r/listentothis • • Jun 12 '15

Reggae Ska Dub Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution -- It's a Wonderful Life [Ska] (2008)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-MpvIjaFu_k
362 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

9

u/PoopChuteMcGoo Jun 12 '15

Great song. I love this album. Although there is some stylistic of overlap with streetlight manifesto, I wish BOTAR would do some more stuff.

-20

u/PinkSpoon Jun 12 '15

Nah, I don't think that they're gonna be doing more stuff any time soon. The lead singer and some other members broke this band up and started a new one called... Streetlight Manifesto :)

17

u/PoopChuteMcGoo Jun 12 '15

They aren't broken up. It's always been a side project, mostly people from streetlight manifesto. They just haven't done anything in a long time.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15

Hey, BOTAR released their album a long time ago, before Somewhere in the Between I believe. Definitely before 99Songs. I remember because I would listen to BOTAR in high school, then being pumped when 99 songs came out my freshman year of college.

Edit: in fact I think BOTAR released their album before the rerecording of Keasby Nights.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

Not quite. BOTAR predates streetlight. The BOTAR album was releases two years before the first Streetlight album

1

u/IAmTehDave Jun 12 '15

IIRC Catch 22 didn't break up, just Kalnoky left it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IAmTehDave Jun 12 '15

Yeah, Catch 22 released a few more albums after TK left. AFAIK they're still around/touring maybe

1

u/Zarahem Jun 12 '15

I was about to say he sounds just like streetlight.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PinkSpoon Jun 12 '15

I was explaining the cause of the stylistic overlap with Streetlight Manifesto /u/PoopChuteMcGoo mentioned. The cause being BOTAR and Streetlight sharing some of the same members and a lead singer. And, IIRC, Streetlight is the newest band formed by Tomas

36

u/Flame_Rei Jun 12 '15

I'll always upvote anything Tomas Kalnoky made.

10

u/HotSauceEater101 Jun 12 '15

One of best musicians alive in my opinion. I absolutely love his work.

3

u/hybriddeadman Jun 16 '15

Not only is he a musical genius, he is a lyrical prodigy. He wrote Everything Goes Numb when he was 22, and that album has the best lyrics I've ever heard.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

I never understand the ska hate. How can you dislike something so happy sounding?

7

u/MichaelJFoxxy Jun 12 '15

It upsets me when I try to talk about Streetlight Manifesto to someone and they automatically write them off because they don't like ska. They don't even give them a chance.

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/Ponyman713 Jun 12 '15

Ride the fourth wave bro.

4

u/dethandtaxes Jun 12 '15

Soooo what is Streetlight Manifesto if not Ska....?

10

u/IAmTehDave Jun 12 '15

Thomas Kalnoky Magical Goodness?

1

u/rilchil Jun 12 '15

It's post ska

1

u/dethandtaxes Jun 12 '15

What other bands similar to SM would you recommend?

1

u/hybriddeadman Jun 16 '15

Less Than Jake comes to mind, they're have a bit less horn sounds, but their music is reminiscent of SM, nowhere near as good though IMO, of course I'm a SM fanboy so nothing will be nearly ass good to me. one of my favorite songs by LTJ is The New Auld Lang Syne

1

u/Whycomike Jul 28 '24

Ye back then the kids would call it ska-punk. I’d throw The Pilfers out for a similar sound maybe?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/dethandtaxes Jun 12 '15

I like genres because it helps me find more music that sounds similar to bands I already like. Granted there is some variation even within genres but specific genres tend to have markers that allow us to group similarly sounding bands together that makes identification and categorization much easier.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

I guess it's more of this ska-punk-alternative hybrid. But are you really gonna have better luck getting people to listen to "alternative ska-punk?"

4

u/CallMeSyd Jun 12 '15

Love this song, love BOTAR, love Streetlight, love Tomas.

2

u/dunkind11 Jun 12 '15

This is great, thank you. This and The Skints will make my morning happy.

