r/listentothis • u/wd3war • Jun 09 '15
Hip-hop K Flay -- Wishing It Was You [Suburban Rap] (2014)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f32nMMYH0_415
u/wordsofjizzdom Jun 09 '15
I love K. Flay, but I'm honestly surprised that this is the song that made the front page. This album is awesome, but this song may be my least favorite from it
10
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
Yeah. I'd rather it were "Make Me Fade" or "Time For You". "Can't Sleep" was cool too, very much like her older stuff.
3
1
Jun 09 '15
Definitely my favorite. The bass at the beginning and the bluntness of it goes a long way.
17
Jun 09 '15
This is mellow. But what is suburban rap? Is it about lyricism, delivery or musical style?
10
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
Her first album back in 2006 was called Suburban Rap Queen and she quite often brings up her childhood and hometown in her lyrics. I've heard someone call it "first world problems rap", and though I don't quite agree with that, it gets the point acros.
9
u/Battymasterson Jun 09 '15
It's a stupid label. Rap is rap, and she just happens to blend hers with other music like indie pop and rock. I'm gonna give OP the benefit of the doubt and say he/she didn't label it that because she's white and didn't come from "the ghetto". Although unfortunately that's usually why that term pops up.
12
8
u/Officer_Coldhonkey Jun 09 '15
Doesn't really sound like rap to me at all. Suburban or otherwise.
3
u/Garbanian Jun 09 '15
This song is probably the least rappy song she has.
2
u/Officer_Coldhonkey Jun 09 '15
Yeah I listened to some of the others.
1
u/Garbanian Jun 09 '15
What did you think? K.flays been my shit for a few years now. Traveled a bit to see her shows. I get to see one every few months and its the beeeeest!
2
u/Officer_Coldhonkey Jun 09 '15
She's alright I guess. I listen to a lot of hieroglyphics, quasimoto, little brother, Jurassic 5 and the like so her lyrical content leaves a little to be desired to me. She's pretty good tho
1
5
u/PM_ME_YOUR_BUTTCHEEX Jun 09 '15
It's a necessary label because fans of it do embarrassingly out of touch shit like say "'the ghetto'" in quotation marks.
4
u/amongvillains Jun 09 '15
There's nothing "rap" about this. I swear people think rap is essentially saying lines that rhyme without singing them and nothing more.
6
u/cheese_stick_mafia Jun 09 '15
In all seriousness, what is your definition of rap then? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapping
5
u/amongvillains Jun 09 '15
This song has more to do with indie-pop than it does with rap. Sure there's a beat that pops up in the chorus, and the words are rhymed, but this dreamy, slow-jam is delivered like a monotone Ring-Around-The-Rosie singalong. Rap doesn't have to be "hard" or "gangster", but this just is not rap.
Maybe her other tracks are different, but as a standalone song, this does not appear to be a rap artist.
-1
u/Cryptic_Spooning Jun 09 '15
you didn't define what you think rap is, though. Why isn't this rap?
3
0
Jun 09 '15
[deleted]
1
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
Check out her earlier stuff though. The last album was her trying to do something new after no longer being tied to a record company.
15
u/ryanmcstylin Jun 09 '15
she came and performed at our small school for fuckin free. Not a lot of people showed up which is sad because she is pretty talented. I saw her show up on the north coast lineup last year too. she does a pretty cool song with loops that I liked and cannot seem to find.
4
u/PM_ME_YOUR_CAMPFIRE Jun 09 '15
Someone lower in the thread posted a song that sounds like it might be what you're talking about
1
4
u/Danarky go fuck yourself Jun 09 '15
I remember seeing her about 5 years ago open up for Passion Pit. Had a great set.
6
u/SuprBestFriends Jun 09 '15
Haven't seen this song posted yet, my favorite K Flay song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=351s97eOsQ8
3
3
Jun 09 '15
I'm amazed to find this on reddit. Huge k.flay fan, I've seen her every time she's been to Minneapolis the last few years. Also spent a shitload of money helping her release this album, as she dropped her music contract and did it on her own.
3
u/pink--mermaid Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 09 '15
I'm going to see her in concert on June 21st! My ex boyfriend showed me her a while back and told me about her backstory. Forgive me if I get it wrong, but from what I remember, she was in her college dorm with a friend and was making fun of rap and said "oh I can do that" so she did. And happened to be really fucking good at it. Although it may not be rap in many people's eyes, whatever genre it is, I throughly enjoy it and can't wait to see her this month. Oh, I've also told the guy that showed me her that she reminds me of a female Macklemore. Not in this song, but check out her other stuff and maybe you can relate.
10
u/entropy1701 Jun 09 '15
Vanic does some really incredible songs with K.flay:
Vanic x K.Flay - Can't Sleep
Vanic X K.Flay - Cops
Vanic x K.Flay - Make Me Fade
12
Jun 09 '15
i prefer the originals all to vanic's remixes
6
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
Yeah. Applying a bunch of unnecessary beats that don't fit the original doesn't make a remix good.
-3
u/Cocky_Douchebag Jun 09 '15
agreed, had these playing on replay for a few months.
I love her voice and her raps but cant really get behind her solo production.
5
4
2
2
2
u/cultculturee Jun 09 '15
I dig this!
I wish when she hit that F# it wasn't flat though ("I can't move...")
4
3
4
3
u/Cailimocho Jun 09 '15
"Sucking on a bottle of Jim Beam, wishing it was you" lol that part is so gross hahaha, whatever, good artist, nice song, thanks for sharing! this has made my morning
1
u/Mr_Wolf57 turntable Jun 09 '15
Suburban Rap is a great to describe this genre. Who else would fall under this genre?
1
0
Jun 09 '15
[deleted]
1
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
She's from Chicago, IIRC.
1
Jun 09 '15
Her music career, however, is not.
1
u/orange_jooze Jun 09 '15
Seeing as how her childhood is topic of, like, a third of all her songs, I'd say it still matters.
7
7
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '15
I love her!! I'm actually seeing her in concert this July.