r/HunterXHunter • • Nov 03 '24

Current Chapter Chapter 405 — Official Release Discussion Spoiler

Chapter 405

Performance


SourceStatus
MangaPlusOnline
VizOnline

Ch. 405 scans discussion thread

Ch. 406 scans release: ~November 8, 2024


List of Chapter Discussion Threads


You can also discuss on our discord.


⬅ Ch. 404 discussion thread

472 Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

197

u/TextureSurprised Nov 03 '24

Congrats to all my theory bros. The theory ended up being true about Hisoka being fake, and also Bonolenov using his ability to turn into him! I hope this gives the people who thought they look cool for calling theories dumb a good lesson, there are so many comments that look dumb now.

I wonder how the Hisoka fans are feeling now that they realized they had gotten all hyped over the mummy guy. I remember that the vicious smile panel was posted frequently as a taunt during the last batch.

I feel like Chrollo's coat is gradually turning into a cocoon, lol.

I didn't really get how people felt about the Sarasa murderer guy. Were they also suspicious of him or not?

We see the Heil-ly base again. I was surprised to see that Morena's desk is just at the other side of the same room that Nobu and Hinrigh saw in the last batch.

56

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

I feel like Chrollo's coat is gradually turning into a cocoon, lol.

Yea i noticed Togashi made it less detailed than before, looks like when Batman Covers himself with the cape lol

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Itszdoodoobaby Nov 03 '24

I seen some of them coping and using “yeah but y’all said Chrollo was disguised as Hisoka so y’all wrong” as a rebuttal. People are goofy.

6

u/Infinite-Worth8169 Nov 03 '24

I'm usually dismissive of "crazy" theories, but when I read the "Hisoka is Chrollo" theory I felt there's some truth to it. Like not necessarily that exactly and I didn't agree with all the "proofs" but it was clear that there was something going on.

78

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

A chapter that turned all expectation! We finally got to see what's Chrollo's plan in c377 and surprisingly the Fake Hisoka theories were true, Togashi really fooled people making them get hyped over Bonolenov for 2 years xD

▪︎Someone pointed out a good point that Pakunoda's last words before her death might be the reason why Chrollo left #9 open.

▪︎I feel like if the PT really killed Sarasa's killer aka Risnorth, then his killers would be known, why would the PT hide their identity after completing their revenge? They'd simply spread the news in the dark web or leave their famous note especially it would be weird if they left the message in the kurta massacre but not Sarasa's killer. The whole point in their origin is to become infamous criminals to make a fearless name for the city so the mafia doesn't mess with the city for human trafficking، so if they did kill him then they'd proudly announce it.

Everyone think the page is implying Chrollo killed Risnorth, but Togashi is being tricky in this arc with all the red herrings i don't think the details we're getting is as obvious as people think, in the same page people talk about Lisnorth' murder "they revised the culprit’s manifesto in the initial report saying it was fake"....why are they hiding the PT crime? Either they had a reason to not reveal the PT/Chrollo as the culprits or maybe the real report is that "Risnorth was killed by his own party to avoid getting exposed after realizing the PT was tracking him", a party killing their own minions to avoid getting exposed is very realistic and common in reality whether in mafia, politics, etc. Either way whatever Togashi got in store is definitely exciting.

▪︎I think This theory needs more attention, the idea of young Tser being groomed by Risnorth is very possible, and I'm considering that Tser himself might be the one who killed Risnorth after all the years of grooming so it should explain why they're hiding the reports of his murder because of course they won't reveal a prince killed him, the idea of a monster killing his own creator seems very poetic.

▪︎This chapter confirms only illegal royalty can be mafia bosses, so whoever was the former Heil-ly boss was definitely a scarred face boss, likely Tser' biological mafia parent In theory. Maybe Risnorth used to work for them and they eliminated him to avoid getting exposed. I noticed Mark aka Tser' personal assistant who brings victims for him, looks Like Risnorth! After Unma/Halkenburg i wouldn't overlook any face similarities, maybe Mark is related to Risnorth as his son or young brother, it's possible the Risnorth family works for Tser or former Heil-ly family.

▪︎Nobunaga being suspicious about Morena and her motivation, considering he noticed their similarities with the PT...i think it's hinting about the idea where Nobu realizes the other 2 mafias are far worse than Morena's gang and they're just trying to use PT/Morena to eliminate each other for reasons that only benefits the other mafias, notice how both Morena/PT targeted the mafia before? Then of course the mafia wants both groups to be Eliminated. Nobu already realized they have a lot of things in common with Morena' gang, he might figure that she had a good reason to turn against the mafia after being raised in their brutal environment, similar to the PT origin.

Theory on Morena's gang origin

It's been stated in c105 the mafia Recruits personnel from meteor city for crime, i think Morena's gang might be the prefect example of this concept that adds more parallels with the PT, the mafia's best method to create criminals is to control them since their childhood, maybe Risnorth used to kidnap kids to sell them for kakin mafias with high prices, they use them for various purposes like human trafficking, commit crimes, black market, etc...basically Morena's gang were once kidnapped children from meteor city and were trained by the mafia to become criminals since childhood.

So Morena and her gang probably grew up/raised by the kakin mafia and they not only witnessed all the brutal crimes but were forced to commit the crimes too, that made them to be the cold murderers they are now that turned them against the kakin mafia and their entire system, which parallels the PT origins against the mafia.

And just like Chrollo being the special PT friend and their chosen leader, Morena must've shared her friends' trauma, they see her as special since their childhood and they chose her as the leader due to her scar that makes her half royalty... i think Chrollo/Morena are meant to have a lot in common at least Nobunaga seems to notice the similarities, maybe Chrollo and Morena are smart enough to realize their common enemy is the mafia that is trying to make them kill each other to get rid of them.

If Morena's gang were trained and raised by the likes of Sarasa's killers then it's no wonder why they "want to destroy the world" it's the only point that the PT disagrees with, probably because Morena's gang trauma is even worse than what the PT went through, the PT witnessed the culprits' crimes on their people so they chose to be criminals to stop the mafia from using their people for human trafficking, while Morena's gang were forced and trained to commit those crimes since childhood.

Sheila × Mafia

Her twisted role was already hinted that she's the only member in PT origin who played double roles in the dubbing, the purple cleaner and her evil twin sister, she played both good/evil twins, Togashi doesn't add those hints for no reason. It would be crazy if it turns out Sheila was one of the mafia's successful child experiments that they trained, washed her brain and inserted her between meteor city kids making her job to lure kids for the kidnappers, maybe it explains Sheila/Tserriednich hint with the Evil emoji, could be a common symbol for children that were raised within the mafia community, and her Sad reaction after Sarasa's death only because she's likely the one who dragged Sarasa to the kidnappers.

If her role is meant to be twisted good/evil then it makes sense she'd feel sad for Sarasa after dragging her to death, Sheila might as well appear in Sarasa's tape maybe they forced her to watch them killing Sarasa as part of their experiments on children to teach them physically and emotionally to be cold blood criminals even if it means killing their own close friend, especially based on their dubbing dialogue i pointed out in Last paragraph seem to imply Sheila had more involvement in Sarasa's death than we think.

2

u/TextureSurprised Nov 04 '24

Everyone think the page is implying Chrollo killed Risnorth, but Togashi is being tricky in this arc with all the red herrings i don't think the details we're getting is as obvious as people think, in the same page people talk about Lisnorth' murder "they revised the culprit’s manifesto in the initial report saying it was fake"....why are they hiding the PT crime? Either they had a reason to not reveal the PT/Chrollo as the culprits or maybe the real report is that "Risnorth was killed by his own party

This is an awesome theory. And another one from the crowd even says something like "maybe if the real murderer is revealed it would be bad for them so they're hiding it", which is also in line with this idea.