2

u/imCodyJay Jun 12 '15

When asked my favorite overall song, most of the time it's this one.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

Massive streetlight fan. Admittedly I live under a rock and had no idea this existed. Thank you!

2

u/MichaelJFoxxy Jun 12 '15

SO HAPPY to see these guys on here. I'm a huge fan of Streetlight Manifesto and Toh Kay's solo project. BOTAR is a beautiful combination of classical and punk, two things you don't often find together. To me this is musical genius.

2

u/blinkjoeboy Jun 12 '15

Great song! Just to clear it up, though - this song came out around 2001-2002, before SM was even formed, not 2008. First Tomas formed Gimp, then Catch 22, BOTAR, and then the foundation of Streetlight Manifesto.

3

u/therapest Jun 12 '15

I don't know why this is but I've always thought of BOTAR as the soundtrack to For Whom the Bell Tolls by Hemingway.

4

u/DavidFrattenBro Jun 12 '15

Because you listened to the lyrics. It's a fair assessment.

0

u/therapest Jun 12 '15

Lol wow, can't believe I missed that connection.

1

u/El_Giganto Jun 12 '15

Reggae ska and dub? Wow. Not really is it?

1

u/Shayreelz Jun 12 '15

It's not technically ska, although it usually gets lumped in there, although there's controversy, most ska fans love BOTAR and Tomas' other projects

2

u/El_Giganto Jun 12 '15

Yeah well obviously. Some of his work can be called ska and is definitely influenced by it, but unless ska/reggae/dub is just a label used by this sub for everything that could be considered any of those three genres, then the reggae and dub just don't make sense.

Ska is one thing, but it clearly isn't a reggae or dub song.

1

u/Shayreelz Jun 12 '15

unless ska/reggae/dub is just a label used by this sub for everything that could be considered any of those three genres

Actually I'm pretty sure that's how it works, they kinda lump them together

2

u/El_Giganto Jun 12 '15

To be fair, that's an easy way to go around things. Can't blame the sub for that. Been gone too long from this sub to keep up with these kinda things.

1

u/jaksalad Jun 12 '15

What is this genre called then? Sounds good to me, what are some other bands?

1

u/El_Giganto Jun 12 '15

Oh the Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution really aren't in one set genre. The frontman Tomas Kalnoky is a punk rocker who loves to experiment with multiple genres. World music, kind of, is often used in Everything Goes Numb, Somewhere in the Between and The Hands That Thieve. This music is all vastly different from the song OP linked, though. 99 Songs of Revolution would come closer to it. Keasbey Nights is different as well, especially when listening to the Catch-22 version.

I don't know anything that sounds like this, personally. If I had to give recommendations based on music by that band, I suggest looking into everything made by Tomas Kalnoky.

Other bands I'd recommend are:

Beirut - has the horns and "world" music style.

Suburban Rhythm - it's a ska band with punk influences.

Andrew Jackson Jihad - I can't really explain right now.

I'd want to give more ska bands, but most bands don't really sound like them. I'd suggest trying out Bomb The Music Industry, as loads love both, but this band is a mostly punk band. Try out Vacation (the album), though.

The Skints is a great ska band. Their first album, Live, Breathe, Build, Believe (or whatever) has great elements of ska and punk. It just doesn't capture the same feeling BOTAR has in this song, though. It's very different. Takes a bit to get into, though.

Defiance, Ohio is a great folk punk band. Acoustic like BOTAR, but a bit more punk and raw. It does it for me, but I doubt you'll find the same thing.

Maybe just start with Streetlight Manifesto and Beirut. You won't get the same sound as in this song, but you might appreciate some of it. I hope you will at least.

1

u/jaksalad Jun 12 '15

Wow! Thanks for the reply!

Already love defiance ohio and AJJ, I really like folk punk. I like some Streetlight Manifesto and I will be sure to check out Beirut and the rest of BOTAR. Again, thanks for the highly detailed comment.

1

u/El_Giganto Jun 12 '15

No problem man! Music is pretty much my thing so I love talking about it :) Have way way way more stuff that I want to show to everyone who cares haha.

