r/AskReddit • • Nov 19 '12

Who thinks "Mens Gift Ideas" are always super lame? Men of reddit what lame "guy" gifts are you tired of receiving? How would you edit these lists your wives, mothers, sisters are reading?

2.4k Upvotes

11.5k comments sorted by

2.1k

u/sokpuppet1 Nov 19 '12

New York Magazine suggested "Beard Oil" as a gift last year. Beard oil.

1.6k

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

does a beard need to be lubed?

→ More replies (234)

438

u/WonderfulUnicorn Nov 19 '12

I've used beard oil before -- it's fucking magical. If your man has a full beard it's practically a necessity.

→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (116)

2.0k

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Judging by the things that get my husband's attention in a shop, good gifts are:

  • Light bulbs

  • Batteries

  • Bungie cord

  • Wire cutters

He doesn't get out much.

469

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

this made me giggle, my husband had the longest conversation about the new eco friendly low wattage bulbs with me in the store last month.

→ More replies (91)

1.6k

u/apoptoeses Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

you forgot flashlights. The men in my life have a strange obsession with a nice flashlight.

edit:as of this time there have been 23 fleshlight jokes. We get it, guys. :)

→ More replies (324)

132

u/engunneer2 Nov 19 '12

Sounds like you should get him make magazine.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (66)

1.9k

u/Beholdereye Nov 19 '12

Cologne. I have an entire shelf in my medicine cabinet dedicated to the various colognes I've received as gifts. I do not need a bottle every single year.

As far as socks and boxer shorts - please leave this to my wife. She knows what fits and looks best on me.

1.2k

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

I can't imagine someone other than your wife buying your boxers (except maybe mom)?

625

u/Beholdereye Nov 19 '12

My mom has tried the last couple of years, but she doesn't understand that I'm in better shape than I was when I lived with them (mostly due to not having the physical downtime now as a husband/father). So the stuff she buys me is usually way too big.

Conversely, my wife's grandmother insists on buying me shirts/socks every year that are clearly too small for me. I usually just donate them to salvation army in January.

857

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

Why do people want to buy other people clothes? Especially when they just have no clue what size they wear? It's like, oh hey these jeans would be great for my brother in law... I think he looks like a 40X36. Why????

→ More replies (300)
→ More replies (66)
→ More replies (75)

422

u/nothas Nov 19 '12

buying cologne for someone is a weird gift

"this is what i think you should smell like! enjoy!"

→ More replies (30)

196

u/bebob10 Nov 19 '12

Could be a nice way of saying you stink dude.

→ More replies (53)

113

u/smile_if_you_like_me Nov 19 '12

Upvote, but I disagree here. I take advantage of the fact that people are willing to stock up my cologne collection for the year. In fact, I make it a point to let them know throughout the year what my favorite cologne is so they know what to get me once the holidays come. It's better than them trying guess what cologne I like or even what to get me. Most of my friends already know and I know what to expect. Win win.

→ More replies (115)

186

u/maemtz Nov 19 '12

Fuck, fuck, fuck. Cologne is my go to gift =/

→ More replies (67)
→ More replies (105)

2.2k

u/LiterallyOuttoLunch Nov 19 '12

Everyone knows just to buy me booze. I haven't regifted since the first Bush administration.

483

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

Such a classy gift I think.... so long as it is Old English or Kentucky Gentlemen.

→ More replies (100)

837

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

To be more specific, scotch.

Get a (reasonably priced but good) bottle of balvenie doublewood 12, glenfiddich 15 or macallan 10 (fine oak).

419

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

Good Scotch is always a tasteful choice!

→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (173)
→ More replies (74)

37

u/allthecats Nov 19 '12

I'm an ex-personal shopper. I can smell bullshit "gift guides" from a mile away.

That being said, the best site for men's gifts that I've found is Uncrate

6

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

I bookmarked it... some stuff is awesome but terribly expensive, but at the very least I think it's insightful.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

2.2k

u/Salacious- Nov 19 '12

I think the same people who write those also write Cosmo's sex tips lists.

1.2k

u/DancesWithDaleks Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

"Slip a donut around his penis and nibble it off." No, really.

edit: You guys might also like Nerve's list of Cosmo's worst BDSM tips.

→ More replies (194)

166

u/knivesngunz Nov 19 '12

At the rate they're going, Cosmo allegedly has more moves than the Kama Sutra to keep their men "coming back for more in the bedroom"

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (951)

1.3k

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

CowJam's Gift Ideas for Men:

  • Anything involving high voltage (tesla coil, nixie tubes, electric fly swatter, etc).

  • Any of the 'adult' (read: expensive) lego kits such as the taj mahal or the millennium falcon.

  • A blu-ray box set. They're pretty cheap and I'll enjoy them. I've just seen all of Heroes for £30.

  • Any blu-ray that has been released following the purchase of a box set. For example, Prometheus or the latest Batman film when it's out.

  • Anything involving a hobby you know I enjoy. Try to avoid the 'joke' products surrounding the hobby (especially golf). I'd rather have something small but decent than large and shit.

  • Vouchers are fine as long as they're for non-sensible shops. If you're getting me a voucher make sure it's for the likes of play.com, firebox, etc and not debenhams.

edit: a watch. I'm never going to complain about a watch, even if it cost you 50p from the market.

81

u/USxMARINE Nov 19 '12

A blu-ray box set. They're pretty cheap

Where the hell are you shopping???

→ More replies (16)

227

u/thunnus Nov 19 '12

I would build the shit out of lego millenium falcon.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (345)

92

u/married_a_beaner Nov 19 '12

I don't think there is a lame gift. There are just gifts. Its the act its self that is special. Someone thought I was special enough to give me something. Whether its a tie or a package of socks it doesn't matter because the giver took the time to think of me.

29

u/and_how Nov 19 '12

I think that is a nice way of thinking about it but I surely know people who gift others out of expectation rather than heart/thought. And I suppose they do take the time but are thinking that they want to spend the least amount of energy on your gift so they can go on to more important things.

13

u/ThePlaceWhere Nov 19 '12

I wish my family understood this concept. Here's the fuckery that goes on at Christmas every year in my family and on every birthday. The recipient buys their own gifts (and those of their own family if it's husband/wife, but they must tell each other exactly what to get), sometimes even wraps their own gift, trades each other the money for the gift (or sometimes doesn't to adjust for the price of the meal), even though everyone spends around the same amount so this is really pointless. If you are like me, and refuse to do that, all hell breaks loose and you get a candy bar with a 20$ bill taped to it from everyone. Also you are known as the "difficult one".

