r/hoi4 • Extra Research Slot • May 11 '26

Help Thread The War Room - /r/hoi4 Weekly General Help Thread: May 11 2026

Please check our previous War Room thread for any questions left unanswered

 

Welcome to the War Room. Here you will find trustworthy military advisors to guide your diplomacy, battles, and internal affairs.

This thread is for any small questions that don't warrant their own post, or continued discussions for your next moves in your game. If you'd like to channel the wisdom and knowledge of the noble generals of this subreddit, and more importantly not ruin your save, then you've found the right place!

Important: If you are asking about a specific situation in your game, please post screenshots of any relevant map modes (strategic, diplomacy, factions, etc) or interface tabs (economy, military, etc). Please also explain the situation as best you can. Alliances, army strength, tech etc. are all factors your advisors will need to know to give you the best possible answer.

 


Reconnaissance Report:

Below is a preliminary reconnaissance report. It is comprised of a list of resources that are helpful to players of all skill levels, meant to assist both those asking questions as well as those answering questions. This list is updated as mechanics change, including new strategies as they arise and retiring old strategies that have been left in the dust. You can help me maintain the list by sending me new guides and notifying me when old guides are no longer relevant!

Note: this thread is very new and is therefore very barebones - please suggest some helpful links to populate the below sections

Getting Started

New Player Tutorials

 


General Tips

 


Multiplayer Tips

 


Country-Specific Strategy

 


Advanced/In-Depth Guides

 


If you have any useful resources not currently in the Reconnaissance Report, please share them with me and I'll add them! You can message me or mention my username in a comment by typing /u/Kloiper

Calling all generals!

As this thread is very new, we are in dire need of guides to fill out the Reconnaissance Report, both general and specific! Further, if you're answering a question in this thread, consider contributing to the Hoi4 wiki, which needs help as well. Anybody can help contribute to the wiki - a good starting point is the work needed page. Before editing the wiki, please read the style guidelines for posting.

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

1

u/Time-Yoghurt7831 May 12 '26

I'm trying to identify China as communist China, and from what I can see, the militia works better for this country than for others. Should I take advantage of the buffs and use a 4x4 militia template like the old times? Or militia still sucks?

1

u/phatwarmachine41 May 12 '26

You can get some good bonuses for militia from subdoctrines so it would be worth a shot if it sounds fun to you. 

1

u/GeneralSEOD May 13 '26

Hey all, 2nd attempt now on Admiral Germany, getting completely and utterly stomped from both ends. Despite IMO being pretty reasonable at the game. Trying to take it slow, get a real powerhouse of industry and economy going, which I have but I just constantly, forever get naval invaded and blocked by the US/UK.

Yesterday I managed to secure all my allies, pretty decently. Had Italy too, but they got invaded straight away and I spent half the game then defending them. It was around 1944 and I hadn't been able to enter Moscow cause I was so busy chasing my tail.

When I tried to use the decisions to build up forts around France, it seemed to click, then go away, and nothing was built. Not sure if this is a bug?

All in all, what am I doing wrong? I come from a time when 20 width with 2 arty was the meta, I've got a feeling that isn't what you're meant to be doing anymore these days.

Especially if I'm trying to keep up, I just feel like I don't have enough research either, or enoguh time to go down all my focuses! Trying to build a navy to take out the UK is near impossible in the length of time. I COULD take out Russia first like I tried on the first playthrough, but I end up getting declared on by the UK anyway.

Thoughts?

2

u/ipsum629 May 13 '26

Line artillery has been trash for a while now. You want infantry and maybe mechanized for defense, and special forces and armor(has some mech in it for stat concentration) for offense.

1

u/GeneralSEOD May 13 '26

Damn I really need to get better at division template switches then, I have a habbit of keeping what I have rather than changing out for better templates later on.

Cheers! I will look into that.

1

u/phatwarmachine41 May 13 '26

Germany has more than enough capability for tanks and planes. I'm willing to bet you have a ton of factories on artillery trying to meet the demands for two battalions of line artillery and those can be put to better use on tanks and planes. Also remember for SP to don't need to have super crazy designs to push Ai. Germany can start building production efficiency on mediums pretty early with tank treaty and the basic chassis can last you quite a while. Fighter 2 with heavy MGs can also be built pretty early and last you a bit before upgrading to fighter 3.

