r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • May 12 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E05 - The Farm
Week 18! The introduction of Simon! Sorry for the very, very late thread, I was extremely busy.
Watch Online: Netflix | Amazon
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (4 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 47,857 (-4 from last episode. Not sure who they were.)
"Frak" Count: 104 (+5)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 16 (+1 from last episode)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 10 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 6 (+1, I'll count a fire extinguisher as a punch)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 39 (+4)
"So Say We All" Count: 24 (No change)
12
u/HoDoSasude May 13 '14
As a woman, this episode creeps me out. I'd rather be nuked than have someone mess with my ovaries against my will. Kara was bad ass as usual to break out of that place.
8
u/trevdak2 May 14 '14
There was a bit of discussion about that in the commentary. Ratings are king in TV production decisions, and for science fiction, women are the key to high ratings. They worried that this episode would scare them away because it was outside many women's comfort zones. In the end they decided that they were going to do it because cylon reproduction was a major plotline, and they had decided not to dance around dark issues in the past.
6
u/HoDoSasude May 15 '14
Yeah, to me Caprica 6 pretty much seemed the sexy woman for ratings. But I wasn't put off by any of it. I was already hooked with the strong women characters, and I understand the reproduction plotline. So, creeped out, but hooked.
4
u/lostmesa May 15 '14
She definitely helped the male demo, that's for sure. I'm so glad she's also a great actress.
4
u/HoDoSasude May 16 '14
Yeah, and I think her character added to the show; like the other characters, even the 6 in Baltar's head had complexity beyond the sexy outfits. Beauty plus plot is a winner in my book.
9
u/onemm May 17 '14
Exactly. Also, you could look at a character like Starbuck, who is incredibly sexy but also reverses typical gender roles.
For example, she's the best fighter pilot, can beat most guy's asses, plays cards, smokes cigars and has sex with whoever she wants to. If I told people I just watched a good movie/tv show and mentioned that one of the main characters acted like this, 10/10 people would assume it was someone completely badass and 10/10 people would assume it was a male character.
Even if I were to look at this episode alone, I could mention that she promised to come back for Anders. Usually the brave man is promising to come back for the helpless woman. Anders is the damsel in distress in this situation(although with many differences to a damsel in distress, like for example he's a lot prettier than most damsels. Also he has a small army, but mostly the first thing)
3
6
7
u/lostmesa May 13 '14
I really liked this episode, even though it's a huge tonal shift from the rest of the series. I always thought Kara and Anders seemed way too close for the second episode together, but hey, I guess they did have a week together. Having a further humbled Adama ("I feel close to the ground") was also a nice touch.
3
u/onemm May 17 '14
Does anyone know what Starbuck whispers to the woman on the machine before she kills the power? I put the subtitles on and it just said [Kara whispers] or something like that.
Does it get revealed in a future episode? Or is it just something left for other people to guess at? If so what do you guys think she said?
2
u/kingfiasco Sep 15 '14
I just recently came across this re-watch and watched this episode tonight. It's been amazing reading the comments along the way.. That being said, when I saw this scene I immediately thought Starbuck was whispering their version of "last rites."
11
u/trevdak2 May 14 '14
The scene where Adama breaks down into tears over Boomer's corpse.... so amazingly well acted.