Oh we've also had years where we've incorporated a white elephant gift as well, which made everyone pissed off and someone cried. We have also tried to incorporate a "hand-made" gift to save money, which everyone ended up spending MORE money on and it looked like shit.

I'm considered an asshole because I think people should actually have to think about others for ten seconds. Anyone else go through this holiday shit?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (28)

766

u/Worstdriver Nov 19 '12

I once bought my Dad a complete set of tires for his pickup truck. The best on the market. They lasted 5 years, over all kinds of terrain, hunting, fishing, picking up loads, general driving. He constantly told his friends, "My son bought me these incredible tires."

→ More replies (46)

2.2k

u/ReluctantRedditor275 Nov 19 '12

I own four flasks. I consider myself a moderate-to-heavy drinker, but this is overkill. Am I supposed to strap them onto some kind of bandoleer and keep it under my poncho when I go to a sporting event? (Actually, as I'm typing this, I realize this is not the worst idea ever.)

397

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Yes, but do you have a Freedom Flask?

EDIT: I understand it is terrible for many reasons, but you gotta admit, the sheer novelty of the idea is compelling.

→ More replies (42)

19

u/pogu Nov 19 '12

Start a liquor geocache group, with a buy in.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (99)

1.7k

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Let me just get this out of my system: unless they have expressly said the kind of animal they want or they are your child (in which case you were probably planning on taking care of it anyway) never EVER buy someone a pet as a gift.

1.4k

u/_Pliny_ Nov 19 '12

I'd go one step further and say don't give animals as gifts.

Kids think of "gifts" and think of toys, which are essentially disposable. Getting a pet should be treated as a adoption; involve the kids in the process of finding an animal, talk about the responsibility involved, the animals needs, etc.

→ More replies (60)

320

u/accidentallyelven Nov 19 '12

This should be a well-known fact, and it saddens me that it isn't. When you buy the actual pet, you're only paying a tiny amount of what the owner will have to spend in food costs, supplies, vet bills, etc. Not to mention time. Years of responsibility do not make good gifts.

→ More replies (26)

19

u/tree_hugging_hippie Nov 19 '12

I'm just going to add that unless you are the parent of the child receiving an animal, just don't get them an animal. The parents are the best judges of whether or not that child is even ready for the responsibility of a pet. Every year after Christmas and Easter you read about how shelters are suddenly full of half-grown dogs and rabbits because someone thought "Oh, little so-and-so would love a puppy/bunny!"

Seriously, pets aren't just accessory objects or cute toys.

17

u/FancyDressKitten Nov 19 '12

As an adoption counselor at an animal shelter, I'm really sad I can only upvote this once.

We only allow goft adoptions if the person recieving the pet is there to pick it out, we are confident that they are aware of the responsibilities of having a pet, there are no red flags on their adoption application, etc.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (51)

1.1k

u/othersomethings Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 20 '12

I've had some great results getting men in my family gifts from American Science & Surplus.

edit: their site has been down most of the day since I posted this....thanks reddit effect. If the link works, give them your business. if not, save it for later and then give them all your money.

285

u/greensmurf30 Nov 19 '12

Did we break it? Or is my internet just pooping on me?

→ More replies (19)

141

u/machzel08 Nov 19 '12

Holy crap this site is amazing. There goes the rest of my day.

→ More replies (10)

65

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

This store is in my town. We shop here SO MUCH. Every holiday season they also do these fun experiments that scare the crap out of the kids.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (105)

1.5k

u/ununpentium89 Nov 19 '12

My boyfriend made everything simple for me- he pointed me in the direction of his Amazon wishlist. Can't go wrong.

1.3k

u/ShoGunzalez Nov 19 '12

Great idea! I'm so going to do this, I just need to get me a girlfriend...

→ More replies (50)
→ More replies (53)

2.6k

u/Squilliant-Flatoose Nov 19 '12

In my family, we just get each other gift cards for Christmas. $50 each. We've also stopped loving each other.

1.1k

u/tuck5649 Nov 19 '12

Gift cards? Who hurt you?

→ More replies (32)

124

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

My dad bought me new plates. For his house. Because his plates were old and I didnt like them.

→ More replies (2)

96

u/iwannagobacktosleep Nov 19 '12

We've also stopped loving each other.

it saves so much time.

57

u/aedile Nov 19 '12

I make it a point to send a picture of whatever I buy when I get a gift card with a "Loving what you got me for [holiday]!" kind of sentiment.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Sofa_Queen Nov 19 '12

Convenient, yes. Personal, no. I stopped giving gift cards to the family members I really like--I shop for them. Not my favorite? Target or Starbucks card for you.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (159)

309

u/Chili440 Nov 19 '12

Try being a 50 year old woman - no, I don't fucking want the Susan Boyle CD.

→ More replies (6)

3.4k

u/FinanceITGuy Nov 19 '12

Older guy here. I welcome and appreciate all gifts, but really I don't need another mug. Here's the proper tip: don't buy him a mug, buy him the liquids that go in the mug. Want to spend $5-10? A nice craft beer would be highly appreciated. $10-15? A pound of good coffee. Want to go over the top and spend $35-75? Buy the guy a damned bottle of Scotch.

1.6k

u/Corix Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Older guy here as well (40)... I wish I had more upvotes to give you. Perfect suggestions on all counts.

→ More replies (247)
→ More replies (317)

876

u/khdutton Nov 19 '12

Please, no Page-A-Day Calendars focused on something that I mentioned in passing that I had a slight interest in eight months ago.

113

u/SimplyGeek Nov 19 '12

I still get calendars. Who uses paper calendars anymore? Let me set aside space on my desk for this block of paper to track my appointments. And when I'm not at my desk, I'm fucked cuz I can't access it. Sweet!

→ More replies (23)

14

u/namulith Nov 19 '12

Well, they remembered something you said in passing eight months ago. Doesn't sound that bad to me. Maybe they don't know much else about you.

→ More replies (34)

2.7k

u/noahisaac Nov 19 '12

My wife absolutely cannot believe that I want tools as gifts. I guess to her, it would be like me buying her a vacuum cleaner or washing machine. To me, though, getting a chainsaw is like a chance to do something awesome.

1.4k

u/dacutty Nov 19 '12

Gave my Dad a Stihl Chainsaw with a 20" bar for his birthday one year. A bad ass chainsaw, I did a lot of research. You should have seen his eyes light up like there wasn't one safe tree on the property. LOL, his house is surrounded by trees. He loses one every wind or ice storm. A very pragmatic gift.