Now I really want this to be true, honestly I'd be disappointed if it's not. It'd be really interesting if there is a connection between the Sarasa case and Tse, so far it seemed unlikely because of Tse's age and the fact that as a prince he couldn't be related directly. But this Risnorth guy offers the perfect opportunity to connect the two cases.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/realbookreader Nov 04 '24

I've also been thinking that Chrollo and Morena will work together since rereading the mafia chapters. It's worth noting that their abilities are perfect inversions of one another, as well as perfectly compatible in a male x female way. Chrollo's ability is taking, stealing, reaping, harvesting. Morena's ability is giving, gifting, sowing, creating. Perfectly inverted but also perfectly compatible since Morena could create abilities for Chrollo to steal. She might even be able to create an anti-Hisoka ability (which could also mean that Morena is the "treasure" Chrollo is looking for), or any other ability that Chrollo wants to have. Only downside would be having to level up the person with the ability before stealing it (and getting them to agree to make the ability for him to steal), but that's not too big of an issue.

And regarding Sheila, I also think it's likely that she played a big role in the Kurta massacre. Not only did she fake an injury to stay with Pairo and Kurapika (and was the only outsider to get to know them), it also happens that Pairo is the only Kurta whose head was severed whole rather than just having his eyes removed, which suggests that she was directly involved in the massacre. Pairo's head is also in Tserriednich's collection along with almost a third of the Kurta eyes, further suggesting Heil-ly ties to the massacre.

Sheila connects to Heil-ly, the Troupe, and Kurta as well as the Elders through the message left behind. It's hard to pin down how exactly they're all connected, but I think Sheila is 100% central to the Kurta massacre and agree it's very possible she was involved with Risnorth and what happened to Sarasa too.

3

u/1vergil Nov 04 '24

Yea Sheila is the key role to solve the puzzle, and regarding Morena i forgot to note the most obvious similarity is that the PT boss is #0 and Morena is also #0 and who ever she infects can be a new #0 after reaching 100 level. Maybe a hint Chrollo will be the new #0 at some point.

4

u/TextureSurprised Nov 04 '24

/u/realbookreader's comment above made me notice something. Sarasa and Pairo were both people closest to Sheila in their respective group of people (Kurapika was too, but he was away), and these two both received a very special kind of bad fate compared to other people in their group. Along with your point about Sheila playing the double role in the dubbing, this makes me even more suspicious of her.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

▪︎Hisoka seeing himself "normal" and not being interested in the ants because they're animals might explain why he ranked the zodiacs low since they also look like furries, it shows that Hisoka's ranks are all based on his personal taste "his boner" so his ranks shouldn't be taken as facts, no wonder why he sees himself The strongest if even the ants power are nothing special to him.

▪︎Since Chrollo is looking for abilities to guarantee Hisoka's death in a rematch, i always thought that Camilla's cat would interest him because he told Neon he believes in life after death so he'd be interested to see what life after death is like.

Although i don't think he'll stop at stealing the cat...once he witnesses Tser' 666 Nen beast that reads the future he'll automatically get interested since it's a good counter to read Hisoka's movements in combat, besides the obvious 666 = Lucifer symbolism that fits with Chrollo Lucilfer name, moreover, parallels future got noticable similarities with Neon's ability:

  • Nosrade' Comment about using the ability to control the world perfectly parallels Tserriednich words in This panel

  • Both Tser/Neon are interested in the kurta eyes and black market

  • Both abilities reads the future, the difference that Neon' ability is selfless compared to Tser, she reads everyone's fortunes except hers, while Tser only sees his own future and whoever HE interacts with.

Going from Neon's selfless ability into Tser' selfish ability seems to fit Chrollo's current arc wanting to kill Hisoka all by himself due to selfish goal without considering the PT' safety. So maybe both Neon/Tser abilities are meant to be stolen by Chrollo but he ends up losing them storywise like when he randomly lost Neon's ability, maybe Togashi is planning for a scenario where Kurapika intentionally kills Tser so that Chrollo loses the ability mid fight to get rid of both Tser and Chrollo.

16

u/Heartman0 Nov 03 '24

god... i never seen someone cook as hard as you before

Imgur: The magic of the Internet

13

u/-Goatllama- Nov 03 '24

Terror sandwich having his ability stolen would be so incredibly satisfying

→ More replies (10)

9

u/goodnamesaretaken3 Nov 03 '24

I like your way of thinking.

I think we are gonna agree on lots of things. When I first read the chapter and the summary. I noticed something interesting regarding name of the fake foundation Risnorth worked for. It was tranlated as "Future of children". Now, let's talk about Tserri's synthesis of art, which is essentially this: "a young individual" with a "future" put into an extreme situation. That's sounds awfully simillar to Sarasa's murder and to this foundation name. So, I think Tserri might have been taught his art by the Risnorth or someone else from that organization. Maybe they made Sarasa's tape for him to watch, and that kinda influenced him to pursue his "art".

I also believe, that the Meteor City elders' perfect relationship with the Mafia... Was probably just them allowing the human trafficking of Meteor city children in exchange for gold and power, by using this fake organization as a front. Narrator said that the troupe destroyed this relationship. And it was implied that York New true purpose was severing the ties Meteor city had with the Mafia. If so, then there's inner conflict between the troupe and elders. And even Nobu hinted at possibility, that troupe was used by someone back in ch.395 when he compared them to Heil-ly. I believe, we've already discussed this before, but now we are getting more clues about that theory, which is kinda cool. I also thought about the possibility, that new Heil-ly are formerly kidnapped Meteor city kids raised to be Mafia members. And that Morena plans to convince to the troupe to join her cause. Because, I find it very strange, that Heil-ly doesn't attack the troupe, nor they ever retaliated when Nobunaga attacked them. This means that, if Nobu's theory is true, then they follow Morena's orders to not fight the troupe at cost of losing their lifes. And if that's the case, then it's clear Morena wants to convince spiders to help her.

As we saw in this chapter important things offten happen off screen...And Nobu got his sword back somehow. People were theorising, that Spiders probably went back to Heil-ly's base with Feitan and Phinks and killed Heil-ly members. But, what if they already joined forces... We only see PT meeting again with Char-a and going through the secret passage to the upper floor. Where Phinks' group originally wanted to go. Now, Spiders actually know, that both families are planning to use them. Hingrich even straight out disclosed it to Bonosoka back in the cinema. And Bonolenov monolog implies he wants to rather have Phinks' group to deal with Hisoka then involve Chrollo who's unstable. So, if they are in contact with Bonolenov, then Phinks' group also already knows about real intentions of both mafia families, right? And if Bonolenov already told them, he found Hisoka then their next logical step would be to get to the first floor as soon as possible, right? So, it's logical to go through that mafia's hidden passage. And since Heil-ly most likely wants to ally with the troupe from the begining...spiders might have took the deal off screen, Nobu got his sword back, and Phinks' group finally convinced mafia families to let them through the secret door.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/leolegendario Nov 03 '24

So Maybe Sheila is Morena's Joker?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/nitseb Nov 03 '24

Nice catch on mark -> risnorth. Pretty sure Tserr is related to those dark videos, then... but wasn't he a good kid up until his 20s? There is a missing piece.

22

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Tser past is unknown but there's a cool Theory that suggests Tser was groomed by Risnorth and turned him to be the monster he is now, that makes me think Risnorth might've been killed by Tser himself, so of course they covered that up and wouldn't reveal the culprit is a prince.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/grady999 Nov 03 '24

ty for writing these long comments. will be a lot helpful while rereading

3

u/Forward-Gap2055 Nov 04 '24

I have always been open for a Morena's gang x Ryodan's collab. This honestly gives me so much hope. It's just that Morena seems to far gone in her mind already

1.0k

u/SabinSuplexington Nov 03 '24

The reveal that Bonolenov was Hisoka earlier means that Hisoka asking Hinrigh about his favorite spider was really just Bonolenov hoping that there was somebody that would have him as their favorite Troupe member.

409

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Dude just wants to know if he's anyone's fav :(

124

u/b0bba_Fett Nov 03 '24

At the very least he's got big support from us Ponzu fans!

→ More replies (6)

106

u/HisaAnt Nov 03 '24

I wonder how he would've reacted if Hinrigh said:

"I love all the Spiders except for Bonolenov. That bumass should be kicked out of the Troupe. You should stick some gum into his holes to make him suffer more when you kill him, Hisoka."

→ More replies (1)

39

u/x10018ro3 Nov 03 '24

Bono is the goat, he has pride in himself. I support an underdog like him. +he does the coolest stuff this chapter; RIP Lynch >:(

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

107

u/litnegotto Nov 03 '24

I got him, i actually like him plenty (even if he never had much focus til now). Bono for the win.