1

u/slothfuck Jun 12 '15

Duuuude, never wouldve thought id see this on reddit. The memories..

1

u/theDoctorAteMyBaby Jun 12 '15

Heh. Oh, the long clam baked high school drives we had to this album.
(I'm most certain this is from way before 2008, BTW)

1

u/TheMrMitchell Jun 12 '15

Actually Tomas Kalnoky (lead singer/guitar player) always considered streetlight to be a side project after complications with catch 22. He only planned on doing one album and a few tours with streetlight. So BOTAR was a side project of a side project. Sad but true fact is we probably wont see anything new from streetlight or BOTAR ever again since hes now pursuing a solo career called Toh Kay.

5

u/SierraMisty Jun 12 '15

I've seen streetlight 3 times in the past 4 years and the last 2 times I saw them they said they were done touring....so ill most likely see them again next year.

5

u/Urvilan grooveshark Jun 12 '15

Except a new touring schedule is up after a year and a half hiatus

0

u/TheMrMitchell Jun 12 '15

Yeahh called "the last good fight tour" as in their last tour. Also i saw them on said tour last month and two original members have been replaced. Sooo yeah.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15

The two members had to do totally unrelated things and had to be temporarily replaced and streetlight has had many "final" and "last" tours. It wouldn't be surprising if they did a few more tours...

2

u/Skankinzombie22 Jun 12 '15

Agreed. It's similar to the Suicide Machines breaking up and saying they're never touring again. Just saw them in Cleveland, OH in April. Bands will always find a reason to tour. It's how they make their money.

1

u/Urvilan grooveshark Jun 12 '15

also inb4 the entire setup is really just Kalnoky, it's like Santana or Springsteen, no one's going to bat an eye if they're replaced.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

I saw their last show in the UK... I'll be seeing them at a UK festival in the summer.

1

u/Uberrees Jun 12 '15

Streetlight is still active...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15

He's been touring as Toh Kay for a while now. And the past two tours have been billed as final tours. I saw them in 2013 and I scrambled to buy their tickets because they announced it would be their last tour in a long time on the west coast. I just saw them two weeks ago, live.

1

u/geek180 Jun 12 '15

Wasn't BOTAR before Streetlight?

1

u/GreenFisk Jun 12 '15

Except they're just in a huge fight with their Record company so they dont want to make anything until they're released from the contract. Wouldn't be surprised if they'd make a new album in 6 months time, just right after they stopped boycotting themselves.

1

u/numba1chief_rocka Jun 12 '15

I don't know about that. Toh Kay's first album came out a year or so after Somewhere in the Between, before 99 SoR and The Hands That Thieve. I don't think they broke up so he could pursue a purely solo career, it seems like he always has multiple projects. Also, the last two tours have been some cryptic variation of "this is our last tour" tour. I think they'll keep touring sporadically and maybe producing music. But who knows?

2

u/DavidFrattenBro Jun 12 '15

The thing about the hand(s) that thieve(s) is that it was their last contractually-obligated album to produce on their shitty record deal that made them a very small profit to divide amongst a 7-8-man band.

Now that they are out of their contract, they can tour whenever they want and people will show up and pay them to play, but we won't be seeing much in the way of new S.M. material any time in the near future.

They'll go the same way Reel Big Fish did and rest on the laurels of a solid 10-year run, keeping the same set lists each show until Tomas gets bored.

2

u/Epiphone_ASG Jun 12 '15

Different situation with RBF tho...I feel they've allowed themselves to become a tour band that plays the same old set-list.

Streetlight, on the other hand, might be the only remaining pertinent ska band out there who has put out real quality material within the last ten years.

Most people don't give a shit about a new RBF or Bosstones album, but there is still a growing audience for Streetlight, and other Kalnoky-related projects. Why? Because Kalnoky never labeled his music as "ska" or anything. He makes quality music. Period.

That being said, I do think there will be another installment of Streetlight music, it just might take another seven or eight years because, as we all know, they take their sweet ass time putting out new material.