→ More replies (119)

1.8k

u/ozzimark Nov 19 '12

There can never be enough chainsaws and torches.

→ More replies (147)

371

u/ThePlaceWhere Nov 19 '12

One year we got my dad a chainsaw (one of the rare times we actually guessed a gift) and just before he opened the box, he jokingly said "I'm glad this isn't something stupid like a chainsaw!" Way to suck out the Christmas joy.

He ended up doing a lot of shit with that chainsaw though, so it worked out.

→ More replies (39)

606

u/avatar28 Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Shit, power tools make anything more fun. I always hated pumpkin carving with the kids (never cared for it for myself either). This year I broke out the Dremel and used the spiral saw bit. Damn if it wasn't a hell of a lot more fun.

edit: spelling. Stupid autocorrect.

Edit 2: Since this comment got a lot more attention than I expected, here is one of the pumpkins we carved. It's a little sloppy because it was cold and dark when we were doing it and I was still getting used to it. It was supposed to be the logo for the Turner Syndrome Society.

→ More replies (60)

138

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

What do you want for Christmas?

A drill press kit.

Ok.

Receive pots and pans set.

Fuck.

Although I do love cooking...

→ More replies (11)

128

u/mozaleia Nov 19 '12

I got a steam mop and a new vacuum for Christmas last year, I fucking LOVED them. I also got a new washer and dryer for valentines day that I picked out. I am a strange woman.

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (387)

881

u/frostingvscake Nov 19 '12

As a woman, my proudest gift giving moment was after my husband proposed to me. I didn't think it was fair that I got a diamond ring and he didn't get anything so I bought him an engagement PS3.

256

u/goose_egg Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 20 '12

After I proposed to my wife, she got me some cool stuff, including an incredible watch and Batman: Arkham City. My response as I was opening the box:

Aww you didn't have to-BATMAN!!!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (51)

191

u/bongozap Nov 19 '12

My mom, for some mystifying reason, used to buy me stuff for bagels. Over the years I got:

• a plexi bagel storage thingy • a plexi bagel-cutting rack • cream cheese seasoning packets • assorted spreaders and knives

I had no idea there were so many things available. I eventually told her I never wanted anything that had to do with the storage or preparation of a bagel.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12

I think sometimes relatives, especially older ones, get caught in some kind of loop. Maybe she saw you eat a bagel once, and she thought "bongozap looks like he's really enjoying that bagel". And then later, when gift giving time came around, she was like "shit, what does he like again?" and some weird neurons fired in her brain and were all like "bagels".

My grandmother does this except with Hello Kitty, because she saw me use a Hello Kitty folder or something. Once. In the eighth grade. I'm in my twenties now, grandma, please don't get me any more Hello Kitty appliances.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/lasercow Nov 19 '12

can i have your bagel stuff?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1.8k

u/1950sGuy Nov 19 '12

All I want for Christmas is the will to live and maybe a new hat.

1.9k

u/c_is_4_cookie Nov 19 '12

...and all I got was this hat.

→ More replies (40)

107

u/redpariah Nov 19 '12

You a big Team Fortress 2 player?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (133)

1.7k

u/Strider-SnG Nov 19 '12

moral of story...buy everyone booze. It's just easier.

1.0k

u/God_Wills_It_ Nov 19 '12

Or weed if you live in Washington or Colorado

→ More replies (83)
→ More replies (74)

1.2k

u/dangerousbirde Nov 19 '12

"I'm tired of receiving good whiskey." - said no man ever.

91

u/neutralchaos Nov 19 '12

I actually don't drink any liquor. Yes I am a man, I just work in a chem lab. It tastes like work...

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (37)

648

u/scientist_tz Nov 19 '12

Learn all about the stuff he might actually like as a gift and put some thought into it.

For example: if he plays Xbox take a look at all the stuff he already has. Is he using a wired headset that's all beat to shit? Get him a wireless one. Is he putting regular batteries in the controllers? Get him a battery pack. Does he own copies of Halo 1,2, and 3? Get him Halo 4. That's a simplistic example but you could apply it to any hobby. Most of the time it requires even less effort. Maybe he likes to go fishing...just go to Cabela's and say "my husband likes to fish" and they'll show you 50 things you could get him.

Worst case scenario: he already has the the thing you got him and has to take it back but he won't really care. The effort is what counts.

483

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

"Oh thanks, you got me an errand. I'd rather just throw it out."

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (86)

1.1k

u/Diablo_swing Nov 19 '12

I never understood why people hated Christmas. After reading this, I realize my parents are the world's best gift givers.

I am definitely looking forward to another year of Astro Boy dvd's and action figures! No man gifts for me.

698

u/Narissis Nov 19 '12

I think I've finally gotten my parents to understand that I'm not just joking when I say I want Lego for any and all gift-giving occasions.

→ More replies (95)
→ More replies (79)

460

u/Janube Nov 19 '12

Gift #1. Amazon gift cards. Seriously. If you're ever even remotely unsure what to get me, this solves your problem 100%. I get to pick the gift, so you know I'll like it, it's a "store" that carries virtually everything, so regardless of what I need, I can buy it. If I get multiples, I can stack them easily on my account instead of keeping track of a million cards in my wallet.

Gift #2. If you are close to me- anything you made yourself that carries emotional meaning or relates to a hobby of mine.

The number of times my brothers and I have simply made each other board game stuff for Christmas... And those are always the coolest gifts.

→ More replies (35)

522

u/four_chambers Nov 19 '12

People tend to get guys power tools and cologne and boxer shorts and whatnot. Guys, I might be 30, but I want the same shit you were getting me when I was 15. Video games, movies, comic books, and toys. I want to rip open a present and see a Mars Attacks set of cards staring back up at me. That would be the best Christmas ever.

435

u/caffeinefree Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

I just bought my boyfriend a remote control helicopter for his birthday. He was outrageously excited about it and has been chasing the cats around the house with it twice a day ever since.

edit: Since lots of people seem to think this is a cool idea, this is the helicopter I bought him. For $30, it seems remarkably sturdy. Despite numerous crashes, we haven't broken it yet. It is a little tricky to fly, but for him that's part of the fun. He likes showing me the new "tricks" as he learns them.

→ More replies (62)

51

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Power Tools are the video games of middle age. Along with actual video games.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/vegan_velociraptor Nov 19 '12

Speak for yourself, dude. I fucking love power tools.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (33)

142

u/sagewah Nov 19 '12

Tools.

No, wait, I fucking love getting tools - as long as they don't suck. If I'm saving up to buy myself a fancy tool and somebody beats me to it and gives me a cheap version of that tool, it kinda sucks a little bit because I'm then obligated to use a cheaper tool.

