r/respectthreads • Ruler of「The World」 • Oct 06 '26

Respect Thread Symposium Week 38 - Rumble Results

Respect Thread Symposium Week 38

Have any characters or teams you want to show off?


Rumble Results

Thanks to all of our participants! Here's our top 3 voted rumbles for this period.

  1. u/doctorgecko - Mydei (Honkai: Star Rail) vs Garnet (Steven Universe)

  2. u/Miserable-Ad-5573 - Solomon Grundy (DC Prime Earth) vs M.O.D.O.K (Marvel, 616)

  3. u/ghostgabe81 - Cheetah (DC Comics) vs Metal Sonic (Archie Comics)


Beyond that feel free to discuss anything related to respect thread creation.

15 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/Fragmentary_Remains Oct 06 '26

Congratulations to all Rumble winners! I think my favourite of the winners would either be Gecko's or Gabe's (Sawblade's is great too of course—it's just the volume of feats covered was a little overwhelming to me specifically). I'm kind of curious about the distribution of votes for this Rumble—given how good all the options were, I'd imagine they would be fairly close

Outside of the Rumble results, I do have an interesting question. When looking to release a Respect Thread on a specific date, when do you start working on it? Given the approaching holidays of Halloween and Christmas, I figure this would be a topical question. Are you the type to plan out your Thread and start the process of making it months in advance? Do you wait until the month in question to start working on it? I'm kind of curious since I'm never even tried to hit that sort of deadline before.

8

u/rangernumberx ⭐⭐ Professional Request Fulfiller Oct 08 '26

Audience Choice Requests

Recently, over on the Scramble server, a tournament took place. Fifteen users chose five requests they would like to see me do, with the populous of the channel voting on which one was the best. Following these (plus an extra round where I got to choose five of my favourite entrants that didn't quite make it), a 1v1 knockout bracket occurred, ultimately being won by my choice of runner up and Yawn's second place entry, Arsene Lupin, the thief. Honestly, having read a third of his appearances now initially appearing to fail to drop everyone's guard before sweeping the contest from the underdog runner up slot is weirdly extremely fitting for Lupin, but that's beside the point.

What is the point is that, I don't think we should leave it at that. These are the people's top choices, after all. As such, until the end of 2027, I am going to put each of the remaining Top 16 threads on the active list with an increasing amount of rewards tied to them. I'd love to see each and every one of these get done, and I hope this goes a way to starting the process.


Top 16

Each of the following will receive 5 +2 bonus points, plus will receive any priority slots I free up.

Charles Barkley, The Baller

The shortest of the threads on the docket, Charles Barkley is the real life basketball player who lent his name to the Genesis game Shut Up And Jam! This, in turn, would be the source of inspiration for Shut Up And Jam Gaiden, a RPGMaker title in a dystopian world where basketball has been outlawed. The JRPG nature may shut some people off, but with only a 6.5 hour longplay, this is among the easiest threads to do.

Lightning, The Saviour

The first upset of the tournament, Inverse had a stacked roster of options in his runoff, with Lightning narrowly edging out and his second place entrant of Sherlock Holmes only just falling short of stopping Lupin in the redemption round. Despite this, she lost her first matchup. Being the protagonist of multiple Final Fantasy games, Lightning has all the issues people may have with Barkley in spades, but would also be a far more satisfying thread to pull off with her various feats, spells, and pieces of equipment. This would require you to go through at least the three Final Fantasy XIII games, with extra credit in things like Dissidia being available, but for your troubles you get an immediate x2 due to her presence in the Oldest 400.

Tick, The Muscle

The Tick! What can be said about the Tick? ...genuinely, what can be said about him, I know he's big, blue, strong, dumb, and yells 'spoon', but that's about it. In any case, this request covers the comic version of the character, which caps out at 192 issues (most likely needing fewer, given Comicvine includes collected volumes, etc in their count). The thread will most likely be for a fairly regular brick, so if you're looking for a fun thread which can give you a shot at the Best 3rd Party Comic award, consider giving him a shot.

