r/Fantasy • Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders • Mar 27 '15

Big List The 2015 Top r/Fantasy Novels of All Time Poll Results!

This list includes all those entries that got at least three votes. The links take you to the Goodreads page for the series/book.

Unfinished series are marked with an asterisk. Note that the concept of finished is rather fuzzy.

Change means how much the rank has shifted from last year. Positive means it has improved, negative means it has become lower. N means that this is a new entry, and x means I haven't calculated - because with series having <5 votes, it becomes essentially meaningless.

You can see the full list on this google spreadsheet. And here's the voting thread.

No.NameAuthorVotesChange*
1A Song of Ice And Fire*George R.R. Martin1360
2The Kingkiller Chronicle*Patrick Rothfuss1341
3The Stormlight Archive*Brandon Sanderson1013
4The Lord of The RingsJ.R.R. Tolkien90-2
5Gentleman Bastard*Scott Lynch812
6The Wheel of TimeRobert Jordan76-1
7The Malazan Book of The FallenSteven Erikson73-3
8Discworld*Terry Pratchett540
9The First LawJoe Abercrombie532
10Harry PotterJ.K. Rowling510
11The Broken EmpireMark Lawrence503
12The Dresden Files*Jim Butcher41-3
13Farseer TrilogyRobin Hobb412
14The Riyria RevelationsMichael J. Sullivan4010
15MistbornBrandon Sanderson32-3
16Raven's Shadow*Anthony Ryan2215
17Earthsea CycleUrsula K. Le Guin212
18The Second Apocalypse*R. Scott Bakker197
19The Lions of Al-RassanGuy Gavriel Kay1724
20The SandmanNeil Gaiman1421
21Demon Cycle*Peter V. Brett1412
22Powder MageBrian McClellan1238
23The Chronicles of NarniaC.S. Lewis12-2
24TiganaGuy Gavriel Kay123
25The Dark TowerStephen King12-12
26Jonathan Strange & Mr NorrellSusanna Clarke124
27Lightbringer*Brent Weeks118
28The Chronicles of The Black CompanyGlen Cook11-11
29The SilmarillionJ.R.R. Tolkien1113
30The MagiciansLev Grossman1114
31His Dark MaterialsPhilip Pullman11-13
32Wormwildbow11N
33Night AngelBrent Weeks1026
34The HobbitJ.R.R. Tolkien1018
35Tawny ManRobin Hobb1012
36The Book of The New SunGene Wolfe8-8
37Hyperion CantosDan Simmons7N
38The Drenai SagaDavid Gemmell7-16
39The Riyria Chronicles*Michael J. Sullivan7N
40Good OmensNeil Gaiman/Terry Pratchett731
41The Empire TrilogyRaymond E. Feist/Janny Wurts729
42The Chronicles of AmberRoger Zelazny7-13
43The Witcher*Andrzej Sapkowski65
44New CrobuzonChina Miéville619
45Kushiel's LegacyJacqueline Carey627
46The HeroesJoe Abercrombie67
47The Legend of DrizztR.A. Salvatore6N
48Liveship TradersRobin Hobb6-8
49The Once and Future KingT.H. White626
50Long Price QuartetDaniel Abraham523
51AbhorsenGarth Nix54
52The Iron Druid Chronicles*Kevin Hearne5N
53GormenghastMervyn Peake536
54American GodsNeil Gaiman5-34
55Low TownDaniel Polansky4x
56The BelgariadDavid Eddings4x
57Dune ChroniclesFrank Herbert4x
58Under HeavenGuy Gavriel Kay4x
59River of StarsGuy Gavriel Kay4x
60The Fionavar TapestryGuy Gavriel Kay4x
61NeverwhereNeil Gaiman4x
62StardustNeil Gaiman4x
63The Riftwar SagaRaymond E. Feist4x
64Watership DownRichard Adams4x
65The StandStephen King4x
66Vlad Taltos*Steven Brust4x
67The Princess BrideWilliam Goldman4x
68Dragonriders of PernAnne McCaffrey3x
69Chronicle of the Unhewn Throne*Brian Staveley3x
70The Coldfire TrilogyC.S. Friedman3x
71The Orphan's TalesCatherynne M. Valente3x
72The Dagger and the Coin*Daniel Abraham3x
73The Shadow Campaigns*Django Wexler3x
74Dread EmpireGlen Cook3x
75The Sarantine MosaicGuy Gavriel Kay3x
76Kate Daniels*Ilona Andrews3x
77AmbergrisJeff VanderMeer3x
78Best Served ColdJoe Abercrombie3x
79DeverryKatharine Kerr3x
80The Chronicles of PrydainLloyd Alexander3x
81The Acts of CaineMatthew Woodring Stover3x
82InheritanceN.K. Jemisin3x
83Riddle-MasterPatricia A. McKillip3x
84The Last UnicornPeter S. Beagle3x
85Conan the BarbarianRobert E. Howard3x
345 Upvotes

274 comments sorted by

58

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Some observations:

  • A chart of vote vs. rank, and a pie chart of the top ten. Notice that it is less steep compared to last year - no. 1 and 2 are neck and neck, I had to double check their votes. ASOIAF is no longer in a clear lead. Is this because of people gettting frustrated at the lack of progress? Maybe. KKC is definitely poised to gain the top spot next year.

  • A word cloud of the titles, and of the authors. Why? I dunno, just always wanted to make a word cloud.

  • Number of entries - 249, number of votes - 1741, time spent counting and listing - 8 hours.

  • Predictably, Sanderson's Stormlight Archive has become much more popular now - Words of Radiance was released after last year's list. My guess is that the series will continue to climb.

  • Perhaps the most dramatic rise has been of /u/MichaelJSullivan's Riyria Revelations (and Chronicles also made the list), Anthony Ryan's Raven's Shadow, the Lions of Al-Rassan (Kay seems to have done better overall too), and Powder Mage trilogy.

  • Mistborn has gone down. I don't know what is wrong with you people. /s

  • For a time while making the list it seemed Harry Potter would lose it's spot in the top ten, and I was like "Oh no oh no no nononoooo", but all's well that ends well.

  • I remember /u/BrianMcClellan saying it would be interesting to see how the list would change over time. Well, there you have it. There are no huge upheavals - nerds still like LoTR. But there have been changes. Also, congrats for Powder Mage having one of the best positive change.

