r/indianrailways
•
u/vpsj
"Sub" Station Master
•
Jul 07 '26
•
1
MODERATOR Help Decide the Future of r/Indian Railways: Should We Allow Viral Train Reels? (Vote Here!)
Our Subreddit has grown immensely over the last couple of years. In 2024, we barely had 20K members. Now we're nearing 400,000. It's an incredible feat thanks to all the RailFans and lovely people here.
However, with the rising growth of this wonderful community, there is an awful increase in Viral clips, reels and videos from social media as well. A lot of pages on Instagram are dedicated to find the most controversial Railways-related content and get their engagement through those videos.
Due to the nature of such reels, they are also posted here and you may have noticed how much they get upvoted. We believe that such content is low-effort, designed for engagement farming and does not lead to quality discussion among the members of the Subreddit.
However, before we make any changes to the rules, we would love to get the opinion from all of you.
Please cast your votes, this will remain live for 1 week from today.
Some explanation of the options:
Option 1: Most strict. Only OC videos. We ban ALL social media reels and viral clips. Only some educational, historic, or informative content will be allowed.
Option 2: In addition to informative and educational content, we also allow RailFanning videos from third party sources provided they don't have low effort/horrible background music. Some high quality reels may be allowed at the mods' discretion.
Option 3: We only ban low effort reels and videos posted on these so-called "Train pages" on social media. Uploader must do their homework and find out the Primary Source (person who uploaded that clip) and add the link to their video to be accepted. It requires some effort and users can't just copy paste videos to farm karma.
Option 4: We allow all train-related reels, regardless of originality or source. We will still remove non-OC content that's old/repost, or does not provide the source or full link.
Option 5: If you have any other ideas, don't hesitate to mention it in the comments.
So please vote, give your feedback and thoughts in the comments on the current state of the subreddit, and based on the results, we will decide how to move forward.
Thank you!
- r/IndianRailways ModTeam
4
u/YoloFromMars Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26
For the love of God can we please ban the
"I AM INTROVERT THIS OLD PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED PREGNANT LADY ASKED FOR MY LOWER BERTH, I SAID NO, AM I WRONG"
Replies:
"NO KING, THEY SHOULD HAVE PLANNED BETTER"
"WOW, THAT IS SO BRAVE"
"I ONCE REFUSED WATER TO A GUY DYING OF THIRST"
-- "KUDOS TO YOU, WE ARE TIRED OF THESE GUYS DYING FROM THIRST".
3
u/vpsj "Sub" Station Master Jul 12 '26
If you come across low effort repeated posts like that, just report them. We regularly remove ranty posts that don't offer any meaningful discussion
20
u/LastOfLateBrakers Platform Ticket Holder Jul 07 '26
Railfanning videos :
we get a ton of those and yes, I get it that you love trains but not every video needs to be posted. Needs significance, like yesterday one person shared a video of Duronto getting massively diverted, so they recorded it passing through a station that isn't on its general route.
"Spotted": even WDM-3A are in active service, so do we really need every WAG-12 spot?
Flairs: while the subreddit is for indian railway, it'd be great if we allowed content from other countries, but only news and rare spots (and their museums), but NO VAGUE POSTING. Share the context.
Miscreant spots: people throwing rocks, peeing on coaches while they're stationary, stealing diesel from engines - share the location, train, date and time. If not OC, then share the source.
14
u/kcapoorv Soup n' Breadsticks Enjoyer Jul 07 '26
I don't agree with point 1 and point 2. There are some real gems by railfans. And there are some low quality stuff by them. it's going to be a subjective assessment if something is low quality or high quality. Can't have a set criteria for it.
Eg: look at how many big boy videos are there on r/trains. I love those videos.
4
u/Short-Horse-1069 Platform Ticket HolderĀ Jul 07 '26
Yes, in the vote above, I have chosen to allow all videos as long as the primary source is linked. Let the voting and the collective intelligence of the sub decide.
9
u/rishdotuk Jul 08 '26
Please no, short form videos are gonna be the end of quality content here and increase the workload for you.
There are so many dumbfucks who will see a reel and post it here *without* checking if someone posted that too. They simply donāt understand how Reddit works.
17
Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26
I've been quite active on this subreddit and i really want to commend the mods here and their work.
I wish other subreddit had mods like we do here. I think people who are active on this subreddit will agree with my sentiments.
6
4
u/paulamit2026 2 AC Comfort Seeker Jul 11 '26
Allow high quality videos, with link of the original source
4
u/NoMedicine3572 2 AC Comfort Seeker Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 11 '26
#1, Because I don't want this to become another Instagram.
3
u/Radiant_Historian854 Platform Ticket HolderĀ Jul 13 '26
as a railfan for 40 years:::::::::::Option 1: Strictly post ONLY Railfanning Videos that's it which are passionately done by railfans. please dont allow falthu videos - Some NONSENSE VIDEOs with some falthu bullywood songs...and IF SOME PPL BLOCK SEATS in BIHAR daily 10 videos, THEY KEEP SPAMMING...HOW IS ITS a PROBLEM with OTHER regions... This SUB is not a HNDU NEWS Paper to cover all videos incidents. ALSO PLEASE KEEP ENGLISH Language as Script. not sure why people write hindi ..
2
2
u/blacjbirds91 Jul 11 '26
Allow all the contents as long as it is related to Indian Railways and Railway Travel un general. Source tagging is better, but the coreect source is not easy to be found all the time.
2
u/MyDespatcherDyKabel Platform Ticket HolderĀ Jul 13 '26
Any source linked reel should be allowed. āHigh qualityā is subjective, let the votes decide whatās HQ.
2
u/odd_pk Frequent Travelerš§³ Jul 13 '26
How about both 2 and 3? Primary source + high quality content, and remove low effort ones
2
u/Doom_TheGreat Frequent Travelerš§³ Jul 13 '26
I think that some reels need to be discussed, whether it's OC or not. Like, videos of weird experiences, complaints, new features, changes etc. (ofc, not randomly but with the appropriate source links). But allowing all reels will be a bad decision. People may just post here because they liked the reel, or to increase its reach. And we aren't here as just audience. We are co-passengers helping out each other, discussing the good and the bad.
1
1
u/nefrodectyl Jul 13 '26
I think everything should be allowed, people can decide what's good and whats not using upvotes and downvotes, it's should not be based on a single person or a bunch of mod's opinion to decide what's high quality and whats not.
-2
u/Civil_Appointment997 3E Economizer Jul 11 '26
firstly change the fk s rules of this sub
If the mods have guts then they will not remove this comment or ban me from this sub and have courage to take criticism..
Anyone can't even share any incidents or post anything related to tatkal tickets or their frustrating experience in this sub... These fk s modes will remove their post and especially Post related to their daddy...
4
u/vpsj "Sub" Station Master Jul 11 '26
Talk like a human being not an animal and you will be listened to.
And what exactly will the thousandth same exact tatkal frustration rant will accomplish? It's been posted to death dozens of times. There are specific places for you to rant freely.
If all you do is angrily rant and can't even be civil, this subreddit is not the place for you.
3
u/Dca_Sylvereon Rajdhani Revelerš Jul 11 '26
These days this subreddit is filled with low effort posts. Regulation is a must.