217

u/Rucs3 Nov 03 '24

"who's your favorite?"

"I like all of them"

"okay but like...what's you favorite underrated spider?"

"There is no underrated spider, all of them rock!"

"Even Bonolenov?!"

"Who?"

91

u/HisaAnt Nov 03 '24

"Ah, that dude with the holes! Yeah, you would've smoked him easily bro."

💀💀💀

21

u/Frezzzo Nov 03 '24

this is way too funny

→ More replies (1)

156

u/Abject-Formal-8659 Nov 03 '24

In the arm-wrestling ranking, Bonorenof is 8th, the same number shown in the cinema when he is disguised as Hisoka. Coincidence? :)

70

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Wow good catch, we thought it's a hint about Shizuku as #8 but nobody considered their rank in arm wrestling! :o

66

u/WilloverStarvdev Nov 03 '24

It would be hilarious if he breaks cover for a bit: "What about the mummy boxer, he seems pretty cool."

80

u/HemaBrewer Nov 03 '24

He at least has my favorite Nen ability, bro summoned JUPITER, that moment will never be not hilarious to me, so random but also really fucking cool.

42

u/UsefulWhole8890 Nov 03 '24

It’s not random. All of his abilities so far (and probably in general) are based on musical pieces.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/_Porthos Nov 03 '24

Egosearching at its finest.

13

u/Bruh_hania Nov 03 '24

Ngl I would do the same

8

u/Fluffy_Reply_9757 Nov 03 '24

I love this XD

→ More replies (3)

300

u/ralsei_support_squad Nov 03 '24

Incredible chapter. So much to unpack here.

  • First, insane that the ”Chrollo is Hisoka” truthers were almost right. Though it was Bonolenov all along, which feels even wilder. (I can’t believe it’s 2024 and Bono's finally relevant!)

  • We find the real Hisoka as well, already on tier 1. Since he has a VIP pass and knows very specific details about Halkenburg’s ability (including the nen beast), some people have speculated he may have a patron knowledgeable about the Succession War?

  • Hisoka: “See, I'm normal. I'm just a guy...” Sure bud, keep telling yourself that.

  • This chapter’s making me very fond of Bonolenov. Despite his crazy skills, he's uncertain and nervous.

  • Bono thinks the “treasure” Chrollo’s after is a nen user on the ship. Since Chrollo didn’t seem to have the passenger list prior to departure, I wonder if it’s someone publicly known to be leaving, so maybe a Zodiac?

  • While he replaced Uvo and Hisoka’s positions, Chrollo left seat No. 9 open. We’ve never known if Shalnark or Pakunoda were 6 or 9, but this seems to confirm Paku is 9, since there hasn’t been enough time left to replace Shalnark or Kortopi. This feels especially sad in light of Pakunoda's bonus page.

  • Turns out a man identical to one of Sarasa’s killers was gruesomely and mysteriously murdered 10 years ago. It makes sense the Troupe would’ve found him, given all their capabilities. Heck, I’d predict they’ve already killed everyone directly associated with the deed. However, the timing of this reveal is interesting. I think we still have more flashbacks to come.

  • Confirmation that the former Heil-ly boss was also a Kakin royal family bastard. It’s been speculated that this boss was related to Tserriednich, who looks nothing like his mother and brothers. Personally, I think this boss + Beyond = Tserriednich, which solves the issue of guardian spirit beasts only protecting relatives of the royal family.

  • It seems the Heil-ly are aiming to kidnap a non-user. They were previously targeting Tserriednich's soldiers around day 7, but since that isn't mentioned here, does that mean they've already gotten one of them, and this is a new victim? I’ve seen Steiner thrown around as a potential target. Twice now, it's been emphasized how vital it is for Steiner to return alive as a witness of the Black Whale voyage.

  • Heil-ly members training to get revenge on Hinrigh? No matter how much they level up, they’ll never be prepared for Hinrigh Biganduffno!

  • The chapter ends with a cliffhanger, as Nobu, Feitan, and Phinks step out onto tier 2 and react in surprise. Since we know the first couple pages of 406 are a full spread, I bet we’re about to get a very epic two-page shot of whatever they’re seeing. Or a map. Genuinely a map would also be nice, it’s getting tricky to track where everyone is.

136

u/7thPwnist Nov 03 '24

Is it really crazy that the fake Hisoka thing is true lol? Honestly as soon as someone pointed out they were watching "The Thing" I was like oh yep it is true lol

81

u/ralsei_support_squad Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

I always thought there was a decent amount of evidence to support the theory, and that people who treated it as completely stupid were wrong, but it still feels shocking to have it confirmed. More in a "wait we're coming off hiatus and getting answers?" way though. Every new piece of information is a little insane.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/portwat Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 04 '24

Former  Heil-ly boss the women that show up in Tserriednich's Guardian Spirit Beast?  That cut mark in her face similar to Morena and other illegitimate children. 

 https://www.reddit.com/r/HunterXHunter/comments/1g753rp/the_woman_in_tserr_nen_beast/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button  

u/1vergil (tagging you as well, since you also made wonderful Analysis)

3

u/PiterLeon Nov 03 '24

Where was shown the man who killed Sarasa??

9

u/ralsei_support_squad Nov 04 '24

Last page of 396. You can see he has the same mole and wart as Mr. Risnorth, whose death was mentioned in this chapter.

→ More replies (3)

256

u/Tomatillo_Thick Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

The biggest reveal this chapter: Hisoka is not above using texture surprise to cheat at a card game. 

Edit: looks like Char-R’s lieutenant is working with Morena. And that they have a “Joker” in reserve. Hisoka Gambit might still be in play. 

Hisoka is on first level - maybe the joker would be to threaten livelihood of 3rd or 7th Prince with a deranged psycho to get Char R and Xi Yu to back off for a bit. Doubtful that Hisoka would take orders like that though, but the threat would be enough. 

106

u/Wolf_of-the_West Nov 03 '24

Cha-R lieutenant reveal was nuts.

→ More replies (2)

84

u/PrimusSucks13 Nov 03 '24

Hisoka finally getting caught not by the mafia,phantom troupe or officials but by a casino for cheating would be hilarious

26

u/Tomatillo_Thick Nov 03 '24

“Excuse me sir, we’ve noticed that the slots you’ve been using have been a bit sticky after you’ve finished with them. Could you please refrain…?”

→ More replies (1)

70

u/LanleyLyleLanley Nov 03 '24

I'm pretty sure he used bungee gum to win at slots too.

26

u/eddit_99 Nov 03 '24

Texture surprise should just change the appearance of the screen and not manipulate the mechanism inside.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/reChrawnus Nov 03 '24

There've been people suggesting Kaiser of all people might be the Joker, and honestly, I'm not entirely against the idea. Might explain why he is so insistent on killing Luzurus.

16

u/Tomatillo_Thick Nov 03 '24

Yeah I saw that post. Makes sense - their (Melody et al) plan is hasty and doesn’t make much sense. If Morena has a plant in Char-R then it would make sense she’d have one in the justice bureau as well. 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

95

u/petrichormus Nov 03 '24

Hold on a minute. The underboss monologue about morena and joker, it implies different things it seems than the TCB one. The official said 'our joker' but TCB said 'your joker' (refering to Morena's joker).

72

u/sikontolpanjang Nov 03 '24

VoraciousDrake use "You might end up having to play the Joker" instead, I guess it's one of those words that can mean both way.

29

u/WednesdaysFoole Nov 03 '24

Although they also left a note regarding their use of "you".

The subject is omitted and thus ambiguous. It could be a “you”, an “I”, or a “we”. I went with “you” because he was “talking” to Morena in his mind, but this one is uncertain.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/petrichormus Nov 03 '24

Maybe the raw simply said 'the joker will be played'. Maybe someone can clarify if the ambiguity was intended from the source because I doubt translators confuses subject here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

178

u/pichukirby Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

Ok so this was technically our first Hisoka sighting in the boat?

→ More replies (4)

84

u/xX_fortniteKing09_Xx Nov 03 '24

What did Bonolenov mean by ” Chrollo… I know now why you left the no.9 spot open”?