  • I've tried to be as accurate as possible, but if anyone finds any errors, please point them out to me. I would've liked to create a Goodreads list too, but I'm totally exhausted right now, so that'll have to wait. Thank you all for participating, and to the mods for cooperating.

29

u/ZuFFuLuZ Mar 27 '15

What it shows is that this is a popularity contest and not really about the quality of the books. And it shows that actively promoting your books in online communities does wonders. No offense to any of the authors we have here (I love having you guys here), but I am pretty sure this is the only place where they rank this high.

70

u/mistborn Stabby Winner, AMA Author Brandon Sanderson Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Though I generally agree with you, I wouldn't worry about it too much. This is just how these things go. I doubt that even those voting would honestly place me above LotR--it's just that they've read me more recently.

Experience has proven that the only real test of a piece of literature is longevity. While there's no way that Rothfuss or I deserve to be anywhere near a top ten best fantasy list, we're the new hot items (which feels weird to say, because we're both close to ten years on the scene now) and so are in the forefront of people's minds.

If I'm still making any kind of list like this in twenty years, I'll start to feel that I might have made something reasonably impactful in the genre.

Curiously, if I were to have made a list like this in the early nineties, when I was graduating high school, I highly suspect Thomas Covenant, the Elenium, or Memory Sorrow and Thorn would be in the Sanderson/Rothfuss positions on that list. Now, those three didn't even make the list.

EDIT: Who mixed up my pronouns? I mixed up my pronouns. Man, it's a good thing I have a copy editor for the important stuff.

14

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

I'm pretty sure you'll be making the list twenty years down the line, for the simple reason that even at a book every two years, Stormlight will take about 15-16 years to complete, so at that time it will be kind of in the same place WoT is today.

Also, given the way you've been improving yourself, it's safe to say that when the next wave of your stuff comes around, it will be just as popular, if not more, given that it will also start to (I think) bring together the bigger plot of the Cosmere.

4

u/hodgkinsonable Mar 28 '15

I'm sorry to be the one to tell you but The Stormlight Archive is going to be longer than that. Sanderson has said before that he is going to take a nice long break (of about 3 years) between the first 5 and the second 5 books, partially so he doesn't burn out and also so he has plenty of time to work on his other books. So by the time that 3 year or so break is done it will take around 2 more years to finish the 6th book, so from now til the final SA book it's much more likely to be 18-19 years.

Though you never know he might smash out the final couple of books even faster than ever before.

2

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

I know, I was just taking a lower bound

14

u/Nuke_ Mar 28 '15

I honestly wouldn't be surprised if he "accidentally" finished the 6th stormlight book during his break.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Surprised (and slightly saddened) at the absence of Tad Williams.

7

u/Pandam4n Worldbuilders Aug 12 '15

Sorry for replying to such an old comment, but I only came across this list for the first time today, including this comment. I just wanted to say that while the votes for who is the better author between you and Tolkien might swing another way, I have no doubt that many people today enjoyed your books more than they did Lord of the Rings. I certainly did, and I enjoyed Rothfuss' and many other authors' books more, too.

Good books are not necessarily more enjoyable, nor are enjoyable books necessarily good (though yours are definitely both I feel), but since this was a vote for your favourite books/series, not the objective best, it doesn't surprise me at all to see you and others ahead of Tolkien. I struggled a lot with some of the slower parts of LOTR when I was younger, to the point that I'm reluctant to read them again now, a little over a decade later. I have massive respect for the Tolkien and the amount of work and creativity he put into building a universe that the trilogy is such a small part of but in the end that doesn't make the trilogy any easier to get through.

I'm sure a part of it is changing times, changing expectations and the vocabulary of that time becoming less relevant, and I'm sure the same will happen to books published today once they get to be as old as LOTR is, but I have no doubt people will be reading and loving your books in 80 years too.

2

u/flyinfungi Mar 28 '15

I'm glad you said this. I saw your work at top and thought to myself. "No way do you deserve to be up there! You aren't even done with the series yet."

Love your work though and you are my favorite author. Please keep up the good work man. I think you are a long lasting force to be reckoned with in literature.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/CurtLablue Mar 27 '15

Well it's all really a popularity contest if it involves voting. Heck professional hall of fames are just as political or popularity things. While there would be some changes I think if you surveyed the general fantasy audience it wouldn't be a radical change.

1

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 28 '15

Um, that's kinda the point. The poll was asking for people's favourite novels. Not those they thought were the best quality.

19

u/eferoth Mar 27 '15

American Gods took quite the plunge. Really glad that Worm made the cut. The rate that it's mentioned on here lately makes me think that one will continue to rise.

Paging /u/wildbow for motivational reasons. :)

Oh and thanks for compiling. I was sceptical as well, but there are some interesting changes.

11

u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Apr 26 '15

Perhaps the most dramatic rise has been of /u/MichaelJSullivan's Riyria Revelations (and Chronicles also made the list),

Woohoo! Always looking for sign posts of things moving in a positive direction - and this one was a big one!

27

u/Chris_225 Mar 27 '15

If I had known the Hyperion Cantos counted as fantasy it would have topped my list. Hyperion all the way down at 37 just seems like a crime against humanity. Ok, grumbling done. Thanks for doing this list.

7

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Well the later books are almost all out SF, but Hyperion itself felt pretty much fantasy when I read it.

16

u/REkTeR Mar 27 '15

Honestly I'm having a hard time understanding how you can even say that, but I don't really feel the need to start an argument, so I'll let it go.

This time.

8

u/Escapement Mar 27 '15

The line between super soft sci-fi and outright fantasy is not all that firm. I would count the Hyperion Cantos a mixture of genres - look at all the effectively magical powers of the Void Which Binds, and the magical stuff with the muse and the god of empathy, and all the other stuff... the sci-fi is extremely soft.

8

u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Well rather than just calling it magic, I prefer to look at it this way:

Science fiction - the improbable made possible

Fantasy - the impossible made probable

― Rod Serling.

To me, the magic in Hyperion & Fall of Hyperion falls into the "improbable made possible" category, so I'd call it SF.

But yeah the Endymion books get into some weird metaphysics, so I get why someone would call it fantasy.

4

u/ManicCetra Mar 27 '15

Personally, I found Hyperion always sat firmly on the Sci-fi side of the line, even at its most outré. Everything it did appeared to take modern technology and concepts to logical points of development far into the future, which is one of the key defining features of the genre to me.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

The line between super soft sci-fi and outright fantasy is not all that firm.

