigh)
Wrong Man, The (1957, Alfred Hitchcock)
Zabriskie Point (1969, Michaelangelo Antonioni)
How many have you seen?