→ More replies (35)

114

u/Epsilon_balls Nov 19 '12

I'd just like to take this moment to mention that if you are planning on giving someone a board game, please either pick one that you enjoy, or check with boardgamegeek first.

→ More replies (32)

60

u/zeroblack Nov 19 '12

I make a small amazon wishlist of different comics and trade paperbacks. I used to get books, but since I shifted to a Kindle this has gotten a bit more difficult for them to gift. I mostly just ask for cash and Amazon gift cards. My parents are thankfully as practical as I am, but I do get the occasional scarf or sweater.

→ More replies (9)

964

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

If I get one more dildo. Amirite?

1.3k

u/coolmanmax2000 Nov 19 '12

Ugh. Re-gifting is the worst.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (38)

888

u/doppelmoppel Nov 19 '12

They're just as bad as Women's Gift Ideas. Because you know, all women like pink stuff, jewelry, smelly crap, and overly expensive red wine as well as overpriced culinary courses.

Best thing to do to anyone is to either gift them something they have mentioned they want, or give them a general voucher.

198

u/iltopop Nov 19 '12

Living in an area where hunting is extremely popular, you can always get your woman a nice pink-camo shotgun. I cringe every time I see a pink firearm.

→ More replies (67)
→ More replies (207)

850

u/MacaroniCrayon Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

My family is upper middle class, and this makes buying gifts fucking imposible. They can all buy their own stuff, and so they do. I've gotten into the habit of going to the mall and pulling one of those christmas angle tags for each 'family' in my family. (one for cousin, wife, kid. one for grandma and grandpa. ect.) I buy all the stuff the starving kid person wants and take a picture. Print the picture, and stick it in their cards with the sentiment, "Look what you did for some sad little shit!" It's the one time of year my family is charitable... you know, because I don't give them a choice.

Edit: Christmas angel*

48

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

I'm not too wealthy but I have a decent job and few expenses so I have a fair amount of disposable income as well.

My GF is poor and she complains there's never anything to get me for gifts.

My solution: we share an Amazon Prime account, whenever I see something inexpensive that I'd like, but don't need right away, I just add it to my wishlist and she then has a bunch of ideas for easy gifts.

Only problem is, now I know exactly what she got me.

→ More replies (3)

107

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

I usually donate to The Human Fund for my coworkers around Christmas. That way I don't actually have to buy them anything.

→ More replies (6)

64

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Actually the donating to charity gift seems increasingly popular in my family. It's pretty much the same deal where we aren't rich, but anything that my parents want that's not like...a boat or something...they sort of already have. So in the past they've asked for charitable donating in their name, or just nothing at all. I kind of feel the same. I'm living more-or-less a minimalistic life in student poverty (living like your poor when you aren't), and I like it. I have what I want and I don't want more to clutter my tiny apartment. So when I make a list it's either very practical things (this year probably socks, a wall clock, and that sort) or nothing at all.

Being away at college I don't care much about gifts, and don't wake up all excited Christmas morning like I used to. I'm just happy to be home with my family for a month or so. It's the only time I'm home all year sometimes.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/WolfPack_VS_Grizzly Nov 19 '12

Dang, tell us how you really feel about your family.

→ More replies (64)

111

u/spock_block Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Things to buy:

  • Circular baking form thingy with a hole in the middle, I just find Torus-shaped cakes are easier to cut into even pieces. Apperently a bundt pan.

  • A lot of candy

  • A mini helicopter I can fly around the room and attempt to land on increasingly more precarious flat surfaces until I finally knock something over and take the secret with me to the grave

  • Socks, preferably fancy ones for sports

  • Things you made yourself (knitting, woodcraft, papercraft, painting you name it)

  • Lego and mechanical lego

  • Just about any form of motor

But most importantly, if you can't afford it, for the love of god don't give me the gift of feeling bad for you. Don't get me anything!

→ More replies (12)

173

u/Joel_Robuchon Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

All I want for Christmas is my Pyrex!!

Edit: it was a Rick Ross reference guys!! I really appreciate all your cooking advice though <3

→ More replies (41)

17

u/immortalsix Nov 19 '12

I want something that will last forever.

Not a flask, beard trimmer, or personalized keychain.

I want a big leather belt (or briefcase or boots). I want a turntable to play records on. I want a compass or a watch I can pass on to my kids.

I don't want something that plugs in - unless it's a drill press or a bandsaw.

I want something that will never end up at Goodwill.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/apaniyam Nov 20 '12

Single dad weighing in.
Either get me a gift, or my son a gift. Don't get my son a gift and put my name on it. I'd be totally ok with you getting him something rad, and me something token (even a nice card). The gift part of Christmas is for kids, I'm there for the family.

→ More replies (2)

259

u/CooterSquirrel Nov 19 '12

Gotta be honest here, as a 22 year old I've only been getting "man" gifts for a few years now (as opposed to "boy" gifts) and I've always been pleased with what I've gotten. We may be defining this differently, or it may be age-related... but when I think of man gifts I think of things like socks & ties, cologne, car stuff (say a box of Armorall products), tools (the Leatherman I got last year is fucking tight), clocks/watches, "bathroom reading" type books, cuff links...

And I love getting all of that stuff.

EDIT Especially cologne, that shit's expensive. Give me a bigass bottle of Acqua Di Gio for Christmas and I'm happy as a pig in shit

71

u/nowhereman1280 Nov 19 '12

I'll second tools. The thing is though, don't buy men shitty tools like the Home Depot Off Brand. Buy the expensive name brand stuff (if you don't know anything about it, find the most authoritative looking guy in the tools section at Home Depot or Lowes and tell them you want to know what the best XXXXX tool is. They'll tell you what the one or two best versions XXXXX tool is and buy one.

Everyone loves a Leatherman, no one loves a shitty off brand pocket knife.

My family all chipped in last year to buy me a full set of cordless Makita power tools (the green kind, not the shitty white kind) and I've made massive use of them this past year. Nothing like having 18 volts instead of 12. Great gift.

→ More replies (50)
→ More replies (73)

305

u/raegunXD Nov 19 '12

This thread makes me laugh. I (a wife) came here for more ideas. But it's all the same! Most of you posted what you hate getting, normal goddamn things, like socks, ties, and sweaters. It makes me laugh because the problem with guys is that you're always vague, non-specific. That's exactly what you guys are doing! You're posting what you don't like getting every year instead of posting what you would rather get!

I want to see some IDEAS, boys! We all know you hate cologne and boxers. What would you rather get?