And most people that like one like the other, that's why they are grouped together under the scifi/fantasy umbrella at book stores. I'm sure there are some that only like one or the other but I've never met anyone like that.

10

u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Well it isn't as if Hyperion exactly needs it. It usually tops the SF lists anyway.

1

u/Farronthedeuce Mar 28 '15

I could never get into Hyperion. It sits on my shelf with a bookmark stuck halfway through it. Maybe I should give it another go.

7

u/The_Mad_Duke Reading Champion III Mar 27 '15

Thanks /u/potterhead! Great to have another list this year, hope this will become a yearly tradition now, it will be fun to track changes over time.

American Gods has fallen a lot. Guess many Gaiman fans have voted for The Sandman instead this year (which is much higher on the list this time).

3

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

That's exactly why I posted this. There was this discussion a while back about how the list won't change much year to year, and so this year the mods went with favorite authors, so I decided to take matters into my own hands.

I certainly intend for this to be a yearly thing.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

To be honest, while I think the observable changes are interesting, the list here just backs up exactly why I decided not to do another one of these this year. You have all the same titles as last year, just shuffled around a bit. Seeing the big gainers is definitely fun, but it's still the same exact books as last year.

You've got five new entries out of 84 listed titles, and of those, two of them were actually on last year's list. Worm and the Iron Druid books were both there last year, if I'm not mistaken.

I'm not trying to say that this wasn't worth your time, and isn't fun to read. Just saying that looking at the list up there completely backs up my decision to go with something new, in my opinion.

EDIT: Those two actually weren't on the list last year! They did receive a vote apiece, though, which is why they're in my head from last year. I just didn't list the one vote books.

8

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

Is worm really that good?

5

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Hey, I just counted the votes, you gotta ask those who voted for it. That said, I've run across worm recommendations a lot of times, and methinks it really must have something going for it to be so popular even though it's a webserial, not even a proper ebook out yet.

2

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

Yeah, nothing against your process. I was really hoping someone would chime in with why they like it. When I first started hearing about it, I read a quick summary and it didn't sound that appealing at all, esp. compared to the other stuff the usually gets mentioned here.

4

u/EtherealDuck Mar 27 '15

Wouldn't let quick summaries put you off anything, a lot of premises sound really stupid but it's all about the execution, and Worm is good.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Different strokes for different folks, but, if you like smart characters that make their way by being clever and prepared rather than using awesome powers, it's for you.

11

u/devotedpupa Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

Also, huge largescale battles vs monsters that are basically raid bosses that don't differentiate between important characters or backgrounds. High risk, actual stakes for actually well written characters, awesome fights.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Escapement Mar 27 '15

Worm is really, really good. The story is very gripping, the plot is interesting, gripping, and poses a number of good twists and turns, and the world Wildbow created is fantastic - detailed, evocative, and at the same time making sense and seeming realistic. There are a number of extremely memorable characters. The world at times gets extremely dark, similar to works like George R R Martin and Joe Abercrombie. The first couple arcs are a little shaky but it steadily improves and the author really finds his voice very well.

I recommend trying it yourself - it's free and online, so it's not like there's a huge opportunity cost for trying it out.

5

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

I recommend trying it yourself - it's free and online, so it's not like there's a huge opportunity cost for trying it out.

That's a good point. It's just that I usually try to finish something if I get very involved in it and it sounds like Worm is encyclopedic in length. Guess I'll put my doubts aside and try it though.

6

u/eferoth Mar 27 '15

It can be enjoyed in short, almost self-contained bursts. A bit similar to Dresden Files in that regard. Think of it as a series of 30 novellas building on each other. I was on and off reading it for a few months, taking breaks between arcs. Very enjoyable read.

12

u/ExcelMN Mar 27 '15

Its awesome. "DC has more continent-breakers, Worm has more broken continents" is a good description I've seen used.

Its smart, its often funny, its brutal as hell, and it follows through its setups and conceits to their logical conclusions.

Note, the first arc is a little slow/slightly choppy while it finds its legs. It starts decent, and quickly progresses to excellent and then stays there until the end.

9

u/fingerboxes Mar 27 '15

Yes. My go-to line is that 'the only reason I don't call Worm the best thing I've ever read is that it would be too melodramatic for my taste'.

4

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

You guys just about have me sold on reading it.

9

u/fingerboxes Mar 27 '15

Everyone I've convinced to read it has been all 'RIP my sleep for the next three weeks'.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I was linked to it from this subreddit, and decided to skim to see if it was worth anything. "Probably not," I thought. "Even if it is good, I don't like reading things online, and my attention span never makes it more than a paragraph or two."

Five hours later, I had to force myself away from the computer to go to sleep.

7

u/meatb4ll Mar 27 '15

I first heard about it in a conversation on some comic TV show subreddit, and I was kind of skeptical. It seemed kind of dumb to start, but I thought I'd give it a chance and at least finish the first arc. It got me hook, line, and sinker. There wasn't any absolute right or wrong - just shades of grey and tortured people trying to do their best.

It kind of reminded me of GoT - I wasn't sure whether I'd like it to start, but found myself hooked by all the ambiguity and different stories that happen. The first chapter is here, and the first arc is only six chapters and an interlude (chapter from another character's POV) long. It's at least worth a chance.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I tried reading it once, and the beginning is rough. That's not surprising, as it's an amateur web serial, and if other folks' opinions are any indicator, the quality improves vastly as it goes.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I am very surprised that the Lions of Al-Rassan beat out Tigana. I mean, I love The Lions... but Tigana has way more critical acclaim. Glad to see Kate Daniels on there representing for the urban fantasy -- even if I like The Hollows more. I'm also surprised American Gods is so low for all the praise it seems to get.

3

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

critical acclaim

But the thing is, this is a list decided by popular vote. It's a measure of popularity, but not quality - even though in my experience there is a correlation between the two

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I voted for Lions above Tigana. I loved both books, but Lions blew Tigana out of the water, in my opinion. It's one of the best books I've ever read, whereas Tigana is amazing, but not nearly as good.

3

u/LetMeSupportYou Mar 27 '15

Tigana left me bitter. I can't even exaclty remember why, but it left me so bitter. The only GKK I haven't read more than once, and probably one of my least favorite.

Different tastes that's all

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I can't decide actually which I liked more. I really liked both.

