r/respectthreads • u/ya-boi-benny • Oct 11 '23
games Respect Johnathan Crane, the Scarecrow (Arkhamverse)
Remnants of Gotham, I have messages for you all. To the vandals who stayed behind to pick the still warm flesh from Gotham's bones: have your fun. You are under my protection. To the cowards quaking behind the police department's walls: you will not be spared. And to Batman: I have already won. Emptied your city with a vial of toxin and a few threatening words. That's how little the safety you provided was worth. And when the dawn comes...when Gotham lies in ruins and I turn my gaze to the world beyond...the legend of the Batman will be worth nothing at all.
Johnathan Crane was a highly educated professor of psychology with an unhealthy interest in fear. Soon, his interest gave way to obsession, leading him to create a panic-inducing drug and a new identity: the spine-chilling Scarecrow. Slipping into the Batman's rogues gallery, Crane would find himself a regular guest in Arkham Asylum among the other insane supervillains. During the Joker's mass breakout of the prison, the Scarecrow would run into a one-sided fight with Killer Croc.
Years later, wounds left untreated, the Scarecrow would try his hand as the Batman's arch nemesis. Promising every villain in Gotham a night of unending horror, Crane unleashed his fear toxin on a city-wide scale on Halloween night in an attempt to finally snuff out Gotham's hope in the vigilante. But even his latest formula couldn't break the Batman's spirit, and Crane found himself on the receiving end of the nightmares.
Note
The Arkhamverse canon is a little bit messy, especially when it comes to non-video game media like the tie-in comics and novel. There are a couple inconsistencies, like dead characters coming back to life or Gotham being fully populated with citizens during the events of Scarecrow’s Cloudburst attack. Despite these inconsistencies, I’ve tried to look at every appearance of the Scarecrow in the Arkham franchise. Full source list can be found here.
Physicals
Strength
Destroys furniture like arcade cabinets or slot machines with his scythe
Repeatedly bashes Batman in the head with a steel rod, flooring him
Durability
Gets grabbed by Killer Croc and mauled by the villain, but Crane survives and grabs onto a floating container of Titan to make it back to land
Remains conscious after Batman slams his head into a console, breaking the device
[Limit] One-tapped by Jason Todd's Robin
Agility
Fear Toxin
Delivery Methods
Handheld
His first syringe glove has needles that pierce the armor on Batman’s gauntlet
His second glove has needles that puncture the armor around Batman’s upper chest and can spray aerosolized toxin
Can toss Gas Grenades that spread out in a radius, inflicting enemies with fear
Crane was going to drop a smoking sack of toxin into the catacombs to poison Gotham’s citizens for a century
A henchmen used a smoking bag of toxin to throw a diner into terror
While incarcerated, Scarecrow induces panic in his doctor and guards with toxins present in his cologne
Rigged Gas Traps
Cloudburst Dispersal Device
Crane has modified Stagg Enterprises’ Cloudburst dispersal device to release his toxins, leading to a gas cloud that covers all of Gotham City. This gas is specifically amplified by the Nimbus power cell within the Cloudburst.
The toxin is so dense that Batman’s scanners cannot penetrate it
Once the Cloudburst is destroyed, Poison Ivy sacrifices her life to empower her plants producing enough spores to disperse the cloud of fear toxin.
Potency
Scarecrow sent a henchman to attack Pauli’s Diner, throwing an armed cop and a number of other patrons into a homicidal panic. This used only five ounces of his fear toxin.
Specific Hallucinations
In Batman
Oracle becomes unreachable until Batman shakes off the effects
The interior of Arkham Asylum turns into a floating, chaotic environment, complete with a colossal Scarecrow. Batman must make his way through this obstacle course and shine a searchlight on the Scarecrow, symbolizing his resistance to the fear toxin.
Batman sees a hallway gradually transform into Crime Alley until experiencing the death of his parents again. Batman then sees himself as his eight-year-old self until he gets a grip.
When climbing up a clock tower in reality, Batman’s surroundings change to swinging pendulums and turning gears
The video game, Batman: Arkham Asylum, appears to crash before resetting itself with a whole new story. Here, Batman is the insane inmate who gets arrested by the Joker, looked over by Harley Quinn and Scarecrow, and imprisoned by criminals in Warden Scarface’s asylum. Joker then shoots Batman in the head, with the game over screen telling the player to move the non-existent middle stick to dodge the shot
Relationship with Joker Blood
Scarecrow’s latest fear toxin was designed to interact with the Joker’s blood present in Batman’s body, leading to the caped crusader seeing hallucinations of his dead arch nemesis. While the Joker hallucinations are normally just irritating distractions, sometimes, they can manifest as debilitating episodes for Batman.
Sees a group of unconscious militia members wake up and become Jokers before him, then the clowns hold him down and choke him, preventing him from helping Simon Stagg
Shows Batman two Scarecrows, and when he grabs the hallucination, the real villain attacks
Once again, he’s forced to witness his parent’s final resting place, although this time he’s accosted by copies of the Joker. Joker instigates Batman into fighting using lethal means, demoralizing the hero.
After the Joker’s blood fully saturates Batman’s brain and the clown’s personality takes full control, the effects of fear toxin instead center around Joker’s fear of being forgotten.
Joker sees reminders of his death, like a painted mural of his corpse, his own cremation and an overgrown, forgotten statue of himself
Witnesses his own wake, which no one came to besides Harley Quinn
Finally, Joker encounters a spectral Batman who locks up and moves on from the Joker’s memory, successfully curing Batman of both the Joker’s blood and the Scarecrow’s toxin
In Anyone Else
Bane is trapped in a nightmare that flashes back to his childhood in prison, where he’s accosted by a bat-like priest character. Bane eventually regains his composure enough to fight Batman, but he’s still plagued with hallucinations, seeing the vigilante as a flaming bat-creature.
Throws doctors and an inmate into a panic before incapacitating them
Limits
In the game, the spores that counter fear toxin were specifically created by Poison Ivy, using her powers to manipulate plant life on a molecular level. In the novel, the spores that counter Scarecrow’s toxin come from the bristlecone pine tree, an already existing plant.
Hugo Strange treats fear toxin exposure with a chemical antidote or isolated confinement
Batman powers through “enough toxins to drive ten men insane”
Other Drugs
Miscellaneous
This resistance isn’t absolute. When Batman injects Crane with his latest toxins, he is driven into babbling and shivering fits.
Has hidden fear gas canisters on Arkham Island. In addition, he’s also somehow established a small headquarters on Arkham Island, complete with blueprints of the asylum buildings.
5
u/XXBEERUSXX ⭐ Heir to the Monado Oct 11 '23
Great thread Benny