27

u/KarmaAndLies Nov 19 '12

Guy's gifts really break down into two areas:

  • Fun gifts: This is very individual and tricky (e.g. for some guys it might be expensive beers, toy helicopters, robots, etc). This doesn't mean random shit off of ThinkGeek that you haven't given any thought to just because it is in the "gifts for men" category.

  • Useful gifts: This is something women themselves don't want and often project that onto guys. That is unfortunate as we really like useful things, in particular if they're novel (e.g. Flashlights, Tools - in particular unusual tools, something to make our lives easier like a snow mover, a more powerful - anything, gadgets, etc).

A fun gift which is also useful (as a bad example, a Swiss Army Knife) are the ultimate.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/MechaGallade Nov 19 '12

After reading this thread, I (19 M) have concluded that the best gifts are legos, craft beers, chain saws, and weed.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (104)

160

u/Tgeo888 Nov 19 '12

Tools. Buy him TOOLS because he's a GUY. -every sears commercial ever

86

u/AbstergoSupplier Nov 19 '12

But tools are useful and expensive

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (36)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12

I want a crossbow that shoots chainsaws. That is all

294

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Things I like to receive as gifts:

  • Blowjob

  • Beer

  • Whiskey

  • Socks

  • Underwear

  • Lego Robotics/Technic

  • Ammunition

  • Blowjob

Things I don't like to receive as gifts:

  • Everything else

It's pretty fucking simple.

EDIT: Fuck. I definitely didn't think the blowjob idea through well enough. Well, here's to hoping my family doesn't get me any blowjobs this holiday season!

285

u/curioushipster Nov 19 '12

I don't quite believe you. What if everyone in your family decides that a blowjob is the perfect present for you?

→ More replies (11)

75

u/OpusCrocus Nov 19 '12

That awkward moment when Mom and Grandma both got you the blowjob you asked for.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (22)

46

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

The avon catalogue men's section is hilarious.

→ More replies (8)

989

u/nemomnemosyne Nov 19 '12

I don't get why people don't just give you cash. Then you can spend it on whatever your girlfriend likes.

875

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Because at that point, if everyone is giving each other money then what's the point? Skip the middleman and everyone by yourselves stuff for Christmas.

Gifts should be thoughtful and have a purpose. They create memories and sentiment to be treasured through the years. It shouldn't be an obligation that shifts into a yearly retarded money Exchange.

→ More replies (56)
→ More replies (41)

461

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

I got the bf a nice beer brewing kit and hockey tickets....win or no? I'd like to think I'm good at gift giving but I don't know.

Edit: So, beer brewing kit=good for people who express interest, shitty and time consuming for the average male who has no interest. Thanks for the constructive feedback everyone.

1.1k

u/catch22milo Nov 19 '12

Well it really depends, if your boyfriend was a recovering alcoholic who hated hockey, I'd say you did a terrible job.

→ More replies (58)

76

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Where are you where there is hockey??

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (133)

9

u/creepyredditloaner Nov 19 '12

My parents know how to buy "Man" gifts. The past several have been - 60 dvd collection of classic horror and scifi movies, three box sets of books from Russian writers, a sword-cane, night vision goggles, and four gift certificates to newegg.

Love my parents.

→ More replies (3)

56

u/-Josh Nov 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '23

This response has been deleted due toe the planned changes to the Reddit API.

14

u/idrinkcoldcoffee Nov 19 '12

This to the nth degree. Please stop buying me crap I don't need and you can't afford!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Lego. As a 24 year old, members of my family look at me weirdly when I say I want lego and I just have to laugh and make out like I'm joking.

But motherfucker, lego is timeless. I'll tip that shit out on my living room floor and play with it for hours.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Mephers Nov 20 '12

My family has always been poor, myself included. When I was around 17/18 I managed to save up and get my Dad a 200-250$ grill, with smoker attachment. He loves cooking, especially grilling and smoking. It was the best gift he ever got. I am now 24, and he still brags about his awesome grill his son got him. I guess its the best grill he's ever owned. I'm still proud of it to this day.

It's served him well. It's pretty damned big.

15

u/bobbyyouspeakenglish Nov 19 '12

i got 5 wallets one year, haven't bought once since, also because i've gotten a couple since then.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Technology. As someone who is in technology, you will never figure out what I want, and theres a good chance I already bought what I want.

*Edit: One of the best gifts I ever got was a car safety flashlight. It has a wind up crank so you don't have to deal with batteries. It also has a blinking red light and magnets so you can stick it to your car in the fog (if your electrics go out). But the best part of it is that it has a window smasher and seatbelt cutter on it. Almost nobody has one of these in their car, but I always keep mine in short reach.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Thunderkiss_65 Nov 19 '12

Some of them are decent, I don't mend getting razor sets as the blades are so bloody expensive and I love getting socks, mainly because I love wearing new socks. I'm pretty easy to buy for, shaving sets, books, socks and I'm sorted.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/0rangePod Nov 19 '12

ANYTHING having to do with shaving.

Basically, this is the male equivalent of buying a woman tampons for xmas.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/buddawiggi Nov 19 '12

I do not get many gifts but the ones I do get rarely hit the mark. They are typical and typically nice; video games, nice clothes, good tickets, popular shows, fancy meals, but all I really want is sex right when I first wake up.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

cut the crap: Low end $5-$10: a roll of duct tape or a spool of 550 paracord, you can NEVER have enough.

Mid range $50-$100: Knives or flashlights. Get a tactical light from Streamlight or Surefire (yes, they are worth the price) Get any folding knife designed by Ken Onion, it will last a lifetime and he can carry it every day.

High end $300-$1500 Buy him a fire arm. From a Ruger 10-22 to a Custom AR-15 he will have this for a lifetime and never forget who gave it to him.

SUPER HIGH END $25,000-$250,000 Take him on an African Safari.

24

u/gutter_is_a_tool Nov 19 '12

Thank you Ron Swanson

→ More replies (6)

19

u/heterosoftballgirl Nov 19 '12

As a woman trolling this thread for gift ideas for the men in my life...you guys suck! "For the love of pete, don't buy undergarments" "I love a nice new pair of socks" "Anything with voltage" "Any electronic gadget for under $1000 I already have" "cologne" "are you saying I stink?" "Chainsaw!" "God I hope it's not a chainsaw!" No concensus whatsoever. That's it! Everyone's getting flashlights and scotch.