189

u/p-p-pandas Nov 03 '24

If I'm not mistaken no 9 is Paku... I think he's just saying that everyone can see how much losing her is affecting him, that he's still keeping her spot as it is.

→ More replies (1)

87

u/7thPwnist Nov 03 '24

I took it to mean that he was planning to disband after this / not re-recruit up to max

122

u/dookie-kid Nov 03 '24

Because chrollo puts up an apathetic front like he's not affected by her death, but that's a cope. In actuality he can't keep replacing his friends like broken tools, these are people he loves and cares about.

There also may have been romantic feelings, at the very least on Paku's side and after she transferred all her memories to the og spiders they'd all know this by now.

70

u/suntirades Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 04 '24

Not just that… Hisoka fucked over the entire group like it was nothing, betrayed Chrollo’s trust and, most importantly, made dear Paku’s sacrifice fruitless. That man has done more damage than Chrollo would ever care to admit.

37

u/TackoftheEndless Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 04 '24

Also in the case of Uvogin, Shalnark and Kortopi, they were able to give a final farewell/requiem for the former, as well as recruiting who they're recruiting now to avenge the latter two, he might feel those have been settled enough so it wouldn't desecrate their memory to replace them.

Until they meet the Chain Dude again and take his life, Pokunda remains an unsolved issue and they won't replace her number until it is.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

84

u/Shadopivot Nov 03 '24

Damn, that's really unfortunate that Lynch is dead, she was one of my faves for the new arc, and her ability was super cool. Glad we're back with the Troupe focus for a bit, things are really heating up!

4

u/mattwing05 Nov 06 '24

Same. Sucks that a unique nen user is already wiped from the board. I was curious if she was going to show any more cool aspects/uses of her ability

→ More replies (1)

80

u/tioluko Nov 03 '24

Member when we were memeing about Bonolenov and Hisoka fighting on 400s+ page sketches?

I think Togashi saw it...

49

u/leolegendario Nov 03 '24

Togashi reading those posts: "How do they know?"

11

u/b0bba_Fett Nov 05 '24

The real reason Togashi started doing the big mural is to distract our memelords from their unsettlingly close predictions.

63

u/smokinnic_suckindic Nov 03 '24

That one soldier guy who sold out Morena’s info to Mr. Wang is fucked LOL

41

u/StupidPencil Nov 03 '24

Most likely already dead. Got transported straight to the kill room.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/SuccessionWarFan Nov 03 '24

The Corporal? Hei-Ly killed him already.

51

u/Condoriano-sensei Nov 03 '24

There's another error in the Viz version: Dogman saying "How should I let you know if Sodom finds the target?". The one who finds the target is Dogman with his ability, and he's asking how should he notice Sodom for him to use his ability of kidnapping.

42

u/alconnow Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

Hisoka: “see I’m normal ♦️”

Yeah, sure.

22

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Studies says psychopaths sees themselves normal, so Togashi is being realistic when writing Hisoka lol

40

u/nitseb Nov 03 '24

I am very curious as to what the mafia guy showed the troupe trio that shocked them. Things get "rough" from now on? They already saw massacre rooms from Heil ly with little reaction. What can it be? Must be something weird.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '24

Hoping that that moustache guy and Wang doesn't really work for Morena, damn their HQ is separating one door is sus asf. Hope no one on the troupe's gets captured.

178

u/leolegendario Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

SO THE THEORY THAT HISOKA WAS NOT HISOKA BUT BONOLENOV (some thought it was Chrollo or Illumi) WAS CORRECT ALL THIS TIME!

So much to discuss in this chapter. Let's get started:

In Chapter 377 Bonolenov reveals that he can transform his appearance with Battle Cantabile: Metamorphosen and asks Chrollo what he should do.
Hisoka from chapter 392 and 393 was Bonolenov pretending to be Hisoka, re-read all of his scenes and your mind will explode.
Bonolenov, a boxer, instinctively counterattacks Lynch after she punched him.
RIP Lynch. I liked her.
The movie showing in the theater where "Hisoka" was in chapter 393 was THE THING! It was in our faces the whole time.
The beginning of this chapter was the first appearance of the real Hisoka on the ship.
Hisoka's line "I don't mind playing with myself." (TCB)/ "There's always Solitaire." (Mangaplus) indicates that he already knows that Bonolenov is after him.

The person Bonolenov transforms into after meeting Hisoka is Owl, a member of the Shadow Beasts from the Yorknew City arc.
Who is the Prince that Hisoka contacted? Is that why he knows how Halkenburg's power works? What is this treasure that Chrollo wants to use to kill Hisoka once and for all? The Seed Urn? The ability of one of the princes/guards?
The Chairman of the "Mom's Help" Foundation, Mr. Risnorth is one of the guys involved in Sarasa's death. He appears on the last page of chapter 395 and more clearly on the last page of chapter 396.
Who is the person without Nen that Morena wants to bring to her side? Will it be one of the princes or one of the guards? If she wants a specific type of Nen no matter who it is, maybe she wants a Specialist.

71

u/alconnow Nov 03 '24

who is the Prince that Hisoka contacted?

Imagine if it was Tyson lmao. Hisoka may be a freak but he is still pretty handsome

16

u/leolegendario Nov 03 '24

That would make so much sense.

9

u/Kujaix Nov 03 '24

I don't see it being Tyson since they wouldn't have reason to be aware of Halkenberg's ability. We've never seen Izunavi really comment on the rumblings. Does Kurapika even know Halk is firing arrows at people?

It's really just Benjamin who knows through his Yu-Gi-Oh man that Halk has some sort of attack you can't block or stop from being fired. Everyone else should just know there is a crap ton of aura being generated and discharged for reasons unknown. I could be missing something but can't begin to determine what?

Really not sure why Chrollo assumes a Prince vs a Queen or even Nasubi or Beyond. No one knows Beyond is under arrest but the V6 and Zodiacs. Possibly not even the Bill tier hunters under Beyond if Pariston&Ging didn't tell them.

48

u/OC_Showdown Nov 03 '24

> Hisoka's line "I don't mind playing with myself." (TCB)/ "There's always Solitaire." (Mangaplus) indicates that he already knows that Bonolenov is after him.

Nice catch!

7

u/Gadzs Nov 03 '24

Can someone explain how this means he knows please?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Kryorus_saga Nov 03 '24

I got a little confused and I may missed out but why is everyone saying Hisoka knows about Halkenburg power?

34

u/karlokattaneo Nov 03 '24

he says he felt the rumbling, but was not interested to fight him once someone, probably the prince that contacted him, told him it was a group ability and that it involved a spirit beast, that's what he means when he says he does not enjoy orgies

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

68

u/SirPurin Nov 03 '24

In contrast to fan translations that i read whom decided to keep Wang's monologue as him talking about morena, in the official they portrayed him as an ally to morena as he says "we". Interesting, I wonder what he's up to, it might be an mistranslation from either side, since the japanese seems to be ambiguous. Wang being on Morena's side feels very possible, as we didn't even saw him doing anything yet really, unlike his Xi-yu counterpart Hinrigh.

35

u/WednesdaysFoole Nov 03 '24

Did you read VC's tl? They left a note about the ambiguity in the original text.

The subject is omitted and thus ambiguous. It could be a “you”, an “I”, or a “we”. I went with “you” because he was “talking” to Morena in his mind, but this one is uncertain.

33

u/LowDevice5478 Nov 03 '24

From the official translator’s AMA: she said that when faced with ambiguity she usually never “take a side” and prefer a generic translation to avoid being mistaken if the meaning is ‘purposely hidden’ by the author in order to have a later reveal. Based on this, she might have had certainty the intent of togashi was to let us know that Wang actually works for/with Morena, and that’s why she made the explicit decision of using “we”

→ More replies (5)

7

u/sikontolpanjang Nov 03 '24

Yeah it could be a case of both wording can worked

33

u/-Goatllama- Nov 03 '24

I'm scared → Everyone

31

u/Bro0om Nov 03 '24

So chapter 392 394, we see Hisoka wandering around like nothing with no disguise. We're made to think that he doesn't care if he's found out.

However, it was actually Bonolenov trying to lure the mafia or anyone with ties to Hisoka.