2

u/SkyCyril Stabby Winner Mar 28 '15

River of Stars master race checking in. ;-)

2

u/devotedpupa Mar 27 '15

I rather like Under Heaven myself.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I have been wanting to read that! I'm on Song for Arbonne right now.

14

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

We really do need a brave soul to run a 'favourite female fantasy author' poll.

13

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Couldn't we just use the normal authors list for that?

15

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

There are 11 female authors on that list - I think there's an appetite to see more listed. There's also an argument that they've been given their chance in the exercise just undertaken.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

How am I supposed to surprise people with my poll topics if you post them in a public forum, Mark?

Seriously, though, that's the next one I'm doing, although it'll be "books/series" as opposed to authors. I plan on putting up the voting thread in a few months. wish has another poll she'll be doing here in the next month, I believe.

3

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 28 '15

Ohh, what's wish got in-store for us? Or is it a surprise?

8

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Here is a spoiler: JK Rowling & Robin Hobb win. =)

5

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

I don't know....do you know how many people I run across that are still going 'wait, Robin Hobb is a woman?' lol. (But, I think you're probably right.)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/JannyWurts Stabby Winner, AMA Author Janny Wurts Mar 29 '15

Nice thought - but I truly cringe to see/even consider works by female authors segregated - sad day the suggestion's even necessary. Blind auditions are not possible with books, only gender neutral bylines, and even then.....

A thread discussion might be more informative - what female authors might ought to have made the list. But if a woman posted that - what's already devalued = no change.

Intelligent commentary without the gender tag is what is really needed - and getting there is the rough bit.

Better maybe: a spotlight thread where a popular male author picks a title they want to champion with discussion as to why that title and author may be relevant to their readership - might cut more bait, who knows?

I still say that looking at GoodReads ratings and looking for gender balance amongst the readership is the most reliable tag for finding works that are not written for a biased audience. It's not a take you find most readers considering, though.

Nice thought, Mark - at least you're concerned, that matters.

6

u/elquesogrande Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

We have two lists noted for female speculative fiction writers in the sidebar with plans on updating and featuring later this year.

Favorite was the phrasing used for this poll in order to make this much more personal. Words like top or best seem to bring in sales numbers and sales volumes and such.

We will be exploring other areas for speculative fiction in 2015: International, language, gender, genres, orientation, and any other part of our SFF community that makes sense.

2

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Why does it have to be a brave soul? lol I'd do it.

E: don't we have a list on the sidebar though? I don't remember if it was ranked by favorite author but I know there's a list of women authors. (I'm on mobile atm)

7

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

You didn't see the bit where Potterhead42 said it took 8 hours work to tally the votes etc?

6

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Oh yeah. Well, I'm a jobless bum at the moment and organizing things (including lists of data) is actually kind of fun for me, so I don't think I'd mind all the work. That said, yeah, it is an enormous task.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Don't worry about it. It's on the agenda. :)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Eko_Mister Mar 27 '15

Why?

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Why not?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Dude. You are amazing. Thanks for putting all this data together. I think there were some pretty interesting shifts. I noticed Melanie Rawn's Exiles fell off the list. And I think I counted a total of 13 entries by women authors out of 85. Huh. I wonder what it was last time? Interesting data! Again, thanks!

2

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Last year's top 85 had 14 + 1 co authored books by female writers, and three of those entries were Robin Hobb.

3

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Yeah, three were Hobb this year as well iirc. Huh. So we actually went down a bit in female authors. Ah well.

1

u/AllWrong74 Mar 27 '15

If she ever releases Captal's Tower (and if it's any good given the near 20 year hiatus), maybe more people can get turned onto the series. IMO, the only reason that trilogy hasn't caught on is because it's incomplete. The first two books were mind-bogglingly good, but how do you sell someone on a series that's waited nearly 20 years for book 3?

Supposedly, she's writing it, now. I'll believe that when the publisher says they've received her manuscript. I've been crushed over this book too damned many times.

1

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

That's a fair point. I enjoyed the first one enough on its own that I guess I don't always think of it in the context of it being a series, tbh.

3

u/JayRedEye Mar 27 '15

Thanks for all the hard work. It is interesting to see the subtle shifts in tastes and trends.

As always, we are very much biased towards The New Hotness. I would like to see a list of older works, say pre-1985 or so. But how many lists do we really need?

9

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

You can never have too may knives lists.

4

u/Monsterpocalypse Mar 27 '15

Thank you for all the work you put in! Would it be possible to do a favorites list of favorite non-fantasy books?

14

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

But... this is a fantasy sub. I am confused.

8

u/Monsterpocalypse Mar 27 '15

?

I mean favorite non-fantasy books among fantasy readers, rather than the general population.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Why don't you make a thread about this? I think it's a fascinating idea, but I don't think it'll be a "big list" anytime soon. We've got a queue of lists over the next few months we'll be doing, already.

3

u/ReallySeriouslyNow Mar 27 '15

I was equally confused at first, but that isn't a bad idea. Would it just be non fantasy? Or non speculative fiction? I suspect a non fantasy poll here would result in a list of mostly sci-fi.

2

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

/u/Monsterpocalypse's idea is a good one, it would be interesting to see what non-fantasy books that /r/fantasy readers enjoy.

4

u/Managore Mar 28 '15

I imagine a lot of sci-fi will make the cut.

3

u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

I think a poll like that would be really hard to do. It's probably easier to narrow down your favorite's from a certain genre then it would be to just say 'name your favorite books that aren't X'. How many people would list the same books? A few might come up, but out of all the books that aren't fantasy, I don't know, it seems like it would be a difficult poll to do.

That being said, the topic does come up once in a while, of what people are reading besides fantasy. I think there was a thread yesterday about it, iirc. (I enjoy these threads! Just think a poll would be difficult to pull off.)

2

u/here_for_the_lols Mar 27 '15

I havent read enough so didnt feel i could vote. I am starting near the top though thats promising!

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Maybe next year!

2

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 27 '15

Well done! This must have taken some time. Thank you!

2

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Oh yes, eight hours, but who's counting ;)

You're welcome!

1

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 28 '15

On break at the moment, or just procrastinating really hard? ;)

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

Why not both? We just had exams, so I declared a break myself, and of course, like all true redditors, I'm a master procastinator.

1

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Mar 28 '15

Nice. Exams went smoothly?

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 29 '15

As always, better than feared, worse than hoped.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/phrakture Mar 27 '15

Anhony Ryan

typo.