18

u/randomPOBS Nov 20 '12

It's almost like different people like different things.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/bwtaha Nov 19 '12

You are more than welcome to buy me cologne, grandma and my aunts. But it must be the cologne that I wear, which is like $70 a bottle. So feel free to just give me $10 instead of buying me that aftershave kit at the gas station.

→ More replies (1)

96

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

If you are close enough to the person that it warrants you getting them a gift, then you are close enough to them to know what they like. General gifts are bad form for everybody around.

→ More replies (41)

75

u/halo00to14 Nov 19 '12

Shirts with phrases, logos, mottos, or "witty." I appericate that you are trying to appeal to my sense of style, but my sense of style is my own and I would rather buy those types of shirts myself. Unless its bought from Woot.com I most likely will not wear the shirt.

If you want to get me a shirt, 14.5x33 plain button down is fine. If it doesn't have tapered sides, that's fine, I'll get it fixed up.

105

u/Robo-Erotica Nov 19 '12

OH WOW A BACON MUSTACHE SOMETHING SOMETHING SHIRT HOW MUCH MORE CLEVER COULD YOU GET WITH THIS SHIT

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (28)

12

u/falco_brawler Nov 19 '12

My coworker was reading "seventeen magazine" and I saw that they had a section on guys' Christmas gift ideas. It was, like, 4 testimonials on gifts guys said they wanted.

Here's what they were:

  1. A snapback (Okay... that sorta makes sense. I mean, I wouldn't want one, but I can imagine a world where someone might.)

  2. An iTunes giftcard (I think the saying "Nothing says I don't know enough about you to pick out something you'll like like a gift card" works really well here.)

  3. Some sixty dollar bracelet (Dude in the picture likes kinda like a chick... I'm sure he'd like it but no other guy would.)

  4. A super-soaker (Seriously. They actually suggested buying a guy a super soaker... in winter.)

→ More replies (18)

16

u/TheFlorence Nov 19 '12

I've always been known as a reader, but for some reason, I never seem to read the books people buy me. I think primarily because the typical gifted book is either a self-help book(7 highly productive nervous tics for super duper awesome people) or a crappy novelty book (30 hilarious pranks printed on 347 pages.)

I don't know why its so rare for people to go "hey, here's a book that is genuinely one of my favorites. I got you the kindle addition"

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Tadhgdagis Nov 19 '12

My grandfather spent at least a decade getting nothing but tacky golf-themed calendars and knick-knacks. He must have been the king of white elephant parties.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/flanjan Nov 19 '12

I wish people still gave me gifts, would be the best gift of them all...

→ More replies (2)

14

u/God_Wills_It_ Nov 19 '12

I think buying power tools is a pretty bad idea unless you know the exact tool that they need. That seems to be a "manly" thing to buy guys.

I would rather just have cash. Or better yet, decided on a date that you know that I would like (some action movie or sports game or whatever) and you do the planning and paying. Then just let me know when to go and how to get there. Easy, fun, different than the normal routine.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Just do something nice for me, I have money I don't need you to buy me anything, make me some cup cakes and give me a surprise blow job somewhere outside the bedroom and we'll all it a day.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

I might be weird, but I don't like gifts. I feel like I can get anything I want on my own. I know people like giving gifts, but the things I want are intangible. It's not that I would be disappointed if someone just dropped a bazillion dollars at my feet, it's just that it's not what I want. I don't even know what I really want.

Though what I don't mind getting is home made food. Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, Fourth of July, whatever, it's all about the food. Stuff that you don't get except maybe once or twice a year. Grandma's cookies etc.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ajtexasranger Nov 19 '12

My mom re-gifts all of the little things that she puts in my and my brother's stockings every single year. This has been going on for a few years. We don't need any small dinky gifts that I can't take back with me. Just send me a Best Buy gift card and let me buy my own gift. It is tacky, but I don't live near them and I can't take back any of the gifts in my suit case.

Actually, one year, we completely forgot about our presents after we had our Christmas dinner. It was a good day.

5

u/oneAngrySonOfaBitch Nov 19 '12

You guys are fucking ungrateful, the worst gift I'm getting is the gift of nothing.

5

u/ThomasStrife Nov 19 '12

As a real man. I expect my wife to buy the sluttiest most sexy lingerie that I get to open christmas eve and wake up to on my floor christmas day. That is all. Anything that stimulates my penis. - A REAL MAN.

5

u/Osricthebastard Nov 19 '12

How about super lame "adult" gift ideas? From the moment I turned 18 all I've wanted from xmas/birthdays were videogames/Game Stop gift cards. You know, the same thing I wanted when I was 17. Honestly do people really think that much changed about me between 17 and 18? I'm 23 now. I still want video games. Or legos. Or nerdy fantasy fiction books. Best christmas ever if you get me any of those things.

Nope. I get socks. Pants. Belts. Wallets. Watches. Toolkits. Adult male gifts. Without fail. If I wanted those things I'd buy them for myself. Xmas is supposed to be about getting things you'd feel guilty buying for yourself during the rest of the year.

Thankfully my girlfriend understands this. She's a doll.

5

u/dMarrs Nov 19 '12

CARDS. Stop giving cards. No straight man thinks a card is anything other than "look,here is a card to show you how much i do not care"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lilfunky1 Nov 19 '12

My husband said he'd shoot me if I got him socks or underwear as an xmas gift.

I don't get it. All his current socks and undies REALLY NEED TO GET REPLACED!!!

And it's not like that would be the ONLY thing I get him...

sigh

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

I was thinking about making my boyfriend a quilt for his bed so he's not so cold during the winter. is that a bad idea ?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/ANIMAL_SOCIETY Nov 19 '12

What about GUN RACKS. I don't even own A gun let alone enough guns to necessitate a gun rack....

5

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12

My list is shamelessly juvenile...

An RC car/boat/helicopter ...take your pic

Pro-grade stunt kite (we're talking two strings here folks)

Binoculars. Why? Because fucking binoculars that's why

A cruiser bicycle with a cup holder for my beer and a bicycle bell

Two tickets to that thing I love

Kick-ass ear buds

5

u/Mysirus Nov 20 '12

Instead of giving you advice on what to buy, and though this is bound to get buried, I'm gonna tell you a story:

I had been dating a girl for a bit, maybe 2 months max, and she didn't ask me what I wanted for Christmas, just told me she got me something. I, of course, not being as thoughtful as she decided to take her out to a movie, cook her dinner, and give all the cuddles to for an Xmas present. What she got me, however, tops almost every other gift I've ever received.