But the real Hisoka is in fact also wandering around with no disguise, just on a higher level.

If that's not a troll I don't know what is.

30

u/DestOsymY Nov 03 '24

Hisoka, chrollo and Morena, such fascinating characters, it's a free for all, and I like how the story lines are merging bit by bit you can definitely see it.

28

u/EigoKaiki Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

To help with the fake Hisoka timeline: This post by u/baddumbtsss had a good summary

"Bono's interaction as fake Hisoka w/ Lynch + Zakuro was after knocking them out -> disguise as Zakuro, confirm w/ Lynch that she knew he was a fake, kill her -> disguise as Lynch and lie that he was the real Hisoka and setup a meeting in the theater -> disguise as Hisoka again, gain access to VVIP thanks to Hinrich -> go to VIP tier as Hisoka, confirm he is there"

Also u/VoraciousDrake made a complete timeline for the events so far here

→ More replies (5)

51

u/BobtheFiveHalf Nov 03 '24

I am glad that Phantom Troupe stuff is much easier to follow. That was a quick read. I didn't think that was a fake Hisoka this whole time. Hisoka thinks he's "normal"; that's hilarious.

43

u/Condoriano-sensei Nov 03 '24

I feel this translation makes a lot more clearer that the Underboss of the Sha-a family is working with Morena at some level.

9

u/Faiz_B_Shah Nov 03 '24

The translation is kind of misleading, as in the original source, the subject was kept ambigious, so a more accurate translation should have been "the Joker" instead of "our Joker"

25

u/Hubbub5515bh Nov 03 '24

Still, the fact he even knows about this joker signals an alliance between them or at least a much closer connection than hes saying.

19

u/sircrazyclown Nov 03 '24

0 ambiguity on Wang's allegiance in this version. A Prince likely invited Hisoka to Tier 1 due to his reputation, according to Chrollo, instead of Hisoka initiating the contact. The "treasure" Chrollo is seeking just happens to be an ability that will help him kill Hisoka. I don't think the Heil-ly plan to indiscriminately kill civilians at all during the funeral, they have a proper objective to find someone/a few people to start spreading the chaos up to Tier 1.

17

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Even the Japanese fandom seem to agree that Chrollo's reason to leave #9 open is respecting Pakunoda's wish to put an end for the PT.

16

u/grady999 Nov 03 '24

its only been 5chapters and i want to jump in a pool to cool off my adrenaline high

31

u/louai-MT Nov 03 '24

Hisoka not getting into the Chimera Ant business because he believes it would be beastiality 😭

I can't with this guy anymore lmao

17

u/suntirades Nov 03 '24

He didn’t know about the ants until Illumi told him. He just didn’t gaf when Illumi filled him in

43

u/layflake Nov 03 '24

I've given my two cents about most of the chapter on the previous 2 threads, so I wanted to bring out another topic.

I know It's sometimes a discussed topic, but after Pakunoda and Chrollo's interactions on flashback, the extra from Vol. 38 where she explains the restrictions of her ability and the empty 9 spot mentioned by Bonolenov on this chapter – in addition to Paku not following the Troupe's ideology in order to save Chrollo's life – I've been fully believing she was in love with him and Chrollo probably would've fallen in love with Paku too If his life's path was different, but I think he's away too twisted to even develop such thing or realize, so It remains platonic. Their relationship is so beautiful and complex.

4

u/Background-Rush4769 Nov 04 '24

i dont think its romantic love more. from his reaction to uvo and shals death it and troupe backstory its clear chrollo highly values his bond with older member also it really possible chrollo suffer from emotional issue's

→ More replies (1)

14

u/petrichormus Nov 03 '24

I think it is almost guaranteed that Hisoka has connection to a queen if he's in tier 1 now. I doubt it's a prince that invited him.

8

u/Epicbear34 Nov 03 '24

I could see Tyson doing it, she and Oito the are only ones to hold in person interviews for guards

14

u/-Goatllama- Nov 03 '24

The Tyson x Hisoka collaboration we didn't know we needed omg

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ChuChuPawon Nov 03 '24

What if it’s just straight up Nasubi

→ More replies (1)

14

u/RaspberryFormal5307 Nov 04 '24

Are we seriously setting up to actually get hisoka vs bonolenov? We are living in the blessed timeline

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Nita_Kalaga Nov 03 '24

the implication that there is probably another fake hisoka.........

6

u/McManGuy Nov 04 '24

Wait a second... how did I forget that Illumi could disguise himself as Hisoka?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Monk_Philosophy Nov 03 '24

This was an amazing chapter. Confirmed a lot of things that have been hinted at, reinforced that everything going on with the PT, Mafia, and lower tiers are on a collision course with the Succession War. Chrollo was after something specific and not just generic “treasure”

The Mafia has their own succession ceremony, feels like that might be its own thing on par with the seed urn ceremony.

New questions or observations I had:

  1. What is the treasure that the PT are after?

  2. If the treasure can kill Hisoka “for good” then why would that push the other PT to kill Hisoka first?

  3. The above question likely has to do with Bono wanting Chrollo to designate a #9 since they’re mentioned together. Maybe replacing Hisoka’s soul with someone else’s?

  4. Is the Casino-Hisoka real? (I think yes due to the card symbols in his text boxes and the whole being turned on by violence thing) What is he after on this ship?

  5. This could intuition or a gamble on Chrollo’s part but if not: why is he so sure that Xi-Yu and Cha-R aren’t lying about the Hisoka situation? Having Bonolonev transform into Hisoka would be sending him to death if either family was playing dumb and had some long con on using the PT to hunt for Hisoka. This says to me that Chrollo and the PT may be clued into the Hisoka’s goals on the ship more than they let on to the reader.

  6. Casino-Hisoka’s fantasy showed a very Tserriednich-coded depiction of Hisoka dancing with an exploding robot. No idea what that means but it does seem.

Lastly, this is the first chapter I’m feeling super bummed about the leaks. There’s barely any discussion to be had for the official release for the most intriguing chapter yet imo.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Sanjipika Nov 03 '24

We all laughed at the hisoka vs bono dressed up as hisoka memes…

Meanwhile togashi was the one laughing at us cause they were real the whole time lmao

8

u/msdamg Nov 03 '24

I remember when I first read it "that's so silly but not impossible"

I wore the clown makeup today it seems

→ More replies (1)

22

u/ThaEarthquake Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

So funny hearing Hisoka disregard the ants like they weren’t a huge threat to the world. That Bolo reveal caught me off guard. I’ve been loving the Death Note type of vibe in this arc, especially the battle between Benjamin & Halkenburg.

11

u/Professional_Pop_148 Nov 04 '24

NOOOOO MY GIRL LYNCH!!! she had such a cool ability and was really fun, I'm so upset. She only lasted a few chapters and yet I liked her so much!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Faiz_B_Shah Nov 03 '24

The chapter is probably the best in this batch till far, although Im disappointed by the official translations for this chapter. The other times, its ignorable, but this time they really made some noticeable issues

→ More replies (5)

9

u/azzelle Nov 03 '24

I don't know why the new world review makes his videos off fan translations. The Mangaplus translation (which isn't perfect) is far better

→ More replies (1)

9

u/D-A_W Nov 03 '24

Is that a real variation of poker or a Togashi invention? I can't find anything on it, and I wouldn't put it past Togashi to invent a whole card game for just one page. Either way, I wonder what the significance of it is. Is it just because Bonolonov was a duplicate of Hisoka? Or is there more to it? Because winnings being increased by the power of the number of duplicates is a really interesting detail. It could be whimsical worldbuilding, but I wonder if it could thematically mean anything more.

6

u/3bee Nov 03 '24

I thought it was mostly there to reflect on Hisoka's character: the more risks he takes, the more satisfied he is when winning. But for sure it could have some broader significance.

9

u/Hisoka_lover92 Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

Togashi really likes to destroy our expectations.I honestly never doubted that 293 Hisoka was fake. It was completely like his character to me, but nah Togashi tricked most of us 🤭. Congrats to the few theorists who expected Bonolenov, I remember most of us thought it was real Hisoka, and others said it was Chrollo or even Illumi. Never underestimate Bono and his acting skills. Anyway, I am glad to see Hisoka again. It has been a long time since his last appearance in Chapter 357. And thanks to Togashi for drawing him this beautifully 😊. Now, let's talk about the chapter:

  • In gambling, number 777 is a symbol of fortune and luck. The other meaning is spiritual awakening and heightened intuition. Don't know if this means that circumstances may go in Hisoka's favor! Togashi likes giving hints after all.