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

thanks, fixed!

2

u/Emospence Jun 30 '15

The * for incomplete series is great.

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Jun 30 '15

I'm glad you appreciate the effort.

109

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

One vote off the top 10! :o

Given that 10th place goes to the biggest selling fantasy book of all time (or 2nd biggest), I think we can say that there's a strong demographic factor here, and also that I (like Messrs Sullivan and McClellan) benefited from being on 'home-turf'.

That said, it's a huge honour and I'm extremely grateful for all the votes - means a lot.

14

u/DeleriumTrigger Mar 27 '15

And, ironically, about the only thing in common between your books and HP is the inclusion of a 14 year old :)

16

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

Doesn't HP also include the immolation of a household pet? ... or am I misremembering?

18

u/Eschamali Mar 27 '15

Dumbledore set a chicken on fire, yes!

3

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '15

Isn't that just in Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality? I could have sworn that was just in HPMOR.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Yes, a character named Ron eventually gets so annoyed with this cat called "Crookshanks" that he sets the poor thing on fire. I'm completely sure that's how it went.

3

u/PlatoandtheSunshines Mar 27 '15

Actually...yes. Yes, it did.

3

u/Leigh_Wright Mar 28 '15

Cue the fanfiction: 'The Broken Potter' or 'Harry Empire' anyone?

(Actually, 'The Broken Potter' could get a little bit too grimdark..) :P

5

u/woodbuck Mar 27 '15

I missed that voting thread and would have totally included Broken Empire, tying you with Harry Potter, so I think that pretty much means you should expect to sell your next 100 million+ books soon.

2

u/Managore Mar 28 '15

Out of curiosity, what are your favourite (non Mark Lawrence) fantasy novels?

2

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 28 '15

My votes are top of the voting thread http://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/2zk51x/the_all_time_top_rfantasy_novels_2015_edition/

On the day before and after several entries might swap with others in my top 10.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BigZ7337 Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

Damn, you were my #6th favorite series, I should have switched you with one of the two Robin Hobb series in my top 5. :/

1

u/the_weagle Mar 28 '15

Aw man! Picked up your second book two weeks ago and have been waiting for your first to make it to my house via media mail since then. Starting to think it may have been lost... Looking forward to reading. Next vote you may have another loyal follower!

2

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 28 '15

Thanks for the sales! I hope book 1 turns up.

1

u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Apr 26 '15

Agreed - and feel similarly.

1

u/boxsalesman Jul 21 '15 edited Jul 23 '15

I have never used this subreddit for anything except the top book list, I did not know you were a regular here.

That being said, I just finished Emperor Of Thorns, I completely loved your books, They are among my favourite books of all time and I enjoyed them more than Harry Potter or Game Of Thrones.

You did a really great job and I'd like to thank you for the wonderful reading experience.

2

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Jul 21 '15

Great to hear! I'm very glad you enjoyed them.

Once you've inflicted any book-hangover on another author, you might like to try The Red Queen's War trilogy that starts with Prince of Fools, also set in the Broken Empire.

19

u/REkTeR Mar 27 '15

Interesting to see the Hyperion Cantos make the list - I know that a lot of the time Scifi and Fantasy are seen as just two sides of the same coin, but you really have to be very, very liberal to apply the Fantasy tag to Hyperion.

I'm also super excited to see Worm on the list - no joke, it may be my absolute favorite out of everything I've read for the last 2 years.

10

u/MadrunBadrun Mar 27 '15

Because of that I am adding Worm to my reading list.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bahamut19 Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

It's certainly a very nice list, but I'm a bit uncomfortable that the 3 best of all time are unfinished works. It will be interesting to see if they stay there when they're finished.

Edit: Having said that if you take out the unfinished ones from the top 10, you end up with LoTR, WoT, Malazan, Discworld, First Law, and Harry Potter. They're certainly be the first 6 that come to my mind if asked to write a list of the best finished fantasy works of all time.

1

u/dragonicus Mar 28 '15

A flag for each unfinished series on the list would probably be a worthwhile addition, /u/potterhead42.

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

I'm no vexillologist, so you'll just have to make do with asterisks. I'll do it in a couple days. Good suggestion, thanks!

1

u/Frinall Apr 21 '15

That's an interesting observation. I agree that it will be interesting to see how they fare once completed. I know that the last couple books of GoT soured my positive impression of the first couple (not that my lack of vote seems to have hurt it too badly!), and if the WoT were still in a similar limbo, books 6-9 probably would have hurt its legacy in my eyes.

8

u/Ted_Cross Writer Ted Cross Mar 27 '15

To have Conan at the bottom is just so wrong. I guess the younger generation is ignoring the classics. Maybe they think of him as a comic, but the novels are brilliant.

3

u/Mr_Noyes Mar 27 '15

Getting old is not for sissies ;)

2

u/techsupportredditor Mar 27 '15

Everyone has there own tastes, I actually like most of the books in the middle to the bottom of the list.

GRRM i got 1/2 thru the first book and called it a day, just couldn't do it.

2

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

Being old doesn't mean it should be at the top of the list, as new and better things come out, they displace the old stuff, otherwise every bestof list would have Beowulf at the top. I look forward to the day that there are enough good things out to push Tolkien down from 4th to 50th or so.

11

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Ted_Cross Writer Ted Cross Mar 27 '15

How? It said Top novels of all time. And the best fantasy books don't really get dated. You could read A Wizard of Earthsea today and have no idea it was so old unless you happened to know that already. Same with the Conan books and many other classics. I like authors like Sanderson okay, but his writing doesn't come close to Le Guin or Howard.

10

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Well they do. Each new generation of authors builds upon what the previous ones did. That's how you get cliches, and tropes, and people subverting tropes and all that. Take WoT for instance - even if I didn't know when it was written, it would be pretty easy to guess it was written sometime after LoTR, maybe around the '80s or '90s. It certainly reads very differently from the current crop of fantasy.

And honestly, if Conan were so ageless, it would've been up there, with LoTR.

5

u/Ted_Cross Writer Ted Cross Mar 27 '15

We'll just have to agree to disagree. Howard is one of the Fantasy giants, and I don't see how anyone can honestly disagree unless they simply haven't read his work. Almost all fantasy writers today were influenced by him to some degree.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

No, it said the "top /r/fantasy novels of all time." In other words, these are this community's favorite books, not the best books ever.