If you want to sealion before Barb, make it a focus to build a good chunk of naval bombers, that will help thin out the UK fleet. If not, pump out a bunch of cheap port guards. Something like 6/0 with support arty and maybe support AA and just cover them around the coasts. Keep like 2-3 tank divisions at home to respond to any dangerous naval invasions until you take care of the Soviets. Then take their fleet plus whatever boats you've built in the meantime and sealion. 

1

u/GeneralSEOD May 13 '26

Is there any estimates for when I should be aiming to invade the UK/Soviets?

1

u/phatwarmachine41 May 13 '26

That's more up to you and your confidence. Prioritizing Sealion and going for an Allied cap in 39-41 means no dealing with the US until later though a failed Sealion can really hurt. An early Barb means weaker Soviets and possibly hitting Autarky achieved if you can get those last resources. Also gives you more time to build up your fleet. Just note that the later you wait on stuff the harder it can get. Allies get the US and Soviets start getting rid of their debuffs. 

1

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army May 13 '26 edited May 13 '26

If genuine naval supremacy is your objective, you need to get on that immediately - a capital navy has the longest lead time out of everything you can aim for, so you need to plan and act accordingly. Build dockyards right from the start until you have some 40, research 36 hulls right away and lay down your capitals to be done mid-39 at the very latest to exercise/refit and have them ready right at the start of the war, before they can hack their way through your convoy stockpile.

And that means taking it slower on land. You will have less mils for longer - 9/0 infantry with basic supports and some light tanks will do fine in Poland and for holding the Westwall, but you simply will not have the same competitive air force and medium tank force at the same time. Making AA support mandatory, building cheap light tanks for longer a good idea, and invading France and Russia much more a question of your actual ability to punch up against stronger enemies. If you're not confident in your micro, it might even be preferable to just hold out on the small Maginot frontline while you beat the Royal Navy and train up some marines to Sealion while your air and armor still catch up, and only then get into the big land wars.

1

u/Wololo38 May 13 '26

Say i'm playing france holding the border against the germans, which area do i need to have air superiority on to help win the fight ? the side where the germans are or mine?

1

u/phatwarmachine41 May 13 '26

On your side. It's wherever the battle is taking place, so in your case the Germans are attacking you in France so you put your planes over that French airspace. 

1

u/ipsum629 May 14 '26

Fights happen in the tile that is being attacked into. This means several things:

  1. The terrain modifiers apply to the defending tile.

  2. Air superiority over the defending tile is the one that counts

  3. If an inland tile attacks a coastal tile, shore bombardment does apply.

  4. To port strike, you have to do it over the land the port is on, not the adjacent water tile.

1

u/ZazumeUchiha Jul 30 '26

How effective are carriers in coastal areas? Aren't the few dozen naval bombers starting from carriers completely negated by the hundreds of fighters that can potentially start from nearby land airbases?

1

u/Western-Help6830 Aug 27 '26

is macarthur and eisenhower, under philippines, not able to assign them as military advisors by design?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army May 14 '26

No, you are. You just need to know how capitulation works - rushing up to the Belgian Rhine is an effective play, but you need to be aware what'll happen if you can't even hold Brussels.

And fallback lines are not great for whole fronts in general. They're useful for repositioning, reserves, and dealing with the game's quirks in little corners, but it only takes one breakthrough to mess them up on a longer front. You want area defence orders instead if you intend to defend only France, set to the border of your northern states or wherever you want to hold with the help of forts.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army May 14 '26

Depends on what you consider the worse screw-up. A broken fallback line will let your enemy pour through with no attempt to stop them until you notice, a defence order will make your units waste a lot of men and gear with bad counter-attacks to retake it but at least stall the enemies some with those to give you more time to notice and respond. As a defending major, the latter is usually less of a problem.

And yeah, a basic idea of the historical timeline is kind of useful to know. If you don't want to go learn a bunch of history though, the easiest way is doing a Germany playthrough or at least going through their focus tree for a good look at all their annexations and in which order they get them.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army May 14 '26

It's very much possible in-game, though - just don't bother with expensive line artillery and make more rifles instead, and let your big forts do the job until the Germans get attacked on more fronts and thin out away from you. It's a long, tedious stretch of defence micro more than anything if you know what you're doing.

Oh, and turtle up in your core. Slovakia is nearly worthless, economically speaking, but nearly doubles your border - manually build a Brno line to plug up your rear and you're all set to hold out even as the Axis engulfs you on all sides.