  • There's a chance that Hisoka already knows that Bono is tracking him.Let's remember that in GI, he sensed Kalluto easily.I don't mind playing with myself might be a hint too. There's also an old man who saw Bono changing his appearance from Hisoka to the owl. It's possible that he will tell Hisoka that there's someone looking exactly like him lol.

  • As usual, a few answers, more mystery and complication. the chapter leaves us with many questions: Firstly, how did hisoka manage to access the first floor and who told him about the succession war, the nen beasts, the urn ceremony, and Halkenburg's ability? according to Chrollo a prince may contacted Hisoka. I guess Tyson is a candidate, she's into hot guys lol. but if he was invited through the bodyguards application then why isn't he doing his job as a bodyguard unless he is/ was a trump card for a prince? I remember Sale was talking about a plan and changing the world yet he died before the reveal of that, what if he was hisoka's sponsor? The other possibility is that hisoka was invited by a queen. The first queen Unma's already plotting things behind the scenes. Or, Hisoka got the vvip card via Illumi or Morena. Lastly let's not forget that in the first day Kurapika made an emergency call, revealing the existence of Nen beasts. So perhaps Hisoka called him and they had an off screen contact.

  • The the news of Sarasa's kidnapper indicates that The PT flashback it's not done yet. the ship could be the battlefield to accomplish justice for Sarasa.

  • Okeni Wang's goal is balance. So it's important for him to get rid of all chaotic sides and to make the spiders clash with Morena leaving no victors. That's how his monologue may be interpreted unless Togashi is hinting him being a spy.

I wanted to add more thoughts, but I barely have free time these days unfortunately.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/1vergil Nov 03 '24

Family theme is important in this arc and we haven't seen who actually raised Tser to be the monster he is now.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/SomnusRain Nov 04 '24

ive got a feeling that some of the members of the troupe will get humble this arc.

7

u/Cgi94 Nov 03 '24

So glad my past predictions of Togashi not going to in depth with the Troupe so soon being wrong 😭. Love him showcasing how competent the members are. Bonoleov really showed how far the Troupe is above their competition. But the amazing part is the awakening of nen we have from various groups 😤😁.

Hisoka just playing while thinking of prey is so on point 😅. Togashi casually dropped another prince reveal. Not only are we looking for Beyond child but now also Hisoka having a potential alliance with one😲

7

u/jun2san Nov 03 '24

the official translation has hisoka saying "there's always solitaire" instead of talking about playing with himself. Is this some sort of censorship? Because playing with himself implies he knows his doppelgänger exists.

15

u/NFLFilmsArchive Nov 03 '24

I wouldn’t say it’s censorship. TCB translated it in a manner that fits his temperament and it’s more of a fun read. The official used Hisoka’s affinity for cards to translate it. It’s just two aspects of his characters.

7

u/Bizzack Nov 03 '24

I’m a little confused but did Nobunaga get his sword back at some point after losing it?

6

u/axecalibur Nov 03 '24

He loses it in 399 and has an empty scabbard in 400

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TheAbram Nov 03 '24

Cha-R controls commodities on the ship, I'm sure they have a katana laying around

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Lightecojak Nov 04 '24

Was it revealed that Ken’i is a mole working for Morena before this chapter? It felt like it came out of nowhere.

7

u/Apprehensive-Pie-50 Nov 04 '24

Does anyone remember where Hinrigh is currently while all this is happening? I’ve lost track of where he was last and how he can come back into play.

10

u/DFBFan11 Nov 04 '24

I believe he went back to the Xi-Yu base on tier 4, since he was low on nen after spamming it all day. He should return soon though, Phinks told them to let Hinrigh know they’re heading up.

4

u/Connolly1227 Nov 04 '24

Basically homie could be in a really tight spot and doesn’t know it

13

u/smokingelato_ Nov 03 '24

I’m guessing Hisoka was invited by Beyond or Pairston rather than a prince like Chrollo suspects.

I think he wants to fight the zodiacs and he would be a good tool for them to do so. Hisoka might have accepted to just be able to fight Beyond too

8

u/3bee Nov 03 '24

Me too! Pariston is a real possibility. And he might even have done it with the purposeful objective of getting the PT on board as well. Assuming he is Sheila.

4

u/msdamg Nov 03 '24

If it's Pariston it would make a lot of sense

9

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '24

Wasn't it implied that Hisoka killed one of the candidates in the chairman election for Parriston?

13

u/Real_Velour Nov 03 '24

Illumi might end up being another fake Hisoka as well

→ More replies (9)

13

u/DerpyNachoZ Nov 04 '24

The Phantom troupe has crazy death flags this arc. I'm loving how much everything is coming together

9

u/surfjams Nov 04 '24

Togashi in an interview: They will all die.

Me, completely ignoring that: Ohhh okay cool! Can’t wait to see them all together again! :D

12

u/nickname10707173 Nov 03 '24

The IV guy and Lynch considered Fake Hisoka (Bonolenov) as extraordinary and even then, Bonolenov doesn’t consider that he can take on Hisoka.

The gap between nen user mafia and usual faces we saw might be really big.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/hyoriittaiii Nov 04 '24

do you guys think hisoka thinks the chimera ants are literal ants 🐜

7

u/-Mastermind-Naegi- Nov 04 '24

Oh yeah absolutely. If you put one in front of him I doubt he'd care about their species. Some of them look less like animal-people than some of the zodiacs.

6

u/anyjuicers Nov 05 '24

has it been established who the Heil-Ly are looking for at the funeral procession, or is that a mystery for the next chapters?

8

u/SpookyGarreta Nov 05 '24

Yes, they are looking for one of Tserr's soldiers - they talked about it in 394, Dogman was not leveled up enough at the time to complete this mission.

7

u/africhic Nov 05 '24

It has not. What we seem to know from this chapter is that they're looking for someone who does not yet know Nen, and they need Dogman to sniff out what type they are. In my opinion, they're looking for a specialist in order to try to give them an ability the others are unable to awaken.

6

u/Bradbro10 Nov 06 '24

I think Hinrigh will lose against the three Heil-Ly to show the power boost from leveling up. I just hope he doesn’t die. Either he is wounded but creates a distraction and escapes or is saved at the last moment by Nobunaga. Wang’s deception will be uncovered and he will die.

I also think Hisoka dies this arc but takes troupe members with him, maybe even Chrollo. The most likely outcome is that the remaining troupe members disperse and end the Troupe forever, which would be a mark of the old world being ended as the story transitions to the new world. My crazy alternative outcome is that the troupe continues instead and Hinrigh joins.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ChuChuPawon Nov 03 '24

And to think we haven’t even caught up with Ging and Pariston

5

u/meertatt Nov 03 '24

So wait is the Cha-r guy who has been working with hinrgh actually Heil-y??

10

u/Rainswort Nov 03 '24

He's for sure not a member of the Heil-Ly family, but this chapter seems to imply that he's collaborating with Morena.

5

u/OKokayfine Nov 03 '24

"It accelerates the schedule a lot, but we might have to use our joker." I see some theorising that the joker is Hisoka, but I disagree. To maintain the balance, Cha-r and Xi-yu have conspired against the Phantom Troupe by leading Hisoka away, so I understand where the theory comes that the Heil-ly would then do the opposite and pit Hisoka and Troupe against each other. It would only be to Heil-lys advantage of destroying everything.

However, now it's revealed that Ken'i is working for Morena, we already know from his previous PoV thoughts that he doesn't believe Hisoka can defeat the PT because he's still under the belief that Hisoka is under the same mindset as before his Chrollo fight.

So it's not much of a wildcard move, a move that does fit the joker is Morena dying. Her death would activate post mortem nen and increase the strength of her contagion ability. Whether that would be in how the contagion spreads or how levelling up is easier, it'll create the chaos needed for her ability to spread on mass to the general public on the ship, which would cause absolute chaos.