If I was voting as to what I thought were the best, most seminal, most important fantasy novels of all time, my top five would have looked very different.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Ted_Cross Writer Ted Cross Mar 27 '15

It would have been a dishonest depiction of the period if it didn't. I think any author today who sanitizes their work is wrong to do so. We don't have to agree with racism or sexism in order to depict it honestly.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Anna_Smith-Spark AMA Author Anna Smith-Spark Mar 27 '15

What interests me is the semantic difference between 'favourite' and 'best'. A list of my favourite novels would probably have looked quite different from a list of the novels I think are the 'best' (hi, Mark Lawrence, I'd have been that voted you needed.... Sorry). And my favourite sequence might have been different to my favourite standalone novel.

But this poll had reassured me I'm not quite as unfashionable as I thought.

Thank you for all the work you put in on it. And I'll be on it one day, if it kills me....

10

u/Ominus666 Mar 27 '15

No Thomas Covenant anywhere? No Elric? For shame.

4

u/pimdiffy Mar 27 '15

Came here looking for Thomas Covenant. Sorely disappointed not to see it.

2

u/Ominus666 Mar 27 '15

I didn't see the voting thread, so I missed out adding it. From what I saw, though, there was only one other recommendation for it. It's a real shame, too--Covenant, along with Elric, are seminal examples of the antihero archetype that seems to be so prevalent in recent fantasy.

3

u/pimdiffy Mar 27 '15

I could really care less about the "antihero" trend so popularized across all entertainment in complete honesty. The Land of Donaldson is the most palpable - although not necessarily most thorough - fantasy world, in my humble opinion. I think Farland does a good job of this as well, if not quite on the same caliber. Thomas Covenant's embodiment of hatred and impotence as tools for survival are unmatched in practice, albeit a fairly common set of traits.

5

u/Ominus666 Mar 27 '15

Oh I'm with you. I remember poring over my oversized Atlas of the Land while on my 4th reread of the series. The Land and lore of TCoTC are staggering, and Covenant's reluctance and impotence and rage were incredibly progressive for the genre. In many ways, I think that they still are. Much like Malazan, though, you either love or hate the series. Some people just can't get over Covenant's actions when he first arrives in the Land.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bartonar Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

People all want their grimdark stories of villains and slightly-less-cruel-villains these days, calling it 'realism'. Says something about the times.

EDIT - Seeing this comment later, I feel I should add that I have nothing against that. In fact I enjoy it sometimes, and done well it can be really awesome (see Prince of Thorns, or The Black Company) I just always get the impression from the internet that people think that's all there should be, because 'Good and Evil are unrealistic', and that's where I disagree.

8

u/Sir_SamuelVimes Reading Champion II Mar 27 '15

This lists are fun and I enjoy seeing them. They give a lot of good recommendations based off of what people like.

I guess my biggest complaint is that the ones at the top will always be a few of the absolute greatest, plus whatever is temporarily trending. It's great to see newer authors like Brian McClellan and Mark Lawrence at the top, but outside of this Reddit circle are their books popular enough to crack the top 50? Would they really supplant classics like Prydain, Conan, The Last Unicorn, Pern, The Hobbit, etc?

I doubt you'll see the Stormlight Archives above Lord of the Rings on most lists. I'm sure it's phenomenal and I really want to read the first two books eventually, but to put that above a definitive work of fantasy seems so odd. I suppose the benefit in that is seeing what people love that's newer to the genre.

13

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

Every vote is a product of its environment. If you want absolutes perhaps the all-time best SELLING list is of more interest. I rock in on that at 195th :)

7

u/Sir_SamuelVimes Reading Champion II Mar 27 '15

Hell, that's awesome. Your debut was only published what, 4 years ago? To crack that list is an amazing accomplishment. Congrats.

This does remind me of another point I wanted to make which fall under your "product of its environment" statement. I wonder if having the presence of the newer authors on Reddit, Goodreads, etc. leads to an increase in popularity and votes. I've seen your reviews a few times when I research books on Goodreads, I've seen Patrick Rothfuss review novels there, etc. I'm sure that has its advantages.

6

u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Mar 27 '15

I'm sure visibility and accessibility have some positive effect.

+Sorry - I meant to add a link to that list I mentioned: http://thewertzone.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/the-updated-sff-all-time-sales-list.html

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

I rock in on that at 195th :)

That's still pretty respectable.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I've seen these arguments before, and I think they're missing the original intent of these lists. The point of these isn't to create any sort of definitive "best fantasy of all time" list, it's to make a definitive "/r/fantasy's favorite fantasy of all time" list. These are the books we, as a community, love the most. That's it.

1

u/Frinall Apr 21 '15

This is an important clarification. I know my (and I'm sure many others') votes might have changed a fair amount if the original prompt had said "best" rather than "favorite".

For example, ASoIaF is definitely one of the "best" fantasy series I've ever read, the quality of the writing is high, the world is believable and the characters are some of the deepest and most complex I've ever read. It is a VERY good series... But I wouldn't put it on my top 10 favorite list. There are just things about it that are not up my alley as a reader. Doesn't make it bad, doesn't mean it doesn't deserve the praise and accolades it has received, but that's the difference between "Best of" lists and "favorite" lists.

1

u/paranoiainc Mar 27 '15 edited Jul 07 '15

3

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

But it is. It's part of the Second Apocalypse series.

1

u/paranoiainc Mar 27 '15 edited Jul 07 '15

1

u/dowhatuwant2 Apr 28 '15

Can you actually use a poll to do these next time? The current method seems pretty poor in my opinion.

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Apr 28 '15

actually use a poll

How do you mean? Was this not already a poll?

1

u/dowhatuwant2 Apr 28 '15

As in use a polling website. Jesus man it takes you 8 hours to compile the results whereas an actual poll would do it for you.

Just put in all the usual suspects as options and add any extras that people request as you go. Also if possible make the selection time last a month rather than a week, I personally completely missed the chance to put my votes down but you'll certainly get more people participating if its just ticking 5 checkboxes as opposed to typing in 5 lines of text, people are lazy.

2

u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Aug 12 '15

The problem with that is it will only have "the usual suspects" whereas when people can write in their choices - we get a much more comprehensive list.

1

u/DaedalusMinion Aug 20 '15

I have no idea how/why I missed the voting on this. Great list and thank you for the effort, I had modmailed y'all 6 months back begging for a post like this. So happy.

2

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Aug 20 '15

Thanks!