She noticed a lot of hang-ups and posters in my room the few times she'd been over to my place, and she knew how much I loved video games (The Legend of Zelda, to be specific). She got me a cloth painting of Link facing down a Darknut from Twilight Princess. The thing was a really nice size, really delicate, and very very pretty to look at. She also got me a Link candy dispenser, with mini sweet-tarts to fill it up with.

In the small span of 2 months, she combined things she'd knew I loved into one of the best presents I've ever received. I guarantee that if you also pay attention to what your boyfriend/husband likes/loves (other than you of course), you'll never turn up with a super lame gift ever again.

20

u/DrellVanguard Nov 19 '12

There is a strong undercurrent of Sheldon Cooper in this thread.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

It's already been said, but it needs to be hammered home. Toiletries. Seriously, if it's something that's going to go into my bathroom, it's NEVER GOING INTO MY BATHROOM.

I've used the same razor type for 8 years. The same shaving powder (yes, powder. Add water and mix in a bowl with a brush) for 6 years. I've used the same deoderant for 2 years, and that's only because they stopped selling the scent I used to use (and dear LORD I will never buy or use Axe...) and I've used the same soap since I was honestly 17 (I'm 33.)

Guys are not like women in that they go "Oh, new skin/hair/asscrack care solution, I MUST HAVE IT."

I also hate ties, since I never wear dress shirts.

And "sampler" anythings...

Wanna get me something I'll use?

PANTS. I wear pants every day. I wear out pants on a regular basis. As long as you know/ask about sizing, I will hug the SHIT out of you for pants.

→ More replies (19)

16

u/petnautilus Nov 19 '12

Apparently every single man loves dumb gadgets.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Convincing Nov 19 '12

FUCKING DEODORANT! I BUY MY OWN, I DON'T NEED EXTRA AT CHRISTMAS!

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Decman Nov 19 '12

I have had a beard for several years now, stop buying me razors!!

14

u/IM_OSCAR_dot_com Nov 19 '12

They'll keep coming until you get the message.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/Lottia Nov 20 '12

Went food shopping with a male friend, he saw a DVD he loved but couldnt afford it today. So I went and got myself lost in the supermarket, went back, picked it up and bought it before getting myself unlost. Now Im going to give it to his secret santa whos recovering from abdominal surgery and had NO idea what to buy this fussy man. I feel like I am secretly santa :3

12

u/abittooshort Nov 19 '12

I received for about three Christmases in a row a "beers of the world" box. It was simply four bottles of beer from various countries, in a tacky display that is only excusable around Christmas time.

I also don't drink.

12

u/kelseykeefe Nov 19 '12

I would never buy my boyfriend ANYTHING listed on the stereotypical men's gift guide. Maybe, if he was in need, I'd get him a new shaving set, but he uses a safety blade thingermajig and who am I to impose upon his beauty regimen? We have blades, we're stocked on shave lotion & aftershave & all other components of whatever your kind does to your face in the morning-- buying him that sort of thing is like buying me concealer or blush. Thanks? I love make up and will use this, but...

Clothes-wise, I don't get him clothes. My boyfriend is of the variety of person where he wears a black tshirt with jeans every day, excepting days when he is in a suit or whatever. Maybe he wears a blazer or sports jacket, but for the most part he is in a black tshirt. My greatest ambition is to destroy all of his tshirts in a brilliant fire ritual and replace them all with ones from Everlane. We've one. He's consented. I'm so close. I'd like to do the same with socks, but I haven't found a reliable internet socks vendor.

What else is on those lists? Tools? ugh. Buying stuff from those lists makes me feel like I'm shopping for a stranger, they're not even good for advice.

I suppose girls lists are the same, though. I've a lot of fucking vanilla "perfume" and cheap lotions courtesy of lists like that. Don't know what to get him?! Screwdriver set! Cheap cologne! A tie! Yet another NOVELTY FLASK. And her?! She'll be needing some candles, lotion, and probably a stuffed animal, because she's a child.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/TheGreatGingerOaf Nov 19 '12

Boxers and socks. It's nice to get them, don't get me wrong, but I like a heartfelt present too.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Ties. I fucking hate ties. Just give me what the tie would cost in cash.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair Nov 19 '12

Nothing like a a hand made, wool, nustack warmer for those cold mornings.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/DarkestSin Nov 19 '12

Last Christmas, I bought my boyfriend an orange crossbow that fires out sucky darts.

How'd I do?

11

u/BroKing Nov 19 '12

How about this:

Every guy is super fucking different. Some like clothes, some could care less what they wear. Some like tools, some gag at the thought of using a saw.

Just ask whoever you're buying for what they want. It's a great way to get the person what they want.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

I'm going to have to go ahead and say that one mens' gift idea is great.

SOCKS!

I could get socks for every god damned holiday on the planet and still be like "FUCK YES! SOCKS!"

→ More replies (2)

8

u/DancesWithDaleks Nov 19 '12

I usually get guys tickets to a band they like or to a comedian they enjoy. If it's too early for something expensive, I get them a DVD of the special or a T-shirt/mug/other thing for the band. For a guy who's into a popular show I'd get him something related (I got my best guy friend a Sonic Screwdriver for his birthday). Never had a complaint, so I thought I'd throw the idea out there.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/overdosebabyblue Nov 19 '12

Any sympathetic boys want to give me present help?

SO's birthday is very close to Christmas. DOUBLE WHAMMY. Thing is, the dude is super pragmatic and only accepts useful gifts. He has requested, supervised the purchase of, and approved upon receipt some snazzy new shoes. I love spoiling people rotten, but he will not answer any further questions about what I can possibly buy him as he think that's enough.

So, any ideas for a present for the boy who has everything??

He's a med student, loves DOTA and TF2, photography and movies.

65

u/brenna8806 Nov 19 '12

Get him a really nice stethoscope! Like the Littman Cardiac series. Get it engraved. SO NICE & so useful.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (47)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

Laser pointers always seem to make my man happy.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Queen_LaQueefah Nov 19 '12

Wallets. I hate wallets and I get at least one for every birthday and Christmas. Quit giving me wallets, dammit!

4

u/electricBuddha Nov 19 '12

Unless you spend more than 4 hours a day with me, please don't improvise with a gift. I use my amazon wishlist to keep track of things I find interesting. I even use categorized lists so you have a selection of many different options. If you wish to improvise, or you think I would really like store x. Please get me a gift card. If none of these options are acceptable, please make a donation to a secular organization that helps people. I would rather not have a bit of stuff that I will not use.