Spider-Man, The Web-Slinger

Spider-Man! Who doesn't love a Spider-Man? This Spidey in particular is from the 90s cartoon, meaning you'll be getting your webslinging, your intelligence, your chasing Shocker to the ends of the Earth, everything outside of actual striking feats. You'll mostly be looking at the 65 cartoon episodes, though rounding it out is a solid handful of comic appearances just to boost him into the next point bracket.

John Egbert, The God Tier

One of the several Homestuck requests put forwards and the only one to make it to the top 16, Egbert struck me as a potential top tier (due to the complexity of the thread and the sheer amount of requests I would feel obliged to do while in the area) only to be struck down in round one by the eventual winner. Homestuck may be long, expansive, confusing to a fault, unavailable to read in its original form without downloading its entirety from a fan site, and take several days to consume without taking time to clip out and RT characters with John himself surely having a complex range of abilities and equipment...but think of the points! There are currently 24 Homestuck requests on the active archive, two of which are forced RTs meaning completing them gets you a hefty amount of forced RT credits to use on threads you want to see made yourself. Definitely the highest amount of points available for a single project here, even if that single project is going to make you work for every last one of them.

Powerpuff Girls, The Triplets

Yet another request I thought would go further than it did, the Powerpuff Girls are your classic flying bricks, saving the city of Townsville from everything from mutated monkeys to the literal devil. Absurd strength, durability, speed, and whatever misc ability they're given for the episode, this request covers the 78 episodes of the original 1998 series, the episodic nature of which would lend itself well to being collabed on. The main drawback for this one would be covering three characters with similar skill sets at once, but that's far from the biggest issue among the characters on this list.

Kaname Date, The Detective

One of the few requests I still couldn't tell you much about, Date comes from AI: The Somnium Files, a mystery solving visual novel by the guy who gave us Zero Escape (meaning I can only imagine how crazy this ends up getting). I think he has an artificial eye that lets him analyse crime scenes or something? I don't know, I'd only really know if I picked this one up. In any case, I hear there are actual combat feats in his games (mostly the first and third instalments of the Somnium Files franchise, though he also makes appearances in the second), but I imagine a lot of the thread will be an assortment of intelligence feats.

Magneto, The Mutant

We started the section with the shortest thread nomination, and ending it with the longest. Magneto dominated his run off and quickly presented himself as a top threat with his incredible aura, but quickly lost his Top 16 matchup. Maybe people rebelled against his popularity, maybe people thought the update wasn't really needed, maybe people just wanted to see a different set of competitors go forwards, maybe people thought they'd be kind on me given the amount of F4 issues I still need to go through. Maybe all of the above. Whatever the reason, Magneto has nearly 900 appearances if you want to do him from scratch, though this number would go down significantly if you just update him with the stuff since his RT was first made.


Top 8

Each of the following will receive 5 +2 bonus points, plus a priority.

Big Boss, The Soldier

Because doing Solid Snake, Liquid Snake, MGS2 Not-Snake, and Pipo Snake was not enough, some people (headlined by Benny, though in fairness his poll was a three-way tie with Animal Crossing and horror puppets) thought I should do Naked Snake as well, the legendary soldier who started it all. The main focus of the thread will be in MGS3, the one game where Big Boss is the playable character back in the Cold War, and will provide him the bulk of his physicals and gear. However, as an overarcing character who plays the role of villain (I genuinely can't tell you at this point if he actually is the villain at this point, things get confusing and it's been a while), he appears throughout a bunch of games all the way back to the original Metal Gear title. Maybe while you're in the region of MGSV you'll want to do Venom Snake, just clear out the lot of them, but that's on you.

Alan Wake, The Author

The (thankfully) lone horror entry to make it into the knockout round, I'm not sure exactly what this thread would entail. I am aware that Alan fends off foes with light, and that the events of the first game stem from the words he writes creating a reality around him, but I couldn't tell you any precise detail as to what needs to be covered in the RT. Either way, the media list isn't the most expansive either, having two games (not RPGs or visual novels for a change) plus a Control DLC to get through before you're done. I can't imagine this will be the most complex thread to put together, just maybe a bit time consuming as you figure out exactly how far the RT should go and what should be covered.