Also, just to be clear, I'm not one of the mods here.

1

u/DaedalusMinion Aug 20 '15

Haha I know, I was just making a general comment. And why not apply to be a mod?

1

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Aug 20 '15

For now the mods are handling the sub pretty well, so I don't think there's any need for me. If they look for new applicants, I'll definitely try.

3

u/alexsbradshaw Reading Champion Mar 27 '15

Well done for making this, it's awesome :D

It's really interesting to see it against last year's list too, so thank you to both /u/potterhead42 and /u/p0x0rz for all their hard work!

I think it's also quite interesting that Song of Ice and Fire has kept the top spot but compared to last year has actually lost 50 votes

3

u/Jakkubus Mar 27 '15

Isn't Worm rather Sci-Fi novel than Fantasy?

5

u/eferoth Mar 27 '15

Depends how you place superheroes. Sandersons Reckoners is basically the same premise. For me it's Urban Fantasy with superheroes. Very character and power driven.

4

u/Escapement Mar 27 '15

I don't think it falls strictly under either. For most practical purposes the majority of the work felt like a fantasy novel, but I could see shelving it under either. While the powers that form the major distinction between Worm and real life fiction are not exactly magic, they're not exactly anything close to conventional physics either.

3

u/Cloneable Mar 27 '15

As much as I like stormlight archive, isn't it a little soon for it to be beating out LOTR? There's still room for a phantom menace instalment over the course of 8 more books.

1

u/Frinall Apr 21 '15

This list is for people's favorite books. What the voting shows it that for many people, (myself included) the published books from the Stormlight Archive are among their favorites. No one is saying it is more influential than LotR or better than LotR, just that we like it more. Personal preference.

2

u/prodsor Mar 27 '15

Many thanks for all the great work putting this together. :-)

2

u/jcb6939 Mar 27 '15

I think it would interesting if people can only vote for one book/series and see how much the list changes

I doubt WOT and Malazan would change much, but I feel like ASOIAF would lose its first place spot

2

u/alexsbradshaw Reading Champion Mar 27 '15

I think you're right, and I feel like if that were the case the LOTR might get a few more votes too.

1

u/yodadamanadamwan Reading Champion Mar 28 '15

I think there's a lot more people that have read asoiaf and haven't read much else though, it's an insanely popular series

1

u/jcb6939 Mar 28 '15

Yeah, but not in this sub reddit

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Irishscribe Mar 27 '15

No L.E. Modesitt? No Elizabeth Moon? Seriously?

Interesting, but a list that doesn't have room among 85 slots for The Deed of Paksenarrion and The Saga of Recluce is completely puzzling. I love Guy Gavriel Kay, but including him 6 times and completely forgetting about Moon and Modesitt is bizarre.

3

u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Moon and Modesitt are on last year's list as well as this year's favorite authors list, but for some reason nobody voted for them in this list.

6

u/Irishscribe Mar 27 '15

I don't take issue with people liking any of these books, but maybe it should be called the "Fantasy we like at the moment" list. I have trouble conceiving of a "greatest of " list that doesn't include Elizabeth Moon, Andre Norton, Tad Williams, L.E. Modesitt, Terry Brooks, Kathryn Kurtz, Melanie Rawn. They may not be currently popular, but that doesn't affect their greatness.

It's a fine currently popular list, but it's a real stretch for top fantasy novels of all time.

4

u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Yeah I guess the title could have been better. I think the "of all time" was just to clarify that this wasn't only for books published in 2015.

Anyway, as it says in the poll

This thread isn't meant to be a commentary on what series/books are objectively best...Just what you Redditors love the most.

Most readers here (am not being a snob, this includes me) got into fantasy fairly recently and via the currently popular books (also, /r/fantasy's majority demographic is <30 years old), so it tends to be heavily weighted towards the recent favorites.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Not trying to dismiss your concerns here - from the mods' comments above there are plans for lists based on subgenre, language, gender, etc, and then there's the underrated/underread list too. All these together should give a better picture of a "greatest-of-all-time" list.

But still, any list is better than having no lists at all :)

2

u/Falstaffsword Mar 27 '15

Man I have a lot of reading to do.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Oh son of a bitch did Fahfrd and the Grey Mouser only get 2 votes

THIS IS AN OUTRAGE

2

u/bengraven Mar 28 '15

Conan, Abhorsen, and Once and Future King are too low, too low. holds his heart

2

u/yodadamanadamwan Reading Champion Mar 28 '15

I tried to read lies of Locke lamora, the first gentlemens bastards book and I was 100 pages in and still bored which is weird because I love long con heist type stuff

2

u/Yggdrazzil Mar 28 '15

A Song of Ice and fire on the number 1 spot? I'm surprised. And Stormlight Archive with only 2 books out that high up, wow, looks like mr. Sanderson has got quite the challenge laid out for him.

2

u/TheDreylingKing Mar 28 '15

I still think it would be cooler to see an actual list of novels and not series. Would be a lot more interesting to see where everything ranks without the big series dominating everything. Hell I'd run it myself but I'm a lurker and we just did this one so I don't want to step on any toes.

2

u/Irishscribe Mar 28 '15

I wonder what this poll would look like if it asked people to vote for page-for-page best quality based on characterization, tight plots, consistently engaging dialogue, compelling storylines, etc. Basically, which fantasy author gives the best bang for the buck on every page s/he writes.

In my opinion, I can't imagine Jordan's WOT even cracking the top 10. I think that if you broke all the series included in this list into single volumes and left each volume to be voted on its own merits, none of the books written by Jordan would make the top 10 (except perhaps Vol. 1). I think what we have here is the sheer weight and longevity of a 14-volume series written by two authors somewhat overwhelming any objective criteria of what it means to be the "greatest of all time."

WOT is perhaps the best example of the whole being judged greater than the sum of its parts.

2

u/aidanmoher Writer Aidan Moher Aug 11 '15

Ryan's Raven's Shadow trilogy @ #16.

Why? Because there're waaaay too many books published to ever have a chance of keeping up, and the lukewarm-to-poor reception of the second and third volumes has me looking elsewhere whenever it's time to pick up a new series.

2

u/skayya Mar 27 '15

I'm kinda surprised at how high the Gentleman Bastard series is on the list. I loved the first book, and enjoyed the second, but Republic of Thieves just killed it for me.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

The format of the vote was to vote for your favorite book, and if it is happened to be in a series then the vote would count towards the series. LoLL still holds up as a great book even if the sequels aren't as well received. Still looking forward to The Thorn of Emberlain myself.