5

u/BellTwo5 Nov 03 '24

First Ike seeing Chrollo in while and Hisoka’s introduction was kind of funny

5

u/shinsekai007 Nov 03 '24

Those hisoka vs bono memes might turn out to be true the upcoming chapters lol, Im pretty sure that hisoka has already noticed that he is being tailed. I wonder which prince invited hisoka and how did he know about halkenberg ability and the whole SW rituales. It seems that halken fueneral is gonna be wild with morena also on the move and with whatever halken is planing. The page whith the news about sarasas killer was fantastic with chrollo casually walking and the news screen behind him very clear what it means, its also very interesting that the official tl indicate clearly that wang is part of Morena group. Finaly I wonder what Nobu and co saw maybe its another huge door?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '24

It'd be such a major plot twist if the one who managed to give Hisoka a VIP card was Kurapika via Queen Oito. It'd be dumb as fuck but also absurdly amusing.

5

u/rusty_shackleford34 Nov 03 '24
  • the door opens to Morena in full attack mode!!!! “ WELCOME TO YOUR DEATH GENTLEMEN, AHAHAHAHAHAHAH…… errr why are you playing rock paper scissors?” “ oh we are just seeing who gets to go first, just give us a second.” ( not saying it is Morena, but be great if it did play out like this.)

5

u/Vaeltaja Nov 03 '24

Wonder if the funeral procession getting crashed by the Heil-Ly will trigger Mizaistom's prediction.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/1vergil Nov 04 '24

The way people compare Netero and Hisoka's preference both are only interested in real challenges especially 1v1...makes me think Hisoka will have no role in DC because it's just battle for survival rather than 1v1, same way Netero was not interested in DC either.

So i wonder what's Hisoka's role or target after the boat arc assuming he survives!

5

u/meertatt Nov 04 '24

I have a bad feeling that the troupe are about to see a dead Hinrigh behind that door. I am not sure why, but we havent seen him since chapter 399...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Maplechan Nov 05 '24

There were a lot of "LOL"s in this chapter. How does this translation work from Japanese?

5

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '24

What do you think of Ken'i Wang, is he the mole from Cha r family Or like a double agent for Morena?

8

u/ChuChuPawon Nov 03 '24

Hisoka’s host is now my second most important mystery. Silent Majority still number one.

The obvious ones seems to be Benjamin Kurapika and Morena.

Benjamin because he seems to know how Halkenburg’s powers work.

Kurapika because they had a sort of alliance previously and Hisoka may just be the wildcard he needs for this trip

Morena seems to have a finger in many pies. Char R and Xi Yu bosses told their underbosses to look for Hisoka so it is less likely for the host to be 3rd or 7th Prince. Heily is last Mafia family and it makes sense for Morena to employ a wildcard too.

Also the scene of Hisoka playing cards and moping could be after Halkenburg’s funeral procession where things happen and abilities are used in public.

4

u/sikontolpanjang Nov 04 '24

Benjamin wouldn't hire outsider

4

u/Costavinc Nov 03 '24

Guys, why on earth is Nobunaga portrayed with his sword in the holster? Wasn't it confiscated by the Hei-Ly?

4

u/amgr12 Nov 04 '24

I though Wang was the underboss but it turns out the mustache guy is his superior? Similar scenario to Camilla’s untouchables and the old lady lol.

7

u/Beneficial_Tonight_7 Nov 03 '24

I’m so glad we got more of hisoka this time, especially him acting normal. Togashi give us more hisoka pls 🙏

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ApplePitou Nov 03 '24

Bonolenov is truly a monster as I can see + monster with high IQ :3

6

u/Kryorus_saga Nov 05 '24

Damn really can’t wait for the leak on Thursday

8

u/contactfetty Nov 03 '24

Every troupe chapter goes so incredibly hard, especially with it right next to kurapika, the irony is so palpable it’s insane

3

u/jackmartin088 Nov 04 '24

Sorry guys this is a question for mostly last week...whats up.with halkenberg? Whats his MO? Like his body died , so what happens to his nen beast now? And now that his body died what happens when borsalino ( or the guy he is possessing) wakes up? Will he be locked up in the body forever? Can he read the possessed bodys memories and knew what benjamin was up to?

3

u/bbsmydiamonds Nov 04 '24

We don’t know where his nen beast is, will have to find out.

If Balsamilco wakes up, Halkenburg is forced to sleep (not have control of the body) until Balsamilco goes to sleep again.

It’s not been shown yet if he can read the possessed body’s memories. I’m inclined to think no, and he just got the information about the TSK-17 from Unma. But I don’t know how much information Benjamin’s guards would’ve shared with her.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DistinctBam Nov 04 '24 edited Nov 04 '24

My guess is Heil-ly are gonna capture one of Tserries friends we met in 394. That’s bound to kick the fourth prince into gear!

Edit: thanks for the correction, it’s 394 not 393!

3

u/Faiz_B_Shah Nov 04 '24

*394. 393 was the chapter where Hinrigh meets Hisoka in theatre

3

u/Maplechan Nov 04 '24

I really liked how this chapter was a lot less dense than all the other ones this arc. Really speeds up the pace of the story and streamlines it.

3

u/Xarviz01 Nov 07 '24

I saw someone in the comments on MangaPlus say that the translation is wrong, and Benenelov actually killed Zakuro, and not Lynch! I would really like some clarification of this, because I just do not understand this page where Zakuro is knocked out to the side, and also talking to ALIVE Lynch. Can anyone please explain this?

5

u/sikontolpanjang Nov 07 '24

That guy is full of shit, just reread again the chapter when we first see Bonosoka, knocked out Zakuro got woked up by Bync and Bync said Bonosoka is the real Hisoka (which we now know is false) and when Zakuro and Hinrigh going to the cinema "Lynch" are not with them and Zakuro trying to "catch up" with her.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/inika41 Nov 07 '24

Just wanted to say I finally caught up to this chapter after rereading from the near-end of the Chimera Ant arc. It took me nearly a couple months, but I’m over the moon that I’ve landed at the point where Togashi and co are well and prepped for (hopefully) more regular releases.

8

u/Lightecojak Nov 03 '24

So this chapter might confirm my hypothesis about why Hisoka is targeting the troupe.

It’s not that because he lost the fight with Chrollo, it’s HOW he lost it.

Hisoka only wants to fight strong opponents and will only kill weaker people if it’s necessary. Chrollo’s entire plan during their fight was to use every person in the arena against Hisoka with a lot of them being puppets. Chrollo relying on weak spectators for victory denied Hisoka the true 1v1 fight with Chrollo he wanted for years. So he’s targeting the troupe starting with Kortopi and Shalnark to prevent Chrollo from using his previous strategy again.

14

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '24

"hisoka will only kill weaker people if it's necessary"

tell that to all the people he killed in phase 1 of the hunter exam

→ More replies (3)

8

u/jojosimp02 Nov 03 '24

Ehhh i don't agree, if that was the case he wouldn't have hired illumi to kill him.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/1vergil Nov 05 '24

Thinking about Hisoka's monologue, people think it's a cope but he's technically admitting he's not interested in fights where he gets stomped that's why he doesn't like the ants whom are extremely powerful nor does he like team fights against him that'd result getting stomped, that's probably why he got turned off by Netero ignoring his offer like he realized Netero is a mismatch and far above his level which would be no fun to him when the fight is one sided.

It seems he's only interested in opponents where they're his match power wise, anyone above his level or below his levels are not his favorite type although his toys box is filled with them but i think the reason why he's opposed with Chrollo between all other toys, is because he believes Chrollo is his match power wise.

13

u/NenDc Nov 05 '24

I personally thought it was just a confirmation that Hisoka think about his fights the same way normal people think about sex with all the preferences involved. For almost all people thought of bestiality is just beyond disgusting, some people who tried don't enjoy group sex as well. Hisoka just convert these preferences on fight as this is his form of having sex. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/1vergil Nov 04 '24 edited Nov 04 '24

I think Kurapika/Chrollo deal will happen but Kurapika will betray him at the end. Something like Kurapika helps Chrollo to steal Tserriednich ability, this would benefit Kurapika to defeat Tser...but he intentionally kills Tser when Chrollo is in mid fight that results Chrollo losing Tser ability which would put Chrollo in the bad situation that might result his death, basically Kurapika getting rid of both Tser/Chrollo at the same time.