4

u/GoNavy_09 Nov 19 '12

I'm kinda tired of getting pocket knives, honestly. I'm a history nut (yay /r/askhistorians) and love any kind of sword or historical blade or reproduction of a historical blade. So if you're going to get me a knife get me something significant or unique. Just because its interesting doesn't mean it'll cost a lot of money and I don't need 50+ dollar store Swiss army knives. I know it's the thought that counts, but when you get someone something that literally costs $1 and that you know they have a ton of already its obvious it isn't a heartfelt gift.

Next would be cheap shaving kits. If you get me something to groom my beard with from The Art of Shaving that's a different story (that place is awesome). But getting me a cheap shaving kit at WalMart isn't going to mean a whole lot because I already have shaving stuff like most guys do.

And don't get me wrong. I'm grateful that people buy me gifts but the things listed aren't gifts that take thought. They're just cheap "male gifts" that people seem to think are always safe when in reality I just want something showing you put thought into it. And that's the key, the things i listed don't require thought. For instance when my girlfriend gets me cigars that shows thought, she knows I like cigars and knows my favorite types. So her buying me cigars is actually meaningful to me.
But just getting the cheapest "male gift" you can find has no thought or meaning behind it. And that is what I get tired of those cheap things.

4

u/Killfile Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12

Guys have routines and we don't like gifts that jostle us out of those routines. If you get me a new razor, for example, I'm going to have to somehow deal with the blades and handle I've already got. Socks, ties, etc all have this problem. Don't mess with our daily routine; feel free to resupply us if you know it, but don't try to change it; your gift will end up covered in dust on a shelf somewhere.

Project gifts: Some guys like projects but if you get us a home beer making kit and we're really not that into beer it feels kind of like you're trying to get rid of us with a hobby or worse, get us to do something. If your gift comes with an implicit time commitment to something that the guy in question "might like" think very carefully about getting it... because while he might like it, he might also not like it.

Clutter gifts: Some guys like clutter, particularly around the office. I've got a tiny collection of desk swag that sits in mine and I'm usually happy to add to it. Other guys are spartan when it comes to their environment; know what kind of person you're buying for. Don't get a minimalist a tiny plush Yoda to sit on his desk, even if he does love Star Wars.

Self directed gifts: These are the safest kind of gift though obviously they feel impersonal. Know a guy who likes movies? Gift card to the movies. He likes video games? Gift card for his gaming service (steam, xbox, whatever). Music? Movies? Electronics? Amazon gift cards. In fact, if you don't know what to get someone, Amazon gift cards are amazing. I don't know if you can get someone Amazon Prime but if that's a thing it should be your default gift for everyone.

Here's one I'd include on every gift list though: If the guy you're buying for is (usually) clean shaven, look around your town to find a barber shop that still does straight-razor shaves. Get him a gift certificate for THAT. This won't help a guy with a beard, but if he's never had a straight shave he'll thank you and if he has he'll be excited to get another.

Of course, if all else fails, you can always opt to re-supply his hobbies. I love coffee, for example, and anyone looking to shop for me need only pop over to /r/coffee and ask them where they can buy a pound of fresh roasted high quality coffee. Most hobbies have consumables associated with them and asking communities that understand those hobbies will usually tell you what to get.

4

u/scottiescott23 Nov 19 '12

Chocolates beers and socks....

then I went to uni

CHOCOLATES BEERS AND SOCKS WOOO

4

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12

A bad gift is anything I can't potentially seriously hurt myself with.

4

u/MonsieurFroid Nov 19 '12

Socks. I am so tired of getting socks every year for any gift-giving occasion.

I take pride in my clothes, and socks are a part of that. White socks? Tube socks? No thank you. If anybody got me some basic black wigwams or big wooly socks, I'd love it, but no, despite walking around in socks most of the time--big, wooly colourful ones, basic thick black socks, argyle when at work--I get white, grey-heeled socks every year. I just donate them to Goodwill, so at least somebody gets a use out of them.

4

u/ChocolateMeoww Nov 19 '12

I'll be straight up: I will never be tired of being taken out to a nice restaurant as a gift. You can never go wrong with gift cards either.

4

u/Miketheclerk Nov 19 '12

Socks!

I'm kidding, I LOVE socks! :-D

4

u/Villanelle84 Nov 19 '12

I take after Dumbledore and mostly ask everyone for socks.

4

u/banana_bob Nov 19 '12

Material possessions are for the weak, just give me a bj and it'll be a merry fuckin' Christmas.

4

u/TheSumOfAllSteers Nov 19 '12

Men know what other men want so well...

Idea. Idea!

Why don't we all just date guys?!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/catjuggler Nov 19 '12

This is what my husband got for his 30th birthday on Saturday and I'm sure Cosmo would hate it.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Ethanmac Nov 19 '12

I'm tired of getting dildos

4

u/Calamitosity Nov 19 '12

For me, it's very simple:

  1. Go to my Amazon wishlist

  2. Sort by priority

  3. Click "Add to cart" until your budget is exhausted

Simple, and makes me a happy camper on Christmas!

4

u/kevinstonge Nov 19 '12

All I want is an 80" TV. I don't want ties or mugs... just an 80" TV. Is that really too much to ask?

4

u/src9876 Nov 19 '12

No more socks please and thank you.

4

u/lisan_al_gaib Nov 19 '12

If he doesn't already have one, buy him a good sturdy axe. They are surprisingly inexpensive and fun to use.

...No, seriously, buy your man an axe.

Every man needs at least one good axe around the house.

4

u/3rdWorldPauper Nov 19 '12

leading up to my birthday, my wife checked (history) the fishing tackle reviews I was following in the net. I got the perfect low-pro baitcasting reel for the summer... now I fake read reviews leading up to any occasion.

4

u/wolf156 Nov 19 '12

Target has a box set of oil and car wash for your car and its packaged as a "Gifts for him."

It's kinda stupid because i sure as hell don't see a vacuum cleaner/cooking pan set combo titled "Gifts for her."

4

u/shane201 Nov 19 '12

A framed photo of me and somebody ... Then they expect you to display it somewhere in your home. It's bad enough I have to see them whenever they come over, but now i also have to see their mug when i'm in my living room. Best gifts are cigarettes or those chocolate turtles.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '12

Anything with mustaches on them. Just because I have a moustache doesn't mean the items I own should also have a moustache.

4

u/phonein Nov 20 '12

Nothing. Seriously, can we just eat food and drink wine and talk shit for a day without stressing? I don;t want anything, If I want something, I'll buy it. It's ok, if you really feel like you have to do something, donate to charity and let me know.

4

u/Ins0mniak Nov 20 '12

Anything from Think Geek works for me. I've said that repeatedly. I still get gloves and mugs.