1

u/skayya Mar 27 '15

Oh, that makes a lot more sense. I assumed it was based on the entire series.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

See, I loved Republic.

1

u/ACDtubes Mar 27 '15

I wouldn't say I DISLIKED it, but it felt a little bit like the series jumped the shark, and for a character who was talked up so much in the previous two novels Sabetha was really, really unlikable for a variety of reasons.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tomolly Writer Tom Wright Mar 27 '15

Wow, thanks for putting it all together. What a bunch of hard work.

Can't wait to see the stats next year. I love data.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

Love Mistborn. If somehow you haven't read it do so immediately.

1

u/MadrunBadrun Mar 27 '15

Dude, You should ascend to godhood for this great deed.

1

u/shrodi Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

Argh! More books added to my reading list! Currently on a science fiction kick, a return to fantasy has to be scheduled soon. I wish I could super speed read, too many good written worlds to explore, will I ever finish even scratching the surface?

edit: huh, 29/85. fail :( Though I have no interest in reading several of those books listed, like Conan or Pern or The Magicians.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '15

I love that I've read at least half this list. I love that I now have half a list to go read.

1

u/Praetor80 Mar 28 '15

Lord of the Rings is way too low, and DragonLance Chronicles arent' even on it?

Great list though.

1

u/BigZ7337 Worldbuilders Mar 28 '15

This is a great list, thanks for putting it together! Would there be any interest in an updated list challenges thing for this year's favorites? I made the one last year, and I wouldn't mind throwing another one together. This is the thread from last year: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/21jqyc/how_many_of_the_rfantasys_2014_top_novelsseries/

1

u/Wizardof1000Kings May 19 '15

Wow, Glen Cook had a huge drop from last year.

-1

u/desert_mp Mar 27 '15

How did Terry Goodkind not make this list? SOT is an amazing collection of work. You can definitely see the "trendy" ones up top. SOIAF was never so popular until the tv series. I read it back in middle school. LOTR....it's declining because the movies are getting older. This list gave me a nice idea of what I'm working on reading next. Sad to see a great collection like Drizzt by Salvatore be so low. But everyone has their opinions, that's what makes these list so wonderful!

9

u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Come on guys, downvoting because you disagree is not cool

4

u/ReallySeriouslyNow Mar 27 '15

I didn't downvote the comment, but I almost didn't bother reading to the polite bit at the end of it because it just seemed like another commenter complaining that their favorites didn't do as well they should have. It gets old when every other comment is someone complaining about what didn't make the list or that a book/series they think is superior didn't rank higher.

4

u/nightwing13 Mar 27 '15

Especially since he was so polite and clearly stated he respects others opinions. Guess others can't do the same.

20

u/elquesogrande Worldbuilders Mar 27 '15

Short answer is that this is a community poll based on voting for Top-5 favorites. Anyone could have participated - this is based on the hundreds that did so.

Can't help but notice that you didn't vote for Goodkind either. Seems a bit disingenuous to complain about others doing the same.

8

u/Suppafly Mar 27 '15

Can't help but notice that you didn't vote for Goodkind either. Seems a bit disingenuous to complain about others doing the same.

Oh snap!

1

u/desert_mp Apr 19 '15

I apologize...I thought the poll was over when I was reading the list.

10

u/darxander Mar 27 '15

It's not rated highly because people feel (myself included) it steals a LOT of stuff from other fantasy series (especially The Wheel of Time), and since TWOT has a lot of fans (it stands at number 6 in this list) there is going to be a lot of disgust at Goodkinds books. Personally I stopped reading Sword of Truth after the third installment because it became predictable

11

u/nightwing13 Mar 27 '15 edited Mar 27 '15

While I voted for SOT and agree it should be on the list, you came to the wrong neighborhood friend. I gave up defending him to people long ago. But its reddit. A republican wouldn't do well in r/politics, a metalhead wouldn't do well in r/music, communities get formed with similar interests and values and this one is as anti Goodkind as it can get.

I wanted to mail him a hand grenade a few times myself when reading them its not totally unjustified. The politics are of course the biggest and most valid complaint. While i feel it was used very appropriately in book 6 Faith of the Fallen, books 5 (Soul of the Fire) and book 8 (Naked Empire) were borderline unreadable. But Richards politics and philosophy were EXACTLY what was needed to fight the empirial order and their way of life and their world domination. Is charmander the best pokemon ever with no faults or flaws? No. But against a leaf pokemon youre god damn right he's the best. Up against a water pokemon he obviously won't do well (sorry for weird example hope some people get the reference at least enough to know what i mean). For the context of the story, Richards objectivist philosophy was exactly what was needed. People just need to get over that although you may certainly disagree with it, and understandably so, all philosophies and political views have some validity to them and pushing aside one of the largest and most epic fantasy series because of it is a waste. Although Narnia has christian philosophy all over there (certainly nowhere near the level of objectivism SOT has) and people can overlook that, the same has to be done for SOT.

As for the predictability argument the fucking Belgariad is on that list. (which I also voted for) so that being used as an argument is invalid to me as tons and tons of beloved books on r/fantasy are "predictable." And anyone who says its predictable certainly hasn't stuck with the series past 3 or 4 books. It just flat out isn't predictable to a point you don't enjoy it ESPECIALLY the most recent one Severed Souls.

The argument that they hate Richard and their frustration with Richard baffles me. Maybe its because in the world of the story he is always right and doesnt have flaws, but all r/fantasy talks about is grey characters, not so black and white and all that. Richard is as flawed a protagonist as they come. He kills anyone in his path he doesn't like, is a borderline tyrant with a temper that rivals the hulk. Its strange that a piece of shit like Bayaz or Ninefingers from the first law is universally loved (another series I voted for) when Richard is hated even though to me they are equally flawed just in different ways.

I could go on literally forever about how great the SOT is and how if people could just get over the politics (which is quite a fucking task as its about as subtle as Ayn Rands strap-on raping you in the mouth) people will realize its an incredibly deep and epic series with amazingly original ideas and a unique world and magic system with characters you care about more than most series.

Also Nathan Rahl is the most badass motherfucker to walk the fantasy worlds, not even the haters usually deny that.

SOT is one of my favorite series of all time. There are literally dozens of us on reddit! DOZENS!