It seems Death Note reference wasn't just to hint about Neon' death but it probably hint the idea anyone Chrollo steals their ability ends up dying, so Tser would definitely die if Chrollo stole his ability.

Death note makes the condition of "losing the ability when the owner dies" to play an important role making a tense situation in Chrollo's own fate. Chrollo had his previous plan that guarantees 100% win go exactly as he planned "only the result wasn't expected for him" but now he's probably gonna put a plan to face Hisoka in rematch where it goes completely unexpectedly for him as in losing the ability that he planned to use against him.

Tho it seems PT worries he's planning to kill Hisoka even if it means sacrificing himself which is why they want to kill Hisoka first to save Chrollo from his Suicidal mission. I think if Chrollo realizes he has no suitable ability to kill Hisoka mid fight, then he'll just use Sun & Moon to nuke himself on Hisoka, Hisoka himself probably wouldn't expect this.

Edit: Chrollo plan' failure mid fight seems to be foreshadowed by Hisoka's Statement, i guess Togashi will give Hisoka that in the rematch, but i don't think Chrollo will stop there in disbelief since he doesn't care if he sacrificed himself as long as Hisoka dies, that's why i think he'll nuke himself at Hisoka with Sun and Moon.

The popular prediction was Chrollo will watch all spiders die and he'll remain the last survivor but after this chapter I'm starting to think Chrollo is planning to do what ever it takes to stop more spiders deaths, so he'd try to kill Hisoka even if it means sacrificing himself, but i guess Machi and illumi will have an important role to change that outcome too.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Fugetsu-Donut Nov 07 '24

Still no leak for 406

9

u/TheSpurm Nov 07 '24

there was a holiday in japan, that delays the day when the shonen jump gets delivered to stores

so expect leaks tomorrow

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TheAbram Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

Another mistake:

How should I let you know if Sodom finds the target?

Honestly, this is getting embarrassing. Literally every chapter in this batch has big errors.

14

u/WednesdaysFoole Nov 03 '24

This one was confusing in the original text. 브이브 brought it up in VC's tl's comments:

Then there’s Dogman’s line with “ソドムで,” which personally felt the most jarring part in this chapter. Since Sodom is standing right beside him, and the line includes “お前,” the flow seems off. I read the “で” as a typo and thought “Let’s go, Sodom” could work, but it still sounded odd.

Assuming it’s not a typo, maybe Dogman is referencing Sodom as a place or talking to someone other than Sodom…

VC went with the original Japanese being a misprint. VIZ went with Dogman talking to someone else, probably because he's facing away from Sodom. These are choices that translators regularly have to make when something's off about the original text, like deciding if it was intentional or not before knowing the next chapters.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/EigoKaiki Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24

I was looking for the reason for this and the other errors in the offficals since c401. It seems that the editor (proofreader) was changed. The guy is on Twitter, and based on the posts there, he seems to be less motivated or competent than the previous editor. (He said after one chapter that his dog got sick so he almost didn't make it.)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/Itszdoodoobaby Nov 03 '24

Interesting differences between the unofficial & Viz translations..

I have to say that I preferred TCB & Veracious’ translations this week. IMO, the official did a disservice to what is otherwise my favorite chapter of this recent batch. 

Dogman’s 5meter sniffles vs Nobunaga’s 5meter En …. I smell fireworks, pun intended. Interesting to note Nobunaga hasn’t obtained his physical sword yet, btw

Also, what ever happened to Belerainte? Is he Hisoka? Did Hisoka kill & masquerade himself as Belerainte? And used Marayam’s ability as an excuse to run loose on tier 1/ the entire boat? Someone please tell me what day Belerainte was last seen in story…

fantastic chapter…. 

→ More replies (3)

5

u/1vergil Nov 04 '24

Giving more thoughts about Rinsworth' murder i think there are 3 possibilities:

• Tser killed him after Being groomed for years, Risnorth made Tser to be the monster he is now, and the monster killed his own creator. The authorities are hiding the reports to not expose Tser as the killer.

• Risnorth own party killed him to avoid getting exposed after realizing the PT is tracking them, that was my first thought in Theory in case Togashi is going for realistic mafia methods eliminating their own minions to avoid getting exposed.

• The PT killed him and completed their revenge but the only reason the authorities are hiding it because the PT reason of the murder exposes Risnorth' shady actions in public so the authorities are trying to downplay it as fake news. This scenario seems possible but it depends on the real report if it contains their famous message then it would explain everything, and if the PT obtained the tape then they would've leaked it everywhere to expose him but maybe they never got the Sarasa tape, maybe Tser does have it which might give more plot importance to the PT interactions with Tser.

5

u/sandalterbang Nov 05 '24

Alright hear my out. The treasure chrollo’s seeking, its kurapika’s ability. But he doesnt want to steal it, he wants to make a deal with kurapika. Help me kill hisoka, then you can kill me afterwards. Either that or chrollo would help kurapika recover the rest of kurta eyes.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/karlokattaneo Nov 03 '24

has someone found any foreshadowing that kenny was a traitor? also smiling at someone might be the condition to activate his nen and now that he's an enemy it's bad news for the troupe

2

u/Slick_Vik Nov 03 '24

Super interesting chapter, glad we’re getting the focus on the troupe for a bit

Hisoka’s monologue at the start of the chapter was really cool to get insight into a characters mind that we really don’t know too much about, calling the ants ants was funny af and goes to show you how off the wall hisoka really is.

The bolonelov hisoka reveal was siiick I’ve always liked bolonelov since the chimera ant arc thought his ability was really cool and I’m excited to see him more. I thought it was super interesting how he really seems to care for chrollo as much as other troupe members even being a recent addition, preferring to have phink’s group find chrollo to spare chrollo and protect him. He’s much more tactical than I would have predicted and handles this whole swap well, I still think hisoka is gonna find him out and they’re gonna fight.

The mafia aspect of this arc is hitting the boiling point dogman time! I think morena is gonna have her symphony moment like chrollo where she unleashes the Heil-Li on the ship, since Halkenberg’s funeral is a great opportunity to get a ton of kills for levels. Contagion is a real problem, I think an underrated aspect of her ability is that since these individuals are extremely strong at level 51, but don’t have formal nen training, I’m curious to see how the troupe does against them. Similar to how if u play a noob in a video game they over perform since you don’t know their thought process, these nen users may not have the intuition to make logical moves which can make them really hard to predict. Nobunaga is one of my favorite members of the troupe so really excited that he’s getting the focus, fr every troupe member seems to really be on their A game.

I think one scary option is the troupe makes it all the way to morena, and realize they are the reason she is the way she is. In building meteor city to be a haven for crime, they may have influenced morena’s life by allowing a place for horrific crimes to exist and if she explains this I could see some more depth into the phantom troupe’s actions and origin.

Banger chapter as always I love hxh so much why can’t it stay forever 💔

2

u/BlackberryChance Nov 03 '24

who told hisoka about the nen cermony and halkunburg ?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/stripzip Nov 03 '24

When in the timeline did the murder of Risnorth happen? 5 years after the flashback? (How much longer after the flashback was 10 years before the present day?)

6

u/bbsmydiamonds Nov 03 '24

The Phantom Troupe formed about 14 years ago, and Sarasa died about 17 years ago.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KilluaZaol Nov 05 '24

I just realised, weren’t Nobu and the boys supposed to grab Franklin on the way?

4

u/stripzip Nov 03 '24

Togashi draws Hisoka like he knows how strongly his presence is felt right now

4

u/Player1iea Nov 04 '24

Bono thinks to himself that he wants Phinks' group to deal with Hisoka.

Who do you guys think would win in a 1v3 battle between Hisoka VS Phinks, Feitan, and Nobunaga?

8

u/jojosimp02 Nov 04 '24

Hisoka gets destroyed in a 3 vs 1.

10

u/Outside_Narwhal3069 Nov 04 '24

I think 3v1's with nen users that talented is a really hard fight and gives the group such a big advantage. Definitely not a fight he should take if he can avoid it.

→ More replies (2)