King K. Rool, The Captain

Like with Magneto, K. Rool is about as long as you want to make him. Absolute shortest, you just need to fix links and update the thread to include feats from Bonanza, quite easy. However, if you wanted to remake the thread from the ground up, this would have you go through Donkey Kong Country games from the beginning, cover handheld ports, figure out what to do about his wide variety of one-off stuff, and potentially cover his Kremling Krew a bit for good measure. At the end of the day, though, he is just a final boss in a series of platforming games. As long as you're willing to stomach doing game RTs, you shouldn't have too tough a time clearing off the Captain.

Courier, The Wastelander

That's right, he saw he had a chance of making a trans woman make a thread of his choice, and Gecko went "go play the transfemme stereotype game". And then the people voted for it, twice, before the questions on how real a character and thread this would be got too loud. That said, I do believe this would be a real thread, if a bit heavy on perk descriptions and arsenal summaries. New Vegas is an expansive game, so tracking everything down would be a notable issue, but at least it's just one expansive western RPG as opposed to if they decided I needed to go RT the deathclaws or such.

7

u/rangernumberx ⭐⭐ Professional Request Fulfiller Oct 08 '26

Top 4

Both of these will receive 10 +2 bonus points, a priority, and will have me make one of your previous Secret Santa requests (if you didn't take part in Secret Santa, then we'd treat this as an Early Christmas, and have me start on the thread immediately).

Three Stooges, The Idiots

Yawn's first entrant and initial beater of Lupin, the Stooges never got the chance for the rematch. Despite the name, this thread would actually cover six different Stooges that always gather in groups of three, like a hag's coven. The filmography would cover 1930 to 1970, and while I can't say exactly how much content there is off the top of my head (nor do I want to actually total it up all over again just for this post) I can say the archive has them down as 22 base points. However, as someone who has previously done a similar thread through the Charlie Chaplin Tramp RT, I can fully endorse this thread as a very enjoyable one to do (at least if you enjoy classic slapstick), one that would be easily to split up if you wish to collab, and likely to be easy watching and feat light compared with some other options on this list.

Larryboy, The Cucumber

I do not know how Larry got this far in the contest, something I made clear with each round he won. The vegetable superhero of Bumblyburg, I don't recall much about him beyond the first two specials he's in, but they seemed to focus more about teaching kids morals than specific bible stories. In addition to durability and plunger ears, this thread would have you tackling a decent amount of equipment most likely. Thankfully Larryboy specifically has a filmography on the wiki, so while I won't do a point count now because it's definitely not a negligible amount of media, it's at least something that can be easily digested.


Runner Up

Miles Edgeworth, The Prosecutor

Initially a tentative entry for possible lack of feats and definite lack of an actual request, Edgeworth nevertheless demonstrated a strong showing in each of his 1v1s, helped by the fact I said I would do Phoenix Wright alongside him. For you to get these rewards, we would have to ask you to do the same, effectively doing the Phoenix RT primarily while gathering Edgeworth stuff on the side, plus going through the Investigation titles. This thread would have you go through a minimum of 6 visual novels plus the two Investigations (plus the optional non-canon Layton crossover), with a pair of very physicals-light characters as you instead contend with legal trickery, magic Japanimerica artifacts, and a whole host of intelligence feats.

But what do you get for all this? Well, I only have 6 +2s remaining to dole out, so all of those. But the points are de facto quadrupled by having both the Phoenix and Miles requests, plus a priority on both. On top of this, you'll get the same Secret Santa / Early Christmas gift as with the Top 4, and to top it all off I'm willing to give away a complete set of mission rewards out of my own pocket. Just pick your month, pick your 10, 15, and 30 pointer missions, and I'll use my own rewards to make them happen! Which technically means you might be able to get further points by fulfilling them yourself? Don't tell Inverse about that though.


With all that done, it's time for me to go back to French literature and trying to recover what I can from my laptop hard drive becoming completely inaccessible last week. Happy RTing!